18 ms·
Macbook charger teardown: surprising complexity inside Apple's power adapter
- Analemma_ 11y agoMy takeaway from this is that the $80 Apple charger is definitely safer and has higher-quality components than the $12 cheapo Chinese charger, but not nearly so much better that it solely explains the price difference, and that Apple is making a healthy margin on these things. So my question is, is anyone selling a quality charger without the Apple tax? Is there anyone making, say, $40 chargers that have the components of the real thing?
- intellegacy 11y agoI've bought two replica chargers for $20-30 off ebay.. i'm on my second. The first one lasted a year, which is about how long my original charger lasted due to the cord fraying
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoThe OP shows why replica chargers are not a good idea. You're lucky if it doesn't destroy your machine.
- TheSpiceIsLife 11y agoSo far I've used about 7 cheapo MacBook chargers off eBay - I have two right now, and have, over the years, given the other 5 away. While a couple of them have died, so have my original three MacBook chargers. None of them has killed or damaged mine, or anyone else's MacBooks.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoYes, some people have good experiences, but it's still incredibly reckless. Chargers without proper safety features and which don't conform to electrical isolation standards could render your $1000+ machine worthless in a puff of smoke, or, worse, kill you.
- jacquesm 11y agoThe 'Original Apple' item shown at the bottom of the post doesn't look as if it fared much better though. The magic smoke definitely came out on that one and whoever owned it was lucky it ended there and didn't end with an actual fire.
- rMBP 11y agoIt could also be the Apple charger's design that makes it able to handle shorting of components without posing a hazard to anything other than itself.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoApple's own charger follows safety standards. It might blow up, but it won't take your laptop with it.
- vacri 11y agoUpthread there is someone saying that their Apple charger set fire to their carpet, and the only reason why it wasn't worse was because they were in the room at the time to stop it.
- guelo 11y agoNobody in the history of personal computers has been killed by a charger.
- DanBC 11y agoYou can't know that. You can't know that there haven't been house fires caused by a charger, for example. Here's a recent house fire that killed five people, started by a phone charger. http://metro.co.uk/2015/06/10/phone-charger-started-fire-that-killed-five-members-of-family-5239404/ http://metro.co.uk/2015/06/10/phone-charger-started-fire-tha...
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoI doubt that short circuits have never killed anyone. That's not the only way a charger could kill you: DanBC points out the risk of fire, which is also a possibility.
- 8_hours_ago 11y agoIt depends on your luck... and I am unlucky. My knock-off charger completely destroyed the power supply in my MacBook Pro after a few months of using it.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoOr is there a charger at Apple's price, but more reliable?
- mikepurvis 11y agoI doubt it, since the magnetic connector itself is patented, and they apparently don't license it— which is why the BatteryBox connector is such an awkward hack: https://www.getbatterybox.com/shop https://www.getbatterybox.com/shop
- shade23 11y agoWow.I never gave much thought to Apple's magnetic connector till.The battery box does look like an ugly hack.But what I dont get is.Its magnets attracting.What and exactly what have they patented?
- jonknee 11y agoWell it's their own connector too, not a standard like USB. Everything about it is likely patented.
- enjo 11y agoUsing a magnet to connect to the device. You can't just reduce something to its simplest component when discussing patents. It's the specific application that matters.
- shade23 11y agoI guess this would be similar to the Samsung/Apple patent wars which happened?I guess that explains why no-one else tried making anything similar.
- noonespecial 11y agoMagnetic self-locating connectors have been around forever. I have a waffle iron from the 60's that's got one. The patented part is the specific size and shape (and pinout I guess) of that particular connector that prevents 3rd parties from making compatible adapters. Apple is far from alone in trying to profit from that shenanigan. It is, of course, profoundly wasteful for manufactures to pursue "nickle-and-dime" profits in this manner at the expense of the public and the environment. Something the cellphone charging standard in Europe tried to address. Just goes to show that there are plenty of places where Apple doesn't do much thinking different after all.
- palmeida 11y agoOn ebay there are a couple that say genuine http://www.ebay.com/itm/Genuine-Original-AC-Power-Adapter-Apple-15-17-MacBook-Pro-Magsafe-2-85W-A1424-/171539712612?hash=item27f0904a64:g:mxMAAOSwv1RUYxxf http://www.ebay.com/itm/Genuine-Original-AC-Power-Adapter-Ap... I ordered one yesterday (not from this dealer in question) that also said genuine. Let's see what they will send to me.
