37 ms·
I still can't get over the headphone jack. Apple does have a good record of abandoning technologies at the right time (floppies, CDs, Flash, etc) but the bigge
by slg 10y ago
I still can't get over the headphone jack. Apple does have a good record of abandoning technologies at the right time (floppies, CDs, Flash, etc) but the biggest difference is that those technologies were all on the downward slope of their popularity when Apple made the move and all had solid replacements available at the time. The headphone jack is just as popular today as it has ever been and it is still more convenient and dependable than wireless headphones for most people in most situations. Maybe that changes soon or maybe AirPods solve this for iOS users (they by design can't be a universal solution) but I can't help but feel that Apple is jumping the gun on dropping the jack. Although as an iPhone user, I hope I'm wrong.
Side note, I think it is hilarious that Apple can't get the AirPods to ship at the same time as the iPhone. Anyone who buys the new phone on release is going to be stuck with the crappy lightning headphones for at least a month and a half.
- DavideNL 10y ago> I still can't get over the headphone jack People can't handle change. Reminds me of Steve Jobs ditching Flash in 2010... https://www.apple.com/hotnews/thoughts-on-flash/ https://www.apple.com/hotnews/thoughts-on-flash/
- apendleton 10y agoUSB is a good counterexample, though. They started pushing USB for all peripherals before anybody else, and before there was a good market for peripherals that supported it. The market emerged soon thereafter, though, and other companies were ditching their parallel ports, etc., within a year or two.
- slg 10y agoExcept USB was a standard. Lightning isn't and it doesn't appear that the W1 chip is either.
- jakobegger 10y agoThey say that the Airpods work with Macs too, so I assume they use bluetooth? W1 could just be their custom Bluetooth chip
- thesimon 10y agoBut they probably can't be paired with any other device than Apple's.
- ubernostrum 10y agoNow that people are actually reviewing them, it seems very clear that you can pair AirPods with anything that does Bluetooth audio. Would you like to revise your priors concerning Apple products?
- thesimon 10y agoReports at the keynote were saying they were not pairable with other devices. But it indeed seems they are.
- ubernostrum 10y agoNot really; people who had preconceived notions of what they thought Apple would do were reporting this. And those people were wrong, and perhaps their preconceived notions are in need of revision.
- apendleton 10y agoRight, I'm not defending this decision, specifically. Just offering a counterpoint to the parent's: > the biggest difference is that those technologies were all on the downward slope of their popularity when Apple made the move This was not the case when Apple pushed hard on USB as compared to other peripheral standards with the iMac in the late '90s.
- strictnein 10y agoUSB isn't a good counter example, unless they were switching to USB-C. But they're not, they're sticking with their proprietary port.
- BurningFrog 10y agoOP is talking about the controversial original iMac launch in 1998: http://www.macworld.com/article/1133334/original_imac.html http://www.macworld.com/article/1133334/original_imac.html "Considering all these amenities, the most shocking part of the iMac isn’t what it offers, but what it lacks. The iMac has no floppy drive, which might be forgivable if there were a Zip drive or other removable-media option, but there isn’t. And most dramatically, this new consumer offering has no SCSI port, no standard serial ports, and no ADB ports. Apple has opted to replace these familiar connections with USB, a high-speed serial architecture that has suffered from slow adoption on the Wintel platform despite its technical advantages (see the sidebar “USB: Ready for Prime Time?”). Currently, no USB devices exist for the Mac."
- strictnein 10y agoBut that was a standard open to all and everyone understood it was the future, even in 1998. Lightning isn't any of that.
- compiler-guy 10y agoLightning isn't the future, but some sort of wireless is. Lightning is just a stop-gap.
- BurningFrog 10y agoStandardized, yes. But it was not at all clear that it would become a dominant force. Far from all standards do. Many think it was the iMac that made it into the success it has become.
- usaphp 10y ago> "but the biggest difference is that those technologies were all on the downward" Most of my friends are using bluetooth headphones nowadays.
- csours 10y agoI've tried a number of bluetooth headphones, none of them have had the sound quality of wired. Songs would skip, quality was not great. Are there bluetooth headphones that don't skip nowadays?
- 6dqh5yapl3 10y agoMy bluetooth headphones (sennheiser urbanite XL) skipped on an android phone (LG G4) but work great on an iphone.
- _ph_ 10y agoYes. I am extremely happy with the beats solo 2 wireless. No surprise, that they are working well with an iPhone. As they support AAC over bluetooth, they offer quality audio - bluetooth headphones which don't do indeed sound bad on IOS devices.
- m_eiman 10y agoI've had these for a while and they're very nice: https://usa.denon.com/us/product/portableaudio/noisecanceling/ahgc20 https://usa.denon.com/us/product/portableaudio/noisecancelin...
- usaphp 10y agoI have Bose Wireless headphones and Beats Wireless, they both work great and I dont hear any difference in quality.
- theshrike79 10y agoIf either end of the connection is implemented crappily, then the quality will suffer.
- mntmn 10y ago
- TazeTSchnitzel 10y agoI thought they might replace the headphone jack with a USB-C connector. Then they could do the same thing on the MacBook and it'd have two USB-C ports. But instead they chose Lightning, so now we have iPhone headphones and Android headphones. Why did it have to be this way?
- serge2k 10y agoBecause Apple. I really don't want a shitty android phone. Might get a 6s I guess. I damaged my 6 recently.
- amiga-workbench 10y agoThen choose a good one.
- usaphp 10y agoWe have bluetooth headphones, which work on iPhones, Androids and computers.
- Lammy 10y agoThe latency of bluetooth headphones makes things like mobile rhythm games unplayable.
- mrob 10y agoDon't most rhythm games have a latency calibration option? Rhythm games don't need low latency, only predictable latency.
- Lammy 10y agoMy iPad 3 is pretty much "the Reflec Beat machine" and while it does have a timing adjustment option it only moves the moment in time that it uses for judgement. If I delay it to compensate for wireless earbuds then it will be visually delayed too past the judge line. Sure they can compensate for this with more options but I like sane defaults. I have never had to touch this slider because zero is already perfect, and in games with separate audio and visual lag compensation options I'm never confident that I've gotten it accurate. This isn't something you should have to ask the user to do. https://i.imgur.com/qU2TEP5.jpg https://i.imgur.com/qU2TEP5.jpg
- strictnein 10y agoAnd to say it was about "Courage". No, we all understand that it's a way for them to make more money selling their horrible headphones and licensing lightning to headphone makers.
- vhost- 10y agoWhy would they include a 3.5 mm adapter then?
- strictnein 10y agoAs a stop gap. Also, it's not clear whether or not the included headphones are 3.5mm or lightning, so they might simply have to include one.
- jakobegger 10y agoIn the keynote they said the included headphones are lightning.
- mcphage 10y agoThe included headphones are Lightning.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cm2187 10y agoI won't even touch a USB ethernet dongle for laptops, let alone a dongle for my iphone. The headphone connector is already pressed close to breaking point in my pocket, I can't have something even bigger sticking out of the phone in a tight pocket.
- heartbreak 10y ago> in a tight pocket Doesn't sound like an Apple problem to me.
- kartD 10y agoThe iPhone ships with lighting to 3.5mm adapter so Apple has heard users... Kinda
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ForFreedom 10y agoright now can one charge and hear music?
