17 ms·
Is Earthly life premature from a cosmic perspective?
- jessaustin 10y ago"So then you may ask, why aren't we living in the future next to a low-mass star?" says Loeb. "One possibility is we're premature. Another possibility is that the environment around a low-mass star is hazardous to life." Wow that is some hardcore "anthropic" logic. Is the question really well-posed enough to lead to the latter conclusion?
- ahmedfromtunis 10y agoThis. Sometimes I feel like such out-of-touch-with-reality 'logic' is why a lot a people don't trust science anymore.
- soared 10y agoThis is actually flawed logic.
- whack 10y agoJust because something is non-intuitive doesn't mean it's "out-of-touch-with-reality". Imagine if you go to a bus stop in a completely foreign city/country, and the bus shows up within 1 minute. There are 2 possibilities. Either A) The bus usually takes a very long time to come (30+ minutes) and you just happened to get very lucky, or B) The bus runs at a very frequent interval, so your 1-minute-wait is somewhat normal Statistically, B is much more likely to be true than A. Which is pretty much what the author is alluding to.
- semi-extrinsic 10y ago> Statistically, B is much more likely to be true than A. Which is pretty much what the author is alluding to. This depends entirely on what you mean by "statistically". Having travelled in many cities around the world, I have encountered many bus lines with long intervals, and not that many bus lines with very short intervals, so I would rather say A is statistically more likely than B. Discarding all previous data and then doing statistics is a great way to be wrong often IMO.
- pliny 10y agoYou are using priors to decide that B is more likely than A, that is, you are saying that the frequent bus hypothesis is likely because buses with frequent intervals are common. If the bus shows up within 1 second of your arrival then there can be no discussion of "frequent buses", you were definitely lucky, but only because the prior for buses with frequency of Order-of (1 second) is so low. The analogy here is time-to-life and we have 1 data point for that, not enough to establish credible priors for minimum\mean time-to-life under any circumstances.
- whack 10y agoThe point of the thought experiment is to avoid using any priors. If you have a single data-point of an event E, taking time T to occur, then there are 2 possibilities: A) Event E usually takes much much longer than T (>100T), and what you just witnessed is an anomaly, or B) Event E usually does take roughly time T to occur, and what you witnessed is within the range of what usually occurs. Both conclusions have an extremely high likelihood of being wrong, since the sample size is so small. But between the 2, conclusion B is more likely to be true than conclusion A.
- cookingrobot 10y agoSimilar logic has convinced Elon Musk that we're living in a simulation. http://www.newyorker.com/books/joshua-rothman/what-are-the-odds-we-are-living-in-a-computer-simulation http://www.newyorker.com/books/joshua-rothman/what-are-the-o...
- Meegul 10y ago"...chances of life are 1000 times higher in the distant future than now." I still don't see this as a solution to the Fermi paradox, considering the billions (more?) of planets in our galaxy.
- jtolmar 10y agoSimple solution - relativity holds up. Our light cone is much smaller than the galaxy. The universe could be teaming with intelligent life but not so full that you'd expect any to overlap the period where we're both using radio waves to communicate.
- btilly 10y agoThe Milky Way is about 100k light years across. If colonization proceeded at 1% of the speed of light, it would take 10 million years to colonize the galaxy. That is roughly 0.2% of the time that the Earth has existed. And a bit under 2% of the time since the Cambrian that we've had complex life forms. Speed of light is a barrier for intergalactic colonization. It is not a barrier for an advanced civilization trying to colonize a galaxy. Even a relatively large galaxy such as our own.
- sampo 10y ago> Speed of light is a barrier for intergalactic colonization. The distance to Andromeda is about 20x times the diameter of Milky Way. But of course this is massively longer that hopping from a solar system to the next.
- btilly 10y agoRight. There are no intermediate stopping points between the two. And Andromeda is in our local cluster and so close on the scale of the universe. Point of interest, we'll meet Andromeda in about 3 billion years or so. Point of additional interest. Due to the expansion of the universe, it is impossible even in theory to travel to most of the galaxies that we can see. Point of amazement. Our telescopes can pick out more galaxies in the universe than individual stars!
- singularity2001 10y agoI thought the very fact that complex organisms can be traced back to the Archean hints at cosmic origins of live on earth. Also no signs of a 'RNA-world' on this planet?
- dreen 10y agoWasn't there a time for some time after big bang when the space was on average a lot more warm everywhere and conditions for life were incredibly more abundant than now? I remember reading something like this here which would seem to be an antithesis to this article.
- jessriedel 10y agoI think you must be referring to this: > The "Dark Ages" span a period during which the temperature of cosmic background radiation cooled from some 4000 K down to about 60 K. The background temperature was between 373 K and 273 K, allowing the possibility of liquid water, during a period of about 7 million years, from about 10 to 17 million after the Big Bang (redshift 137–100). Loeb (2014) speculated that primitive life might in principle have appeared during this window, which he called "the Habitable Epoch of the Early Universe" . https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronology_of_the_universe#Dark_Ages https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronology_of_the_universe#Dar... http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?fromPage=online&aid=9371049&fileId=S1473550414000196 http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?fromPag... Note that the other, Avi Loeb, is the same from the OP article. The cosmological dark ages lasted from photon decoupling (when photons started free streaming and the cosmic microwave background was born) to a few hundred million years later when the first stars begin to form. Loeb's suggestion is a narrow window of a few million years when the CMB itself would be the source of warmth, rather than stars. I'm not sure how matter was distributed on small scales during that time period.