- austenallred 11y ago>On eBay >say genuine Having been an eBay buyer/seller for a long time, I would put way less stock in someone on eBay saying a product is "genuine" than you appear to be.
- listic 11y agoI've been buying some ThinkPad chargers on eBay and never encountered outright fraud. When they say genuine, they really are. Otherwise they use different words.
- austenallred 11y agoThey usually work, but I've never seen a legitimate name brand coming from Hong Kong via eBay. My experience was mostly in sporting equipment, and the stuff that I ordered looked and smelled like it was "Adidas" or "Nike," and even said "Nike," but it obviously wasn't made by Adidas or Nike.
- listic 11y agoAren't the actual, truly genuine Lenovo parts made there, too? Hong Kong is a Chinese territory.
- austenallred 11y agoLots of actual stuff is made (or shipped) from Hong Kong. I don't know enough about the specifics of Lenovo, I'm just saying I've bought and sold hundreds of thousands of dollars of items on eBay, and I've never yet seen a "genuine" name brand on eBay that shipped from Hong Kong that was actually legitimate. If I had to bet money on it, I would guess that these are the same type of things that you find in Chinese "fake markets" - name brand items that would pass as name brand to anyone who is not very, very familiar with the brand. If it works it doesn't matter in the end, but I've seen some real duds from those types of markets, as well. Maybe they "fell off the truck," but my money is on that they're fakes that are designed to resemble the real thing as closely as they can.
- sowbug 11y agoNot quite on point, but I hope someone soon creates a small adapter with a USB 3.0/3.1 Power Delivery-compatible plug on one end, and my laptop's charger plug on the other end. Then I'll be able to invest in a very high-quality 100-watt USB power supply that will work with any legacy laptops I have lying around. I expect all my future laptops/mobile devices will be Type C/USB 3.1, so I'll keep using that power supply for many years.
- XorNot 11y agoThe problem is the market at the moment is terrible. When buy genuine Apple or Samsung you know the quality is good. But when you pay something closer to what it should cost, who knows what you're getting? Could be a decent charger, could be heavily marked up Chinese junk.
- Brakenshire 11y agoIt's because the market is so fragmented. USB-C and USB power delivery will do a huge amount of good. The USB smartphone charger market is starting to produce genuinely well made third party products.
- alasdair_ 11y agoI recently bought a VESA monitor conversion kit for an apple display (why Apple can get away with charging $1000 for a 27 inch display is beyond me) that turned out to be a knock off. It looked IDENTICAL to the official apple version on the outside but the screws didn't line up perfectly and it was clearly an inferior product. I'm not planning on skimping again, even for essentially just a hunk of machined metal.
- eropple 11y agoI wouldn't buy one (I've got two Dell UltraSharps and I'm happy as a clam), but an Apple 27" monitor is also a Thunderbolt dock, most of which retail around $200. It's more expensive than its competitors, but I think that it's merely overpriced instead of exorbitant.
- OxO4 11y agoGroupon seems to be selling original ones starting at $30 (MacBook Air): https://www.groupon.com/deals/gg-apple-magsafe-2-power-adapters-for-macbook-1 https://www.groupon.com/deals/gg-apple-magsafe-2-power-adapt...
- woah 11y agoHidden gem in this article is a comically bald-faced lie from Steve Jobs: > "That switching power supply was as revolutionary as the Apple II logic board was. Rod doesn't get a lot of credit for this in the history books but he should. Every computer now uses switching power supplies, and they all rip off Rod Holt's design."
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoIt may not quite be true, but it's not necessarily a lie. People often don't realise where an invention came from.
- hydrogen18 11y agoYou're not really doing Jobs any favors. Instead of saying Jobs was a liar, you're saying he was an ignorant liar.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago"Liar" is too strong a word here. It's a misconception at best. Jobs would not have known the history of switching power supplies.
