23 ms·
Justice Department says it will end use of private prisons
- xyzzy4 10y agoI know I'm probably in the minority here, but what we really need to do is only keep violent offenders in prison, and everyone else can be free.
- tptacek 10y agoThat won't help: mass incarceration is primarily a phenomenon involving "violent" offenses. http://harvardjol.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/HLL104_crop1.pdf http://harvardjol.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/HLL104_crop... By way of example, a plurality of offenders awaiting trial in Cook County lockup are there for domestic violence.
- galdosdi 10y agoNot a great example since that's a jail (for short terms stays awaiting trial) not a prison (for long term stays to serve the sentence)
- themartorana 10y agoInteresting paper. I do like that it addresses that many prison wins could be had through prosecutorial reforms. While the War on Drugs may have little secondary effect, it was in the same timeframe as "tough on crime" rhetoric as a whole, and with it came prosecutorial aggressiveness. Also the decline of the middle class began around this time period as well... The paper also notes how incredibly difficult prosecutorial reforms would be to come by, which seems both true and depressing.
- tptacek 10y agoIt does not gloss over that; it considers that possibility in detail, and addresses it with facts. But ultimately, yes: the problem isn't the war on drugs or long sentences (at least not directly), but rather the staffing and aggressiveness of prosecutors.
- themartorana 10y agoYup, I changed my comment while you were replying. I still disagree that a lot of this isn't the result of the War on Drugs (and there are studies that agree[1]: "More than 50 percent of people in federal prisons are incarcerated for drug law violations. Almost 500,000 people are behind bars for a drug law violation on any given night in the United States – ten times the total in 1980.") but again we end at the same conclusion. [1] http://www.drugpolicy.org/sites/default/files/DPA%20Fact%20Sheet_Drug%20War%20Mass%20Incarceration%20and%20Race_(Feb.%202016).pdf http://www.drugpolicy.org/sites/default/files/DPA%20Fact%20S...
- pc86 10y agoCook County lockup is a jail, and prison is not jail.
- dudul 10y agoWhat kind of sanction do you imagine then against "non-violent" offenders? Who is to decide what is "violent"? We could make the case that even white-collar crime is a form of violence (e.g. ruining people's life, etc)
- hx87 10y agoThe only right way to do private prisons is to give each prisoner a fixed grant with which they can use to buy space in a prison. This is the only way the prison's incentive can match those of the prisoner.
- swalsh 10y agoYou get what you incentivize. If you incentivize headcount, you get a higher headcount (thanks to lobbyists) Your suggestion might improve facilities, but that's not quite the goal either. If the goal of our system is to reform and reintegrate people who have committed crimes back into the society, maybe that's what we should be incentivizing. We could develop quality measurements based on outcomes, and give bonuses based on the percentile prisons rank in.
- anonu 10y agoAbout time ... I hope this brings the cost of making outgoing calls from prisons down as well... No reason for calls to cost in excess of $1 a minute these days...
- afarrell 10y agoI'm curious what the breakdown in nonmonopolistic cost of this would be. I assume the largest component is the cost of surveillance to make sure they aren't taking out a hit on someone?
- r_smart 10y agoI doubt it. We're already all paying for that to be conducted on everyone in the country.
- afarrell 10y agoBy a totally different entity who is going to avoid submitting its data into court records.
- r_smart 10y agoIsn't the FBI also conducting similar kinds of surveillance activities as the NSA, though not as broad in scope?
- afarrell 10y agoHere is an introduction to the 4th amendment law surrounding wiretapping, drawn by a New York defense attorney: http://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=1704 http://lawcomic.net/guide/?p=1704 Note that it assumes that an investigation is being conducted for the purpose of submitting evidence to a court.
- r_smart 10y agoSorry, I seem to have misunderstood a crucial part of what you were saying, which is: using the data as evidence in court. I also dug around to see if the FBI has any surveillance apparatus like what the NSA is doing and didn't come up with anything credible in the few minutes I looked. They appear capable, but, as of yet, have not started that anyone knows of.
