20 ms·
The price of solar power just fell 50% in 16 months
- Retric 11y agoA side effect of this, large scale grid solar is now significantly cheaper than rooftop solar due to labor costs.
- giarc 11y agoAt which point would it be financially beneficial for a farmer to turn a field into a solar farm rather than plant a crop? I have no knowledge in economics of either so I couldn't even estimate.
- MichaelBurge 11y agoI think you get fined if you do that.
- lotsofQs333 11y agoWhere? Even if this was true, surely it would depend on where you live, yeah? Country and local laws would vary? The questions was what it would cost a farmer, not farmer in place where it's obviously illegal? What...
- riffraff 11y agoJust for the sake of trivial knowledge (your comment is obviously correct that it varies) it is actually forbidden in Sardinia (Italy) to replace farmland with solar power fields. You are only allowed to setup photovoltaic panels if you have plants below them (asparagus and some flowers grow fine, apparently). I have no idea why.
- mikestew 11y agoCare to explain? Because unless you're arguing along the lines of something something farm subsidies, I'm pretty sure you're wrong.
- MichaelBurge 11y agoUsually farmland is zoned only for farmland use. You need an inspector to approve any building, and it must be related to farm use. In Oregon, here's the list of allowed uses of farmland: http://www.oregonlaws.org/ors/215.213 http://www.oregonlaws.org/ors/215.213 You could probably install solar panels for the purpose of powering your house and farm equipment, but you couldn't install solar panels everywhere and sell the electricity to the public: "Utility facilities necessary for public service, including wetland waste treatment systems but not including commercial facilities for the purpose of generating electrical power for public use by sale or transmission towers over 200 feet in height." It's not just a local thing: Maybe there are places where it doesn't hold, but the government wants to ensure the US isn't dependent on other countries for food. So it puts restrictions on the farmland to ensure that there's always enough food available. OTOH, if by 'farmland', you meant 'desert in Nevada', I can't imagine anyone would care if you bought it up and installed panels there.
- mikestew 11y agoThanks. It's been so long since I've lived in farm land that I forgot about "let's not turn farm land into subdivisions" zoning.
- imglorp 11y agoOn a related note, an agricultural high school near me has a field dedicated to solar panels, that powers most of the school buildings. The students are learning how to farm photons alongside corn. http://solarbuildermag.com/news/church-farm-school-in-pennsylvania-gets-1-1-mw-solar-array/ http://solarbuildermag.com/news/church-farm-school-in-pennsy...
- Tloewald 11y agoI think the economics of food production will probably trounce that of power production. In any event, it's more efficient to stick solar panels in the desert and wire electricity to places that are less sunny.
- frandroid 11y agoThe Gulf states are the most polluting per capita on the planet, so great planetary benefit can be derived even just by using the power where it's generated.
- Retric 11y agoDiminishing returns mean you end up covering deserts with solar before farm land. Next, highly marginal farm land. On the other hand, wind farms have a tiny footprint so that's already a major thing in some areas.
- wmeredith 11y agoRE: Windfarms This has been a dramatic change in the US midwest landscape over the last decade. When driving through Iowa or Kansas these days, the horizon is constantly dotted with wind turbines nestled in amongst the corn fields or livestock pastures. 15 years ago this was NOT the case.
- eganist 11y agoYup. You can even see it from the air. With ever-increasing turbine sizes, these things are easily visible from 39,000 ft.
- maxerickson 11y agoI don't see a way to link it directly but the layers on this map can be adjusted to show the many wind and solar projects in the US: http://www.eia.gov/state/maps.cfm http://www.eia.gov/state/maps.cfm
- SwellJoe 11y agoThere's a lot of farmland and ranch land in the US that shouldn't be farmland or ranch land. They're too dry, too hot, and competing for water resources with people and natural (sometimes endangered) ecosystems. So, maybe it's something that should be encouraged; the food those farms and ranches produce would need to be replaced by food grown in more appropriate climates, and we'd need to rethink our recent "local food" movement, in some regards, but agriculture, and particularly animal agriculture, are an ecological disaster almost everywhere they exist. Couple that with limited water resources (where a lot of agriculture takes place in California, Texas, Arizona, and New Mexico) and you've got a recipe for serious problems long-term. That said, agriculture could also shift. Less water-intensive foods, more foods that are appropriate for the area they're being consumed in. Anyway, I think solar farms replacing agricultural farms could be a net win for the environment, even before considering the improvements that come from turning off coal-fired plants.
