28 ms·
Apple should stop selling four-year-old computers
- applecore 10y agoWhy did Apple stop making new computers? Is there an underlying business rationale or is it component supply challenges?
- rbritton 10y agoI suspect it's more a problem of focus. Yes, Intel has slowed in the release of new processor architectures, but there are lines Apple has ignored and many other components (e.g., graphics cards) have continued advancing. I feel they're consciously choosing to allocate their hardware engineering resources to mobile instead.
- derefr 10y agoApple would certainly pause the production of new computers (or at least the announcement of such) if doing otherwise meant triggering the Osborne effect. Maybe they're waiting until the USB-C/Thunderbolt 3.1 accessory market stabilizes, and then moving everything over to being more MacBook-like (where the rMB is the only thing they were confident enough in their continued support of to continue releasing it in the interim.)
- karma_vaccum123 10y agoThey are simply exploiting the fact that their brand identity plus retail presence generates plenty of sales....plus most consumers don't care what is under the hood.
- nxc18 10y agoIt doesn't make money. Even though they have a crap ton of cash because of their mobile business, they don't seem willing to invest in their desktop os or their PC business. Its surprising because the mac + ios system is such a powerful combination. With MS at least trying lately with their pen enabled devices, bash on windows, and general lack of complete disdain for customers, they may be getting ready to eat Apple's lunch. Compare that with 4 year old laptops, little real innovation in mac os (the latest I can recall is implementing Windows 8's window system for full screen and making dev's lives harder with all the security changes in el cap) and it starts to make you wonder. Not saying Windows is better than Mac, just wish Apple would stop pulling an MS and actually try with their OS.
- davesque 10y agoI had been waiting for a hardware update from Apple for months. Recently, I broke down and just built a custom PC for exactly the reasons you're saying.
- stupidcar 10y agoThe Mac does make money though, about 13% of revenue in Q4 2015: http://www.macrumors.com/2015/10/27/q4-2015-earnings/ http://www.macrumors.com/2015/10/27/q4-2015-earnings/ Yes, the iPhone delivers the lion's share of revenue, but the Mac is still an important product category. To me, the problem seems to be one of focus. The extreme centralisation that Apple inherited from the Jobs era means that, when the leadership is focussed on a particular product or product category, be it the iPhone, the Apple Watch, or a new service like Apple Music, then progress in all other areas grinds to a halt. I can understand that Apple wants to avoid the Microsoft problem of having multiple, independent business units that end up distrusting and working against one another, but the complete opposite situation isn't healthy either. A company of Apple's size and means should be able to do more than one thing at once. A few years ago, Apple had a perfect opportunity to finally break the Mac out of its 5-10% niche of the PC market. Windows 8 was a dud, while Apple's brand and reputation were at their zenith, and their hardware had a huge edge in terms of quality and aesthetics over anything other PC vendors were putting out. The time was right for a huge push of the Mac. But they didn't do it. Perhaps it was absent mindedness. Perhaps it was a lingering fear of taking on Microsoft in their own territory. Perhaps they genuinely believed the PC/laptop market was going to be disappear and be replaced by tablet computers. But for whatever reason, they blew their chance. And if I was an Apple shareholder, I'd be pissed about it.
- pmontra 10y agoPerhaps they already have most of the customers that want to spend the money a Mac costs AND want to buy from Apple. There is no way for Apple to swap market share with Windows unless they sell a Mac for $300 and I'm pretty sure Apple doesn't want to sell at such a low margin.
- 10y ago
- nxc18 10y agoIt doesn't make money. Even though they have a crap ton of cash because of their mobile business, they don't seem willing to invest in their desktop os or their PC business. Its surprising because the mac + ios system is such a powerful combination. With MS at least trying lately with their pen enabled devices, bash on windows, and general lack of complete disdain for customers, they may be getting ready to eat Apple's lunch. Compare that with 4 year old laptops, little real innovation in mac os (the latest I can recall is implementing Windows 8's window system for full screen and making dev's lives harder with all the security changes in el cap) and it starts to make you wonder. Not saying Windows is better than Mac, just wish Apple would stop pulling an MS and actually try with their OS.
- tim333 10y agoThey have not stopped. The new Macbook came out last year. A leisurely schedule of new releases perhaps. They are not doing bad in terms of market share. 7.5% Q4 15 vs 6.7% a year earlier global share. I think that's probably their best ever? http://www.macrumors.com/2016/01/12/4q15-pc-sales/ http://www.macrumors.com/2016/01/12/4q15-pc-sales/
- jpalomaki 10y agoJust looking at the latest figures can be dangerous. Sales are certainly going well, but there seems be some annoyance groving among the users and competitors are improving (for example Dell XPS 15" and Windows 10 with Ubuntu).
- Someone 10y agoIf they just updated the CPU, people would complain about such things such as the amount of on-board memory (which often cannot be upgraded in recent Apple hardware), the video card, external ports, etc. So, my guess would be that their replacement hardware isn't ready. Follow-up question is: why is the hardware not ready? Possible answers (with varying degrees of realism) include: - they don't think they need it yet. - they wanted to have it ready, but hit some snag designing or producing it. - they are designing their own ARM CPUs, and want some more room to ensure that they will be faster than the old hardware. - they are designing their own ARM CPUs, and hit snags doing so. I would think it is one of the first two, but it would be more interesting if it were one of the last two.
- jaxondu 10y agoLooking at just Macbook Pro retina, which they skip a generation of Intel processor, my speculations: * They have issue getting USB-C/Thunderbolt 3.1 right, power usage wise * They are trying to incorporate TouchID, which requires custom chip like in iPhone, such chip takes time * They want P3 extended sRGB for the retina screen but has issue with supplier. * They are building a new trackpad that can support Apple Pencil, and it takes time. * They have move majority of Mac hardware people to focus on ARM chip based Mac. * They have a brand new overhaul design, but Johnny Ive is too busy with flagship building * They are teaching customers that you only need to buy a new Mac every 5 years. But there is no excuse for Apple not to make an interim upgrade with whatever new generation of Intel CPU.
- GrumpyYoungMan 10y agoIf I had to make a bet, I'd guess that they're trying to add touchscreen capabilities to OS X to match up with the MS Surface Pros.
- justin66 10y agoThe power savings from including a newer Intel processor seem pretty massive in and of themselves. It doesn't seem like they'd have to do a massive overhaul to make an update worthwhile.
- chrisseaton 10y agoProcessor speed isn't a limiting factor for me, but the 16 GB max RAM really is and it's definitely becoming a problem for daily work as a programmer working with compilers and VMs. I just wish they'd fix that.
- yuhong 10y agoAt this point this would likely involve a move to Skylake and DDR4.
- toodlebunions 10y agoGet an iPad Pro! It's a Pro computer, according to the new commercials. /s
- mark_l_watson 10y agoI know you are joking, but the iPad Pro is my work horse now unless I need multiple side by side SSH shells, or an IDE for programming. It is great for writing, doing research, etc.
