19 ms·
My Next Mac Mini
- benologist 10y agoNUCs are awesome, I'm waiting to add this passive cooling case to mine, then an external GPU effectively everything but my MBP will be able to share. http://www.fanlesstech.com/2017/01/exclusive-akasas-skull-canyon-case-final.html http://www.fanlesstech.com/2017/01/exclusive-akasas-skull-ca... These also look quite capable: http://www.anandtech.com/show/10966/zotac-mini-pcs-kaby-lake-ces-2017 http://www.anandtech.com/show/10966/zotac-mini-pcs-kaby-lake...
- Marazan 10y agoApple's attitude to the Mac mini truly confuses me. Many years ago I was interested in getting one for eithet iPhone development or as a media pc but every time I looked they kept seeming to jack the price or downgrade the spec (relatively speaking).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rwmj 10y agoTBH I've never understood what Apple gets out of selling the Mac Mini. It cannibalizes their own low-end laptops/desktops, and at the same time must be quite a marginal product mainly sold to a small number of hackers who probably put Linux on them.
- zymhan 10y agoWhy would anyone buy a Mac Mini and put Linux on it?! There are a million other small PCs that are far better for that. If I was going to buy a Mac Mini, it's to have an affordable Mac that I can stick somewhere in my house to run occasional OS X software. I already have a few other computers, plenty of them running Linux. A Mac Mini is a great way to get a cheap OS X setup going. Also, it's not low margin, they charge $200-$400 for each upgrade you make. So if you only want a 1.8GHz box with 5400rpm spinning rust, then you're still paying $500 and Apple can't be out more than $300 in parts and costs. Especially given that they've been selling this model for 3 years, the cost of production is quite low.
- rwmj 10y agoBack when I had a Mac Mini (10 years ago), you could pull them apart and upgrade the RAM and hard disk, which I did. Is that not still the case?
- washadjeffmad 10y agoYou still can, but they're a few hardware generations out of date. You'd have more fun with a raspi 3 or a less expensive mini-ITX build that you can upgrade with current gen components.
- snuxoll 10y agoNo you can't, the current Mac Mini has RAM soldered onto the board. I think the only machines Apple now sells with any internal expansion are the 27" iMac and the trashcan.
- lultimouomo 10y agoRam is soldered so you cannot upgrade it. You can swap the HD with a SATA SSD, iFixit has an easy 35 step tutorial to do that (plus 35 steps back to reassemble it) that involves a custom made tool to remove the motherboard and a pretty rare anti-tamper Torx TR6 screwdriver. (Once you get ahold of the screwdriver it's actually not as hard as it looks. You can DIY the motherboard removal tool from a wire coat hanger and in 40 minutes of focused work you'll be done.)
- bangonkeyboard 10y agoThe last Mac mini "update" in 2014 soldered the RAM to the motherboard and sealed away access to the internals. [0][1] [0]: https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/IMG_0456.jpg https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/IMG_0... [1]: https://arstechnica.com/apple/2014/11/not-the-upgrade-we-were-hoping-for-the-2014-mac-mini-reviewed/2/ https://arstechnica.com/apple/2014/11/not-the-upgrade-we-wer...
- jdeibele 10y agoYou can't upgrade the RAM anymore. "Mac mini (Late 2014) does not have user-installable RAM." https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT205041 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT205041
- nottorp 10y agoI think it's sold mainly to companies that want a cheap machine for iOS development. Hackers are more likely to build themselves a hackintosh and triple boot.
- washadjeffmad 10y agoHeadless systems, digital signage, PVR/HTPC, and testing farms are what we mainly use them for. They're crammed behind every conference TV and in every AV cabinet, but I doubt too many people use them as their primary device.
- rwmj 10y agoWouldn't a NUC or Brix running Linux be a better choice for this?
- danvasquez29 10y agoProbably, but in an office with a couple hundred macs it may seem easier to keep everything playing nicely together.
- washadjeffmad 10y agoI think so, and definitely for at home use, but outside of server the Linux team doesn't have much purchasing power.
- quantumhobbit 10y agoI have one that I was using as a great home theater of to stream Netflix and other online services. I wish they would support it more because it was far more versital than the roku I use now and much simpler to use than a Linux or windows equivalent.
- swozey 10y agoAndroid net/media boxes are becoming very popular, to the point you can grab them off of Amazon for very cheap. I haven't jumped into that ecosystem yet so I'm not sure how great they are or what the best ones are. I've been thinking of buying a few of them to replace the Rokus around my house.
- voltagex_ 10y agoGoogle have really hamstrung the Android TV ones, but most of the media boxes you get off Amazon won't have that. I have the Xiaomi MiBox 3 and it's a pain to put other apps on it. Anything that isn't explicitly Android TV compatible won't be installable from the Play Store, and even if you sideload it, it doesn't show up in the menu. Amusingly, this is the most useful that "OK Google" has ever been (Xiaomi's remote+voice control is excellent) I will say it's worth reading up and buying based on chipset+firmware. You probably want Android 5+, something that runs Kodi well, Ethernet and HEVC decoding. I'd recommend the Mibox but Google and Xiaomi have really made a mess of it.
- ajmurmann 10y agoI've been to countless offices that use Mac Minis for dashboards and CI monitors.
- Symbiote 10y agoI set one up at work for this purpose, but using an old, unused Mac Mini. If I'd needed something new for refreshing a couple of web pages, I'd have bought a Raspberry Pi or similar. Would anyone really buy a Mac Mini, new, to do this?
- ajmurmann 10y agoWell it depends. If it was just me I'd buy a raspberry pi. If it was a single or small number of machines for work I might buy a Mac mini, just because I know for certain that it will work and know exactly how much labor will go into it. The labor and risk easily can outweigh the lower price of acquisition.
- srj 10y agoIf you already have an expensive IPS monitor which Mac do you buy to do your design work? There's the old mini and then the really pricey trashcan Mac.