- nashashmi 11y agoHah! Only if dictatorship could ordain things to be done so correctly. Unfortunately we live in a capitalistic democracy.
- richmarr 11y agoWhere do you live? How come your goverment isn't able to control taxation, or its regulatory environment?
- SwellJoe 11y agoAre you sincere in your belief that only a dictatorship could lead to more environmentally responsible agriculture and land use in the US? It seems like trolling, but if you're sincere, I could point you to some references on how our current laws reward irresponsible water and land use in many cases. There are many things a "capitalistic democracy" (if that's really what we are living in, which I also think is debatable) can do, and many things that are already being done, to guide how land owners utilize their land. The unintended consequences of current agricultural and water-use law in places like some parts of California, which have experienced more years of drought than years of normal rainfall for more than a decade, have been pretty significant. Government at local, state, and federal levels, have helped create the problems I'm talking about, so why shouldn't they be able to help alleviate them?
- tinco 11y agoWell the farmer doing it himself wouldn't be financially attractive (too big setup costs). But if the farmer is the land owner then he could rent it out to a power business that are good for the upfront costs. The exact point that would happen is when all the cheaper (non-arable) available land is already covered. That might have already happened in specific locations and countries. Note that at the moment upfront costs (the panels) are so expensive it will be a long time before solar panel 'fields' would become any significant fraction of total arable land. I.E. a simple few acre farm field might be worth a couple hundred thousand euros, but totally filling it with panels might cost billions.
- mrfusion 11y agoOr do both! Grow mushrooms under the panels.
- Detect 11y agoRaise panels up a bit and can graze animals underneath them too.
- DamnYuppie 11y agoCows would tear them up pretty quickly by rubbing up against them. Not saying they couldn't be re-enforced but I just wouldn't stick em out in a field with livestock.
- sokoloff 11y agoThe grass under/behind the panels would grow using what light source? I have a hard time growing grass under some shade trees that are far from opaque and along a [solid, south-facing] fence line.
- spiderfarmer 11y agoIn arid regions with a low crop per acre yield it's beneficial right now. If the farmer has the money to finance it by himself it's almost certainly beneficial. But ofcourse it's better to just put them on your roof. In Germany and The Netherlands most farmers have solar panels on their (quite large) barns.
- stale2002 11y agoThis is a common mistake that people make, especially when talking about fancy, flashy technologies, like drive way solar panels, road solar panels, ect We do not have a shortage of land or places to put solar panels. Land is cheap, cheap, cheap compared to the other costs of solar panels. There is no need to come up with fancy schemes to convert roads or windows or farms or whatever to solar panels. We aren't running out of land for them any time soon.
- epistasis 11y agoFarmland is already being converted, with predictable NIMBY reactions: http://watchdog.org/191942/critics-want-sunshine-huge-mn-solar-power-project/ http://watchdog.org/191942/critics-want-sunshine-huge-mn-sol... http://www.startribune.com/big-solar-parks-proposed-for-minnesota-not-so-popular-with-neighbors/297894931/ http://www.startribune.com/big-solar-parks-proposed-for-minn... Including "prime" farmland: http://www.mprnews.org/story/2016/02/03/opponents-want-minnesota-solar-farm-plan-stopped http://www.mprnews.org/story/2016/02/03/opponents-want-minne...
- mrfusion 11y agoWhy can't large scale solar be combined with wind power to get double he energy output from the same land?
- jksmith 11y agoWell large corp/utilities need to grab it now because if endpoint arbitraging becomes widespread, that will be a serious threat to the old utility model.
- vonmoltke 11y agoThis article is making a really big deal out of bids. While the trend is encouraging, let's wait and see if the winning bidders can actually deliver at the prices they bid before getting too excited.
- tim333 11y agoHard to tell for a while as these tend to be 20 year contracts.
- mdorazio 11y agoI think that's part of the reason the bids are so cheap, though. They're probably counting on some cost reductions over time so that even if they lose some money up front, the long-term profitability will be there. I doubt that anyone can actually deliver solar power at a profit today for the bid prices listed.