- simonsarris 10y agoCorrections Corp down 20% https://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3ACXW https://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3ACXW
- thefastlane 10y agogood.
- rememberlenny 10y agoDown 32.88% on writing.
- fapjacks 10y agoGood.
- azinman2 10y agoNow 37%. It's insane that prisons could be on the stock market at all. Talk about perverse incentives....
- SparkyMcUnicorn 10y agoIt's down 46% now. Another one to watch is The GEO Group which is down 44%.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- TheOneTrueKyle 10y agoInsane are the people who look at that stock and say, "that's a good investment"...
- mtgx 10y ago"Terrorism can only be good for business."
- nkrisc 10y agoThe same entity (government, state or federal) that sentences individuals to imprisonment should be the same entity responsible for bearing the burden of imprisoning the individual.
- SixSigma 10y agobe careful what you wish for because you missed (outsourced) from that list
- sremani 10y agoI agree, legislators should add more budget as they expand the definition of criminal behavior. If you want to criminalize up-skirting, all the power but allocate money for the costs. Do not put the burden on corrections department to find money, because you have new prisoners coming your way. Much of the burden of costs move to prisoners was because politicians want to expand the definition of criminal behavior but not the burden of increasing prison population.
- jessaustin 10y agoThen they came for the up-skirters, and there was no one left to speak...
- 20yrs_no_equity 10y agoAnd should be responsible, including fines and jail terms, for any harm that happens to the individual while under their care.
- munificent 10y agoOK, fine, I guess we'll privatize the courts too since you asked for it.
- chinathrow 10y agoNo, he didn't ask for it. Where did you read that?
- callcallcall 10y agoThis is a good start but we must end the use of State private prisons as well. Do you even know who your state representatives are?? Call your state reps: http://tryvoices.com/ http://tryvoices.com/ ACLU: https://www.aclu.org/blog/speak-freely/end-prisons-profit https://www.aclu.org/blog/speak-freely/end-prisons-profit
- Yhippa 10y agoCase in point: http://www.cnn.com/2009/CRIME/02/23/pennsylvania.corrupt.judges/ http://www.cnn.com/2009/CRIME/02/23/pennsylvania.corrupt.jud...
- themartorana 10y agoWell, that's just corruption of the worst kind, but private prisons or no, I'm betting this judge would have found an alternative stream of dirty money if private prisons didn't exist. I mean, look I agree with you that they need to be closed, but there are likely better examples of them just being worse on merit, without having to dive into bribery and whatnot.
- pc86 10y agoThis article is from 2009, and the judge is currently serving a nearly 3-decade sentence for his numerous crimes.
- jsprogrammer 10y agoThe article says the judges took a plea deal for only 87 months of prison time.
- wlesieutre 10y agoOther sources agree with the 28 year sentence. Here's one from 2013 regarding an appeal being denied, and as far as I can find it didn't go any higher. http://thetimes-tribune.com/news/court-denies-civarella-appeal-1.1525776 http://thetimes-tribune.com/news/court-denies-civarella-appe... EDIT - You can verify this online at https://www.bop.gov/inmateloc/ https://www.bop.gov/inmateloc/ and search for 15008-067
- aphextron 10y agoThe real problem is at the State level, although this is a good precedent for future suits.
- madaxe_again 10y agoExactly this. From TFA, this is federal prisons only, and affects precisely 13 prisons. That just leaves the other ~130 private state prisons. The plummeting stock will rebound the moment the market stops panicking, and some vultures will make a killing. It's big business, and they won't go quietly into the night.
- giarc 10y agoCan these federal private prisons just start accepting state inmates? Thereby remaining profitable?
- duskwuff 10y agoNo. These facilities are privately operated, but are owned by the federal government. The operators can't choose to turn them into state prisons, no more than they could choose to turn them into hotels.
