19 ms·
Facebook disabling messaging in its mobile web app to push people to Messenger
- exolymph 10y agoUser-hostile moves like this fill me with deep, deep frustration.
- beagle3 10y agoWhich is why they started doing them only after they have achieved world domination. Where are you going to go, myspace? Google+? To quote Mel Brooks' brilliant "History of the World, Part I" - "It's good to be the king".
- cpach 10y agoMore than 50% of my time is spent chatting in a specific small group of friends. We used Whatsapp before (when they didn’t have web access). Before switching to Facebook I tried convincing them to try Slack but alas that option lost out. Too bad, because I think Slack is a really good platform.
- beagle3 10y agoWhat was the reason to drop whatsapp? And why is slack better than facebook? If you don't want to trust slack of facebook, rocket.chat is shaping up nicely as a self-hostable solution.
- joshschreuder 10y agoAre they getting rid of messenger.com too?
- kobayashi 10y agoWhen I navigate to it on my OS X and iOS platforms, it just pushes me to download the app. Was there ever something different there?
- ben_jones 10y ago- Spend $18bn to acquire Whatsapp's current and future users - Force people to download Facebook Messenger - ??? - Profit?!
- SimeVidas 10y agoThis is hostile as fuck. Just clicking on the Messages icon on the mobile website launches Google Play Store.
- ranci 10y agolol
- whyagaindavid 10y agoUse this app to "intercept" https://f-droid.org/repository/browse/?fdid=org.surrel.messengerbypasser https://f-droid.org/repository/browse/?fdid=org.surrel.messe...
- qmr 10y agoThe amount of stupid hacks I have to go through to make Android usable is making me consider trying out iPhone.
- ceejayoz 10y agoWhile I agree in general and prefer iOS, in this particular case that's a bit of an odd statement. On iOS you couldn't fix this behavior at all - the "stupid hack" won't exist.
- intrasight 10y agoThat's why Android is winning. The easy things are easy and the hard things are possible.
- qmr 10y agoI don't get why launching play store from browser is even possible. Did anyone really think that would be used for a good purpose, instead of just rampantly abused?
- baby 10y ago
- wwweston 10y agoJust an FYI for any Facebook product geniuses who might be reading this thread: If you're serious about this, you're going to also want to remove any non-FB contact information for users (email, phone number) that might be displayed, because I guarantee you that rather than installing Messenger that's what I'm going to use if you let me. And really, if you're going to be so blatantly user hostile, it makes sense to really be thorough about it.
- cypher543 10y ago> At the moment, you can just dismiss the notice and go about your business. Hah, if only it were that easy. When viewing messages in Chrome for Android, I get redirected to Messenger on the Play Store when I close the overlay. Then the Play Store opens again when I tap on a conversation. Screw you, Facebook.
- Globz 10y agoMight because of this new "Deep learning text" ? I know this will be mainly integrated into Messenger.
- prdonahue 10y agoFacebook's forced migration of their users from basic, functional chat is, in my opinion, more frustrating than any single decision they've made to date (perhaps second to platform risk materializing to those businesses built on top of them). I once had a (protracted) debate with one of their earliest product designers who defended the decision unconditionally. His arguments were—more or less—"it's better for the user". If instead it was simply "it's going to improve our bottom line" I'd not have given much of a second thought. It's just changes like this that they attempt to spin as positive to their users that drive me crazy. ETA: found the convo from August 2014 and pasted below. Note this is when they first disabled within the app (and you could start the download to trick it into letting you continue). > Me: Jared, i get that they want to encourage adoption of the standalone app -- probably for some business purpose, now that they're publicly traded -- but why cripple existing functionality just to obtain that goal? make it annoying so that you have to dismiss the "upgrade" comment .. fine. the only reason i can see is profit, which is fine/just own it, but people are masquerading this as a good product decision for users which i disagree with (obviously). > Jared: A force is rarely a good product decision. That engenders distrust, and certainly they did not predict the frustration that would occur. I whole heartedly believe the standalone application is better. I believe Facebook took a calculated risk, but not a disingenuous one, and not one targeted at making money, one of the form of 'you won't know how to fly unless I push you out of the nest and then, woah, how much you'll thank me' and their convictions, which were backed by engagement data, were unable to actually test the event of "forcing the change". The reaons I belive they took the risk were to minimize ongoing development of a duplicative codebase and achieve engineering focus. Now, with similar information to Facebook, I ask myself what would I do - would I recall the change with a more transitional approach (e.g. 60 days until install)? Or your friend sent you a sticker / selfie / audio file, to view use the new messenger app? It's a tough question and I pose it back to you, what would you do?
- marcoperaza 10y agoThey only put that spin on it because it works. If they didn't do it, they'd seriously hurt for it in the press and in the court of public opinion. Every company does it. Until people savvy up, they're getting exactly what they deserve.
- jds375 10y agoSo rather than fixing the problems that result in users messaging via the mobile web app instead of the messenger app, they're just going to "solve" the problem by forcing users to use the messenger app? This is why Facebook as a company doesn't have high levels of consumer trust. This will bite them in the future. Once you lose that level of trust it is extremely difficult to gain back.
- yungookim 10y agoWell said
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- manojlds 10y agoI have no qualms using WhatsApp. It is a very efficient and useful app. They should probably merge messenger and WhatsApp (or maybe not lest they end up making WhatsApp bad too)
- optforfon 10y agofrom what I understand, WhatsApp works in China and Messenger doesn't. So I doubt they'll merge. But it'd be nice if you could message from one to another
- webvictim 10y agoWhatsApp would never accept that. Their brand is a ton better than Messenger's is, for good reason.
- rpgmaker 10y agoI hope the bigwigs at FB don't read your comment. Messenger and whatsapp should never be merged. Part of the reason why I'm glad that Messenger is doing so well (I don't use it myself) it's because I believe that gives them less incentive to mess with whatsapp too much. It's very likely that they will fuck it up eventually but the longer it stays usable the better.
- 10y ago
- yefim 10y agoNow it's going to be much harder to send messages from your friend's phone when your phone dies. Before you could use an incognito tab, and now you have to log out of the Messenger app entirely and log in as another user.
- e12e 10y agoThank you for bringing up this point - I've often thought about it before, but I didn't immediately think of the connection here. Just another reason why these kinds of changes are a bad idea. It might not be that often that you're without your device (battery died, stolen, forgotten), but when that happens not having a great fallback is really annoying. This goes for all kinds of apps and services, not just fb messaging.
