19 ms·
The aggressiveness of the price drops on solar is pretty amazing. I just lost one of the inverters on my grid-tie system after it had run trouble free for 13 ye
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
The aggressiveness of the price drops on solar is pretty amazing. I just lost one of the inverters on my grid-tie system after it had run trouble free for 13 years. So we're looking at the first "major" repair to the system I installed in 2003. And in 2003 my 5.2kW of panels on my roof cost $38,000 before subsidies and $19,000 after. 28 panels, two 2.5kW inverters, net about 4.2kW of generation.
I priced out replacing all the panels (now I can do in 10 panels what used to take 28) and the inverters with a single 5kW inverter, $7,000. My price, no subsidies. That is over 80% reduction in cost, over 13 years, of the list price of $40K.
And that is why it is a huge problem for the power companies, it makes less sense now to not have panels on your roof.
- warmwaffles 11y agoHow long until you start seeing a return on investment? Right now my electricity bill for my home is ~100 a month in Texas. I would need to keep the same panels without maintenance fees for 33.33 years by your price point of 40k
- schrodinger 11y agoYou can also sell electricity generated by your panels back to the grid.
- ericabiz 11y agoEffectiveness of this varies by state or region. For instance, when I was in the Bay Area 10 years ago and looked into this, PG&E would let your electricity bill get to 0, but wouldn't let you go into rebate territory. They just wouldn't pay you for the additional electricity generated. I think other states/utilities have different options. Most solar quotes take this into consideration, and quote you for enough solar to get into the minimum bill for your region (most utilities have a few hundred Kwh you can use per month at an obscenely low rate, and then it ramps up from there--solar is quoted so that you'll always stay within that cheapest range.) For my current house in Austin, I'm still interested in solar, but it was both more cost-effective and had a shorter payback time to re-insulate to R36 in the attic and redo our horrible system (which had no ducts at all--agh, stupid 1956 house) than it was to do solar at the time.
- blacksmith_tb 11y agoSadly, not in very many places. In most US states, for example, utilities have lobbied to get laws that don't allow residential customers to sell power back to them, at most net-metering agreements will allow you to get credits from any excess power your panels generate (which is how my utility handles mine - unfortunately, since I generate more than I use, I can't actually make use of those credits fully, and I'm giving away some power to the grid).
- qaq 11y agoY but now it's 7K and not 40K.
- krschultz 11y agoPayback of 6 years with the new cost, even for your low electric bill.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoExcellent example of why solar panels (in the right locations) and LEDs are a better investment than the S&P500 right now. You spend dollars now to eliminate the need for future dollars.
- antisthenes 11y agoWhile that is true, keep in mind that future dollars are less expensive than present dollars. But it stands to reason that the prices of energy will rise faster than the rates of inflation, so it would still be a good investment.
- Someone 11y agoIf everybody buys solar, electricity prices will only rise faster than inflation in periods without much sun. It might even be profitable to play a 'buy when it is free or cheaper, use when it costs money' strategy. You can get there by buying large batteries, charging them from your neighbor's solar panels when there is lots and lots of sun (they may even sell at prices below zero), and discharging them, selling to you neighbors, when there is little sun and wind.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI'm already investigating buying 50+ MW at a time of Tesla Powerpacks in certain markets exactly for this purpose, as an independent generator. Buy power when people are paying you to take it, releasing it back to the grid at the most expensive times.
- mrec 11y agoAnd presumably a lower bill implies lower energy usage, so he'd need fewer panels to cover it.
- michaelbuckbee 11y agoI've been trying to do this calculation myself. One factor I hadn't initially put in was the fact that I didn't need to think about a backup generator for our (east coast) storms.
- brians 11y agoYou might—I do. Your inverter won't power the house when the grid supply is down. Why? Well, because if the grid supply's down, it's probably because there's a line down somewhere. Therefore there's a lineman trying to pick that line up somewhere. He's going to be handling both ends of a broken, downed line. The generator-side line is tagged out, that's safe. The house-side line? Well, that's up to you—and so your equipment will deactivate to avoid creating a safety hazard for grid maintenance staff.
- maxerickson 11y agoAn auxiliary grid independent outlet is apparently becoming a feature on newer inverters: http://www.sma-america.com/newsroom/current-news/news-details/news/12929-sma-strengthens-sunny-boy-tl-us-series-with-two-new-powerful-models.html http://www.sma-america.com/newsroom/current-news/news-detail... A generator probably beats a lot of battery systems (which along with the right inverter and a transfer switch is another way to use the solar for backup power).