- gohrt 11y agoWhen you make statements that you don't know are true, but smart enough know that you profit in some way from people believing them, and you make no effort to find out the truth, you are a bullshitter. Jobs made a career of this sort of behavior. On the scale of respectability: 1. True statements. 2. Keeping your mouth shut. 3. Speculating. ... N-1. Making self-serving wishful statements as though they are facts. N. Outright Lies.
- Steko 11y agoThis whole tangent is because 'comically bald faced lie' is a comically bald faced worse way of describing the situation with words than how the article itself described it -- 'entirely false' -- despite Adam comment's description of the 'bald faced lie' as being somehow 'hidden' instead of being called out explicitly and discussed in detail.
- jabl 11y agoFascinating. The magsafe connector is awesome in preventing something snagging the cable from dragging your laptop along with it. But, as the article says, reliability is a problem. The thing is definitely not toddler-proof. I have a 2012 Macbook Air, and I'm on, I think, my fourth charger.
- engi_nerd 11y agoHad a 2011 Macbook Pro. Was always very nice to the charger, never abusing or dropping it. But Apple's decision with all their cabling to not incorporate strain relief was frustrating. I went through four chargers in four years. Why does Apple continue to ignore strain relief on their cabling?
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> Why does Apple continue to ignore strain relief on their cabling? Form > Function
- imglorp 11y agoRevenue > Form > Function
- spike021 11y agoOdd. I have a 2011 MBP as well and over four years of constant use in school (plugging in the charger at the dorm, unplugging and throwing it into my bag, plugging it in in class, removing, etc. in various places) it's held up. I use it now with my newer Macbook (just needed to get the magsafe 2 adapter dongle).
- engi_nerd 11y agoIt wouldn't have been so bad if you weren't paying for the high-quality engineering inside the charger itself. You get really nice, clean power out of them, but when you go through a charger every year, $80 is a little painful.
- 11y ago
- tptacek 11y agoThe LED in the Macbook power connector is programmable? Has someone written a tool to make it blink or something?
- kogepathic 11y agoIt's not programmable, there are two LEDs (well, 4 total) in the magsafe connector: one orange, one green. The same guy did a write up on the protocol used to communicate with the magsafe tips. It can also be used to trigger the above LEDs: http://www.righto.com/2013/06/teardown-and-exploration-of-magsafe.html http://www.righto.com/2013/06/teardown-and-exploration-of-ma...
- agentultra 11y agoI really hate how weak they made the strain relief. I found mine frayed within a year of use (in and out of bags and often hastily "wrapped up" in exactly the way the device suggests one should by form... but which everyone advises against). So I did what any enterprising hacker would and tore it open to strip and re-solder the connection... only I found super-thick solder points and don't have a strong enough gun to de-solder them. Ended up just blowing cash on a new brick. I was rather impressed by how many components they stash away in these things. I just wish the cables themselves were a little more reliable. They're otherwise fine devices.
- atomical 11y agoI don't know why this is down voted. This has happened to me many times.
- hedgehog 11y agoTheir wrapping instructions are terrible. You'll kill either the cable or one of the prongs pretty quickly. To protect the end when it starts coming apart silicone tape is ugly but effective (also works for the USB cables).
- pja 11y agoA bit of Sugru works as an alternative to silicone tape IME. I’ve got a bunch of frayed cables which are still going strong thanks to a chunk of Sugru round the frayed part.
- bartvk 11y ago> only I found super-thick solder points and don't have a strong enough gun to de-solder them. What often helps, is add a bit of solder to it. This makes the heat transfer much more efficient, and you'll be able to desolder it.
- weland 11y agoThis is a pretty interesting article! I raised more than my fair share of eyebrows by telling people I'm not really surprised with this kind of complexity (note: I'm an EE by formation, I took a frickin' two-semester course on power supplies) but that it doesn't fully justify the price difference. Also, Jobs was a blatant liar :-). The SMPS in any modern computer is based on a standard topology that Rod Holt -- though a brilliant engineer in his own right -- didn't invent. I don't remember the specific details, but it's based on a flyback design that was certainly well-known at the time.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoThe same site has a long article about Jobs' claim about the power supply. http://www.righto.com/2012/02/apple-didnt-revolutionize-power.html http://www.righto.com/2012/02/apple-didnt-revolutionize-powe...
