23 ms·
What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture?
- tired_man 10y agoI thought having the poor taste to plunk one down into a neighborhood where it was a sore thumb was enough. I'm happy to see there are other aesthetic reasons, too.
- AWildDHHAppears 10y agoMeh. If you don't like a McMansion, don't live in one. It sounds like petty jealousy.
- bullfightonmars 10y agoI interpreted this as design critique. The author doesn't seem to have anything against large houses and uses lots of them as counter-examples for good architectural design.
- DannyBee 10y agoErrr, he named the blog "mcmansionhell", gonna suggest he might have something against them :) Also note the blog is sort of a tautology. "Mc·Man·sion məkˈmanSH(ə)n/ noun a large modern house that is considered ostentatious and lacking in architectural integrity." So houses lacking in architectural integrity ... lack in architectural integrity?
- cstejerean 10y agoThe author uses a very specific style of houses, and that's fine. But for example none of the houses listed as great design have a garage upfront (and some look like they don't have a garage at all). A front facing garage is a huge convenience but it makes it much harder to have the symmetry the author wants. When it comes to houses form should follow function and that seems to be completely ignored in this critique.
- SerLava 10y agoI'm sure it's a component for some people, but really those houses do suck. If you have a million dollars to burn on a house, just hire an architect. These houses are often built en masse to hit marketable squarefootage numbers and get noticed in listings, for the cheapest possible cost of construction.
- AWildDHHAppears 10y agoI believe in the right to own property. I don't want to put undue restrictions on what a person can do with his private property, especially when the problem is simply "aesthetics." If you don't believe in the right to do what you want with your property, that's fine, but you may be more happy in a Communist country.
- SerLava 10y agoYou're hallucinating an argument right now. Nobody here wants to infringe on someone's property rights. It's a submission about why some houses are ugly, with a comment thread about why they're ugly. Your comment is bad, but by that I don't mean "punishable by 15 years' hard labor in a Siberian gulag." Is that hard to believe?
- detaro 10y agoWhere was anything said about putting restrictions onto what people do with their property? I skimmed the article again just to make sure, and I can't find any argument in that direction. Saying "X is ugly" or "X is ugly, here is a rule to try to explain why" does not mean "X should not be allowed to exist".
- parsnipsumthing 10y agoEr, can you give some reason why you think this? The author seemed to go out of his way to ground all of his critique in well-cited design principles. It's depressingly indicative of modern internet discourse that the first recourse is a lazy ad hom.
- AWildDHHAppears 10y agoThe guy likes his houses symmetric. That's about all he said.
- SerLava 10y agoWell, then you must have clicked a different link from everybody else.
- eropple 10y agoEven setting aside that the link is criticism and not complaint: are you familiar with negative externalities?
- bumblebeard 10y agoA house can still be an eyesore even if you don't live in it.
- wavefunction 10y agoJealousy would imply some sort of want on the part of the jealous. If someone doesn't like a McMansion they surely can't be jealous of someone who does...
- JabavuAdams 10y agoFunctional and aesthetic design affects the surrounding neighbourhood. So, you get to live on the inside, but you inflict these design choices on everyone else. No man is an island.
- cstejerean 10y agoEntire neighborhoods are built in this style because people like these houses and buy them. You might not, but don't assume that everyone else shares your taste in housing. Sure, if one house is built in this style amid a neighborhood with a different aesthetic the complaint might be warranted, but complaining about the design in general being inflicted upon neighbors in all cases is not.
- applecore 10y agoThis critique is composed entirely of exterior shots. Maybe the McMansion layout leads to a better interior configuration for a given square footage?
- SerLava 10y agoThe critique was mostly of facades and the suggested changes didn't generally have a secondary effect on the layout. The layout of these McMansions is often just as bad as the external appearance.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- JabavuAdams 10y agoQuite possible, but there is a tension between individual concerns and community concerns. If everyone can just build anything they want, then you end up with Second Life, and everything looks like crap, all the time.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoI'm not sure this is true. I know of several communities without strong regulations on what can be built (beyond perhaps size limits), and they tend to be pretty interesting. They also tend to develop their own individual character, due either to engineering limitations or social mimesis. For example, Japanese houses are pretty disposable, but you can build more or less anything you like. (Here's a great article on it. https://urbankchoze.blogspot.com/2014/04/japanese-zoning.html https://urbankchoze.blogspot.com/2014/04/japanese-zoning.htm... ) If you combine this with the fact that Japanese depreciation rules promote 30-year disposable housing, you get a lot of very interesting homes. The result is that a ridiculous fraction of the interesting houses you see on archdaily are Japanese. Or if you look at modern wealthy residential areas in north Delhi, you get a lot of interesting buildings. The neighborhoods again have their own unique character; it's a lot more heterogeneous than typical US suburbs, but it's clearly got it's own character. I can't find many pictures online, but I'll try to take a few next time I go.
- jasode 10y agoI also dislike McMansions but I disagree with his pseudo-scientific criteria of "voids" and "secondary mass" that he applied to the various houses. The bungalow home and the colonial homes that he praised, I didn't find the aesthetics to be pleasing. To me, the photo from wikipedia is more like the McMansions I think of as ugly: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McMansion#/media/File:McMansion,_Munster,_Indiana.JPG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McMansion#/media/File:McMansio... The wiki example has the siding that covers the entire side combined with the Greek columns in the front entry. It's a weird mismash of gaudiness. The garage also overwhelms of rest of the house. Like another poster mentioned, some of the awkward boxiness is due to homeowners wanting 3500+ sq ft homes on small lots that are 1/3 and 1/2 acre. An architect no matter how talented is too constrained by the lot dimensions to avoid designing an oversized out-of-proportion box.
- omginternets 10y ago>I disagree with his pseudo-scientific criteria of "voids" and "mass" that he applied to the various houses. Having domain-specific vocabulary doesn't imply something is scientific, much less pretentiously pseudo-scientific. It's hard to talk about the specifics of a problem if you don't have names for things, don't you agree?
- jasode 10y agoTo clarify, I wasn't criticizing the "names" he calls things. It was the criteria. For example, he has this rule: The secondary masses should never compete with the primary mass. Whether he wrote it as "secondary outlines should never compete with primary outlines" or "secondary shapes should never compete with primary shapes" ... it doesn't matter what the labels are. I disagree with the rule as of the defining features of what makes a house a "McMansion". It's an inconsistent guideline.
- blatherard 10y agoArchitecture has been using rule-based language since long before the advent of modern science. See, e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitruvius https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitruvius
- Animats 10y agoAfter reading this author's criteria, look at Fallingwater, Frank Lloyd Wright's most famous house. Secondary masses all over the place, dominating the structure. No center of symmetry. So much window area that it's more voids than structure. The problem with McMansions is usually too much house on too little land, with no visual relationship with neighboring houses. On a bigger lot with more trees and space around the house, most of them wouldn't look bad.
- ska 10y agoLiterally the second paragraph is a disclaimer that you shouldn't try and apply these runs universally, particularly modernist (e.g. Falling water). The claim is more narrow, and aimed at the architectural traditions on which these houses are based.
- CPLX 10y agoHe was pretty explicit that he wasn't talking about modern and contemporary styles.
- rayiner 10y agoI was just thinking--this guy would hate Frank Lloyd Wright's Oak Park bungalows: http://www.thecraftsmanbungalow.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/IMG_4592a.jpg http://www.thecraftsmanbungalow.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/....