- chrisseaton 10y agoWith a Bluetooth keyboard? Surely?
- mark_l_watson 10y agoI bought the Apple keyboard+cover. When I write, I only write 3 or 4 pages a day, so that minimal keyboard is OK.
- ksk 10y agoI don't quite understand how it is a "work horse" when you write 4 pages a day.
- 10y ago
- oldmanjay 10y ago"...that doesn’t mean it isn’t unconscionable for Apple to continue to sell outdated products to people who may not know any better" I may suffer from a lack of nannying instincts that make these sort of hyperbolic assertions hard to swallow. Is it a common impulse to want to save all those poor people from themselves for no particular reason? If they "don't know any better", it's pretty clear they don't have a personal reason to care, and this entire sentiment becomes rather condescending in that light.
- CydeWeys 10y agoIt's not about nannying, it's about Apple doing damage to their brand. They are the largest publicly held corporation in the world, yet a lot of their important brands are languishing and have become terrible values for the money because they haven't been updated in four years. I know very few people who have bought Apple PCs recently. I'm using a Macbook Pro Retina that I got in the 2013 refresh cycle, and if it were to get stolen tomorrow I'd buy a Windows PC to replace it because buying essentially the same laptop three years later for the same price makes no sense when the rest of the industry has moved on a lot more. As the "tech guy" in my extended family and friends group, a lot of people come to me for laptop-buying advice, and I haven't been able to recommend anything Apple in over a year.
- toodlebunions 10y agoIf you buy something new, isn't it reasonable to expect something is new? Not four years old and soon to be antiquated?
- kazinator 10y agoNo, it isn't reasonable. You can buy a "741" op-amp IC, and it's the same circuit on the silicon as it was in 1968. It's just "newly made". A new pair of jeans isn't going to have some amazing new development compared to the pair you had 25 years ago. Same YKK zipper, etc.
- toodlebunions 10y ago
- intopieces 10y agoWhy should Apple stop selling anything that people want to buy? For most people, buying a new computer is something you do when your old one breaks. I know Apple cultivates itself as a "professional's brand" but that's not really the case anymore. Every 18 year old with a pocket full of graduation money next to her iPhone grabs a new Mac, and any Mac she grabs will perform a vast majority of the tasks she needs. The real question is not "why does Apple still sell.." It's "why do people still buy ...?" Answer: because it works.
- melling 10y agoBecause the computers get slower with each OS upgrade. At some point this catches up and the machine feels slow. CPU's might not be improving at the same rate but GPU's are. iMacs, for example, use a mobile gpu on the desktop. i've goto a 2010 iMac and it's slow because i didn't opt for an ssd at the time and got a painfully slow 5400 rpm drive. People buy because they don't know any better. Wait until every new Mac in the fall has USB C connectors.
- Ressuder 10y agoAbsolutely not true. If anything, El Capitan improves performance.
- loopbit 10y agoEl Capitan improves performance compared to Yosemite, just as Snow leopard improved on Leopard, but if you look into more than two generations of the OS the trend goes the other way. I currently have two apple laptops, an old macbook that came with Tiger and use it to test beta versions of OSX. It's running El Capitan right now but is almost unusable. My main computer is a rMBP that came with Lion. It worked better (faster, snappier) with Mountain Lion than it does with El Capitan.
- ams6110 10y agoI used an old 12" PowerBook G4 running Tiger for years past end of support. I just loved the size and the keyboard. It was also user-maintainable. Battery, memory, hard drive all easily accessed. I still have it and it still works. I tried running OpenBSD on it and while that worked, performance was a lot worse than Tiger.
- yuhong 10y agoBackground: This is about the last MacBook Pro without things like soldered RAM I think.
- hiram112 10y agoYes. I recently almost purchased one of these for $800 on eBay simply because I have a spare SSD and 16 GB of DDR3. I won't pay $2000 for a laptop from Apple that has these things already soldered in. In the end I still couldn't justify it as I want an I7 which they no longer sell with the ability to add ram and SSD.
- PhantomGremlin 10y agoI want an I7 which they no longer sell You can still buy the 2012 Macbook Pro with an i7. You must BTO: 13-inch MacBook Pro 2.9GHz Dual-core Intel Core i7, Turbo Boost up to 3.6GHz 4GB 1600MHz DDR3 SDRAM — 2x2GB 500GB Serial ATA Drive @ 5400 rpm SuperDrive 8x (DVD±R DL/DVD±RW/CD-RW) http://www.apple.com/shop/buy-mac/macbook-pro?product=MD101LL/A&step=config http://www.apple.com/shop/buy-mac/macbook-pro?product=MD101L... Cost is $1249. Bring your own RAM and SSD to upgrade as desired.
- hiram112 10y agoThanks - I did not know these were still sold. I usually look on EBay for a new one, and $700-$800 (with no tax) is a price point that I'd be willing to pay. I've never seen a new i7, though. At $1300 (with tax), I could get a pretty nice Thinkpad or Dell Precision with quad core 6th gen Intel and still use the ram and SSD.
- derefr 10y agoThe main reason to keep selling old models is a logistical one: what Apple actually wants is to get rid of all their pipelined stock. That doesn't mean that they produced too many 2012 MBPs; but rather, they have a bunch of last-gen components they've already irrevocably taken receipt of, and are now stuck integrating, manufacturing, and warehousing; and those components can go together to make (among other things) a 2012-MBP. Which still sells. So making and selling those is one strategy for getting rid of those components. Adding a channel for using up last-gen stock has, after all, been stated as the main reason for the existence of the iPod Touch.
- CydeWeys 10y agoDo you really think they have pipelined stock that is over four years old? Wouldn't that represent a massive failure in many regards? It'd be interesting to see a disassembly of a Macbook purchased new today to find out when the components inside it were actually assembled.
- nikdaheratik 10y agoThe non-Retina 2012 MBP is their institutional laptop product. If it was a consumer oriented product, they would have gotten rid of it, but they keep selling thousands at a discount to universities and high schools. They haven't dragged in an update as the specs and prices are good enough for what those customers need, and they are pushing a move to iPad for them anyway. Their other products should have been updated by now. Especially the Mac Pro and Mac Mini. And they've been skimping on the graphics card for lower end models. The price/performance has been very frustrating as you can get a good (e.g. Alienware) desktop with the same high end graphics as the high end iMac but for the same price as the low end model now. Their laptops are still good even at the price, but the rest of the line could be much better.
- IBM 10y agoAnyone who buys a Macbook Pro today, before they're updated in the fall, will be able to use it for the next 3 years without issue. My Macbook Air was purchased in 2012 and is still fast enough that I probably won't replace it for another 2 years. People keep their computers longer now because they're fast enough. This has been true for the PC industry for at least 5 years now and it's why sales have been declining since they peaked in 2011 [1]. The year over year changes from Intel/AMD are incremental and I suspect Apple has decided they're not going to buy every iteration. It's even less important to get every chip now that Intel has stretched their development cycle from Tick-Tock to Process-Architecture-Optimization [2]. [1] http://static1.businessinsider.com/image/56968e64c08a80492c8b794e-1200-900/20160113_pc_bi.png http://static1.businessinsider.com/image/56968e64c08a80492c8... [2] http://www.anandtech.com/show/10183/intels-tick-tock-seemingly-dead-becomes-process-architecture-optimization http://www.anandtech.com/show/10183/intels-tick-tock-seeming...
