17 ms·
Wealth doesn't trickle down – it just floods offshore, research reveals (2012)
- elcapitan 11y agoWith all the attacks from the left against allegedly "privileged" people, I can actually well understand why those people want to secure their property by moving it out of reach. The fun thing about this new outrage (the "Panama Papers") is that it will probably spawn more of that, in order to protect against the populist new regulations and taxations that will inevitably follow. The only thing I find regrettable is that it is not available for average incomes - I would love to have something like that. In case some massive redistribution schemes appear along the horizon, maybe a new industry around that will evolve.
- SCAQTony 11y agoThe poor are really pro at spending money. Then can turn trickle down into firehose-up and given the chance.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoThis is an important difference between the rich and the poor. The poor actually spend their money.
- Aeolos 11y agoWhich means that BI would stimulate the economy in a way that trickle-down economics cannot.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoYou understand that "stimulate" in the Keynesian context means "cause inflation and lower real wages", right? Why would this be a good thing in an economy at full employment?
- Aeolos 11y ago> Why would this be a good thing in an economy at full employment? This is a strawman argument. Apart from (arguably) Switzerland, what other economy is at full employment? > You understand that "stimulate" in the Keynesian context means "cause inflation and lower real wages", right? 1. Real wages have been decreasing year-over-year since the '50s. BI would not change that. 2. This is the least of the worries for the 19.9 million Americans who live in abject poverty, and the many more who have to choose between paying rent, food or transportation (=cannot even afford to find a liveable job.)
- yummyfajitas 11y agoThe US is at 5.5% unemployment, the UK at 5.4%, Germany at 4.8%. This is the ballpark of the natural rate of unemployment. Do you really believe there is a significant pool of workers who are unwilling to work currently, but might work if we inflated away the value of their sticky nominal wages (thereby fooling them into thinking they weren't taking a pay cut)? Where are they? (1) is just not true. Real comp (which is actually what I should have said, since comp is what determines buyer and seller willingness to trade) has done nothing but increase. https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/COMPRNFB https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/COMPRNFB If BI did not change this then it would not be stimulus. So which is it?
- CuriouslyC 11y agoJust to be fair, you should include labor force participation when quoting those low unemployment numbers. If you include people who gave up looking for a job after the meltdown we're closer to 9% unemployment.
- vkou 11y agoDon't forget to add underemployment to the list - people who have jobs, but not enough working hours to survive. In the US, at least, an incredibly common opinion is that those people are scum, and deserve nothing. It's very strange to hear you call it the 'natural rate of unemployment.' The human impact poverty has on the unemployed is devastating. (Yes, there is also the working poor.)
- dredmorbius 11y agoNB: This is a 2012 article.
- known 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income FTW
- negamax 11y agoI am seeing this response to many/all of the wealth disparity articles. I personally don't think this idea is properly analysed. I think people should rally for extension of basic services as human rights. Internet, electricity, food etc instead of a cheque at end of the month from the state. That seems more sustainable and works out as common infrastructure. Like roads for e.g. That will alleviate lives of many and will provide security, without creating any access and mismanagement in the system
- netcan 11y agoI'm also not a fan of Basic income being used as a catch-all answer and I'm not a fan of BI, as it's described in a lot of recently popular future looking leftists camps. But I am a proponent of BI generally. If we want post earnings wealth distributions (I don't think we can have our modern system of economy and governance without it), direct & simple redistribution is the best answer. Centralised provision of food is a terrible idea. It would destroy the economy of food production. Why do this? How is it better economically, more just or more effective to give people food or food stamps than it is to give them money to buy food?
- negamax 11y agoI get you. I am definitely not in the camp of central provisioning of food. But how's that different from BI? BI is pretty much central provisioning of resources. Yes it's money. But that money translates to resources. That's the point I was trying to make when mentioning about beefing up common infrastructure to a point where it's next to free to a degree. In other words, basic income should be replaced with basic minimalist modern life style. Giving people money, creates all kind of access and may even cause more disparity. What if people spend all the money on video games or alcohol or foreign holidays. Won't it be better instead of basic income we aim for better basic life for everyone?