- orbitur 10y agoIt doesn't seem like you can even log out anymore inside the iOS Messenger app. My wife was without her phone a few weeks ago and needed to message someone via FB. I could not find the log out button in iOS Messenger, and the only way to do that seems to be logging in to fb.com and hitting a button there which will deactivate your phone session.
- nodja 10y agoUse messenger.com
- jeswin 10y agoAs a heavy messenger user, my typical use-cases can entirely be fulfilled with a web-based messenger. However, FB doesn't let people open messenger.com from a mobile browser. And if you request the desktop site, it's virtually unusable on the tiny phone screen. It must have been really hard to make a responsive messenger UI.
- mfkp 10y agoThis announcement coming on the same day as the post about Facebook not using the microphone in the app seems strange to me. I don't want any Facebook apps on my phone due to privacy and tracking reasons, and so I used the web view (with an app wrapper like Tinfoil with location disabled), now I won't be able to send messages any longer. Guess I won't be using Messenger any longer.
- xuki 10y agoYou can disable microphone access for Messenger app. I disable everything and only enable them when needed.
- mfkp 10y agoI assume you must be on Android 6.0? Some (most) of us are still on older phones without that functionality.
- tdkl 10y agoFolio and Swipe for Facebook use mbasic.facebook.com and are being actively worked on.
- e12e 10y agoIt's a loosing game to use "open" web solutions to provide a third party application to these silos. Twitter already killed themselves this way (they're just too big to die quickly), and I think facebook will too. Facebook as "facebook" is useful and fun, and a way to connect with people and share stuff. Facebook as "messenger" is phone service. It's infrastructure that's part of your life. It's part of direct human contact. It's way too risky to trust to an entity like Facebook (or Google). If these companies had "invented" email, we'd been set back decades. Just look at how badly MS manages to preform as a netcitizen with Exchange and Outlook (for no good technical reason). Without the network effect and competition that the open email standards push, we'd all be faxing print-outs between hobbled messaging silos. I mean, we're still using SMS. SMS! Because the big boys couldn't agree to just have user@facebook talk to user@outlook and user@google or user@apple in a sane way! Both FB and Google even had XMPP going for a while, but didn't even federate with each other. It's as if Gmail suddenly stopped accepting external mail (not that their magic black holing isn't annoying enough to work around as it is).
- spost 10y agoI mean, to be fair, the only thing I use Facebook for is Messenger, and the Messenger app is actually halfway decent. It caches user names and pictures a little too aggressively, and the new trend of "let's add a row of buttons to the text input box, doubling its size to reduce screen space for features that should be optional" is incredibly obnoxious, but overall it's a decent app. It's obviously not designed for the users, but it's better than the Hangouts app. This isn't to say that removing the web functionality isn't a dick move and fairly user-hostile, but I don't really understand why so many people act like Messenger.app is an affront to god and man.
- taurath 10y agoEventually facebook will become so user hostile the network effect will mean that so many people are leaving it'll be like Digg and Myspace all over again. Can we go back to the time when companies tried to please users instead of advertisers?
- yungookim 10y agoI bet this was the decision made by the board members for the "share holder value" in attempts to increase earning per share via advertisement. Once the messenger gains enough users, it's obvious that there will be ads on FB messenger
- kinkdr 10y agoI think we are slowly going back to the time when social networks didn't exist. The "social network" generation is maturing enough to know better than using social networks, and the new generation considers them lame and apparently prefer more discreet methods of communication and socializing. FB(the platform), Twitter and the rest, are slowly finding their place as news aggregators and celebrity/corp point of presence. As for FB, the company, I just hope they keep giving us amazing tools like RocksDB and React.
- jsn117 10y agoie snapchat
- rhizome 10y agoYou mean like AOL? I haven't seen your vitriol since the last big FB redesign that even my aunt complained about, which was like what, 5 years ago? I even posted something to FB in the last few years, once it was apparent that FB had not done further obvious redesigns, "remember back when we all hated FB and were going to never use it again?" Nobody replied or liked it. FB is the Great Mall of the Internet, people don't really care if it sucks because it's just a place where people are. Many don't even have a concept of websites sucking.
- alaskanloops 10y agoHas there ever been a time like that? Sounds like you have a bad case of "back in my day"-itis.
- rietta 10y agoI dislike this change. I specifically only access Facebook on my phone via the web app because (1) it saves significant battery and (2) I absolutely do not want the popup bubbles during the work day from church and other social groups I am connected to on Facebook. Ultimately, all this means is that I will stop accessing Facebook Messenger on my phone all together. I will communicate with the people who matter most over the Signal app or plain old SMS or email.
- Swizec 10y agoProtip: www.messenger.com works on computers. Doesn't seem to work on mobile tho
- robocat 10y ago> Doesn't seem to work on mobile tho Did you try the Android "Request Desktop Site" checkbox? Edit: just saw that Zem says that works: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11835060 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11835060 Edit 2: Jeswin says it isn't useable: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11834996 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11834996
- bobajeff 10y agoThis is a good work around. However I will not be relying on this. I'll just reduce my use of Messenger (and probably Facebook) all together. I'm currently not that dependent on Messenger since most people just text or call me anyway. The rest of Facebook I usually avoid anyway as it's in a different wavelength than I am.
- zem 10y agoit's usable for me if you switch to desktop, but still go to m.facebook.com rather than www.facebook.com (easiest way is to go to facebook first and then switch to desktop). i'm guessing that whatever ajax call clicking on the message icon triggers gets a "this is a desktop" token attached to it even if you are visiting the site via m.facebook.com
- peteretep 10y agoHelp me understand - why is this so bad?
- JoshMnem 10y agoSome people don't want any Facebook software in their phones for legitimate privacy reasons.
- curiousgal 10y agoEmphasis on legitimate, Facebook is giving Google a run for their money when it comes to privacy invasion.
- yellowapple 10y agoNot to mention that Facebook's apps are notorious for their battery usage (probably because of their egregious privacy-violating "features", but whatever).
- peteretep 10y agoWhat is it that Messenger the app can access that Messenger via Facebook cannot, for people who take their privacy seriously?
- em3rgent0rdr 10y agoPrivacy concerned users can use wrappers around the Facebook website, such as the open source "Tinfoil for Facebook" or "Face Slim" android apps, then Facebook cannot access certain things (depending on your configuration). If have to use a proprietary facebook app, then likely cannot achieve the same degree of privacy protections.
- peteretep 10y agoI'm sorry. I still don't understand what specific information Facebook can gather from them using their app that they can't from the browser. When I look in my phone settings for the Messenger app, I can switch off it's ability to look at locations, photos, etc. Tinfoil appears to be an app to specifically work around the fact that browsers can leak more information than the app would.