- ChuckMcM 11y agoWell one issue with grid-tied systems is that when the grid is offline they provide no power (they explicitly don't want to back feed into the power lines and kill some lineman who things power is off). So one of the certification issues is to make sure that your inverters recognize that state and shut down. But a side benefit of putting in the system was we did a lot of electrical panel work, and as as result put 8 circuits on to a transfer switch (the incremental cost was the transfer switch and the electrictian's time wasn't materially affected.) So when the power does go out we can fire up a generator and switch over to gen power easily.
- 1024core 11y ago33.3333 * 7 / 40 = 5.83 years
- Osiris30 11y agoI keep a close look at the economic of rooftop pricing in TX - it's still not profitable switching but getting close. Cons: - Retail cost of electricity is already v low in most of TX (Houston, Dallas) - so it's hard to compete. - not much competition in the solar rooftop installation space (due to first point above) - No net metering policies in Houston, Dallas. Pros - High solar yield
- toomuchtodo 11y agoKeep in mind that the 30% tax credit will eventually taper off. It might behoove you to wait now, but not forever.
- cmarschner 11y agoROI can only be one factor. The other is that you are suddenly using clean energy. Doesn't this make you feel better?
- dragontamer 11y agoThe typical American median household income is $51k. Spending $40,000 of that on "clean energy" so that they can "feel better" is well outside of the typical person's price range. Even $7000 would be cost-prohibitive, especially if they're paying or saving up for their kids. A cold can of beer also makes you feel better. Its a hell of a lot cheaper too. The answer for the typical American is to wait for utility-scale to build Solar out for them. When the city as a whole notices that solar is cheaper than running peaker plants or whatever, then the city / municipality can purchase an entire field of solar (AND the energy storage needed to make it useful) and give it out for the whole town. And in the mean time, you can drink your beer on the porch while you wait for progress to be made.
- kragen 11y agoUS$40K was the cost when Chuck did it in 2003. Now we're talking about US$7000 over 25 years, which is US$23 a month. US$23 a month is not "well outside of the typical person's price range" in the US. If you want to "save up for your kids", the way to do it is to invest your money in the investments that have the highest ROI, as long as you have enough liquidity to weather emergencies. Pay off your 23% credit card before your 17% credit card, pay off your 17% credit card before you start putting up solar panels that will have a 16% internal rate of return, and put up the solar panels before you buy the cold can of beer with its 0% ROI. Twenty years from now, you'll be drinking your beer on the porch and sending your kids to college, while your typical American loser neighbors are whining about their credit card and electric bills.
- dragontamer 11y ago> US$40K was the cost when Chuck did it in 2003. Now we're talking about US$7000 over 25 years, which is US$23 a month. Chuck is replacing a $2000 inverter in just 10 years. If your emergencies include "fixing the damn solar panels that you bought", that's your own damn fault. In any case, when middle-class Americans start buying solar en masse, I'll admit I'm wrong. But for now, I'm going to bet you that this is a luxury that is not cost-effective for the typical middle-class American. It ain't like a Washing Machine, Refrigerator or Water Heater. I'll tell you that much.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoThat is a slightly more nuanced question than you might think. First, I work from a baseline cost of $19K, even though the list price was closer to $40K I didn't pay that for the system so I use the actual cost in my calculations. Second there is the point where the money you've saved is equal to the money you paid, we hit that point about 10 years in. And then, depending on the life of your system (which has "positive cashflow" at that point) determines your overall rate of return. The replacment inverter (which is actually going to replace both inverters) is $2K ("upgrade" pricing from the manufacturer) And as the inverter was failing our system was under performing (so not generating as much power). The question will be how much longer am I willing to run the panels. The warranty is 25 years, so in theory another 10 years but the manufacturer (Sharp) no longer makes them and cannot replace them under warranty (they can only offer to repay you to buy a panel from some other vendor with equivalent specs and size). So from a money perspective, had I used the $19K and put it into an S&P 500 ETF in 2003, it would have doubled by now (SPX was 1,008 in 2003, its over 2,016 today). So "bad investment" comparatively. If the panels continue for an additional 8 years and PG&E's costs stay about the same then I'll have generated about $20K in value from them so that would pencil out to a ARR of about 3.5%. Initially I funded the panels with a refinance of the house loan and that was at 6% but that has since been refinanced even lower. However had it not been, at my original purchase I'd still be running a deficit trying to both pay back the house and generate cash from the solar. Interestingly for me, with the $7K it would cost to re-implement that system today, and 4% mortgage rates, it would have a rate of return of closer to 14% (10% if you subtract 4% as the cost of capital for a mortgage refi) and pay for itself in a bit more than 3 years and have doubled the return in 6. The challenge is additional regulatory changes which get incorporated into new installations versus the regulation regime I operate under based on my 2003 install date. I wonder sometimes what the trigger is for resetting the project's origin date.
