25 ms·
Online Dating and the Death of the 'Mixed-Attractiveness' Couple
- exolymph 11y agoDon't we sort ourselves this way in person too, though?
- zhemao 11y agoI think the issue is that physical attractiveness is one of many traits we judge potential partners by in person. But it's the primary trait used online because it's often the only piece of information we have.
- roel_v 11y agoDid you even skim the article?
- lsc 11y agoI thought that the parent comment was suggesting that we sort ourselves by physical attractiveness for social groupings in the general case, e.g. most people hang out with other people who are fairly similar in looks, style, ethnicity and income
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago> most people hang out with other people who are fairly similar in looks, style, ethnicity and income Physical attractiveness correlates pretty well with income. I don't think people pair much with ethnicity these days, more with cultural compatibility. Eg: Muslims and Christians are less likely to mate than Christians and Atheists. I can imagine though that people reject other ethnicities outright if they assume a certain cultural background.
- lsc 11y ago(this is largely irrelevant to the discussion, but it's an interesting sidetrack, I think) >Physical attractiveness correlates pretty well with income. In the bit of the world where I live, there seems to be almost an inverse correlation between physical attractiveness and income, just because nearly all the high-income folks I know are serious computer types, which (at least before a few years back) correlated with not taking particularly good care of your body, in part because physical attractiveness mattered a lot less when getting a computer industry job than in nearly any other industry. When me and my friends or co-workers went out to lunch, the service staff was almost always way more attractive than we were. Now, there's some pretty obvious selection bias there, of course, and I don't doubt that you are mostly correct (if you correct for age, first) with a large enough and random enough sample size, but in the context of this website, the sample isn't particularly random.
- exolymph 11y agoYes, this is what I meant. Sorry if that was unclear.
- jack9 11y ago> When was the last time you met a couple where one person was attractive and the other was not? Kristen Bell and Dax Shepard (Dax is jacked, but that's not part of his movie persona) Olivia Wilde and Jason Sudeikis Katy Perry and Russell Brand but not Britney Spears and Kevin Federline (from a visual pov) but he was in a different social class. I don't understand who thought this was a demonstrably true premise. The concept of beauty has been expanded. There's no validation of the attractiveness ladder theory which this article is leveraging up front. Attractiveness does not lend well to that stratification.
- s_m_t 11y agoHoly shit if those guys are unattractive I am FUCKED
- X-Istence 11y agoWelp, looks like I am out too.
- marincounty 11y agoThose guys are smart enough to play down their looks for good comedic roles. I've seen both when they are not in character, and they look like leading men. I used to get paid to take portraits. I can guarantee some people just don't photograph well. They might be a 10 in person, but a 6 on film. I still haven't figured it out completely. I think current society puts too much importance in what a person looks like in a picture. In two psychology classes in college, I was told people end up with someone who is attractive as they are, but where I live--well let's just say if a fugley man makes a lot of money, or does someting society affirms him for, he can marry/mate way out of his league. Sit in Mill Valley, or Tiburon, CA on a weekend afternoon and try to figure out what that female saw in that guy. (I'm just speaking for myself. I'm probally wrong. If I offended you, I'm sorry. I will probally still get hammered though.) It seems to work in a contrarian way for women? I have seen women work so hard to have a powerful career, and money, and the guy is looking at the maid. I don't think it's fair, but I've seen it happen too often. (Don't beat me up over this last sentance--I'm probally wrong, and it's not the least bit politically correct.) I do see it changing a bit. Dependent attractive women are not as desirable as they once were, especially if they use their looks to get ahead, and the guy knows what she's doing. I gave found the whole mating process screwed up, and steps we get to marriage even worse. Using a one dimensional picture to weed out potential mates, seems almost as bad as bar hopping. At least with bar hopping, you could weed out the wrong ones pretty quick?
- s_dev 11y agoAs long as there remains a degree of wealth inequality and as long as wealth attracts -- the "mixed-attractiveness" couple will probably remain. Online dating maybe an influencing factor in peoples choice of partner but it isn't the only one.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago> As long as there remains a degree of wealth inequality and as long as wealth attracts -- the "mixed-attractiveness" couple will probably remain. If I remember correctly wealth inequality in couples is becoming rarer and rarer as well. I think that's the article I read about this: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/27/upshot/marriages-of-power-couples-reinforce-income-inequality.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/27/upshot/marriages-of-power-...
- cloudjacker 11y agothe article you linked was in regard to marriage. wealth gives you gaggles of companions of whatever variety you want. this is parallel to a marriage.
- hoodoof 11y agoWomen like funny men. That's been my experience. Funny is attractive. Self confidence plays a big role too, which goes with funny. Not "jerk self confidence", but "talk to you comfortably self confidence". Also, I don't rely on online dating. I'm not a "player" by any stretch of the imagination, but life is too short to wonder what a woman would have said, so if I see a woman I like, I talk to her and ask her out if its appropriate. Politely and unintrusively. You risk nothing except rejection and stand to gain a whole lot more. Life gives to people who ask.