- gojomo 10y agoAnother popular account of the idea (via Loeb) that life (especially simple life) may have been more common earlier: http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/mysteries_of_the_universe/2014/02/what_if_we_ve_misunderstood_our_place_in_the_universe_a_harvard_astronomer.html http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/mysteries_o...
- civilian 10y agoDoes Loeb address whether there would have been oxygen and carbon 10-17 million years after the Big Bang? I thought that the heavier elements formed much later, and had to be forged in the center of stars. Our first generation of stars appeared 560million years after the Big bang. (Reference is the same wiki article you linked)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- egypturnash 10y agoI was idly looking at "age of universe", "age of earth", and "age of life" numbers and wondering something like this just the other day. The universe is only about 3x as old as life on Earth, and we've just barely gotten to the point where we can make noise nearby worlds can conceivably hear. Radio's a hundred years old. That's nothing on those time scales. Look at this diagram of the size of the space that could pick up on our radio broadcasts with regards to the Milky Way: http://www.planetary.org/blogs/emily-lakdawalla/2012/3390.html http://www.planetary.org/blogs/emily-lakdawalla/2012/3390.ht... If we get at all pessimistic about the likelihood of life happening, it doesn't feel like much of a stretch to imagine that we are some of the first ones. I would love to be proven wrong in this by having some advanced Elder Race show up and try to help us get out of this short-sighted, self-destrictive capitalist spiral we're in, but I'm not gonna hold my breath.
- mablap 10y agoIf we assume that life is common enough* that it will evolve independently multiple times in the future, then the chance we are "the first" is closer to that of being "the last", unless you have a convincing prior I'm unaware of. So it should be a pretty low probability. Don't you think? *Common in the sense of "easy enough to create", i.e. the macrostate corresponding to "life" can be made up of a very large number of microstates.
- Houshalter 10y agoThe first intelligent life to evolve will be able to colonize it's entire galaxy in a relatively short amount of time. The fact that Earth hasn't been colonized is pretty strong evidence to me that we are the first. To me at least. Even if aliens chose to leave Earth alone for some strange reason, we still haven't observed any evidence of aliens elsewhere. No dyson spheres, no signals from space, no stars arranged in perfect geometrical patterns. Let alone visits from aliens, either to help us or hurt us.
- mablap 10y agoWoah there, how do you support your first claim? The Milky Way is about 100K light years in diameter.
- DannyB2 10y ago> Stars larger than about three times the sun's mass > will expire before life has a chance to evolve. Protip: if you are looking to hide the existence of your civilization, a good place would be in the vicinity of one of these.
- Aelinsaar 10y agoDefinitely. No need to be worried about what orientation you are in relation to a hypothetical observer either. Then again, you could sit in a molecular cloud, or near something really exotic like a neutron star of some variety to REALLY hide over longer time scales.
- fastaguy88 10y agoIf I were reviewing this paper, I would be quite surprised that there is no mention of how long it took life to emerge on Earth after there was liquid water. While the earth is around 4.6 By old, my understanding was that liquid water was not present until about 3.8 Bya, and that life probably emerged in the by 3.5 Bya. So, 300 million years for life to emerge in on Earth with liquid water. I realize it's only one data point, but it seems like it should inform the probability calculation.
- antognini 10y agoFor some context, Avi Loeb has a certain ... reputation in the astrophysics community. He's a super smart guy, but he has a habit of writing a ton of short, very speculative papers. One gets the impression that he's throwing a lot of ideas out there and seeing what sticks. It can be as valid a strategy in astronomy as in the startup world, but the downside is that it can be hard to believe anything he writes. As far as this paper goes, the most interesting implication isn't mentioned in the phys.org article. It seems to me that main idea of the paper is to connect the development of life to the cosmological evolution of the universe. We find that we live in a somewhat special time, when the universe is just starting to be dominated by dark energy after having been dominated by matter since ~300,000 years after the big bang. Anytime you see that we live at some sort of a special time, the Copernican principle leads one to wonder if there is some underlying reason for this. The main argument of this paper is that as the universe becomes more dominated by dark energy, the expansion of the universe accelerates and this shuts off the flow of gas onto galaxies. As galaxies stop accreting matter, star formation slows, making it less likely that life will develop in the far future. However, low mass stars are more abundant and have a longer lifetime, so even if it takes a longer time for life to evolve in that environment, it's still, on balance, more likely that life evolves around low mass stars in the near future ("near" still being tens to hundreds of billions of years). So we would expect that the typical life form will evolve around a low mass star, far in the future. Thus, life on Earth seems to have developed early, but maybe not unusually so, and it's maybe not a coincidence that we happen to live a little after the time at which the universe became dark energy dominated. I would file this away in the "interesting if true" category.