- eli 10y agoAt the time it really did feel like they were jumping the gun with floppies and optical drives too.
- cm2187 10y agoI wasn't but I still was annoyed that many MacOS drivers were only available on floppies.
- mikeash 10y agoMaybe, but it wasn't at all to the same degree. Floppies were verging on uselessness in 1998. Capacities hadn't increased in a decade, while code and data sizes were growing exponentially. Floppies could barely fit anything useful anymore. A wide variety of replacements were available, with Zip, Jazz, Bernoulli, CD-RW, and others all competing. There was no standardization, so the replacements kind of sucked. Removable data storage was just a complete mess at the time, so eliminating the most standardized but vastly least capable option wasn't that big of a deal. With audio connectors, it's not like that at all. For wired connections, there's one universal standard that works great. There's no analogous situation to being unable to fit your massive bloated Word documents onto a 1.44MB floppy disk. Moving past the floppy disk solved a bunch of serious problems, while moving past the headphone jack isn't solving any problems.
- an_account 10y agoWireless headphones that just work are seriously really nice. Once you use them, you wonder why all headphones aren't wireless. Removing the headphone jack forces people to solve the wireless headphone problems: pairing, latency, and charging. I'm not convinced apple isn't timing this well, but I see what they're getting at and I think it may be more like these past example than people are saying.
- xer 10y agoThe thing about 3.5mm jack is economy. Can you afford wireless? Apple is all premium.
- ProAm 10y agoUsually premium means better though.
- ceejayoz 10y ago> the biggest difference is that those technologies were all on the downward slope of their popularity when Apple made the move and all had solid replacements available at the time Was that downward slope clear at the time Apple made the changes, though? I remember "no Flash on iPhone" being a major complaint of many pundits.
- k-mcgrady 10y agoDropping the DVD drive was also a pretty big thing at the time as there wasn't even a 'similar' alternative (another type of removable media the industry had switched to. In the past it seems when they drop technology it real does make the changeover period quicker. This time I'm not so sure it will but at the end of the day I don't think it matters. Most people use the headphones that come with their iPhone and they will continue to. Not to mention Beats has 60-80% of the headphone market share depending on who you believe so with Beats + EarPods + AirPods most people are covered.
- izacus 10y ago"Most" people do a lot of things, but that doesn't mean that use of proprietary patent protected communication standards doesn't really hurt innovation and customers in the long term.
- esolyt 10y agoFlash never worked well on mobile devices. So Apple never tried to implement it. Headphones worked fine with every mobile device in the world.
- berberous 10y agoI think they are really shooting themselves in the foot if they don't open up and license the W1 chip to any manufacturer that wants it. If the only way forward is to buy poor quality AirPods (I'm assuming that they audio quality, like with the EarPods, is 'okay', but not great considering the price) or even more overpriced Beats, then this is a really user hostile move. Yes, you could use Bluetooth, but I'm guessing (hoping...) Apple has done some work to make the stream quality sound better and the connection process more stable. If they were to freely license that technology, people could buy great sounding headphones, with an improved UX, from any company they chose too. Now, it just seems like Apple's "courageous" way forward is all about pushing you to high margin Beats and EarPods.
- k-mcgrady 10y ago>> "poor quality AirPods" ...you haven't even used them yet...
- bluedino 10y agoThe EarPods leave quite a bit to be desired.
- 542458 10y agoYeah. Apple is not incompetent as far as headphone design goes - the EarPods have a surprisingly good soundstage and are very well balanced. They're also very light and pretty comfortable for most people. They don't isolate, but isolation is not really the use-case IMHO.
- callesgg 10y agoSurprisingly good for what they are...
- irunbackwards 10y agoI don't understand, aren't there tons of companies doing bluetooth/wireless earbuds right now?
- 10y ago
- acomjean 10y agoI can't get over the headphone jack either. Another dongle to loose. Tons of headphones obsoleted. Can't charge while listening. Laggy audio. more batteries in the world. They're ok with a bulge for the camera but not headphones? I work in a lab and a phone with headphones is standard equipment on the commute and work (for at least part of the day). I would seriously move off iOS if I was making music with it. If only iOS devices were made by other manufacturers... (I know I know....) on the plus side minimum memory had been bumped.
- tajen 10y ago> Tons of headphones obsoleted. They do provide the lightening-to-jack adapter in the box for free.
- Frank2312 10y agoI sure hope they don't force their customers into an extra 100+$.
- takeda 10y agoWho will carry that with them?
- supercoder 10y agoPeople carrying headphones around id imagine
- nsxwolf 10y agoJust leave it connected to your headphones.
- valarauca1 10y agoSee here is the crux of the issue I use my headphones for: -Listening to the environment while PC Gaming using a Windows PC -Listening to records using my stereo -Listening to music while working on my Macbook Pro -Listening to music while being mobile w/ iPhone 6 -Listening to music while driving in my car (audio jack works faster with less interruptions then USB) The big win of 3.3mm audio jack is they work with all these different systems and use-cases. There is nothing to lose, nothing to think about. Plug and Play. Dead simple. Dumb analog. Now to fully cover all my uses cases I have 2 more things to carry around with me full time, and not lose. Not a simplification, buying a Nexus. Steve Jobs is dead.
- wayfarer2s 10y agoHonestly I'm glad they're moving towards wireless. I replace way more headphones than I care to admit just from them wearing out with normal use. It's usually just the wire itself that is worn out, the earpieces are almost always in good condition. The only thing I worry about is losing the AirPods, but they seem like a step in the right direction.
- majewsky 10y agoBut wireless is an option already. That's not a reason to eliminate the 3.5 jack at all cost.
- Esau 10y agoPlus, some people don't want Bluetooth on. Like me.
- throwanem 10y agoSo use the adapter?
- Esau 10y agoI suspect the adapter will be annoying and easily losable.
- throwanem 10y agoI suspect the adapter will cost ten bucks a throw. Buy a spare. (Or don't. But it's an odd place to get frugal when we're talking about a $700 phone.)
- mikeash 10y agoWell, here I was typing up a sarcastic reply about how Apple is congenitally incapable of selling anything with a price tag under $20, but they already have the thing on their store, and it's $9: http://www.apple.com/shop/product/MMX62AM/A/lightning-to-35-mm-headphone-jack-adapter?fnode=85 http://www.apple.com/shop/product/MMX62AM/A/lightning-to-35-... That certainly does help alleviate the pain.
- kayoone 10y agoThere is still the adapter so i don't really get the hate. Moving to digital has a lot of potential in the long run and personally i am very happy with my bluetooth headphones.
- tebruno99 10y agoThe adapter doesn't allow you to charge. So older cars can't Music+GPS+Charge which means you just have a dead phone when you get where you are going.
- acomjean 10y agoThis is a really good point. The car is another use case. My car has the cable, but no Bluetooth. Gps navigation is still a big power draw. I get the feeling our use cases are no longer the same as the people who design these devices.
- acomjean 10y agoThis is a really good point. The car is another use case. My car has the cable, but no Bluetooth. Gps navigation is still a big power draw. I get the feeling our use cases are no longer the same as the people who design these devices.
- TillE 10y agoAnd the adapter is digital, right? Phil said the Lightning port was great for "digital audio". They have to cram a DAC in each one? I could just about tolerate a very simple small analog adapter, but this is going too far.