- rectify 11y agoIf by funny you mean attractive face.
- cheriot 11y agoThat's the thing about real life interaction. She's now making a decision with more information than your photo and there's no lineup of photos next to you. The articles point is that the longer you know someone, the less their attractiveness matters. I suspect that slope starts rather quickly.
- beachstartup 11y agothe vast majority of ugly people are only 'ugly' because they're too fat or too skinny. it's amazing how good looking your face becomes when you're in shape and have a decent amount of muscle mass with definition.
- neverminder 11y agoNot really. Attractiveness of face is all about symmetry and proportion. For example: If you have a huge nose or a massive protruding mole you'll never be attractive no matter your body composition. I'm sure an algorithm could be (already is) composed to verify attractiveness of face.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago
- sndean 11y ago> Dating Site OKCupid, for example, has shown that its users routinely rate members of their own race as more attractive. > In this case, the data is clear that men’s preferences are much more homogenous than women’s. “There are women who 95% of men say yes to, and there’s nothing like that for men,” says McLeod. “A man is really attractive if 40% of women say yes.” So women have more complicated taste than men. But there are probably certain clusters of women (based on demographics, location, etc.) who'd find a specific look attractive at a rate higher than 40%. There'd be a "George Clooney cluster" and a "Leonardo DiCaprio cluster". I just need to find the sndean cluster.
- cheriot 11y agoThat's been my experience. I appeal to a relatively small subset of women, but using OKC in a major city I was able to meet plenty of women in that subset.
- nroets 11y agoThe reason why so many woman find Clooney or DiCaprio so attractive is not their looks. It's things like being the center of attention.
- estefan 11y agoWealth + status
- coldtea 11y agoWell, it's not that simple, because there are men like Clooney and DiCaprio in "everyday" life too, who don't have wealth and status, but who do get most of the women swoon for them... (And the opposite: people with wealth and status that only attract cheap gold-digger types, and women in general could not care less for).
- estefan 11y agoYes, it's not a one-size fits all. I recommend The Evolution of Desire or The Red Queen. Both fascinating.
- spacehome 11y agoWow, this article is really written from a shockingly myopic male point of view. What men find attractive in women is primarily looks, but what women look for in men is a lot more holistic. You can't have a discussion of mixed-attractiveness couples without figuring out what women are attracted to, and it's not primarily visual.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago> but what women look for in men is a lot more holistic. Citation needed. Pretty sure physical attractiveness is something both genders can judge pretty well and clearly it plays a role in relationships also because it is something you can influence to a degree which also implies a certain type of behavior.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- enraged_camel 11y ago>>What men find attractive in women is primarily looks, but what women look for in men is a lot more holistic. Pay attention to the looks on your female friends' faces next time they notice a muscular guy with a six pack jogging down the street and you'll quickly let go of this belief.
- FilterSweep 11y agoI believe there's some truth into both comments. Let me ask you - would you notice any difference in their faces if muscular guy jogging is 5'8" or 6'2"? I sure would.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoGoing to agree with the_mutsuhiko and ask for a citation there. A woman who isn't as intelligent as she is physically attractive isn't all that interesting. And to be honest, after dealing with an ex-girlfriend of mine, I'd love to avoid people with self-image problems, drug problems, and staggering amounts of debt.
- simula67 11y ago> Tinder calls each user’s ranking his or her “elo score.” The term comes from the world of professional chess, where elo scores are used to rank players. If an average player beats a grandmaster, her score increases significantly. So there is a penalty for swiping right always. All the people claiming that folks should swipe right always and then select from matches were wrong.
- EGreg 11y agoThat's a non sequitur. The ELO is calculated when someone swipes right on YOU. When you swipe right or left on a woman, you are affecting her ELO, not your own.
- djhn 11y agoHopefully corrected by your enthusias/selectiveness towards everyone in general.
- shoyer 11y agoIt's still not clear to me that there's any feedback to the user based on how they swipe. Tinder could simply be adjusting scores of the people being rated. I can see the feedback loop going very wrong if how you rate others has a significant impact impact on your own attractiveness score. I don't think it serves Tinder's interests to reward people for swiping left more often -- they benefit when people use their platform, which requires getting matches. I'm sure Tinder has experimented with penalizing users who always swipe right, but probably not by adjusting the attractiveness nob. Always swiping right doesn't make you any less attractive, but it might suggest you're less likely to engage when someone likes you back. If Tinder is optimizing for maximizing user engagement, this would naturally enter into their pairing algorithm in a different way. That said, the last thing Tinder wants to do is discourage the hypothetical "super user" who is very attractive, always swipes right and goes on tons of dates.
- raverbashing 11y agoThe second sentence does not conclude from the first Because even when "swiping right always" people will filter the obvious non-matches Especially given Tinder limits amount of right swipes for free plans.