- abritinthebay 11y agoI think this isn't so much Jobs lying as it is him doing his normal embellishment. Rod Holts design wasn't electrically unique, but it was extremely light and small. The Apple II wasn't the first computer to use a switching supply but it was shockingly light of a power supply which really helped the Apple II's reputation. Which... as far as Jobs was likely concerned was all that mattered, but it wasn't the rip-off he claimed, it was just the start of the trend and Holt was at the right time to be one of the first on that wave.
- somedudethere 11y agoYeah. When Apple claims to have invented something, they don't mean that they invented the very first instance of it, they mean that they invented a practical and transformative consumer implementation, which depending on who you are can be viewed as just as important (because what use is a technology if it can't be used on a practical level?)
- ksk 11y ago"popularized" and "invented" are two words which would be useful in this situation. Hopefully, we can all agree on the distinct meaning of those words. >because what use is a technology if it can't be used on a practical level? I know you meant it in a general sense, but the act of demonstrating something can also be useful. It could be that its not very profitable to manufacture or that it could serve as an inspiration for others to improve upon the idea itself.
- joshmn 11y agoNow do the cord, and find out why they always turn to shit.
- msoad 11y agoI'm so sad to see MagSafe was replaced with USB-C in the new MacBook. Hopefully they don't deprecate MagSafe for larger laptops. I won't mind USB-C + MagSafe charging capability though! ;)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Brakenshire 11y agoI'd gladly exchange Magsafe for generic interchangeable chargers. One charger for a laptop, tablet, smartphone and e-reader, and provided as a matter of course in cafes, libraries, trains, workplaces etc would be superb.
- eropple 11y agoI under no circumstances want my probably-not-very-secure peripheral bus accessed by things provided by a matter of course in cafes, libraries, etc. Magsafe is stupid and that is fine by me. This is also why I carry my own USB adapters rather than relying on others', and have a USB condom (they call them SyncStop now, I think, but that one is big and weird) in my wallet just in case.
- kens 11y agoMagsafe actually isn't stupid - there's bidirectional communication with the laptop over the data pin in the middle of the connector, using the 1-Wire protocol. The protocol is probably simple enough to have no security issues, but now I wonder if a malicious connector could carry out an attack (buffer overflow, bad data, etc). Some security engineer might want to investigate this...
- eropple 11y agoStupid has degrees. I'm a lot more confident in the ability to secure Magsafe than something that has to support such functionally open things as Alternate Mode.
- _sword 11y agoHas anyone else ever had the cord of their magsafe charger start sparking or catch on fire (as it burns through the insulation and rubber) right behind the adapter? I've had it happen with I believe three chargers across two different computers.
- justinsaccount 11y agoFrom the article: Problems with Apple's chargers The ironic thing about the Apple Macbook charger is that despite its complexity and attention to detail, it's not a reliable charger. When I told people I was doing a charger teardown, I rapidly collected a pile of broken chargers from people who had failed chargers. The charger cable is rather flimsy, leading to a class action lawsuit stating that the power adapter dangerously frays, sparks and prematurely fails to work. Apple provides detailed instructions on how to avoid damaging the wire, but a stronger cable would be a better solution. The result is reviews on the Apple website give the charger a dismal 1.5 out of 5 stars.
- chain18 11y agoYup had one catch one fire, was just thankful that I was around to see it happen and stop it from burning the house down. The charger was around 4 years old but I never wrap the cable so it seems like a major design flaw.
- throwaway420 11y agoDespite the visual appeal of their products, Apple normally does a very good job with prioritizing function over form except in this case with the charger wire being so fragile and thin. I know I'm not the most careful and delicate person in the world, but the failure rate here is ridiculous compared to other similar products I own. The end of the cable gets frayed every single time. Otherwise, Apple makes ridiculously durable products that I use for years on end. It's just weird that their charger's wire almost seems purposefully designed to break in this manner. This isn't just a minor annoyance and monetary concern where I'm just annoyed at having to buy a new charger every year or so - there's a real safety issue here with this wire being so fragile - it could be both a shock and fire hazard. Shame on Apple for ignoring this very real problem with their product.
- DarkTree 11y agoHonestly, I've never had the frayed problem with my macbook chargers, even with 2 years of use. However, I have had to buy 2 chargers since my original one because they will stop working after a couple of years. That's quite frustrating.