- manarth 10y agothe really pricey trashcan Mac Whose last update was 10 months older than the mac mini's.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- notalaser 10y agoQuite a while ago (~2007) I bought a Mac Mini which I used as my main machine for quite some time (until 2011 or so, I think). I did a lot of programming on it. It was a very good machine and frankly, if Apple were to upgrade it to a decent spec (for 2017), I'd buy one on the spot. I don't need a laptop and, consequently, I don't want to pay a single penny for portability. My previous monitor was almost ten years old when I gave it away, and I'd have kept on using it if I hadn't had to buy a larger one (tl;dr small desk, got a big 1080p monitor and hung it on the wall behind the desk for extra space). Unless an iMac is going to last me 10-12 years, there's no point in paying a single penny for a monitor that I'm going to stop using when the computer it's glued to goes obsolete. Sexy design, stupid engineering. That leaves me to choose between a Mac Mini and a Mac Pro. I don't need a Xeon machine, but a three year-old dual-core i5 machine with a crawling hard disk isn't quite on-par with what I need, either. My current machine is a five year-old quad-core i7 that's running just fine. My only beef with it is that between 2012 and 2017, a bunch of things happened on Linux and now I'd really, really rather use OS X (hell, I'd rather use Windows if it didn't shove ads down my throat...). An up-to-date Mac Mini would be exactly what I need -- small, runs OS X, doesn't come with a bunch of hardware that I don't need, can run Emacs, compile C programs, run Perl/Python/whatever scripts, plays music and ssh-es into other boxes (my current machine does all that, too, except its OS keeps breaking)
- antfarm 10y agoThey make nice build/CI servers for iOS development.
- newscracker 10y ago> Apple's attitude to the Mac mini truly confuses me. I'm probably speaking for thousands of people. It's been complete frustration to see what Apple hasn't been up to on the Mac front. Apart from not updating a few ranges for years (and introducing updates that reduce or remove the kind of expandability the core Apple customer base wants), not reducing the price of old systems is highly insensitive on the part of the company. It looks like in another one or two years macOS won't support some of the aged hardware that Apple sells. That may be the time it'd completely junk those ranges. It's sad to see this. Though lacking in certain ways, the HP Z2 Mini seems like a decent alternative for people who can move out of macOS.
- ianai 10y agoThey definitely have unmet demand. They also just cut their CEOs pay for under performance. They could upgrade the whole line in one go and be right back to relevance.
- kogepathic 10y ago> Though lacking in certain ways, the HP Z2 Mini seems like a decent alternative for people who can move out of macOS. The Z2 Mini is a completely different class of hardware. People who are looking for an alternative to the Mac Mini would be well served by an Intel NUC, Zotac ZBOX [0], or Gigabyte BRIX [1]. [0] https://www.zotac.com/product/mini_pcs/all https://www.zotac.com/product/mini_pcs/all [1] http://www.gigabyte.us/products/list.aspx?s=47&ck=104 http://www.gigabyte.us/products/list.aspx?s=47&ck=104
- protomyth 10y agoand yet, the HP Z2 Mini is the same price as the middle Mac Mini packing quite a bit more power and expandability.
- orbitur 10y agoBlog post leaves out an important point: is it easy to get macOS running on that particular model? edit: The mini hasn't competed on a purely specs/price level since, perhaps, its first year or two of existence. There have long been better, similarly sized options if you don't care about OS X.
- taspeotis 10y agoThe blog doesn't even try to make that point. > It turns out there’s another OS that has all those: Windows. I’ve had Windows 10 on a gaming PC I built over 6 months ago and I’ve not had a single problem with it.
- orbitur 10y agoWhich is strange, since the Mac mini's only value for the last 9 or 10 years has been it's ability to run OS X/macOS. From a purely technical/specs/price standpoint, the mini hasn't been a competitor since 2006, so I'm not sure what the blog post is saying that is new.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- taylodl 10y agoIt's small and quiet. Quite nice for a living room machine. It's also rackable so you can put them in your data center and use them as an iOS build server. It's odd the Mac Mini can fill both of these divergent niches but such is the Mac Mini - it's a niche machine.
- delinka 10y ago>Do I actually need this computer to run macOS? I quickly realised I don’t. This phrasing leads the reader to assume that that macOS can be run on some other computer. I think the author's intent was "Do I actually need [to run] macOS?"
- manarth 10y ago
- caleblloyd 10y agoThe NUC has full Linux support out of the box. You can configure them with 16GB of RAM and a 256GB-512GB SSD for $400-$500, especially if you go for the old model (Gen 6 Skylake instead of Gen 7 Kaby Lake, not much has changed)
- pmorici 10y agoAre you sure? I have one and the wifi definitely doesn't work out of the box and there are a couple other annoyances the worst being the machine locking up if you let it sit for too long. I haven't spent time to investigate but that isn't the definition of "works out of the box"
- windexh8er 10y agoSince there are a number of iterations of NUC I suppose you could have one that doesn't. However most of the Intel wireless chipsets are some of best supported. I own two Intel NUC and two Gigabyte Brix machines - all of them were specifically selected to run Linux and all of them work flawlessly out of the box under any major distro. One of my favorite desktop machines is the Intel Skull Canyon (NUC6i7KYK). It has an i7-6770HQ, supports 32GB of RAM (all of the newer, i.e. Skylake and greater do) and the real difference I wanted was the fact that it has two M.2 slots AND a true Thunderbolt 3 port (for support of the Razer Core external GPU enclosure). Highly recommended if you want a performant machine in a small form factor with multi-monitor support and flexibility given it's size. I only hope that Gigabyte continues to make the Brix line, especially when Ryzen drops from AMD. As much as I like the Skull Canyon I'd love to drop Intel from a pure privacy standpoint.
- peatmoss 10y ago> I'd love to drop Intel from a pure privacy standpoint. Are you referring to the Intel Management Engine? I was under the impression that AMD was as bad if not worse than Intel in that regard: https://libreboot.org/faq/#amd https://libreboot.org/faq/#amd Or is Ryzen expected to be better in that regard?
- andreapaiola 10y agoBetter late than never...
- rwmj 10y agoI would take a look at the Gigabyte Brix. The basic model is £119 [1] - considerably cheaper than the Intel NUC. I have a couple running a firewall and a little server, and they have trucked along for years without problems. [1] For a more complete spec including the other parts you may need, see: https://rwmj.wordpress.com/2015/05/04/new-home-gateway-router-part-1/#content https://rwmj.wordpress.com/2015/05/04/new-home-gateway-route...
- benologist 10y agoAlso ASRock and Zotac make nice ones too. I think these three companies actually work with the NUC insides.