- matznerd 10y agoYou can complain about this, but I have recently bought two pairs of headphones, LG tones and JayBirds, and they are both bluetooth. I really do not see myself going back to wired headphones ever again, so this move is pretty timely.
- bashinator 10y agoI myself have about a thousand dollars invested in high-end headphones and earbuds (Sony DJ cans, Extreme Isolation EX-29 for the open office, Sennheiser earbuds for the commute) that I have no intention of replacing or buying a dongle for.
- zyxley 10y agoYou don't need to buy a dongle - it comes with one.
- csommers 10y agoI seriously question the quality of the DAC in that dongle.
- Gorbzel 10y agoClearly you've never seen any teardowns of Apple adapters. Usually the best (cleanest power, data throughput, etc) in their respective categories.
- jdminhbg 10y agoIf you cared about the quality of the DAC, wouldn't you have bought a great one already?
- cortesoft 10y agoAnd you think the built in DAC on the old iPhones was better?
- Zombieball 10y ago
- danso 10y agoWell, for anyone else who like me can't get the Apple earbuds to stay in my fucked up ear (cauliflower ear, from wrestling), I bought these Bluetooth earbuds a month ago and now use them all the time: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B01GDIUA8Y/ https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B01GDIUA8Y/ At $45 they're not the cheapest but they've got pretty good sound quality and work well from a physical standpoint
- Esau 10y agoTo me, the biggest problem with this move is that you can't charge the device and listen to music with corded headphones at the same time. Unless there is some option I am unaware of. In any case, I just decided to replace my iPhone 5 with an iPhone 6s, which I should be able to find on sale.
- tarcon 10y agoThe iPhone Lightning Dock offers a traditional headphone port for that use case.
- strictnein 10y agoA $40-$50 (2/5 stars on Apple.com) adapter to cover that use case. A $10-$20(?) dongle to cover the using normal headphone use case. Pass.
- ProAm 10y agoThat's convenient...
- seiferteric 10y agoI guess Apple's solution is to always buy more stuff. I could easily see "needing" to now have three docks and 2 adapters. One dock at home office to listen/charge when working at home all day, one for work office for same reason and one in the car for long road trips / commuting (no BT in my car, just aux). Maybe I could get away with one adapter if I leave it connected to my headphones... But I can't be expected to reasonable carry around docks with me or even to consistently remember them when I hop into the car. I already know it would be a matter of time before winding up in a situation where I would not have an adapter on me, or needing to charge. Basically this is an anti-consumer move, there is zero benefit to consumers and actually makes everyone's lives more inconvenient. It's strange because I don't need any of this stuff right now with my iPhone 6+, it was a solved problem. Never before, after a new Apple release have I felt that what I have now is more desirable than the newer version.
- 10y ago
- troncheadle 10y agoBluetooth headphones outsold standard audio jack headphones in the US last month for the first time. This is perfectly timed.
- joakleaf 10y agoDoes the survey account for the number of phones that are sold with audio jack headphones? It could be that the only reason bluetooths outsells jacks, is because people get jacks anyway for free.
- randomdata 10y agoDoes it matter in this case? If the remaining headphone users stick with whatever headphones come packaged with their phone for free, then they still wouldn't be using the audio jack with the iPhone 7, as the iPhone 7 comes packaged with lightning headphones.
- seiferteric 10y agoHow many headphones are people even buying? I have a drawer full of headphones I have collected over the years. Not at all surprising people would only be buying wireless headphones, but it does not mean they are more commonly used.
- brightball 10y agoVery valid point. People already have plenty of wired headphones.
- tnecniv 10y agoDepends on what you mean. I have two pairs of headphones at any given time. One is a high quality over ear set for work/transit/home. The second is a "beater" cheap pair I bought at CVS that I wear when working out or walking. I lose the beater pair all the time, but don't care because they are cheap.
- melling 10y agoPS/2 keyboards weren't on the way out. Apple led the way and pushed USB for a few years before it caught on.
- gyey 10y agoBut the lightening port is a closed standard, as opposed to USB. It would have made much more sense here if Apple had used USB-C instead of lightening.
- melling 10y agoYep, and everyone else will drop the headphone jack for USB-C. The headphone jack is dead. http://www.theverge.com/2016/4/27/11516410/intel-usb-c-audio-no-headphone-jack http://www.theverge.com/2016/4/27/11516410/intel-usb-c-audio... Apple really can't change ports again. I think they're really going to push for wireless. When they get wireless charging they'll remove the lightening port.
- theshrike79 10y agoPeople really need to study the timeline here. Lightning was out year(s) before USB-C ever got certified.
- jonlucc 10y agoI don't think that changes the point. The parent is saying that there's a difference between dropping a universal standard in favor of a closed standard.
- melling 10y agoThere's a legacy connector in every box. All your legacy headphones still work. Apple didn't want to add an additional port and they can't exactly switch to usb-c at this point. In 3 years when all other phone makers drop the headphone jack for usb-c, can we get a lightning to usb-c?
- 10y ago
- slantedview 10y agoPros for wireless: no wires. Pros for wired: better fidelity, no batteries to charge, lighter weight, more headphones to choose from, cheaper headphone options, no adapters to lose, can listen to music while charging. Be bold.
- wayfarer2s 10y agoAnother pro for wireless is that you get more space inside the phone, which means more room for chips, batteries, etc. And you have to consider things like headphone jack make it harder for your phone to be waterproof since that's one more place you have to figure out how to seal.
- Larrikin 10y agoSony figured out the waterproof headphone jack issue three iterations ago. My z5 is just fine in the shower
- theshrike79 10y agoDo you shower with your phone often? =)
- kirykl 10y agoOne of Apple's core tenents is 'to hell with legacy' Lightning headphones are a stop gap. The future is wireless.
- jonknee 10y agoMy issue with this is there are wireless headphones today, you don't need to remove the headphone jack to support them. It's a step back for no compelling reason.
- jjawssd 10y agoThat would make sense if wired wasn't far superior to wireless from a reliability and throughput standpoint
- ceejayoz 10y agoThe iPhone's Bluetooth 4 is capable of 24 Mbps. If that's not enough throughput for your music listening, I'm not sure what to tell you.
- falcolas 10y agoI work in an office with a lot of 2.4 GHZ wifi going on - bluetooth anything (including keyboard and mouse) doesn't work worth a damned in that environment. Wireless is a poor substitute for wired in most real-world usecases. Wireless gives you: unpredictable performance, latency, contention for available frequencies, and having to deal with batteries. I think it's OK for wifi, only because most of the time the bandwidth of wifi is greater than the bandwidth of your ISP. But I think that's a problem with the state of ISPs, not a blessing of wifi.
- heartbreak 10y agoWere you given early access to Apple's "wireless" AirBuds?
- ForFreedom 10y ago
- rsync 10y agoI never got to the point you are at because I could never get over the USB jack. It took 30 fucking years and a lot of blood sweat and tears but finally finally there is a global, universal, cheap and simple charging standard that just works. You can find a USB port anywhere and there are extra cables everywhere and life is just slightly better all around. Except for Apple.
- cm2187 10y agoWell, mini USB, then micro USB, then USB-C, then... I have to change my cables every 5 years, not exactly "a" global standard.
- yoodenvranx 10y agoI have to change my cables every 1-2 years because they will inevitably break with normal usage.