- humbledrone 10y agoFTA: > Disclaimer: These same principles do not always apply to Modernist or even canonically Postmodern architecture. These principles are for the classical or traditional architecture most residential homes are modeled after. Those bungalows were definitely not modeled after classical or traditional architecture, so the principles in the article wouldn't apply. I'm sure the author has different opinions about modern architecture (i.e. the style that FLW defined). The difference is that McMansions are (poorly) aping traditional architecture, whereas FLW was creating his own style.
- fizx 10y ago
- manigandham 10y agoThere are plenty of great looking "mcmansions" - bad design for some houses (of any type) shouldnt be generalized to an entire construction and development approach.
- 99_00 10y agoI think the term mcmansion is abused. In common use MacMansion seems to mean "big new house which I don't like", and the reason can be anything from looks, to environmental footprint, to simple envy.
- Houshalter 10y agoThis is entirely subjective preferences for the appearance and aesthetic. Personally I liked the "McMansion" examples better and found the arguments for why they were bad unconvincing. The rules seem arbitrary and made up.
- jernfrost 10y agoThey are not. As someone who does GUI design, I recognized many of the rules. If you look at GUIs that don't follow rules for balance e.g. they clearly looks worse than balanced ones. The McMansions look cool in a theme park way. But there is nothing timeless about them. It is like the things we thought looked cool in the 80s like big shiny metal fonts. It was cool then, but today we are like "oh my, how did we ever think this was good!"
- Houshalter 10y agoYour second paragraph kind of contradicts the first. If you admit that aesthetics can change over time, then they aren't objectively true. Aesthetic preference is all about what associations you have, not the features themselves. Personally I don't think the examples looked good. And while some of these features might work well for GUIs, forcing them on houses can cause problems. E.g. limiting the number of windows to fit the style. Windows and natural lighting have been shown to have a huge beneficial effect on mental health. Or forcing the house to be symmetrical could make the room layouts suboptimal. Form should follow function, and these rules oppose function.
- acbabis 10y agoI'm not an architect, and I probably wouldn't have even noticed how ugly these houses are if I spotted them in the wild, but having read this article, it seems mind-boggling that someone would spend the money it takes to make a house and not adhere to basic architectural principles. Can someone explain how this happens?
- trentmb 10y ago> Can someone explain how this happens? Principles aren't facts? People hold different sets of principles? I guess what I'm asking is: are these principles culturally universal?
- ipsin 10y agoI tend to think of "basic architectural principles" as the things that keep buildings from falling over. If land is expensive and you want a lot of space, isn't a "McMansion" the ideal building for you? I don't have any stake in this fight, but I also don't have a lot of sympathy for people who want to control what their neighbors' houses look like.
- ams6110 10y agoIt's a least partly like any other fad. There's no rational basis for it, but the look becomes popular for a period of time. Then years later people scratch their heads and say "what were they thinking?"
- Animats 10y agoIt's a consequence of excessive land costs. If the lot costs half a million, it seems appropriate to put a big fancy house on it. This leads to too much house for the lot. Most people's idea of a house is rather conservative. It includes slanted roofs and modest sized windows with small panes. If you build a modernist steel and glass house with stone elements in a suburban setting, you may get a writeup in Architectural Record, but it will be hard to sell.
- codeonfire 10y agoEvery article about apartment buildings complains that new buildings are simple, ugly boxes and should be more artistic flowing examples of the character of the neighborhood. In private homes everything is too complex, unbalanced and disproportionate. Homes should be simple proportionate boxes where all the windows are the same size and line up. Architects think individuals should live in their designated worker eat-sleep unit pods while large classes of people as a whole deserve unique and inspiring works of art. To break it down even further, I will just guess that commercial architecture pays better than residential and this is manifesting as a hatred of "McMansions". There are always going to be both ugly and beautiful homes.
- azraomega 10y agoOr live in a wooden box with perfect symmetry and aesthetics, with a zen like elegance. Simplified living for the modern generations. It can be your for only $2,000 a month with no down payment!
- toast0 10y agoIn my mind, Bad Architecture means the form doesn't function. This critique is entirely aesthetic. I agree, they don't look nice, but I've seen plenty of buildings that look nice, and are terrible to be in (hello commercial bathroom with tons of afternoon sun, poor ventilation, and the toilet paper dispenser glued to the window; it was pretty though). Moreover, if it's my house, I don't care too much what it looks like on the outside, cause I'll be inside for much more time than i spend looking at the outside.
- PhantomGremlin 10y agoI don't care too much what it looks like on the outside, cause I'll be inside for much more time than i spend looking at the outside. I had this exact thought. My primary concern about a house is how well the interior has been designed for my needs. The exterior appearance is way down on my list. Unfortunately the article didn't even mention interior. I've seen a lot of absolutely awful interior floor plans.
- cardiffspaceman 10y agoThe modern home's interior spaces are even more abusive of the client's reasonable desires as opposed to a rational integration of these desires into a whole. I toured a development's model homes at the beginning of the current big-screen TV era. I looked in vain for a place on a wall that could hold a 55-inch flat screen. I did find a cubbie hole near the dining table that was described as intended for a 32-inch tube TV. And if you own several paintings, better board up several windows.
- PhantomGremlin 10y agoI looked in vain for a place on a wall that could hold a 55-inch flat screen I don't think this has gotten better. I toured some homes last year, and the flat screen TVs were placed above the fireplace. Two problems: 1) you wind up constantly craning your neck to watch TV, and 2) if you actually use the fireplace the TV probably gets much warmer than it should. And yet these houses all sell for $500,000 or more. Or even a few million dollars in expensive places like the Bay Area.
- laretluval 10y agoI conjecture that the entirety of architectural design theory is just an attempt to create a formal system such that the styles preferred by people that architects don't like are "bad", and the styles preferred by people that architects do like are "good". The class of people who own McMansions are not very popular among the class of people who write about architectural design on tumblr. If the conjecture is true then it should be possible to find cases of houses that clearly defy these principles of "mass", "balance" etc., but which are deemed "good" through a series of ad-hoc exceptions and explanations. Those houses will probably not be suburban. De gustibus non est disputandum. This is equally true when you can create a low-dimensional approximation to your taste in terms of abstract principles such as "mass" and "balance".
- jschwartzi 10y agoThe thing that's crappy about McMansions isn't the people, it's that they're built by consciously aping a style, and then ignoring all of the rules of the style. If you regard architecture as a language, McMansions are composed entirely of pidgin. It's akin to people calling their development process "agile" but following none of the rules of agile. They have "stand-up" meetings that don't go anywhere, retrospectives that are meaningless, and sprints that constantly expand in scope. Superficially it's agile, except that it violates all of the actual rules of agile development.
- laretluval 10y agoNo, it is irreducibly a matter of taste.
- ssalazar 10y agoSure, and some peoples' taste will fetch millions of dollars and last for centuries whereas others will be demolished and forgotten within a decade. Don't you think that phenomenon is worth trying to understand?
- laretluval 10y ago
- ourmandave 10y agoDefinition of "McMansion": a large modern house that is considered ostentatious and lacking in architectural integrity. The architectural integrity I guess is the problem. The house can be sprawling (no well defined center) or has to many windows (that may be of different sizes). It sounds like designers hating on Comic Sans or programmers arguing over tabs vs spaces. But worry not... This rounds up post #1 of McMansions 101 - but don’t worry, there are many more factors that make an otherwise normal suburban house a McMansion, and each will be covered in their own special posts.