- andy_ppp 11y agoIt's some factor of both things are cheaper now and things will be cheaper in the future. I'm betting these companies know what they are bidding for and it's likely technology will continue to make incremental improvements in this area. Compound interest works well here too and even modest decreases in costs compounded over 20 years will be very worthwhile.
- epistasis 11y agoGiven that the vast majority of solar costs are upfront, and that the lifetime of a solar install is greater than 20 years, how would future cost reductions help with a project that's starting soon?
- tim333 11y agoIn this case: >DEWA invited developers to submit bids for configurations made up of three sub-phases: a mandatory 200MW to be commissioned in April 2018, and another two optional 300MW tranches in 2019 and 2020, respectively,” the firm said in an analysis of the results. so it's not being built for 2 or 3 years and they are probably hoping costs will continue dropping during that period. The details of the situation are quite complicated, more details here http://www.apricum-group.com/dubai-shatters-records-cost-solar-earths-largest-solar-power-plant/ http://www.apricum-group.com/dubai-shatters-records-cost-sol...
- tim333 11y agoPretty impressive. They need to work on cheaper batteries now.
- ebbv 11y agoThose prices are dropping drastically too as manufacturers have been opening manufacturing facilities and the technology continues to improve.
- dpierce9 11y agoBatteries would be great but they are not necessary unless you want to replace all generation with solar which would be a gargantuan undertaking. As part of the current generation stack, even at expanded scale, solar works very well without storage.
- dragontamer 11y agoYup. There's no reason why we can't rely on peaker plants a little bit longer. In general, there's a ton of power-plants designed to turn on and off throughout the day to inject power into the grid when demand grows. The chief benefit however, is that this happened starting at daytime hours (when workers come into factories and tons of energy is suddenly demanded from the grid). However, because 12:00 noon is peak solar, peaker-plants will shift to later in the day to 3:00pm to 5:00pm or so (as opposed to running from 12:00 to 7:00 each day, they'll maybe run 3:00 to 7:00 each day). Peaker Plants can be Hydro or Natural Gas. Natural Gas Peaker Plants are the most expensive, and they currently happen to run during a similar timeframe as solar. For now, Peaker Plants can remain the solution. We need something to work on cloudy / rainy days after all. And "battery" tech is getting better. http://www.aresnorthamerica.com/ http://www.aresnorthamerica.com/
- epistasis 11y ago> There's no reason why we can't rely on peaker plants a little bit longer. No reason other than them being more expensive than batteries: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-12-22/batteries-gaining-favor-over-gas-peaker-plants-in-california http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-12-22/batteries-... >We need something to work on cloudy / rainy days after all. Even without storage, interconnecting grids with HVDC across the US (or across a continent) solves this problem really really nicely. China is already building tons of HVDC to do this, and we need to as well. Long haul transport over HVDC is also cheaper than peaker plants. That said, natural gas peaker plants stick around as long as the fuel costs are low, and the capital has already been sunk into the plant. But for new capacity, I think there's going to be a huge shift towards storage.
- hughes 11y agoIf the price of solar continues to drop rapidly, why would anyone buy solar? Waiting a couple years for another 50% price drop seems like an obvious choice while we're still in the $5k-10k range to outfit a home.
- maxerickson 11y agoPresumably people buying solar now are comparing it to the other available options rather than future solar.
- Scirra_Tom 11y agoIsn't it only dropping because people are buying it? If no one was buying it, it'd get more expensive. Also, a 50% drop this year doesn't guarantee a 50% drop next year. And perhaps there's some speculation that traditional energy sources are going to increase in price going forwards. Also, I think for a lot of buyers there's more to the purchase than cost. A lot of organisations have environmental targets to hit nowadays, solar is one way to realise these targets. And as another commenter mentioned, some people buying might not have a choice (not having electricity isn't an option).
- dabeeeenster 11y agoSome of the costs are not going to come down much more. Installation labour, roof panel frames, inverter etc. etc. can come down a little but not by much. https://electrek.files.wordpress.com/2016/05/chart.jpeg?w=771&h=514 https://electrek.files.wordpress.com/2016/05/chart.jpeg?w=77... The price curve has to start flattening out soon! (I hope it doesn't, but I can't see how you can carry on achieving 50% price drops so rapidly...)
