22 ms·
Google Puts Boston Dynamics Up for Sale in Robotics Retreat
- Analemma_ 11y agoI have to assume the timing of this, coming so soon after the Pentagon bailed on BD, is no coincidence. Does Google figure that the division cannot turn a profit without that sweet spigot of defense dollars?
- melling 11y agoWhat other non-defense products do they have? What other non-defense clients do they have? Consumers robotics is still waiting for its Apple II moment.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Consumers robotics is still waiting for its Apple II moment. Elderly care in first world countries.
- melling 11y agoIdeas are easy. I've got a dozen great ideas too but I won't waste anyone's time. The trick is for a company to profitability make a product then parlay that into the next big thing.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoHonda has been building robotics for years ahead of everyone else. Google "japan elderly care robotics". What's cheaper? A robot, or a human caregiver who has fully loaded costs for decades? If you can even find the human who wants to do the job. http://asimo.honda.com/ http://asimo.honda.com/
- melling 11y agoA human is much cheaper because no robot can currently do the job. You are completely missing the point. Years ahead means nothing. it could be 20-30 years before it can replace a human for that job. In the meantime, it's a pet project. The idea is for companies to find revenue from the technology as soon as possible then turn that revenue into R&D to build even better robots. Look at the revenue the smartphone market generates. There's an arm's race to get consumers buying new devices. We need a couple $100 billion robotics companies pushing boundaries. Also consider, for example, how Elon is bootstrapping electric cars and private rockets.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Also consider, for example, how Elon is bootstrapping electric cars and private rockets. That's a great example. And I agree with you in part. Look how far Elon and Co have come in under 15 years with both Tesla and SpaceX. Bootstrapped? Indeed. But they also had to prime the pump with demand (SpaceX with gov contracts, Tesla with wealthy purchasers)
- melling 11y agoYes, they had to find customers. That's how business works. You sound as if they cheated. You find someone willing to pay for your product. The "build it and they will come" doesn't usually work out so well. Finding governments or wealthy people to pay for your products counts when building a business. Elon didn't invent this tactic.
- Oletros 11y agoWhen Google acquired them,, they said that they didn't want to be defense contractors
- mtgx 11y agoExactly. And then they went ahead and tried to get a defense contract from Pentagon anyway. In fact, about 3 months after they said that, they started wanting to sell Google Glass to the military. Not as bad as selling them autonomous robots, but still. It just shows much little when we trust what Google says when an acquisition happens. Eventually they are just going to do what they think will make them money, regardless of what they promised. That said, now I'm worried that an actual defense contractor will get those robots.
- 91bananas 11y agoCurious, because you think this is a consumer technology?
- 13thLetter 11y ago"That said, now I'm worried that an actual defense contractor will get those robots." Why is this worrying? If you're afraid that the military will do something evil with the robots, you're going to be dismayed to learn that they already have automatic rifles, tanks, and atomic bombs.
- Oletros 11y ago> And then they went ahead and tried to get a defense contract from Pentagon anyway. Source for that? > In fact, about 3 months after they said that, they started wanting to sell Google Glass to the military Source for that?
- Alupis 11y agoI believe Google was in the process of winding down all of BD's defense contracts anyway - because they have no interest in being in the defense contractor business. But to have bought a leading "next-gen" defense contractor, only to wind down all of their contracts, and then sell off the company... seems... wrong? Almost like a deliberate destruction of this company.
- woah 11y agoIs there anything wrong about destroying a defense contractor?
- Alupis 11y ago> Is there anything wrong about destroying a defense contractor? A company like Boston Dynamics? Absolutely yes. They were working on next-gen robotics that would directly save American soldier lives - both while in combat and during rescue operations. Their technology was also being tested for domestic search-and-rescue operations where it was too dangerous to send in humans.
- nitrogen 11y agoSome people make the case that war should remain dangerous so countries are reluctant to start wars. Or maybe some see a trajectory from robotic mules to robotic weapons platforms. In those cases, no amount of search-and-rescue window dressing would change their minds.
- Alupis 11y agoWar is not the only scenario where there is armed conflict. Stopping a genocide, inserting a military "buffer" in-between two hostile nations, general peace keeping, hostage rescue, VIP protection, bomb location/defusal, hijackings, and more come to mind. The fact is, soldier's lives are going to be put into harms way, even in a perfectly at-peace world (which none of us live in). Perhaps I'm biased, as I come from a military family, but I'd far rather a walking circuit board take a bullet over a human soldier.
- j1vms 11y agoIf the Pentagon had indeed bailed on BD, it is possible that they know that their own research is safely near par or even further along than that of BD. While they would have otherwise funneled money over to GOOG regardless, they possibly tilted the other way as the US government slowly distances themselves from the country's tech industry - that is, until AAPL and others get "on-side" again. Of course, we may never know for sure.