- justratsinacoat 10y ago>It sounds like designers hating on Comic Sans or programmers arguing over tabs vs spaces This, basically. I find it darkly humourous that HN's commentariat, in this thread and indeed whenever confronted with domain-specific jargon from non-computron fields [0], analyzes said field and finds 'obvious' problems. Have you ever tried to explain, say, 'tabs vs spaces' to some mundane? Its history, from makefiles to Python, seems uninteresting to someone peering over their iPhone N+1; "why don't you guys just decide on one? Why is this a big deal?" They can say this because 'tabs vs spaces' is a triviality -- to those who don't have to deal with the consequences of the argument. Inasmuch as HN is explicitly for interesting tidbits of info that don't necessarily have to do with hacker-style nerdery, I'd expect that we who ostensibly know so much would be able to appreciate that there are aspects of the world, and of other intellectual professions, that we don't necessarily wot of. I mean, unless, of course, one's own buzzsaw-mind is capable of intuiting and then dismissing the well-cited terms of an artisanal field that has been around for many centuries longer than has the idea of computers, but cognitive empathy is a useful practice for everyone. [0] With the exception of economics, because bike-shedding, because everyone knows about money; they spend it every day!
- ptaipale 10y ago>* is considered ostentatious and lacking in architectural integrity.* It would be nice to write out the passive voice. Who considers that the building is lacking in architectural integrity?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lnanek2 10y agoI don't really agree that most of what he says is a bad thing. E.g.: " Another issue with McMansions and mass is the use of too many voids. Some McMansions are so guilty of this they resemble swiss cheese in appearance. In the below example, the masses are so pockmarked with voids, they give the façade an overall appearance of emptiness. " So what? Personally, I'd prefer the 26 voids example he gives because it looks like a nice place to sit in a chair reading a book by sunlight. He's recommending making a much worse lighted set of rooms just to change the outside appearance, which I couldn't care less about. Similarly his complaints about secondary masses. His example photo shows a big offshoot of a house sticking forward, but I'd rather have the extra room than cut it off and have less space, or make it a separate garage I have to put my shoes on a trek out to instead of just being able to walk over there inside. The whole thing sounds like what programmers and designers get up to if we don't have usability studies with users showing us how stupid we are, thinking the huge buttons we make are titles and never pressing them, or not finding actions we think are obvious in our apps. Sounds like he's just going on without caring about the people who live in the house.
- robotresearcher 10y agoThe whole thing is an aesthetic argument. You aren't obliged to agree or defend yourself if you disagree. Similarly, some people get value from the simplicity and symmetry of the MacBook Pro/Air design, while others don't care at all what the bottom of a laptop looks like if the tech specs and price are good. https://tektype.files.wordpress.com/2010/07/laptop-bottom.jpg https://tektype.files.wordpress.com/2010/07/laptop-bottom.jp... http://www.ishootshows.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/apple-macbook-air-11-inch-0811.jpg http://www.ishootshows.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/apple-... The principles the author describes are not telling you what you should think, but rather they are patterns that predict the reactions people have had historically. As other commenters describe, some well-regarded designs have come about by people deliberately acting against the accepted principles. But it doesn't hurt to know what they are.
- cstejerean 10y agoTastes in design change over time. I have seen plenty very ugly houses, but some of those examples actually look great to me. Not everyone wants to live in a symmetrical box without a garage.
- VLM 10y agoCould summarize the design choices to malignancy, fakeness, and excess. Those are best avoided in programming BTW, its not just a house architecture problem. Also bad always crowds out good. The design pattern of mcmansions is malignant. Oh you still have money, lets slap on an asymmetric ugly random whatever, any old place till you run out of money. The design scheme is tumor like. Ah the underlying tissue must have had a good blood supply in that direction as the tumor expanded in that direction. They're almost organically gross as opposed to simply random. The fakeness isn't properly explored in the blog. There is an uncanny valley effect where anyone who knows anything about Georgians, for example, can trivially identify a Georgian-inspired fake Georgian. I mean, you blew a million bucks and got all the hundred bucks parts wrong... how silly. Also there's the fast food cookie cutter nature of McMansions where even if a single Big Mac isn't repulsive, an entire subdivision of identical ones is repellent, endless roads of ticky tacky. A semi-competent architect could make a nice looking Georgian pretty easily, but it doesn't flow to have dozens of CCR enforced utterly identical ones packed into a small area. Shotgun shack townhouse from Boston, yeah those look right when packed together like books on a shelf. If you must have lot spacing of 3 feet between houses, at least select matching appropriate styles, shotgun shack instead of southern plantation on LSD. The excess is very much fast food like. Well, yeah, it sucks, and it sucks just like everyone elses, and you have no choice in some areas of the country, but the excess is very 128 oz big gulp or super size frys like. Oh you still got money, well, lets put more columns and weird dormers and rooflines until you run out of money. Sure it'll be ugly but the point is to show off how big of a subprime balloon payment adjustable rate mortgage you can take out, and ugly does get noticed... The offensiveness of a mcmansion is bad always crowds out good. If you don't have land, why "must" you have an ugly mcmansion instead of a nice looking row of boston style townhouses? If you do have land, why "must" you have an ugly mcmansion instead of a nice plantation era with luxurious porches and stuff?
- PhasmaFelis 10y ago> The fakeness isn't properly explored in the blog. There is an uncanny valley effect where anyone who knows anything about Georgians, for example, can trivially identify a Georgian-inspired fake Georgian. I mean, you blew a million bucks and got all the hundred bucks parts wrong... how silly. Class signalling. It's important to keep the new money in their place.
- karma_vaccum123 10y agoMost of these homes have awful interior features like oversized entryways that feature giant voids. The heat flows to the ceiling, which is a terrible waste. Similarly, the "great rooms" of these homes tend to have too-high ceilings which once again is wasteful as furnaces must work even harder. These homes tend to also have ridiculously oversized garages that are fashioned to make the home look much larger than it is.
- WalterBright 10y agoMy garage is too small, it's hard to maneuver tools around the car. Worse, the ceiling isn't high enough to have a lift installed. I regret that every time I have to work under the car.
- gluggymug 10y agoDig a pit perhaps?
- WalterBright 10y agoGarage pits are illegal. I would have put one in otherwise.
- jessaustin 10y agoHow many transmissions do you rebuild in the average year? If this is to change the oil, just use a couple of small ramps like a normal person. I once changed the oil on my old Integra by driving one tire up on a regular red brick. b^)
- WalterBright 10y agoWhen I was a kid, the biggest barrier to working on my car was I had no money for proper tools, and was always making do. Having good tools makes things much more fun, and I get better results, too. A lift falls into that category, it makes working under the car fun rather than a painful bitch. It's especially bad as I get older and I am not able to move my head back and forth to get what I'm looking at in focus :-) And I am tired of setting my hair on fire with the lamp (fortunately, that at least isn't a problem anymore as my hair has decamped for the fjords). Getting the car up on jack stands takes about 10 minutes, off is another 10 minutes. It just takes away from the fun, whereas a lift is boom! it's up. So it doesn't really matter how much I'd use it, a used one isn't that expensive and I am willing to spend the bucks on it. A piece of advice - never ever support your car on brick. It can crush unexpectedly and then the car falls on you, you die. I once used cinder blocks to hold the car up (making do), and they suddenly turned to dust and the car fell, fortunately before I got under it. Now I use two sets of jackstands (the extra set as backup), and I give the car good shoves before getting under it.