- todd8 11y agoAttractiveness is, as everyone should recognize, subjective. Some people are very sensitive to height and some are very sensitive to intelligence and so forth. After being married for the period when most people were finding partners, I divorced and started dating again. I realized that I wasn't very good at small-talk, and I was having trouble meeting women. The HN comments here are full of suggestions, but they are isolated and not systematic. By now I'm sure that everyone is aware of the "pick-up artist" community on the internet. I'm not a fan of the idea of learning how to impress as many women as one can in order to have sex with someone you really don't care about, but while that almost underground community was still nascent I read about it and decided that it was something interesting enough to investigate. I traveled to southern California and met Mystery, the person described in Neil Strauss's (at the time) new book, The Game. I hung out with them for two days and was invited to go out one evening with them. There were around a dozen guys in the group and it was a very fascinating evening. No, I didn't pick up a girl in a club and get laid, but talking to the guys was very interesting it did change things for me. Most of the guys I met were like me. They were lonely and wanted a serious girlfriend and had always had trouble approaching and striking up conversations with stangers. I was always able to talk to people from my field or other academically inclined people, but I learned to be more interesting to others and to understand attraction from both sides. It helped my confidence tremendously and consequently I found more women attracted to me. That's a long introduction to my recommendations: - don't get caught up in the manipulative techniques being promulgated by the recent pick-up experts - learn more about attraction by reading some of the early stuff talked about by, say, Mystery - approach more strangers and stike up conversations (you don't need to be online to meet people) - develop a wider circle of friends - get out and make your life itself more interesting by finding new interests, this make you interesting to others - take your company public! Success helps. Generally, I've found online dating to be a slow, frustrating process. It's much better to simple strike up conversations with people that you find attractive. The time to line up dates online and exchange information and then discover that the person is nothing like their old high school photos is disheartening.
- colmvp 11y ago> Attractiveness is, as everyone should recognize, subjective. Some people are very sensitive to height and some are very sensitive to intelligence and so forth. While it's subjective, there are stats from MANY dating sites that show having certain traits (e.g. tall black guy or short Asian woman) will give you an advantage in dating over others (short Asian guy or tall black woman). Oktrends showed tall guys unequivocally have more sexual partners than short men.
- alistproducer2 11y agoI am married, but was given a pass to use Tinder while researching a dating app. One of the most interesting things that came from it is that I saw a definite pattern in the women who swiped right on me. Dating apps are markets where we are the commodity. If I were to assign a number to my matches, they would've all been in the same range. From that I extrapolate that I must be in that same number range to the opposite sex. I got true "price discovery" for myself.
- stuxnet79 11y agoThat's interesting. I'd be very interested in determining my "market value". So on the app you can tell which women swiped right on you and which didn't? I am going to install Tinder tonight to check it out then.
- emodendroket 11y agoAFAIK you both have to agree and then you'll be shown each other, although I wonder how well this works since as I understand most men just swipe right to everything without even looking and then cancel if they get a match they don't want
- Grishnakh 11y agoI've had some interesting experiences here. I live a little over an hour outside of a major metro area that has a lot of single women. Sitting at home swiping, I get almost no matches, and when I tried swiping right on everyone once, the results weren't great, making it seem like my "number" isn't as high as I thought. But then when I go into the city on the weekend and start swiping, I get a boatload of matches from much more attractive women, the kind I really do want to date. It's just like they say in real estate: location, location, location. If you're not a good match or cultural fit for the single women in your area (I'm not), and you're a bit too far for a lot of people to want to bother dating you, the "market" is going to look really bad.
- draw_down 11y agoI've noticed a similar effect between the mid-sized city I live in and when I opened my dating app while visiting SF. The women in SF I matched with seemed "cooler" and were significantly more physically attractive. And in reverse, when I go to the little town in western MD where I grew up, the results are pretty abysmal. As far as maximizing one's own rating, there are a number of subtle signifiers that can be deployed (though it's unethical to outright lie about yourself) and it helps to not be cliche. And of course, the basic matter of having good photos of oneself. Good lighting, well dressed, taken with a longer focal length than a smartphone camera, etc. (I don't fully understand the effect myself, but longer focal length tends to result in a more flattering photo)
- panglott 11y agoLooks like HN is obssessed with physical attractiveness. Humans are interested in other things about their mate as well: intelligence, for example. In surveys, nearly everyone reports that they would like a mate at least as or more intelligent than them. And we rarely have good, direct signs of intelligence, so we use things like language, humor, &c. People also care about in-group membership, social class, and many other things. There is some correlation of physical attractiveness to income &c., in that more attractive people do make more money than less attractive people on average, but I would need more evidence to say this correlation is strong. Look at that chart: the main way straight people meet their partners is through friends. In-person meeting pairings vastly outweigh online meeting pairings. Back in the 1940s, people meet through friends, through family, in elementary or high school, or by being neighbors. I shudder to see the rise of "at a bar", but online dating is a huge, huge improvement.