- stupidcar 11y agoThe Pentagon bailed because the bigdog project just wasn't practical[1]. The large version was too noisy for use on the battlefield, and the small version was too weak to do useful work. It seems like Google are bailing on BD for much the same reason: Their tech works, but it doesn't actually solve any practical problem that Google have, and isn't close to producing any independent, sellable product. [1] http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-35201183 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-35201183
- psbp 11y agoDepending on how much it sells for, this might be the first case of the Alphabet strategy actually working. Otherwise, BD might have just embarrassingly died inside of Google.
- vonsydov 11y agoyeah and larry and sergey wouldn't have liked that considering how innovative bd is.
- falava 11y agoWhat is BD? I suppose is something related to robotics, but I'm not familiar with the acronym.
- venachescu 11y agoIt's quite likely the latter, who in the world can / will pay more than Google?
- sharemywin 11y agoThey need to talk to Disney. They could build a tomorrow land but with real robots.
- mxfh 11y agoI guess their board is hung on the decision which franchise to start first: Westworld or Futureworld
- njharman 11y agowestworld
- randcraw 11y agoNothing at Disney is real. Reality is vicious, not cute.
- Animats 11y agoI mentioned above that Dr. Martin Buehler, the brains behind BigDog, is now at Disney. We can expect legged machines from Disney soon. They've played around with this in the past, with Lucky the Dinosaur[1], but Lucky tows a cart whose wheels provide stability. Now that they have the top guy on balance and slip control, Disney's robots should get better. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucky_the_Dinosaur https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucky_the_Dinosaur
- gjvc 11y ago"Don't be evil." is clearly still true!
- vonsydov 11y agoDamn. BD is probably the coolest company within Google.
- temuze 11y agoThis is surprising to me. It seems that many prominent Googlers are very optimistic about robotics. For example, in the FAQ of Jeff Dean's recent talk in Seoul, he mentioned how Deep Learning has a lot of potential to reinvent the field of robotics. Also, Demis Hassabis recently tweeted about progress in learning 3-D environments. I'd be surprised if Google wasn't looking into general purpose robotics... Perhaps Google is disappointed in their robotics acquisitions and wants to start from scratch? It seems that they are farther on the software front than anyone at the point. I wonder what they'll do in their hardware/power divisions... (Also, it kind of seems like Tesla and Google are on a crash course here. Tesla is ahead in power/hardware and is developing a top-tier AI team for self-driving cars. Elon also seems very interested in Robotics + AI. Google seems to be working from the opposite end.)
- jonas21 11y agoMost of Google's robotics acquisitions were driven by Andy Rubin, who was trying to build a robotics division within Google. Once he left the company, it probably left their future uncertain.
- wpietri 11y agoIt's always a bad sign to me when a company's strategy lurches based on who's around rather than on changing external circumstances. It suggests to me that the strategy isn't a coherent, collectively understood plan, but a political balance.
- ansible 11y agoIt suggests to me that the strategy isn't a coherent, collectively understood plan, but a political balance. I suspect that's the way it is... everywhere, all the time. That's been my experience.
- ethbro 11y agoI think it's a stronger phenomenon in cutting edge areas, as there's less group-think to fall back on or use as a crutch. Everyone knew what to do with a typewriter, even if the visionary leader left. If the person who was saying that microcomputers were going to be the next big thing quit? Nobody else has that idea in their heads.
- maxerickson 11y agoI wonder if they are keeping any of the people or IP.
- donjh 11y agoVery curious about this. I could see them keeping some of the IP and then selling the rest.
- SemiTom 11y agoI wonder if this impacts the Robotics organization they had on California Ave in Palo Alto. I saw them testing out some robotic dogs
- newobj 11y agoGuess I won't be getting a bipedal robot as Google I/O swag this year.... or will I?
- itg 11y ago"“There’s excitement from the tech press, but we’re also starting to see some negative threads about it being terrifying, ready to take humans’ jobs,” wrote Courtney Hohne, a director of communications at Google and the spokeswoman for Google X. Hohne went on to ask her colleagues to “distance X from this video,” and wrote, “we don’t want to trigger a whole separate media cycle about where BD really is at Google.” “We’re not going to comment on this video because there’s really not a lot we can add, and we don’t want to answer most of the Qs it triggers,” she wrote." I found this to be disappointing. More concerned about their brand image than trying to push robotics research forward.
- CodeCube 11y agoThis is incredibly disappointing to read. If they can't deal with the cultural repercussions of what they're building, then they're right, they need to get out of that game. Let someone else take the robotics helm
- FranOntanaya 11y agoPerhaps there's a strong correlation between the people that get terrified by automation and the people that click ads.