- Brian_K_White 10y ago"Your conversations are moving to Messenger" No problem. It's not there's conversations with dead people in there or anything.
- ori_b 10y agoThe conversations are not lost; they're stored on Facebook's servers. There are plenty of reasons to dislike the move, but this isn't one.
- Brian_K_White 10y agoThey are moved to where I no longer have access to them.
- dingo_bat 10y agoI'm sure that's not true. Unless you have forgotten your password or something.
- ori_b 10y agoThey remain accessible, same as always; The only thing that changes is the application you are using to look at the chat history.
- yellowapple 10y agoNot everyone has access to that application.
- ori_b 10y agoThe desktop site still exists. It can even be viewed via mobile, for the sufficiently desperate.
- pfista 10y agoI'm surprised at all the hate coming from everyone. Then again I already use messenger.com never used the mobile web app for chat.
- sp332 10y agoMessenger.com blocks most mobile browsers.
- curiousgal 10y agoI know every time a post about Facebook makes it to the front page here people say they don't use Facebook anymore but as a heavy Facebook user I am so fucking glad I blocked all Facebook domains last week. I feel liberated! This move would have quite ecked me but nope! Fuck you Facebook.
- em3rgent0rdr 10y agoCongratulations! I've tried that before, but have relapsed after a few months.
- vinceve 10y agoThe reason I use the web interface and not the app are following: - you can't disable notifications - you can't secure your app (aka Pin protection or a password) - huge battery drain as it is constantly connected to the internet. The web app is easy. You log in and you check your messages. An alternative for android that I have found for Android is called fast Facebook. It shows a web view of the chat and ignores the market:// redirects. Which is already better.
- iamdave 10y ago- you can't disable notifications You absolutely can mute conversations, tap the (i) at the top of each convo, very first menu option should be "Notifications". With you on everything else.
- zem 10y agoif i understand you correctly, that's muting conversations on a one-at-a-time basis, which is not the same as being able to globally disable notifications from the app
- iamdave 10y agoYou can disable those too, click the "Profile" icon (the one with the silhouette) at the main screen, third menu option after user name and phone number is notifications. Globally.
- notatoad 10y agoon android at least, you can always globally disable notifications from an app: long press on a notification, tap the little i in a circle that appears, and there should be an "allow notifications" box you can un-check.
- mcintyre1994 10y agoTo add to the reply for Android, you can do this for iOS too if you use that. Settings > messenger > notifications > toggle for allow notifications, or to modify them if you prefer.
- chrisdbaldwin 10y agoWhy is anyone using Facebook for chat at all? (Real question)
- jrochkind1 10y agobecause many of their friends they want to chat with are.
- eachro 10y agoBecause a lot of people use it for chat. The network effect is powerful.
- dingo_bat 10y agoBecause everyone has it. And it doesn't need a phone number. So it's almost as ubiquitous as SMS, without distributing your phone number. Win-win.
- chrisdbaldwin 10y agoSo if its main selling point is being ubiquitous, why the fuck wouldn't they force everyone to the same platform?
- yellowapple 10y agoI have the opposite question: if its main selling point is being ubiquitous, why the fuck wouldn't they want to maximize the number of ways users can access it so that it stays, you know, ubiquitous?
- dingo_bat 10y agoYup, because they're idiots and it's moves like this that will allow an upstart to steal all the market.
- anentropic 10y agohow often do you want to chat with someone you wouldn't give your phone number to though? if they can call you via messenger anyway, where is the win in them not having your phone number?
- BuckRogers 10y agoI have a FB account but rarely login to it. I've never installed the app on my iPhone because I don't want notifications and generally find FB distasteful. If there was a higher class crowd on FB I would probably use it more but for me it ended up being a bunch of people from my hometown / high school who are angry, usually at other ethnic groups and don't seem wildly successful in their own right. If I do want to login, I just wait until I'm at a computer. The standalone Messenger app is horrible for permissions and should be avoided at all costs. If you can muster the strength to delete FB, even better. I'm able to very easily not feel tempted to login to that cesspool so I haven't needed to delete mine.
- aembleton 10y agoYou could just de-friend them.
- fwn 10y ago...or unfollow them. Most of the time, if someone complains about "stupid discussions/content" or anything alike, I feel that facebook just isn't used in its full potential. I unfollowed/unfriended/blocked all the connections to people who produce content which isn't enriching my browsing experience. As a result I follow around 10% of my facebook friends, which is a set of about 200 connections with (mostly) valuable content.
- BuckRogers 10y agoI would end up with about 10% or less like you said. I figured if I'm going to start deleting people I'll just delete FB wholesale. Just helps me get spied on anyway.
- JoshMnem 10y agoSimple solution: don't chat on Facebook. Reply via the web interface and tell the other person to send you an email, SMS, or Google Hangouts message.
- curiousgal 10y agoSimple yes, practical no.
- yellowapple 10y agoPractical enough for me. The only thing I use Facebook for is to say "Thank you" when folks wish me a happy birthday on my "wall". For literally everything else, the friends and family worth talking to have gotten the message that I'm not reliably reachable on Facebook and therefore should be reached by other means (and if they're worth talking to, they should already have my phone number and/or email address). It's about drawing a line. I drew that line two years ago, and not once have I looked back or otherwise felt any semblance of regret or frustration from it. Among SMS, email, Telegram, Google+/Hangouts, ordinary phone calls, snail mail, in-person, and the cornucopia of other communications options out there, there's zero reason to put up with Facebook's nonsense.
- mrweasel 10y ago> The only thing I use Facebook for is to say "Thank you" when folks wish me a happy birthday on my "wall". You can fix that by removing your birthday from Facebook. I did that one year and it turned out as expected, people only wish you happy birthday on Facebook, because Facebook more or less tells them to.
- technomancy 10y agoThe other way to solve this is to set your birthday to an incorrect date; that way you don't have to feel bad about not saying thanks.
- 10y ago
- areyoucrazy 10y agoI have stopped using Facebook (Twitter and everything social) half a decade ago. I don't use messaging apps and turn on my phone only when I really need to. Result: more free time to do interesting and productive things and people aren't bothering me as much. I have taken control of my life and I'm not being pushed around to do things based on notifications or desire for artificial status(likes, retweet, stars). Stop using these services that sell your privacy, control your communication, make hostile changes and in the end do not care about you.
- davidbwire 10y agoI concur with you. I realized that social apps were taking too much of my time an uninstalled them from my phone. I only use my laptop to access fb and Twitter and I'm very happy with the move.
- askafriend 10y agoTry doing that as a mobile developer.
- dump121 10y agofree time which now you are spending discussing about FB.