- tyingq 10y agoIf your performance & storage needs are modest, the ASUS chromebox is just a little higher than that, but comes with 2GB RAM and a 16GB mSATA SSD. I believe the Brix comes with no ram, no hard drive. It's very upgradable as well. It ships with one open DIMM slot, so upgrading to 4GB RAM is dirt cheap. The Celeron 2955U isn't a speed demon, but it's good enough for a home machine. And, you can get a ROM image that allows running an actual linux distribution instead of ChromeOS: https://johnlewis.ie/custom-chromebook-firmware/rom-download/ https://johnlewis.ie/custom-chromebook-firmware/rom-download...
- bsenftner 10y agoI've been picking up Intel ComputeSticks: $99 gives you Win10, WiFi, 4GB RAM, HDMI & USB. I seem to remember I put a 32 GB SD card into my first one... I've been putting them behind our TVs, giving them web access. All I put on them are Chrome and Mame. The $99 ComputeSticks are just powerful enough to play standard def video from someone like NetFlix or Amazon. Higher bit rate streaming video is too much, and the'll stutter. But they have higher spec ComputeSticks I've not played with for $199, and $299. (Maybe I'm being grumpy, but most video content simply does not need to be 4K, or HD.) They are great with 3D graphics, as far as rendering. I write 3D, and have been having a good time with their 3D performance, using WebGL. Seems like the Nuc prices are just at that level that one could pick up a desktop with the necessary CPU, video card and RAM while being expandable to the future - where the Nuc is not...
- coldtea 10y ago>Well, perfect except that six years in this machine is very creaky. It needs a reboot every week or so (otherwise it will refuse to launch anything). That sounds totally unrelated to the age of the machine, and totally related to what's installed, the mini running out of disk, etc. Maybe do a clean install of the OS? Aside from the mechanical parts (CD ROMS, Hard Disks, etc), the "digital" parts of a PC do not age and their age does not affect program execution speed (all other things being equal). Either they work, or they don't (well, corrupted memory can cause crashes when accessed, but it wont slow down programs).
- zymhan 10y agoYeah what the hell, how can you write a tech blog complaining about a product if you don't perform even the most basic of system maintenance. Or, if you are doing maintenance, why not explain what you are doing? Also, can't a Mac Mini that old be upgraded with a 2.5" SSD and more RAM?
- mynegation 10y agoIt would be a fair criticism if cards were not so obviously stacked against me, the end user and maintainer. New versions of software are written for new and more powerful hardware. I don't know about Mac mini specifically, but it is incredibly hard or even impossible to upgrade Apple products with new hardware.
- radley 10y agoOnly the "current" Mac Mini has upgrade restrictions. But the prior model has almost identical specs and can be upgraded.
- gtani 10y agoYes, the quad cores sold prior to Oct 2014 can be found in craigslist/ebay etc for US$700-1100 tho i think they're limited to 16Gb RAM http://barefeats.com/macmin14.html http://barefeats.com/macmin14.html
- Symbiote 10y agoEspecially useful, "VESA mount bracket included in the box". If you don't mind ~35mm more depth to your TV, you can mount the NUC on the back. Or, mount it to the back of a monitor, for an iMac replacement.
- protomyth 10y agoWe just did a full lab (30 machines) of Intel NUCs (NUC6i7KYK) mounted on the back of LG 21x9 monitors. It is quite a nice setup. I dearly wish there had been an Apple Mac Mini update, but we can get by with Windows in that lab. Went with Samsung M.2 SSDs and 32 GB of memory.
- Joeri 10y agoOne of the big selling points of the mini is that it's really quiet. Does anyone with actual experience know how the NUC compares? From what I've read it's significantly louder, which is not what you want from a living room PC.
- analog31 10y agoFor the living room PC, I recently went even further downscale and replaced a wheezing old desktop box with a fanless mini-PC running Win10. It solves the problem of when both kids have homework at the same time. The only software on it is Chrome, since the kids do all of their stuff in the cloud. Oddly, it's the end of an era: The first computer I've owned that I'm not tempted to install MS Office on.
- remir 10y agoWhy not go with a Chromebox or Chromebit instead? Seems like the perfect solution for your kids and no maintenance for you.
- analog31 10y agoThis is certainly a possibility, or even plain Linux. For myself, I'd like to be able to run Jupyter/Python, but I think this must be possible on a Chrome machine.
- lebrad 10y agoI have a 2011 Mac Mini and the fan gets annoyingly loud when under load. I was also annoyed by the fan in my NUC so I put it in a fanless case. It's dead quiet, and stays cool enough to run under load without throttling.
- Joeri 10y agoI have a late 2009 mini, and the fan is never loud, not even after sustained load. That's the thing holding me back from replacing it.
- 10y ago
- raphinou 10y agoHonest question : any good reasons to go with Windows rather than Linux?
- daenney 10y agoA lot of it would depend on what your use case is. In this case the author needs an Elgato/Geniatech EyeTV stick and app for his purposes which isn't supported on Linux by the manufacturer. It might work, but it might also not be worth the hassle. However, if you want something that plays media but doesn't (necessarily) also have to be able to receive regular terrestrial signal it shouldn't matter much beyond user preference and ease of installation/maintenance/debugging.
- fulafel 10y agoThose have been working for years very well under Linux, and see much use with MythTV etc. Vendor drivers are less likely to see long time support.
- peatmoss 10y agoI bought one of those HDTV terrestrial sticks (RTL2832) for about $10. I use it for FM Radio, but I'd guess that would still work for TV on Linux? Think Penguin sells a stick that's a bit pricier, but also presumably very easy to use with Linux: https://www.thinkpenguin.com/gnu-linux/usb-tv-tuner-w-support-hd-atsc-dvb-t-digital-tv-us-canada-europe https://www.thinkpenguin.com/gnu-linux/usb-tv-tuner-w-suppor... There's also the Linux TV site that discusses the software side of things: https://www.linuxtv.org/wiki/index.php/TV_Related_Software https://www.linuxtv.org/wiki/index.php/TV_Related_Software
- technofiend 10y agoit doesn't fit the original requirement as it is too large but when these discussions come up i feel obligated to mention silicon dust as well. http://www.silicondust.com/hdhomerun/ http://www.silicondust.com/hdhomerun/ they make outboard tv tuners that will either do over-the-air or digital cable and stream wired or wirelessly. one model even transcodes to h.264 and they publish plugins for kodi and plex along with working with a variety of commercial and open source apps. it was my preferring tuning device with both myth tv on linux and Microsoft media center until i ditched cable entirely.