- slang800 11y agoMaybe, but does anyone think about the ad-buying system that they are supporting before they click on an ad? Personally, I doubt that ethical consumerism runs that deep.
- slang800 11y agoEspecially since the robots that BD is making are prohibitively expensive, and will remain that way for several years. If anything is going to take away human jobs, it's the software at the core of Google's business, which costs nothing to deploy and is inherently better than humans... Unlike robots that cost more than a typical human makes in their lifetime and are only now beginning to gain proper mobility. If anything, the real concerns about their research should be their ties to the DoD and the military use of robots.
- Isamu 11y agoThe graph of govt funding (almost all defense dept) of Boston Dynamics can be seen here: https://www.usaspending.gov/transparency/Pages/RecipientProfile.aspx?DUNSNumber=797866001&FiscalYear=2012 https://www.usaspending.gov/transparency/Pages/RecipientProf... Peaked in FY 2012, went to nothing (negative?) after Google X bought it at the end of 2013. Not sure if that is more because Google X wanted a real product, or that the defense dept didn't want to continue the relationship, or what. The marine corps passed on big dog as "too loud" at the end of 2015, that killed a potential customer for that product.
- Isamu 11y agoI interpret the graph as the Google acquisition being primarily responsible for killing the defense investment in BD.
- sndean 11y ago> went to nothing (negative?) after Google X bought it at the end of 2013. Yeah, does anyone know if BD paid the DoD ~3.5M in 2014? I haven't seen that kind of thing before.
- ogsharkman 11y agoI was just wondering the same thing
- Isamu 11y agoProbably a contract that was "on the books" in FY 2013 but later canceled before payment in FY 2014. I assume there is a considerable time lag in payment when dealing with the US govt.
- vonmoltke 11y agoThis most likely. You get to count the money for a contract when it gets booked and awarded, even if you don't start work on it immediately or actually receive any money. If you book a contract (and count the money) in one fiscal year and it gets reduced or canceled in a subsequent one the reduction counts as a "loss" even if no money has actually changed hands yet.
- ocschwar 11y agoNow I can go work for Boston Dynamics and be evil!
- golergka 11y agoAm I stupid to think about Xerox PARC or Bell labs? Seems like a company that will not produce immediate revenue in near future, but at the same time create technologies that will influence the world for dozens of years.
- krylon 11y agoFWIW, I was thinking of the PARC analogy as well.
- Rezo 11y ago"Google’s public-relations team expressed discomfort that Alphabet would be associated with a push into humanoid robotics". Observe the Innovator's Dilemma in effect: a successful company is putting too much emphasis on customers' current needs, and fails to adopt new technology or business models that will meet their unstated or future needs. When realized, humanoid robotics will make the (self-driving or not) entire car industry seem like a quaint little side business.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoI'm skeptical of humanoid robotics. If we're talking about productivity, humanoids will never be competitive with purpose-optimized robots. A few suitcases full of robots of different sizes will outperform a humanoid at almost anything. Sex robots is one area where humanoids will be strong. But I think that's one area where a lot of humans will draw a line. Many humans won't even date someone with different skin color yet, let alone another species like a robot. There is maybe a marketing advantage in the fact that they look like people so they might be seen as more trustworthy or comfortable. But there's the uncanny valley thing too. And with the little robots people will already have gotten really comfortable with, like, their kitchen counter robot making them coffee and breakfast long before a compelling, affordable humanoid robot exists. I guess humanoids might make good spies if you can make them indistinguishable from people, but that's pretty sci-fi. And people who want to boss around a slave that has human feelings and stuff, but who don't like the idea of owning a human would be pretty into humanoids. But all of this seems like fairly niche interests to me?
- avar 11y agoYou're missing a few advantages: * Automatic ability to integrate into environments designed for humans. Think doorknobs, ladders etc. * All the advantages of legged locomotion over wheels. * Once you have legged locomotion down you might as well do it on two legs and add some arms, and voila you have a humanoid robots.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- aresant 11y agoRobotics, particularly without the gov't pig trough, needs a visionary and a long game point. Andy Rubin was a visionary and he bailed. He left Apple to found Danger which was one of the "genesis" products that led to the smartphone era. (1) He made the next huge leap with Android and almost failed until Google showed up to help him fully execute his vision under their stewardship. After Android became a very mature business in its own right what to do with the visionary founder? The article states that "Page is interested in robots" - can you imagine if Larry Page came to you and said "Hey how about you literally build robots all day. You could be Tony Stark and here's $100m to get you started. We'll change the world!" It's a hard to turn down offer, Rubin accepted and tried to recapture the magic pursuing somebody else's vision. But it's damn tough to be a founder / visionary under somebody else's thumb, especially when you're set for life financially. That's a story that never works out, but is played out again and again in technical acquisitions as big organizations attempt to find a place for founders. (1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danger_(company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danger_(company) (2) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mergers_and_acquisitions_by_Google https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mergers_and_acquisitio...