- emodendroket 11y agoThey are... but isn't something like Tinder essentially just showing you a photo and letting you decide? That would encourage the opposite behavior... which is what the article says.
- nish1500 11y agoIf people were actually looking for what they report in surveys, attractiveness would be half as important, and intelligence twice as much.
- baron816 11y agoThis is something I hope to address with my company, [Krewe](https://www.gokrewe.com/get_started https://www.gokrewe.com/get_started). It allows you to meet people and get to know them before you go on a date with them. It places you into a small social group and gradually allows you to expand that group so you can build up a big network of people in your neighborhood.
- cableshaft 11y agoIn what way is your concept different from meetup groups on meetup.com?
- PaulRobinson 11y agoTinder is not an app people seem to use to find "the one". From speaking to people who use Tinder (I settled down some years ago, so my experience of online dating was limited to OKCupid and PoF which were big back then), that the traditional route of finding a future spouse is still open, and Tinder is for hook-ups, one night stands, short relationships or maybe finding "friends with benefits" type relationships. None of them are thinking they're going to find their future spouse on Tinder, that would be a nice bonus. Tinder is an app for getting laid. When I was single and I went to a bar because I wanted to get laid (and I'm prepared to admit I was shallow enough to want to do this on occasion), my search parameters were very, very different than when I decided I wanted to settle down and find somebody to share my life with. I don't think I'm unusual in this. This article takes a slim premise and develops a hypothesis as fact that is too large a burden for it: that because on Tinder people are making flash judgements based on attractiveness, long-term relationships will change in their fundamental structural nature as relates to attractiveness. This is nonsense. Tinder is an asynchronous singles bar. It's the same behaviour that has been going on for hundreds - perhaps thousands - of years, but you can raise the bar of what you're looking for in terms of attractiveness if you yourself are attractive because you are not time-bound to last orders at the bar, and you are less likely to drop inhibitions because you are hopefully not constantly drunk whilst using it. Sure, people might get married after meeting on Tinder, just as they do after a hook-up from meeting drunk in a bar. But falling in love at work or based on a long social relationship is not suddenly going to stop happening because of Tinder.
- saturdaysaint 11y agoIf you haven't been in the dating pool for a long time, this is sort of like someone in Duluth making sweeping statements about Silicon Valley culture. Sex is undeniably part of Tinder's allure, but consider that the lascivious media stories and coworker jokes make it a lot less likely that couples that met through Tinder are going to volunteer the information. You're going to be misled by quite a bit of sampling bias if you just go by what you've heard. As someone engaged to someone I met on Tinder, and I met a lot of attractive, relationship-minded women, Tinder is just far and away the most efficient way to meet attractive women. Even if you're looking for a relationship, the idea of placing any weight in elaborately written profile statements (which often tell you far less than 10 seconds in front of a person) and sending messages to random women on OK Cupid seems like a waste of time. Tinder takes all of the most awkward "breaking the ice" parts of looking for a hook-up OR a partner and turns them into a fun little swipe game. I'll also add that most women I met on Tinder weren't above a hook-up but not-so-subtly had a relationship on the agenda, and that this affects guys behavior. If you sleep with an attractive, compatible woman a few times, it's not unheard of to start to form a friendship, at which point most (not all) guys in our society start to blanche at the idea of her doing the same with other partners. There's also the fact that for many of us, hook-up sex isn't even the best sex. So there's a natural draw to exclusivity.
- LoSboccacc 11y ago"I looked so hard for x that when y dataset confirmed my feeling, I ran to the press" - social studies in a nutshell.
- iopuy 11y agoI don't believe Tinder's elo ranking is used in any sort of significant manner within the app. Maybe it influences the order in which profiles are displayed but you can easily exhaust an geographical location of users. I'd be terrified if some of the women I'mean shown on there have elo rankings comparable to mine, not so much if the results are comprehensive.
- tmsam 11y agoIn the chart of trends in how people meet, there is a suspicious uptick in "at a restaurant/bar" in the last few years... that is totally just a cover for people who met on Tinder and then got serious.
- creshal 11y agoYep. I can brag to my friends I found hookups on Tinder, but I can't tell my parents I found my spouse there. (If only because I want to avoid the "tinwhat?" discussion.)
- cm2187 11y agoOnline dating doesn't really have any stigma anymore. People aren't shy about it.
- jnbiche 11y ago> any stigmata anymore I'm assuming this was a spell check issue. Stigma is the appropriate word here. Stigmata are these: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stigmata https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stigmata
- cm2187 11y agoActually it's me being temporarily dyslexic! Let's still call it a typo. Thanks
- zem 11y agostigmata is also just the plural of stigma; that usage hasn't disappeared yet.