- skybrian 10y agoThis is basically an article of the form "I believe the status of X should be lowered," giving some reasons why. I'm sure they believe it. Everyone always thinks their own culture has better taste. That's pretty much what culture is, a loose agreement on what the best X is for a wide variety of X. The best way out is not to play. Why have any opinion at all about "mcmansions?" Also, why a special term? Why not just call them mansions?
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> Also, why a special term? Why not just call them mansions? This one's pretty straightforward. McDonald's is low status. Therefore, mcmansions are also low status. (I believe the term originates in the desire to mock mass-produced buildings, e.g. a big tract where all the houses basically share a form. That is clearly not how it's being used here.)
- ethbro 10y ago> Also, why a special term? Why not just call them mansions? Because they do share characteristics distinctive from large homes (e.g. mansions). The wikipedia article takes a nice crack at it, "The term 'McMansion' is generally used to denote a new, or recent, multi-story house of no clear architectural style,[8] which prizes superficial appearance, and sheer size, over quality." Or in other words, conspicuous consumption without commensurate quality.
- blatherard 10y agoYour comment is a comment of the form "this is an article that has form X "and gives reasons why. I'm sure you believe it. Everyone always thinks articles that agree with their opinions are superior. The best way out is not to play. Why have any opinion at all about "articles?"
- skybrian 10y agoYes, better not to post at all about stuff that doesn't interest you. But apparently I'm not entirely immune to being interested in status-claims.
- 10y ago
- jonahx 10y agoMcMansions look cheap -- this is their defining quality imo, more so than any of the more abstract qualities the article discusses. Even people without much formal knowledge of architecture (like myself) have an intuitive sense of what cheap wood or ersatz brick look like. You can just immediately sense the economy of the construction.
- tbihl 10y agoThere's an urbanist podcast/nonprofit that releases really good, approachable content, and I recently saw a video they did where they went into a typical subdivision and just looked at the houses. In particular, he singled out the complete lack of any porches, saying "these are people who can't afford their houses. If you live out in this countryside place, the absolute highest-returning space is the deck/porch. It wouldn't take more than maybe 10k to construct really good porches (less than 10% even in this cheap area), and not a single house has one. That means they built a huge house and ran out of money before they could build the most important part." I guess that's just a different way of saying what you're saying. I think buyers choose mcmansions for a couple reasons. The first are the ones sucked into it by the school or proximity to work (where proximity is VERY subjective.) The others actually want those houses, either because it's a cheap structure in which they can imitate the many nice interiors they've collected in their heads, or because they want to build their walls to encompass a maximum volume, hoping that their house will insulate them from all the shit in their work and commute while they're in it.
- jccalhoun 10y agoI remember noticing this back when MTV Cribs was a thing. So many of the people on there had these big houses that had huge bare white walls everywhere and the same staircase and living room with the 15 foot ceiling and one wall of windows. When they showed a house that was older and was better quality it was a stark difference.
- carsongross 10y agoThe lack of balance, proportion, controlling lines[1] and symmetry are all bad aspects of nearly all modern (in the chronological sense) architecture, not simply McMansions. My primary issue with McMansions specifically (beyond the fact that they lost the thread on western architecture, which should be blamed on the academy[2]) is that the materials and workmanship are terrible: ugly gaps, quick to stain stuccos and metals, slapdash construction and very little craftsmanship. The flip culture that the mortgage-debt bubble of the last 15 years created has exacerbated this issue to almost comical levels. [1] - https://www.amazon.com/Old-Way-Seeing-Architecture-Magic/dp/039574010X https://www.amazon.com/Old-Way-Seeing-Architecture-Magic/dp/... [2] - https://www.amazon.com/Bauhaus-Our-House-Tom-Wolfe/dp/0312429142/ref=sr_1_1 https://www.amazon.com/Bauhaus-Our-House-Tom-Wolfe/dp/031242... EDIT: After reading another post[a] of his, it is worth mentioning another chronic problem with modern (again chronological, not stylistic) building: the buildings often look like they are about to fall over. A particular pet peeve of mine is the flashing gap found at the base of many houses and buildings, which introduces a disconcerting negative gap right where a soothing, wide foundation should be. Visual insanity. [a] - http://mcmansionhell.tumblr.com/post/148935246684/mcmansions-101-columns http://mcmansionhell.tumblr.com/post/148935246684/mcmansions...
- monk_e_boy 10y agoI'd never heard of the tern McMansion before reading the article (I'm from the UK.) These poorly designed houses seem to have huge, vast amounts of land around them. In the UK plots are much smaller. Do you think cheap houses filling large plots is the issue?
- carsongross 10y agoIt certainly doesn't help, but there are plenty of packed-in developments with similar issues. In fact I would say that the platonic American McMansion is on a fairly small plot of land and is built up absurdly close to the property line.
- azernik 10y ago
- Spooky23 10y agoMcMansions are striver homes, and they throw too many prestige elements at the house. It's like when you look at a home with an over the top 80s kitchen -- they don't age well. The other thing is that they really aren't architected. Builders drive the design vs clients, and the bling is there to hide the lousy construction material and craftsmanship. The insides of these things are an even bigger shitshow -- all cheap Home Depot fixtures and millwork.
- ascendantlogic 10y agoThe issue isn't so much the design, but the cultural attitudes towards the upper middle class. Looked down upon by the truly wealthy, and viewed with suspicion and derision by the middle and lower classes. There's a lot of emotional hostility towards the people that buy these houses that spills over into the critiques of the structures themselves. That said, this person isn't necessarily wrong. Having a lot of visual interest in your home isn't a bad thing, but you have to have visual interest surrounding the home as well. The issue I have with McMansions personally is having a 4000 square foot house on a postage stamp lot looks ridiculous. I was once told many years ago the following quote: "Rich people have big houses, but wealthy people have land". 4k sq/ft home on 1 acre? Probably not the best looking neighborhood. 4k sq/ft home on 5 acres? Probably a very wealthy, upscale area.
- carsongross 10y agoI live in an area (East Sacramento) with many homes in the 3k sq/ft range built on 10,000 foot or smaller lots, and it is lovely. Mid-town sacramento has even larger victorian buildings on even smaller lots, also lovely. The problem with todays building is not building-to-lot ratios.
- ruffrey 10y agoeast sac is beautiful.
- copenja 10y agoConsidering an acre is over 43,000 square feet, I would say 4K square foot house on 1 acre is pretty reasonable.
- ascendantlogic 10y agoSo here near Cleveland, about 20 years ago a development went up called Barrington. It was full of McMansions and was bought up by sports stars, music stars, a variety of rich and nearly-rich people. The problem is that for houses of that size, they need a LOT of room between them. Even with 3/4th acre and full acre lots, the end result was what looked like a bunch of big houses essentially stacked right next to each other. There are other developments in other towns nearby that are similar. Large houses but not more than an acre between them. While what you say is technically correct, the overall look is not attractive.
- cleandreams 10y agoUseful! I live in a neighborhood of mixed age houses and it is interesting how many of newer houses make me wince. This article helps me understand why. They lack harmony with themselves and their surroundings because of these failings. But here's another thing. I think these criteria (which are based in couple thousand years of western design principles) all fundamentally rely on the restraint of self-expression in favor of impersonal principles. Lots of the asymmetry and weird bulkiness I see around me seems to come with an attitude of 'Hey ma, I'm expressing myself!' Asymmetry is like loud, brash rock music. As I've gotten older I'm bored with a lot of the crudeness that is passed off as self expression and I wish for more restraint. Fat chance, I know.