- zmanian 11y agoLeaving out this context from Bloomberg article is negligent on the part of the journalist...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- budu3 11y agoIt's my understanding the Andy has always been a Robotics geek even dated as far back as his days a Danger. So I find it hard to believe the argument that Andy has to be coerced into perusing a Robotics vision that he had no passion for.
- legulere 11y agoHis wikipedia article says that his first job was as a robotics engineer at Carl Zeiss for three years.
- xyzzy4 11y agoYet another company destroyed by Google.
- slang800 11y agoDoes Google actually have a history of destroying companies that they acquire?
- awqrre 11y agonot sure how many of those were acquired, but see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Google_products#Discontinued_products_and_services https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Google_products#Discon...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- xyzzy4 11y agoYes, they acquired Meebo and shut it down.
- tdicola 11y agoDodgeball, https://www.flickr.com/photos/dpstyles/460987802/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/dpstyles/460987802/ "So.... Alex and I quit Google on Friday. It's no real secret that Google wasn't supporting dodgeball the way we expected. The whole experience was incredibly frustrating for us - especially as we couldn't convince them that dodgeball was worth engineering resources, leaving us to watch as other startups got to innovate in the mobile + social space. And while it was a tough decision (and really disappointing) to walk away from dodgeball, I'm actually looking forward to getting to work on other projects again."
- wingless 11y agoCould be worse. Could be acquired by Yahoo.
- afokken 11y agoWhat if Google is already using AI to make business decisions and AlphaCEO has determined that BD wasn't a good investment? :)
- krrrh 11y agoThe complexity of business decisions at one of the largest companies in the world makes Go look as easy as Chess. :)
- kazagistar 11y agoYou mean so much more complex that it takes an additional decade for AI to get there?
- wpietri 11y agoMy sympathies to all the Boston Dynamics employees. This sort of "we love you"/"we hate you" whipsaw has got to be hard on them.
- hitekker 11y agoIf this article is to be believed, shortsightedness and bottom-line-thinking are contradicting what Alphabet is suppose to be. >Alphabet is about businesses prospering through strong leaders and independence... Sergey and I are seriously in the business of starting new things. Alphabet will also include our X lab, which incubates new efforts like Wing, our drone delivery effort. We are also stoked about growing our investment arms, Ventures and Capital, as part of this new structure.[1] From the Alphabet website, to this article: >Aaron Edsinger, director of robotics at Google in San Francisco, said that he had been trying to work with Boston Dynamics to create a low-cost electric quadruped robot >In the meeting, Rosenberg said, “we as a startup of our size cannot spend 30-plus percent of our resources on things that take ten years," and that "there’s some time frame that we need to be generating an amount of revenue that covers expenses and (that) needs to be a few years. Focusing on building revenue is good for established companies, sometimes even for company devisions. Not always useful for startups (imagine if FB bootsrapped), which in my understanding, was what Alphabet was trying to incubate. > “There’s excitement from the tech press, but we’re also starting to see some negative threads about it being terrifying, ready to take humans’ jobs,” wrote Courtney Hohne, a director of communications at Google and the spokeswoman for Google X. Hohne went on to ask her colleagues to “distance X from this video,” and wrote, “we don’t want to trigger a whole separate media cycle about where BD really is at Google. Ignorance aside, you can glean more of the poor distinction between Alphabet and Google here. X[2] is suppose to be a separate company from Google, under Alphabet, yet it is referred to as Google X here. Even Courtney Hohne, a director of communication, lists herself as working at Google, not at X or at Alphabet. This confusion between the two hints at larger problems, which bodes poorly for Alphabet's lofty aspirations. [1]http://abc.xyz http://abc.xyz [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X_(company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X_(company)
- bunkydoo 11y agoNot to knock "Google X" but they seem to be extremely wishy washy when it comes to picking a direction. (Glass, robotics, curing aging) they really don't seem to have the "skate to where the puck is going to be" mentality at least from the outside looking in. Apple is struggling here too, but only very recently has this come to the attention of media and shareholders.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoAgreed. This feels like something Yahoo! would do. Perhaps there are hidden machinations and defence-washing for PR purposes. But perhaps it's about corp comm being given veto power over R&D - in which case it seems like a terrible mistake.
- Joeri 11y agoTo be fair, that's what great R&D labs look like while they're inventing. They're all over the place, and only with hindsight can you connect the dots.
- njharman 11y agoHope some new/tech Billionaire buys it, just cause robots are cool and they want them to advance. I would! I really want to ride a big dog around my neighborhood / to work.