- tim333 10y agoSeconded from a 2012 Air. Still works fine.
- dejv 10y agoSame here, but I had to replace battery last year.
- enraged_camel 10y agoThirded. It still works like a champ after 4 years. No issues.
- slowmovintarget 10y agoWhether it "works fine" (and my Pro works fine) is not the point. When you can now buy more powerful laptops with longer battery life for less money than current Macs, it becomes hard to justify the premium price for a Mac. It seems like Apple is hoping the consumer won't notice and still buy the brand as though it's a designer item and not electronics. I suspect that this is not the primary motivation for their current lack of new tech. I think that the largest part for this regression from the cutting edge is a consequence of no longer having Steve Jobs pushing every part of the company for its utmost. Apple, when you anthropomorphize the actions of the company as a whole, comes off as arrogant. They had earned this by actually delivering the best you could buy. The best laptops, the best phones, the best music players, the best tablets. With the exception of tablets, this is no longer true, in any category (not even phones). And that is the issue. Not whether the device is still good enough. It ought to be the best, because that was what we came to expect from Apple. The premium ought to be a no-brainer because you get what you pay for. It isn't like that anymore and if you're a fan of Apple (and I have been since the Apple IIe) then you really wish it were.
- jordanlev 10y agoIt was just 6 months ago the internet was singing the praises of the "outdated" 12-inch MacBook Pro: https://marco.org/2016/01/04/md101ll-a https://marco.org/2016/01/04/md101ll-a
- jonknee 10y agoSinging the praises? Here are some quotes from the piece: > it’s an open secret among Apple employees that the “101” still sells surprisingly well — to a nearly tragic degree, given its age and mediocrity. > Geeks like me often wonder why anyone would still buy such an outdated machine. > I’m right there with everyone else who’d strongly advise against buying this machine for most people who’d ask me
- jordanlev 10y agoWow, that's weird -- I distinctly remember reading this in January and coming away feeling great about my 4-year-old MBP that still runs just fine. Totally stuffed the bad parts down the memory hole -- thanks for rightfully calling this out.
- GirlsCanCode 10y agoWe've 'switched back' at our office. Developers now have PCs because they need NVIDIA for Cuda programming.
- macawfish 10y agoAs a teenager, I subscribed to MacAddict from 1997-2001. It was very exciting to watch the company transform over this time. Alas, since then my relationship to Apple has evolved dramatically, to the point of more or less despising the company and its manipulations. I am grateful for this journey. It has given me a sharp sense (distaste) for manipulative marketing tactics and branding in general. When my hard drive crashed badly in 2010, I quit for good, jumping over to Ubuntu full time. (More recently I installed Arch, which makes me excited about computers again!) Anyway, It's completely frustrating to me even my most financially disabled friends will, to this day, look to spend $1200 as much on a Mac laptop or an iPhone when they could get an equally powerful, used machine for $150. A close friend of mine just spent $300 on a used G5 iMac from 2006... I told him not to but he didn't listen. He has had to learn the hard way that the computer is slow, won't accept updates, won't run any new software or drivers, etc. because Apple's branding black magic is that powerful, that it could completely trump the well reasoned advice of someone knowledgable about the subject that you've known for years.
- Retra 10y agoWhy do you think it's Mac branding that makes your friends not heed your advice instead of the expectations that you would ask of them more effort than they are willing to expend? Most people are not willing to explore a lifestyle change when purchasing a computer. It's not unlike the idea they won't learn to sew to save money on clothes, or learn to change their own oil to save car maintenance fees. Was your advice an offer of convenience for them, or an offer of lifestyle conformity?
- macawfish 10y agoWell, in the case of my friend who bought the iMac for $300, my advice was "don't buy that computer its not worth $300”. It was solid advice. He just hadn't gotten over the beautiful allure of the thing to see through to its desperate software and hardware situation. The expectation of effortlessness is all tied up in the marketing. The marketing promises a kind of magic, which I feel is bullshit, a fantasy world where you don't have to think about the clothes, they just appear on your shelf, when in reality, they're actually made by a person, whether that person is your Amish grandmother, a friend, a kid in an Indonesian factory, or you yourself. And someone is going to have to wash them when they're dirty, and fix them when they have holes or do the work of recycling them... Computers require effort and attention and energy to maintain no matter what, even Macs (especially macs...). If not up front, then somewhere down the line. It's fascinating to live in a time when it's arguably easier to install Linux on a given computer than Mac OS or even Windows. This is new. My advice to people is that learning some user friendly Linux is a good investment of technical energy. It's like buying a used car instead of a brand new one. You could spend $10000 rebuilding that used car before you made a dent in the cost of a new one. For a lot of people, the time it takes to keep a used car working well is worth the trade-off.. BTW, I've had a lot of success hooking people up with old (2011) i5 Thinkpads running Linux and/or Windows. They run great and people really like them. Mine has 16GB of ram in it goes real smooth. I use lots of tabs. Too many tabs. And Bitwig. Bitwig works great on an old thinkpad with Arch!
- pronoiac 10y agoThere was an article about its appeal: https://marco.org/2016/01/04/md101ll-a https://marco.org/2016/01/04/md101ll-a Upgradable storage, memory, and an optical drive. It's cheap and not that outdated.
- SyneRyder 10y agoYup, Marco's take on this is a good one. (I bought a 2012 MBP in late 2015 for many of those reasons.) One thing that is often overlooked is that the trackpad click is much better on the 2012 than on the Force Touch models. There is a really satisfying click, mostly because it has so much more room to travel. That was a big part of my decision to stick with the 2012 over any 2015 MBP or MacBook models. I feel about the 2012 MBP Trackpad the same way some folks feel about a Model M or Das Keyboard.
- wwweston 10y agoAnd personally, I think that we passed the point of adequate specs for most purposes 8 years ago. I have two MBPs. One is a 2008 that is beat to hell at this point but still functions pretty darn well with an SSD and maxed out RAM. It's good enough I've been able to do most day-to-day development with it and audio production up through this summer. If it were effectively invulnerable and weren't eventually going to stop receiving OS updates (or if security/compatibility weren't a concern), I could conceive of using it indefinitely for most work. I also have a 2012 that is still adequate (though, weirdly, sometimes worse in terms of locking up, not sure if that's the later version of OS X or no SSD). I bought it not because I needed anything newer, but because I didn't want to be stuck searching for a replacement when the 2008 fails. And perhaps interestingly, I bought it used because Apple has decided to no longer offer a 15" model with a matte screen that's upgradable anymore.