- e12e 10y agoHow is HN not a social network? (I'm not being snarky, I'm just curious on your line of thinking here)
- shawn-butler 10y agoThere is no network or linkage between users? And people are not allowed to post inane topics or messages. Pretty basic.
- e12e 10y agoHow do you think the voting ring detection works? Some users post contact info in their profile, so there is the possibility for messaging (email). Yes, there are policies, and structure and many good things - I'm not sure that means that HN isn't a social network of sorts? I suppose it might boil down to a technicality, but I always read "social network" as a graph that describes how a group is connected - not as some strict technological definition. So a bunch of people that informally meet at a cafe to discuss politics, art and other topics can be described as a social network.
- idobai 10y agoWhy not just use Telegram(https://www.telegram.org/ https://www.telegram.org/) and ignore the fb hegemony?
- lholden 10y agoI only use facebook over the browser when using my phone. The facebook applications request an appalling number of permissions... never mind the general intrusiveness and battery hogging. Screw you Facebook.
- davidbwire 10y agoAndroid 6 fixes this excessive need for permissions by mobile apps. You only grant permission at runtime and can withdraw it at anytime.
- e12e 10y agoAs far as I know, it's still tricky to install an app, then revoke all permissions before the app can possibly run? It would be different if no apps got any permissions by default, and they all had to "prompt on first use" - but that's not how it works, or is it?
- abhinavk 10y agoThat's how it works for apps targeting API 23 (Marshmallow).
- davidbwire 10y agoWhen an app installs it has zero permissions. When the app needs privileged access like microphone access a system notification pops up saying "To record a voice message allow AppX microphone access". You can choose to grant the permission or ignore it.
- DoubleMalt 10y agoWhich means I will actively start steering my conversation partners to matrix.org and vector.im
- andrewmwatson 10y agothey did this before and rolled it back, if i'm remembering things correctly.
- brianberns 10y agoFacebook's "Paper" app has a better UI than the official client, and it still has messaging directly integrated.
- tdkl 10y agoIt's not available all over the world and is iOS only.
- chamakits 10y agoTry Mbasic.facebook.com instead. I also use the browser for Facebook, and have now switched to mbasic instead. It's great.
- jmspring 10y agoWell, this will mean even less fb interaction for me. FB iOS apps were resource pigs and data whores. Neither installed. Maybe I'll just vnc in to a browser on the home machine when I need to message. Otherwise, iMessage it is.
- foobarbecue 10y agoI read "FBIOS"
- marme 10y agoi refuse to install the mobile app because there is no way to stop people from calling you on messenger. There is no way to turn it off or have some kind of do not disturb. If someone wants to mess with you they can just keep calling you and your only choice is to block them and remove them from your friends list
- k-mcgrady 10y ago>> "If someone wants to mess with you they can just keep calling you and your only choice is to block them and remove them from your friends list" This seems like either a made up scenario or you have weird friends. Who would keep calling someone to 'mess with them'???
- lucb1e 10y agoA classmate when you're holding a presentation? It sounds entirely plausible to me.
- k-mcgrady 10y agoWhy would you have your phone on while giving a presentation? Also, it's not a very Messenger specific problem - they could do the same thing with your actual phone number.
- lucb1e 10y agoWell I usually put my phone to silent during class and especially presentations. The person you commented on mentioned there is no silent mode. Of course you could turn the phone off entirely, but then it takes longer to turn on, and you have to unlock the SIM card again... quite a hassle just to make facebook's apps shut up. I don't know though, I've never used Facebook Messenger.
- k-mcgrady 10y agoIf you silence your device it will silence everything on it. No noise, no vibrations, no way for apps to bypass it (iPhone at least, and I'm pretty sure it's the same with Android).
- Animats 10y agoWhat was the alternative before Messenger? SMS?
- cft 10y agoThis is a nod probably towards the trend that Facebook itself is dying. What is left is Messenger, WhatsApp and Instagram.
- joliya65 10y agoI think I'm going to be dumping Facebook soon, I can text anyone anytime anyway. Seems like every week Facebook is pissing off large groups of people
- beedogs 10y agoI guess people will just have a hard time getting a response out of me if they try and contact me via Facebook message. The Messenger app will never touch my phone.
- colordrops 10y agoSpeaking of dark patterns, Google has completely broken Gmail and Google Docs/Drive in incognito mode in Android Chrome. It purposefully loses the cookie and will not function once you switch away to another app and then back to the browser. They are trying hard to force people into using the native apps, or at least staying logged in, for GMail/Inbox and Drive. It's really lame. Instead of being passive-aggressive, they could just put up a message saying that they don't support a specific usage. This is a well known "bug" that has been around in their bug tracker for a while.
- jakub_g 10y agoInstall Chrome Beta, Opera, Opera Beta. Voila, now you have 4 separate cookie jars for different use cases. For staying logged in gmail/fb I use Chrome beta, Chrome stable for normal browsing.
- shabbyrobe 10y agoIf you're a Linux user, see the `--user-data-dir` option of the `chromium-browser` executable. Whack 'em in `/tmp` for as many pseudo-incognito cookie jars as you like!
- shostack 10y agoAnyone have a more informed opinion on whether this is in some way due to their efforts with bots? I'm guessing a native app enables a lot more on that front in some regard than web, or perhaps provides a moat.
- tdkl 10y agoSo after this and screwing with Instagram (removed API access to timeline 3rd party apps used and enabled global curated timeline only) I wonder what will they ruin with WhatsApp.
- cm2187 10y agoI am not a mobile app junkie, and I count the number of messaging apps on my mobile: imessage, whatsapp, kik. That's already 3, ie two too many. Then I would need to add facebook, telegram, google's latest thing, skype? I mean why not a different messaging app for each contact? Why does facebook thinks I need more messaging apps?
- webvictim 10y agoIf it's not their messaging app you're using, they're not happy.
- lucb1e 10y agoThe only messaging app I have installed is Telegram. People who can't use that (my cousin still has some old Blackberry, a classmate has no smartphone and my dad has no messaging apps) can use good ol' SMS, and that works fine since it's practically free nowadays. Problem solved.
- dump121 10y agoIts funny how every post about FB on HN, brings out users claiming not to use FB and so now they have so much free time now, which they can use to discuss FB :D
- trakout 10y agoAre you sure it's funny?
- partycoder 10y agoPeople follow the path of least resistance and that path will not be Messenger, but something else, like Google hangouts.
- e12e 10y agoGranted, it's been a while since I used hangouts, but surely that'll not be the path of least resistance. It's still a crap, web only interface? And google just launced Allo to kill video chats in hangouts, so I guess there's nothing left to save? It'd be a good time for Duck Duck Go to revive it's XMPP server, and give it some polish, IMNHO.