- MrTonyD 11y agoBasic income doesn't solve this problem. I've worked with several executives who get to decide how much they want to "appear" to make in the United States -- all the rest is hidden offshore in stocks. The stocks they own have a very low "face value" -- since their value is set by transfers from other offshore stocks set up in a maze through different countries (so the Panama revelations won't catch them.) I have literally worked with executives hiding billions. Basic income does absolutely nothing to solve the problem of opaque financial instruments (derivatives, trusts, non-profits, and charities are also used to make money disappear. But mazes of offshores seems to be preferred by the rich people I have worked with - they are legal and well understood by all the big accounting firms.) It would be very easy to make holding such stock illegal. And, considering the cost to our society and our world, any downsides would be outweighed by the incredible gain.
- ageek123 11y agoDoesn't solve what problem? It doesn't solve the "problem" of some people being very rich, but it does solve the problem of some people being too poor to meet minimal daily needs.
- MrTonyD 11y agoA guaranteed income solves the income problem -- but that shouldn't be conflated with the causes of that problem that it solves. The massive income inequality, which is arguably an underlying cause of the problem, requires different solutions. Ironically, by correctly solving income inequality it may obviate the need for a guaranteed income - since other solutions may have that as a side effect.
- jensen123 11y ago> It would be very easy to make holding such stock illegal. Really? I think the USA already has many laws in place to make offshore tax evasion harder. These laws also have the effect of making it very hard for Americans to do (honest) financial stuff in other countries. For example, you want to buy a second home in another country, and maybe open a bank account there to take care of related bills? Or maybe you see some great investment opportunities in another country and want to open a brokerage account there, to buy some ordinary shares? Well, because of the laws already in place, many foreign banks don't want to deal with you, because complying with these laws is such a hassle. Well, I guess maybe it would be worthwhile for them if you were a billionaire. Also, you might end up with a tax bill of more than 100% of your gains back in the USA, if you're not careful.
- SixSigma 11y agoThey are breaking the social contract to operate. We give them limited liability, they give us the finger.
- ajuc 11y agoOffshore is down. What were you expecting?
- alexc05 11y agoIsn't that clever? Of course it is. Land is above "sea level" and all that. (Except when it's not, but in the whole macro sense land must be above sea level)
- xenadu02 11y agoSomething is wrong and broken with "modern capitalism" if a mere 90,000 people have more wealth than 90% of the planet. All the arguments about investment and job creators falls flat; we have gobs and gobs of excess capital desperately seeing some productive investment. Capitalists don't need any more capital at the moment. (Reminds me of the hedge fund carried interest exemption, which primarily benefits less than 100 people in the USA, with the vast majority of the benefit to the tune of > 1 billion dollars going to about ~5 people. So much so that they spent millions lobbying Congress to stop any attempt at closing the loophole and succeeded.) I wish the old Soviet Union was still around. The communist revolution scare put the fucking Fear of God into the capitalist class.
- Houshalter 11y agoMost that wealth only exists on paper sadly. If they were to actually withdraw it all at once and spend it, the value of the money itself would rapidly decrease. Likewise if you tried to tax all the wealth they are actually consuming, e.g. all their income or all their consumption, the amount doesn't come out so big either. IIRC it's between a few hundred and a few thousand dollars per person in the US.
- js8 11y agoBut that's exactly a sign of the problem! The money represent abstract power, not specific goods and services. This IMHO runs completely against the idea of free market, and the expectation that people will either consume or invest, instead of saving money (in order to gain power by postponing the economic decision).
- usrusr 11y agoYet ironically, the power derived from that wealth does not exist on paper, but is nonetheless very real.
- vixen99 11y agoI suppose you were either there and knew what it entailed or are clear on your facts? The Soviet Union at one late stage couldn't even supply sanitary towels for half its population and thus women had to tear up old clothes to take care of menstruation. But who cares as long as it put "the fucking Fear of God into the capitalist class". It didn't of course and thank goodness because the last 20 years of capitalism has seen the greatest decline in world poverty ever in the history of humanity. That's the result of letting individual humans make decisions about how they want to trade goods and services with other human beings. By the way, the Gini index ranks Bosnia, Ukraine, Ethiopia, Bangladesh, Egypt and Vietnam as more equal than the UK. But in which of these countries is it better to be poor?