- robin_reala 11y agoI’ve never even had that. Sold a heavily used 2008 MacBook with its original charger last month with no signs of fraying or problems. I’m yet to have a charger die on me in any way.
- trymas 11y agoI've seen that from some models made in ~'08-'09, the cables do not fray. I have 2013 rmbp 13" I have handled my charger with great care avoiding as much twisting ant touching as possible, and after around 20 months, cable isolation just tore up by touching it.. It seems that cable isolation is made of such plastic, that it completely degrades after some time..
- masklinn 11y ago
- mpg33 11y agoI actually find Apple's charging cables to be pretty flimsy and not very durable.
- riffraff 11y agohaving had 5 chargers' cables of 3 kinds break on me in less than 10 years, I agree wholeheartedly. But I think TFA is about the charger internals, rather than the cables per se.
- silveira 11y agoAll this and the thin wire is what is going to break. I was around my 4th charger when I lost count.
- nevereverreg 11y agoI have had 4 or 5 power supplies. Never had to replace any of them. Ended up giving the Macs and original adapters away, as I upgraded to new systems.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 11y ago> I think with the smallest amount of care and consideration the apple chargers last a long time I treated my Apple chargers carefully. They destroyed themselves after about 2 years. Laptops get transported a lot. Their chargers should not be so delicate.
- bdcravens 11y agoIndeed. I throw my rMBP in a bag all the time. It's odd that Beats headphone cables are actually thicker and presumably more durable than the connecting cable on my $3300 laptop's power supply.
- jloughry 11y agoAn interesting feature of switched-mode power supplies like this is that they'll run on DC input, if that's all you have! DC passes right through the bridge rectifier into the chopper---not sure how happy the PFC circuit would be about that---and the rest of the circuitry works as usual. If the DC supply voltage is high enough, it'll work.
- yourapostasy 11y agoPlease forgive the ignorant questions of a software guy that probably have blindingly obvious answers to a EE. Does this mean that theoretically, I could attach a 18V/18.5V [0] DC power source (like a solar panel array running into a DC-DC converter) to the prongs and as long as I can supply about 100W/8.5A my MacBook Pro will boot? [0] http://apple.stackexchange.com/questions/111250/how-to-charge-the-macbook-pro-from-12-volts http://apple.stackexchange.com/questions/111250/how-to-charg...
- kens 11y agoChargers require a minimum voltage to work. They typically say 85V and might work with lower, but I expect 18V is way too low. I'd also be very nervous about feeding DC into a PFC circuit (which is designed to track the AC waveform) - does anyone know for sure what PFC does if you feed it the wrong frequency? (Someone else asked about 400Hz aircraft power too.)
- TD-Linux 11y agoIt probably won't blow anything up, but the active PFC might not be very happy as it tries to track the AC waveform to control the current draw. It might just not work. You'd be better off getting one of the cheaper clone adapters with passive or no PFC if you want to make a dedicated DC power supply.
- craigjb 11y agoNot an ignorant question at all! This is actually a subtle problem in switching regulator design: high duty-cycle operation and efficiency. Basically, if you input a voltage very close to the output voltage, the switch part of a switching regulator must be always or near always closed. And, any inefficiencies such as voltage drops in the power path are visible in the output. Being Apple, I'm sure it has 100% duty cycle operation. However, it's likely not optimized for hat (uncommon case). [edit] as the other comment points out, my comments forgot about the PFC circuit. But on switchers without this, near output voltage input is possible.
- blhack 11y ago>It enables the output when the charger is connected to a Macbook, disables the output when the charger is disconnected I don't think this is actually true... I found out by doing something really stupid. The pins on my charger get really dirty, which makes the charger connector get REALLY hot (like burn your finger hot). One day, I was cleaning the pins off with a wire brush, but I [stupidly] forgot to actually UNPLUG THE CHARGER. I knew this because when I applied the brush, (the end of it looks a lot like steel wool), it started sparking against the brush.
- bdcravens 11y agoI haven't had wear and tear issues, but I rarely use it (have Thunderbolt monitors home and office, with built-in power) and I keep it in a Quirky PowerCurl when I do use it (usually only when traveling)
- mosdave 11y ago> There's a lot more circuitry crammed into the compact power adapter than you'd expect, including a microprocessor. microcontroller.