- stared 10y agoAnd I couldn't be happier. I discovered Messenger as "FB chat without all the distractions" (and much snappier); and seeing that it gets prioritized (instead of being an alternative way) is, for me, a good thing.
- lucb1e 10y agoFine that you are happy with it (though I have moral concerns with Facebook as a whole, if you're happy with it, that's quite alright). However should that mean that everyone has to be happy with installing this app, instead of being given the choice to use the website?
- stared 10y agoIn theory it is great when there are many choices. In practice, companies focus - and it is better when they have a single working product than a few almost-working products. I don't want to say that everything FB does is fine - but this particular product is OK. Looking other way - would I like to get a working standalone product being integrated in FB, so that I cannot use it without viewing wall. Hell no! On mobile I use FB app anyway - so maybe it is why I don't feel the pain. (And installed Messenger app quite some time ago.)
- robbiep 10y agoThis is awful. I refuse to have the Facebook app on my phone, and obviously refuse to have messenger too. The last thing I want is more of my xommunications and data owned by that company. Fortunately I can do perfectly well without reading my messages on the web browser. I hope this decision marks an inflexion point for the company
- iokanuon 10y agoThat's not true. You still can access the conversations from a browser on Android. - press the chat icon - wait for Google Play to open - switch back to your browser - press the "X" on the "Your conversations are moved to Messanger" dialog - select the person you want to chat with - wait for Google Play to open again - switch back to your browser Proof that it works: http://i.imgur.com/29BoF8V.png http://i.imgur.com/29BoF8V.png
- ganeshkrishnan 10y agoThere is an easier way. Before you click on chat, from chrome preferences choose"request desktop site" Click chat icon. Profit
- jakub_g 10y agoBoth m.facebook.com and mbasic.facebook.com work for me and I see chat, Chrome Beta for Android. Maybe they (for now?) didn't enable it everywhere yet?
- gengkev 10y agoFrom the TechCrunch article: "At the moment, you can just dismiss the notice and go about your business. But this summer the warning will become an impenetrable wall, and your only option will be to download the official Messenger app."
- iokanuon 10y agoAaand it's gone. Now you can't dismiss it at all.
- skykooler 10y agoBrilliant. So much for being able to use Facebook on a non-Android device.
- alephu5 10y agoIf fb can't support basic browser based text chat they have a major lack of talent. If it's costing them much to support they have serious financial problems. I don't think that either is true so I guess they just want to sniff around my phone. Sorry fb, not today.
- padraic7a 10y agohttps://github.com/gsurrel/MessengerBypasser https://github.com/gsurrel/MessengerBypasser Problem solver for Android. Available via fdroid.I use Tinfoil for Facebook and this compliments it nicely.
- pbiggar 10y agoSo glad they're doing this. FB messenger is just about my favourite messenger - it beats the pants off iMessage and isn't as annoying as WhatsApp (the UX around starting a conversation with a new person in whatsapp is super shit). It was really annoying that there's some holdouts where voice chat doesn't work (has anyone noticed how much better the quality of voice chat over FB messenger or iMessage is, vs phone calls). Or where they didn't get my messages because they didn't have notificartions set up for FB messenger. Glad they're fixing this (and I might be the only person on HN who is :))
- sidcool 10y agoSo what's stopping you from simply using the native FB messenger. What's the point in forcing everyone install the native app?
- pmontra 10y agoI think it's their second attempt at this. I remember when they were opening dialogs to invite me use Messenger to reply to messages on a page I admin. I switched the browser to desktop user agent, which on a tablet is ok. Eventually they gave up. I'll do the same this time.
- yason 10y agoYou can just switch over to the desktop version of Facebook and the messaging will work as on a desktop browser. You can also use messenger.com by requesting the desktop version. It sucks but not as much as the intrusive messenger. The trend is alarming though and just fortifies my perception of Facebook further. They're trying to make their cust..uh, I mean, products, behave the way they want instead of listening to what people want and how they want it. That's a classic bad move from any company. Since this is HN, wasn't success supposed to have a high correlation with "Make something people want" ? Facebook's leverage is mostly based on their user base. As soon as there's at least one commonly used social network where I can find most of my friends, bye bye Facebook. That is a ridiculously hard problem to solve and Facebook know that. At the same time they're just using more and more of that leverage by trying to force things down on people's throats instead of adding to the pile of reasons why people would want to use Facebook. This makes it imperative that once something else, something even moderately bearable that is not Facebook, becomes available then people will be fleeing in masses.
- bricss 10y agoScrew you FB!
- georgemcbay 10y agoI'm not going to claim that my experiences here are the norm because I doubt they are, but the primary impact of Facebook previously splitting Messenger off into a separate app (from the native mobile app) in the circle of people I communicate with on Facebook is that we all (organically, without ever really discussing it) just switched back to using olde timey SMS/MMS for things that would have been Facebook messages. Not at all a spiteful/angry decision, just more of a "well, if I have to go out to another app to do this shit, I might as well just use this thing that works with all my friends including the increasing number of them that don't ever login to Facebook anymore".
- Manishearth 10y agoInterestingly, it lets me use the mobile webapp messaging without asking me to do anything. Because the OS I'm on has no Messenger app, and it probably will never have one. So if you spoof your UA string, it may stop bugging you and let you use messenger as usual.
- qmr 10y agoParent is almost, but not quite, entirely useless. Would you mind sharing with the class what that particular UA is?
- Manishearth 10y agoFirefox on Firefox OS Mozilla/5.0 (Mobile; rv:47.0) Gecko/47.0 Firefox/47.0 I don't think its useless. Pretty sure Facebook didn't special case Firefox OS, they special cased android/ios. A random UA string (anything that doesn't say android) would be enough.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- djloche 10y agoI'm on a blackberry passport and have also not seen this change (yet). I'll be proactively moving away from facebook as a communication / messenger as they'll more than likely close these loose ends.
- f_allwein 10y agoYou can also use Trillian for FB messages instead of installing the FB app. https://www.trillian.im https://www.trillian.im
- sp332 10y agoSeconded! I use the paid version but the free version supports Facebook messenger just fine. I just got my brother on it yesterday and he already recommended it to everyone fed up with the new change.
- Nexxxeh 10y agoI had an ancient account, over a decade I guess, back when I was on AIM, ICQ and MSN, I think? I recently signed back up for just this reason. So far, so good! I InApp'd a month, but will likely get a year's worth at renewal.
