24 ms·
The U.S. Navy’s Big Mistake: Building Tons of Supercarriers
- hackuser 10y agoOn a purely temporal level: The aircraft carrier became the dominant naval warfare tech in 1942, 74 years ago. 74 years before that was just after the U.S. Civil War. I wonder how many Civil War technologies remained dominant in WWII; probably not much in the navy. Now that is a very flawed, simplistic comparison. But it makes me wonder if aircraft carriers are obsolete and we just don't know it yet because there hasn't been a naval war since then. And it makes me wonder about other technologies, such as tanks and fighter planes. Many of the technologies used seem to be modernizations of what was used in the last large war, which ended in 1945. Did innovation stop then? Remember how quickly things changed in around 25 years between WWI and WWII: Tanks, planes, and aircraft carriers, to name a few, either didn't exist or were insignificant in WWI, and WWII ended with bombers dropping nuclear weapons (another platform and strategy still in use today).
- drdeadringer 10y agoArguably, the submarine survives even today from the Civil War. Other than that, I agree that that's pretty much it.
- yareally 10y agoHave to go back about another 100 years before the American Civil War for military useage of submarines. Also, rifled bullets/artillery shells, breech loading rifles, cartriges and semi automatic (repeating) rifles first came in mass use during the American Civil War. Trench/defensive warfare was also adopted towards the end of the war for some of the major seiges (Petersburg for example). There's other examples I could list, but I would say it's an understatement to say that the only direct use of 18th to 19th Century weaponary we still use to day is subs. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turtle_(submersible) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turtle_(submersible) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nautilus_(1800_submarine) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nautilus_(1800_submarine) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spencer_repeating_rifle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spencer_repeating_rifle
- ktRolster 10y agoThe iron-clad.
- vacri 10y agoTrench warfare well pre-dates the US civil war. They were used at least as far back as the War of the Spanish Succession (1700s). The Maori also used trenches when fighting against the British, two decades before the US civil war.
- logfromblammo 10y agoVauban [0] designed his first handbook for trench warfare after the Siege of Maastricht in 1673. Prior to that, siege mining and sapping had been used by Rome and Warring States China since about the 4th century BCE. This also marked the first purported use of poison gas in warfare, when the tunnels were intentionally filled with smoke. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S%C3%A9bastien_Le_Prestre_de_Vauban https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S%C3%A9bastien_Le_Prestre_de_V...
- linkregister 10y agoCivil War technologies that persisted to WW2 and beyond: the rifle, trench warfare, howitzers, battlefield surgery. I agree in general with the article (the tl;dr being that carriers are extremely vulnerable to asymmetrically small threats). It omits the reason the U.S. Navy employs them in the first place: force projection. Without a carrier group, an overseas nation has no credible opportunity to bombard a far away theater, engage in air sorties, land troops, or any other expeditionary action. Defense of carriers is a problem that must be solved, or the U.S. would have to accept a military stalemate for naval warfare. This has serious strategic, diplomatic, and economic consequences. Many countries' posturing depends on the U.S. Navy's implied or explicit protection.
- Retric 10y agoIn air refueling lets counties drop bombs on the other side of the planet. Aircraft carriers are cheaper but that assumes they are not sitting ducks and we can't find a friendly airfield somewhere.
- newjersey 10y ago> Aircraft carriers are cheaper but that assumes they are not sitting ducks and we can't find a friendly airfield somewhere. This is probably incredibly naïve but wouldn't it help us get a "friendly" airfield if we could say something like "you can allow us to use your airfield or we will move in our ships in N hours anyway". Am I missing something here?
- Retra 10y agoAre you suggesting that it is acceptable to force neutral parties into a war? Or are you trying to negotiate with your enemies for the right to bomb them? I'm not sure I say any reasonable interpretation of that proposal.
- burfog 10y agoIt's been done many times. The UK grabbed Iceland in WWII, providing a base for transfer of US aircraft. Germany took a trip through Belgium and got the Swiss to allow trains through. When things get serious, thoughts like "I would never do such a thing!" are quickly cast aside.
- andyjdavis 10y ago>But it makes me wonder if aircraft carriers are obsolete It is not quite the same as being obsolete but I suspect that they are far more vulnerable than we realize. Every day missiles get both technically better (faster, longer range, harder to detect) but also cheaper making it more affordable for someone to acquire ever larger stockpiles of them for deployment en masse. Meanwhile developing countermeasures that can deal with barrages of incoming missiles that are getting progressively more numerous and faster seems like a very difficult, expensive proposition.
- mcphage 10y ago> But it makes me wonder if aircraft carriers are obsolete and we just don't know it yet because there hasn't been a naval war since then That's what the article is about. Well, that they're obsolete, and also that they're incredibly expensive.
- osivertsson 10y agoI agree that aircraft carriers, tanks, and fighter planes are obsolete in some sense. They fit badly with todays conflicts. Thankfully many engineers don't want to work with innovation in this space. We don't have the global notion in society of competing for resources required for survival against other nations anymore, which would have been a strong motivator in the past.
- vlehto 10y agoIt's not about engineers. The theory of international relations still maintain that diplomacy between nations is essentially anarchy. The reason why the seven seas are so peaceful today is that the top dog (U.S.) has been favorable to free trade. The reason why regular citizen doesn't have that "global notion of society competing for resources" is twofold: A free trade works. B pax Americana related propaganda has been broadcasted for what, 7 decades now.
- knodi123 10y ago> : The aircraft carrier became the dominant naval warfare tech in 1942, 74 years ago. 74 years before that was just after the U.S. Civil War. I wonder how many Civil War technologies remained dominant in WWII; probably not much in the navy. Fighter planes are that old too. And machine guns, and grenades, and even night vision goggles. But the aircraft carrier of today is very different from the aircraft carriers of WW2, and so is the rest of that equipment. Except the grenade.
- hollerith 10y agoThe M2 50-calibre machine gun is still very heavily used by the US Army and the US Navy and is a WW II-era design. In fact, I think a lot of the M2 currently in use were manufactured during WW II.