- sambe 11y agoThere doesn't seem to much in the article to suggest it doesn't trickle down, so the headline is rather sensationalist. They are saying that lots of it goes off-shore, but unspent wealth will not "trickle down" anyway (granted, there is perhaps more incentive to spend if the alternative is getting taxed, but the extent is unclear). These people are likely still spending quite a substantial amount back into the economy (and tax, although obviously nowhere near what they "should" be). I do think there is general agreement that trickle down is not as effective as "advertised" but that doesn't mean zero effect. It's also worth noting that the headline figures are total amount saved offshore across all countries, not the tax on that amount (or its returns) for a given country and its alternative internal tax structures.
- Nutmog 11y agoAgreed. If they ever spend it, it'll trickle down. If they don't spend it, it'll be increasing the value of all the dollars that everybody else has - they've basically lending money to the rest of the world until such time as they decide to spend what they have, then it'll cause some inflation and the poor people will effectively be paying back that loan. If they never spend it, then everyone else wins. Setting fire to money or burying it in a hole is like donating it to everyone else who also has money. I don't understand what the problem is with a small number of people having a lot of money. What harm are they doing? Or is it simply plain old-fashioned jealousy?
- vinay427 11y ago> Or is it simply plain old-fashioned jealousy? Please don't make the mistake of thinking this is jealousy. There are plenty of wealthy Americans who generally oppose the wealth inequality we have today, and I can't imagine they are jealous of themselves for believing that. I think that if one is empathetic to those who grow up in different environments (whether it be of a different race, religion, or income bracket) then the realization is that they should have equal opportunities to succeed. That, in my opinion, doesn't seem very likely if so much money remains at the hands of those in the top wealth echelons. Could the nation succeed by putting business interests first? Perhaps, but at what cost to the vast majority of its people? To some, that cost is not acceptable.
- eveningcoffee 11y agoWell, this is what you believe it does, but is it proven or at least fairly convincingly demonstrated by at least some model or more thoughtful argumentation? I have not researched this topic or given any longer thought about this, so at this point I am honestly curious. For example how would the market react to this? Mostly what would happen with prices of essential goods and housing? More importantly, how would people react sexually? Would they start having more babies just because they now can? What group of people would pick up this behaviour? For example in my opinion most of the possible wealth accumulation in the third world countries is destroyed by very high population growth (in most countries above 4 times in 50 last years; fortunately this decreasing in many places). Is this mostly a solved problem for developed world?
- onion2k 11y agoWell, this is what you believe it does, but is it proven or at least fairly convincingly demonstrated by at least some model or more thoughtful argumentation? Yes. It's been modelled extensively, and has been found to work, and it's worked in different pilot programmes over the past 40 years - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income_pilots https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income_pilots Is this mostly a solved problem for developed world? 19.9 million Americans live in extreme poverty[1], so no it isn't. [1] http://www.worldhunger.org/articles/Learn/us_hunger_facts.htm http://www.worldhunger.org/articles/Learn/us_hunger_facts.ht...
- eveningcoffee 11y ago19.9 million Americans live in extreme poverty[1], so no it isn't. The question was not about the living conditions of the people but about their reproductive behaviour. I understand that this is mostly cultural phenomenon, so the question is, is this behaviour still prevalent in the dormant condition and will reappear when given opportunity. Yes. It's been modelled extensively, and has been found to work, and it's worked in different pilot programmes over the past 40 years - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income_pilots https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income_pilots Interesting list but I did not see any of my questions addressed there.
- jokoon 11y agoThis will keep going as long as people agree that survival of the fittest is a sound and fair argument to make the rules in society. Everyone is fending for themselves, and less and less people consider it to be a fair deal to contribute to society. So less join with it, and the one who do want to shield themselves from it. The result is rent seeking and an epidemic of tax dodging. That's how the social net is slowing being deconstructed. I actually have a lot of sympathy for politicians who legitimately try to make people work together (not necessarily taking sides here). Seen how politicians are being systemically hated, I'm sure politics is actually a very tough job right now.