- gurkendoktor 10y agoGreat article, and one more point: The weight and terrible screen resolution are not show-stoppers for people like me who mostly use their Mac on a desk, with an external display. (Mine is actually a 2012 Air, but I barely move it and can absolutely relate to happy cMBP owners.)
- 10y ago
- slyrus 10y ago"Making computers is hard. Let's just sell phones, apps, songs, ads, and whatever the hell people are paying us for icloud for!" -- Apple, probably.
- draw_down 10y agoDing them for supposed planned obsolescence or tell them to stop selling 4 year old computers, take your pick :)
- protomyth 10y agoWe've been pretty loyal buying Macs, but at this point we just cannot justify it anymore. We had a brief flirtation with giving people iPads instead of PCs, and that is better from a support / update point of view. But, the desire for a "real computer" is pretty strong with the generation of people we have on staff. At this point, I'm reading up on Chrome books and Chrome boxes to see how simple IT things (e.g. network login, server storage) are managed and can we use them with local not cloud storage[1]. We might do more Win 10, but Microsoft sure isn't making it easy with their OS. I guess the Enterprise edition might be ok. Creative arts will probably always be Mac, but we are an all Adobe institution after the Final Cut Pro X fiasco so even that is not a certainty. 1) I have to obey a couple of very un-fun local laws and will buy old machines rather than deal with problems in that area
- pmontra 10y agoCould you elaborate on the last point (law requirements for local storage) ? I can think about many cases but I'd love to know about a real one.
- protomyth 10y agoWe have a local law that talks about research data[1] and its movement. The problem is if some security issue happens in the cloud, it is likely to leak documents and I am a bit worried about the wording as it applies to liability. Storing them locally and have a data breach would be problematic, but at least defensible 1) Basically, no data may be shared unless approved by a local institution. Its legacy from other groups taking the data we generate and writing grants to get money that never benefits the local people or institutions. A long, long story that someone should write a book on.
- pmontra 10y agoWaiting for that book :-) A data breach should be equivalent to having paper documents stolen from a safe, unless there is negligence. Did you check with a lawyer, right?
- nommm-nommm 10y agoWould anyone care if Lenovo or Dell was selling outdated computers? Hell, they probably are. Do we have different expectations for Apple? Is it because they are more of a luxury brand? Why does Apple have an obligation to update their hardware every X years? Also from what I have seen prices of MacBooks seem to have been going down quite a bit.
- yuhong 10y agoThey don't typically sell new computers this outdated.
- glogla 10y agoYes. New Thinkpads have CPUs two generations newer than lates rMBPs
- Xorlev 10y agoYou certainly can buy an outdated Thinkpad, but the lines are refreshed often. Literally from the first Google result: > At CES 2016, Lenovo announced a massive overhaul of its ThinkPad line. In addition to unveiling new ThinkPad X1 notebooks, tablets and convertibles, Lenovo also unveiled refreshes to its X, T and L series ThinkPad as well as a new ThinkPad 13. Except the ThinkPad 13, which comes with options for either Windows or Chrome operating systems, all the ThinkPad models unveiled come with Intel's sixth generation Skylake processor, giving them a boost in performance and battery life.
- CydeWeys 10y agoI just looked at some bargain basement Dell desktops and laptops (in the ~$400 range) because your comment made me curious. Both desktops and laptops come with Intel N3000-series processors, which were released last year. So no, Dell isn't selling anything that is nearly as outdated as what Apple is selling, for substantially more money.
- jarmitage 10y agoRead this as "Apple should stop selling four-year-olds computers" and I was like hell yeah they should! Get those babies on Raspberry Pi's asap.
- nissehulth 10y agoThey become sad after 5 years, I guess. http://thenextweb.com/opinion/2016/03/21/apple-hypocritical-insensitive-pc-users-old-pc/ http://thenextweb.com/opinion/2016/03/21/apple-hypocritical-... "There are over 600 million PCs in use today that are over five years old. This is really sad, it really is."
- BatFastard 10y agoI have half a dozen desktop PCs from 2000-4 in use in my house. I had to update the graphics card, but a Core2-Dou at 3 GHz with a decent graphics card will run virtually every program in existence. Recently I went from 2.4GHz processor to 3GHz processors, 15 bucks on ebay ;-) I don't get the obsession with notebooks. Why do I want to spend 4X the amount of money for something that last 4 years if I am lucky. For the <1% of time I am not working from my desk? In meeting I prefer people NOT to bring a notebook, this way they pay attention and I can get them out of the room and back to work faster.
- newmanships 10y agoI think more and more people are not working at the same desk everyday (people working at coffeeshops or traveling) or don't have space for a desktop/don't want the extra stuff that is required for a desktop if they are living in a small apartment
- majewsky 10y agoAlso, in companies, devices are usually swapped out after a fixed period anyway (3 years at my workplace). When you manage a lot of devices, the increased failure rates near the end of the devices' life cycle can really hurt, so it makes sense to replace devices early and sell the used devices in bulk for a few bucks, hopefully after wiping the drives. ;) And given that you swap out the employee computers well before they break down, the shorter lifetime of notebooks doesn't matter. What matters is that your employee can take her device to a meeting room, or to a customer site.
- psykpsyk 10y ago
- shurcooL 10y agoMany people who are asking or hoping for an update to the non-Retina MBP are missing an important point. Apple already has released an update to it with newer CPUs, and better screen, and thinner, it's the Retina MBP. The non-Retina MBP is effectively discontinued because it's largely replaced by the Retina version, and has been for many years. They still sell the non-Retina MBP (in one size only, no 15") just for few people that absolutely need a built-in optical drive in their MBP for some specific reason. The non-Retina MBP is not meant for the general public. If you walk into an Apple Store without knowing anything, the chances of you walking out with one is less than 1%, it's hard to find and store employees will recommend something better for your needs.
- kristianp 10y agoThat's a good point. The article does mention that its latest release was over a year ago, which isn't bad: "The Retina MacBook Pro is 442 days into its current cycle, despite refreshes coming every 268 days on average in the past."
- snowwrestler 10y ago> They still sell the non-Retina MBP (in one size only, no 15") just for few people that absolutely need a built-in optical drive in their MBP for some specific reason. The key here is "built in," because Apple also sells a USB external optical drive. In fact a 13" retina MBP + USB optical drive is lighter than the 13" non-retina MBP by itself. Actually there are a few reasons people still buy the old MBP, but price is probably the main one. https://marco.org/2016/01/04/md101ll-a https://marco.org/2016/01/04/md101ll-a
- shmerl 10y agoI don't think Apple care about their desktop OS and hardware anymore. It has been stagnating for a while already. I suppose recent rise of stats for global Linux usage can indicate OS X refugees who are fed up with that stagnation.
- xlayn 10y agoI didn't read a single technology or feature any ultra modern computer has that the 4 years old MBP doesn't have, nor about anything you can't do on it any newer computer does. People are interpreting "PCs are extremely good and capable now" as "PC is dead".