- gumby 10y ago> I wonder how many Civil War technologies remained dominant in WWII; probably not much in the navy. The US civil war was not a particularly maritime war, so indeed not much in the navy. But that war pioneered two interesting logistical elements: first, it was the first war to permit rapid movement of material via rail (a surprising amount of rail was constructed during the war). Second is that it was the first economy vs economy war. By and large the Europeans ignored the lesson, because they figured the details of what was going on in the US just weren't that interesting (big mistake). WWI was an economy-vs-economy and rail war (one problem is that both sides built rail heads to their fronts, so if they could move forward they couldn't supply their new front while the enemy could). The only European power that paid attention was Russia who therefore chose another rail gauge. WWII was economy-vs-economy on a global scale: the US poured huge sums (mostly in kind) into the UK & the Soviet Union so Germany had to battle a large economy on both sides. In the Pacific the trigger for Pearl Harbor was the US cutting off Japanese access to raw materials (what are bizarrely called "sanctions" today) in the hope of ending prior Japanese aggression in Korea and Manchuria: again, economic struggle. Big Napoleonic set piece field battles and ship-of-the-line battles appear to have faded into history, but most of the military spending in the US, Russia and China seems to continue to focus on that obsolete model. These carriers and attack subs aren't that useful in the asymmetric fronts we have today. By the way another good lesson was the American Revolution, which was mostly won via lobbying/payments in Whitehall. Both sides have conveniently ignored that for their own political reasons :-)
- andyjdavis 10y ago>In the Pacific the trigger for Pearl Harbor was the US cutting off Japanese access to raw materials (what are bizarrely called "sanctions" today) in the hope of ending prior Japanese aggression in Korea and Manchuria: again, economic struggle. Building on your point about WWII being economy Vs economy and the economic underpinnings of the war in the Pacific, I have a memory of reading a similarly economics-centric analysis of the start of the war in Europe. I do not have a link but from memory Germany had insufficient farmland relative to its population and little access to important resources, especially oil. This set them up to be dependent on their neighbors indefinitely, neighbors who could turn off the food/oil tap at any time. That was not an appealing idea to the Nazis. Not sure how well accepted that theory is or isn't but it certainly seems to hold a lot more credence than "the war in Europe started because Hitler."
- philwelch 10y agoIronclad, steam-powered ships? Another good counter argument is that there were lots of wars between the US Civil War and World War II between first-class opponents of relatively similar capabilities, including both of those conflicts, World War I, the Franco-Prussian and Russo-Japanese wars. Since World War II, only arguably has the Korean War pitted two relatively equal foes against each other, and even then China had a huge advantage in manpower while the UN forces had a huge technological advantage. If the NBA was dissolved and Golden State periodically faced college teams, 75 years from now they would probably still have a small-ball 3-point-shooting lineup. That's the state of military doctrine today. Outright defeating a nearly-equal opponent is impossible in the nuclear age, so the only remaining problem is how to curb-stomp much weaker opponents as humanely as possible.
- cinquemb 10y agoAlso in between the time period you mention, and arguably still true today is the varying tactics that are used in war even with opponents of equal numbers of forces/capabilities on paper. If one side couldn't sufficiently protect its population (economy), that could be used to coerce an end on favorable terms to the other side. >Outright defeating a nearly-equal opponent is impossible in the nuclear age, so the only remaining problem is how to curb-stomp much weaker opponents as humanely as possible. I think this is true as of today, but I don't know if this will remain true in the future because people will still seek out the ability to apply asymmetric means on another all else being equal, in ways that would probably be hard to combat. However, such would depend on how one defines what such outright defeat would look like and I posit that the closer that one defines that with something that doesn't look like what usually is conjured up in minds when war is brought up, the more successful one is probably going to be (assuming one would want wage war to achieve some ends and is open to the option of winning such without leaving any trail of bodies in the wake). Not a question for you, but for everyone who's interested, but what would outright defeat look like in the cyber-warfare today and tomorrow as the domain considered to be cyberspace continually expands to compose how we relate with one another and the world, where there will be economic incentive to place nanomachines in living organisms (things that "we" are doing now in research labs) that can communicate/execute complex logic manifested in the behavior of said organisms orders of magnitude faster than humans can even perceive (and have a really hard time even finding/observing now with the most expensive of equipment)?
- bane 10y agoCarriers are obsolete, but very few nations can field the weaponry needed to kill one reliably. > And it makes me wonder about other technologies, such as tanks In the current, more urban, modern war, tanks were actually demonstrated to be pretty useless. I once spoke to a veteran of the Iraq war who mentioned the thousands of tanks in country sitting useless because they couldn't really be used in a city. Turrets too long, too slow, too easy to disable, big slow moving metal boxes. The military tried to use Bradleys instead, but they were also far too slow and prone to ambush. Thousands also sat mostly unused. The workhorse for years was the so called "uparmored" Humvee (HMMWV), a beast totally unsuited to its task, but just about fast enough, and just about able to be A-Team MacGuyvered into a suitable urban assault rig. The "big armor" was the Stryker, which was designed to be armored, armed and fast. But by the end of the war was surrounded in anti-RPG cages so wide they could barely fit down a major road. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/35/Stryker_25th_ID_Iraq_DF-SD-05-12693.JPEG https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/35/Stryker_... However, all of these were fairly useless against IEDs and nobody quite knows what the next workhorse armored vehicle is going to be, but I believe they're probably going to be something out of the MRAP program. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MRAP https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MRAP The Humvee is being replaced by 2 or 3 purpose built vehicles. Important to this is that all of the vehicles are built using lessons learned during a very long, mostly urban war. The next time a war starts out in vast open plains, the tanks will probably come into their own again, but to be honest, lots of their mission has been taken over by a variety of flying platforms that can deliver payload more reliably and at less risk.
- lmm 10y ago> it makes me wonder if aircraft carriers are obsolete and we just don't know it yet because there hasn't been a naval war since then. Aircraft carriers probably made the difference in the Falklands war. > Tanks, planes, and aircraft carriers, to name a few, either didn't exist or were insignificant in WWI Tanks played a critical role in the closing years of WWI. Planes were significant (though for reconnaissance rather than attack). > WWII ended with bombers dropping nuclear weapons (another platform and strategy still in use today). Bombers dropping nuclear weapons is barely a strategy that exists today. Some countries retain the capability because if you already have a heavy bomber and a nuclear warhead it doesn't cost a whole lot to make them compatible with each other, but the only serious delivery mechanisms for nuclear weapons are missiles.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y ago>the only serious delivery mechanisms for nuclear weapons are missiles. And merchant ships docked in your enemy's ports. And trucks. And terrorists. WWIII will start as a cyberwar. Western systems of all kinds are insanely vulnerable to cyberattack. You may not be able to force a Western country to surrender by bringing down its banking and civilian comms systems, but you can certainly make it much less able to fight any other kind of war. How much money is being spent on cyberdefences?
- mcv 10y ago> Aircraft carriers probably made the difference in the Falklands war. British carriers are much smaller and cheaper than American supercarriers, though.
- lmm 10y agoTrue - although I've also seen soldiers claim that full-size carriers would have been much more useful, and perhaps that the invasion would not have happened if Britain had still been operating the Ark Royal. (Most immediately the sinking of HMS Sheffield might have gone quite differently if the British had been capable of operating fixed-wing AWACS)
- spacecowboy_lon 10y agoAsk the RN if they think carriers are obsolete given their experience in the Falklands war. And no having planes flying in form half a content away is not the same as having local assets.
- twic 10y agoDuring the Falklands war, we didn't have very good naval SAMs worth tuppence - the obsolete Sea Slug, and the then-modern Sea Dart, which still wasn't all that good: 40 mile range, can't hit anything below 30 metres altitude, such as sea-skimming missiles, or even low-flying aircraft. We now have Aster 30, which has a range of 120 miles, and can hit supersonic sea-skimmers, ballistic missiles, anything you like. Those ranges are still much shorter than the ~500 mile combat radius of a Sea Harrier or an F-35B, admittedly. But since destroyers are a third the price of a carrier, you can have several and spread them out.