- Gibbon1 10y agoI'll tack onto this, I think one of the issues with the McMansion 'style' is taking it in creates a large cognitive load. As in doesn't blend in with the surroundings and doesn't actually blend it with itself. So processing it to make a short term mental map is hard.
- bitwize 10y agoTo me a McMansion is built like a suburban tract house, but has façade features that make it look vaguely mansion-like. The architectural equivalent of Imari Stevenson's "Lamborghini", which is a fiberglass shell on a Pontiac Fiero chassis and powertrain.
- rdtsc 10y agoTrue. Visually they might look the same but one is built from cheap wood, cardboard and gypsum with some faux brick panels glued on the front, while other would be built with brick for example. But just like people who can't afford a Lamborghini would buy a car that has a similar shape and look, so someone who can't afford a $10M mansion would be buy a $2M McMansion just feel like they live in a mansion. No amount of architects of HN-ers guilting them with practicalities of construction materials, or aesthetic debates is going to change that market.
- bitwize 10y agoMy point was that construction is what makes the McMansion, not masses and voids. Though the two are related in that solid construction lends itself well to some designs and layouts, and poorly to others.
- snicker7 10y agoThe author explains what good design principles are, but not why they are important. So what if a house had too many 'secondary masses'? Why exactly is that such a bad thing? The author fails to answer such basic questions.
- ranger207 10y agoIn architecture and most other forms of art, the principles are not based on objective truths. Instead, they are the result of centuries of what is subjectively pleasing. It's survival of the fittest, but "fittest" is determined by subjective values.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 99_00 10y agoThat's a great blog. I don't like the term MacMansion. Everyone seems to have their own definition and sometimes it's applied to anything new and big that someone is envious of.
- zeroer 10y agoI get what the author is saying. But as a home owner, I'll be spending 98% of my time in the house, not staring at the exterior. I'd like to see criticisms of the experience of living in a McMansion.
- dsego 10y agoBut could you live with it?
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoI should have known what was coming when the article kicked off with, essentially, "If your tastes differ from mine, don't worry! You're not stupid, just uneducated." But even then I was expecting him to list things like shoddy construction, or dull featurelessness, or cookie-cutter tract construction. No, his #1 issue is houses that are (gasp) not perfectly rectangular. #2 is houses that are are asymmetrical, but not in a cool way. He actually calls out one house specifically for having too many windows. I thought windows were for letting sunlight in, but apparently they're actually intended for class signalling. And class signalling is all this is. He gives the game away when he specifies that these rules are very important unless you're using a cool, [m/M]odern style where rule-breaking is socially approved. This is no different than the byzantine fashion codes manufactured by society matrons around the turn of the last century to exclude the vulgar nouveau riche. Never wear white after Labor Day; never have too many windows on your house.
- dsr_ 10y agoMy objection -- visible in nearly every one of the listed McMansions, but also a few of the 'classic' buildings -- is that a roof is a functional object, and every time you create a valley between two neighboring rooflines, you increase the likelihood of failure. Housing should be built for the climate of the area where it is placed. A SoCal-style flat roof built around a central courtyard and pool is perfectly reasonable there... and a really bad idea in Minnesota or Maine. There's no reason to put a two-story barn pseudo-conversion in a place where they never had that style of barn and will never need to shed snow quickly. First function, then play around with form.
- sliverstorm 10y agoThe beauty of harsh weather is bullshit design doesn't survive. Though, I'm a form follows function guy.
- zeko 10y agoWhile McMansions do seem kitschy and aesthetically unappealing to me, that is my subjective feeling. I find it inappropriate and offensive that this author decides to be the sole authority on aesthetics of PRIVATE properties, appealing to some sort of an unassailable, celestial authority that mainstream architecture is and promoting boring, utilitarian designs. Just how far down the slippery slope of the rabbit hole do you want to go? Why not box people in grey Soviet apartment buildings? All of this sounds to me like arrogant ramblings of people who like authoritarianism and can't grasp the concept of personal freedom and that people like homes that are wacky and extension of their own egos and sense of pride in their financial success.
- alecdbrooks 10y ago>I find it inappropriate and offensive that this author decides to be the sole authority on aesthetics of PRIVATE properties, appealing to some sort of an unassailable, celestial authority that mainstream architecture is and promoting boring, utilitarian designs. Just how far down the slippery slope of the rabbit hole do you want to go? Why not box people in grey Soviet apartment buildings? This is a straw man. The author isn't against interesting designs, just careless ones. And interpreting this article as a advocating authoritarianism is reading a lot into it.
- zeko 10y agoExploring the wider picture and integrating the issues at hand isn't a straw man argument, it's called thinking as well as not being naive to the ominous specter of slowly creeping authoritarianism. People find "careless" designs interesting. Who is he to dictate how private property should look? He is utterly intolerant of personal freedom and promotes sterile, totalitarian looking architecture.
- davidivadavid 10y agoWhere is he dictating anything? It's a blog. People use blogs to give their opinion. Is that too much freedom for you now?
- 10y ago
- jimmaswell 10y agoThat all sounds like opinion to me. When I look at the examples of what I'm supposed to think looks awful, I just see a house. The one with so much overwhelming "secondary mass" looks nice to me. If you need to study architecture to "realize" how bad those look, maybe they actually don't look bad. All the people buying them seem to agree. There are legitimate problems with the construction quality, as others have pointed out, but trying to claim they objectively look bad is clearly wrong.
- dsego 10y agoEat shit, millions of flies can't be wrong.
- jimmaswell 10y agohttps://xkcd.com/359/ https://xkcd.com/359/
- tempestn 10y agoThat one in particular looked nice to me as well. And others I could certainly see what they were talking about aesthetically, but many of them came with concrete benefits - all those "voids" in the second story of that one I'm sure let in a lot of beautiful light and scenery for the people actually using the house.
- mangeletti 10y agoIs it just me, or is Tumblr's UX absolutely terrible? You reach the bottom and it says "keep reading". Keep reading what, the last post in the list or pagination to more posts? So I click it, takes me to the last post (fine), so I scroll down to look at some of the pictures, etc., and then at the bottom it seems to continue back at the top of the prior post list. So I go back, scroll back down to the bottom of the page and notice a "See mcmansionhell's whole Tumblr" link. Perfect. I click it... App Store.
- cosarara97 10y agos/cutre/cture/ (On the title)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- galfarragem 10y agoBad architecture and good architecture are like good software and bad software. For non-IT folks it doesn't matter once the software works, for IT folks, it matters, they can 'see' things that the others can't. With architecture is the same. Disclaimer: I'm an architect. edit: this is the best blog I (didn't) know explaining what makes architecture good. There is a lack of short articles on this subject. Thanks for posting this.
- johnnyhillbilly 10y agoHaving had several visits to Italy recently, I value their sense of what is beautiful. Firstly, it feels great to be there. Secondly, the lot of them look really cool no matter what they do. My take on this is that these McMansions are an in-between step. They look like a Picasso - and not in a good way - because they are not designed as a whole. Once complex manual labour (most importantly: masonry) can be automated, and once one figures out how to combine a modern, relaxed lifestyle with architecture, these "mansions" will come to be seen as barbarous monstrosities.
- galfarragem 10y agoThis is the main reason why I will always stay in Europe.