- jnbiche 11y agoOh? Can you point me to an instance of that usage, where "stigmata" is used as a plural of "stigma" (meaning: a socially-ostracizing feature or trait), in a contemporary, edited publication? A will grant that it's sometimes used in the medical literature to mean "a clear, diagnostic sign of some illness", but the allusion there is to the stigmata of Christianity. I've never, ever seen it used to mean the plural of stigma as the word is commonly used in English.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- erikb 11y agoIs it possible to find your elo ranking in Tinder somewhere?
- rmc 11y agoI've never used Tinder, but if they have an office in the EU, then they fall under EU Data Protection Directive, and hence they're required to tell you what personal data they hold on you. If they are US only, well, that's why the Safe Harbour law was struck down.
- hkjgkjy 11y agoYet another good reason to stay away from/not start tech companies in the EU. // European entrepreneur with grudges towards the EU gov
- kaio 11y agoWhy do you feel this is bad? If you use my personal data and score me with some obscure system, i think it is just fair to tell me. If you score me bad, i deserve at least to know it before i run into problems Ok.. for a dating app it might not be that important but rating systems like the schufa(credit trust network) already have big influence on my daily live.
- hkjgkjy 11y agoWell, you are saying it's not that bad yourself! Scheiße Mann. The EU takes bigger mandates than it should. I'd wish for it to keep the peace and let people trade and travel freely, but why should it decide more? When Berlusconi (the Donald Trump of Italy) was in power a good argument used to be "why would I want the Italians to decide who is in my parliament, if they vote someone like that into their own?" The Data Retention Directive (Datalagringsdirektivet in my language, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Retention_Directive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_Retention_Directive) is a shit law that invades my privacy. My government (the Swedish) has been paying high fines for years because they didn't implement it. It was deemed illegal in 2014. Having to pay the VAT (Mehrwertsteuer) at the rate of the country where the customer is located, having to include the stupid cookie notice. I mean, the list goes on with just countless stupid things that Brüssels bureaucrats feel the need to enforce upon all of us. The free trade in EU is great for trade, but for online business they are causing more pain than good.
- ImTalking 11y agoAbout 3 weeks ago, I was having dinner with my 15 yo daughter at a restaurant in a very high traffic area. We were people-watching and we came to the conclusion that people very rarely chose a mate outside of their own appearance level. If the woman is unattractive, then her mate is unattractive, and the converse. We did our little experiment for about 30 minutes, and did not see any couple where one was significantly more/less attractive than the other.
- ekianjo 11y agoThis certainly does not seem to apply in Japan where women who look for mariage are far more interested in status and money than the guy's age or looks. I see that constantly.
- neverminder 11y agoI'm pretty sure this applies to other countries as well. Women are drawn to powerful men, because power translates to stability and security for the family.
- FilterSweep 11y agothis is where the myth of "outkicking coverage" comes into play.
- draugadrotten 11y ago''Our generation of women is constantly told to have high self-esteem, but it seems that the women themselves are at risk of ego-tripping themselves out of romantic connection,'' ...''They are with an '8' but they want a '10'. But then suddenly they're 40 and can only get a '5'!'' http://www.smh.com.au/lifestyle/life/why-women-lose-the-dating-game-20120421-1xdn0.html http://www.smh.com.au/lifestyle/life/why-women-lose-the-dati...
- nailer 11y agoWomen's value is primarily measures by beauty, men by power - we might dislike this, but that doesn't change it. These peak at different times for each gender.
- tempodox 11y agoThis is giving dating apps too much credit. They don't work for the same reasons dating websites don't work.
- raverbashing 11y agoYes, dating websites won't solve your personal issues
- tempodox 11y agoI must have really pissed you off if you're going ad hominem. Do you run a dating app? http://www.cbsnews.com/news/online-dating-services-dont-work-scientists-say/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/online-dating-services-dont-work...
- sbarre 11y agoMaybe he's just generalizing in the same way you are? ;-)
- raverbashing 11y agoTake the "your" as a generic indicator, dating services won't fix one's personal problem No I don't run a dating site and I get few matches from them, but I bet your success's got more to do with yourself than necessarily with the app A lot of people do have dates through those apps The link you provided is from 2012 and is specific about the matching algorithm, which you are free to try to find a better one
- tempodox 11y agoIf the landscape had fundamentally changed since 2012, we would have heard of it for sure. No marketing department would let that slide. Besides, you can call finding another person that one clicks with a “personal issue” all you want, but it's the problem dating services set out to solve, or so they say.
- EGreg 11y agoThis article outright says that women still don't agree on attractiveness while men largely do. So, it doesn't bear out its own conclusion. It just goes round and round with different side points.
- justatdotin 11y agophew! in before ...
- prawn 11y agoI've long thought that in being able to instantly compare someone visually to countless alternatives, online dating makes people overly picky. As such, I've always wanted to build a dating site/app that rate-limited the number of people shown so viewers would be encouraged to read profiles and consider things a bit more. Dating crossed with Deal of the Day.