- elpasi 11y agoThis is going to be a hard blow for all the people determined to believe the conspiracy theories about Google trying to take over the world...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- riazrizvi 11y agoIt's interesting that this is a top story, we can see from the popularity on this site. Yet on http://reddit.com/r/google http://reddit.com/r/google it is nowhere to be found...
- avuserow 11y agoIt's there now (with a timestamp of 2 hours ago), but /r/google isn't what I would consider a good barometer of what's important or popular news. It's larger than I expected at ~77k subscribers, but contrast with /r/android at ~623k subscribers, and it does not show up frequently on the first dozen pages of /r/all in my experience.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoInteresting comments at the end about corp comm not wanting to be too close to Boston Dynamics. A self driving car is "cool" a robotic driver that can get in to a car and drive it away is "scary"[1]. Coupled with the stories about progress in AI and I can see why it might give someone the jitters. Doesn't help that the connection is still there, if only unacknowledged. I've been following robotics since the 80's and one of those places that seems to get started and then vanish time and again are robot security guards. Certainly an ambulatory robot like some of the ones BD built with AI to investigate disturbances around a facility would be a potentially revenue generating product. The optics though leave a bit to be desired. [1] This was one of the tasks of the DARPA robotics challenge.
- louprado 11y agoCan anyone comment on the target use case for bi/quadruped robots ? Industrial operations have smooth flat predictable flooring where wheels are just fine. It's also too expensive for a consumer grade household assistant (but this would be the killer App). This seems targeted for disaster/rescue ops and military applications. Perhaps Google doesn't want to enter those markets.
- vamur 11y agoFor example construction, guarding, supermarkets, restaurant.
- ausjke 11y agoMaybe more of a culture conflict between east and west coast? sort of like MIT vs Stanford, they behave differently actually. Otherwise I would think Google can buffer money&time for pure R&D with no quarterly revenue pressure in certain fields, e.g. robotics in this case.
- crb002 11y agoHoping John Deere buys it. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lYh54Qdh_5g https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lYh54Qdh_5g Only farm big iron should be combines. Smaller bots for planting, weeding, and spraying are the future. Bosch is getting too far ahead. http://spectrum.ieee.org/automaton/robotics/industrial-robots/bosch-deepfield-robotics-weed-control http://spectrum.ieee.org/automaton/robotics/industrial-robot...
- debacle 11y agoSo we need copyright encumbered robot repairs as well as copyright encumbered equipment repairs?
- 100ideas 11y agoAre they keeping Bot&Dolly?
- mchahn 11y agoWas the push towards humanoid robots a PR gimmick? I would think the ideal robot would look very different than us and not have the limitations that our bodies have. Airplanes don't flap their wings.
- JeffreyKaine 11y agoBut if you want a multipurpose robot that works alongside us in the human world performing many diverse tasks that a human would perform, being a humanoid might be quite useful. Jobs are designed for humans in many cases, so looking and moving like a human seems like a good thing.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoIts initially so they can fit in with an existing work crew, using tools and devices already there. At this point, that market is huge.
- partycoder 11y agoI hope this doesn't include the self driving cars.
- Futurebot 11y agoI really hope that the last paragraph is wrong. Getting out of that area because they're afraid of neo-luddite backlash is ridiculous. Instead, they should be using their considerable power to push the much-lauded "Silicon Valley Democracy" (http://www.vox.com/2016/2/19/11057836/silicon-valley-democrat-explained http://www.vox.com/2016/2/19/11057836/silicon-valley-democra...). Things like: - Guaranteed income, or at least a stopgap like the old welfare system, but with far less means-testing and much more generosity - Universal, free higher education - Free, universal health care - Smart, flexible regulatory apparatus - A complete rethought system of unions (a la Sweden) - Massive push (or even buildout) of dense urban housing developments. Make the modern "company town" an explicit goal if you must, then expand it to regions across the country I really wonder if the Nordics have a leg up on us here; they're already 3/4 of the way towards this ideal, both in terms of policy and a cultural understanding of the benefits of a truly progressive taxation system/public goods and services. Would a Danish or Finnish robotics company bail out just because of fear of backlash, or would they say "society already has you covered, people"?
- randyrand 11y agoHow do you make higher education free? Doesn't someone have to still pay for it?
- miracle_code 11y agoHow about the big and worth billions companys pay for it, it is their share for the future at last? Just talking out of my ass here, but the american educational system is flawed big time in that regard, let education and teaching be free, everybody profits in the end. But then again, a well schooled and open minded citizen is not needed in the big scheme of american things. Who will fight their wars then??? /s
- webXL 11y agoU.S. corporations have a much higher tax rate than the rest of the developed economies. The vast majority of corporations aren't sitting on mountains of cash like Apple. Additional tax expense is financed by a combination of higher prices, input cost cuts, and reduced profitability. You're not going to get much there.
