17 ms·
Should All Research Papers Be Free?
- arek_ 11y agoWho will produce meaningful research for free?
- rfrey 11y agoThe people who conduct the research, and the people who fund the research, are not collecting the fees to view the research.
- pen2l 11y agoMoreover, the people conducting the research pay to the journals too. There's sort of an application fee for submitting your paper to a lot of big-name journals.
- ikeboy 11y agoThe open access journals charge thousands. Journal publishing has costs, and they need to be born by someone. If not from access fees, they'll need to be paid upfront, which means each study costs more, which means either less studying gets done, or funds come from elsewhere to fund it.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y ago>Journal publishing has costs I've yet to see any justification at all for the outrageous fees charged by academic journals. The only costs I can see are printing/distribution and web hosting. Typesetting is trivial. Editing is non-existent. Editorial isn't paid. Peer review isn't paid. Having a nice office and marketing staff who hold university libraries to ransom shouldn't count as a cost.
- ikeboy 11y agoThe first fact you need to deal with is that open access journals, started to explicitly counter the cost problem, have similar costs. If it was as simple as you think it is, open access journals would be much cheaper. (Arxiv is not peer reviewed, and does not count.) The second point is that publishers costs are around 70% of revenue, as the article says margins are around 30%. That means there's a limit to how low they can go and not lose money, and I doubt many of those complaining would suddenly stop if prices were 30% lower.
- denzil_correa 11y ago> (Arxiv is not peer reviewed, and does not count. Oh it does count. Peer reviews in journals are done by scientists for free. Peer review adds completely negligible costs (or even ZERO) to a journal. ArXiv is the perfect example.
- ikeboy 11y ago> Peer review adds completely negligible costs (or even ZERO) to a journal. Then can you explain why arxiv costs around $10 per paper, while plos charges over 100 times as much?
- denzil_correa 11y agoI don't know why PLOS charges more. The point I'm trying to make is that - just because there's an OA journal out there which charges $100 per article; it doesn't mean that the costs are justified.
- ikeboy 11y agoDo you have any compelling evidence that the costs for OA journals is one or two orders of magnitude less than everyone claims they are? (See e.g. http://www.nature.com/news/open-access-the-true-cost-of-science-publishing-1.12676 http://www.nature.com/news/open-access-the-true-cost-of-scie... which also shows a wide variety in publishing costs.)
- rfrey 11y agoFrom searching on the web it seems like the only open access journals who charge thousands are the traditional publishers (Wiley, Springer) with an "open access" option. They probably have internal conflicts around cannibalizing existing business. Exclusively open access journals seem to charge $USD500-1000. Happy to be corrected with other examples though.
- ikeboy 11y agohttps://www.plos.org/publications/publication-fees/ https://www.plos.org/publications/publication-fees/ lists significantly more than that.
- rfrey 11y agoI stand corrected, thank you. Furthermore, the journals seem to have many more articles than I thought - I had estimated 20 per journal, but most PLOS journals seem to have 30-40 articles. In my original $ estimate I also assumed 10 issues a year, most PLOS journals seem to do 12. So consider $2250/article as a representative price in the PLOS suite, by 35 articles by 12 issues - About $USD950,000/annum revenue per journal. I wonder how that compares to revenue/issue for the traditional subscription model augmented by online fees? I looked at Elsivier and Wiley's financial statements but there wasn't enough info broken out to guess. EDIT: closer reading of Wiley's statements [1] suggest $1.385 billion revenue from journal subscriptions with 1600 "scientific and professional journals" in print, for revenue of $865,000 per journal. [1] http://www.wiley.com/legacy/about/corpnews/fy15_10kFINAL.pdf http://www.wiley.com/legacy/about/corpnews/fy15_10kFINAL.pdf
- imglorp 11y agoSome things, like dissemination of knowledge, are truly in the interest of all humanity. It seems criminal that a few hundred people at the publishing houses should benefit at the expense of billions' welfare.