- ojbyrne 10y agoAt the risk of sounding frivolous, there are numerous prisons that have been turned into hotels. http://www.nileguide.com/blog/2010/10/30/incarcer-vacations-11-prison-turned-hotels/ http://www.nileguide.com/blog/2010/10/30/incarcer-vacations-...
- azernik 10y agoThe government can choose to do that (in those cases, sell off the property). Not private prison operators. The issue of property rights, not the inherent concepts.
- 10y ago
- Shivetya 10y agoSadly its likely being done to score election points with minorities who they will claim are unfairly treated by the "private prison industry" which actually is more truthful if portrayed as the union prison industry which contributes to the party that will portray otherwise
- lotso 10y agoNope, Obama and his DoJ have made criminal justice reform part of their platform.
- steveklabnik 10y agoI am glad to see this move, but > The 13 privately run facilities will not close overnight. That is, this affects 13 prisons. I'll take it, but not exactly a sweeping reform.
- munificent 10y agoGotta start somewhere.
- steveklabnik 10y agoAgreed, and hopefully, this can be the first of many such reforms. The headline makes it sound like an end, rather than a start.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jonesetc 10y agoThere are only around 100 federal prisons total. This is a large chunk for the federal level. State prisons are a much larger issue.
- steveklabnik 10y agoAgreed on both counts.
- mason240 10y agoThat's because this is a non-issue.
- 20yrs_no_equity 10y ago[Redacted for not towing the party line close enough.]
- saboot 10y agoI would think a government run prison would be more amenable to public pressure to reform and change, as opposed to a free market solution.
- 20yrs_no_equity 10y ago[independent thought not tolerated on hacker news]
- karma_vaccum123 10y ago> But the justice system has no interest in justice, in my opinion. Then fix it. Private prisons are absolutely not the right solution.
- Unbeliever69 10y agoOur society has no interest in justice, in my opinion.
- dnautics 10y agoThat's actually not generally true. It seems to me that If the government cares about prison abuse, it's relatively easier to make that a contracting criterion and switch contractors (or ban contractors) than to top-down reform an entire system that is run by the state. I looked for but haven't seen any statistics, but I've heard of horror stories emanating from non-private state-run prisons just as from private prisons.
- agwa 10y agoThat doesn't help if the public doesn't care, and for decades there was no public pressure to reform any prison, public or private. Now that criminal justice reform is mainstream, private prisons have received a disproportionate amount of public attention, enough for the feds to phase them out. I hope the newfound criminal justice reformers don't declare victory as soon as private prisons are gone. Never forget that over-criminalization and mass incarceration preceded private prisons, not the other way around.
- jansen 10y agoGood start! I just wish this change would be happening for the right reasons, e.g. that privately held prisons are creating a false incentive, an incentive to be more profitable by having more prisoners and thus the creation of a lobby for such thing.
- tptacek 10y agoIf you look, I think you'll find very little evidence of that actually happening. Further, state-run prisons create as much if not more incentive, in the form of public sector unions.
- r_smart 10y agoIt is curious how overlooked the money unions dump into lobbying is. They are spending massive amounts of money lobbying DC, but nobody seems to talk about it. The people that complain about companies who run private prisons lobbying congress never have a thought for say, the corrections officers' union, doing the same. Why?
- wfo 10y agoUnions generally represent a large collection of human beings who all donate a small fixed amount as dues, and are usually quasi-democratic. That is, unions closer resemble the expression of the will of actual people, whereas non-union corporate lobbying represents the interests of a single corporate leader choosing to spend a huge amount of money to obtain influence in the democratic process wildly out of proportion to his actual vote. A teacher's union lobbying is acting in the interest of millions of American teachers. An oil company lobbying is acting in the interest of the CEO of the oil company.