- dicroce 11y agoIf efficiency went up, installation can come down...
- Retric 11y agoPeople need power now and are not willing wait 5 years. So, someone is going to buy additional power generation now. In which case it's a question of current solar prices vs. (coal, nuclear, etc.) not future solar prices vs current solar pirces.
- sdneirf 11y agoI cannot imagine utilities lobbying group not going whole hog to squash this.
- cubano 11y agoIt's interesting how no one is discussing how the governments massive subsidy of the solar and wind power industries are completely distorting the market for these "prices", so studies like these are pretty much nonsense. Of course price/KW will drop massively if the entire thing is being propped up by taxpayer dollars and not the actual need to be profitable. I guess I just need to resign myself to the idea that so many misguided people now believe that government can print and spend money on everything and that will always work forever. But it won't.
- udfalkso 11y agoWhich government are you talking about? You realize this article is not about the United States?
- jahnu 11y agoFor other energy sources what % of the prices at each level rely on some sort of government subsidy?
- comatose_kid 11y ago"Oil, coal and gas received more than four times the $120 billion paid out in incentives for renewables including wind, solar and biofuels" source: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-11-12/fossil-fuels-with-550-billion-in-subsidy-hurt-renewables http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-11-12/fossil-fue...
- ptaipale 11y agoHowever, those subsidies are not paid in the same geographical and political regions at all. Sun and wind subsidies are paid out in places like EU countries, especially Germany, where they distort the market. Gasoline on the other hand is taxed highly. Oil, coal and gas get subsidies in places like Venezuela, Saudi Arabia, Iran or Malaysia, where they distort the market. That Venezuela distorts its markets in some way does not really make it a good idea to distort the market in Germany (or USA) in another way.
- 11y ago
- d_theorist 11y agoThis might seem like a weird thing to complain about, but am I the only person who is sick to death of headlines of the form "X just did Y"? It's the "just" I object to. It seems to be some sort of trend over the last couple of years. I think it's to make it seem more dramatic or something. It just happened! My god! In this case it is especially ridiculous, since the article describes something that happened over the course of 16 months.
- MattBearman 11y agoI was just (sorry) gonna post the same thing. 'Just' and '16 months' are pretty far apart in my mind, I found the headline quite awkward to read because of it.
- d_theorist 11y agoYes. I think headline writers are trying to force things into this form.
- bemmu 11y agoMaybe people like fresh things? Here's an A/B test I recently ran on some notification messages. There were two messages, only difference is the word "new" in there. A: "You received a message from the admins about your Facebook page." B: "You received a new message from the admins about your Facebook page." A clickthrough 15.64%, B clickthrough 15.95%. About 1000 samples per group. Not sure if noise.
- nothrabannosir 11y ago.3% on 1k? That's three people.. Yes, noise.
- nkrisc 11y agoThat's a great way to get a gut check on the validity of the result. Put it in real terms.
- 11y ago
- alex20 11y agoAnd here in the USA some states are punishing solar customers who sell their energy, by taxing them on infrastructure costs, to protect the big energy companies. Their reasoning for taxing them is to "maintain the lines and equipment". The counter-argument to that is, "customers who consume pay taxes and fee's to maintain the lines, and on top of that, the government is giving them tax breaks to help "maintain the lines" i get mad even thinking about it. Same with internet, Cable, TV. The lawmakers will always try and mitigate the disruption, but all they are doing is delaying the inevitable.
- maxerickson 11y agoWhich states do you think have the worst solar laws?
- Mvandenbergh 11y agoThe solution to this is to bill people separately for fixed transmission & distribution infrastructure, capacity, and electricity used. Ideally electricity used and fed back into the grid would both be constantly re-priced as well to reflect supply and demand. FYI - most regional utilities in the US are publicly owned, not private, so I'm not sure who "the big energy companies" are.
- jmcgough 11y agoMy gf is an electromechanical engineer at a solar power startup (and obviously supportive of solar power initiatives). Just asked her about this, and she said that: 1) the electrical grid wasn't designed for transferring power this way, and it can damage the grid 2) because solar power isn't a constant power source (say, a cloud blocks the sun for a minute), power companies need to keep power available for someone who's using solar. The amount of this is dictated by their peak power usage. May not seem like a big thing, but as more and more people switch to solar, they suddenly need to hold massive amounts of power, as disruptions can affect people in entire regions. Then she started getting heavy into the physics of reactive power and my brain stopped working T_T Anyways, there's a reason that they're charging fees for solar usage. You're using their electrical grid, and it costs money to maintain it and improve it to handle some of the new challenges of solar power.