- nottorp 10y agoSpeaking of NUCs, are there any that are (a) quiet at load (b) have the PSU integrated in the case? Those are about the only redeeming qualities of a Mac Mini right now, and it pisses me off to no end that no one bothers with (b) on the Wintel side. Edit: please don't explain to me how a power brick that's sometimes as large as the NUC doesn't bother you, it does bother me.
- rwmj 10y agoThe Gigabyte Brix [edit: the base model] is fanless, and if you use an SSD it's completely solid state. I have two next to me right now and they are completely silent as you would expect. However it has a small external power brick. It's only about 1/4 the size of the machine (at least that's for the UK PSU).
- windexh8er 10y agoConsidering there are tens of options in the Brix lines the comment about them being fanless is untrue. Most are actively cooled machines. None of the Brix or NUC I have are particularly loud. If you're doing heavy lifting on a small form factor machine you have to expect a small fan to generate noise to dissipate heat, there's really no way around it.
- rwmj 10y agoI edited the comment to reflect the fact that the base model of the Gigabyte Brix -- which I have two of -- is fanless and passively cooled.
- arachnophobe 10y agoI've used a gigabyte Brix n2807 - it's slightly larger than other Brix models as it takes a 2.5" drive (using an old laptop drive to save costs). It's not powerful, but it runs Kodi and Windows 10 okay. Wi-Fi and Bluetooth don't work (or didn't when I first tried) with Linux out of the box. Up to 8gb LPDDR. No power brick. £80 on offer a couple of years ago.
- facepalm 10y agoIt seems to me an Amazon FireTV or even one of those sticks (firetv, chromecast) could do everything he wants.
- UnbornSoul 10y agoIt can't be used as a DVR.
- CydeWeys 10y agoAren't DVRs kind of a dying product category? They're only relevant if you have a cable subscription, and most people putting media PCs in their living room are relying on streaming services. I don't know anyone who uses a DVR anymore, but I know dozens of people with Netflix/Amazon/Hulu/etc. subscriptions.
- UnbornSoul 10y agoHere in Europe the situation is mostly the other way around. Netflix is available in most countries for a year or two. Amazon launched only a month ago in most European countries. Also the author mentioned Eye TV which is DVR software.
- rch 10y agoEven cable subscriptions include DVR-like features.
- matthewn 10y ago> They're only relevant if you have a cable subscription This is news to those of us who use DVRs to record over-the-air HD broadcasting. My homebuilt DVR is what makes NOT having a cable subscription workable.
- jmkni 10y agoI wish Apple would just team up with Intel and license macOS on the NUC. It's a perfect successor to the Mac Mini.
- rocky1138 10y agoWhat's the point of OSX on the NUC when Linux or even Windows does everything a NUC is usually used for?
- jmkni 10y agoI'm thinking more about what people use Mac Mini's for. Apple clearly aren't interested in the Mac Mini anymore, so why not license macOS on a superior machine in the same category instead? Similar to how they no longer make their own monitors, and now recommend an LG 5K monitor. For example, I use a Mac Mini for Xamarin. When it dies, I don't want to spend money on a new one because they are really overpriced, would rather buy a NUC and a copy of Mac OS and use that instead.
- mobiletelephone 10y agoThe mac mini just works because apple put the effort into making it work. If they were to license macos for the nuc then they would have to put the work in there too. If they are not interested in working on the Mac mini, why would they be interested in working on the nuc?
- protomyth 10y agoI once believed that, but it really isn't true anymore. Intel made quite the effort to kill third party chipsets. We are not living in the early 90's. Intel decided (quite differently than ARM) that it would have a set of configurations and take over almost every aspect of it chips. Look at the NUC, it is a stock Intel everything design. It would be rather easy to support from Apple's perspective.
- Koshkin 10y ago
- finstell 10y agoNowadays, I kind of enjoy seeing posts about people abandoning Apple ecosystem. Although it's painful, I myself have been yet another avid fan of pretty much Apple offered, it feels like this is not going to last forever. When they do the math, iPhone might seem the most lucrative (they seem not to care about anything else) but since they are killing the ecosystem with no Mac Pro, no Mac Mini and with so called pro MacBooks, developers will abandon Apple eventually. Even if iPhone becomes/remains the most technologically advanced smart phone on the market, it would be like a distant paradise island with no airports. Airplanes (developers and subsequently the end users) will be landing on alternative airports on emerging islands, letting them prosper. Consequently, Apple island will be deserted.
- CoolGuySteve 10y agoI had whatever the latest iPhone was for the past 8 years. But at some point I realized a whole Huawei/HTC/LG/whatever Android phone could be purchased for the price of an iPhone screen repair and it's pretty much adequate for what I want to do. So now I'm using a Nexus 5X. It's okayish, but costs 1/3 the price of the iPhone 7 that would also be relatively ok. Phones are just phones these days. The awkward part is that if you've ever played audio or video on an iOS device, you've executed some of my code.
- stoolpigeon 10y agoI chuckled at this because I have a 5X too and I like it but my wife's Moto G4 Plus is amazing and cost something like half of what I paid for my Nexus, so I feel like I paid more than I needed to for a solid phone.
- voltagex_ 10y agoI think the 5X gets security updates until September 2018. Meanwhile, my Moto X Style, which was top of the line not too long ago, got the September 2016 rollup... in January 2017. Nougat was rumoured but I'm not betting on it. I haven't installed Cyanowhatever it is now - mainly because the IR sensors and gestures are really handy.
- return0 10y agoCan that thing run OSX ? damn, i just ordered a mac mini to do some ios dev.
- wildchild 10y agoApple is a scam and nothing else. It's more clear for me after my Mac Mini 2009 is no longer supported by Sierra without any constructive reason (you can install it with pair of crutches but no Wi-Fi). Actually Apple is selling fancy outdated hardware with pretty questionable "new features" like touchbar bullshit to excuse their ridiculous pricing model. Awesome that more people abandoning it.