- Retric 11y agoDon't forget about taxes. Interest on that 6% loan get's deducted from your income which is an arguable subsidy. Alternatively, you also avoid paying taxes on your S&P returns. In many cases solar is really close to a no brainier. Which is why Florida Utility's have tried so hard to block residential adoption.
- kayoone 11y agoOps point was that the original price of 40k in 2003 is now 7k for the total installation. That will change your math somewhat :) So even with your low power bill it's more like 6 years.
- amelius 11y ago> How long until you start seeing a return on investment? Why can't the utility companies do the financing (upfront investment), place them on our roofs, and get a little bit of the profit? Seems like a win-win situation. And otherwise government, or specialized banks?
- m3mnoch 11y agothis argument kind of annoys me. "yeah, but how long before you see a return on investment?" how about instantly? this is what we did: 1) calculated our monthly electricity payment: $160 or so a month. 2) priced out solar to push our payment to net-zero-ish: the savings really start multiplying once you get down into the regulated tiers. 3) replaced our electricity bill with a solar installation loan. what did we get in return? instant insulation from rate hikes: http://business.time.com/2011/12/16/plugged-in-then-pay-up-electricity-costs-rise-300-in-5-years/ http://business.time.com/2011/12/16/plugged-in-then-pay-up-e... instant equity on our house. oh, and look! i can now have a solar-powered car! but yeah, if i happen to still live in this house in 15 years, sure, no electricity bill. and, i'm sure somewhere along the line i'll end up "making all my money back".
- up_and_up 11y ago> instant equity on our house. Depends. Solar doesnt necessarily add value. Depends on the appraisal. I only know because I tried to buy a home with solar panels. The homeowner had raised the price of the home to include his investment in the panels but the appraiser wouldnt include the panels in the appraisal.
- TheIronYuppie 11y agoAppraisals are not strictly tied to price of homes. Only the value for the loan. That's not to say you're not going to associate the two together (if you're buying a house with a loan), but the $30k one way or the other isn't a huge percentage of a 30 year loan.
- up_and_up 11y agoDepends on where you buy. A 200K home in the midwest, 30K is a big percentage. The assumption being made here is that investing in solar automatically raises the value of the home. I am saying not necessarily. The example above was an appraisal in Madison WI, which, though in the midwest, definitely has plenty of solar installs.
- 11y ago
- ryanmarsh 11y ago$100 a month in the summer in Texas? You living in a shoe box in the panhandle or what? I spend $700 a month in August. Tell us your secret for real.
- driverdan 11y agoI live in TX and have never spent anywhere near $700/m on electric. Either you keep your AC at 65 or something is very wrong.
- majewsky 11y agoAnd I'm sitting here in Germany with my €30/mo bill. :)
- eru 11y agoWhat are you setting your AC to?
- warmwaffles 11y agoI live in a brand new home. Spray foam insulation. Keep the AC at around 74 year round. I also have natural gas running in to my house for my stove and water heater. All of my light bulbs are LED.
- thechao 11y agoIs this DIY, or installed? If it's not DIY, mind passing along who you're using? Inquiring TX minds would like to know!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 11y agoMy wife and I designed the system but it was installed by a Los Gatos company that did not survive. As part of our education efforts, my wife completed a program to become a certified solar installer (you needed to be certified to get the full rebate at the time) but one of the women she met in the class was working at this company and it just made sense to give them the job to help them bootstrapping their company.
- lucisferre 11y agoSo what you're suggesting is to take the installer course and then hire one of your classmates.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoNot really, I was just relating how it worked out for us. There are a number of Solar Power advocacy groups around, in the Bay Area we went to meetups of NorCal Solar[1] (back in the early 2000's they would tours where you could see houses that had solar and ask questions). Great way to hang out with like minded individuals and collect folks experience with various installation companies and system options. Installations are common enough these days that you can probably find someone who has already done what you are thinking of doing, and tell you how it worked out for them. [1] http://www.norcalsolar.org/ http://www.norcalsolar.org/
- thinkcontext 11y agoWhy not replace your current panels with new ones? If you can generate nearly 3 times as much electricity with the same roof footprint and be able to reuse your racks and electrical installation, you should be able to be in the black in no time.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoSort of, and sort of not. I am already "in the black" as it were since the system has already provided more value than it cost to install and maintain. So no worries there. But 325W panels are physically larger than 185W panels (not twice as large but still) so replacing the 28 panels on the roof with them would get my raw input up to 9.1kW but I'd need roughly 33% more surface area. That would add another strut on the mounting system and the top row of panels would extend beyond the peak of the roof (now disallowed by the building code). However, it would be "easy" get get 16 in there, which would be an equivalent raw foot print (5,200 watts)
- coryfklein 11y ago> And that is why it is a huge problem for the power companies It is a problem, but not necessarily in the way you may be thinking. Peak residential power usage is in the evening when solar isn't available. Power companies therefore end up spinning down coal and natural gas during peak solar, then just spinning them back up again as the sun begins to set. [1] So you haven't replaced the coal and natural gas plants, you're just running them less. This results in higher overall costs, because you pay $$$ to build huge plants then just let them sit most of the day, which results in higher per-watt cost of non-solar power because the infrastructure and maintenance is no longer amortized over whole-day usage. [1] My friend, a manager of 30 years at a huge mid-west power company
- adamweld 11y agoWhich is exactly why Tesla and other companies are investing in residential power banks. They have the potential for huge efficiency gains across the grid.