- samfpetersen 11y agoIs this not just a symptom of oil prices dropping? Solar has to remain competitively priced or the industry is screwed
- ohitsdom 11y agoAn entire industry can't just lower prices to meet a competitor.
- rhino369 11y agoWithout subsidies an industry can't not just lower prices to meet a competitor. Especially with the sort of auction pricing in energy markets. If the going rate for energy is 5 cents a KW*hour, then you can't sell it for 6 cents. Solar survives off subsidies in the USA. Though in places like Dubai it might be a competitive energy provider.
- mtgx 11y agoNo, solar installations have doubled every 2 years, which would be inline with the price dropping in half every 2 years, too. http://cleantechnica.com/2014/07/22/exponential-growth-global-solar-pv-production-installation/ http://cleantechnica.com/2014/07/22/exponential-growth-globa...
- RivieraKid 11y agoI'd guess that the profit margins were minimal before oil price drop, so lower demand for solar should not result in producers lowering their margins. But perhaps the inputs for manufacturing solar energy are dependent on oil price (transportation etc.).
- TheCoelacanth 11y agoNatural gas maybe. Oil probably not since it is rarely used for electricity.
- cakeface 11y agoHow much of these low bids in Dubai are due to the low cost of labor there? Also I am guessing that various building regulations are significantly cheaper to meet than in the US. I remember reading about the huge building boom in Dubai being possible because of large groups of extremely low paid laborers. I'd guess any other utility project in Dubai would benefit from this as well. That isn't to say that there aren't improvements in solar cost. There are improvements. I just wouldn't compare a bid in Texas to one in Dubai.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoThe aggressiveness of the price drops on solar is pretty amazing. I just lost one of the inverters on my grid-tie system after it had run trouble free for 13 years. So we're looking at the first "major" repair to the system I installed in 2003. And in 2003 my 5.2kW of panels on my roof cost $38,000 before subsidies and $19,000 after. 28 panels, two 2.5kW inverters, net about 4.2kW of generation. I priced out replacing all the panels (now I can do in 10 panels what used to take 28) and the inverters with a single 5kW inverter, $7,000. My price, no subsidies. That is over 80% reduction in cost, over 13 years, of the list price of $40K. And that is why it is a huge problem for the power companies, it makes less sense now to not have panels on your roof.
- warmwaffles 11y agoHow long until you start seeing a return on investment? Right now my electricity bill for my home is ~100 a month in Texas. I would need to keep the same panels without maintenance fees for 33.33 years by your price point of 40k
- schrodinger 11y agoYou can also sell electricity generated by your panels back to the grid.
- ericabiz 11y agoEffectiveness of this varies by state or region. For instance, when I was in the Bay Area 10 years ago and looked into this, PG&E would let your electricity bill get to 0, but wouldn't let you go into rebate territory. They just wouldn't pay you for the additional electricity generated. I think other states/utilities have different options. Most solar quotes take this into consideration, and quote you for enough solar to get into the minimum bill for your region (most utilities have a few hundred Kwh you can use per month at an obscenely low rate, and then it ramps up from there--solar is quoted so that you'll always stay within that cheapest range.) For my current house in Austin, I'm still interested in solar, but it was both more cost-effective and had a shorter payback time to re-insulate to R36 in the attic and redo our horrible system (which had no ducts at all--agh, stupid 1956 house) than it was to do solar at the time.
- maxharris 11y agoThe availability of solar power at night or on cloudy days just improved 0% in 16 months. Saying that solar is okay because it's hooked up to the grid is not an answer, because that's just another instance of a reliable energy source (fossil fuels, nuclear, hydro) bailing out an unreliable one (solar, wind).
- durkie 11y agothis is the same as the "electric cars are actually powered by coal!" argument. it seems like it ignores all side effects of an incremental improvement in pricing/availability of technology: proliferation of EVs leads to removal of internal-combustion cars (all point sources of pollution), in turn leading to lots of cars dependent on the grid for power, in turn leading to that cleaning up power plants instantly cleans up millions of cars. by the same token, price reductions in solar power cost leads to battery storage systems (or other storage systems) being even more desirable and cost-competitive, in turn leading to them being installed in preference over other types of power plants.