- WatchDog 10y agoI must be abnormal, as I have never broken a USB cable.
- yoodenvranx 10y agoI play a lot of Ingress and Pokemon Go with an external battery. Due to the movement and flexing while walking around, the cable destroys itself.
- developer2 10y agoYou're in the minority. Normal people don't break cables. The latest Apple cables still have the cheap rubber sleeve peel away, but you can rip it off entirely and have the metal-coated cable last years without the wire fraying. If you're actually fraying the wire itself, you are treating your phone extremely poorly. I am not gentle with my equipment, and I've never had an Apple cable fall apart to the point of needing replacement.
- rajacombinator 10y agoApple headphones are super poor quality as well. I can get some Chinese ones off Amazon for $10 that absolutely destroy the Apple ones.
- jclarkcom 10y agoCan you point me to one? I've tried nearly a dozen of Chinese clones and they all suck compared to apple's. I hate to pay $30 for headphones but ended up going back to apple.
- theshrike79 10y agoPlease provide links to these absolute destroyers.
- daxelrod 10y agoWhich ones?
- r00fus 10y agoPray tell, which ones? My experience is the opposite.
- phatbyte 10y agoPlease let us know where we can buy it?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dr_ 10y agoIt really depends on how one primarily listens to music on their phone. There are a LOT of people who listen to music on their phone while working out. Having a cable dangling, disconnecting or having the phone fall while you are working out is pretty annoying as well. Bluetooth headphones were never a perfect option, but the new phone and wireless chip very well could be.
- aquark 10y agoI switched back to wired headphones after going through several (different) pairs of bluetooth headphones that could seem to cope with the sweat overload for more than a month or two before dying. The cord is a bit of a pain, but the cost of the bluetooth headphones was more so!
- kilroy123 10y agoI just don't get the supports of this. I have a pair of bluetooth headphone and of course normal corded. Bluetooth sucks! It's buggy as hell. You have to constantly get it to re-sync with your device. Interference constantly makes the signal get crappy. Ever been on a call with your fancy blue tooth headset while someone turned on a microwave near by? I have, that shit stops working! I'm all for moving forward with an all digital solution, but blue tooth just doesn't cut it 100% of the time.
- exclusiv 10y agoThey're pricey (~ 450 USD), but I recommend the Sennheiser Momentum bluetooth wireless [1]. Great sound for music (aptX) and phone calls, comfortable, solid noise cancellation. You can still use them corded if you want too. [1] https://en-us.sennheiser.com/momentum-wireless-headphones-with-mic https://en-us.sennheiser.com/momentum-wireless-headphones-wi...
- eagsalazar2 10y agoThis. Bluetooth just sucks. I recently tried out 3 of the top rated bluetooth headsets on Amazon after giving up a couple years ago. It still just sucks and is not reliable. Battery life is terrible if you want headphones you can use all day while at work or commuting (won't even come close to making it through the day with smaller headphones). This is just a terrible decision IMO. OTOH I'm a diehard Nexus guy so I guess I really don't care :)
- sahaskatta 10y agoWhich bluetooth headphones did you try? I have the following two and they work perfectly. - Plantronics Backbeat Go - Jabra Pulse Both worked perfectly paired with my Surface Pro as well as my Nexus 6P. I also had a Nexus 6 prior to that and it paired to that device with no issues whatsoever as well.
- kristjansson 10y agoPlantronics seem to have simply mastered bluetooth. The backbeat pro pairs easily with everything I've tried, long enough range to leave my phone at my desk all day, connects to work + personal at the same time, and are pretty good headphones to boot.
- lifeisstillgood 10y agoFor me the awesome / scary / new best practise was the Tim Cook must have asked "how many people use headphones, whilst charging" and they could tell him, to the user, to the minute, to the location. Yeah, we can lose 4% of Abba lovers. Go for it
- specialp 10y agoI am not sure if I agree with the floppy being abandoned at the right time. This was at a time where the cloud would be emailing something to yourself, no USB drives, and CD writers that were expensive, and burnt a coaster half the time. Also back then Apple had a minuscule market share, so they did not really kill it. It just made most people have to buy an external floppy drive. Yes the floppy did have to go, but USB sticks needed to come first, and they were not there yet. There really wasn't any other alternative for say saving your work at school and going home.
- baby 10y agoOn the website it's written that the iPhone comes with a jack to lightning adapter.
- codemogul 10y agoForced adoption is a factor to be considered in their strategy. In the United States, 13 states and DC have standing laws forbidding the use of cell phones in "hand-held" mode while driving. [1] In other words, you can talk with it, but not on your ear. To ensure compliance, most manufacturers include cheapy bud and microphone wired headset kits in their boxes. By virtue of their control of 12% or so of the phone market, Apple is putting a lot of Lightning headsets into the stream, and making a bet that a lot of those people in the ecosystem will upgrade to the pods. [1] http://www.ncsl.org/research/transportation/cellular-phone-use-and-texting-while-driving-laws.aspx http://www.ncsl.org/research/transportation/cellular-phone-u...
- kennell 10y agoAs for the AirPods: $159 for something that i will most likely lose within the first 3 months? Nope, not buying it. Also, the battery life will be probably be cut in half after 2 years usage or so.
- j45 10y agoDoes anyone know if aptX support has arrived in the iPhone for bluetooth devices? I have been increasingly using devices like the Sony SBH80, or SBH54 and they work seamlessly for the most part already between my phone and laptop. I don't think the headphone thing has been thought thru but their wireless jump to the W1 seems to be at least in part bluetooth 4.x based which itself is a far superior technology to even BT 3.0 that many devices today have. The other problem I've run into is having a phone and headset with the same version of bluetooth. Bluetooth audio, once high quality enough through codecs like aptX will become like wifi, we will wonder why we were tethered with wires to begin with. Bluetooth 5.0 appears to have taken a big step towards the audio quality issue resolution. I've previously owned the Sony MW600 and SBH52 bluetooth receivers for the past 5-7 years. As the tech improves it's going to become more viable and is in line with Apple's generally wireless strategy between Macbook, iPad, iPhone, etc.
- morganw 10y ago> aptX support ... iPhone Nope, but "iOS devices support the non-mandatory codec MPEG-2/4 AAC, as defined in Section 4.5 of the A2DP specification, Version 1.2.Accessories should use the AAC codec in addition to SBC, because it provides higher audio quality for a given bit rate. " source http://theheadphonelist.theheadphonelist.netdna-cdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/bluetoothdesignguidelines.pdf?9f6996 http://theheadphonelist.theheadphonelist.netdna-cdn.com/wp-c... via http://theheadphonelist.com/wireless-fidelity-making-sense-bluetooth-headphone-technology/ http://theheadphonelist.com/wireless-fidelity-making-sense-b...
- yborg 10y agoVery good question. It's basically incomprehensible why Apple doesn't support the codec in iOS, especially since the other issue that replacing wired headphones with Bt is that the sound quality is inferior - even with aptX support. I'm very surprised that I have seen almost no mention of the fact that Apple didn't just remove an "outdated" interface and inconvenience their customers, they also simultaneously reduced the quality of their audio experience.