- eru 10y agoMilitary change tends to be quicker when hot wars are fought. We haven't seen much of that in the last few decades. (Comparatively.) From a historic perspective, http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/books/bookreviews/11773582/Why-Did-Europe-Conquer-the-World-by-Philip-T-Hoffman-review-a-strong-case.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/books/bookreviews/1177358... makes similar arguments. But looking at the time from around 1200 to 1914, and comparing Europe with India and China.
- rdtsc 10y ago> Soviet Adm. Sergei Gorchakov reportedly held the view that the U.S. had made a strategic miscalculation by relying on large and increasingly vulnerable aircraft carriers ... In a 1982 congressional hearing, legislators asked him how long American carriers would survive in an actual war. Rickover’s response? “Forty-eight hours,” he said. True. But these carriers are just large jobs programs which also let us bomb poor countries here and there. And of course they look cool as hell. If anyone attacks our carriers in large numbers they'll also be the target of our nuclear missiles. So in a way our conventional weapons have to just look cool on paper and be usable against 3rd world countries (that is why A-10 is still in use even though Russian tanks have long stopped being vulnerable to them. But groups of farmers with AK-47s are still blown to bits easily). If Chinese or Russians launch their ballistic anti-ship missiles at these carriers, soon they'll be seen ballistic missiles flying at their mainland, coming from some place in Nebraska probably.
- mcphage 10y ago> If Chinese or Russians launch their ballistic anti-ship missiles at these carriers, soon they'll be seen ballistic missiles flying at their mainland, coming from some place in Nebraska probably. I mean, sure, but if they're going to be destroyed quickly anyway (as you admit), then why are spending so much money on them?
- rdtsc 10y agoAs I pointed out it is a jobs program, they look cool, and they let us "project power". Meaning we park it by Afghanistan and launch fighters to bomb stuff on the ground. Or go and "indimidate" the Chinese in their disputed naval territories. Not that we don't already have enough bases around the world, but it is nice to have a floating base. Jobs programs is not a joke. If you know anyone from a town with a military contractor facilities or a large base, those bring money into local economy. Congresspeople will go to great legths to ensure military buys more of whatever brings in jobs and cash back where they are from. Here is an example: http://www.military.com/daily-news/2016/02/11/ohio-wins-again-in-armys-budget-for-more-m1-abrams-tanks.html http://www.military.com/daily-news/2016/02/11/ohio-wins-agai... nobody needs more tanks, they are just hadning that over to Lima, Ohio so people there have jobs. Yeah we want to be able to maintain the tanks and all but that is just the official spin and justification. If they can do it for tanks, you be they do it for other, bigger toys.
- 6nf 10y agoSupercarriers are good value for money compared to fighter jets or submarines. The three new Ford class carriers will cost around $30 billion total. Compared to the estimated 1 trillion spent on the F-35 that's peanuts. Virginia class attack subs are 2.6 billion each, and the US navy wants 50 of them.
- meric 10y agoAircraft carriers require planes on them. A Ford-class aircraft carrier can carry 75 planes.
- burfog 10y agoThe ship is as cheap as roughly 40 planes. In other words, we shouldn't be terribly concerned about the cost of the ship. The ship reduces the distance that the planes fly, thereby increasing aircraft life. If we get 50% more airframe life, it's a win for that alone.
- meric 10y agoYes! If it's worth it to build planes, it's worth it to build a carrier, and if a carrier is going to be built, there's no point unless there are planes also. Planes and carriers go hand in hand.
- PantaloonFlames 10y ago> Supercarriers are good value for money compared to fighter jets Good value? You're comparing the cost of Tennis rackets to tennis balls, which is irrelevant. We either buy both, or neither. As for your arithmetic regarding carriers and subs, that flies in the face of the article. The Ford is now (2015 at time of writing) at $14.5B, and is late. To expect that the Navy delivers 3 of those, for just $15B more.... not realistic. The value of the subs is that they are not vulnerable. According to the article.
- jedc 10y agoFormer US Navy submarine officer here. It is very difficult to attack/destroy a submarine. And it's pretty easy for submarines to attack/kill surface fleets. That's why I've been similarly skeptical of the Navy's heavy reliance / budget for carriers & carrier groups.
- Spooky23 10y agoFascinating analysis, that the authors sort of rebuffed at one point. Carriers are there to project power. China may have catamaran missile boats and Sovremmry destroyers, but guess what? Those ships won't be operating far from Chinese coastal waters. Those "obsolete" carrier battle groups can operate virtually anywhere on the coast of any ocean. And they'll be able to deploy whatever mix of manned and unmanned aircraft they need to.
- kosmic_k 10y agoWere carriers truly obsolete then why is china rapidly building it's own? It already has been building forward operating bases in the South China sea. Why invest in building a new class of ship which they have only recently operated if it was already obsolete.
- nl 10y agoIt’s not hard to come up with quotes from the Chinese showing how much this carrier has to do with national pride instead of military usefulness: “Building aircraft carriers is a symbol of an important nation. It is very necessary,” the China Daily paper quoted Admiral Hu Yanlin as saying earlier this month. “China has the capability to build aircraft carriers and should do so,” he said. If you’re used to reading through DoD propaganda, no matter what country it’s coming from, you see what the admiral is saying here. Here’s my loose translation of what Admiral Hu is getting at: “We don’t actually need a carrier, but it’s part of being one of the big boys so we have to do it, like paying for your kid’s wedding. So we’ll turn out a few of them, but we’re only going to do it when it’s cheap and doesn’t interfere with production of real weapons like the DF-21.” http://exiledonline.com/war-nerd-china-joins-the-yacht-club/ http://exiledonline.com/war-nerd-china-joins-the-yacht-club/
- kosmic_k 10y agoThey may say that, but I cannot fathom building a fully functioning carrier to be cheap by any measure. Chinese planners cannot possible expect for their artificial islands to last long in a conflict. They would be very vulnerable targets for cruise missile strikes from the Philippines, or Vietnam. So long as air power will play a significant part in warfare platforms to bring airpower where ever needed too will play a part.
- rhino369 10y agoPresumably the Navy tests how vulnerable they are to ballistic anti ship weapons and decides it is still worth it. The article sort of ignores the difficulty of hitting a moving ship with a ballistic missile when you don't have direct sight. No way would the carriers be able to operate in the Taiwan straight during a war, but they further off shore and launch air raids. The first steps in any major war would be to blind the other sides offensive radar and satellite capabilities.
- rgbrenner 10y agothe chinese are working on the DF-ZF, a hypersonic glide vehicle... it could search for the supercarrier when it nears the carrier group, and maneuver itself into position to hit it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WU-14 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WU-14 This is the last stage.. it gets launched by a missile like the DF-26 or DF-31: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-26 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-26 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-31 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-31 The DF-31 can hit California from China. So if this works, they could keep a supercarrier out of the pacific ocean with enough of these (assuming they can get an approximate location).