- CoolGuySteve 10y agoI'm running a $65 FireTV with Kodi sideloaded that accomplishes everything I need. The device is silent and the remote is bluetooth and feels nice in the hand. (But to be fair, my router is used to download torrents and I don't ingest any Live TV.) To be honest, I think the NUC or any other intel platform is overkill for TV these days.
- DrNuke 10y agoTrying to sell my mid 2011 right now but market is flooded, you didn't see this a couple of years ago.
- germinalphrase 10y agoMy experience as a buyer doesn't match. I've been trying to find a cheap older model just to noodle around with/set up a lightweight media server. Everyone around me are trying to get 2x their practical value, it seems. But then, I've been keeping a 2009 MBP alive with salvaged parts - so I probably don't adequately consider the apple tax on used equipment.
- Damogran6 10y agoThat NUC looks like it would be SO close to my needs...but the need pushing a new, small, quiet computer into the living room is VR...and I don't think it would quite do that. (Perhaps a TB3 dock to a gtx1070?) I'm not ever sure if the blocker is processing power or physical video ports.
- benologist 10y agoThere's another NUC called Skull Canyon that's a quad core Skylake i7 with Thunderbolt 3. It's not quiet, but there's a fanless case coming for it so it's going to be. It's about the size of a VHS video cassette, or ~2x the NUC the OP mentions. http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/nuc/nuc-kit-nuc6i7kyk-features-configurations.html http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/nuc/nuc-kit-nuc6i7kyk...
- Damogran6 10y agoThat NUC looks like it would be SO close to my needs...but the need pushing a new, small, quiet computer into the living room is VR...and I don't think it would quite do that. (Perhaps a TB3 dock to a gtx1070?) I'm not ever sure if the blocker is processing power or physical video ports.
- srj 10y agoI had the same experience when I went to create a small recording studio for my wife. I figured I'd use garage band on a Mac Mini and connect the mixer to that. I changed my plans after going to Apple's website - I don't want to buy old tech and especially not at full price. It's bizarre to see a company with the wealth and resources of Apple not even putting out spec upgrades for their machines. I could say the same about my old MacBook Air I've been wanting to upgrade. Just throw us a bone here Apple. Even a small bump in specs.
- rsync 10y ago"It's bizarre to see a company with the wealth and resources of Apple not even putting out spec upgrades for their machines." What's so bizarre is that the things that people want are actually the easiest and cheapest things for apple to do. All anyone wants is a macbook air with a retina screen. Not a new 12" one, not a new form factor, not design and engineer some new razor thin design ... just take the same old cad drawings and put a nicer screen on it. All anyone wants is a mac pro tower (not the wastebasket) with nicer internals and fast SATA/USB ports. That's it. Nothing new to design, no new manufacturing processes - you don't even need new press photos. If you're going to relegate the product line(s) to second tier, why not just save a ton of money and give people exactly what they were all asking for ?
- remir 10y agoWhat Apple lacks is humility. Jobs even said people don't know what they want until "you showed it to them". So, I highly doubt that Apple will listen to what people want. I mean, Apple would make a killing with a new Mac Mini with better spec, a Macbook Air with better screen res, couple of USB-C ports, a 24" iMac instead of 21, etc... But Apple won't do it because that would be listening to people, and this is something they're too proud to do.
- brandon272 10y agoIt's interesting... unless my memory is failing me, you never hear Apple say anything to the effect of, "We listened to our customers, so we decided to _____" I mean, I agree with what Jobs said when he suggested that customers expect Apple to innovate and curate and make it's own decisions about what products it develops. But I think you can also take that too far, especially when your customers are screaming at you on certain topics.
- labrador 10y agoI don't understand, since Apple has so much money, why they don't put some of it into the Mac line. It seems short-sighted.
- scribu 10y agoI think the limiting factor is not money, but mental bandwidth. Even if they could just go out and buy a whole extra product team that's up to their standards, they would still need constant attention from the leadership to be successful.
- labrador 10y agoIt may be possible to turn the PC OP found into a hackintosh. There's nothing preventing Apple from taking that machine and making macOS run on it. I can't imagine they'd need a lot of people to do that.
- Joeri 10y agoThe team they have right now is more than big enough to manage all product lines they have. The reason they're struggling is probably because they have lots of people working on other things than their current products, like the car.
- supercanuck 10y agoI've tried this but i've struggled mightily getting audio via HDMI from the Nuc. no matter if I install Windows or Linux. I simply replace the mac mini with the nuc, same hdmi etc and nothing. So tread carefully.
- base698 10y agoJust bought a NUC with an added 32GB of RAM as a dev machine. It's been great so far.
- smcl 10y agoWhich model is that? I've considering a dedicated windows dev machine, ogling the Surface Book but can't find anywhere that sells the 16/512 model in Czech Republic. I hadn't considered an NUC, I just presumed they'd be low on RAM and non-upgradeable
- base698 10y agoGot the Skull Canyon one: https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B01DJ9XS52/ref=ox_sc_act_image_2?smid=ATVPDKIKX0DER&psc=1 https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B01DJ9XS52/ref=ox_sc_act_imag...
- plg 10y agoWhere does one buy one of these Intel NUCs???
- nnain 10y agoI hate to bring this up -- but I earnestly think that Apple would do better with a Product Manager at the top post. Tim did good work for the company in optimizing operations, however envisioning new products is a different ball game.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sunstone 10y agoFor friends and family I've been building a few Zotac CI323's running Ubuntu 16.04 for this purpose. Not expensive even after adding a 80gig ssd and 8gigs of ram, passive cooling, between Chrome, Kodi and VLC it handles a lot of content.
- sams99 10y agoI have a skull canyon NUC and love it. I work in a co-working space. At the end of my day I can disconnect it and put it in my locked drawer. It is tiny and super fast. Caveat though for those thinking they can hackintosh this thing, it is going to be tricky and incomplete https://www.tonymacx86.com/threads/intel-nuc-skull-canyon-skylake-os-x-el-capitan-installation-using-only-unibeast-multibeast.195888/ https://www.tonymacx86.com/threads/intel-nuc-skull-canyon-sk...