- r_smart 10y agoThe CEO of an oil company represents all of the people that work for that company, and the many people who are investors in that company (often including pension funds, which are beholden to those same teachers in the union). It's disingenuous to act like the CEO's interests are the only ones involved in a corporation's lobbying. Indeed, CEOs are often voted out of companies by the board. Are businesses less democratic that unions? Almost certainly. Does that change whether or not their actions are moral? I would argue not. My step-father was a in a union for a long time, and spent time as an officer for the union. He didn't have much great to say about it.
- OliverJones 10y agoDoes anyone know whether this DOJ order also covers the facilities used for detaining undocumented immigrants?
- chris11 10y agoI think it might. The article mentioned that one response by companies was that the conclusion of the report was not supported by the evidence because some of their prisons primarily contained non-citizens, and that population had different problems. I'm not really sure how the government decides to place undocumented immigrants though.
- jessaustin 10y agoICE isn't part of DoJ.
- rayiner 10y agoI think this is huge. Private prisons are already illegal in New York and Illinois and a few other states, and the federal government not using them will help other states flip.
- WalterSear 10y agoI hope so.
- dnautics 10y agoAre prisons in new York and Illinois relatively more or less humane than other states? How about per capita incarceration rates?
- r_smart 10y agoI think this is a hugely important question. There's nothing about private prisons that says they have to be worse than state-run prisons. As a crazy thought experiment, a private-prison could drive profits up by creating an environment that was better than living in a shit apartment, working a shit job. Encourage recidivism through kindness, drive up profits. It's obviously still against the interests of everyone but the business, but would certainly be more humane treatment than any prisoner is getting in a state-run prison ("I hang out with my friends and play xbox!"). As a less flippant example, creating better conditions would mean less unrest, less unrest would mean you could get away with fewer staff. Staff expenses are usually one of the highest costs for a business, so cutting that would positively effect the bottom line.
- JBReefer 10y agoRikers is infamously horrible, but it's a jail, not a prison. It's run by NYC. http://www.vice.com/read/the-feds-are-suing-new-york-city-because-rikers-island-is-a-gitmo-style-hellhole-1218 http://www.vice.com/read/the-feds-are-suing-new-york-city-be...
- hardlianotion 10y agoGood, if this is something that the UK will take notice of. We picked up this practice from the US some time ago and the performance has always been controversial.
- justinlardinois 10y agoI thought it would be useful to post a link to a list of all the private prisons in the United States, but I can't seem to find one online anywhere. Is anyone aware of such a list?
- MrZongle2 10y agoFTA: "Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates announced the decision on Thursday in a memo that instructs officials to either decline to renew the contracts for private prison operators when they expire or “substantially reduce” the contracts’ scope." So the options are 1) decline to renew the contract, 2) renew the contract or 3) reduce the scope of the contract...when the contract is up for renewal, within the next 5 years? So, what's the incentive for any federal official to select Option 1...or, barring explicit resources to make up the difference, Option 3 for that matter? This is a "feel good" move. I predict little, if anything, will be changed as a result of this in 5 years' time.
- JackFr 10y agoWeird thought -- has anyone ever considered non-profits privately running prisons? Advocacy groups, human rights NGO's, hell why not even religious institutions. You think we need prison reform, here's your chance . . .
- huac 10y agoThe Quakers invented solitary punishment.
- patmcguire 10y agoHow did they enforce it? Couldn't the prisoner just leave? Or were these non-pacifist Quakers?
- haroldp 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eastern_State_Penitentiary https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eastern_State_Penitentiary
- mintplant 10y ago> While some have argued that the Pennsylvania System was Quaker-inspired, there is little evidence to support this; the organization that promoted Eastern State's creation, the Society for Alleviating the Miseries of Public Prisons (today's Pennsylvania Prison Society) was less than half Quaker, and was led for nearly fifty years by Philadelphia's Anglican bishop, William White.