- sickbeard 10y agoNone of this Chinese weapons/aircraft have done any actual combat. Their J-31 (f35 clone) is a terrible at flying
- spacecowboy_lon 10y agoIts not just the CAV its the whole support structure you have to attack / get past - you would have to disable the picket ships and CAP as well and then hit the target which in its self has plenty of Point Defense.
- poof131 10y agoAs a former Navy F/A-18 pilot, I have strong opinions on this and generally agree with the analysis. A few thoughts: 1. The services are building what the defense contractors want to build more than what the war fighters want. Knew a lot of pilots who didn’t like the F-35 and would have preferred more, cheaper planes specialized for specific roles. This defense contractor capture is a big problem. 2. The services waste these ‘big war’ resources on our insurgency campaigns. F/A-18s were about 10k per flight hour and perform worse than platforms such as the Super Tacono[1] when supporting war fighters on the ground. We spent hundreds of billions more than we needed to on the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan because when the game starts everyone wants to play to justify their budgets. Programs such as the Super Tacano were shut down to protect and justify the massive expenditure on fighter jets. Funding for different types of wars needs to go through different sources to prevent this enormous waste of money. 3. I’d be for a submersible carrier that could surface to launch and retrieve drones that act as missile trucks for both air-to-air and strike missions. I wouldn’t go all in on unmanned aircraft though, since I would also assume the possibility of totally denied electronic environment where signals are jammed and space assets are unavailable. 4. To force military leaders to focus on the services and not themselves, I’d support a ban on senior level leadership (O-7 and above) from accepting board seats or contractor / full-time positions with defense contractors. Too many leaders make decisions while in service influenced by their personal outcomes when they get out. This behavior reinforces a system that supports the status quo. Senior leaders have great retirement packages and can do things other than maintain an incestuous relationship with the military-industrial complex. Although sometimes other jobs seem to result in more bad behavior such as pressure to look the other way on Theranos and its questionable product.[2, 3] Does look like their board has gotten a bit better with the only remaining military / diplomat being General Mattis. Glad to see Admiral Roughead and Secretary of State Kissinger are no longer there. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embraer_EMB_314_Super_Tucano https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embraer_EMB_314_Super_Tucano [2] http://www.techinsider.io/emails-theranos-elizabeth-holmes-us-military-2015-12 http://www.techinsider.io/emails-theranos-elizabeth-holmes-u... [3] https://www.theranos.com/leadership https://www.theranos.com/leadership
- gozur88 10y ago>To force military leaders to focus on the services and not themselves, I’d support a ban on senior level leadership (O-7 and above) from accepting board seats or contractor / full-time positions with defense contractors. That is an excellent idea, though I would extend it to cover any senior government leadership revolving into private sector positions in industries they regulated or for which they awarded contracts. There's clearly a conflict of interest, and nobody is going to starve on a senior official's retirement package.
- nickbauman 10y agoTerrible analysis. This is especially funny: Mitchell sank a captured German battleship to prove a point. Except what point are your proving when you destroy a captured ship?
- coredog64 10y agoPrevailing wisdom at the time was that airplanes were toys that could not in any way, shape, or form put enough explosives on target to do anything more than scratch the paint.
- nickbauman 10y agoSo this proves that a carrier is totally vulnerable?
- Hondor 10y agoThe article seems to be saying America's military isn't powerful enough. Is that really a problem for anyone, even America? I thought most of their military was just a byproduct of the military industrial complex and not actually needed for anything.
- hoodoof 10y agoerr, not needed for anything? You should read up on events in the South China Sea. Also pay attention to China's ever growing military and political ambitions. And the increasingly belligerent Russians. A good chunk of that money that sloshed around over the past X years of boomtime ended up in the military, and alot more is going in yet. Resources are getting more scarce and countries are willing to act to secure what they want/need.
- JanezStupar 10y ago> I thought most of their military was just a byproduct of the military industrial complex and not actually needed for anything. Except for upkeeping Bretton Woods, which you know is the accord that made US guarantee safe naval trade routes for everyone in the world. But yeh, beyond that and perhaps upkeeping Pax Americana it is not really used or useful for anythings else. Eventually when Pax Americana runs its course people are going to see what the US military was good for.
- gozur88 10y agoAnother uninformed article from warisboring. At least in this one they don't laughably assert the first ever air attack on a battleship happened at Pearl Harbor. Unless I'm Googling the wrong David W. Wise, the author has never been in uniform and has no actual expertise in naval affairs. Most of the points in the article are regurgitations of dubious headlines ("CBG Never Detects Chinese Sub!"), and x vs y comparisons that don't make sense in isolation. There is, though, a valid question buried in all the war nerd theorizing - what is it, exactly, Americans want their navy to do? Do we still expect to be able to fight a two front war against well armed adversaries? Now that the cold war is over, does it make sense to have alliances in Asia that require large force projection?
- hackuser 10y ago> Now that the cold war is over, does it make sense to have alliances in Asia that require large force projection? Yes, even more now that China is likely to become a 'peer' threat. It's really the U.S.'s only use for a high-end Navy. Also, I agree that War is Boring is sensationalized and ignorant in general. It's heartening to see others have noticed.
- gozur88 10y ago>Yes, even more now that China is likely to become a 'peer' threat. Eh... why? In 1950, with the Soviets bankrolling rebel groups and invasions all over the world you could make the argument countries needed alliances to counterbalance the threat. But today... is it really unreasonable to expect wealthy countries like Japan and Korea to see to their own defense? While I agree at some point China is likely to be just as strong, militarily, as the US, I don't see a compelling US interest in using warships to defend, say, Japan's claim to groups of uninhabited islands in the middle of the South China Sea. To paraphrase Pournelle, I'm happy to be a friend of freedom everywhere, but a guarantor only of my own.
- georgeecollins 10y agoThe problem is that if you don't guarantee the freedom of Taiwan and, more importantly, Japan, those countries may decide that the safer thing to do is to switch sides rather than fight alone. Then you are not facing a peer threat, you are facing a coalition that can plausibly threaten to cut off your naval access in the Western Pacific.
- brooklyndude 10y agoMy understanding is building ships is our jobs programs. Thought that all 50 states had a role in building one ship in the end. Isn't that what war is all about? Boys and testosterone? It's that simple. Boys and toys. Someday we will advance as a society beyond that, but who knows when that will be. Guess one can say, "hey we need this to advance our science, war is the big experimental space." Don't really seeing Elon Musk doing much war planning. He does seem to be getting us to Mars just fine. The amount of $$$s spend building one ship could probably build a heck of a lot of hosptials and universities, all around the world, but guess that would be just kind of boring. There are still many people in my Brooklyn 'hood that can't read and write. Think that would be a far better mission, AKA Education. But just my opinion. Maybe we can do both?