- known 11y agoI bet Google self driving car will be next
- Animats 11y agoI was afraid this would happen. Boston Dynamics did good work, but it was all DoD funded at a very high price point. It cost about $125 million and ten years to get to BigDog. That's all R&D; there's no marketing cost in that. DARPA is a patient customer. Google, from the parent article, is not. BigDog is a great achievement, but it was developed to DoD specs, and it's just too big, heavy, and noisy. The militarized version, the Legged Squad Support System, was bigger and stronger, but the USMC decided it just wasn't useful militarily. Atlas is really an evolved BigDog that stands upright, with similar hydraulic actuators. A hydraulic humanoid is just too bulky. BD has some problems that aren't well known. BD's CEO, Marc Raibert, is around 67, and due for retirement. He and his girlfriend owned the company, so they're the only ones who benefited from the Google buy. I doubt that the employees got anything. Also, the brains behind BigDog was Dr. Martin Buehler, who previously had an ambulatory robotics lab at McGill, and whose group built the first good running robot quadruped. (Using my anti-slip algorithm, I found from reading a thesis that cites my work.) He was the chief engineer on BigDog, and quit right after BigDog was publicly demoed.[1] He's now at Disney.[2] Raibert seemed to like hydraulic systems; his name is on patents for BigDog's rather clever hydraulic actuators. But that approach seems to be too heavy for a humanoid robot. Atlas weighs 330 pounds. Schaft, a University of Tokyo spinoff which Google also bought, uses water-cooled electric motors, like Tesla, to get the power to weight ratio needed. You need huge torque only a small fraction of the time, so overloading motors is fine if you can keep them cool. I'd expected that Google would get Boston Dynamics and Schaft to work together, and from that would come a new, lighter humanoid with good balance. But the Bloomberg article said that BD didn't play well with Google's other robotics companies. BD is near Boston, Schaft is near Tokyo, and Google never tried to get them under one roof. Whatever happened to Schaft, anyway? They built one very nice humanoid robot before Google bought them, and haven't been heard from since. Google wouldn't let them enter the DARPA Robotics Challenge. Computationally, BigDog/Atlas are not that compute intensive. The balance and locomotion algorithms for BigDog ran on a Pentium 4 running QNX, with the servovalve control loop at 1KHz and the balance control loop at 100Hz. Google's expertise isn't in that kind of hard real time work. You need that stuff down at the bottom to keep from falling down. BD didn't do much work at the higher levels of control; they were mostly building teleoperators with, in the later versions, automatic foot placement. From the article: "In a private all-hands meeting around that time, Astro Teller, the head of Google X, told Replicant employees that if robotics aren’t the practical solution to problems that Google was trying to solve, they would be reassigned to work on other things." (Probably related to maximizing ad revenue.) That's a great way to lose your robotics expertise for which you overpaid. I used to work in the legged locomotion area. But I could never see a path to a profitable product. Toys were at too low a price point (even Sony gave up), and a legged working robot for maintenance tasks was a long way off. We're getting closer now; a useful robot that costs about as much as a car seems well within reach on the hardware side. [1] http://www.robotics.org/content-detail.cfm/Industrial-Robotics-News/2012-Engelberger-Robotics-Awards-to-be-Presented-to-Richard-Litt-and-Martin-Buehler/content_id/3586 http://www.robotics.org/content-detail.cfm/Industrial-Roboti... [2] https://www.linkedin.com/in/martinbuehler https://www.linkedin.com/in/martinbuehler
- 1qaz2wsx3edc 11y agoI for one approve of this pre-emptive strike against robot-kind and skynet-like future. Especially after seeing the abuse we've put countless robots through. I mean, it's probably a good idea to have robots decentralized from google's AI. :P
- samstave 11y agoOne of my personal failures was that I interviewed at danger years ago, but I was deathly ill with the flu, but I wanted to work there so bad I went with the interview regardless and did extremely poorly as I had a fever of 103 or so and I was hardly able to answer questions.... I wish I would have rescheduled that interview as I believe I would have got the job had I not looked like I was about to expire.
- tdicola 11y agoAnd if you got the job you probably would have been absorbed into Microsoft after the acquisition and then worked on their failed Kin phone. Honestly I think you got the better half of the deal.
- p1mrx 11y agoPerhaps they didn't want to hire someone with a reckless disregard for the health of their coworkers.
- taneq 11y agoYou're getting down voted but you have a great point. There's nothing worse than working with Typhoid Mary who struggles dramatically in to work no matter how sick she is and coughs all over everyone.