- Sakiina_ 11y agoAnyone here heard of the Magsafe saver? https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/lightning-magsafe-saver-protects-your-cables#/ https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/lightning-magsafe-saver-p... This is what I got-- took an eternity to get to me, but it works well enough. I wrap my cables. I had my Macbook Pro for two years, abused it, charger was fine. I sold it with the Macbook when I moved back Stateside after living abroad. My next charger broke, because my kitten decided it made a great teething chew. Cha-ching. $80. I noticed a bit of wear, so I got the dinky plastic protectors. They seem to be working well. I use it on my lightning cable, too.
- Gracana 11y agoHow does that not just move the point of strain further down the cable? It looks like a rigid extension of the strain relief boot.
- Sakiina_ 11y agoIt is fairly rigid, but there's some flex. It just seems to make it so there's not such a sharp "curve", if you will, if you wrap the cable, at the end, where it seems to fray the most, and where I noticed the most wear.
- tylerpachal 11y agoMy solution is to pop the spring out of a pen, and wrap the spring around the end of the cable. It achieves the same thing: adds support while still being flexible.
- ericd 11y agoAs another option, white sugru works very well, and lets you taper down the amount to spread the stress over a larger area.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mschuster91 11y agoWhat I wonder: EVERYTHING is available as China knockoffs, but I have yet to see a fake, replacement MagSafe connector...
- privacy101 11y agothe Chinese don't want to loose that business I guess
- Kluny 11y agoI have. I bought a replacement magsafe from one of those little outfits that buys "old macbooks in any condition! ca$$h today!" and refurbishes them. I paid almost full price for it thinking it was OEM, but when I got home and matched it up to my extension cable, it was obviously a cheap knockoff. Worked well enough even though it was unsightly and difficult to use (the extension cable was really hard to slide on and off), but at $85 compared to OEM at $90, why bother?
- pfooti 11y agoFraying on the charger (dc-carrying) cable is definitely an issue, but my biggest gripe about these chargers is the form factor of the AC-carrying part of the power cord. I can't speak to non-US chargers, but the three-prong cord that plugs into the wall has no coiling shape. If the plug itself had a self-clip (like at the end of the charging cable), at least I could keep my cord from unrolling in my bag and expanding to fill the entire free space. I'm usually torn when I'm leaving the house with my macbook: do I bring the long cable and deal with bag disorganization, or do I hope I'm close enough to a plug and the plug orientation doesn't make me regret my lack of regular power cord? You'd think with all this industrial design effort spent (pretty successfully IMO for the most part), there'd be an improvement in that particular cable.
- tburch 11y agoI'll just leave this here... https://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/image/upload/s--HwBqLe3c--/c_fill,fl_progressive,g_north,h_358,q_80,w_636/1992se3paqpt8jpg.jpg https://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/image/upload/s--HwBqLe3...
- bartvk 11y agoLooks like the DC part of the adapter is very tightly wound. It's not even visible coming out of the adapter itself. This looks like a good way to fray the cable.
- tomcam 11y agoYou know what's not surprisingly complex? My feeling about how screwed I felt when I got the Macbook and its charger consisted only of straight-to-plug wall wart, power cord to Mac, as opposed to cord-to-wall-wart, wall wart, power cord to Mac. They halved the length of the cord while forcing you to stick your wall wart right into the socket, crowding out other cords if it's on a small power strip. That and the fact that it's not MagSafe anymore.
- toyg 11y agoIs this the new model? I got the 2012 version (UK) and got the modular charger with cord-to-wall-wart plus wall-wart-only...
- tomcam 11y agoYes. It's the MacBook Air-like fanless one [1] with only 2 ports: headphone and USB-C. And half a power cable. And no MagSafe. Did I mention I'm a little bitter? [1] http://www.apple.com/macbook/ http://www.apple.com/macbook/
- madeofpalk 11y agoWell you got half a laptop, so you got half a charger! But in all seriousness, if you consider the charging experience is very similar to an iPad (complete with the sound it makes when you plug it in), you start to see how they justified it.
- harperlee 11y agoNot to mention (this is going offtopic): no usb-c to mini display port for Target Display Mode with an iMac, although it is technically feasible and a matter of having a passive cable. They just wont create the usb-c versions of most of the peripherals during an unspecified amount of time. Because Apple.