- huac 10y agoYeah. It's an interesting place to visit. I also believe that originally a "penitentiary" referred to a prison where prisoners were held in solitary confinement, with the goal of reform, or 'penance.' But we should remember that solitary confinement is almost universally worse than other forms of punishment, in terms of the mental toll it takes upon the inmate. The Wikipedia page is a good place to start: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solitary_confinement#Historical_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solitary_confinement#Historica...
- _audakel 10y agothis just makes me glad that Garry Johnson is campaigning on criminal justice reform. From his website "How is it that the United States, the land of the free, has one of the highest incarceration rates in the world? The answer is simple: Over time, the politicians have “criminalized” far too many aspects of people’s personal lives. The failed War on Drugs is, of course, the greatest example. Well over 100 million Americans have, at one time or another, used marijuana. Yet, today, simple possession and use of marijuana remains a crime — despite the fact that a majority of Americans now favor its legalization. And who is most harmed by the War on Drugs? Minorities, the poor, and anyone else without access to high-priced attorneys."
- patrickaljord 10y agoI agree, the only reason private prisons exist is because the government was sending so many people to prison the public prisons could not keep up budget wise. So they had to ask the private sector to help keep costs down. Private prisons are just a symptom (only 6 percent of state prisoners, 16 percent of federal prisoners are in private prisons) of the real problem that is the US is sending too many people to prisons, more than any country and mostly because of harsh punishment of victimless crimes such as the war on drugs but not only that, there's also the 3-strike rule, minimum sentences, ridiculous regulations etc and both republicans and dems are responsible as these were passed by Clinton with the agreement of the opposition. Sickening really. And now they are blaming private prisons? How about admitting the government was wrong on the war on drugs and harassing the poor with victimless crimes which resulted in a waste of trillions of dollars and millions of poor sent to prisons having their life ruined. Not gonna happen I know, or at least it will but very slowly and they will blame the private sector all the way during the process. Again, this is really sickening.
- burkaman 10y agoHe supports private prisons though, he cited building them as one of his greatest achievements as governor. Presumably he won't be happy with this decision.
- _audakel 10y ago
- benevol 10y agoGood. Next step towards a civilized society: End the death penalty. Unless you want to remain on the same list as a couple of medieval-minded countries, that is.
- rglovejoy 10y agoYou mean like Japan and India?
- adventured 10y agoSo when are we shutting down half of the government prisons, laying off a million government employees at the federal and state level, and giving back hundreds of billions in tax dollars currently being used for the government prison complex?
- haroldp 10y agoAs soon as we end The Drug War.
- panic 10y agoIf you want to know more about what goes on in these prisons, a reporter spent some time in 2014 working for a (state) private prison and wrote an article about the experience: http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2016/06/cca-private-prisons-corrections-corporation-inmates-investigation-bauer http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2016/06/cca-private-pris....
- Matt_Mickiewicz 10y agoThat was a great article.
- ams6110 10y agoI agree there are apparently huge problems with private prisons. But I don't see any reason to believe the government can run them better or cheaper. Why not simply demand the standards we want from the private contractors running the prisons, as a contingency to get paid or renewed? That would require actual oversight, and is probably less fun for people like Sally Yates than having a convenient scapegoat to justify expansion of the Bureau of Prisons.
- yardie 10y agoThey weren't being run any better or cheaper as far as the government/tax payer was concerned. They were cheaper for the corporation. Minimal training, safety, health and food standards. Pocket the difference and charge the government the full rate.
- finid 10y ago> Yates said the Justice Department would not terminate existing contracts but instead review those that come up for renewal. She said all the contracts would come up for renewal over the next five years. Which means that over the next five years, the govt. will continue to use facilities that "are both less safe and less effective at providing correctional services than those run by the government," and with no real cost benefit.
- Guvante 10y agoInstantly replacing everything would require: * Paying out a large number of contracts which have cancellation clauses (don't complain too much about these, the companies at the other end of the contract made good faith investments due to them) * Quickly finding people to handle all of those prisons Alternatively you can simply let each individual contract fail to renew which allows you to take your time finding replacements for everything you need.