- AhtiK 10y agoSkylake supports HEVC (H.265) codec making it so much more battery efficient to encode and decode video [1]. Smaller battery consumption also means less heating issues, so that's what keeps me excited about "ultra modern" computers that none of the MBPs has. [1] https://software.intel.com/en-us/blogs/2015/12/11/codecs-are-they-slowing-you-down https://software.intel.com/en-us/blogs/2015/12/11/codecs-are...
- kalleboo 10y ago> Smaller battery consumption also means less heating issues This is the main thing for me - I'm still using a 2012 rMBP as my main machine, and I have no complaints about performance except often when you try to make the most of the performance it's capable of, it overheats and throttles down. Especially a problem in the summer.
- cletus 10y agoSome people point to the limited improvements in Skylake and Broadwell as an argument why it doesn't matter that Mac updates have faltered. I respectfully disagree. Look at the 12" Macbook. This, to me, is just too much compromise. Only one port and it's USB-C and it's the power?? Compare this to the healthy amount of ports on the HP Spectre in what is still a small form factor. Add in the terrible (IMHO) keyboard, pointless Force Touch and lack of tactile feedback on the trackpad. Yet the Macbook Air remains with a relatively crappy display. For year it was suggested it wasn't economical/possible to add a retina display to this form factor. The Macbook is proof to the contrary. Plus with the 12" Macbook, 13" Retina MBP and 11" and 13" Macbook Airs, it seems clear that not all these SKUs are going to survive. I have a 2011 13" Macbook Air as my personal laptop. At the time I considered it to be about perfect in terms of portability and power. But the design is getting pretty long in the tooth now. Crappy (relatively) display. Look at the Dell XPS 13 and 15s as inspiration. For one, they have really thin bezels. The Mac Pro? Introduced with much fanfare 3 years ago and hasn't been updated since. Mac mini? Coming up on 2 years without an update. And we lost the quad core options. This all comes as Apple has pushed the iPad Pro as a laptop replacement. My point is that with the Apple ecosystem (and many others) there's a halo effect. People buy into part of it based on the complete range, regardless of whether or ot they'll buy into the rest. They have the option. The sense I get from Apple is they're no longer interested in the PC/laptop segments. They seem to no longer care about power users even though power users are influencers. Also, it seems like the days of only horrible trackpads on PCs might finally be over. At least it seems like some models might have decent trackpads. Can Apple really think tablets are the future? Maybe they aren't but we're a long way from that. The UX on an iPad Pro with a keyboard is as terrible as Steve Jobs used to say it was (Jobs famously called touchscreens with keyboards terrible). So even if Apple does update their lineup later this year I'm not sure I'm going to buy in because the writing seems to be on the wall. At this point a Dell XPS 13 or 15 seems like the way to go.
- rsync 10y ago"Mac mini? Coming up on 2 years without an update. And we lost the quad core options." Also, they dramatically reduced its utility by removing the optical drive. It is stupefying that you cannot buy a mac mini with an optical drive. It's ridiculous. It takes most of the interesting use-cases off the table and makes many other use-cases a pain in the ass. I would have kept buying mac minis, continuously, every 3-4 years, forever. Instead, I bought two of the fastest/latest ones with optical drive and that's all I'll ever have.
- greenspot 10y agoI miss something between a MacBook and a MBP. Something light with a Retina display, minimum 13" and a good CPU. Basically a Thinkpad X1 Carbon with OSX.
- jwatte 10y agoHow long did the Mac Plus form factor (and 16 MHz 68k) stay on the market? Much longer than 4 years. ("Mac Classic" anyone?)
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoI bought my rMBP in late 2014. At the time, I just needed a laptop, Windows or otherwise as I mainly use Linux. Other than the rMBP, every laptop that I could physically get my hands on was flimsy junk. The keyboards flexed, that plastic around the screen flexed, the screen was not steady in the open position. Even my workstation (Lenovo w530) for work is a hunk of flimsy plastic. It's just crazy. Maybe things are different now? Or maybe I didn't get my hands on some better ones, but how can companies sell so much junk?
- willtim 10y agoIt's obviously all subjective. Personally, compared to Lenovo, I find MacBookPro keyboards to be "junk". I also don't want a glossy glass-covered screen, a glued-in battery or a heavy dent-prone radio-attenuating metal case. Each to his/her own.
- diimdeep 10y agoIt's 2016, it is much more effective to integrate battery, who needs removable anyway ?
- willtim 10y agoCan you explain "more effective"? The 2016 Thinkpad X1 Carbon is significantly lighter than any MBP and still allows a user to replace the battery using a screwdriver - they are consumables after all.
- bitwize 10y agoFor casual and most technical users[0], Apple machines are still way ahead of the competition in all areas that matter: available software, quality of OS, build quality, portability, battery life... Why should Apple mess with a good thing? The market supports selling the machines they have at the prices they ask. No need to spend NRE costs on new kit. [0] Meaning Web devs, engineers, and scientists, most of whom can't stand Linux. The only thing that matters in software is the experience of the user.
- jwatte 10y agoSorry, I can't find versions of 3ds Max, Inventor, Solidworks, or AutoCAD for the Mac. Also, no Visual Studio. And no Excel. The Mac "equivalents" where they exist are far inferior. How does the Mac have better available software these days?
- rm445 10y agoAutocad and Excel have native Mac versions.
- sbuk 10y agoAh, the "CAD" canard. 1. 3dsmax is but one 3D/animation program, most are multi-platform (see Maya, Cinema 4d, Modo etc...). No, it's not the "industry standard". 2. PLM software like Inventor and SolidWorks are underrepresented on the Mac. Software like Fusion 360 and OnShape[0] are beginning to make up for this 3. AutCAD is available for macOS. Has been of about 5 years. Autodesk in fact produce plenty of software for the Mac... [1] 4. No, but there is Xcode. And IntelliJ. 5. No Excel? Microsoft appear to disagree. [2] Based on your comment, you have no clue what you are talking about, and I'm so bored of seeing this nonsense every time this comes up. Please, stop. [0] https://www.onshape.com/ https://www.onshape.com/ [1] http://www.autodesk.com/solutions/mac-compatible-software http://www.autodesk.com/solutions/mac-compatible-software [2] https://products.office.com/en-gb/excel https://products.office.com/en-gb/excel
- Arcaire 10y ago> 5. No Excel? Microsoft appear to disagree. [2] In my considerable experience using Office on Mac in tandem with Office on Windows, the Mac experience is severely, severely degraded in comparison. Extreme slowdowns in large documents, odd crashes, and difficulties handling macros are pretty much the defining experience for Office 365 on Mac for me.
- jwatte 10y agoNot a single computer sold by Apple meets the minimum spec for a VR experience, nor the next crop of AAA games. What does that mean to the creative that used to prefer Macs for their content creation? What does that do to the brand long term?
- AWildDHHAppears 10y agoReal "creatives" _never_ preferred Macs. Mac, until very recently, didn't have any way to calibrate a monitor (and you had to buy a 3rd party monitor to get a full-gamut display), or 10 bit/channel color. For all our color-critical work at our shop, we _never_ used macs.