- ForHackernews 10y agoElon Musk is a prime example of boys and toys. Granted, they are toys with more peacetime applications, but don't kid yourself, it's still a testosterone-fueled dick measuring contest. Witness the puerile "mine is bigger" feud with Jeff Bezos/Blue Origin.
- adventured 10y ago> Boys and testosterone? It's that simple. Boys and toys That's impressively sexist. Why are you referring to men as boys, if not for derogatory purposes based solely on their sex? I see that in public forums extremely frequently now, and it's only ever done as a belligerent insult. Here's a historical reality check for you: "European Queens Waged More Wars Than Kings" http://nymag.com/scienceofus/2016/01/european-queens-waged-more-wars-than-kings.html http://nymag.com/scienceofus/2016/01/european-queens-waged-m...
- woodman 10y ago> Isn't that what war is all about? Boys and testosterone? It's that simple. Boys and toys. I have to assume that you aren't even half seriously suggesting this. What about all the war that happened during the majority of man's existence, when the "toy" was a sharp stick? Sure you had the odd technological mismatch at the onset of ${metal} age, but the majority of the time both sides had the same rocks and sticks.
- mozumder 10y agoI don't know why all military ships aren't submarines, from aircraft carriers on down..
- vlehto 10y agoIt's mostly about radar masts. If you wish to shoot down enemy missiles with your missiles, you better do it early than late. Now to have some early warning, that antenna needs to be relatively high to get significant area inside your radar horizon. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radar_horizon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radar_horizon But I have no idea if that is smart thing to try anymore.
- funthree 10y agoI would like to comment on this but my account was killed. I said something in favor of the German ethnic group in a comment thread. I guess it was deemed too right of the far left attitude on HN. As a German-Jew I feel like I've been unfairly bullied. I was just trying to level the world out. If you're a mod please fix my account. I have a good geopolitical understanding to provide to this thread, but what's the point if my account is dead or I make a new one and get it killed?
- alricb 10y agoIndeed, it's a mistake, but the solution isn't military, it's political; to ensure its safety, the US must promote disarmament on a global scale, with Russia and China, but including itself.
- kosmic_k 10y agoThe problem is that the same massive range of area denial weapons and cruise missiles also puts fixed assets such as airstrips and bases as far as Guam in jeopardy of attack. Thus there is the problem of how do you get platforms capable of delivering payloads onto your adversary. Carrier's are efficient at that. Unlike fixed bases, they're far more difficult to track and hit. They can launch a large number of aircraft which can hit a larger number of targets with stand off munitions. Drones can be used to delivery, although it is worth noting that most modern cruise missiles effectively are drones themselves with a several hundred pound warhead. The author completely ignores China's increasingly sophisticated anti-submarine underwater listening network. Just how stealthy are our submarines in comparison to the detection capability of a potential adversary? Furthermore how long with a submarine stay hidden after launching a cruise missile attack? If we're to assume that the range places it within the sphere of A2/AD then it would be just as vulnerable as a surface ship after attacking. Which then begs the question of how do you deliver payloads? You could opt to instead rely on munitions which can be launched for farther away, but such munitions certainly would be more costly. I would think that the optimal solution in respect to limited resources would be some mix of long range munitions to counter area denial capability followed by the deployment of shorter ranged assets. But that's just my 5cent as an enthusiast who doesn't actually have any professional experience in the matter. Although from what I read about the author, it appears we're on similar footing in that regard.
- akiselev 10y ago》 The author completely ignores China's increasingly sophisticated anti-submarine underwater listening network. Just how stealthy are our submarines in comparison to the detection capability of a potential adversary? Our nuclear submarines would probably be easily tracked with their "listening network" (I don't know anything about it) but diesel-electric submarines, which seem to be making a resurgence although not with the pro-nuclear forces in the navy, are far quieter and harder to detect. Combine that with the sound matting being develop for next gen subs and/or titanium hulls like Russia used to make, and you've got a very formidable submarine capable of high speed travel which will be very hard to detect with passive or active sonar.
- 10y ago
- partycoder 10y agoWell, once space launches get cheaper, one significant way of projecting power is: space. You can just drop a metal rod from space and cause significant damage (see "rod of god").
- fooey 10y agoSeems to me, all the countries capable of taking out US carriers are powerful enough that if a war actually broke out, it's the sort of end of the world scenario where losing a few boats will be the least of our worries. When the nukes start flying, who cares how many knights each side had? The carriers are for suppressing the parts of the world who are incapable of threatening them. Most of the military is completely irrelevant if there's ever another world scale conflict.
- ethbro 10y agoAh, but there's the rub. If you have nukes and your opponent has nukes, and your opponent tells you they will use their nukes if you use yours, when do you use your nukes? Probably to prevent core territorial incursion to the extent it would dissolve you as a viable entity. But to protect / secure the South China Sea? To win a proxy war in the Middle East? Where's the line? Because it's certainly not "as soon as hostilities break out."
- Snargorf 10y agoIf there ever was a major war between civilized nuclear powers, and it didn't immediately go nuclear, we might end up with a weird sort of gentleman's agreement where it's accepted to fire nukes into your own country (at invading enemy forces) but not at another country. I can see that being an evolutionarily stable strategy.
- manachar 10y agoI would think that a cold war situation is far more likely. No reason to use nukes in your own territory, many very good reasons to not use nukes at all. So long as the early warning systems (i.e. satellites) are still in place we will probably assume that the other side would rather avoid irradiating their own territory and prefer other aggressive tactics.
- ethbro 10y agoMy extremely boiled down version of the MAD calculus was that one was only required to use nuclear weapons if one's capability to use sufficient nuclear weapons at some future point in time were being lost. Hence the Cuban missile crisis being such a big deal.
- hoodoof 10y agoWars are won by the countries that have the largest manufacturing capacity. This is what happened in World War 2 - the American and Russian manufacturing capacity overwhelmed that of the Germans and Japanese.
- andrewstuart2 10y agoWell, that and the two nuclear bombs.
- hoodoof 10y agoJapan's military power was broken before the bombs were dropped.
- vkou 10y agoThe war was won at that point - the only question was how long it would take to win it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bayesian_horse 10y agoThere's much controversy whether the decision to surrender was reached with knowledge of the bombs or before.
- Nokinside 10y agoThat was true in the WW2. Access to energy being another big factor. Germany and Japan were essentially cut off from oil. There will never be major conflict between nuclear powers where decisive victory is possible. There can only be limited regional conflicts that are won or lost. If the stakes become higher than that, it will be tie or everybody loses. The idea that US, Russia or China could surrender is not reality.
- falsedan 10y agoReminds me of a Lewis Page (of The Register ca. 2010) rant against UK military waste. His book's worth a read [0]. [0] https://www.amazon.co.uk/Lions-Donkeys-Dinosaurs-Blundering-Military/dp/0099484420 https://www.amazon.co.uk/Lions-Donkeys-Dinosaurs-Blundering-...