- Waleedasif322 10y agoSo Bill Clinton says in the video: "We overdid it at putting in too many young, non-violent offenders in jail for too long." Not "We", Bill. You did that. I hate it when presidents can get away with their actions by just a few words.
- themartorana 10y agoPlease explain how Clinton did that alone. Be sure to explain away Regan, Bush Sr., the Justice Department, the War on Drugs, Three-Strikes laws, and just about everyone else down the chain that instituted those policies. Also explain away the tough-on-crime atmosphere in the 80s and 90s that started these policies, the undertone of institutionalized racism, and be sure to end with how nothing has changed through today, despite a decade of understanding how terrible the entire thing was.
- nilved 10y agoPlural "you." Clinton is part of the establishment that did this. GP & I are not.
- themartorana 10y agoStill disagree. The country wanted this and bought into this. They voted in "tough on crime" mayors, governors, congress people, and yes, presidents for years - decades, even. It started before I could vote, and maybe before you could, but this wasn't some faceless elite "establishment" - it was the whoooole country.
- madgar 10y agoA whole lot of people seem eager to ignore that America arrived where it is today based on tens of millions of voters repeatedly deciding who runs their governments. As if they were the first citizens to look around and find themselves wholly dissatisfied with the state of government.
- Waleedasif322 10y ago
- nstj 10y agoFor interests sake, the top global incarceration rates[0] are listed below. Note that influencing the Seychelles number is their small population (around 100,000) and the fact that they house a number of jailed Somali pirates. Prisoners per 100,000 population: 1: Seychelles, 799 ; 2: United States, 698 ; 3: North Korea, 650 ; 4: St. Kitts and Nevis, 607 ; 5: Turkmenistan 583 ; 6: Virgin Islands (United States), 542 ; 7: Cuba, 510 ; 8: Rwanda, 492 ; 9: Guam (United States), 469 ; 10: El Salvador, 465 [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_incarceration_rate#Incarceration_rates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_incarcera...
- cloudjacker 10y agoExplain St. Kitts?
- allendoerfer 10y agoThese are truly awesome news. Obviously there is the broken system itself that gets improved (let's not pretend that it will be fixed instantly). But aside from that, showing that politics can actually fix something, which everybody sees is so obviously broken, is really important. That is how politicians can regain trust and bring a society back together. Because what happens when a society has lost trust and is anxious can be watched right now all over Europe and America: populism, hatred and extremism.
- daveheq 10y agoThe only way they can do this is because federal private prison industry isn't that big, there's not that much money flowing into politicians' pockets for it. Good luck trying to pry state leaders' hands off it.
- chrstphfi56 10y agoWE have got. To think and act WITH our intuitive minds....We must use what God and the Universe HAS given Us to truly discern Good from Evil..and STOP playing we are still Blind
- gozur88 10y agoEh... the Justice Department will be under new management in less than six months. Nothing they say about policy going forward really means much.
- naveen99 10y agoI wonder how much a private prison could pay a person to commit a crime that would land them in prison and still be profitable for the prison and the prisoner... Would be a win win gamble. Steal a car. If you don't get caught you keep the car. If you get caught, collect money from the private prison. Private prison collects from the state... ofcourse it could go wrong.
- knodi123 10y agohomeless people might be up for it. Special wing with friendlier guards for the volunteer criminals?
- kavbojka 10y agoI kinda feel people make too much of private prisons and far too little of the heinous things that have been done in their names by government-run and managed prisons. For any one truly interested in questioning the whole idea of putting some people that some other people deem a menace into (super expensive) cages, I recommend reading "Are Prisons Obsolete?" http://www.feministes-radicales.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/11/Angela-Davis-Are_Prisons_Obsolete.pdf http://www.feministes-radicales.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/...