- pen2l 11y agoI agree with you that knowledge should be accessible to all. But, do realize that there most certainly is value being contributed by journals who are making you pay. For example, the editorial work, the typesetting, the selection, the whole system, etc. So they do need a paycheck from somewhere. So, I think this is actually like the common software/music/movies piracy situation... but a lot better! My (simplified) feelings about piracy are: do it if you're dirt-poor, don't do it if you can easily afford it. By this account, Kanye was a d-bag for pirating.. whatever software he pirated, because he, of all people, should be able to afford it. A starving artist with lots of debts, in my opinion, can't be accused of doing a great moral wrong when he's stealing a thing which has an effective zero marginal cost (arguably). The biggest problem here is that... there do exist people like Kanye who really should pay for things but end up not doing so. What's different in this scenario is that... I am almost 100% certain that all institutions that should be paying... will be paying! I mean, can you imagine some Harvard or MIT lab skipping payment on the journals? No, that's just not going to happen. The Harvards and MITs of the world will keep paying... the rest -- the public, or schools in suffering areas and nations, who can't afford it as easily, will be able to get it using scihub. It works out wonderfully in this way.
- east2west 11y agoJournals do minimal typesetting, and practically no editorial work. Paper reviews are done by academics, free. Editors are mostly academics, not depending a paycheck from publishers. There is cost, like marketing cost, but none that justifies $35 per article to the general public.
- chestervonwinch 11y agoHere's the breakdown of the current job postings at Elsevier (not to say that this reflects accurately how the $35 / article is divided up): * 112 IT * 10 customer service * 3 data analysis * 28 editorial * 3 accounting * 4 general MGMT * 3 HR, 35 marketing * 18 manufacturing * 22 product MGMT * 3 program MGMT I would really like to see an official breakdown of the cost per article and especially the processing cost paid by authors. edit: formatting.
- yeukhon 11y agoI am still willing to pay for a high-quality printed version of research journals, but for the online access I think we should simply give away because research knowledge should belong in the public domain when you choose to publish the knowledge with a research journal. You are not publishing a paper within your 4x4 walled intrnaet. But I get it. There is a business cost behind running a journal / magazine (although not all reputable one charge fees!). So here is the radical question: why the fuck do we need 100+ CS-related journal publishers out there? All we need is one.
- ycmbntrthrwaway 11y ago> So here is the radical question: why the fuck do we need 100+ CS-related journal publishers out there? All we need is one. I don't get it. You want it to be monopoly?
- jacquesm 11y agoIt need not be a monopoly even if there is only one. It could be a decentralized single entity along the lines of usenet with a whole pile of people contributing and there being only one major distribution network.
- payne92 11y agoI feel especially strongly that papers that result from taxpayer-funded research should be free.
- mmmBacon 11y agoI also think code used to produce results should be published as well.
- SalmoShalazar 11y agoI agree with this in theory... but do you really want my garbage, ad hoc, messy code that I used to pipe output from one program to another?
- bravura 11y agoYes. Especially because if you are forced to publish your code, it will be better.
- return0 11y agoAbsolutely yes. Science isnt supposed to be clean and tidy, but reproducible.
- nv-vn 11y agoConsidering that a mistake in such a program could completely skew results, yeah that seems pretty important.
- lacker 11y agoYes, because if it doesn't even compile then I will call BS on your results.
- skybrian 11y agoSee, that's exactly what you shouldn't do if you want to encourage academics to release the source code. Academic code sometimes only has been made to work on one machine (the author's). Someone reproducing the results should still have access to the source, even if they have to hack it to work on their system.
- jammycakes 11y agoSomething I'd like to see here: results published in research papers aggregated and released as open data. There must be a lot of interesting meta-analyses that aren't getting done because the necessary data is locked away behind paywalls, and usually not in an easily machine readable format into the bargain.
- stegosaurus 11y agoAll everything 'should' be free. At least, that which is not scarce. The correct question to ask is 'can' all research papers be free - does the world continue to spin, will research still happen, will we still progress, if they are free? The only reason we even have this debate to begin with is because the producers of this information require scarce/controlled resources in order to survive.