- DCKing 10y agoTo be fair to Apple, I think they have a good point. Digital connectors are superior in almost every way (space use, port flexibility, sound quality, even cable integrity). I admire them for ripping off the bandaid, like they did previously with disk drives and parrallel ports. Someone needs to lead the way to abandon legacy, and Apple can do that far more effectively than others (e.g. Motorola has also abandoned headphone jacks with their Moto Z line). One thing I cannot get over though, is that they chose their own propietary, you-have-to-pay-Apple-for-a-license, cannot-use-them-with-anything-else Lightning 'standard'. USB Type C is the standard for this stuff now, and any trivial technical merits Lightning might have over USB Type C don't weigh up against the universal nature of USB Type C. The sheer arrogance. Digital connectors the future? I'm on board with that. Propietary connectors? Fuck that.
- jonknee 10y ago> Digital connectors are superior in almost every way (space use, port flexibility, sound quality, even cable integrity). Then why has almost no one decided to use Lightning headphones when given a choice?
- scottmf 10y agoChicken/egg
- jonknee 10y agoIt's not a chicken and egg problem, every iPhone for years has a Lightning port and yet almost no one buys any Lightning accessories other than charging cables. For headphones it offers no advantage and an obvious limitation. If Apple didn't remove the headphone jack in the iPhone 7 do you think any large number of people would intentionally buy Lightning headphones?
- SCdF 10y ago> (space use, port flexibility, Except they only gave you one port, so you can't even do something as benign as charge your phone and listen to fucking music at the same time. > sound quality, I challenge you to prove that one, I'm sure sound quality is indistinguishable. If it's good enough for every sound engineer ever it's good enough for me. > even cable integrity) Again, is that even true? You can knock out a cheap headphone cable that works perfectly, whereas lightning devices are always crazy expensive.
- ch4s3 10y agoMy hope is that this will help push towards a better bluetooth. If a lot more people are paring headphones daily the market will demand better pairing. (I hope)
- lnanek2 10y agoYeah, but Apple isn't using Bluetooth for the AirPods (they've already been quoted in the press as saying their technology is more battery efficient than Bluetooth). Do we really want everyone moving away from a wireless standard and implementing their own custom pairing solutions like Apple did, that will only work when the producing companies for the accessory and the host match?
- pbreit 10y agoIf you have to include an adapter in the box... But seriously, how hard would it have been to do a generation of keeping the jack with the Lightning headphones (and putting Lightning on Macs)?
- winkle 10y agoI purchased a bluetooth receiver for my car last year since I already had a headphone size cord to plugin to my phone. The same thing could be used for your now obsolete headphones. Although all I could find was the refurbished version. https://www.amazon.com/Etekcity-Bluetooth-NFC-Enabled-Certified-Refurbished/dp/B01CU00VQ0/ https://www.amazon.com/Etekcity-Bluetooth-NFC-Enabled-Certif... Now you just have to carry your phone plus a bluetooth receiver to plug into!
- georgespencer 10y ago> the biggest difference is that those technologies were all on the downward slope of their popularity when Apple made the move Were any of them? MacBook Air released in 2008. DVD media sales rose YOY 2005 => 2009. Flash video did not decrease in popularity pre-iPhone, it decreased because of the iPhone. > The headphone jack is just as popular today as it has ever been "DVDs are as popular today as they have ever been" - someone in 2008 > they by design can't be a universal solution They've been explicitly designed to be as close to a universal solution as is possible. Pair them with one of your Apple devices and that pairing is synced to all others. Instead of unplugging your cable from your phone to your Mac you simply start doing something on your Mac and the audio source switches. If the Airpods did not require power and were simply completely wireless they'd be the perfect solution. Apple is betting that battery advances will mean that the utility of these headphones (no wire, built in sensors) massively outweighs the cons (require power). Right now they only benefit "a lot" of people.
- theli0nheart 10y ago>> the biggest difference is that those technologies were all on the downward slope of their popularity when Apple made the move > Were any of them? MacBook Air released in 2008. DVD media sales rose YOY 2005 => 2009. Flash video did not decrease in popularity pre-iPhone, it decreased because of the iPhone. And yet most people still need to buy external DVD/Blu-Ray drives. It's been 7 years, and not having DVD drives built into Mac hardware is still incredibly inconvenient. >> The headphone jack is just as popular today as it has ever been > "DVDs are as popular today as they have ever been" - someone in 2008 I'm sure someone said that, but I think most people were already moving on to Blu-Ray.
- cloudjacker 10y agoand not having a dvd drive built in is incredibly convenient for the form factor and durability of the machine
- pritambaral 10y agoThat gain in form-factor is not comparable to the removal of the 3.5mm port though.
- totalZero 10y agoThey probably deleted the jack so they can sell more airpods and beats wireless headphones. This technology delete doesn't strike me as an improvement, but rather a a way of coercing clients to spend more on accessories sold by Apple and subsidiaries.
- CodeWriter23 10y agoThe telling thing for me was Phil had to defend the headphone idea with three different arguments, along with an inflammatory photo of a switchboard. When Steve Jobs deleted the floppy drive, he simply declared that floppies had no future.
- clashmoore 10y agoI believe that Apple collected anonymous usage data of how often the headphone jacks were used on their iPhones and determined that it would be safe to remove - even with a vocal group that would complain. Whenever you install or upgrade to a new OS, Apple prompts users if they'd like to send the anonymous usage data and I feel the headphone jack would be an important data point they've been researching.
- twblalock 10y ago> Side note, I think it is hilarious that Apple can't get the AirPods to ship at the same time as the iPhone. Anyone who buys the new phone on release is going to be stuck with the crappy lightning headphones for at least a month and a half. Why? The phone comes with an adapter. Any headphones that worked with previous iPhones will work with the iPhone 7 via the adapter. People will just continue to use the headphones they already have.
- 2muchcoffeeman 10y agoBecause ditching the 3.5 mm jack is a fairly big deal and you'd think they would show you how well it works to encourage people to buy in to their idea and included them as standard.
- calsy 10y agoI don't think Apple jumped the gun, they hold the gun. Being a tech giant has its advantages, one being that you can push people into modifying their behaviour to adapt to your new products. There will always be initial 'outrage' but that is nothing new. Apple have no doubt made a calculated decision, weighed up the pros and cons and determine this is the best course of action moving forward. The iPhone6S series isn't going anywhere anytime soon and it's certainly still serviceable as a device, it didn't die today with the release of the iPhone7. If people are concerned, hold off on the purchase, do the research and make an informed decision for your own needs.
- panglott 10y agoFloppy drives were still going strong when Apple killed them, as were CDs. Apple briefly made a candy iMac that had neither a floppy drive nor a CD drive nor any other kind of removable drive...I always wondered what you were supposed to do if you had hard drive problems...Target Disk Mode, I guess, if you had another Mac. Apple wants to make a thinner phone and eliminate wires. If you want to use different headphones than the ones that come with...well, do so. Are AirPods the most advanced headphones ever to come with a music device? They're usually pretty bad.
- robotresearcher 10y agoThat iMac supported USB thumbdrives or any other USB drive. Like a MacBook Air or other ultrabook format machine today. > Are AirPods the most advanced headphones ever to come with a music device? They don't come with it. They are optional accessories. The new phone comes with Thunderbolt wired headphones.