- awinder 10y agoI ran a windows pc connected to a tv for a while and ultimately decided that it was a lot of upkeep and hassle. Some of it was that I was using one of those infinitv cable card tuners with windows media center. But a lot of it was the pain of managing upgrades, and dealing with wake/sleep with an ir receiver. It was just always a lot of work. So I moved to an Apple TV and a server running freenas. Any computer-y stuff basically involves the Apple TV talking to the nas, and I can admin the nas over web ui and ssh. I'm sure you can get remote admin setup with windows for similar experience, but having been on both sides, stuff breaks down all the time on windows and it's just a less-than-stellar OS for the tv.
- luckystartup 10y agoI'm confused. That Mac Mini is still amazing. They didn't say anything about wiping the hard drive and reinstalling everything. Maybe there are some problems with the harddrive, so just replace it with a new SSD. Check the RAM and see if any needs replacing. You need to do all of that before you go out and buy a new computer. I'm using a Lenovo Q190 [1] that runs lubuntu. It's a little slow to start, but everything runs fine. I run Plex Server, Plex Home Theater, Spotify, and RetroPie. I would gladly trade it for a 2010 Mac Mini. That's crazy. Just reinstall everything and run a scan on your disk and RAM. [1] http://shop.lenovo.com/us/en/desktops/lenovo/q-series/q190/#tab-tech_specs http://shop.lenovo.com/us/en/desktops/lenovo/q-series/q190/#...
- ychombinator 10y agoIf only Firefox / Intel would sort themselves out and get H.264 encoding working on the NUC so you can watch YouTube above 720p on Linux. Sigh.
- ychombinator 10y agoIf only Firefox / Intel would sort themselves out and get H.264 encoding working on the NUC so you can watch YouTube above 720p on Linux. Sigh.
- puzzlingcaptcha 10y agoYou can also build a good ol' fashioned htpc at almost half the price of this NUC: https://pcpartpicker.com/list/DmXrtJ https://pcpartpicker.com/list/DmXrtJ Could be even cheaper if you already have some spare parts. It might use a bit more power and has a larger footprint, but there is enough space for 3.5" drives and it is practically noiseless at any load. Plus you can expand it with a TV tuner, a graphics card or a HDMI capture card.
- gjkood 10y agoI have found the best way to enjoy Apple hardware without the sticker shock is to just go ahead and buy used Macs from vendors such as OWComputing (macsales.com) or macofalltrades.com. The hardware is rock solid even if it is 3 or 4 years old and the software is upgradeable. And I know I will be able to use it for another 5 years without too much hassle. My casual computing needs do not include high end gaming or deep learning using the latest GPUs. I don't need anything more powerful to browse the internet, check my email and some casual document editing. This is what my family also does 90% of the time. Sometimes it is cheaper to just change the timing belt on your car rather than leasing/buying the next latest/shiniest new thing.
- esfandia 10y agoI had the same experience as the OP. My Mac Mini was getting old, and the fan was making a worrisome noise. I wasn't going to buy the "latest" Mini, since it is very stale, hard to upgrade and expensive for what it is. Funnily enough I was already running Windows on that Mini anyway, so my next computer didn't have to be a Mac. But I did enjoy the small footprint, and I have to say that the Mac is probably the easiest hardware to run Windows on. The drivers have been tested and everything just works. I ended up with the latest "Skull Canyon" NUC as well. Even though it is thinner than my old Mini, its footprint on my desk is about the same, it's just less square. I'm not a fan of the color or the design; it seems marketed at teenage gamerzzz, not at the boring middle aged guy who prefers a minimalist Scandinavian style. But that's not very important. I did have to buy the SSD and the RAM separately, I had to install Windows myself (so that's no better than buying a Mini to run Windows on), and I did have to hunt for a couple of drivers. I don't know why they don't sell a fully configured machine. Its fan is not as quiet as the Mini, and it has some weird transient behavior when it wakes up from hibernation. It didn't come cheap (I maxed pretty much every spec though). It is very fast, it does the job competently, but I don't Love it like I Loved the Mini. Sad that Apple has abandoned this cute nifty little machine.
- nextos 10y agoThere are brands that build absolutely awesome fanless cases on top of Intel NUC boards. I recommend those: http://www.aleutia.com/computers/ http://www.aleutia.com/computers/ http://www.cirrus7.com/produkte http://www.cirrus7.com/produkte Intel is a bit lazy. Many manufacturers are selling cheap fanless devices for a lot less money. Their Core m3 is a fanless CPU. They should release a fanless NUC themselves. I love NUCs because their hardware just works on Linux and they are relatively affordable. Fanless cooling would make them perfect.
- lobster_johnson 10y agoLast year I got a fanless box from Atlast to use as a headless Linux server running Plex Media Server. Really excellent little box. Quad-core i5, 120GB SSD, 8GB RAM, Ubuntu preinstalled. $600 plus $50 shipping to the US (they're in the UK): http://www.atlastsolutions.com/fanless-mini-itx http://www.atlastsolutions.com/fanless-mini-itx They Atlast guys are also very friendly, and they know Linux.
- kkylin 10y agoI remember going to the Apple Store the week they released the 2014 Mac Mini, taking one look, and going back to my campus bookstore and buying the last of the 2012 Mac Minis. Still very happy with that purchase. Not sure about the rationale behind most of Apple's design decisions the last couple years...
- fowlerpower 10y agoSomeone here needs to explain it to me because I just don't understand. We have the largest computer company in the world, a shit load of people work there, supposedly smart people. Yet they can't put together a refresh of many of their desktop machines. Why the fuck not? What do all those people getting paid all that money do all day? I can only imagine the conversations, "it takes years it has to be super innovative". No it fucking doesn't not on the PC, just put the latest processors and tech in it. You don't have to innovate every fucking time, not on the desktop PC. We see this all the time with Apple devices and I can't understand it. I mean I don't understand what do they do all day every day for 800 days that they can't refresh this simple Machine. Maybe I'm being nieve here or I'm missing something.
- intrasight 10y agoI think what you're missing is that Apple pursues high-margin endeavors, and competing with a $300 NUC isn't going to be a high-margin business. Some easy money for Apple would be to sell OS licenses for Intel NUCs.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wl 10y agoApple could sell a $300 NUC for $600 and people would still buy it. The issue is that Apple doesn't sell anything decent in this form factor that runs macOS.
- intrasight 10y agoI agree that they could and should - I'm just speculating as to why they don't. As they probably could make their desired margins, it must be they would consider it a "distraction" from future endeavors (VR, cars, etc.)