- savanaly 11y agoIt's not exactly post-scarcity, it's just zero marginal cost. It's true that, given the product has already been created and has zero marginal cost, it "should" be free. But for setting the expectations that producers of future products have about what compensation they'll receive we can't simply say it should be free.
- zanny 11y agoThe marginal units absolutely can be free, just pay for the research itself. Fixed cost for fixed work.
- ycmbntrthrwaway 11y agoThat is how private research is funded, say at Microsoft Research. You agree on "deliverables" and get your money for each stage of your work. Deliverables include tech reports, source code, prototypes and things like that. You get nothing after your stop working on the project. For producers, i.e. researchers, this scheme is not worse than grants and getting money for published articles, citations etc., they don't get money for years after the publication anyway.
- stegosaurus 11y agoPosting in a seperate comment here as I was mainly aiming to provoke debate with the original one. This generally chimes with my feeling. It seems to me that the users of research can derive vastly different value from it and so the flat price model doesn't really work. Consider some new research on light emitting diodes and the value Samsung might get from that vs. me reading it out of curiosity. For that reason, to me it makes sense to treat academic research as infrastructure and have free access to all funded via taxation.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ikeboy 11y ago>The largest companies, like Elsevier, Taylor & Francis, Springer and Wiley, typically have profit margins of over 30 percent, which they say is justified because they are curators of research, selecting only the most worthy papers for publication. > But that financial model requires authors to pay a processing charge that can run anywhere from $1,500 to $3,000 per article so the publisher can recoup its costs. These two facts seem to point strongly to the publishers' being in the right. 30% is not a high number. If they were to lower their prices by 30%, running completely as nonprofits (or whatever number would break even), do you think people's complaints about difficulty of access would go away? If not, your complaining is not about their profit. And you can't seriously expect them to eat a >$1000 loss on every paper. Either we need a single party to fund upfront, like the government, or we need some other way to pay for it.
- ikeboy 11y agoThe quote from the The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (not the UN charter http://www.un.org/en/charter-united-nations/ http://www.un.org/en/charter-united-nations/, odd mistake by the nytimes) is also misleading. The very next sentence says >(2) Everyone has the right to the protection of the moral and material interests resulting from any scientific, literary or artistic production of which he is the author.
- Blahah 11y agoNote that the authors do not get materials benefit when journals sell their articles. If anything that sentence means that authors can claim back the profits made by publishers.
- ikeboy 11y agoAuthors sign over their copyrights to the journals. Are you suggesting copyright should not be transferable (people should not be permitted to transact freely)? Authors do benefit by being able to publish for much less than it would cost were they to bear all the costs. To be precise, they benefit by the cost of open access that offers comparable service.
- GirlProgrammer 11y agoThe ones that taxpayers pay for should be!
- ycmbntrthrwaway 11y agoThe main problems with tax-funded research and grants is that money is given in return for citations in journals with high "impact factor". As a result, publishers of those journals are indirectly supported by the state. Instead, government or funding organizations should review the results of the work for themselves, but they are unable to do it, because they usually don't understand a thing about research subject.
- return0 11y agoThat's the problem, organizations don't want do do the work so they outsource it. But the journal market is not free, it's dominated by incumbents who earned the position centuries ago. As the experience with open access journals shows so far, it's near impossible to get scientists to volunteer their free labor to a new journal. Regulatory action (like requiring open access for all govt-funded science) should be taken here.
- drjesusphd 11y agoBut the publishers outsource the same work to referees. Why not cut out the middle man and have the funding agencies orchestrate the peer-review? That's what they do for grants anyway.
- x5n1 11y agoWhat benefit do the publishers provide to anyone? Why do the publishers deserve billions of dollars?