- bdg 11y agoHow are politicians "systemically" hated?
- dcposch 11y agoCongress has a 11% approval rating. Nearly 90% of Americans agree that it's performing inadequately Given that all 535 members won an election to get there, that is pretty surprising. Widespread dislike of the entire political class is a new phenomenom in US politics. It seems to be driven by: * Unprecedented polarization * Filter bubbles -- new media makes it easy to hear only news you already agree with. * Gridlock and dysfunction
- vinay427 11y ago> Given that all 535 members won an election to get there, that is pretty surprising. I agree with your premise that politicians are generally disliked, but the obvious explanation of this is that voters disapprove of many of the representives they didn't vote for, especially those who belong to a different party or no party.
- _yosefk 11y agoWe're lucky that those evil businessmen line up to fill the pockets of the various nice politicians with tens of millions of dollars of, ahem, speaking fees and what-not - the politicians surely deserve it, with their "tough job" and all. As to favors given to businessmen in return for the money at taxpayers' expense - we can't really blame politicians for that, since being the nice people that they are, they just act on their nature of doing good!
- wj 11y agoIf I was incredibly wealthy I would attempt to have a not insignificant portion if it offshore as a hedge against my local or national government instituting an out-sized tax on wealth or nationalizing my business.
- alecco 11y agoShh, don't break the hypocrisy/circle-jerk.
- andriesm 11y agoWhatever happened to the principle that whoever makes the through legal trade gets to own it? Why does the US have such gigantic monetary needs? How on earth does the US get into 18 trillion of debt? Where's all thr fruits of that money???? Surely the solution is not for the government to keep being given more of the people's money?!! Government is a bottomless pit waste of money with very weak oversight - the more money you give the government - the more it wastes. If people paid for the things they need directly, rather than have the cost/administration overhead of government, society as a whole would be richer. Corporations don't use very many government services - so why should they be heavily taxed? The more ridiculous the taxes in the US become, the more businesses will simply incorporate overseas. The US taxes need to become radically lower and radically simpler - then the US stands a chance to actually collect taxes. See Ireland 12.5 corporate tax rate.
- bakhy 11y agosome time ago, the definition of "trickle down" on wikipedia used to contain, in the first sentence, the statement that the goal is to achieve wealth distribution. the contradiction was too glaring, i presume ;) because, if so, then why not just give the money to the people? their spending will then inevitably reward and enrich those market actors that deserve it, leading to a much healthier market then one created by governments transferring money to arbitrary, politically connected capitalists. ceterum censeo, basic income is the future!
- ThomPete 11y agoThis is one of those re-occurring strawmen that just won't die and it's hurting the debate. It becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. Of course wealth does not trickle down. That's why it's defined as wealth. The real discussion to be had is the difference between lazy wealth (ex. real estate) and active wealth (investing in your own company) The claim has never been that people like the Koch brothers somehow spend their wealth to the benefit of people "below" them and since it's their wealth then of course it's not trickling down. The claim is that a lot of the wealth that is created from the millions of businesses which then result in jobs, a couple here, a couple there benefits people. It's obvious that if you think about the ultra wealthy then the trickle down effect is minimal there is a limit to how many Bentleys you can own. But if you take the large majority of small businesses and entrepreneurs who create a little but in quantity then wealth does trickle down. Working wealth that is.
- pmoriarty 11y agoDo most people work for large, medium, or small businesses? I seem to recall reading somewhere that they work mostly for large businesses. If so, then "job creation" effect of small businesses is not that great.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoAnd I recall reading that 50% of Americans are self-employed or work at small businesses.