- jpalomaki 10y agoNeed to throw in the mandatory pointer to Christopher Alexanders "Timeless way of building" [1]. The text is also available at Archive.org, see [2]. I originally bought his books because they were mentioned to be behind the software design patterns "movement" that was quite popular some years ago. Reading his books changed the way I'm looking at houses and apartments. Not from outside, but the layout. I guess (some of) the patterns are quite obvious, but as usual, it helps when somebody points them out. Two example things that stuck to me: 1) Intimacy gradient: Public areas where you host guests, meet people and closer to the front door. The deeper you go, the more private it gets. 2) Parents and children's realms: Separate areas for parents and kids, common area that connect them. When shopping for apartment and browsing through many different layouts, this kind of simple things help rule out many of them. [1] https://www.amazon.com/Timeless-Way-Building-Christopher-Alexander/dp/0195024028 https://www.amazon.com/Timeless-Way-Building-Christopher-Ale... [2] https://archive.org/stream/APatternLanguage/A_Pattern_Language_djvu.txt https://archive.org/stream/APatternLanguage/A_Pattern_Langua...
- vanderZwan 10y agoRelated: Ugly Belgian Houses http://uglybelgianhouses.tumblr.com/ http://uglybelgianhouses.tumblr.com/ Doesn't try explaining anything though.
- dsego 10y agoAlso ugly croatian houses fb page https://www.facebook.com/UglyCroatianHouse https://www.facebook.com/UglyCroatianHouse
- velox_io 10y agoI'm not a big fan of the McMansion houses, but I'm sure they mean the world to their owners, who have made large sacrifices to get the house of 'their' dreams. Personally I like the Georgian style; big windows and look decent when they're kept simple, or something a little more modern depending on the location. Yes, money doesn't buy happiness, but I'm sure we all have a picture on our mind of a dream house. Nothing wrong with aspirations, excuse me while I do more than just dream!
- Lazare 10y agoMy issue with the article is that it is: 1) Making purely aesthetic arguments 2) In several cases I feel that the "bad" architecture is aesthetically more appealing than the "good architecture. For example, when the author discusses how "secondary masses should never compete with the primary mass"; what that seems to mean in practice is "ugly, squat, lumpen buildings are good; interesting, attractive silhouettes are bad". No doubt the author would disagree with my characterisation, but then, that's sort of the point. It feels very subjective. Of all the examples given, the one I unambiguously agreed with was the one where none of the windows styles matched.
- elgoog1212 10y agoGo to any blog about "good" modern architecture. As it turns out "good" architecture these days is roof-less bauhaus with windows that take the entire front wall, including the bedroom. Looks good on Tumblr, impossible to live in, expensive to build, and insane heating bll. No, thanks. Case in point: http://designhomes.info/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mid-century-modern-architecture.jpg http://designhomes.info/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/mid-centu...
- elktea 10y agoThis sort of thing was popular in the 2000s but thankfully I haven't noticed any new builds like this for a while
- com2kid 10y agoI'm sitting here in Seattle where these buildings just, thankfully, recently started to become popular. I despise traditional architecture. Give me something so modern that it makes the neighbors puke.
- mrcsparker 10y agoThose homes are beautiful, but Seattle might be a bit tough with the flat roofs. I grew up in a house like that in a rainy area and we had standing water issues on the roof. It was a beautiful design that was completely inappropriate for the region.
- codeulike 10y agoWhat would the software equivalent of a McMansion be, and what sort of arguments would be used to disparage it and also defend it?
- abraae 10y agoIt would be a large piece of software, built to time and budget, that was perfectly functional, met the user's requirements and that they were happy with. So nothing like most software at all.
- ilaksh 10y agoThe main problem with McMansions is that they waste a lot of space and energy. The purely aesthetic perspective should embarass contemporary architects by its shallowness.
- Jedd 10y agoThis seems to be an unpopular opinion - but I agree. The word 'energy' doesn't appear anywhere in the original article, and only a couple of times, en passant, on the HN discussion. However the wanton misuse of materials (including energy) and on-going misuse of same, is the thing I find least attractive about these structures. Sure, it's not a purely aesthetic response, but it's hard to look at one of those things going up in the neighbourhood and not think about these aspects. They all face the street, too. (Thoughtfully designed structures would be aligned, as appropriate for the region, with north / south.) It's a weak line, but the owners aren't the ones who have to look at the outside all the time, so they aren't as impacted.
- stcredzero 10y agoThe overarching theme of American architecture gone wrong is the lack of supporting real community. It used to be that supporting commerce did that as well, but the car changed this.
- brokenglass 10y agomight want to fix the typo in the title
- ryanmarsh 10y agoPeople don't buy these for curb appeal. They buy them because of interior features. Also, the exterior appeal only matters in relation to the architecture around it. My wife knows the difference between good architecture and bad, we just haven't seen a new neighborhood that resembles the old rich parts of town. So as long as we keep buying vaulted ceilings, open lofts, big kitchens, and game rooms ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Source: I own one and I did mortgages for a while. Was product manager for a company that sold some tech to home builders.
- johnloeber 10y ago> They buy them because of interior features. This seems incorrect. If it were true, then there would be no reason for the exteriors to be so god-awful. If all you care about is a lot of good interior space, then why pay for misplaced Roman columns? In fact, some McMansions can be identified by their poor handling of interior space, mostly due to having too many disjoint or poorly connected masses.
- ryanmarsh 10y agoInteresting layout is a feature during the sales process.
- sireat 10y agoMy SO is an architect, my relatives and friends are also architects. Common complaint of theirs: clients like to meddle Analogy would be asking for <blink> tags to a web developer or for gold incisors to your dentist instead of ceramics
- nradov 10y agoUnlike architects, clients have to actually live in the houses (or at least convince other clients to do so). So clients are entitled to meddle. Let's not pretend that architecture is fine art.
- sireat 10y agoAs I mentioned in another response, I meant to specify that meddling here means asking for specific features in a house in a specific place. Again, if you are a real estate developer of McMansions who knows what people buying McMansions want it might be a perfectly rational decision to meddle and ask for these features.
- massysett 10y agoSO better not let his/her clients know how s/he feels about them. Customers who are handing you money don't like to be seen as "meddlers".
- sireat 10y agoFrom what I understand it is about 20-30% of the customers who are the meddlers. Meddling means being unreasonable about specific features(I want a bathroom here! where it is a really bad idea because of a multitude of reasons) in a building/house. The problem for architects without FU money is that they have to be very tactful about handling these needy customers.
- jessaustin 10y agoYeah that sounds like a lot of architects. They have an ideal home in their head, and if clients let them they'd only ever draw one plan. Every request is a deviation from the ideal, so it would be better if clients didn't communicate such banalities as how many children there are or how big the home office should be.
- AReallyGoodName 10y agoAmericans are really snooty imho. I suspect the snootiness is both the reason these houses exist (I have a bigger house than you) and the reason this criticism exists (I have a nicer looking house than you). I feel like it's a rather toxic cultural thing to care at all about other people's houses. Likewise with cars. It's also something that's not nearly as prevalent in mainstream culture outside the US (snobbery is the domain of the upper classes exclusively).
- mbfg 10y agoI'd take any of the McMansions shown here. sorry.
- gopi 10y agoMaybe i am unsophisticated but i liked the supposedly bad examples better than the good examples!