- acdha 10y agoIt's not helpful trying to play No True Scotsman by defining “real creative” as “what we do”. Anyone with more than cursory exposure to printing, video, photography, etc. knows that there's a sizable percentage of people who vocally prefer Macs – certainly not everyone, but far, far too many to pretend that a claim like “never preferred” is anything other than fanboy hyperbole. As an aside, what do you mean by “calibrate a monitor”? ColorSync arrived in 1993.
- AWildDHHAppears 10y agoMac LCD monitors have a LED back light that's too blue and too narrow a gamut to do color grading. Yes, it's true that some of the early CRT machines were capable of this.
- acdha 10y agoSo let's correct your statement: 1. Every Mac since the early 90s has had support for color management 2. Most people doing serious color work have to buy a more expensive, professional-quality display – as has long been the case on every platform. This was a staple of reviews for printing, photography, scientific/medical imaging, etc. publications, along with comparing color calibration devices, and a big reason why CRTs persisted longer those fields than the general market.
- gkop 10y agoAnother problem is that, as recently as May 2016, a brand-new 13" MacBook Pro from the Apple store is loaded with Yosemite. It's a totally crappy first-use experience to discover you are on an old version of the operating system.
- laurentdc 10y agoIt's just that most people don't care. You won't believe how many students (non IT related field) I see who still run 10.8/10.9, or whatever OS their MacBook came out with. Also: if you hold down alt-R for performing Internet Recovery on a Mac it downloads the OS it came out of the store with. No idea why. I've had to internet recover a 2013 MacBook Air a week ago and it downloaded... Mavericks.
- fernly 10y agoIf they refresh, how many ports would the new MB Pro have? I was seriously taken by the looks and weight of the latest MB, but the idea of a single port -- and needing a bulky adapter dongle to connect an HDMI cable or any of a dozen legacy USB devices I routinely use -- killed it. A laptop that requires a hub dangling off it is just not acceptable.
- addicted 10y agoThe 2012 MBP bought new today for $1100 will serve a lot of people really well. An $800 Dell XPS will serve them much better, last them much longer, and keep them much happier. A $500 Chromebook might be an even better choice. Unless you have no escape from the Apple eco system lock in, it's almost impossible to recommend a mac to anyone anymore. Even if Apple does come up with a great refresh to their lineup, their treatment of the mac over the last couple of years means they might simply do this again, which means I really cannot recommend them anymore. Apple has pretty much destroyed all teh goodwill they built up with me, and the only way I can recommend a mac anymore is if they open up OS X to all hardware makers (but then, I'd trust Windows which has been doing that for decades, over OSX which has not and Apple would almost certainly have trouble supporting OSX on non Apple devices). And finally, because of how deliberately tied up Apple's ecosystem is, that means I cannot recommend iPhones/iPads anymore despite iOS being a superior platform anymore. I genuinely feel Apple is trading away their past reputation in an effort to extract money from consumers who may not know better.
- hyperbovine 10y ago> The 2012 MBP bought new today for $1100 will serve a lot of people really well. I am writing on exactly such a device, and I have absolutely no reason whatsoever to upgrade. The display is incredible, it's every bit as fast and responsive as the day I bought it, it doesn't creak or feel like it's about to fall apart. When you think back to the late 90s, when operating a five year old laptop felt like using a mechanical typewriter, it's truly amazing. I wonder if this will serve as some sort of high water mark for Apple product design. This machine has literally turned out to be years ahead of its time.
- flashman 10y agoAgreed. The article says: > there’s a certain point at which it just starts to look like absentmindedness Yes, but there's also a certain point at which a computer is fast enough, powerful enough, capacious enough, has enough battery life... The 2012 MBP is by no means state-of-the-art, but it is objectively good enough for most purposes.
- 10y ago
- maxsilver 10y agoCan Apple at least just put a Retina screen and 16GB RAM option on the 13' MacBook Air. That's all I'm waiting for. They don't even have to bump the CPU or ports or anything else. It's not a hardware problem. My MacBook Pro's HD 4000 drives a Retina screen, the Air's current HD 6000 certainly could too. Microsoft and Dell have been shipping Retina screens and 16GB ram ultrabooks for 2 years now -- but we're forbidden from using it for iOS development. I totally get that it's more fun to go "Scrooge McDuck" swimming through their iPhone money. But if Apple could kick out just a basic spec bump from 1-2 years ago for the Air, I'd be thrilled.
- lostlogin 10y agoI'd be pretty happy if they fixed that weird "wake from sleep, 2 mins use, back to sleep" thing. But a retina would be nice. Also, move the damn power button away from delete.
- kalleboo 10y agoI think they're more likely to drop the Air in favor of the new Retina MacBook line than update it...
- maxsilver 10y agoYour probably right. But if they do that, I'm out. I simply won't buy a laptop that ships without a working keyboard.
- vegabook 10y agoit's not just the hardware. El Capitan, the latest and greatest, still ships with a stone age Vim 7.3 from August 2010. And we're told not to touch it because /usr/bin is sacrosanct. Bunch of add ins doesn't even work properly. Seriously Apple just doesn't seem to care. This isn't hard to fix, and it's an embarrassment compared with Linux.
- hiram112 10y agoI think the solution is to install the Brew version of the Unix-land tools you use, then set your path to favor these over the Apple supplied executables. That's what I did for Emacs, find, bash, etc. and it works fine.
- rleigh 10y agoThis is a workaround, one which I use myself. But I do have a not unreasonable expectation that the base operating system will be actually maintained rather than abandoned. The amount of unmaintained and obsolescent stuff is quite bad, and getting worse.
- wyclif 10y agoI use Brew as well, but look...it's ridiculous for a company that prides itself on out-of-the-box experience to ask people to do this when they could fix it themselves. It's not hard to do. There is simply no reason why Apple can't ship a laptop with the most recent versions of the common userland utilities.
- davidf18 10y agoWell, the new retina Macbook Pros should be coming out in a few months. Increased battery life and hopefully a lighter 15" retina Macbook Pro will be a compelling reason to upgrade. Moreover, now that Windows 10 Anniversary Update has the integrated bash shell, this makes the Windows platform finally much more competitive for Open Source software development.
- Canada 10y agoI'm keeping my mid 2012 air for at least another year. It's fine. Use it every day and I'm not gentle with it. Only the battery needed replacing. Let's be real here. If you need real power you get a proper desktop or use servers. If you're constantly running your laptop hard enough to power up the fan then you're doing it wrong.
- mrbill 10y agoI would rather pay $200 for a refurbished Thinkpad t420s and then $150 in SSD /RAM / wifi card upgrades than $750-1K for a brand new laptop. My last Mac Mini went 4 years before I upgraded to the current model, and honestly there's not a lot of performance difference between the two, at least for my use cases.