- fiatmoney 10y agoUS defense doctrine mostly revolves around massive surprise first strikes on countries with limited ability to retaliate. Aircraft carriers are OK at this, if you want to, eg, bomb the crap out of Uruguay and don't have basing or transit rights nearby. That doesn't eliminate their vulnerabilities or the cost/benefit ratio, but having a few is handy if you're running a global empire.
- argonaut 10y agoI don't think this describes US defense doctrine. America has not launched a massive surprise first strike in a very long time (if ever). Iraq and Afghanistan knew the invasion was coming a long way off. To me, US defense doctrine relies on 1) massive logistical power projection capability to counter any terrorism threat (real or perceived) anywhere on the globe, and 2) large conventional forces to counterbalance other large geopolitical rivals (Russia, China).
- fiatmoney 10y ago"Surprise" is relative; "blitzkrieg" (or "shock and awe") might be more apt. Iraq I, Iraq II, Afghanistan, Grenada, Panama all fit the pattern. Kosovo doesn't as much, but then again there were other considerations there (eg, not pissing off Russia too much). You're right on the higher-level strategy, but operationally it relies heavily on immediately killing off all C&C, air defense, air force, etc. in the first few hours so you can then bomb with impunity.
- einrealist 10y agoDon't worry. The Donald will make America great again! And he will make the Military great again! And all Supercarriers will be great again! And now shut up and ask no further questions!
- Marazan 10y agoIt was allowing so well until it mentioned ballistic launched anti ship missiles. No one is going to launch a ballistic missile at a carrier group as it is indistinguishable from a nuclear weapon launch. So the only situation a ballistic missile attack against a carrier group will occur is in WW3 and we are all dead anyways.
- Arnt 10y agoAren't there radars around to distinguish between missiles headed for space and ones headed for Baltimore, based on the early part of their trajectory? Presumably those radars could also distinguish between missiles headed for Baltimore and ones headed for a mostly-empty area of the Pacific.
- Nokinside 10y agoThis is not correct. Maybe it was real thing from cold war era. In any case, it has not been true for a long time. Conventional missile artillery is today's reality. The idea that detecting launch of multiple MRBM's or IRBM would be automatically assumed to be nuclear strike is absurd. US knows that China's second artillery has wast range of conventionally armed ballistic missiles and they are part of their conventional military strategy. Russia has batteries of Iskander-M missiles directed towards Europe. Large air-defense missiles like Patriot, S-300, SM-3 can also be mistaken as ballistic missiles during the launch. Terminology: Ballistic missile is general term referring to a missile that follows a ballistic trajectory. There are several different classes of BM's (Ballistic Missiles) and they can be easily distinguished from each other by following their trajectory little bit (there are battlefield-range, short-range, medium-range, intermediate-range and intercontinental BMs).
- Marazan 10y agoWhen people talk of ship killing ballistic missiles they are talking about China's Domgfeng arsenal. Dongfeng missiles are giants compared to any of the SAMs or missle artillery you mentioned.
- 10y ago
- hudibras 10y agoIt can be easy to lose sight of in this new era of America intervening and starting conflicts of our own choice throughout the world, but the U.S. is still 100% committed to total defense of both Taiwan and South Korea. I'm not talking about Afghanistan or Iraq levels of commitment (~100k troops for a few months, 3-4 carrier strike groups), I'm talking full mobilization of the reserves (1 million U.S. troops in uniform), commandeering the entire civil aviation fleet, every Marine, every ship in the Navy, every aircraft in the Air Force heading to the Western Pacific, fighting-to-the-last-man-like-it's-World-War-Two level of commitment. All decisions on U.S. military force structure, including the number of aircraft carriers in the fleet, flow down from what is required to fight those two conflicts.
- mercer 10y agoCould you elaborate on why this is the case? Or point me in the right direction?
- cjslep 10y agoThe Korean War has technically not achieved a final peace, only reached an armstice [0]. There's been many incidents along the border [1], notably the Axe Murder Incident [2]. The Korean war was a conflict primarily between North Korea and China versus South Korea and the United States. However, a relative was in the CIA at the time and I have the distinct impression from them that the US was also shooting down Russian airplanes, as they were shooting down ours, in the conflict. Should conflict restart, there's no telling who would get involved again. Taiwan has a complicated history where Japan had gotten China to cede the island in the 19th Century, then tried to leverage it to take over China during WWII, then when WWII was over and the Chinese Civil War went into full swing the losing Republic of China (which had replaced the Qing dynasty) fled millions of people to the island. The ROC government remains there governing Taiwan defacto, but the PRC considers it part of its borders in a dejure fashion. Since recognizing Taiwan as an independent nation would 100% surely anger China, the US has not done so [3]. The disparity between reality and theory has yet to be rectified and resolving it would definitely take armed conflict. This would destabilize the region and threaten a significant amount of the world's shipping [4]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_Armistice_Agreement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_Armistice_Agreement [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_border_incidents_involving_North_Korea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_border_incidents_invol... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axe_murder_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axe_murder_incident [3] http://www.state.gov/r/pa/ei/bgn/35855.htm http://www.state.gov/r/pa/ei/bgn/35855.htm [4] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/39/Shipping_routes_red_black.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/39/Shipping...
- hoodoof 10y agoSo Pearl Harbor 2 will be 10,000 simultaneous anti-ship cruise missiles.
- DanielBMarkham 10y agoThe military's job is to make people we fight want to stop fighting. That's it. If you keep strategy simple and easy-to-understand, you can stay on mission. Unfortunately, that's not where we're at. The military is used for all sorts of things -- famine relief, nation-building, geo-political force projection, and so on. This is the problem with aircraft carriers. They might be lead weights in the event of an actual shooting war with a major superpower, but right now we're using them for mobile airports. And mobile airports are useful for all kinds of things. If you get rid of the mobile airport, then what's going to take their place? Who's going to show the flag in the Taiwan Strait or the Persian Gulf? Who's going to support some U.N. humanitarian mission that's urgent, remote, and requires CAPs? The more capability you develop, the more you can't imagine doing without that capability. So our floating airports are here to stay -- until somebody sinks them. Which means we have to support both those and figure out how to do our actual job, which is making people we fight want to stop fighting. We see this same pattern of behavior in platform after platform. When you get to a certain rank at the Pentagon, you feel it's "your time" to bring a big change to the services. And that means big bucks, big capabilities, and so forth. Nobody wants to be -- or gets rewarded for being -- a wise and crafty caretaker of an ever-shrinking pile of money. (Yes, I'm sure there's lip service paid to all of this. I'm simply making an observation as an outsider watching DoD for several decades.) Quick tempo lethal aerial force projection is going to have to be submersible. Otherwise hypersonic missiles make mincemeat out of your task force. No matter what kind of radar-controlled gun you have, you ain't stopping something coming in from directly overhead at Mach 10. The kinetic energy alone is sufficient here. Got a lot of other thoughts on this, but on some topics on the net I've learned to keep my mouth shut :) ADD: No matter what, Congress needs to re-sort out DoD. We need one service for police force work, nation-building, and humanitarian aid. Another force for space. One for cyber. Then leave the other ones alone. I might would peel off strategic missiles from the Air Force because strategic missiles have nothing directly to do with flying around. Re-split the money. Then reduce senior staff by 20-40%.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> The military's job is to make people we fight want to stop fighting. That's it. > Unfortunately, that's not where we're at. The military is used for all sorts of things -- famine relief, nation-building, geo-political force projection, and so on. I'll give you famine relief, but geo-political force projection is the same thing you said was the entire goal of the military. A military that can make people who fight you regret it is the same military that sends the message "if you fight us, you'll regret it". It's not logically necessary that we use the military for nation-building the way it is for force projection, but if we're going to do nation-building the military is the appropriate group to do it.