- bjterry 10y agoThis conversation has gone in a very interesting direction. It's true that on one level the perspective of this blog author corresponds to a sort of class-based tutting of the nouveau riche, but on another level I can't shake the feeling that he is pointing to something that's real. I have much more experience doing web design (some) than I do evaluating architecture (none). The principles he is describing apply in a similar manner to web design, and they are similarly hard to articulate. When you see a block of text without enough space between paragraphs, you know it doesn't have enough space, even though you would be hard-pressed to provide an objective reason why a paragraph needs 20 px vs. 5 px vs. 100px vs. 500px. Only one of those distances feels right, and it has almost nothing to do with how much vertical space is available on your screen or the relative ease of reading paragraphs with that precise distance between them. Similarly, you can feel a wrongness when a similar visual element is repeated, but without consistency, like a second text box that has a grey that is just slightly bluer than the last text box, even though they contain text of the same type at the same level of semantic importance. That is the equivalent of including windows with wooden shutters, and a set of windows with blinds, and a set of bay windows on the same facade. (For a visual-design example of his masses and voids principle, see the BeOS UI window, but I think this is the weakest of his principles) It is easy to be a contrarian and say "this guy is wrong, all of this is subjective," but I think that contrariness is more wrong than right. The best functional (not purely artistic) designs, whether they are web designs or architectural designs, hold to a set of quasi-universal aesthetic standards, including balance (symmetry or balanced asymmetry), repetition (consistency in web development terms, repeated elements in musical terms), and appropriate blank space. I suspect that these core principles reflect aspects of human cognition that are not subject to pure subjectivity. I think if you were designing from first aesthetic principles, you would probably retain balance and thematic cohesiveness (repetition). What you would lose is the trappings of particular eras, like roman columns or those shutter windows. Even if your house was based on a geodesic dome you'd want it to have a certain proportionality and space between visual elements. The problem with McMansions is that they take ONLY those trappings, and discard the principles, and that's what this article should really be about. The reason for this is obvious: the uneducated consumer sees only the trappings, because they are concrete and obvious, thus easy to evaluate. They are associated in the minds of buyers with high class, and so they seem high class in this particular instance.
- bane 10y agoThis post wades into an area normally met with knee-jerk comments and defensive house owners, but I think there's some really subtle points being made here -- I don't agree with some of them, but I think the author is really trying to figure out what exactly is going on with some of the really terrible McMansions shown. However, these problems extend up through real mansions as well. Here's a ~$9million house being built that suffers from almost all of the claims put forth in the post even though they're supposed to be hallmarks of McMansions and not real mansions https://www.redfin.com/MD/Potomac/10501-Chapel-Rd-20854/home/10885534 https://www.redfin.com/MD/Potomac/10501-Chapel-Rd-20854/home... After spending some time thinking about the problem, I've come to the following hypothesis: architecture schools aren't producing architects trained to produce quality designs that match the desires of the vast majority of the marketplace. Consider the following: we've been though decades of massive architectural development in practical housing, the result of which appears to be variations on boxes-with-mixed-materials https://encrypted.google.com/search?q=modern+house+design&hl=en&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjrmb-elsLOAhVI0h4KHfVGBrcQ_AUICCgB&biw=1536&bih=796 https://encrypted.google.com/search?q=modern+house+design&hl... Most consumers don't want these kinds of buildings and the ones who do buy them because they're custom architected and that acts as a status symbol. Consumers want classic "house" shapes on various degrees of "fanciness". Most consumers also don't know good from bad architecture. But it's okay, because it appears most architects don't know good from bad either or else we wouldn't be getting endless variants of boxes-with-mixed-materials. The last time the kind of design this blog is looking for was actively used was during the American colonial period. And that wasn't always a successful meme -- America is littered with old homes with huge pillared entrances on otherwise modest homes. http://www.house-design-coffee.com/porch-columns-disaster.html http://www.house-design-coffee.com/porch-columns-disaster.ht... It could be worse, America could be littered with craptastic hyper-modernism and weird vestigial bits of unintersting history http://uglybelgianhouses.tumblr.com/ http://uglybelgianhouses.tumblr.com/ But Europe isn't immune to this nonsense either, McMansions have started infecting everywhere from Ireland to Germany. Asia has it's own entirely unique series of architectural sins. I think there's a number of forces at play here that have all led up to where we are. - A growing desire in industry to find ways to minimize materials usage in new construction (older homes are sometimes hilariously overbuilt) - A rising and increasingly affluent middle class - A lack of good examples to educate people on -- most buildings are crap...even the ones that are well considered often fall apart quickly http://failures.wikispaces.com/Fallingwater http://failures.wikispaces.com/Fallingwater - A lack of architects who can produce something other than boxes-with-mixed-materials - Continued cost cutting as plans go to market - Consumers who are fine settling with "nice enough" if it saves them $100k-$200k on a similarly specc'd home - Most people don't give a crap about gardening or yard maintenance. Who cares what your house looks like or how small the property is if you're spending all day inside your climate controlled 5000 sq ft personal facility with movie theater, gym, gourmet kitchen and jacuzzi? It also turns out most McMansions are actually pretty nice places to spend time: well lit, nice materials on the surfaces you interact with, tons of space so you don't have to make too many compromises, open floor plans and so on. They are worlds better than the 60's, 70's and 80's era homes I grew up in and later owned. The 70s and 80s were particularly abysmal for material quality and energy use. Holy crap the heating/cooling bills on those homes.
- alricb 10y agoFrom a purely functional perspective, complex roof lines and the multiplication of volumes suck for durability and energy use. The more complex the roof, the more vulnerable areas it contains. The more edges and transitions you have, the harder it is to properly flash and air seal the enclosure. And huge voids suck too: windows have poor thermal resistance and large glazed areas mean overheating due to the sun's radiation. Add cheap material and poor construction practices (the famed "ductopus" is often found in million dollar homes) and you get crap housing, even without taking aesthetics into account.
- hartror 10y agoThere is a huge cheap build going on next door. It is two stories with 7 bedrooms with no back yard because pool. The contractors I talked to joked it will be knocked down in 20 years because of the low build quality.
- brownbat 10y agoThere are better ways to critique McMansions. The article's approach is to list a series of hard aesthetic rules, then show how some McMansions break them. That would be a valid critique, but the article never fully establishes that those aesthetic rules are universally desirable. In aesthetics, rules are made to be broken. If standards are broken haphazardly or unintentionally, that may be a sign of poor aesthetics. But I'm convinced McMansions intentionally break several of those rules. Breaking those rules is the only way to convey something that the author somehow completely fails to notice. A better aesthetic test of McMansions would only involve two questions: 1) Are McMansions effectively conveying some idea, and, 2) Is that idea is worth conveying? Setting (2) aside for the moment, I think McMansions meet (1) very well, primarily by breaking the author's "rules." Think about who buys these. The architects and the purchasers are not ultra-rich, but are still in a class that wants to display wealth. When purchasers in this group compare several homes, they are most likely to buy the one that makes them feel like they're displaying the most wealth and power for their price point. Wait, why would a tangled mess of asymmetrical nonsense achieve that? Because the aesthetic McMansions are shooting for is "this is more than one house." Bits crop up all over the place and the masses are obscured so that the building gives the appearance of multiple dwellings. What does it look most like? Villages that have cropped up around a central castle, organically growing in different heights and orientations without much central planning. (Maybe more from fairy tales than real world villages.) The image the McMansion tries to convey is one of dominion over a territory or a population. I think McMansions succeed, primarily through the subversion of the author's favored aesthetic tropes. But even if McMansions successfully evoke small villages, part (2) is the more important question. Is mimicry of an order of magnitude of wealth and power beyond one's reach aesthetically appealing, or desperate and ostentatious? I'd find a critique along those lines far more compelling. The fact that some buildings fail to satisfy some arbitrary checklist is not the more important thing, what the building says about the owner's character and insecurity is far more interesting.