- r0m4n0 10y agoI don't mind the release cycle as it exists... I get the newest model when they come out and the feeling of missing out on something better doesn't linger over me. There aren't a million configurations of the same laptop, there are only a few, which makes things simple on aspects of development, support, and troubleshooting. When people on this thread compare MacBooks to "chromebooks" I don't even know what that means... It could be any number of manufacturers using any number of combinations of hardware to run a common OS. Just because it has the latest Intel doesn't mean the rest of the components aren't subpar. Even if they are higher quality, it wouldn't nearly stack up to the millions of users that have tried and tested the exact configuration of my MBP. Most of the professional community feels the same way, even within the last year [1] [1] http://stackoverflow.com/research/developer-survey-2016#technology-desktop-operating-system http://stackoverflow.com/research/developer-survey-2016#tech...
- verisimilidude 10y agoLast week I bought a new computer. And for the first time since 2002, it wasn't a Mac. I wanted a Mac Mini, but that's a tough buy when you can get something much smaller, more flexible, and more powerful in the PC realm. I wound up buying an Intel NUC and slapping Ubuntu Gnome on it. Most surprisingly, Gnome 3 does not feel like a compromised choice in comparison to OS X. It's not a seamless experience by any means. That said, I'm really digging some of the UI choices they've made. It's a UX that's committed to a vision of how the user should interact with the computer. I remember a time when the Mac also felt like a strongly opinionated experience, designed by and for humans. It no longer feels so. It feels aimless and stagnant, even regressive in some ways. It feels designed by committee rather than vision or voice. The changes do not seem to serve any higher purpose than making the UI look cool in screenshots. I miss the high-contrast controls, readable fonts, always-visible functionality, personable quirks, etc. I still use a Mac all day at work, and I still respect it as a good tool for getting shit done, but I really wonder about the point of it. If I can pick up a free alternative like Ubuntu Gnome and actually feel happy and productive quickly, what's left to recommend the Mac? If Apple doesn't care any more, why should I? (Alright, now y'all can light me up.)
- lastyearman 10y agoWriting this from a 2010 MBP. When I bought it PC laptops were just horrible beyond belief. Full of stickers and adware, creaky plastics, horrible touchpads and keyboards, etc. To this day it has worked perfect. Battery still has 89% capacity and with a SSD upgrade and adblock it's as fast as I need it. OS X works and looks about the same. Meanwhile I've seen lots of Acers die and Windows being the fiasco it is. So in my mind Apple and OS X has been a really reliable work horse that I don't need to fuss with.
- tbihl 10y agoIn my mind Apple does great hardware, but that only matters for mobile. I would've gotten a MBP if I hadn't wanted a stylus. If you're doing a desktop with OS X, you overpay and have no flexibility compared to what you'd get with Windows. I confess that I've seldom had the Windows stability issues that people always mention, so I don't see that as a big deal.
- diimdeep 10y agoApple have MBPr and it is powerful reliable machine. On other side Air model is really outdated at the moment. I think they just can't miniaturize MBPr specs in Air sized model yet and don't want release half backed laptop, wait.. I forgot about new MacBook. Damn Apple.
- rincebrain 10y agoAt least until recently, they would have been hard-pressed to do a refresh - Broadwell had basically no non-low-power SKUs for a long while, so you wouldn't want one in your MBP. So they'd need to refresh with Skylake, which would add lead time, particularly with how long it took to ramp up Skylake manufacturing yield. Meanwhile, if they were going to leverage anything from Skylake for OS X features (looking at you TSX-NI), they wouldn't want to refresh the desktop until they could get it there too, which would probably mean Xeon E[57] v4, and that only came out this quarter.[1] So I'd probably blame this current delay on refreshing on a ripple from Intel's Broadwell/Skylake timeline debacle, and Apple deciding to merge any intervening hardware upgrades into the next iteration forward. [1] - The slight oddity with this logic is that the Xeon E[57] v3, Q2 2015, _does_ have working TSX bits, so they could have conceivably shipped that, even though it's "technically" Haswell. Maybe they got scared when Intel had to use the chicken bits to disable TSX in the first Haswell revs? [2] [2] - http://www.anandtech.com/show/8376/intel-disables-tsx-instructions-erratum-found-in-haswell-haswelleep-broadwelly http://www.anandtech.com/show/8376/intel-disables-tsx-instru...
- msoad 10y agoThe fanless CPUs and USB-C ports on top of new monitors made this iteration a bit longer but wait for it. Some cool computers are coming out of Apple very soon. I haven't seen them but every Apple employee I talk to seems to be very excited about them. They also have a ridiculously large track pad with better palm rejection
- ryanmarsh 10y agoI just dropped off my 15" rMBP for service. The work order showed the purchase date: May 2013. Wow. It's an i7 w/ 16GB RAM and an SSD. I had no idea it was that old but I'm a little surprised the specs don't feel that outdated. I mean, don't get me wrong. If I were to replace it I don't want to pay top dollar for old hardware. Makes me wonder if has something brewing the the desktop space.
- PebblesHD 10y agoI'm still using a Mid-2012 Retina 15" Pro, which I upgraded significantly when purchasing. It was plenty of power to crunch database reports and compile my code then and its still one of the most powerful laptops available. I don't see a reason to get rid of it until either a significant jump in processing power or some massing improvement in other hardware, until then my Quad core 2.6GHz lasts 9hrs on a charge and runs every piece of software imaginable without skipping a beat.
- vbs_redlof 10y ago9 hrs is a massive stretch. I'm lucky to get 4~5hrs on a single charge.
- PebblesHD 10y agoReally depends what I'm doing, if I'm just on Cisco remote it lasts all day and more, but if I open Outlook it goes in 6 hours or less. Worse if the GPU fires up, then its maybe 3...
- sengork 10y agoThis is the 'Good Enough' inflection point, much the same as with PCs (minus the gaming and virtualisation crowds).
- xf00ba7 10y agoYou know, I've had Mac's that well...I have no idea when they'll die. They're all still going. My Apple IIlc is in fact still kicking. I have a 2007 MBP that runs like a champ (well, swapped in a SSD, but other than that...). The OS might have some features that make it tough for bleeding edge developers...but you know, for the most part people need those features (security, etc.). The Dell and Sony laptops I've had just don't hold up to constant use. Lenovo on the other hand was a different story. I loved their keyboards and the build quality is quite good, equivalent to Apple. Style though, until recently hasn't quite been up to the fruit standards.
- uptown 10y agoStill using an early 2011 MBP. Replaced the drive with an SSD on day one, and have since swapped out the DVD with a 1tb hard drive. Upgraded the RAM and it works well for its age, but it's had its main board replaced as part of the 2011 video card recall and it's definitely got some issues that would benefit from a clean install of OSX. I'm a buyer of their refreshed MBP ... whenever that comes to market.
- adventured 10y agoMac sales were down 11.5% in the latest quarter. Apple knows where that's heading: their Mac business will get cut in half from 2015 to 2021 or so. Few businesses are going to be interested in investing into regular updates to a segment that is being significantly reduced in size. More likely, Apple will cut how many PC models / variations they sell, and the business will slowly fade until it's a nearly meaningless portion of their business. In ten years the traditional PC market will be 3/4 smaller than it was at the peak a few years ago, and that drop will go the same for the Mac.