- zmmmmm 11y agoSomeone has to coordinate the peer review process - that is, vet the trash, enforce standards, locate qualified reviewers and coordinate their feedback into digestible form. Now, in my opinion 95% of this is automatable and the other 5% probably costs about $50 per manuscript, so the current fees are certainly outrageous. However I don't think we will be doing ourselves a service to say that publishers do nothing at all. They just don't do anything comparable the value that they extract.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- return0 11y agoI hope this publicitly doesnt lead to swift shutdown of scihub. She provides us with a great service that helps many researchers work faster. We should also commend her for stirring the most lively debate about an anachronistic and dumb publishing system.
- denzil_correa 11y ago> “The real people to blame are the leaders of the scientific community — Nobel scientists, heads of institutions, the presidents of universities — who are in a position to change things but have never faced up to this problem in part because they are beneficiaries of the system,” said Dr. Eisen. “University presidents love to tout how important their scientists are because they publish in these journals.” For me, this is the cog of the problem. People who are in a position to change should push for it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- platform 11y agoTaxpayer funded research must be free to read. Also, a research that has been at least partially tax-funded resulting in a publication, must not be usable as an necessary ingredient for a commercial patent. That is, a patent can include this type of research, but it cannot be a 'necessity' for the patent to be viable. Or, if the particular research, is necessary for a given patent to be viable, the patent must grant no-fees, no-commercial-strings-attached use. This allows a corporation to establish patents as means to protect itself, while allowing the tax funded research to be used by others without commercial strings attached
- mrdrozdov 11y agoThis isn't the right question. The question is, "Who should be profiting from research papers?" The Journal performs quality control for the sake of consistency and prestige, but the papers and their reviews are put together by researchers, commonly at great cost for marginal personal gain. The article's hero doesn't really care. She needs to read papers, and needs other people to be able to read them, so she built sci-hub (demo: https://sci-hub.io/10.1038/nature16990 https://sci-hub.io/10.1038/nature16990).
- platform 11y agoWRT > This isn't the right question. The question is, "Who should be profiting from research papers?" I am not sure that the way you put it s right either. Because "who should be profiting from research papers?" is too generic of a question, and does not appear to necessarily supersede the question 'should tax-funded publication be readable for free?' If I may rephrase your question to be: "Quality control of a research paper, must be, necessarily funded (either by money or a form of barter). Therefore question a) who should fund it, question b) who should receive funding to do the quality control" Then, obviously, this is an important question. And I do not believe has been clearly answered either in polices or on this forum. My answer to ( a ) would be -- the same entity that funds the research (therefore in this case the tax payers) My answer to ( b ) would be -- a licensed or otherwise professionally certified group, independently selected (that is not selected by the researcher that authors the publication).
- lacker 11y agoWhy does it cost $3000 to publish an article?? You can put it on Medium for free.
- sre_ops 11y agoBecause most of researchers are incoherent.
- arbre 11y agoCan someone explain me why the researchers themselves don't publish their work for free? The article says they are not paid for the articles so I don't see why they couldn't do that.
- return0 11y agoMost journals withhold the copyright, and the scientists happily relinquish it. They can distribute preprint copies of their article (very few do in life sciences) but not the article itself.
- danieltillett 11y agoI would not say that most scientist happly relinquish it, but they trade off the prestige gained from publishing in the journal for the copyright. The real problem is the use of journals as an arbiture of research quality. If it didn’t matter to your career if you published in Nature or PLOS One then everyone would publish in PLOS One. If you are more likely to get a job or grant by publishing in Nature then people will do almost anything to get their work into Nature. We are trying to solve the wrong problem by worrying about journals controlling copyright.
- return0 11y agoSorry, i find it hard to imagine a scientist feeling sad that he will publish a Nature paper. You are spot on that we need a new arbiter. It's 2016 and we rely on this ancient system, it's no wonder that the elseviers of the world take advantage of it. But the control of copyright is a real problem, and i think we underestimate how much it hampers science (esp. considering the wonderful things one could do with machine analysis of the texts)
- danieltillett 11y agoI have not met a scientist (including myself) that was happy about giving up the copyright, but it is viewed as the cost of publishing in a “prestige” journal. Nearly all scientists would prefer to retain the copyright if they could and make their papers widely available to everyone interested provide it did not exclude publishing in a career advanacing journal.