- arkem 11y agoI know what you mean but Mary Mallon aka Typhoid Mary was asymptomatic and wasn't coughing over anyone. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_Mallon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_Mallon
- Fomite 11y agoEpidemiologist +1
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 11y ago
- dbcurtis 11y agoBD has done a lot of work on DARPA grants, and is very good at specmanship. If the DARPA contract says "must run continuously for 10 hours" then you can bet that the MTBF of all the critical components is slightly north of 10 hours. BD is stuck in an academic research mindset, and hasn't really internalized the mindset necessary to create something sufficiently robust to be a product. I got to tour the maintenance garage at the DRC Finals, pretty much every Atlas and every Atlas spare part in the world were in the building. The Atlas looked like a delicate "lab queen" contraption next to the CHIMP robot used by Tartan Rescue.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- gene-h 11y agoThis is not very surprising. From Boston Dynamic's recently released robots and their proposed direction for the future it was pretty clear they were not working with the other robotics divisions. Almost all of the robots Boston Dynamics has made are hydraulically actuated. In fact, pretty much all the robots Marc Raibert made when he was at MIT's leg lab were hydraulic. They are pretty dead set on this approach[0]. This is in contrast with google's other divisions Meka Robotics and SCHAFT which use electric actuation. Heck, SCHAFT's whole shtick is that they were able to make stronger more powerful electric actuators. Not to mention a big part of Meka's tech are their electric series elastic actuators. Boston Dynamic's message that their next robot will be hydraulic too but 3d printed, was a pretty strong indication they were not going to work with them. It might even show that Boston Dynamics is more of a hardware company, focusing on building robot systems, rather a software company, focusing on walking algorithms. This battle over hydraulics vs electric actuators has been fought before in the robotics industry and hydraulics lost[1]. While hydraulics were stronger, electric actuators were more reliable. More reliability means said robot generates more value before it breaks down. [0] http://www.3ders.org/articles/20150818-google-partially-3d-printed-humanoid-atlas-robot-goes-on-successful-walk-in-the-woods.html http://www.3ders.org/articles/20150818-google-partially-3d-p... [1] http://www.roboticsbusinessreview.com/article/the_first_industrial_robot_why_it_failed/P2 http://www.roboticsbusinessreview.com/article/the_first_indu...
- iamgopal 11y agoI have been robotic engineer for quite some time now, and I can predict that, adding intelligence to hardware already existed is quite easy, like smart refrigerator which close automatically after some time, or door which send you notification when kids are at home, but to build robot that can paint a complex building is next to impossible, not that it can't be done, but to do it in a economically rewarding way is not just possible, because of relatively high number of technology involved for relatively low return of investment.
- devy 11y ago...but to do it in a economically rewarding way is not just possible, ... I think you meant to say "but to do it in a economically rewarding way is just not possible". Different order means exactly the oppose. :)
- adrenalinelol 11y agoIf you're going to correct him/her, why not also point out: "a economically -> an economically"
- devy 11y agogood catch :)
- yeukhon 11y agoIf someone build a real Iron Man, can he be arrested for building a military grade weapon? I mean I would love to become a real Tony Stark and building an armored AI robot for my own (perhaps minus the destructive part of the robot...)
- cm2187 11y agoI don't know if the future of robotics is a vicious terminator. I see it more as a mix of a maid, a cook, a butler and a handyman.... A domestic robot that will clean the house, walk the dog, take delivery of parcels, cook like a chef, repaint the walls while you are on holidays, iron your clothes, change the bulbs, ensure there is always enough toilet paper, refill your beers while you watch your match on tv,....
- bitL 11y agoGoogle obviously has the need to be adored; if somebody with a reason contradicts what they say (what can you know - you are just a founder of Boston Dynamics, not a mighty Googler!), they get rid of them. Seriously Google, you were once great, now your search is unusable and I can't see anything worth coming from you :-/ If PR dictates your focus, what is Ray Kurzweil going to do there - developing a new VA synth instead of singularity? Do we need to travel to Osaka to see real humanoids from Hiroshi Ishiguro and get the feel of the future? Does Japan have to be again 20+ years ahead of the US? Are we going to stop humanity progress because some retarded internal politicians want to keep their power or some shortsighted capitalists want to keep milking their cows? We have the possibility to improve human condition tremendously with the robotic technology at hand and we are going to be stupid about it and fall back to "business as usual" idiocy? Is this Larry why Tesla inspired you so much when you were still young and idealistic? Even Intel seems to be 5 years ahead of you when it comes to releasing consumer humanoid robotics... [sorry for a rant]
- bravura 11y agoExecutives at Google parent Alphabet Inc., absorbed with making sure all the various companies under its corporate umbrella have plans to generate real revenue, concluded that Boston Dynamics isn’t likely to produce a marketable product in the next few years and have put the unit up for sale Serious question, but how is DeepMind going to generate real revenue?