- hendersoon 10y agoThe NUC in question, the NUC7i5BNK, is $620. That is without RAM or storage, so add another $50 for 8GB RAM, $80 for a 128GB M.2 SSD, and $100 for a Windows license. Total price is $850. This guy isn't cheaping out, he just wants more hardware for his money. $700 at Apple gets you a much slower 3 generation old i5 with a 1TB hard drive. But, with MacOS. It's one thing for Apple to charge a premium for better hardware. But that is NOT what they're doing. They're charging the same amount for ancient, inferior hardware.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- chatterbeak 10y agoIt works well... > It’s never bothered me, needed rebooting because it was flakey or even broken a sweat doing all the things I’ve asked of it. But then ... > I’m not a huge fan of the aesthetic or DOS roots of Windows The Mac community has done a great job feeding lies to Mac users! There are no "DOS roots" in Windows 10, just as there are no "Apple ][ DOS" roots of Mac OS X. We switched back 100% to Windows after Windows 10 came out--we needed NVIDIA and lots of RAM (256GB) for the programming we do -- and have had no trouble. And we have beautiful glass cube workstations (Lian Li) and 100% stable machines that never crash, hang, or act weird.
- once-in-a-while 10y ago(this is nothing nice to say, but here I am, the one without "karma" -- whatever this means to you, to me it simply means: "sold" -- so, I will tell you some naked Truth): As of today, the guy heading Apple(R) is a man(?!) who has the courage to publicly state: "Homosexuality is maybe the biggest gift God gave me". If this is what majority thinks on this Planet, I want to leave for a better place already... (Yes, I know, many of you cowards can't agree publicly, but at least, do it in your heart! Thank you.)
- rswail 10y agoThis is irrelevant and attacks a person for their sexuality. You should be ashamed of yourself.
- once-in-a-while 10y agoDo you not understand that this is a global, personal attack on ourselves? Homosexuality is a "problem" of maybe 3% of human beings. So, now should somebody be proud of this, and attributing it as a "gift of God Personally Himself"? Are you really so blind to not see the obvious? And why does a comment like mine need to be "flagged"? Can't you see that this is "dictatorship of relativism" already? If not, I'm really sorry, not of you, but about the whole web community...
- jakobegger 10y agoCan someone here explain why Apple seems to be the only company that builds small stuff with an integrated power supply? What's the point in making something small, when you need a huge power brick to power it? It's a shame that Apple's stuff is outdated, but it's just so much nicer when you look at the details.
- Viper007Bond 10y agoBy having an external power brick, you keep a ton of heat out of the device. That means a smaller device and less cooling needed.
- jakobegger 10y agoThat's obvious, but if that was such a major obstacle, how does Apple manage to do it? The Mac Mini, the Apple TV, all the Airport routers -- they all have a built in power supply and use a standard figure-eight power cable. This is not rocket science. Why does no other company manage to do that?
- intrasight 10y agoComplete PC with OS for ~$220. HDMI 2.0 with 4K at 60Hz. I expect that they'll sell a ton of them as HTPCs. https://www.amazon.com/Intel-BOXNUC6CAYSAJR-NUC-Kit-NUC6CAYS/dp/B01MXYZ8V5 https://www.amazon.com/Intel-BOXNUC6CAYSAJR-NUC-Kit-NUC6CAYS... I use a Raspberry Pi 2 as my HTPC. As I only watch my own media on my NAS, it is perfectly adequate. But what is pretty surprising to consider is that this NUC is only about twice as expensive as my complete Raspberry Pi system.
- HillaryBriss 10y agoHe had me at: the last update Apple made to them was mostly a downgrade in terms of performance. No one except the most desperate of people should even consider buying one of these things. The fact that Apple will still happily sell you a 2-3 year old computer for new prices is beyond insulting.
- dbg31415 10y agoI use a Raspberry Pi hooked up to my NAS and it's great. All for about $100. Approximate setup I used: * Amazon.com: CanaKit Raspberry Pi 3 Complete Starter Kit - 32 GB Edition: Electronics || https://www.amazon.com/CanaKit-Raspberry-Complete-Starter-Kit/dp/B01C6Q2GSY https://www.amazon.com/CanaKit-Raspberry-Complete-Starter-Ki... * Amazon.com: Air Mouse,ELEGIANT 2.4G 6-Axis Portable Mini Wireless Air Mouse Remote Control Keyboard for PC HTPC IPTV Smart TV and Android TV Box Media Player: Computers & Accessories || https://www.amazon.com/ELEGIANT-Portable-Wireless-Control-Keyboard/dp/B01LYL2XG1 https://www.amazon.com/ELEGIANT-Portable-Wireless-Control-Ke... You can also get some game controllers and RetroPie and turn your Raspberry Pi into a sweet little gaming machine. I have every NES, SNES, Genesis, and N64 game ever made I think. Plus it plays every video format (tends to struggle with 4k video outputs... I don't have a 4K TV so I just re-downloaded the video after I saw the issue). * RetroPie - Retro-gaming on the Raspberry Pi || https://retropie.org.uk/ https://retropie.org.uk/ * Amazon.com: Buffalo Classic USB Gamepad for PC: Computers & Accessories || https://www.amazon.com/Buffalo-Classic-USB-Gamepad-PC/dp/B002B9XB0E https://www.amazon.com/Buffalo-Classic-USB-Gamepad-PC/dp/B00...
- Entangled 10y agoThe next Mac Mini should be the exact size of an Apple TV but in aluminum case, with the most RAM it can get and the fastest processor in the world. We pay for quality and we expect Apple to deliver. That NUC is ugly as fuck.
- pacomerh 10y agoIf that ugly NUC ran macOS I would be ordering one right now. I don't mind if a desktop comp is ugly, I always hide them anyways, I only care about the results. But I do mind if my laptop is ugly.
- yalogin 10y agoThe problem is evenntoday there is no replacement of comparable alternative to the Mini. The Intel NUC is just a kit not a machine. So I cannot order it for my mom. Either the machine has no profit margin or the other companies are clueless to not bring a worthy competitor to market in all these years.