- jimjimjim 11y agounpopular opinion ahead: no, and probably not even for taxpayer funded research. Can you demand a lift in a garbage truck? or in a tank? both of these things are provided for local or central government. why not? because it distracts from the job that they are there for. The same can be said for research (and source code). It takes time, effort and money to publish and peer review research. If journals can't make money providing access to the research who is going to pay for it? Also there is currently a lot of BAD research out there. Domain experts don't have time to review all of it. Journals with prestigious names act as filters and as sort of priority queues for where you should look first.
- jacobolus 11y agoJust to clarify: Is your position that research written by academic scientists, funded by government grants and university budgets, reviewed by volunteers, and proofread and typeset by the researchers themselves, handed off to a journal to put in a print edition or stick a pdf on their website, should belong exclusively to the corporate owners of the journal for a period of ~100 years after publication, with no profit flowing back to the university, the researcher, or the reviewers? If this is not your position, can you clarify what you think scientific publishing should look like? > because it distracts from the job that they are there for. What is the “job scientific papers are there for”, if not sharing knowledge with other scientists and the people of the world? As for your silly garbage truck / tank analogy: instead of these, we have buses, which work much better for the task.
- adrianbd 11y agoThis. Journals made a lot of sense before the age of the internet, when they actually did have to do a lot of work to coordinate the activity of physically collecting research papers, mailing them for reviews, paying dedicated people for typesetting and so on. Although the cost of all of this has almost vanished now that tools for editing are so accessible and delivery costs are inexistent, publishers still charge ridiculous sums for papers produced mostly from public money simply because of their prestige.
- vlasev 11y ago
- Chinjut 11y agoYes. ("Betteridge's law of headlines" fails)
- nether 11y agoNot much of a law when it's broken so often.
- catnaroek 11y agoWhat follows is just my very uninformed opinion. I'm not a scientist myself, but my interest in CS and math has made me an avid reader of scientific papers and books - whenever they're publicly available, that is. What publishing houses do is exploit the rules of the social games that scientists themselves willingly play. When the importance of an academic work is judged by the names of its authors, or by the name of the journal in which it is published, or by the presence of fashionable keywords in its title or in the abstract, scientists are giving publishing houses the very rope with which they will be hanged. So, while the behavior of publishing houses is certainly antisocial and most abominable, it is only made possible by the very scientific community that condemns it. Is there any fundamental reason why scientists can't always submit their papers to the arXiv, and let the web of citations determine their relative importance?
- KKKKkkkk1 11y agoPapers not published in a prestigious journal are not cited.
- andreasvc 11y agoNot necessarily true. Depending on the field, publications in arxiv can be important and cited.
- Al-Khwarizmi 11y agoIn my country, for example, most applications for tenure, salary complements, required assessments, etc., have an assessment scale like this (simplified but this is basically the idea): Paper in the 1st quartile of the ISI JCR journal list - 3 points Paper in the 2nd quartile of the ISI JCR journal list - 2 points Paper in the 3rd quartile of the ISI JCR journal list - 1 points Rest - 0 points So if you publish a ground-breaking paper in arXiv that everyone reads and everyone cites, you get exactly zero points. Of course, stuff like length of the paper, number of authors, possible overlap with other published papers, or just actual quality (as in someone reading the paper to see whether it's any good) also count zero. And then you have the roulette factor of submitting a paper to a first-quartile journal in year X, which gets published in year X+1 (due to the length of the publication process), only to see that in year X+1 the journal is now fourth-quartile as in CS they are dancing all the time...