- the_duke 10y agoI very determinantly refuse to install both the regular FB app and the messenger, even though this is quite inconvenient as I often miss messages or event invites. But they require pretty much EVERY PERMISSION there is on Android, which is ridiciolous, and totally inacceptable to me. So this change will make it even harder for me to access FB messaging. Buuh.
- crummy 10y agoAre you on a modern Android build? You can now selectively enable permissions, as of Android 6.0.
- the_duke 10y agoI can't upgrade to 6.0 yet. Also, I haven't tried it with FB, but a lot of apps actually fail or don't work properly if you don't give them all of the permissions they require.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- XJOKOLAT 10y agoI don't want notifications. I don't use FB to chat. I'm totally happy with the web FB. And, maybe I'm wrong, but it appears like the FB app using a crap-tonne of data in comparison with web. Side benefit: FB app not following me around like a stalker.
- erikb 10y agoYes, enforcing your users. That is how it works. (/sarcasm) I was a very active facebook user for a long time and never imagined that I could stop using it, having so many of my relationships hosted in there. But honestly it all went so strange. 90% of the FB notifications are spam. The very good inapp chat was replaced by a worse extra app and now they enforce it everywhere. In the end I just deactivated notifications for all of that. Byebye, social network.
- sdoering 10y agoI rotally agree. During the last months I monitored myself using FB less and less. For years I have to used the app or messenger. If needed I only ever access the website. If they take the messaging functionality away I will even use it less. Or leave it all behind.
- allthetime 10y agoThis is kind of a non issue... You can just use messenger.com, no need to download an app. I'm probably biased though because messaging is the only thing I really use Facebook for, and event tracking.
- sp332 10y agoMost mobile browsers are blocked by messenger.com though.
- dec0dedab0de 10y agoI recently uninstalled both apps, and my phone seems to be running much smoother since. If someone needs me they can text. I think it's time to ween off facebook, and sell my stock.
- orian 10y agoOh, so it wasn't only me ~2months ago. I guess I ended up in an experiment ;-)
- MarkMc 10y agoAnd yesterday Pinterest forced me to install their app just to view a picture. Native apps are really becoming dominant over mobile web apps.
- oneloop 10y agoIt's really sad to me to see a bunch of intelligent people here being led like sheep by Facebook (no, this isn't a sheeple post, hear me out) Virtually everyone here complains "Facebook does XYZ really bad but I still use them because all my friends are there". I have a solution. Why don't you get all your friends off there? Pick a platform that you really like and start evangelising. The only reason why Facebook has as much power as it does is because of user lock-in, but that use lock-in is only strong because no one fights it actively. Example. A while ago, WhatsApp didn't have a webapp. Telegram did. I prefer typing on my laptop instead of mobile if I can. Therefore, I started evangelising from WhatsApp to Telegram. Now all my friends are on Telegram. (They didn't leave WhatsApp, but now they use Telegram between them). (BTW, I kind of regret this now that WhatsApp has a webapp AND encryption by default, but that's another story). So, stop complaining and do something about it.
- Hamcha 10y agoThis is exactly what I did, and I'm so happy I did. I'm now Facebook-free which is something I didn't think I could get (albeit I lost contact with a couple of people I rarely spoke with). I'm using Telegram a lot lately (although it was more about other people bringing me in rather than me bringing them over) and I still wouldn't switch to WhatsApp now. The webapp requires your phone to be turned on and connected (as it acts as some sort of bridge or something?) unlike Telegram which "just works" once you give permission. Plus I find the whole infrastructure to be much nicer for group chats (with nice things like bots that are quite useful).
- jasonlotito 10y ago> I have a solution. Why don't you get all your friends off there? While I don't disagree with your goals, it's not just moving your friends and family off Facebook. It's also moving their friends and family off as well. And all the groups they are associated with, and the people they interact with.
- barney54 10y agoThis is one reason I refuse to use Facebook's messaging app. There are plenty of ways to contact me on my phone. My friends know what they are. I don't see some Facebook messages, but that's just too bad.
- shrugger 10y agoWhoa, who would've thought that a multi-billion dollar company would ever make a decision in order to promote newer versions of their own software?!?! /s The whole point of Messenger is to consolidate messaging infrastructure. Being able to glean customer interests from that is just a bonus. Mobile web app is horrendous, and they know it, this is the solution. I agree that Facebook lacks that trust with people, but they have every right to try and make their platform better and more efficient, and don't necessarily deserve the knee-jerk "they're up to something!" like this.
- Zelmor 10y agoMark my words, pop-up advertisement will be served via chat-bots in a year. Hence the push to an application that has a pop-up feature like those head-bubble things. I've been using Tinfoil for Facebook for a good while now, since my old phone is just incapable of handling their applications. I guess it's time to just delete my profile for good.
- bunkydoo 10y agoWell this means I'm done for good with Facebook. My disabled account will soon be deleted I guess, messenger is just packed with spyware :(
- draw_down 10y agoOh interesting, like what?
- Zpalmtree 10y agoI really hate using Facebook in general, and very rarely have to use it for group projects. I'm loathe to even load the website on my phone, so this is an awful update...
- lucb1e 10y agoI would encourage you to not give them what they want. Just use a computer/laptop when chatting with some project group (that's what I did back when Telegram and Slack didn't exist yet).
- wilwade 10y agoI don't use FB, but my wife does. She is quite unhappy about it. She doesn't want FB to have access to everything (yes, some poor folk like us are not on Android 6 and will not be for a while.). The other issue is the size of the app. I realize that most people don't have this issue, but on the lower end phones adding another 36mb app means loosing another. And given history that 36mb app is likely to be 80 by the end of the year.
- Karlozkiller 10y agoI found this app meant to fight this block by facebook. https://github.com/gsurrel/MessengerBypasser/blob/HEAD/README.md https://github.com/gsurrel/MessengerBypasser/blob/HEAD/READM... I tried it with tinfoil for facebook and it seems to work well. It also states that what crashes the tinfoil-app is a call to launch Messenger.
- Digit-Al 10y agoI had to uninstall the Facebook Android app and the Messenger app a while ago. After an update, just having the apps on my phone was causing it to keep stuttering. And if I actually opened the Facebook app my phone would completely lock up requiring a reboot.
- fma 10y agoI hate how when I go to a website it forces me to open it in the app. If I Google a restaurant, and Yelp comes up, opens up in Yelp app....same with Amazon. Seems like you can long press a link to open it in the browser...but it's a very poor user experience. When I am running low on space on my phone, those apps the the first to get deleted Facebook and Messengae first, of course!. Facebook caches their data and at one point it was at 700mb...with no way to clear the data except for deleting the app and reinstalling.