- Practicality 11y agoI don't understand why this is a problem. Two things: 1) You're still using MUCH less overall fossil fuels. A 40% reduction in fossil fuel use would do wonders for the world economy and be a huge step forward in reducing emissions. 2) If other people are feeding power back into the grid, then you can be using their solar power. It's sunny somewhere, right?
- hueving 11y agoThat same argument could be used to advocate everyone running diesel generators at home 24/7 because of the power outages that occur on the grid. Sure, coal and gas pickup the remaining tab, but even if they are covering half of the usage, that's better than all of it.
- heygrady 11y agohttp://cleantechnica.com/2015/08/10/adding-energy-storage-to-home-solar-does-it-make-sense/ http://cleantechnica.com/2015/08/10/adding-energy-storage-to... You can add a battery backup system to cover night-time usage on your own home. The $10k battery system basically doubles the price. But since the solar panel's price just dropped by 50%... Cloudy days you might still be in a deficit. What is so wrong with a mixed system that uses renewables where it makes sense and relies on other sources to fill in whatever gaps appear?
- neves 11y agoIf you decide to go out of the grid almost completely, and buy batteries to store your energy. Have any idea about how much you'd spend?
- ams6110 11y agoEven with recent developments, being totally off-grid only makes sense when it's your only option (remote rural cabin, etc). Solar panels with enough battery backup, plus an alternate generator (gas or diesel) for times when it's overcast for longer than your battery reserve are still going to have a very long payback time if utility power is an option. There's a reason utilities exist, after all. It's always been possible to have your own electrical generator, it's just way more cost-efficient to do that at utility scale. That will likely continue to be the case with solar and batteries.
- brianbreslin 11y agoIn some states, the utilities don't let you sell back I think (Florida being one. we have a super friendly power lobby here. /sarcasm). But I am curious about the cost and hurricane proofing of a set of panels + battery backup. My parents would totally buy a combo for their house if they knew it wouldn't get ripped off in a storm.
- efields 11y agoCurious… does it ever get low enough that electric heat becomes desirable? We moved into a place that had electric heat on the ground floor, ran it the first cold month, saw the bill, then made it a purely "on demand" heating solution. The rest of the apartment was gas forced hot air, which was on a normal schedule. To heat a whole home in a Boston winter seems like it might cost $1000 or so. Is it reasonable to expect rooftop solar to ever generate that much electricity?
- sgt101 11y agoThree issues - in the winter the days are shorter, the weather is cloudy and it's cold at night. So maybe you could do something with storage heaters, but I'm not feeling optimistic.
- antisthenes 11y agoBoston is not the best place to generate solar PV energy. Nor is it a good place to live in a suburban style (town)house, considering how much more efficient condos are in terms of heating and efficiency. When you start with one of the worst possible use cases of solar, you can't expect great results. Electric heating is great for individual rooms, not for whole house heating.
- maxerickson 11y agoAn air source heat pump might make more sense than just using the electricity (they often provide 3 units of heat for each unit of electricity, a COP of 3 compared to 1 for resistive heating). It depends on how much summer power could be sold for and how much all the things cost. Newer ones would work fine for most of the Boston winter.