- Tenoke 11y agoLike https://coffeemeetsbagel.com/ https://coffeemeetsbagel.com/ ?
- colmvp 11y agoI'll just say that CFB isn't more or less better than other online dating sites in the regard of being 'picky.' I've used it for the last four months and have gotten a grand total of... drumroll please one date. And trust me, I've been really kind to like many women of various interests and ethnicities. I've also been thoughtful in my messaging to women.
- prawn 11y agoYes, that has the general idea!
- rsmsky1 11y agoIt hasn't worked for me. They keep showing me guys outside my preferences, so I stopped using it.
- massysett 11y agoI think that's what eharmony does.
- noir_lord 11y agoI met someone online who had an absolutely fascinating (to me) profile she listed a bunch of authors I liked, my opening message was a question of which protagonist she preferred from the two sets of books and she was also also into a lot of the same stuff as me (politics and history) but didn't have a profile picture. We had long conversations and I had no idea what she looked like for the first month or so, she commented that I hadn't asked for a picture which men normally do straight away, my response was "I enjoy talking to you". She eventually sent a picture when we arrange to go on a date last week, turns out she is absolutely stunning (not I find her attractive, I mean objectively stunning) and the reason she took her picture off was all the "Hey baby, want sum fuk?" messages she was getting. Date went well and we are going out again soon, I'm not handsome, I'm pretty average looking except for been in decent physical shape (swimming, cycling and dropping 60lbs will do that), frankly if I'd known what she looks like first I probably wouldn't have sent her a message in the first place figuring I didn't have a chance. The world is a strange place sometimes.
- nxzero 11y agoIdea that people make logical choices when it comes to dating is nonsense. Most people when looking for a long-term relationship are more set on being in control than finding the right person. Beyond that, most people end up in a relationship not by choice, but out of habit. Ran into a guy joining Tinder the other day, he said they were saying the valuation for the company was a billion... :-)
- Lio 11y agoA small off topic point based on the article, it's not "ELO" or "elo" it's "Elo" as in Mr. Arpad Elo, the Hungarian-American mathematician and chess player. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arpad_Elo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arpad_Elo
- SeanDav 11y ago> http://blog.okcupid.com/index.php/we-experiment-on-human-beings/ http://blog.okcupid.com/index.php/we-experiment-on-human-bei... I found the referenced article to OkCupid rather interesting. It seems that if you can block people from visually seeing each other, until the actual blind date, then even very attractive women report having a great time with very plain men. So it seems that while people will almost invariably filter and match each other on looks if that option is open (which it usually is these days), but at the end of the day, looks are not important if you can meet in person first.
- colmvp 11y agoOn the flip side when I read Washington Posts Date Lab, it's pretty clear right off the bat whether the lack of mutual physical attraction will result in follow up dates.
- kfk 11y agoMatch making is a very interesting topic, I had a go at a very simple algo few years ago: https://github.com/kfk/scripts/blob/master/match-date.py https://github.com/kfk/scripts/blob/master/match-date.py The output is clear: even random matching has a higher score than all girls (or boys) liking the same boys (or girls). This is, indeed, a serious problem if you take that people nowadays have access to: 1. An enormous pool of potential partners 2. A lot more information The .2 is particularly worrisome. It is clear that too much information early in the interaction can actually bring to suboptimal equilibrium. The thing is, when you know everything about somebody you tend to act on your most superficial preferences, getting to know gives you access to a much deeper connection (and a much better choice).
- amelius 11y agoPeople are underestimating the importance of smell in the equation. I want a smell-based Tinder. Seriously, most of the girls I met online seemed to have incompatible pheromones. Unfortunately, specifying smell is not possible, I suppose because of the huge gap in science w.r.t. the olfactory system. This is curious because from an evolutionary perspective smell is the sense that developed before the other senses.
- rprime 11y agoCheck this out https://smell.dating https://smell.dating. Posted recently on HN as well.
- PerryCox 11y agoThat sounds pretty creepy but I can understand how big of a factor smell is in regards to dating.
- atom-morgan 11y agoYes and anything else that influences hormones (birth control). Don't marry a woman if she's never been around you off of the pill.
- amelius 11y agoGood point. By the way, I've heard that the sense of smell of a woman changes during pregnancy. A friend told me that she didn't like the smell of her husband while she was pregnant. Not that it matters much in this case :) but interesting anyway.
- wcummings 11y ago>Don't marry a woman if she's never been around you off of the pill. This is an extraordinary statement that requires extraordinary evidence.
- atom-morgan 11y ago
- k__ 11y agoWell, I met most of my partners RL. I have specific tastes and somehow I'm bad in writing people on dating sites the "first message". The only people I met from dating sites wrote me first. Also, many people look different on photos than in RL. And some people are only attractive after I talked to them in person for a while. I still like online dating websites. I find about one person a year online, that I like. Most of those won't become serious relationships, but it's nice to meet new people from outside my filter bubble once in a while.