- JoachimS 10y agoI thought the big problem for the US Navy in terms of spending spinning out of control was related to the Zumwalt class destroyers. Started out with a plan of 32 ships, then down to seven and now three. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zumwalt-class_destroyer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zumwalt-class_destroyer
- vlehto 10y agoI think one of the biggest strengths of U.S. military has been ability to pour money in R&D without wasting it to unneeded projects. This happens via embarrassing cancellations, but anyhow it seems to work to some degree. Now U.S. can pretty much rely on having the newest tech on all fronts, while everybody else is scrambling to have fleeting glory of adequate gear fielded.
- alvarosm 10y agoArticle sponsored by Russia, China and Iran. Quite probably at least.
- gk1 10y agoDo you have any evidence of whatsoever or do you think there's a conspiracy behind everything? I know the author and he doesn't strike me as someone on China's or Russia's payroll.
- alvarosm 10y agoWell, an article so one-sided, incomplete and inaccurate can only be called propaganda. I don't like evangelists. By the way, propaganda is much better when the author has no idea he's on anyone's payroll. Of course I have no evidence of anything but I'm just stating the obvious here.
- campuscodi 10y agoI don't see this a mistake at all
- ObeyTheGuts 10y agoNoone ever learned from Rambo: greatest weapon is human brain.
- vvvv 10y agoI can't believe nobody commented yet on how like a TIE fighter the "unmanned underwater vehicle during a Navy demonstration" looks. US truly is evolving into the Empire ;]
- vlehto 10y agoMy prediction for the Ford carrier program is that it will be cancelled and replaced with... Even bigger carrier. Significantly bigger. China can bomb shit out of Guam airstrips. Or from submarines any airstrip that stays stationary. U.S. can in near future do everything a 100 gigagram Ford carrier can do with 45Gg America class carrier. With the exception that Ford will have triple the planes, triple the cost, triple the price and about double the range of planes aboard. In near future you can do almost everything with three Americas than with single Ford, with almost exactly the same $/kg of ordnance delivered. This happens because V-22 osprey and F35B have short takeoff and landing while having incredible capability. Ford will rely on F35C, V-22 and super hornet. The hornet being mostly stopgap measure. But Ford is still limited to planes less than 30 tons and less than 1700km range. Something that could launch C130 super hercules (70 ton weight, 3800km range) safely, would make super-duper-giga-hyper-carrier look like worthwhile investment. The weight of Ford is not the main problem, but it's not long enough. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ar-poc38C84 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ar-poc38C84 Now you could replace significant portion of Guam with floating airstrips. You could dominate entire northern pacific with single carrier with it's organic refueling. The alternative for hypersupercarriers would be America class + some flying boats acting as refuelers, gunships and transports. That would be more robust way to do things, as you are putting your eggs to more baskets. But it's also something that China and India and Brazil can somewhat easily replicate to lesser degree. (They don't get V-22, but anyhow.) So for reasons of military industrial complex and to appear unachievable military power(Trump?), U.S. will make something huge before Ford program runs its course.
- DonHopkins 10y agoTIL they measure the weight of aircraft carriers in grams. Is it to make them seem bigger yet less expensive? So what's the typical cost per gram of a modern aircraft carrier? How about its range in centimeters on one load of nuclear fuel?
- zimpenfish 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_John_C._Stennis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_John_C._Stennis 103300 long tons => 1.049576e+11 grams according to Google. At a cost of $4.5bn (Wikipedia) that gives you about 4.3¢/g if I'm not mistaken. Same article says the range is "unlimited; 20-25 years" but doesn't qualify that with speeds. Although if it could sustain 35mph for 20 years, I make that approximately 987bn cm range.
- Shivetya 10y agoI was under the impression that large carrier fleet was championed by the Navy ages ago because they didn't want to take second place to the Air Force's Strategic Air Command. This was especially true after WW2 as the Navy was so very large and influential. They don't have a place in a war with another super power but the greater point here is missed. No one and nothing has a place should another war break out among the super powers. that is a no win game. So where do they fit it. In projecting power when lower tier countries act up, when threats to shipping lanes are caused. Do they need 11? Certainly not but this is all a dick wagging contest among the branches of the US military which compete more than they cooperate exaggerating the true cost of the military. My view, totally off the cuff, six is all they need.
- vinceguidry 10y agoThis question gets asked on Quora over and over and over and over and over again. The article makes three main points, that carriers are expensive, vulnerable and useless. All three points are wrong. Sure, $6 billion looks like a lot of money. But it's a drop in the bucket compared to the rest of the Carrier Battle Group. You need a lot of ships to properly protect a carrier. Sure, in a conflict with a major international power, our carriers won't stick around. But first, 48 hours is a long time in the context of modern conventional warfare. Guerrilla warfare lasts as long as the people involved want it to last, conventional wars are decided in time periods measured in hours. So a carrier battle group isn't particularly vulnerable. Sure, new tech like ASBMs will force us to change tactics, but we're developing new tech too. Also, nobody is predicting another war with a major international power. The game changer isn't carriers and hasn't been for decades. The game changer is nuclear weapons. If Russia or China decides to target our carriers, the response will have nuclear components. Nuclear weapons are the only things keeping our carriers afloat anyway, if they didn't exist, we'd have scrapped them a long time ago. So, 48 hours. During this time, each carrier, with it's compliment of an entire fighter-bomber wing, has destroyed much more than its share of enemy military targets. Also, the battle groups don't have to actually see battle in order to be useful. A carrier is essentially a floating air base that we can put pretty much anywhere we want, giving us the global strike capabilities that make it so, if we have to threaten a petty tyrant with utter destruction, he doesn't just laugh us out of the room.
- bayesian_horse 10y agoIt's increasingly likely that Russia or China may fight a war with the US outside their traditional borders. For example in the South China Sea. It would be conceivable that a conflict there would stay "sub-nuclear", as neither nation's home territory is threatened.