- robertwalsh0 11y agoFull disclosure: I'm a founder of a company called Scholastica that provides software that helps journals peer-review and publish open-access content online. One of our journal clients, Discrete Analysis, is linked to in the NYT article. It is incredibly obvious that journal content shouldn't cost as much as it does. - Scholars write the content for free - Scholars do the peer-review for free - All the legacy publishers do is take the content and paywall PDF files Can you believe it? Paywalling. PDFs. For billions. Of course the publishers say they create immense value by typesetting said PDFs, but as technologists, we can clearly see that this is bunk. There's a comment in this thread that mentions the manual work involved in taking Word files and getting them into PDFs, XML, etc. While that is an issue, which you could consider a technology problem, it definitely doesn't justify the incredible cost of journal content that has been created and peer-reviewed at no cost. Keep in mind that journal prices have risen much faster than the consumer price index since the 80s (1). The future is very clear, academics do the work as they've always done and share the content with the public at a very low cost via the internet. PS. If you want a peek into how the publishers see the whole Sci-Hub kerfuffle, check out this post from one of their industry blogs - the comment section is a doozy: http://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2016/03/02/sci-hub-and-the-four-horsemen-of-the-internet/ http://scholarlykitchen.sspnet.org/2016/03/02/sci-hub-and-th... 1. https://cdn1.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/jtj2dzMfklULQipRZt_3xaLoFxU=/800x0/filters:no_upscale()/cdn0.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/6143539/fig-increases.0.png https://cdn1.vox-cdn.com/thumbor/jtj2dzMfklULQipRZt_3xaLoFxU...
- dinkumthinkum 11y agoWhy are you under the impression scholars write the papers for free? That is what researchers are employed at universities to do ... Yes, it is not like publishing a book but these papers are not really like books anyway.
- Retra 11y agoThey're not getting paid by the publisher.
- 11y ago
- kombucha2 11y agoYes
- reuven 11y agoWhen I finished my PhD at Northwestern, part of the university's procedure involved going to the ProQuest Web site. ProQuest is a journal and dissertation publishing company. They asked if I wanted my dissertation to be available, free of charge, to anyone interested in reading it. Clicking on "yes, I want to make it available for free" would cost me something like $800. Clicking on "no, I'll let you charge people to see it" would cost me nothing. Having just finished, and being in debt to do so, it shouldn't come as a surprise that I wasn't rushing to pay even more. So now, if people want to see my dissertation, they have to pay -- or be part of an institution that pays an annual fee to ProQuest. (BTW, e-mail me if you want a copy.) My guess is that it's similar with other journals. And while professors have more than PhD students, they have limited enough research funds that they'll hold their nose, save the money, and keep things behind a paywall. Which is totally outrageous. It's about time that this change, and I'm happy to see what looks like the beginning of the end on this front.
- jmvalin 11y agoThere is an alternative: you host your thesis (and/or papers) on your own website, or you put them on arXiv.org. It's called self-archiving and it's allowed by most publishers. Funny thing is: making your papers available for free also increases the number of citations, something academics really care about.
- juliendorra 11y agoAnd another alternative at some universities is the university thesis open archive itself. In Northern Europe I'm told some universities won't even give you your diploma if you don't upload your thesis in their open archive. Frankly, every university in the world should have an open archive for thesis (and mutualized is even better). It's just the continuation of keeping thesis copies at the university library.
- haskal 11y agoThere's nothing that stops you from uploading the PDF elsewhere, right? Why not just push the file to some free hosting service (or even GitHub in a GitHub Pages repo)?
- bloaf 11y agoYes. They should. It is in the best interests of humanity to make the knowledge obtained through research available to anyone looking for that knowledge. There is a clear consensus among scientists that the current publishing model is at best inexpedient and at worst hostile to that end. Most people are asking what good the current publishing model provides, but I think to answer that question we need to ask: "compared to what?" It seems clear to me that the current model is better than having no publishing mechanism at all, but I doubt that anyone seriously thinks that the "none" model is the only alternative. I think that if we sat down today and thought up a new publishing model from scratch, we would be able to outdo the status quo on just about every "good" people have mentioned here, as well as provide features that the current model is incapable of. I think it is highly likely that we could make a system that ran on donated resources alone. Some things we might want/have in a "from scratch" model: 1. Direct access to data-as-in-a-database instead of data-as-a-graph-in-a-PDF 2. Blockchain-based reputation system for scientists 3. P2P storage and sharing of scientific data 4. Tiers of scientific information, e.g. an informal forum-of-science, semi-formal wiki-of-science, and formal publications 5. Automated peer review process 6. A better and more consistent authoring tool for scientists
- leed25d 11y agoResearch funded by taxpayer dollars should be free to those who paid for it.