- dataker 11y agoYou can't just "ditch" online dating to find something serious. More and more, people seem to mistrust and misunderstand face-to-face communication. Sometimes, they even lack the words to describe a meme or emoji. For the majority of us, If you talk to a random stranger in a coffee shop/museum/gym, the conversation will be often awkward or reckless.
- rsmsky1 11y agoI think some guys are completely delusional about their looks. I've had morbidly obese guys hit on me when I'm a fit woman. I've also specified in my profile that I like to exercise and am looking for someone who is in shape. I also think somehow my attractiveness isn't coming out as well in photos as it is in person. At least that's what my friends have told me but maybe they're lying.
- Unklejoe 11y agoMaybe your face is just uglier than you think? :) Just kidding. I have the same experience as a man. I'm no George Clooney, but I have all of my teeth and consider myself to be "average" looking. That said, I get messages from women who are very unattractive to me (morbidly obese is common). But I can't knock them for it. Maybe the girls that I message are saying the exact same thing about me. Who knows. The problem is that there's basically nothing to lose by sending someone a message.
- rsmsky1 11y agoWell the thing is I specify in my profile the body type that I am looking for which is not obese or morbidly obese since I like to exercise and it's important to me. When emailing guys at least I look at their preferences and only email if I meet those preferences. I think online dating should offer better message filtering so those people don't get to our inbox.And some guys lie about their body type as when I see their photos they say they're athletic and toned when they're morbidly obese.
- mariodiana 11y agoPeople don't read the directions on the over the counter medications they're taking, so don't be surprised if there are people sending you messages who haven't bothered to read your profile.
- Overtonwindow 11y agoI think online dating has killed the culture of courtship. It makes it too easy to reject people for the most superficial reasons, and gives the illusion that the dating pool is much, much larger than it really is.
- Unklejoe 11y agoAgreed. In my generation, it comes off as awkward to approach a person in the bar or other social gather and try to start a conversation, but it's completely normal to send a random person a message on Facebook telling them that they're beautiful.
- Overtonwindow 11y agoThis. Right. Here. Screwing up the courage and calling someone on the phone and asking them out is seen as creepy, and weird. Yet stalking them online and sending dick pics is just "funny." Our parents would have never met in today's society. Relevent: https://xkcd.com/642/ https://xkcd.com/642/
- rileyteige 11y agoOn the other hand, I met my wife 5 years ago at my college's swing and salsa dancing clubs, and I always found it much more awkward to get a random message from someone on Facebook trying to flirt with me "digitally". To each their own. I don't know which generation is yours, but it really depends on the setting of the "social gathering" to determine whether approaching a member of the opposite sex would be considered awkward. I interacted with many women at that dancing club and had many opportunities to carry those into full-blown relationships. I see it often at dance clubs (talking ballroom, swing, salsa, etc. clubs) even outside of college. I am biased because of course that's where I met my wife, but many of my friends had the exact same experience.
- Overtonwindow 11y agoI'm 34 old. lol I think you did the right thing. My humble old man opinion is that we need to go back to that in-person dating, and social connection. Get offline and interact with one another. I applaud you sir.
- deadtofu 11y agoOne fun fact: Since Tinder requires a FB login, the DC OKCupid is chock filled with spooks.
- Wonnk13 11y agoInteresting... never thought of that. I hate the fact that i'd have to reactivate FB to just use a dating app.
- sakopov 11y agoOnline dating is the death of dating. Period. Dating apps and sites are making relationships disposable. People start treating relationships as this high which is only good while it's new and then they move on to the next great thing because it's always there and it's always waving you in. Nobody has an interesting courtship story. It's just a boring "Oh i thought she was hot and I messaged her" kind of thing. I only know 1 couple in their late 20s/early 30s where both partners are truly happy. Everybody else is just stuck in a perpetual mindfuck or is cheating their way to happiness. I you haven't read "Brave New World" I would highly recommend this book because it shows the society we're becoming.
- willvarfar 11y agoThere has always been people seeking out casual relationships. And there has always been people seeking out long term relationships. These are often the same people, at different times. Modern technology hasn't changed human nature, its only enabled efficiencies for those living in large cities. I know many couples who found each other through online dating and are in it for the long run.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- danneu 11y ago> It's just a boring "Oh i thought she was hot and I > messaged her" kind of thing. Just a stone's throw from "oh, I thought she was hot and I walked over to her" except that your scenario has the benefit of not being dependent on physically chancing across cute women as you romp through your daily life. You're not Hugh Grant in a romantic comedy, so all that matters is that you're getting the results you want and enjoying the ride. Online dating doesn't stop you from attending singles night at the roller rink, but it might give you more opportunities to find what you're looking for. That it's your Brave New World seems more indicative of personal self-limiting hangups about what courtship should be vs. what it actually is.