- akeck 10y agoApple "should" sell hardware people will buy, since they are a hardware company. I'm about to buy one of these laptops. It's fast enough for web coding, organizing photos, Darktable processing, and Inkscape. I'm mostly space constrained vs. CPU constrained. The standard-form-factor SSD in "101" model, and its replaceable RAM, means I'll be able to get 6-8 years out of it. I'm currently using a 2009 Macbook Pro that I upgraded to 8GB of RAM, when one of the original DIMMs died. That type of fixability isn't available in newer Apple gear.
- cdysthe 10y agoGood thing Apple price these relics competitively. They don't?
- jrnichols 10y agoI've been getting more and more life out of my Apple stuff. For example, my early 13" 2011 MacBook Pro (2.3 GHz i5, 8gb RAM) feels like a much newer machine now that I replaced the spinning disk with an SSD. For what I'm doing with it, things are great. I have the feeling that macOS Sierra will be the last OS X version that will run on it, though. At that point, I might finally do an upgrade, which I plan to keep for a 5 year cycle if at all possible.
- slantyyz 10y ago>> I've been getting more and more life out of my Apple stuff. The thing is, your next upgrade is probably going to involve a device with soldered on memory and a chassis that isn't as conducive to end-user hardware upgrades as the model you have. The upgradability gravy train pretty much ended with the 2012 unibody models. The only way you can maximize the life of your next purchase is to buy the maximum spec'ed machine. Doesn't sound like a problem, but maxing out an Apple BTO machine gets expensive fast. I thought my 2011 15" MBP would still be my main machine today (the specs still hold up today), except mine was one of the models that had the overheating GPUs and it got bricked and stopped booting. It wasn't until after I switched to a Windows laptop that Apple finally acknowledged the problem and issued a repair order. By that time, they had basically lost me as a customer of their computer products.
- jrnichols 10y agoThat is true, but I'm seeing that spreading into the non-Apple world as well. It's as if the industry realized that people just don't do many hardware upgrades to laptops. Desktop space is a whole different story, though. Although the resale value on the Apple stuff seems to hold up a bit. I've had friends upgrade to a newer machine for the price they would have paid for a PC just by selling the old Mac. I suspect that too will slowly change as time goes on. (Was just looking at eBay for example - I could sell the Mac Mini that I have and only had about a $100 loss on it. I bought it almost two years ago now.)
- musgrove 10y agoApple's stuff is still expensive. Putting new components and building newer models will surely raise costs, and prices, which may be something Apple realizes isn't feasible with their target market. I'm a developer/designer and I still had a hard time plopping down what I did for my MBP.
- mark-r 10y agoApple's always been a big proponent of the "shock and awe" product announcement. Since the introduction of Retina displays, has there been anything that would qualify? The small incremental component improvements just don't cut it.
- chenster 10y agoThis is my personal opinion. My Late 2013 MacBook Pro is running so smooth that I have no doubt that I would keep it for at least another 2 to 3 more years before looking into replacing it with another MBP. So In between now and then, why even bother to look for another computer? Apple probably saw the same that users would keep their Apple computer long enough before needed another major replacement to buy new ones every 3 to 5 years or so. IMO, for everyday tasks or even medium-to-high CPU instense tasks, current MBP handles very well, given that you are not a gamer or 3D CG designer. Secondly, for the price you pay, it makes no reason to look into another Mac every or every other year. Serious, the author Sam Byford's 2012 MacBook Pro should be fine running everyday tasks. Mine is only 1 year newer, so if mine running so well, so should his. Admittedly, having SSD makes a HUGE difference in terms of stability and performance. I encourage everyone should have it. Maybe that's what the author's really missing out.
- xbmcuser 10y agoWell people should stop buying it if they don't want apple to sell. As long people are buying why shouldn't they sell it. With every macbook pro made and sold Apple per unit cost keep coming down. It is probably making $100-200 more on each unit then when it first started selling it.
- schuke 10y agoI'm constantly amazed by people's lack of care for the Macbook Air's abysmal TN screen. It's so good to see this being pointed out in this article. But still I can't believe there is no a single mention of TN or IPS on this page!
- bartvk 10y agoFor me, the most important is the resolution, which is 1440x900. Doesn't seem too bad for me, for a 13".
- Philipp__ 10y agoIt's all up to your needs in the end. I am always for more battery and better optimisation than latest and fastest! We are in a weird period in terms of PC hardware. Things settled down and people expect new shiny hardware every year or two. But why? Get used to it, you don't buy latest car model every 2 years. If a machine gets the job done use it to every last bit. Bought rMBP 13" (maxed out) in November and I can see myself using it for 5 years easily! Consumer society is hungry and they want redesign, shiny new specs every year. But those times are 20 years behind us. So just enjoy in your machines... :)
- thallukrish 10y agoI bought a MBP in 2012. The motherboard went bad after a year. And after a year the cable to the hard disk had to be replaced. Also I feel the upgrades we do on OSX causes the MBP to slow down. It is sleek, elegant, battery life is great (actually I need to replace it now, its dying), great design etc. But I feel the more perfect it is designed to be, the more vulnerable it is. I say this when I compare this to my HP pavilion sleekbook which did not have any trouble so far in the last 3 years.
- rbanffy 10y agoI suppose the non-retina MacBook Pro is still made due to some supply agreement with a sufficiently large buyer that wants a specific configuration to be available for a certain period. And, frankly, an indestructible computer that's field upgradable (or upgradable at all) is not a bad proposition. I'd prefer a cheaper one, of course.
- znpy 10y agoI think there is a simple answer for this: Apple is busy doing other stuff (probably figuring out the next market to dive into) and isn't caring that much about 15" rMBP which after all still sells good. Imho Apple will upgrade when sales will slow down below a certain threshold.
- slr555 10y agoThe dearth of Macbook Pro releases may not represent an obstacle or even a nuisance for everyone but for devotees of the Mac such as myself whose work falls under the general rubric of "creative", it presents real challenges. The Mac issue is not necessarily speed (which could mean processor, bus, GPU etc) but isolation. The platform is burdened by I/O options that are not mature or well supported. Things became really challenging when Apple bet on Thunderbolt, which from my non-techie perspective seems to have never gained great acceptance by peripheral makers. By stripping out Firewire and and providing somewhat limited USB 3.0 support Apple really narrowed the universe of mass storage and other peripherals that were viable. Everything that formerly lived happily in the enclosure of a Mac Pro now had to live in a stack near a laptop or new Mac Pro cylinder. The more compact Mac Pro exacerbated workplace sprawl rather than helping it. Macbook Pro models faced the many of the same issues. I have been nursing along an early 2009 Mac Pro, praying is does not have a major component failure because apple has left me as a photographer/videographer out in the cold. While I realize the Intel processor road map has created challenges for Apple, they need to get updated machines into the market or face defection from people like me who have been Mac Zealots since the mid-80's.