- cft 11y agoPublishing used to cost money when it required physical printing/distrubution/storage of journals. Now all of this is basically free, but they still charge. Most theoretical physicists for example only care about "publishing" in the ArXiv (all free, open source). The traditional publishing is ridiculous.
- iabacu 11y agoPublishing cost today is smaller -- yet publishers actually charge more. Libraries used to get a physical copy of the papers, which would grant lifetime access to the research. Today, they pay for subscription, and as soon as they stop paying, they lose access to everything.
- jeffdavis 11y agoNothing is "free", the only question is: "who pays, and how does that change the incentives and results?".
- js8 11y agoOf course there are things that are "free", such as scientific progress and artworks made by already dead people, or sun radiation. Making everything "non-free" will lead to self-contradictory theories such as labor theory of value.
- pmarreck 11y agoHow is something that is, in essence, "truth determination and dissemination," not free?
- davnn 11y agoI think Elbakyan should do everything to make sci-hub easily replaceable. Once it's hosted on multiple places it would be much harder to shut down. Maybe completely free research papers are not the future but there should be a Spotify for research papers that is affordable for everyone. I hope that Elbakyan will reach her goal and ultimately change the whole industry.
- dschiptsov 11y agoAt least they will get wider and less biased and institution-conditioned reviews.
- sandra_saltlake 11y agorequired open access publication
- baby 11y agoYou don't want me to read your paper? Charge for it.
- kriro 11y agoIf it is funded by government in any way (public university, research project) I think it is borderline defrauding the tax payer that the research funded by tax-money is not free by default. Since close to all research is government funded in some way, shape or form...my answer would be yes in the general case. I think the long term answer is decentralized publishing. Publish everything you do on a university or private website and let others decide if it's good or not when they want to cite it instead of a peer review that is set in stone. I think people reading papers deciding if they want to cite you are smart enough to figure out if it's good research or not. The peer review process is overrated (and quite often suffers from insider networks). If you decentralize publishing you can also have other researchers upvote a paper to basically approve of the academic standards in the paper. I also think the static nature of papers is a problem. I'd much rather cite a specific version of the paper. I'm thinking about git and pull requests along the lines of "want to cite, fixed layout" or "new research disproves this" etc.
- _pmf_ 11y agoSome research grants are industry subsidies. Taking this away results in pure, accessible research that is absolutely useless.
- doppioandante 11y agoLately I have been thinking about this, and I figured that publishing/citing can be described exactly using a Merkle tree. Things like ipfs have been on the hn front page quite a lot, I wonder whether anybody thought about using them to decentralize paper publishing.
- adrianN 11y agoThis is not a technology problem. People send their papers to reputable journals because of their reputation and journals have a good reputation because everybody wants to publish there. Getting papers into a big journal is nearly the only benchmark academics have when it comes to getting a job or tenure.
- 11y ago
- guico 11y agoI wonder, in the end what's really holding open-access publishing back? What can we do, as technologists, to help fix it?
- ajuc 11y agoScience funded by taxes should be free, obviously.
- ordbajsare 11y agoDangerous as normal people then can read government funded garbage science and question it's validity.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deepnet 11y agoIt is tragic that foundational papers are hugely paywalled. I can read David Silver on arXiv but not Donald Michie or Robin Popplestone. I am missing the foundations of my science, so much is uncitable for me, and bibliographies are useless before 2001. Yes I can track them down but the effort is huge as I'm far from an urban centre. My light does not diminish yours, let me cite you
- tomahunt 11y agoThere must be thousands of people who could use free access to research papers: PhDs and Masters now in industry trying to apply the state of the art, engineers who have worked their way into a subject, concerned citizens who want to read the source material. I am a PhD who'd love to be working in industry, but I'm shit scared that once I leave the gates of the university I'll simply lose touch with the state of the art because the papers will no longer be accessible.