- kalleboo 10y ago> Apple briefly made a candy iMac that had neither a floppy drive nor a CD drive nor any other kind of removable drive They never made a candy iMac without a CD or DVD drive. They didn't drop optical until the current design of aluminum iMacs in 2012. > I always wondered what you were supposed to do if you had hard drive problems When they dropped the optical drive with the first MacBook Air, they shipped it with the OS on a USB drive http://www.iclarified.com/images/news/16130/55529/55529-500.jpg http://www.iclarified.com/images/news/16130/55529/55529-500....
- exwardna 10y agoI suspect the lack of jack is a question of advertising / creation of a new environment to force people keep their Bluetooth on. Would that be among the reasons why Apple made that choice?
- supernintendo 10y agoYou're not alone and I would expand this distinction to not only factor in popularity but functionality as well. CDs phasing out floppy disks may have been done in part for DRM purposes but the advantage was at least clear; 700MB is a hell of a lot more than 1.44MB. With the iPhone 7, Apple is taking away a time-tested feature in favor of alternatives which do not present clear advantages. Bluetooth headphones are annoying to pair and tend to have connectivity issues in conditions like rain. Lightning headphones are expensive and prohibitive. Dongles suck. As for AirPods, I'm not getting the sense that they provide much more in the way of functionality or sound than any traditional, run-of-the-mill pair of headphones. They certainly won't sound as good as my Audio Technica ATH-M50x. What do I have to be excited for? I know it's hackneyed to glorify Steve Jobs but he always seemed to have his eye on the ball when it came to tech. Macintosh is the obvious example but if you look at his work at NeXT or building products like WebObjects, you see a CEO who predicted the resurgence of distributing computing and the overall dominance of networking in software. With the iPhone, Apple's move to phase out the physical keyboard on mobile devices was done to put content front and center - a design informed by Jobs' vision of a portable "post-PC" device that would act as the source of most of our media consumption. What is the removal of the 3.5MM jack informed by? Trivial product metrics like thickness and water-resistance? A cynical attempt to make money from licensing proprietary standards? Or maybe Apple is going through the motions, asserting its reputation as a "gatekeeper" that dictates which standards should be left in the past. Whatever the case may be, the iPhone 7 is not a compelling product. As an iPhone user, my next smartphone will most likely be an Android.
- 7952 10y agoI would be interested to know how often those jacks fail and need warranty replacement. For whatever reason I seem to break them easily and have moved to Bluetooth to avoid this. The design puts the strain on the socket rather than the jack. There may well be a small minority who regularly need repairs because of this.
- mxfh 10y agoDoes Apple prohibit to include audio sockets in case accessories? Some kind o flush T-Type bottom dock for angled jacks and with pass-through charging lightning capabilities should be a a no-brainer then. Otherwise a Bluetooth receiver with extended battery life to wired headphones seems more robust and practical to me anyway. Otherwise I never use headphones when on the go, so I cant really talk about that use case in practice.
- aidenn0 10y agoIt actually looks like they timed this pretty well; in June bluetooth headsets outsold wired ones: http://www.prweb.com/releases/2016/07/prweb13581918.htm http://www.prweb.com/releases/2016/07/prweb13581918.htm
- StillBored 10y agoSo, its not like you can't buy something like this https://www.amazon.com/Bluetooth-Receiver-Portable-Wireless-Smartphones/dp/B018280BU0/ref=sr_1_7/156-6761745-9434314?ie=UTF8&qid=1473280986&sr=8-7&keywords=bluetooth+headphone+jack https://www.amazon.com/Bluetooth-Receiver-Portable-Wireless-... That that said, I have a few of them and pretty much never use them because the extra battery life hassles aren't worth it relative to just plugging into the audio source. Apple has lost a few sales in my house because they failed to support one thing or another. My wife is an apple user, but I can never get over the lack of sd/pci/whatever slots, or frequently things like bluray playback... When shopping for a new device. As far as headphone jacks? Probably just another reason for me not to buy an idevice, I have a fairly large collection of bluetooth headphones, because of some work I was doing with A2DP a few years ago, but I pretty much use wired headphones because I've had the headphone battery die before the phone/etc way to often, and frankly when it comes to comfort (while sitting at my desk), or fit when running I stick to certain headphones not because they have cables but because they are better in the given use case.
- bobbywilson0 10y agoMost, if not all of the previous tech they abandoned seemed too early at the time. It forced those who were making products for Apple to follow their lead. Apple has always tried to reduce clutter with design, and a lot of that times it means getting rid of something that doesn't seem like it need to be removed, e.g. limited ports, no removable micro sd for iPhone, wireless devices and accessories, removing drives, soldering in laptop parts. There is a population of people that absolutely despise Apple for doing this. This seems like a classic 80/20 situation where the 80% don't have the need for a headphone jack or are willing to use wireless headphones and be fine with that. While the 20% are upset because like many of the replies below people have specific use cases for why they need it. It is more likely that we will see other manufacturers drop the headphone jack as well because Apple did. Again, most people will be fine with that. Bluetooth headphones and ear pieces have already been around for awhile. You also have to think about Apple's purchase of Beats Audio. With that said I will concede that I am also a bit bummed about them removing the port now as well, but I have learned that Apple is incredibly stubborn when it comes to listening to their consumers about these decisions, and you just have to abide, or buy something else.
- smegel 10y ago> is still more convenient and dependable than wireless headphones for most people in most situations And about the same as USB-C driven headphones. Which the iPhone supports just fine. How did you manage to avoid mentioning that in your comment?
- mcintyre1994 10y agoIf it's really Airpods or bust, they just added $160 onto the price of the phone. I don't think they mentioned any third parties other than Beats.. I guess because they own Beats.. but if the choices are Apple and Beats then the price is going to be ridiculous.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- midnitewarrior 10y agoApple's profits are on the downward slope, and their new acquisition of Beats along with them changing the headphone interface that's been in use for decades gives them great opportunity for revenue -- selling people premium upgraded headphones while instantly forcing all their devoted fans to upgrade. That has got to be worth $50-200 a user. As far as traditional headphones go, if it ain't broke, don't fix it. Unfortunately, Apple knows we've hit Peak Smartphone, and they are running out of grown opportunities, so this is simply an attempt to create more growth where it doesn't otherwise exist. It's mostly milking their customers and the industry.
- hardtke 10y agoThis may be a case where the European Union antitrust authorities mandate that Apple do something different. This seems to be a textbook case of monopoly status in one domain being used to exert a monopoly in another (headphones).
- daenney 10y agoI'd love to see how a claim with the antitrust authorities will hold up about Apple having an (iPhone) monopoly and abusing that somehow to get a monopoly in the headphone space, which is served by a bajillion manufacturers already providing many wireless and some lightning headphones. Don't forget Apple is also shipping the adapter that keeps all those minijack devices working. No matter how many times people want to try this, Apple doesn't have a monopoly when it comes to the mobile/smartphone (hardware) space.
- karmachameleon2 10y agoYou're overlooking the fact that governments don't actually act according to common sense. The EU is happy to rob a few billion dollars from a big company every now and then, so they have more loot to piss away. Didn't they just declare that Apple is a tax-avoiding criminal organization recently? Nevermind that according to the standard interpretations of international laws, Apple has done nothing wrong. On the other hand, HSBC and the like are free to launder money for drug cartels and actual terrorists, and get a few $Billion slap on the wrist when caught. Laws only apply to us little folks.