- 746F7475 10y agoI'm guessing that market is kind a small. Most people I know have either transitioned into just using their smart phones and tablets or at least into using laptops and on other side thous who want to play games have needs that mini/mini-like computers can not fulfill. Mini is kind a odd computer, it isn't mobile yet doesn't provide much more power than a laptop (if any). I think a mini-like computer would probably do everything I need it to do, but I rather get a laptop and just dock it. Which also has the extra benefit of being portable
- bitL 10y agoGet a NUC5i5/NUC6i5 instead, that works with OS X like a charm. Kaby Lake won't work till Apple releases something with it. I have a quad boot on 5i5, Linux/W7/W10/OSX, a perfect little development machine.
- dragonshed 10y agoIt's interesting to me how few people consider this an option. I got a 6i5 and other than wifi, macOS runs great on it.
- bgarbiak 10y agoNot having a wifi is, I assume, kind of a deal breaker for most of the people.
- bitL 10y agoYou simply buy a generic Broadcom BCM94360CD for $25 and you are set; works on macOS, Linux, W7, W10. The only missing thing in NUC is a more powerful graphics card for machine learning/games but that will come with 7nm process as well I am sure. Similar size to Mac Mini is Zotac NEN, including quadcore i5 and NVidia 970M, which might be an interesting NUC alternative (though considerably pricier). I run SteamOS on 4k TV with it.
- DCKing 10y agoI understand this blogpost is meant to point out that Apple is abandoning desktop computers and their various use cases. It's all very bad and we haven't had enough articles discussing this yet, why won't Apple think of us anymore, etc. etc. But I'm surprised he quickly says "No worries you might say, go to Apple and buy a new Mac mini!". If your Mac Mini behaves like he describes, wouldn't the straightforward response be to open it up, give the fans a good cleaning, maybe replace any HDDs with SSDs, and give it a fresh install (of either OS X or Windows 10)? If you blog about tech as this guy does surely it would be no issue at all to just (attempt to) quickly fix these issues. Don't get me wrong, I too like buying new toys. But I'm amazed at how some apparently tech-savvy people think "this computer does not work as it used to, so it logically follows I should buy a new one!". The problems with his Mac Mini don't sound particularly bad and perfectly fixable in less time it would take to set up a new computer.
- camperman 10y agoI don't believe you can - it's all soldered on. Like the new Macbook Pros, it's designed to be impossible to upgrade.
- DCKing 10y agoThis is not as true for the Mac Mini, not even the latest generation. Although not plug and play, the hard drive in these machines are serviceable with a basic kit you can buy off eBay and clear instructions from iFixit. The Mac Mini referred to in this post moreover is 'over six years old', making them a little easier to service.
- Twiebie 10y agoThis doesn't run MacOS without some hackingtosh stuff, does it? Or did he switch to Windows with it?
- Viper007Bond 10y agoThe article mentions switching to Windows.
- intopieces 10y agoI'm usually happy to jump on the hate train even for companies I like (criticizing is fun) but this faux incredulity is becoming really stale. Apple doesn't make the computer that fits your niche because it doesn't have to. They make gobs of money selling old machinery because for most people it works just fine. A significant portion of every day computing is in the cloud anyway. It's why computers now have less file storage than before. Most people spend more time looking at their smartphone instead of their computer screen.
- otikik 10y agoI've got a Raspberry Pi 3 with raspbian and a SSD, all inside a tiny white box. It reproduces x264 video just fine. Now that we might upgrade to a 4K TV I might need to look for alternatives. I wonder whether the NUC is my best option.
- rcarmo 10y agoI built a Mini-like machine with a fair amount of oomph before Christmas, and have all the part lists and build details online: https://taoofmac.com/space/blog/2016/12/17/1840 https://taoofmac.com/space/blog/2016/12/17/1840
- khazhou 10y agoOk great. So now I want to buy this. With a hard drive, etc ... I want to go a purchase site, select my specs, and hit purchase. NOT SO FAST. This is a Kit. I have to buy the components separately and assemble. Hurray for roadblocks.
- biot 10y ago> a died in the wool Mac user What an appropriate typo. Normally it should be "dyed in the wool".
- notadoc 10y agoLooks like a good machine. Really makes you wonder why Apple seems to be neglecting the Mac Mini, or the Mac line in general.
- simonh 10y agoI just don't think Apple is trying to cover the whole computer market anymore, and in fact really haven't done for the whole post-NEXT era. They do basic and pro desktops and a few basic and pro laptops and that's it. There will always be some pros and some consumers that want or need something a bit different and for them there's Linux and Windows, and from Apple's point of view that's fine. Apple are long past trying to occupy every ecological niche that computers can fill. The level of fit and finish they put into their products means they just don't have the bandwidth to cover all the market, or update every product on every cycle. The NUC us a great little device and Windows 10 is the least worst version for years, so go for it. Enjoy.
- synaesthesisx 10y agoApple is aggressively at work with their new depth sensors + SoC and GPU for their new lens wearable.
- general_ai 10y ago"Never had to reboot". Yet every time I start my sparingly used Windows machine the first thing it wants me to do is reboot to install updates, and it's pretty insistent about it.
- fuzzy2 10y agoNot only that, it will reboot when it decides to and you can't do a thing about it. You haven't pressed a button for a while because you're watching a movie? Time to reboot! I know about "work time", but it can last only 12 hours (IIRC).
- spraak 10y agoI never really use my laptop as a portable computer. It usually still just sits at my desk, so I think next time I buy a machine I'll consider getting something like this and max out the RAM and get a nice USB monitor.
- bootload 10y ago" Is this what I’ve been missing all these years as a died in the wool Mac user?" Laser focus in apple (cf @nattnewton), laser focus in customers perceptions.
- forgottenacc57 10y agoAll technology companies fail due to dogmatic self belief above their world view. The Apple world view is that they do not need to aggressively compete in desktop/laptop computing.
- aorth 10y agoActually that machine looks great—but where do I buy one? I searched for the product number of that NUC on Amazon and only find different (older) versions? There's something to be said for Apple's naming scheme versus "NUC Kit NUC7i5BNK" !
- rasengan0 10y agoI'm in the same boat but opted for ChromeOS with Linux https://github.com/dnschneid/crouton https://github.com/dnschneid/crouton on https://www.groupon.com/deals/gg-acer-116-chromebook-2857 https://www.groupon.com/deals/gg-acer-116-chromebook-2857 My current mac mini sits idle only used for activities Chrome / linux doesn't support Oh yeah, Apple? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13511241 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13511241