- yolesaber 11y agoYeah because no one is in satisfying real relationships anymore... Maybe you just need to expand your social circle. Sounds like you just have a sad sack group of friends.
- ohyes 11y agoTinder really replaces the subtle social signal of "hey you should come talk to me" most of the time that is based on looks.
- ska 11y agoDoes it even make sense to use the simple categorization into genders here? For example, is there any reason to think that typical 25 year olds are looking for the same thing that typical 35 year olds are even on the same site? Or gay people vs. straight people? Or ...
- cowardlydragon 11y agoI notice that bar/restaurant and online dating are the main gainers. So, real meat market, or virtual meat market, those are the primary gainers. We live in a very superficial society these days, so it isn't surprising...
- Wonnk13 11y agoAny advice for someone who doesn't currently have a FaceBook? I don't miss it, but it dramatically restricts the number of apps i'm able to use.
- animal531 11y agoI feel your pain. I immediately wiped Tinder when it asked me for a Facebook signup. But there are other apps such as Badoo etc, it just depends on where you live.
- wcummings 11y agoOnline dating is so dehumanizing. People must really crave validation to subject themselves to this.
- fitchjo 11y agoSo you are saying those that are seeking a partner/significant other are doing so because they crave validation? Not sure I really understand your thought process.
- ajarmst 11y agoFormally, this phenomena is referred to as Joel-Brinkley Asymmetry.
- thegayngler 11y agoI rarely meet someone I am actually attracted to online. I don't know what's wrong with me. Guys tend to want to hook up all the time but I prefer to like someone and have some attraction to them before hooking up.
- davidw 11y agoI do not miss dating one bit. Getting married was one of the best things I've ever done, and I enjoy it more and more as time goes on.
- rectify 11y agoFor those of you who may read "The Red Pill" and are familiar with its terms and have incorporated it in their worldview. I am here to tell you that that subreddit is actually "blue pilled" and omits a key fact about dating and sexual marketplace which is the following: Facial attractiveness trumps everything else. Women prefer beta guys with a better face to alpha guys with an unattractive face. There is no game, there is only face. That and not having aspergers syndrome.
- technocodes 11y agoYeah basically.
- stuxnet79 11y agoI`ve seen enough contrary evidence to not make this a truism across the board but I more or less agree with you.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoThat way lies "bone law" and things like http://forum.bodybuilding.com/showthread.php?t=156144623 http://forum.bodybuilding.com/showthread.php?t=156144623 (Link goes to a thread titled "You need a teardrop-shaped inner canthus to be facially aesthetic. No excuses!" and apparently written in all seriousness).
- reign341 11y agoCan't help but wonder where this game denialism stems from. I assume you were born with an ugly face and use that as an excuse to not work on yourself.
- Futurebot 11y agoMore on assortative mating and its effects: http://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21595972-how-sexual-equality-increases-gap-between-rich-and-poor-households-sex-brains-and http://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21595972-how-sex... http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/27/upshot/marriages-of-power-couples-reinforce-income-inequality.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/27/upshot/marriages-of-power-... http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21640316-children-rich-and-powerful-are-increasingly-well-suited-earning-wealth-and-power http://www.economist.com/news/briefing/21640316-children-ric...
- zw123456 11y agoI have actually wondered if online dating would have an effect on the gene pool over time. Perhaps to short of a time frame for "evolution" to be invoked, but selection perhaps. If "mixed" attractiveness couples are declining due to online dating, then over time, one could assume that there would become an "attractiveness divide". Could be the seed for a script pitch for a dystopian future film there :)
- TaylorGood 11y agoAny profile tips? Any discovered must-includes or avoid-mentioning-at-all-costs? Just downloaded again after reading this thread and curious as to what is working for some of you..
- rectify 11y agoWhy "apparently"? It seems like a sensible theory. You seem to have issues with reality, it may offend your noble sensibilities but real it is. Beauty is objective, there's ugly and then there's attractive. Holding hands, giving likes to politically correct comments on reddit and facebook to each other and singing kumbaya wont change reality.
- dang 11y ago> You seem to have issues with reality Personal attacks are not allowed on Hacker News, and the rest of this comment also breaks the guidelines by being snarky and dismissive while containing no information. Please post civilly and substantively, or not at all. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11474702 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11474702 and marked it off-topic.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- e0m 11y agoNotice that "At a bar/restaurant" rise in sync with "online". I bet a majority of those are people who met online but tell others (including the survey) that they met at a "bar". If you combine that increase with people who self-report meeting online, it may imply that as many people meet online as through friends.
- nono2222 11y agoIn our modern society being good looking has become extremely valuable. Even more so than being rich, being successful, or having an amazing personality. Just be good looking. Your life will be infinitely easier. I find it extremely funny how Indian and Chinese programmers are writing the code (Tinder,OkCupid) thats cucks themselves with Indian and Chinese women sleeping with white guys on Tinder whereas you almost never see the opposite scenario of white girls with Asian men.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]