- importantbrian 10y agoI don't think removing the headphone jack is going to be as big a deal as everyone here makes it out to be. I have a pair of bluetooth headphones I use for the gym and I love them. In fact all the headphones I see at the gym anymore are wireless. The only thing I hate is having to charge them. If battery technology keeps improving there will be no advantage to wired headphones. Even from a sound quality perspective there are some very nice sounding bluetooth headphones out there, and I suspect that will only continue to improve. The only thing I really use wired headphones for anymore is as monitors when I'm playing in the band, and that's only because our monitor setup is wired. If I could find a good wireless IEM setup I would be in heaven. I see this as the direction the market is headed anyway. Apple has just moved to embrace it early.
- DarkTree 10y ago> I don't think removing the headphone jack is going to be as big a deal as everyone here makes it out to be. > I have a pair of bluetooth headphones I use for the gym and I love them. Yeah, that's why you don't see it as a problem. The majority of people still use corded headphones, some of which are high-quality, pricey investments that you don't just want to stop using. If you end up misplacing that little dongle, you can't listen to music privately until it's replaced. Seems like a downgrade in functionality, with almost no improvement, considering you are already using your bluetooth headphones effectively.
- huckyaus 10y ago> The majority of people still use corded headphones, some of which are high-quality, pricey investments that you don't just want to stop using. The vast majority of people I see in public use the standard Apple earbuds. I suspect that the percentage of people with expensive cans is very low, and that most people that buy the iPhone 7 will continue to use the stock lightning earbuds.
- importantbrian 10y ago^ This Are people really using high-end headphones on the go with their iPhones? I have some very nice corded cans, but they require a headphone amp to really sound good, so they only get used at home.
- goerz 10y agoHow long before that headphone to lightening dongle will break the lightening port? A broken lightening port, Apple has told me, is "unfixable" and they wanted me to replace the entire phone.
- tlrobinson 10y agoTo me the biggest difference between this and the examples you mentioned (floppies, CDs, Flash) is Lightning is a proprietary connector, not an upcoming industry standard.
- calibration263 10y agoThe future is an upcoming industry standard. Bluetooth. This year I believe is the first year we're seeing fully wireless earbuds, last year or two wired bluetooth earbuds were becoming more popular. Both in the historical examples and now the technology is more expensive and has some drawbacks, however they're much more practical(other than charging, which apple is betting will improve and that 4 hours of playback with 24 hours of recharge in the case will be acceptable).
- phatbyte 10y agoAs fair as I know the new iPhone will come with a ligthning adaptor for regular headphones jacks. So that will sort users for now.
- mdip 10y agoThe cynic in me sees this as a further attempt at lock-in. As you mentioned, when the other technologies were abandoned, a suitable replacement existed that was widely in use regardless of platform. With the headphones, buying a set for an iPhone will now no longer work with other non-Apple devices (at least, at the moment -- are they licensing this to others and are any others interested in lightning headphones?). I have two friends, recently, who destroyed their iPhone 6 (toilet and cement drop) and opted to purchase a higher-end Android device as a replacement (slightly less expensive with slightly better specs and they liked my phone when I let them play with it). Had they owned a pair of $200 "pretend" high-end headphones[0] that would have only worked with an iPhone, I doubt they would have been so quick to switch. I guess that could work the other way -- preventing Android users from switching to Apple, except it's resolved by a dongle on the Apple side without loss of perceived quality. Wireless isn't a suitable replacement, either. Every time I see a new set of excellent Bluetooth wireless headphones, I think of the drawer full of the previous BT headphone/headset devices I'd bought and the several that aren't there because I've lost them. Usually something fell off of the device or the battery stopped holding a charge as long as the phone (when I remembered to charge those, too). The AirPods are small so they end up in the pocket opposite my phone with other things[1], most likely, my keys. They appear durable enough to survive in that environment, but it'll take about a week before I pull my keys out (I've only got 3 keys and a couple of rings), one snags on a ring and falls onto the ground without me noticing. Welp, I'm done, off to the drawer you go, mono-Pods. I lose wired headphones much less frequently. They're usually plugged into my phone (and recent phones hold them tight) and wrapped inconspicuously around my neck. If I pocket them and they snag on my keys, I notice. But the best part is if I lose them, I can find a pair that suites my needs for $15 or less. Something tells me the Lightning headphones aren't going to be that cheap for a long time[2]. [0] "Pretend" high-end headphones refers to the likes of "Beats by Dre" and many others that are little more than the "Air Jordans" of headphones. You pay five times the price of similarly capable headphones because it's got a logo of a perceived "bad ass" on it. [1] Because, at least where I live, wearing them in your ears when your not using them is going to get you labeled a "Douche Bag" pretty quickly. [2] A quick search yielded several with the "basic features" I'd be looking for at around USD$50.00. Yikes.
- wklauss 10y ago> Side note, I think it is hilarious that Apple can't get the AirPods to ship at the same time as the iPhone. Anyone who buys the new phone on release is going to be stuck with the crappy lightning headphones for at least a month and a half. There are other vendors that make Lightning headphones (Philips, JBL...) and plenty of wireless headphones in the market.
- pfranz 10y agoI think it would have been a better transition if they had shipped the AirPods a year before removing it from the phone. Many people have been using bluetooth headphones for awhile, but Apple didn't offer anything until today. Let's say I go with AirPods. The presentation just showed initial pairing and focused on the phone. It seems to work with iphone 5 and forward, which is great, but does it work with my older laptop? What about non-Apple bluetooth devices? It would be also be a nice little perk to have it work with AppleTV for watching TV at night. Traditional bluetooth sucks when switching between devices (in addition to pairing). It would be nice if they could prove to everyone that was a solved problem (and prove the lighting earpods aren't just a stopgap) before ditching the headphone jack.
- inputcoffee 10y agoRemember Flash? It looked like it was the wrong time to drop it, but Apple was able to move consumers along.
- broodbucket 10y agoOne was a proprietary technology with a myriad of security and portability issues. Another is a universal standard that has worked with every type of device for decades. This isn't even comparing apples to oranges, it's comparing apples to giraffes
- stcredzero 10y agoa good record of abandoning technologies at the right time (floppies, CDs, Flash, etc) but the biggest difference is that those technologies were all on the downward slope of their popularity when Apple made the move I seem to remember commenters on "social media" (or at least their precursors) being just as confused over all of those changes. (With the possible exception of less outcry over optical drives going away.) It seems like there's always some supporters and always some detractors when Apple does something like this. Maybe that changes soon or maybe AirPods solve this for iOS users (they by design can't be a universal solution) There's an Apple pattern, where they support a less popular but more capable existing standard or come up with something superior to a standard, which spurs the development of an even better universal standard. It's high time that someone developed wireless headphones that weren't as much of a compromise as they generally are.
- evolve2k 10y agoI am troubled too but here's why I think this makes sense. Phones will continue to get thinner and thinner. Apple have looked ahead and said, in the future when this thing gets thin enough there won't be any space for any adapters. The main competitor for use of the Lightning port is charging (as we can see from all the comments), but what if come iPhone 8 they will introduced simple wireless charging. Suddenly the need for any port then would come into question and pave the way for a significant further reductions in phone thickness.
- endgame 10y agoCan we also take a minute to notice that this is also closing the analog hole?