- daveguy 11y agoBy shoving twice as many advertisements in each search? Smart advertisements that understand what you want -- that knows if you just bought a frying pan you probably aren't in the market for a frying pan.
- drewda 11y agoWest Coast point of comparison: http://www.willowgarage.com/pages/about-us/history http://www.willowgarage.com/pages/about-us/history
- tim333 11y agoBoston Dynamics always seemed an odd fit for Google give they were making robots for the military and Google has its "don't be evil" motto. I'm not sure how you bring those two together.
- pgwhalen 11y agoWell perhaps the military isn't evil. Maybe that's how.
- tim333 11y agoYeah but the whole killer robot thing. Not sure it's the image Google's after.
- krapp 11y agoI don't know why people keep taking "don't be evil" seriously. It's obviously an effective slogan and somehow it's convinced a lot of people that Google is something other than a business, whose only purpose is to make a few people very very rich, but unless Google is legally bound to "not be evil[0]", it doesn't mean anything. [0]illegal forms of evil notwithstanding. maybe.
- awqrre 11y agoGoogle dropped that motto long ago ( http://www.siliconvalleywatcher.com/mt/archives/2009/04/google_quietly.php http://www.siliconvalleywatcher.com/mt/archives/2009/04/goog... ) ... note: I had to use duckduckgo to find that web page in the top 10 results.
- ww520 11y agoThis sounds like turf fighting gone bad. The immediate revenue generation is just an excuse. Google has many other research projects that won't be profitable for a long time, like self driving.
- colordrops 11y agoEveryone saw the recent Atlas videos. Even with the QR code shortcuts, the demo was nothing short of miraculous. No one is even close to what Boston Dynamics is doing with legged locomotion, which is an insanely valuable technology. There's no way Google would just let this company go because of monetization or PR reasons. Something else is happening behind the scenes that we aren't yet aware of.
- nojvek 11y agoGoogle is the moonshots and the AI company. If anyone could monetize this it was Google. This really does come as a big shock. Doesn't google have billions as cash. How much of a dent is Boston Dynamics really to the finance sheet. I bet there is a chash of egos involved in this sale.
- TheArcane 11y agoI would absolutely love to get an insider insight.
- clairity 11y agothe future of robotics is taking advantage of passive-dynamics. the problem with boston dynamics was they leaned heavily on active control, which makes locomotion energetically expensive. when you watch those videos, notice how lumbering the motion is and hoe hard those machines work. i would bet that that is the underlying reason why google pulled out.
- colordrops 11y agoI watched the videos, and I see what looks like machine learning managing those legs, and whether there is active or passive dynamics driving the motion of the legs is unclear. I am no expert in robotics though, so someone correct me if I am wrong. If you are suggesting systems like Theo Jansen's Strandbeest is the future of robots, you are sorely mistaken. How would a robot utilizing passive dynamics climb steps or a ladder, or dance, or pick someone up and jump across a gap?
- 11y ago
- dschiptsov 11y agoThe story for robotics, it seems, is similar to classic AI - our models are too primitive and technology too crude. Nature has its reasons to make everything from tissues of specialized cells. This is the way to achieve precision, elasticity and adaptability.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Simon321 11y ago>“There’s excitement from the tech press, but we’re also starting to see some negative threads about it being terrifying, ready to take humans’ jobs,” wrote Courtney Hohne, a director of communications at Google and the spokeswoman for Google X. >Hohne went on to ask her colleagues to “distance X from this video” and wrote, “we don’t want to trigger a whole separate media cycle about where BD really is at Google.” >“We’re not going to comment on this video because there’s really not a lot we can add, and we don’t want to answer most of the Qs it triggers,” she wrote. AI fear-mongering is already doing damage. What a disappointment...
- aliakhtar 11y agoI cannot agree more.
- drstrangevibes 11y agogoogle are not a hardware company. theres no money in hardware it doesnt make sense, google also need to shift the perception that they are evil. This company doesnt help them achieve that. Especially as the combination of machine learning and robotics is going to put the majority of human being out of work in the near future, having this company for google is in no means useful
- rwhitman 11y agoThey mentioned this in the article, but I'd say it has a lot to do with image. Boston Dynamics seems fixated on posting videos of people abusing their robots to demonstrate their ability to regain balance, but the general public finds them pretty disturbing and are easy fodder for late night comedy jokes about robot uprisings. Not really the kind of visual you want to put in people's minds when your company is simultaneously developing AI that was broadcast besting a human at the world's hardest board game. No short term ROI + product milestones in the form of creepy videos = Google's black sheep