- swehner 10y agoThe funny thing to me is, it's more important what your neighbour's house looks like.
- gsmethells 10y agoThis made the rounds on Facebook. It does a good job of covering why bigger is not necessarily prettier.
- skilesare 10y agoPeople have already mentioned Christopher Alexander's Pattern Language and Timeless Way, but I'll note that he has further distilled those ideas in his The Nature of Order Series: http://amzn.to/2b4XYf5 http://amzn.to/2b4XYf5 1. Levels of Scale 2. Strong Centers 3. Thick Boundaries 4. Alternating Repetition 5. Positive Space 6. Local Symmetry 7. Good Shape 8. Deep Interlock and Ambiguity 9. Gradients 10. Contrast 11. Echos 12. Roughness 13. The Void 14. Simplicity and Inner Calm 15. Each in the Other
- sp527 10y agoAll his examples of presumably 'good' architecture strike me as hideous and in many instances depressing. I'd take the McMansion over those hands down.
- jernfrost 10y agoAs someone who has done a lot of GUI design, I recognize many of the design principles. The point of balance and symmetry e.g. is very relevant for GUI design as well. It is very useful to know these sorts of principles because without them you notice stuff looks wrong but you don't know why and you don't quite know how to fix it.
- bootload 10y agoShallow article, it's like it had all the engineering in the design/construction has been sucked out. I would have expected something on the lack of: * energy efficiency/re-cycling of building materials used * integration of passive/active energy saving power * poor design in creating buildings capable of whole life existence * improved use of natural light and air flow * use of factory built, prefabricated frames (ie: Holland) If you watch or catch Kevin McCloud's, Grand Designs (BBC) would appreciate this. [0] Any others you can think of? [0] Though even best intentions have problems: cf "Grand Designs presenter Kevin McCloud's eco-development 'riddled with building errors" http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/earth/environment/conservation/11773530/Grand-Designs-presenter-Kevin-McClouds-eco-development-riddled-with-building-errors.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/earth/environment/conservati...
- re_todd 10y agoIt always amazes me that the people I know who are financially well-off almost always choose to live in an ugly McMansion. Voluntarily. I've determined that if I ever become well-off I'll buy an old Craftsman or Spanish style home. They may be smaller, but I can always buy sheds or storage space.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- NietTim 10y agoBut why would you care about the outside of your house when the inside is nice and cozy?
- jasonkester 10y agoI know, right? Look at [Other Group] with their [Thing They Like]. Can't they see how it goes against [Thing Our Group Wants To Signal]? If only they had cultivated [Subjective Taste We've Cultivated] they would be ashamed. It's almost like they watch Television. Or Sports on Television. Or eat Fast Food and enjoy it. Or prefer sandwich bread to crusty artisanal bread. Or drive Big Flashy Cars. Or drive pedestrian affordable cars. Or support Obama. Or support Trump. Or drink instant coffee or take public transportation. There's no end to the list of things that the Other People do that Our People can look down on and laugh. If only they knew better.
- willis77 10y agoUpvoted from my sensibly balanced Craftsman home while eating crusty artisanal bread and drinking pour-over Blue Bottle coffee before I head to work in my 2012 Volvo XC90 while listening to NPR.
- heptathorp 10y agoI hate to be the one to tell you this but Blue Bottle is the McDonalds of third wave coffee.
- rbanffy 10y agoTo be fair, I found the second one perfectly reasonable - it's kind of nice on its determination to avoid the recipe the article outlines. Having said that, it's often better to fail by actively trying to avoid following the norm than to try to follow it and not quite succeed.
- jheriko 10y agoyou would think 101 would tell you what the hell a mcmansion is, instead of me needing to google it to find out half way through what is otherwise an interesting article.
- emodendroket 10y agoWell, if you need education to understand why your house is not aesthetically pleasing, maybe you should just forego the education and be happy with it.
- digi_owl 10y agoAs a foreigner, what i find myself thinking is that the mcmansions are trying to catch the feel of a generational dwelling while being brand new. Meaning that if you look at old houses in Europe or similar you very often find extensions and whatsnot that have been added without any overall design in mind. Instead they were going by the time and resources at hand at the time of addition.
- mrcsparker 10y agoThis whole article reeks of magical thinking (as do many of the comments here). I have been looking for information on what constitutes a McMansion vs a non-McMansion and the arguments parallel the same sort of stuff that made Feng Shui so popular: there are magical rules that make things right or wrong. Would love so see a real test done on these assumptions. If there are real rules that are being violated with these homes, then an unbiased test should be easy to put together.
- imgabe 10y agoIf you like McMansions and think they constitute good design, you are more than welcome to spend your money on one. The "Mc" part comes because they are cheaply mass produced with little thought or effort put into the design. The didn't decide to "break the rules" because they were pursuing some artistic vision. It was just a matter of expediency to create the most volume for the least money.
- ghaff 10y agoI suspect you're looking for a more absolutist set of principles than exist when, in fact, these things exist on a continuum and opinions vary. I think there are certain overall factors that trigger the broad McMansion dislike but they're not universal. (From an architectural perspective) a lot of mishmashing of architectural styles and features without any sort of unifying aesthetic. Yes, that's a matter of taste, and there are ugly buildings with unified modernist aesthetics but we can probably agree that architecture should be more than pich two from column A, one from column B, and one from column C. In many cases, McMansions are in large developments with big houses on small property lots with, often, minimal landscaping both for reasons of space and because they're fairly new, which accentuates all that there is to not like about the houses themselves. I suspect that the McMansion style gets wrapped up in a lot of cultural biases and attitudes such as you see here. [ADDED: The OP did make an effort to offer some tests. My untrained paraphrase would be that McMansions tend to be sort of a jumble of often seemingly random design elements.]
- squozzer 10y agoThe author made some good points but focused solely on the outside appearance of the home. Another critical aspect of architecture is the layout and use of interior space - a point where many beloved designs - such as colonial - have weaknesses. For example, long hallways. McMansions seem to be designed from the inside out, which is almost a given for an overtly modern (Bauhaus) style, then a traditional skin applied.
- hx87 10y agoMost of these houses, and most McMansions, would look and function much better if they just rid of two features: 1) Gables that don't terminate a wing of the house 2) Massive hip roofs #1 makes no sense from either an aesthetic or functional point of view and ends up doing nothing besides adding cost and making solar panel installation more difficult. #2 also makes solar panel installation more difficult, is harder to ventilate (or air seal and insulate, in the case of cathedral ceilings), and unless labor is extremely cheap, more expensive to build compared to trussed gable roofs.
- galfarragem 10y agoArchitecture is materialized values. McMansions materialize the values of the majority of Americans.
- tripzilch 10y agoYou've got to know to the rules before you break the rules. I don't know about McMansions. Certainly (~20th century) Dutch architecture follows somewhat different design guidelines. We don't have as much space, sometimes sacrificing balance or even proportion. We definitely have much bigger windows (voids), it's a cultural thing. Similarly, fig.2 "Secondary Masses: 6" looks to me like it could be a Mediterranean communal farm, grown organically (truly don't see what's wrong with that one tbh). But I don't want to go into details. The most important rule of design is: You've got to know to the rules before you break the rules. Some of these rules are grown by circumstance, and you can't always break them (or build a shitty house--but sometimes you can be clever). Some of the rules are grown by taste or preference. These you can play with. Some of the rules are grown by circumstance, turned into preference, because technology advanced and preference didn't. These you can also play with. Relating this to HN: The above holds just as much for designing webpages or app user interfaces.