- unixhero 10y agoWhat miserable trash. Apple id dead to me. It already was, even more so now. Why am I even here.
- unixhero 10y agoWhat miserable trash. Apple id dead to me. It already was, even more so now. Why am I even here.
- shams93 10y agoApple may make more money on people having to replace an easy to use headphone conveter for $99. The original android spec for 1.0 based on the HTC g1 reference device had a hardeware keyboard like Blackberry but it had all digital audio. You needed a micro usb to 8th inch convertor which was really easy to lose. After the lessons learned with the g1, subsequent Android phones added in the 8th inch audio jack and lost the hardware keyboard. There's a reason why the 8th inch is such a big deal its a standard that goes back to the 1880s.
- homero 10y agoAirpods will get lost within days
- Whitestrake 10y agoYou know, with all the people who are supposedly going to lose Airpods, it seems to me like you could just about bend down and pick a pair up off the ground if you lose your own!
- homero 10y agoThey'll be stepped on and crushed
- skywhopper 10y agoMeh, I hate cords, so I've been using bluetooth headphones for years. Just a matter of finding good quality ones. I do think it's dumb to get rid of the headphone jack though. The waterproofing I think they could overcome, and it's not like they could get rid of the DAC processor. It's about space inside the case and thinness, but I think a thicker phone without a dumb camera bump and with outrageously long battery life would be more impressive, IMO.
- Tloewald 10y agoI've seen some articles about the reliability of lightning connectors — I've certainly had a few of them "wear out" (i.e. no longer consistently make good contact with the phone's socket) but so far all of our many devices with lightning ports still have well-behaved ports (and this includes an iPhone 5 that is used mercilessly by one of my daughters). Overall, I like the lightning connector as a port, but not so much as a cable. That said, I've had an iPhone headphone socket fail owing to pocket lint. (It was fixed at the Genius bar for no charge.) I've been told that pocket lint being forced into iPhones sometimes leads to more serious internal damage. Besides that: 1) How often do you use headphones with your iPhone? I use my iPhone as a small sound system or a wireless source for my car far more often than I use wired headphones (basically, on planes). As I understand it, Apple has greatly improved the iPhone's speakers. (The 12.9" iPad Pro has ridiculously good audio.) 2) Have you gotten over Apple ditching serial ports in favor of ADB, ditching SCSI in favor of IDE (which was a technical regression at the time), ditching ADB in favor of USB, ditching the floppy drive, switching from round laptop power connections to magsafe, not supporting Flash, going from magsafe to magsafe2 and providing $10 converters, switching from the horrid old iPod adapter to the lightning port? 3) If you have one really nice set of headphones you use with your iPhone, just keep the adapter on it. (And if your cable is replaceable, which is the case with all the mid- and high- end headphones I've owned, you can presumably get a lightning-compatible replacement.) If you have several — the adapters are $9 each. If you have a ton of different crappy headphones that you use with your iPhone… Why? 4) I really hate dealing with headphone cables. Usually they get tangled unless I carefully spool them back into their case (in the case of Apple's earpods or whatever they're called). If I were paid $5/h for the time I've spent untangling or spooling headphone cables, I would be able to buy all the lightning adapters I'll ever need. If the wireless headphones live up to Apple's claims, I'll be pretty happy.
- deepGem 10y agoI see it as a ploy to move people up the ladder to the airpods. Though it's an expensive proposition, I for one will happily ditch the wired headphones for the wireless counterpart. However, what I really dread is losing the airpods and, I can't even imagine what my 3 YO will turn them into :).
- abalone 10y agoYour comment implies they are replacing the jack with wireless earbuds, but that's not what happened. They are doing two things: 1. Switching to a proprietary connector for wired headphones. 2. Releasing improved wireless headphones as an optional add-on. So you still get "convenient and dependable" wired headphones supplied with the phone. And you get an adapter for using 3rd party wired headphones, so you are not "stuck with the crappy lightning headphones." Wired headphones, whether existing ones from 3rd parties or the upcoming ones from Apple, are unaffected. As for whether Apple is Really Wrong This Time in requiring an adapter for 3rd party wired headphones... Putting aside how utterly vindicated they've been every time they've done this in history... According to Apple this was to enable major iPhone 7 features like the improved camera.[1] Was that worth requiring an adapter for certain cases, cases which will probably diminish over time as more 3rd party headphones go wireless? I'd say it seems in the ballpark of the sorts of tradeoff decisions they've made in the past. [1] https://www.buzzfeed.com/johnpaczkowski/inside-iphone-7-why-apple-killed-the-headphone-jack?utm_term=.iaPVBOVPv#.ov70pA0dD https://www.buzzfeed.com/johnpaczkowski/inside-iphone-7-why-...
- dingo_bat 10y ago>Anyone who buys the new phone on release is going to be stuck with the crappy lightning headphones for at least a month and a half. Pretty sure they can just use standard Bluetooth headphones. Also, these exist: http://www.samsung.com/global/galaxy/gear-iconx/ http://www.samsung.com/global/galaxy/gear-iconx/
- wdr1 10y ago> (floppies, CDs, Flash, etc) but the biggest difference is that those technologies were all on the downward slope of their popularity when I remember the lack of Flash support on iOS being fairly controversial at the time. IMHO, it was the combination of lack of iOS support + iOS usage skyrocketing that killed Flash; not that iOS dropped Flash because it was already dying.
- dschiptsov 10y agoPresumably, they want to push just a new DRM tech. That's why your headphones and speakers must have a wireless (digital) interface. Apple is a digital content distribution company in the first place.
- questionr 10y agodoes anyone know whether the mere use of the 3.5mm drains batteries? I presume so.
- moridin007 10y agothe invisible hand of entropy guides us all
- piyush_soni 10y agoA very, very common scenario for me was to listen to music in my 2009 car (on long drives) through AUX cable, while still charging the phone through a car charger. It seems that time is gone now.
- greendesk 10y agoI personally have the opposite opinion - I did not like the headphone jack and I am considering iPhone 7 because it does not have it. I was never sure if the jack is all the way in or it is halfway in. Sometimes the audio would disappear, and I would find out the headphones have slowly came off; but not all the way out, just enough to distort the sound.
- sreenadh 10y agoThe airpods MUST be sold along with the iphone if the the phone does not have an audio jack.
- codeulike 10y agoThis is pitch perfect: http://appleplugs.com/ http://appleplugs.com/ Upgrade to iPhone 7 with Apple Plug.
- davidcollantes 10y agoI don't have a problem with the removal if the headphone jack, as I never listening with the phone connected to power at the same time. Why crappy lightning headphones? What makes them crappy?
- joemi 10y agoOut of curiosity, what is it about Apple's lightning-to-3.5mm adapter that people find so much more repulsive than the 1/4"-to-3.5mm adapter that so many better-than-cheap-earbud headphones come with these days?
- PopsiclePete 10y agoI think it's a gamble, yes. I personally hate cords. I'm always getting entangled in my cord in the gym and I'm looking forward to something wireless. My gut feeling is, in another 5 years, we won't ever believe we put up with wired headphones.
- lancewiggs 10y agoPerhaps a global perspective might help - from what I see in this international city the switch to wireless headphones and earplugs is well underway. I've been unwired for 2-3 years now. AliExpress can deliver you a decent set of Bluetooth headphones for $50-$100, or earpieces for $12.