- yourapostasy 11y agoIn places that cold, the gist I get from reading about heating/cooling is you are better off bringing down your air changes per hour [1] (a function of how airtight your residence is), then insulating (including nearly eliminating all thermal bridges), then passive heating, then active heating, in that order. I've read field reports of people with measured air changes per hour that meet the PassivHaus standard, with 60+ R-value insulation (again, PassivHaus standard), isolated the foundation with insulation, consolidated all possible thermal bridges into a single, small conduit, and heat input from passive solar concentrator, enjoying NE US winters with only double-digit gas/electric bills for active heating in the worst months. With a rocket stove, most could avoid even that nominal amount and take care of burning their brush pile at the same time. The insulation will cost you upfront, though. Corning FOAMGLAS is my favorite at the moment because it doesn't involve greenhouse gases during its manufacture, but it and its installation can easily add 15% to your overall build cost. Use EPS (looks like giant styrofoam blocks roughly the size of 3 feet thick doorways, wish all the styrofoam we throw away into landfills could somehow be recycled into these) instead, and you still are looking at around a 10% upcharge. Granted, you're hovering around 70'ish R-value with that much, and thermal changes take a much longer time compared to conventional residences. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_changes_per_hour https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_changes_per_hour
- kragen 11y agoA really interesting thing about this is that the price of solar panels has changed almost not at all in those 16 months: http://www.solarserver.com/service/pvx-spot-market-price-index-solar-pv-modules.html http://www.solarserver.com/service/pvx-spot-market-price-ind... shows that it's 0.49 to 0.63 € / Wp today, while 16 months earlier, it was 0.45 to 0.62. This is a dramatic contrast from the continuous 36% per year reductions from 2009 to 2012. In large part because it's night half of the time, solar has a pretty low capacity factor, like in the 20% range (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor for details) so it matters whether this is 800MW peak or 800MW average. I think it's peak, which means that we're talking about something in the range of US$400M to US$500M worth of solar panels at current prices — which are the same prices as in 2014, when bids were twice as high! With a 35% capacity factor (Dubai is equatorial and sunny, although even Arizona only gets 19%), this project will have only 800 MW * 35% * $ 0.0299/kWh = US$73.4M/year of revenue, which is only a 16% return on investment — or ⅓ that, at 5⅓%, if we assume that the non-module costs of the project amount to ⅔ of the total cost, as shown in the bargraph on the article. So, is the winning bidder (strangely, not named in the article!) really willing to accept a 5⅓% IRR for this investment, because PV solar park competition is really that cutthroat? Or are they betting that by the time they have to buy the modules, the prices will have fallen (returning to their former exponential decline?), and/or that the notorious "soft costs" that eat up half the project cost are becoming cheaper? There's no real floor on the cost of silicon photovoltaic modules, since almost all of the cost of producing them from raw materials is energy, not the materials themselves.
- maxerickson 11y agoIt seems part of the story was crystal production getting ahead of demand. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polycrystalline_silicon#Capacity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polycrystalline_silicon#Capaci... The price graph a little lower is interesting.
- kragen 11y agoThank you! I remember that catastrophic price spike. Note that in the 2009 to 2012 timeframe, though, the polysilicon price was relatively stable (declining only by half), and it's declined since then, so polysilicon pricing is only part of the story.
- toephu2 11y agoUnfortunately the price of solar hasn't dropped that much in California, and may take some time. If you get a bid from a solar company they almost never give you the cost per watt (at least for the 5 companies I got bids from), but you should do that calculation yourself and then compare against the average in California to see if they are ripping you off: https://www.californiasolarstatistics.ca.gov/ https://www.californiasolarstatistics.ca.gov/
- logicallee 11y agoThere is a nuanced economic issue related to this priced drop. Today, (and for some time in the past) solar panels can be an investment, that is paid off by the amount that is saved by not having to use the grid (for example.) So a homeowner might calculate that by investing $20,000 in solar panelling today, they can have a 100% return within 72 months (6 years). It's free if they manage to use it for 6 years. Afterward the fact that this paneling is installed is "profit" - they get the ongoing money from their savings. So they are motivated by self-interest to make this investment, even if they assign "$0" to how much it's worth to them to reduce their carbon footprint on the planet; they don't have to care. But look at what happens if they consider that the investment price will drop by 50% in the next 18 months. Then they will have a 100% return in 36 months, plus the 18 months they wait means their investment is repaid in 54 instead of 72 months. Or, perhaps, they can install twice the paneling in 18 months. Either way their ROI is better. So that means for the next 18 months they are simply continuing to use the grid, which might have a higher carbon footprint. This might, paradoxically, drop adoption of solar paneling today (depending on people's expectation of the price change in the future.)
- mmanfrin 11y agoSo then you consider that others are logical actors, and will follow to the same conclusion; meaning that the price won't drop in 18 months and is therefore the proper investment now. But then you think that others will think this too, so then you should wait. And then you remember that you should never go in against a Sicilian when death is on the line.
- Clobbersmith 11y agoHow can something "just drop" over 16 months? I think it's amazing that solar is becoming more affordable, but a year and a half is hardly sudden.