- ThomPete 11y agoThe job creation effect isn't the argument here. The argument is wether wealth is better while active rather than passive capital. People with great wealth don't spend proportionally as much as people with less wealth. I.e. it's true that the wealth of the 1% doesn't trickle down but the 99% does because it's active and thats what makes the economy go around (economic activity, spending money) But if you want to discuss that then: "...American Business is Overwhelmingly Small Business. In 2012, according to U.S. Census Bureau data, there were 5.73 million employer firms in the U.S. Firms with fewer than 500 workers accounted for 99.7 percent of those businesses, and businesses with less than 20 workers made up 89.6 percent..."
- facepalm 11y agoIs offshore money a good investment? Sounds to me it would just be sitting there passively, by the uncle scrooge mentality it would therefore be a gift to society. Money is an obligation of society to return something to the individual who owns it. If that obligation is never claimed, great...
- anon4 11y agoStudy finds that sky is blue. Politicians shocked.
- narrator 11y agoAnd then it floods back in in places like the Vancouver real estate market.
- dplgk 11y agoRich people do not need money. Give them more, they will invest it or hoard it. Give poor people money, they will spend it right away. Which helps an economy more?
- alanwatts 11y agoThe answer to this logical question is obvious. Unfortunately this is a debate that is dominated by emotions and not logic due to 100+ years of propaganda, brainwashing, M.A.D. scare tactics, and the fallacy of Malthusian-Darwinian ideology
- rebootthesystem 11y agoHey, folks, go start a business before voicing opinion about these matters. It's just amazing how there's this recurring theme on HN of folks without a clue about business thinking they actually know something. Better yet, this is HN. Go formulate a startup and apply to YC, let's see how far you get and what you learn about what it takes to provide excellent innovative products that people want to buy. You'll also learn the gut-wrenching realities of being an entrepreneur. And then, a few years later, you'll find yourself having a surreal conversation with some know-it-all who never risked anything, never tried to innovate, never tried to launch or run a business, who is absolutely certain you are a greedy pig, your company is evil and the customer service person should be just as wealthy as you are. You don't understand just how dumb some of these comments sound from the vantage point of someone who achieved success through continued struggle and effort spanning years and at great personal and financial cost. There's nothing wrong with Capitalism. What's wrong is the victim culture we seem to be developing --which leads exactly nowhere at both a personal and national level. I say this in the nicest possible way. Get a clue. Please.
- solidangle 11y agoApparently complaining about living in poverty is victim culture. Apparently complaining about working two full-time minimum wage jobs while barely being able to pay the bills is victim culture. Apparently complaining about not being able to afford a quality education for your children (so that they do not have to live in the same poverty) is victim culture. Apparently complaining about not being able to afford healthcare is victim culture. Sure, people doing startups or creating other businesses work hard, but that shouldn't be the norm. Working 40 hours a week as an employee should be enough. And by the way we're not even complaining about the people creating businesses, we're complaining about the people who inherit their wealth, get everything handed on a silver platter, and who still aren't grateful and don't want to pay their employees more than minimum wage. We shouldn't accept that kind of wealth in our society when there are people living in (extreme) poverty.
- rebootthesystem 11y agoHow dare you? My grandparents arrived at these shores without a dime to their names, without command of the language, from a GENOCIDE where they endured the trauma of having seen members of their families raped and murdered. They woked their asses off and made it. And they instilled that culture on their children and grand children. So, yes, fucking stop thinking like a victim. It's insulting. Yes's there are those who absolutely need help. Stop complaining and go help them. Don't blame others.
- SixSigma 11y agoCapital goes to where to where it will do the most work.
- dredmorbius 11y agoCounterhypothesis: capital goes to where it will extract the most wealth, without necessarily producing greater societal value. Often the inverse.
- dingdingdang 11y agoGreat article - "...new study suggests a staggering $21tn in assets has been lost to global tax havens. If taxed, that could have been enough to put parts of Africa back on its feet – and even solve the euro crisis"
- xixi77 11y agoThe article has nothing to do with trickle down or taxes: it just underscores that many people are not too excited about keeping their property in places where rule of law is rather peculiar. E.g. if you look at the title graphic, 2nd largest capital flight figure is for Russia -- I highly doubt its 13% (iirc) flat income tax is to blame for that.