- kevando 10y ago"Company makes product and decides how users should use it."
- goblin89 10y agoThat’d be the end to staying in touch through mobile FB in w3m on an EC2 instance SSH’d into from China. (Not that it’s that convenient… Gotta say though, impressed with both FB being able to work in w3m, and with w3m being able to handle FB.)
- exabrial 10y agoI don't want their battery sucking apps on my phone. Occasionally I'd like to see messages people send me. Really really really stupid.
- calsy 10y agoSo much complaining. The web app version is crap, of course they want to move people over to the app. Why waste resources on an inferior web version when they can focus their attention on the very successful mobile app. Its just good business sense and seeing that 99.9999999999% of Facebook users already have Messenger installed, its a non issue.
- stirner 10y ago> Why waste resources on an inferior web version when they can focus their attention on the very successful mobile app. Perhaps because the web version is not limited to the proprietary runtime of a single operating system.
- baby 10y agoI would think most phones support a messenger app. Except if you have a really old or bare phone, but then it might not even support internet?
- stirner 10y agoThere are many devices that are not smartphones. Yes, most devices support the abstract concept of a messenger app, but they each have their own runtimes and APIs that the app must be written for. Writing a web version supports a huge number of clients in a single pass.
- omarforgotpwd 10y agoSeriously, I am surprised by how out of touch most people on HN are. I'm 23 and everyone I know uses this app, and it's pretty good. One of the main reasons people use it is that you can type in the name of anyone you've ever met and start talking to them instantly. The idea that people are going to stop using Facebook because they no longer support messaging on the mobile web is laughable any place but HN. Any serious FB messaging user knows the app is much better than the mobile web client, which nobody uses.
- reustle 10y ago
- Nitish_shah 10y agofb account deleted.. just now
- Tepix 10y agoI refuse to be pressured into installing Messenger. I will tell my Facebook contacts not to use Facebook messaging.
- ohthehugemanate 10y agoso... will it still work on facebook lite? For those of us who avoid the official apps for battery/data consumption, FB Lite is an available middle ground...
- Zak 10y agoIt looks like for the moment, yes. FB Lite isn't offered in Google Play for users in wealthy countries, but there are mirrors for the APK.
- galdosdi 10y agoThis is kind of convenient; it gives me one more excuse not to use facebook. A few days ago I got the usual notification email that somebody had sent me a message on FB. Clicking is a low barrier so I clicked, curiously. Then I instead got the "No, now you have to install Messenger app" screen. That was enough of a barrier that I said "oh forget it, who cares, anybody who knows me would know better than to send me an FB message anyway, if it matters they'll get in touch via a 'real' communications medium like email, text, or phone" So sending me an FB message is now a black hole and I'm fine with that. FB's decision just pushed me and all other similar users (users that already are on the fringes of FB usage, using it only rarely) even further away. I'm not sure if that's a bad thing or good thing for them, since honestly I don't know what FB could do alternately to win back people in my "barely use FB" demographic, and from comments here it does seem like people who actually use FB regularly did not share my reaction ("screw it then") and instead felt forced to install the app and move on with their lives.
- rtpg 10y agoThe counterpoint is that I know heavy FB users (myself included) who have opted to just install Messenger on their phones, essentially being able to get rid of FB on the phone, to limit distractions but keep the nice communication While I kinda get removing it from the mobile app, I don't really know what the rationale is for getting rid of mobile web chat though. It's not like it's disappearing from the desktop web app anytime soon, right? right?
- teej 10y agoThe rationale that Facebook is using is chat isn't chat anymore, chat is a platform. You have Line/QQ/WeChat to thank for that. Cut the edges to funnel into the "core", and soup it up with platform features to compete with China. Personally I'm not convinced that "Westerners" are going to get on board with Chinese-style all-in-one chat apps. I'm doubly unconvinced that Facebook will pull it off.
- mr_spothawk 10y agoAs a westerner, WeChat was one of the coolest apps I encountered living in China. That said, we should probably consider all of these platforms harmful. I've migrated (and been pressuring my connections to migrate) to Telegram.org
- foobarbecue 10y agoI've heard that the reason there are so many "varieties" of products in grocery stores (think varieties of Colgate toothpaste) is that the manufacturers are trying to maximize the shelf space their products take up. Are Google and Facebook doing the same thing with home screens? Is that why they're smashing their big apps into little ones?
- Geee 10y agoIt seems that the actual problem is Android with their permission system.
- nowaq 10y agoDid they notice people are uninstalling FB app? :) It's a bit scary to see how they grab vast amounts of our attention. I've heard they aim to make the Messenger a "business" communication app that replaces email. I sincerely hope they will not succeed.
- cs702 10y agoFree market ideologues would have you believe that companies have only incentives to improve their products and services, giving customers what they want, so the company can earn more. Competition will ensure this happens, right? Not in this case. Here we have a company that has incentives to cripple its product and services, taking away from many customers features they clearly use and want, and giving them something else they clearly don't want, so the company can earn more.
- NEDM64 10y agoTheir main product is the Facebook feed. And they seem to give people what they want. Too bad that what people want is to just turn off their brain.
- cderwin 10y agoYou forget, Facebook's customers are not its users; they are assets whose access they are selling to their actual customers, ad agencies and marketers. Advertising made up nearly 97% of Facebook's revenue in Q1 2016[0]. Messenger and messaging is something Facebook has not previously monetized, and I would presume this is part of Facebook's plan to monetize messenger by releasing ads on it in Q2 2016[1]. This all makes perfect sense if messaging in the Facebook app is used by few enough of its users that the cost of maintaining and monetizing it would be greater than ad revenue it could generate, which seems reasonable to me. So, in fact, they are only improving their products and services for their paying customers, advertisers. I'm rather confidant that Facebook would not be doing this if its users were its paying customers. [0] http://investor.fb.com/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=967167 http://investor.fb.com/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=967167 [1] http://techcrunch.com/2016/02/18/facebook-messenger-ads/ http://techcrunch.com/2016/02/18/facebook-messenger-ads/
- bfrog 10y agoUh, I pretty much hate the facebook app these days because they're always trying to cram their overly zealous messenger app down my proverbial throught. No facebook, I don't want a bazillion notifications and another massive app on my tiny phone.
- edem 10y agoYet they killed the FB messenger for PC. Makes no sense. Now if I'm at my PC I need to log in to their website to chat since I only use this feature of FB.
- Fej 10y agoMessenger recently started killing my battery life so I uninstalled it.