- therealdrag0 11y agoI'm curious as to the reasons behind the drop, and if that has anything to do with solar being solar. Could the same thing have happened for wind or nuclear given certain social and political pressures and incentives to innovate and mass-produce?
- sc90 11y agoHow low would it have dropped minus incentives/subsidies?
- ry_ry 11y agoSolar remains a long-term choice, though. I love the idea, but I'll have sold my current house before a suite of solar panels pays for itself, and from my limited knowledge, the price of solar-equipped houses doesn't reflect the investment before it's paid for itself. Disclosure: UK, we have no sunshine.
- downandout 11y ago"One can suspect that Masdar had access to long-term financing through the wealthy emirate of Abu Dhabi that no commercial banks, the primary source of capital for the other bidders, could match in cost." I was excited by this headline until I read the article. This price drop is the result of advances in financial - not technical - engineering. It means nothing for the cost of solar outside of this specific deal, as below-market interest rates are just more subsidies. This is yet another eco-clickbait headline.
- SFJulie 11y agoI hate these stupid work hours anyway that create this stupid habit of burning energy when it is not "naturally available". Couldn't changing the business hour according to the sun and wind be the real cost killer? No technologies, no investments involved, it just requires one smart boss, some smart accountant and employees. Imagine it: people would have no way to avoid raising their kids during the down season, we could fire teacher, single could do art, we could stop funding culture and it would be popular culture, maybe science, less working hours, but more people would have to work. It would solve quite a few problem.
- daveheq 11y agoAnd the world marches ahead of America
- Animats 11y agoIt's time to get most air conditioning load onto solar. In the US, areas south of 37° (central California across to everything south of Virginia) should have enough local solar power to drive daytime air conditioning. For that, we don't need storage, we don't need to feed much power back into the grid, and air conditioning is the big residential load. 21% of electricity consumption in the South is for air conditioning. This is a no-brainer right now. Here's an application for "smart power" technology. When a cloud comes over and blocks the sun, air conditioner compressors should shut down temporarily. If the cloud cover remains, start up again, on a somewhat random time delay, to give generators time to respond. (This will probably be implemented with some overly complex system that involves "the cloud", rather than being done by a simple broadcast signal.)
- lucasmullens 11y agoGoogle Project Sunroof can tell you if you should invest in solar based on your roof area [0] [0] https://www.google.com/get/sunroof https://www.google.com/get/sunroof
- martinald 11y agoThis headline is beyond misleading. The reason this bid was so low that it is financed by a state owned company in Abu Dhabi. "One can suspect that Masdar had access to long-term financing through the wealthy emirate of Abu Dhabi that no commercial banks, the primary source of capital for the other bidders, could match in cost." The cost of capital is the most important thing on these projects. If you're getting below market capital financing then no shit, prices are going to fall a lot.
- einarvollset 11y agoWithout even reading comments: the naysayers are talking about peak demand when the sun is not shining. What they're missing: distributed, fault tolerant energy storage using eg Tesla powerwall.
- Iv 11y agoPretty trivial remark, but when the prices are so low, leading to most prices have two trailing zeros, couldn't we maybe switch for another unit than $/kWh ? Maybe $/MWh ? So we are currently at 29.9$/MWh. For information, the average household in the world uses 3 MWh per year and a typical US one does a bit more than 10 MWh. Advanced and ecologically minded countries like Germany go down to 3 MWh. Keep in mind that the location is important. Dubai has a lot of sun, you would not get this price with the same tech in, say, Canada.
- ksec 11y agoWhat about land cost? Do the cost stated there include land cost? What about in places where land is expensive?
- disposeofnick9 11y agoThe price of raw cells are super cheap now and if you're willing to reearch, engineering and DIY, you can build great panels for even cheaper. As many large projects come online, both li-ion and solar are going to fall through the floor faster than Moore's Law for some time, and the slow down. I suspect solar deployment will take the US by surprise, because of the compelling economics. Hint: go long on SCTY
- wesleyd 11y agoThe idea of an always-on grid sized for peak demand is going to seem hopelessly anachronistic in just a few years. Third world power grids - frequent outages, sized for average load, cheap in every sense, barely regulated - are the future
- wesleyd 11y agoIt still amazes me that here in silicon valley, no available electricity tariff reflects the timing of the supposed solar glut.