- pheroden 11y agoAll of this is literally on the tech specs page. http://www.apple.com/macbook/specs http://www.apple.com/macbook/specs You can be disappointed, but if you're bitter, it's your own fault for not properly researching. Don't blame Apple, no bait and switch here.
- swiley 11y agoYou can tell they're non trivial if you do any kind of HF radio stuff. When you plug one in the higher end of the spectrum fills with one kind of wideband digital looking noise for about a second, and then another noise there after.
- kens 11y agoThat's interesting. What frequency range are you looking at, and how do you examine it? The charger waits one second after being plugged into the laptop before enabling the output voltage, so that would explain some of the behavior you see.
- grandalf 11y agoWhile it's clear that Apple attempts to limit the production of junk peripherals by patenting its connectors, it would be great if licenses were made readily available to companies wishing to make high quality stuff. Even just putting a magsafe connector on the brick itself would allow the cable to be easily replaced if it frayed. Does anyone know if Apple laptops contain enough protective circuitry to be used safely with inferior power adapters? It appears that some of that sophistication is actually just moving parts out of the laptop and into the adapter.
- joeyspn 11y ago> The ironic thing about the Apple Macbook charger is that despite its complexity and attention to detail, it's not a reliable charger. Maybe that's what they want... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planned_obsolescence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planned_obsolescence
- rdtsc 11y ago> The charger uses an advanced design called a resonant controller, which lets the system operate at a very high frequency, up to 500 kilohertz. Wonder what would happen if the 500 kHz signal would be fed to an antenna? Would that emit a signal, would it not work at all or become dangerous and probably highly illegal? Here is an example what an antenna for 500 kHz looks like: http://g0mrf.com/500kAntenna.htm http://g0mrf.com/500kAntenna.htm
- zik 11y agoSwitch mode power supplies are notorious emitters of radio frequency interference. There are regulations they have to pass and passing them is often one of the hardest parts of power supply design.
- kens 11y agoThat's one of the reasons the charger has a bunch of inductors and capacitors on the AC line, to keep interference from exiting the charger through the AC line. The metal shielding around the charger also helps.
- specialp 11y agoAll Apple needs to do to stop their cables from fraying at very high rates is to use a continuous flex cable like these: http://www.igus.com/wpck/15029/productoverview_CF?C=US&L=en http://www.igus.com/wpck/15029/productoverview_CF?C=US&L=en I used to work on amusement rides, and we had a problem with cables on bumper cars breaking very often due to movement. After replacing them with these they never failed again.
- seesomesense 11y ago"most of the circuitry is covered by the metal heat sink, held in place by yellow insulating tape." This sounds a bit dodgy to me. Could someone with domain expertise comment on whether this is normal ?
- sdk77 11y agoIt's normal. Actually the part mentioned that wraps around the power supply is not only a heatsink but also a shield for reducing radiated noise. PSU like this are very noisy and without (a.o.) this shield it may not be possible to get it approbated. The shield has transparent plastic foil beneath it to act as an insulator (barely visible on the first photo, but on the picture with the shield removed it's clearly visible). The usage of yellow tape is perfectly normal.
- zik 11y agoOne thing which bugs me about this article is he conflates "complex" with "good". As an electronic designer I spend a huge amount of effort trying to make things as simple as possible. Complexity may be required to meet certain requirements but in general keeping it simple makes things more reliable and more cost effective.
- tajen 11y agoYes I wondered whether this complexity is a factor of enterprise design: Each engineer is responsible for a subsystem, ending up with x^n pieces, whereas the counterfeit one took 1 or 2 engineers.
- dfox 11y agoThere are two sources of complexity in the charger: PFC and efficient resonant converter, which is to be expected of high-quality charger. The whole magsafe handshaking mechanism, which looks like an afterthought to solve reliability problems caused by arcing on the pins, that also got used to block counterfeiters.
- chmaynard 11y agoHere’s my approach to the MacBook flimsy cable problem: 1. Sometime during warranty period, purchase AppleCare extended warranty. 2. Don’t worry about cable strain, just treat cable as if it were well made. 3. When cable frays, return power adapter to Apple Store for a free replacement. 4. Rinse and repeat. AppleCare also comes in handy when the $800 display fails.