- alphonsegaston 11y agoMany university library systems have programs where alumni (and sometimes outsiders) can purchase access to their resources for a yearly fee. If that's unavailable to you or cost prohibitive, most academic libraries are open to the public. When I worked at an engineering library for a large university, a good part of my day was spent helping working professional access these kinds of resources.
- DaveWalk 11y agoDepends on your field, but my local library has the latest Cell, Science and Nature magazines for perusal, and anything older than 1 year is usually released gratis. If you need more than this to stay up to the state-of-the-art, chances are your future "industry" job will also have access to this, or it will become more of a hobby. Just my opinion as a PhD, working in industry, who does not read nearly as much as he used to.
- alkonaut 11y agoLet's rephrase the question: should public research funded with public money have results available to those who paid for it? This isn't Elseviers fault, or the researchers fault or the universities fault, it's the fault of whoever distributes public money to research without having proper criteria for what is expected in return.
- julie1 11y agoShould leibniz, keppler, Einstein, newton, flemming, jenner papers should have been free? Oh they were. And it is thanks to flemming that people stopped dying in atrocious ways over the world from gangrene. Should citizens be able to access state of the art research about how to prevent vascular disease, dietetic, chemical pollution, effects of fracking, urbanisms to help them make good choices when voting? I do think so. Because no vote exists without enlighten choices. Chosing without relevant information on future choice that will impact every one require citizens that can have a constructed opinion. And experts are doing a poor job at being right. (look at the financial regulations made by experts and the long lasting crisis since 2000). So yes, papers should be free to support the exercise of democracy.
- sre_ops 11y agoI see the smartest people in the room do not know the difference between society journals and regular journals. It is actually very simple. If it is a society journal then the copyright is owned by a society and the society decides what they want to do. Some of them outsource production to publishers by paying publishers money. The others do it all themselves. Over last 10 years most of smaller society journals went away because contrary to popular but highly delusional belief turning the manuscript into a readable paper is a rather expensive process and most of the society journals cannot afford it. So instead they simply sell the copyrights to the likes of T&F, Springer, etc. EICs get to continue to dabble with deciding who gets accepted and someone else gets to do the unsexy part of making sure that 3/4 of the content has not been lifted from websites or other papers. Most of the publishers have different level of open access policies, some of which are pay $X thousand dollars (i.e. production costs at the publishers scale which are an order of magnitude smaller than for the society which has no scale ) and the content is available for free to anyone all the way to "pay $X per article"
- adultSwim 11y agoYes
- erikpukinskis 11y agoA better question to me is "Should there be fields where distributing your work for free will harm your academic career?"
- justncase80 11y agoI was thinking a good startup company may be an open publication and peer review site. Something where users are non-anonymous and they are weighted by their accomplishments irl. Submissions and peer reviews would be open to anyone but weighted heavily by ranking, which is affected by irl achievements and cumulative quality contributions to the site. Like a combination of stack overflow and wikipedia maybe. Money would be made by donation (ala wikipedia) and paper submission fees. Perhaps organizational level membership fees, such as universities, etc. Just an idea I haven't had time to work on.
- tn13 11y agoAll the state funded research must be in public domain. Everywhere else the one who funds the research must decide what to do with it.
- sekou 11y agoProviding more open access to existing research information is just as important as empowering people to share and distribute the findings of their research in formats that both machines and people can understand. I believe we have already produced large amounts of data in wildly different fields of study that can potentially be used with the help of machines (and the diverse perspectives of many humans) to solve problems for which we currently don't have answers. It looks like the Fair Access to Science and Technology Research (FASTR) bill linked in the article would be a step in the right direction for US citizens. I wonder how other forces (like Sci-Hub) will affect the direction of things to come.
- n2dasun 11y agoI found it chuckleworthy that this posted on the NYT site, which is known for paywalled articles.
- naveen99 11y agoI plan to submit my next paper to peerj https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/PeerJ https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/PeerJ