- epistasis 11y agoBeing a manager at a large power company for 30 years is both an advantage and a disadvantage. For the past 30 years, the energy industry has changed incredibly slowly, so ones expectations of what is possible in the way of innovation is far far lower than it should be. The "duck curve" that your friend is referring to will be solved in a variety of ways, from wind to storage to HVDC interconnects to the rest of the nation, to peaker plants. In the future, coal is dead. No need to build any more of it. Nuclear is too expensive to build anymore. (Unless somebody actually does thorium innovation, but I'm not holding my breath...) When storing a kWh costs $0.10, and there's also adaptive pricing to match supply and demand better, these problems will melt away. It does require a huge mental shift, but the cost savings will make that happen
- jobu 11y ago> When storing a kWh costs $0.10, and there's also adaptive pricing to match supply and demand better, these problems will melt away. If the math and assumptions in this article are correct, then that's exactly the (wholesale) price point Tesla is aiming for with the Powerwall: http://cleantechnica.com/2015/05/09/tesla-powerwall-powerblocks-per-kwh-lifetime-prices-vs-aquion-energy-eos-energy-imergy/ http://cleantechnica.com/2015/05/09/tesla-powerwall-powerblo... There are a couple other (not yet released) energy storage solutions mentioned there that might get the cost down even lower - Eos Aurora and Imergy Flow Battery
- mtgx 11y agoNot too long ago some of the comments here were saying "how will we feed all of those millions of EVs out there if the EVs do end up replacing most ice cars?" Well that's the utilities opportunity to survive. Utilities should actually lobby against ICE cars and pro-EVs. They will be the ones charging EVs everywhere. Not everyone will afford to charge their own EV at home where they have solar panels.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- antoniotamer 11y agoWould you be able to share what company quoted you for $7k? I'm going to be getting quotes on a solar installation, and your quoted price seems rather good. Do you get to reuse parts of your old installation?
- ChuckMcM 11y agoWell in my case we already have the mounting equipment on the roof and wiring. And we were looking at new panels and a new grid-tie inverter, so 16 x 325W Kyocera panels was $5,600 and the SMA Sunnyboy 5Kw inverter was $1900 (total $7,500). I would not expect a company to quote a new install for that price since they will have to add the mounting system and pay their installers for a day's labor getting everything set up. [1] http://www.solar-electric.com/ http://www.solar-electric.com/
- aagha 11y agoOther than the fact that $7k still isn't that cheap (for many people)--how long does the "average" home of 4 take to recoup that cost? I think the barrier is not only cost, but also know-how. Few people are likely to tackle a challenging project like this with a $7k out-lay.
- kriro 11y agoThe huge power companies still control the grid in many countries though. I hope improvements in batteries/storage will remedy this and we'll shift towards community grids of sorts. You'll still need the traditional grid for peaks but the power is shifting (pun non intended). It's a great development, I haven't looked into the net power needed to produce solar/photovoltaics panels but it was dropping quite a bit as well. I'm a bit surprised there are no mini wind turbines. I read about some promising developments (with close to 0 noise output) but it seems to have fizzled.
- luckydude 11y agoHey Chuck, I've been waiting for solar to come down and it sounds like it has. When you priced it, was it just for parts or was that $7K installed? And for the do-it-yourselfers, how much of the cost is installation now? Is it practical to do most of the grunt work yourself and then get an electrician in to do the final part?
- ChuckMcM 11y agoAs mentioned elsewhere it was just parts. Installation of grid tie systems isn't hard but does have a number of building code things you have to follow (at least in California). At the time we did the install my wife took a solar installer's course which went over the current code. I can recommend that as a plan of action, find a local group offering job training as a solar installer and take it. Then using that knowledge you can design an installation that meets your local code.