- rufius 10y agoHonestly... That's the only part of FB I use. For a while now I've had only the Messenger app installed and just a FB shortcut to the webpage on my iPhone. I only check FB about once a week and use Messenger daily with friends that live or travel internationally.
- pasbesoin 10y agoThe Facebook community is, by and large, a positive for the world. The Facebook platform is one giant, dark pattern. Here's hoping the community wins. Why we need to continue fostering alternatives. Diversity and competition, to keep things a little more honest.
- roymurdock 10y agoI love how every HN thread about Facebook's scummy forced engagement tactics always turn into Fbook addiction-denail support groups. Just drop Fbook guys - trust me, you'll be fine without it. If someone really wants to talk to you they'll get your email or phone number through a mutual friend/family member.
- intrasight 10y agoPrevious long-time Facebook user here, but forgive my ignorance - what is Messenger? An instant message app I assume? How does this differ/improve upon the instant messaging built into every phone?
- blhack 10y agoMessenger is a facebook instant message app. It improves on what is already built into your phone because it hooks into all of your facebook contacts, which means full names, and pictures.
- intrasight 10y agoNot much of an improvement, IMHO, to warrant all this grief.
- mkhpalm 10y agoDidn't they already do this long ago? I thought it was a few years ago that they made me install messenger to use messages. That thing was a little too... cowboy... with all those bubbles splattering all over my screen. I uninstalled Facebook Messenger to save my sanity and haven't conversed via messages for years.
- j45 10y agoI've been hit with this and rather than give in to Facebook wanting me to install their messenger, will be looking into a third party app like Trillian, etc to do my chats.
- zatkin 10y agoI have the Messenger app. When I first installed it, it asked me to do the following: - Enable Notifications - Enable access to my Contacts - Add my phone number to my FB account I respectfully refused to allow any of this. Every time that I opened the Messenger app, I got a pop-up asking me to enable Notifications. I enabled notifications, then went into my iOS settings and disabled them. This stopped the pop-ups, but now I see a red warning symbol on my Messenger "Me" icon in the lower right which wants me to enable Notifications once and for all. I also see another red icon on the People icon which says that I need to sync my contacts. I'm disappointed in the direction that Facebook is turning the Messenger app towards. They seem to be desperate for these three options to be enabled.
- pritambaral 10y agoBehaviour like this is why we need efforts like purple-facebook[0] I wish to be able to host purple-facebook on a server and throw a web UI in front of it. It won't be as complete as messenger, but at least basic chat will work without having to download a sneaky app. 0: https://github.com/dequis/purple-facebook https://github.com/dequis/purple-facebook
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- datapolitical 10y agoIt's incredibly difficult to do end to end encryption well in a mobile browser. Facebook has hinted they are rolling that out and it will create all kinds of frustration for mobile web users.
- geggam 10y agoFacebook has peaked... its downhill from here... annoying the users so they find something else small group by small group
- pomber 10y agoWhere I live, messaging using Facebook is the most effective way to communicate with my phone company, my ISP, etcetera. That is the only reason I use Facebook messaging (I communicate with friends using other services) and one of the few reasons I still have a Facebook account. Installing Facebook messenger app is too much just for this.
- Jaruzel 10y agoI have a blackberry (BB10 based Q5) as my personal phone. The reasons for this are manyfold, and I migrated from Android. I love my Q5 it does everything I need really well... except for FB and Messenger - there's no native apps. So I am now in the situation of trying to convert my friends to something else for chat, or change my phone. It will probably be the latter. (Written via my Blackberry)
- stolsvik 10y agoWhy do they want two apps? I have never used messaging in FB after they started forcing me over to Messenger in a nasty way (I read the messages on the Web platform when I happen to log in there, which is seldom).
- ptaipale 10y agoI dislike this change, but fortunately - at least so far - it is possible to use Chrome on an Android phone and request the desktop version of any site, and Facebook desktop version still allows using the messaging function in browser. I'm not going to install Facebook messenger, it east battery and reports my location when I don't want it to. So if they kludge the desktop site so that it doesn't work on Android Chrome, I'll just not use Facebook messaging. Facebook should at least add an auto-reply function to tell anyone who tries to message me that "please send email to xxx instead".
- daimyoyo 10y agoI saw this change last night. I will never, EVER install FB Messenger because I don't want facebook to have access to my contact list. Period. This is the worst move the company has made since Beacon and I am at a loss for words to think of how they are justifying forcing people to use an app they clearly don't want to use.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Pxtl 10y agoYuck. I guess I can't be reached by fb messenger, then.
- marxidad 10y agoI can't install Messenger on my MotoG3. It slows it the eff down to a crawl and drains the battery, even when I'm not using it.
- hobarrera 10y agoThis seems to be the behavior last time I used the app (about 3-4 months ago). Honestly, I just use Messenger without Facebok, since the IM part is the only thing I'd need on the road.
- em3rgent0rdr 10y agoFaceSlim has figured out a way to bypass this restriction: http://techcrunch.com/2016/06/03/facebook-is-disabling-messaging-in-its-mobile-web-app-to-push-people-to-messenger/ http://techcrunch.com/2016/06/03/facebook-is-disabling-messa...
- bane 10y agoWhat is it with companies? Why force these unnecessary transitions. What kind of possible revenue stream will the dedicated Messenger app provide that just using the messenger on the web app not provide?
- andmed3 10y agoIf only there was a way to disable fb messages altogether, otherwise people who will be sending me messages there, will be distracted, and I will be the one to blame...
- andmed3 10y agoIf only there was a way to disable fb messages altogether, otherwise people who will be sendig me messages there, will be distracted, and I will be the one to blame...
- vu3mmg 10y agoI think facebook is trying to apply the bargaining power as a monopoly service provider .Facebook is trying to act smart with new enduser agreement for messenger .Facebook knows that, most of their user base will switch to messenger .I think normal non tech saavy users dont bother much about this .
- kevincox 10y agomessenger.com has a functional messenger, that they are updating regularly and it scales very will to different screen sizes. Unfortunately they won't allow you to use it if they think your device is a phone, just pointing you towards the native application. I don't know what this obsession with native applications is. A lot of the time I prefer to just use your website.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ionised 10y agoThat will be why Tinfoil has suddenly started crashing when I try to view my messages. All the reason I need to drop Facebook entirely then.
- unicornporn 10y agohttps://m.facebook.com/messages/ https://m.facebook.com/messages/ still works.
- TylerH 10y agoIt's already nigh impenetrable. Each tap or action within Messages on the mobile site brings up that modal and also switches your active app to the Google Play (or I imagine the Apple App Store for iPhones) store page of Messenger. Really, really, really annoying. So I've just started requesting the desktop site on my mobile browser.