- akshatpradhan 10y agoOr research money will be poured into an Iron Dome[1] for Carriers. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_Dome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_Dome
- spangry 10y agoOther than nuclear powered subs, aren't carriers the only US naval vessels in service that are nuclear powered? And therefore the only vessel able to power the US navy's future rail gun? [1] I was also under the impression that once full spec rail guns are mounted on US carriers it vastly increases the carrier's durability in combat and expands its combat role. The 32MJ version has a range of 220 miles and uses non-explosive ordinance, meaning less chance of secondary explosions due to on-board fires during combat. Also very hard to detect or deploy countermeasures against a hunk of metal flying really fast (5600mph muzzle velocity apparently), containing no explosives or electronics. So carriers are currently giant, slow-moving targets that need to be protected by a flotilla of other ships in order to achieve force-projection. With rail guns, they become highly durable and versatile ships capable of ship-to-ship combat, air defence, point defence, long-range land bombardment, being a mobile air strip etc. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electro-Magnetic_Laboratory_Rail_Gun https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electro-Magnetic_Laboratory_Ra...
- chiph 10y agoThey just need a ship with sufficient electrical generation to run one. The new DDG-1000 (USS Zumwalt) likely has this, with twin 35 MW generators. I'm not sure the rail gun has a sufficient rate of fire for use as a missile defense weapon. It'll more likely be used for short bombardment and anti-ship fire. I doubt that rail gun projectiles have sufficient penetration into water to be useful for torpedo defense, but it's probably something they've modeled.
- spangry 10y agoFunny, I was just wondering about this while having a shower. Could rail gun ordinance be used under-water, say, to take out a sub? It seems like you'd face the same problems as you would with in-air ordinance, just to a greater degree (e.g. friction). The objective might be slightly simpler though: rather than delivering maximum kinetic energy to the target you instead just want to punch a hole through it. That change in objective might simplify the design of the 'underwater rail gun' ordinance: just use some nice heavy ferromagnetic metal, shape it to reduce drag and pierce armour (i.e. make it pointy) and maybe coat it in teflon? I dunno, not really a physics or weapons nerd here. I just like magnets :) EDIT: just to clarify, I'm thinking of torpedo defence in the context of 'destroy the sub before it gets within range'.
- AlgorithmicTime 10y agoI think they forget that ASBMs and submarines are sea denial weapons. The US Navy is not a sea denial force, in general. It's goal is command of the sea, which requires more than just ballistic missiles and submarines.
- tiatia 10y agoCarriers are great against Iraq and Libya. Against Russia or China they might well be useless. Against an able opponent, there are only two kinds of ships. Submarines and targets! http://www.johntreed.net/sittingducks.html http://www.johntreed.net/sittingducks.html
- sixQuarks 10y agoThe US outspends the next top 20 countries in defense spending combined. But I'm thinking this figure is wrong. If it costs the US $20 billion to build a super carrier, what would the same thing cost for China (which doesn't have to deal with high pension costs and labor?) Probably $5 billion or less. And if these other countries are spending their money on more effective weapons, where does that leave the US?
- oldmanjay 10y agoThis article is one tree in a dark forest. The real problem, which underlies all the issues faced by our government, is the complete reliance on robber-baron contractors who happily enrich themselves at the public trough while working the congress to ensure that the purchasing rules keep them locked in on the path to enrichment forever. It's good to poke holes in the need for military hardware that costs a unicorn's specious valuation, but it's not the actual problem here.
- aerovistae 10y agoIndeed. SpaceX has fixed just one of these cases but there are countless. If only it could be addressed more systemically.
- pm90 10y agoIs that really what we need? Advanced weaponry at cheap prices?
- random28345 10y ago> Is that really what we need? Advanced weaponry at cheap prices? That reminds me of the high-school math teacher who brings condoms to the class when he teaches, because he's statistically less likely to contract an STD than if he left his condoms at home. While technically he's making an optimal decision, he should really re-examine his assumptions.
- aerovistae 10y agoI'm not talking about weaponry in particular. Financial wastefulness is a pervasive problem across all segments of government.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Tloewald 10y agoAs I understand it, back in the 80s US carriers were regularly destroyed in joint naval exercises with Australia by diesel submarines (inexpensive ones of the kind owned by all of our enemies). They're very quiet when running on batteries. The US navy would respond by changing the "rules" so that the ships were not considered sunk — I imagine in much the same way that the Japanese navy brass changed the rules after cadets sank their fleet in wargames played in their preparations for Midway. Putting so many eggs in one basket is scary at the best of times, but the US carrier fleet is the worst of all worlds — hugely symbolic and stupendous sunk cost (no pun intended). Not only are they ridiculously expensive in and of themselves, virtually everything else in the Navy (and thanks to the F35, the air Force) is constrained by its role being defined in terms of how it functions as part of a carrier task force. This isn't just a navy problem, it's a defense and foreign policy problem, and a fiscal disaster.
- btbuildem 10y ago"In 2002, the U.S. Navy held a large simulated war game, the Millennium Challenge, to test scenarios of attacks on the fleet by a hypothetical Gulf state [...]. The leader of the red team employed brilliant asymmetric tactics resulting in 16 U.S. ships, including two supercarriers, going to the bottom in a very short span of time. The Navy stopped the war game, prohibited the red team from using these tactics and then reran the exercise declaring victory on the second day." This reads like something out of Yossarian's diary.. It seems the only reason there isn't a war on between the superpowers is that it's economically more beneficial to not have one at the moment. Hundreds of billions of dollars are pumped into outmoded solutions, but at least we don't have to sink the ships so that the contractors can sell more of them -- the government happily keeps buying more. The bankers' loans, the unions' workers and the lobbyists' friends are all humming along finely.
- dskrvk 10y agoTrying to build ever-larger aircraft carriers is like vertically scaling using mainframes. The number of uses for these seems to be dwindling, and it's becoming harder to justify the cost and complexity of maintaining this expensive and uncommon hardware. Compare with horizontal scaling, which in this case translates to large numbers of individually-capable units acting in coordination. It's just too damn hard and expensive trying to protect a single valuable target against an ever-increasing number of threats.
- nikdaheratik 10y agoIf you want to replace carriers, you need to look at each role they're playing and see what works to fill that role. Air-to-air: Fighters based half a world away don't do much good if you need someone to shoot enemy planes down right now. Carriers are still useful for this in many situations. Air-to-sea: I think this is where the article makes its best point as missiles and smaller craft make it much harder to keep these safe. Air-to-ground (strategic): Land based bombers and drones work as well or better if you have your targets planned out 12-hours in advance. Putting a carrier there in this case may be a waste of resources. Air-to-ground (tactical): Having this awesome air force half a world away is kind of useless when you're getting beat up on the ground right now. Drones may be able to take up the slack on this, depending on what the enemy has to counter it, but carriers are still good for this role. So basically, if you are unchallenged at sea, but have to fight against an enemy with aircraft nearby, like Iraq, or you need air support because you're fighting someone who is able to do alot of hit and run tactics, like Afghanistan, then carriers are useful. If you're fighting against another country with a huge navy, or you have some place with a friendly airbase nearby that's relatively safe, you might not need them. Considering the types of wars we've been fighting lately in the U.S., we can probably do with fewer carriers, but still need a fair number.