- johansch 11y agoYou really tricked them! Had them replace their faulty product!!
- tomcam 11y agoThe embedded TI MSP430 microcontroller can easily be had for $.15 in quantity 1 compares to the original Mac's 68K, but using 1% of the power of the 68K. From the article: The 68000 microprocessor from the original Apple Macintosh and the 430 microcontroller in the charger aren't directly comparable as they have very different designs and instruction sets. But for a rough comparison, the 68000 is a 16/32 bit processor running at 7.8MHz, while the MSP430 is a 16 bit processor running at 16MHz. The Dhrystone benchmark measures 1.4 MIPS (million instructions per second) for the 68000 and much higher performance of 4.6 MIPS for the MSP430. The MSP430 is designed for low power consumption, using about 1% of the power of the 68000.
- outworlder 11y agoThe Thunderbolt display is handy to avoid carrying chargers around - except if you own a Macbook Air (and even more so on the 13" model). You see, a Macbook Air charges on one side, but the Thunderbolt port is on the other side. It creates a lot of strain. No such issue with Macbook Pros.
- ageofwant 11y agoNo mention of Dave's eevblog ? Its both entertaining and informative: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wi-b9k-0KfE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wi-b9k-0KfE
- pi-rat 11y agoI wish Apple used magsafe connectors for both ends on their charger cables. Sucks to throw away a perfectly good charger, just because a tiny length of cable (usually near the brick) is frayed.
- jupp0r 11y agoMine fail on me every 9 months. I think there is just no way you can avoid that if you just roll/unroll the cable several times per day. Their AppleCare program takes care of for "free", but the downtime is really annoying, that's why I keep one of those fake adapters around to bridge those gaps.
- hk__2 11y agoI roll/unroll the cable several times per day and my charger is completely fine. I got it with my Air mid '13 two years ago and use every day. It has probably a lot more to do with the way you roll it (and/or the one Apple thinks you should) rather than an inherent cable weakness.
- mindo 11y agoNeed to change MBP charger every 6-12 months because of the crappy cable. It's super fustrating.
- praveenweb 11y agoI guess there is a similar problem with the lightning connector for iPhones. I had to change my iPhone cable multiple times in the past 4 years. Be it the 30 pin connector or the new lightning connector, its so fragile. Always been an ardent fan of Apple and its products, but disappointed with this strategy of making money through intentionally designed fragile cables that won't last more than a year leading to accessory sales.
- capitan417 11y agoThere's no way that the cost of these individual components can be used to justify the price tag. That's pure delusion.
- doYouEvenHalt 11y agoHmm. Any citations to back this up?
- kens 11y agoAt the end of the article, I price out most of the charger components . I also estimate reasonable R&D costs. Based on these numbers, it's the profit margin that makes the charger expensive. See also this detailed analysis of Apple's profit margin: http://www.digitaltrends.com/mobile/iphone-cost-what-apple-is-paying/ http://www.digitaltrends.com/mobile/iphone-cost-what-apple-i...
- nvcken 11y agoTechnically , have anyone can give me advice that we should keep charger plug-in when using macbook or plug-out when full-charge?
- frankiechh 11y agoKeeping the battery always topped off isn't healthy for it. I keep my charger in during the day then take it off when I leave.
- nvcken 11y agoSo you mean we do not worry decayed battery or cell memory effect when plug-in charger during the day working although battery still 100%. Is it right ? Why is it possible ?
- ctz 11y ago> the imitation leaves out the ground connection Genuine Apple adaptors come with plugs with plastic earth pins. You can feel the tingle from leakage current with such plugs.
- swingbridge 11y agoThe detail of engineering inside of Apple's products is impressive. A lot of attention paid to things that one almost never sees. Like others though the cable ends on computer and iPhoje chargers do always get frayed. I wish they could make that bit better.
- frankiechh 11y agoQueue the Hacker News Noobs complaining that the charger isn't "open" enough. Zzzz...
- mcv 11y agoVery interesting. So why do these expensive things keep breaking all the time, and how can I fix them? I'm on my third charger for my Macbook.
- sethkontny 11y agotear down and data transmission reverse https://www.instagram.com/sethkontny/ https://www.instagram.com/sethkontny/