- antisthenes 10y ago> so even if it takes a longer time for life to evolve in that environment, it's still, on balance, more likely that life evolves around low mass stars in the near future ("near" still being tens to hundreds of billions of years). So we would expect that the typical life form will evolve around a low mass star, far in the future. I find that premise to be false, given our (limited) knowledge about exoplanets already. The limited Goldilocks zone for low mass stars usually results in planets being tidally locked, leaving life to develop in narrow bands or in the hostile zones with direct sunlight or lack thereof. Not all exoplanets around faint stars may be tidally locked, but with increasing distance it also pushes them out to the limits, where there may not be enough energy for life to develop (at near freezing ocean temperatures) With more information we may find that perhaps there's also an optimal star brightness, which provides just enough energy at just the right distance for life to develop, disqualifying most dwarf stars. In either case, whatever you believe, given our extremely limited information, any papers produced can be labeled as speculative, especially when we're talking about something where N = 1.
- themgt 10y agoWhat seems to me obvious if one looks at: a) the age of the universe b) the age of the earth c) the age of life on earth d) the age of aware-enough-to-look-at-stars-and-wonder-about-aliens life on earth Is that life itself is relatively "easy" and is likely to be common. It seems more likely to me that the crucial "filter(s)" are for a species of lifeforms to cross the boundary into a global, technological civilization. There appear to be very unique, perhaps somewhat accidental set of circumstances that led to homo sapiens crossing that rubicon that aren't just evolution doing a "dial intelligence to 11", but more about an ability for intelligent individuals to share and store their thoughts and build shared abstractions and culture over periods much longer than individual lifetimes (e.g. capability for complex vocalizations and extremely precise control with hands and fingers; not living in water)
- marcosdumay 10y ago> Is that life itself is relatively "easy" and is likely to be common. It's either that, or life is so hard that it can only appear during a short time-span.
- jseliger 10y agoIs that life itself is relatively "easy" and is likely to be common. Life appears common, but multicellular life appears to be extremely uncommon and appears to have evolved only once on earth, at least according to Nick Lane's excellent (though inadvertently depressing) book The Vital Question: Energy, Evolution, and the Origins of Complex Life (https://www.amazon.com/Vital-Question-Evolution-Origins-Complex/dp/0393088812?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=390957&linkCode=as2&tag=thstsst-20 https://www.amazon.com/Vital-Question-Evolution-Origins-Comp...). I can't gauge the accuracy of his claims but the book does not appear to have been rebutted, at least from what I've found. Given all the discussion about biology on this thread I'm surprised no one else has mentioned it.
- derekp7 10y agoAlso, as far as we know, single-celled life also evolved exactly once. This is one thing I haven't seen a good answer for -- if life came about so early, that would indicate that it is easy. But since it occurred only once, that would indicate that it is hard. The common explanation is that once life evolved and began to spread, that it would prevent other life from appearing by out-competing it. But there is plenty of raw materials and sunlight to go around, so I don't buy that explanation. The only thing that seems to fit, is that life is hard to evolve, but has extra-terrestrial origin. If that is the case then life should exist (at least in bacterial form) wherever a suitable habitat is found.
- danieltillett 10y agoThe big argument against intelligent life being common (and us not being unique) is the existence of stars. No civilization more advanced than us is going to let stupendous amounts of energy go to waste in the form of star light. If you assume von Neumann probes and Dyson spheres are possible, then star light is incompatible with the existence of advanced technology. While life appeared very early in the history of the earth, technologically advanced life took billions of years to evolve. You require a planet with an extraordinarily stable climate to allow a technological society to evolve and I predict this is the filter. Just one factor contributing to this stability is the need for a very large moon to keep the axis of rotation stable over billion of years. If the Earth didn't have its moon the Earth's axis would tip over creating massive climatic change. The more we look at the universe the more unlikely the stability of Earth's climate looks.
- mixmastamyk 10y ago> the need for a very large moon to keep the axis of rotation stable First I've heard of this, do you have any more information?
- danieltillett 10y agoYes there is lots of information on this out there [1-3]. Really the moon is very, very, very unusual. 1. http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v361/n6413/abs/361615a0.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v361/n6413/abs/361615a0... 2. http://www.astrobio.net/news-exclusive/the-odds-for-life-on-a-moonless-earth/ http://www.astrobio.net/news-exclusive/the-odds-for-life-on-... 3. http://www.space.com/12464-earth-moon-unique-solar-system-universe.html http://www.space.com/12464-earth-moon-unique-solar-system-un...
- Falcon9 10y agoFrom what little I understand, a Dyson Sphere would require so much material in terms of heavy elements that you'd have a great deal of trouble building a significant number of them even if you were raiding the entire universe for these materials. But like I said, I understand very little (and would love clarification).
- dannylandau 10y agoVery recent video profile on Avi -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SKLMXdZNmZk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SKLMXdZNmZk
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoThe universe may only be 20B years old. It takes our galaxy 250M years to rotate once. So the universe is only something like 80 galactic years (days?) old. It is still early innings.