13 ms·
Kill the laws that keep car dealers in business
- devit 11y agoMaybe the dealerships and in general physical shops should evolve into paid-for showrooms? That is, you pay, say, $50, and you get to try a bunch of cars or in general products that they have on loan from various manufacturers and get some guidance from the staff if needed. Then once you figure out what you want, you buy it online and get it shipped to you. Then there is no need to "protect" those shops, since the customer is paying precisely for the only value they add, which is the ability to try out things and ask for advice, and in fact the value of the advice would increase since there would be no conflict of interest.
- BinaryIdiot 11y agoIf you're selling me something very big and expensive I better get a chance to look at it up close and try it out. If you're going to charge me for that experience then I will go somewhere else. What should happen is the car manufacturers buy out the best dealerships and simply sell the cars direct. It'll allow them to optimize their distribution and inventory channels and give them a bigger margin overall. It's going to put many dealerships out of business but it's an old business model that no longer works in the world; you can't expect to keep it afloat when there is no good business reason for doing so.
- qq66 11y agoThe car manufacturers actually lobbied for laws that prevent them from cutting out dealerships, to remove barriers to entrepreneurs investing in building brand-exclusive dealerships. The dealerships wouldn't have been built without these laws protecting them, that's why the manufacturers lobbied for them. The legal system in place was a precondition for the development existing American car dealership network, and I doubt that the dealerships are going to go down without a breach of contract fight.
- dexterdog 11y agoSounds like the same kind of nonsense that came with taxis.
- 1stop 11y agoExcept that the largest margin for dealerships and car manufacturers is the Aftersales parts/accessories. There is a good reason they exist, it's just that companies like Tesla are offering a different business model of packaged accessories (some other car manufacturers do similar but usually on top of individual accessories not instead of).
- BinaryIdiot 11y ago> Except that the largest margin for dealerships and car manufacturers is the Aftersales parts/accessories Isn't that always the case? Regardless, cutting out the dealership gives the car companies more margin for this stuff and possibly lower prices for consumers (possibly though probably doubtful).
- 1stop 11y agoNo, because the manufacturers don't make all the accessories (think window tinting, etc). And the dealerships, which typically become multi-brand dealership groups can get economies of scale the manufacture typically can't.
- bluecalm 11y agoI would prefer paying for trying. It's added to the price anyway, it would be more customer friendly to have the fees exposed and not bundled with the purchase itself.
- coldtea 11y agoA lot of things people say they would pay for, when speaking to the press or market research etc, in practice they never do -- and obviously not in large numbers. I've read several stories of founders for example hearing people say "I'd buy that" etc, but in practice they found out nobody would bother with their product/service, it solved a non-painful enough problem, etc. Paying for checking out cars to buy seems like one of these things.
- jonlucc 11y agoI see an even bigger problem. Most people hate car salespeople. I hate car shopping and mattresses are even worse because the salespeople's incentives are very unclear and they clearly dick around with people. That perception isn't going to change overnight (and the salespeople's tactics would be tough to change quickly), so I won't pay for it any time soon.
- gshubert17 11y agoThe last new car I bought was a Saturn in 1992, mainly because their business model involved no haggling on prices and salespeople were there to help customers find the best match for them. I don't understand why this model didn't spread further.
- ghaff 11y agoThe are no haggle dealerships generally and Scion, I believe, is a no haggle brand. There may be others. (Of course that doesn't necessarily mean that trade-ins and financing deals are no haggle.) As for why it hasn't spread further, I imagine it's partly because a lot of people go into a car dealership expecting to apply their (they think) leet negotiating skills and will walk if told that the price is the price. From the dealer perspective, bargaining is also an opportunity to price discriminate. Given that dealers don't in general make a lot on new car sales, the best answer is probably that it's the system everyone is used to.
- blumkvist 11y agoI'm very curious as to how much time did you spend thinking about this solution before proposing it to fix the extremely complex problem of distributing durables.
- suneilp 11y ago"the price of the cars that are sold needs to be high enough to cover the costs of building and storing the unsold ones." We shouldn't be having this problem anymore. It's a massive detriment to the economies of scale model. Most people don't need to buy a car overnight, which ironically is because they are so expensive. Keeping a small amount of cars for test driving and personal inspection is all that is needed. Then all that needs to be done is to batch up requests for production and shipping. Charge more 2 day shipping. Maybe Amazon can get into selling cars and same day deliveries for free with Amazon Prime.
- jpfr 11y agoIn Europe, only used cars are sold directly off the parking lot or showroom of the dealer. Normally, you choose the options (color, engine options, leather seats, ..) and the car is built for you. You can pick it up some weeks/months later. Manufacturers of high-priced cars may invite you to pick up the car at the plant when it comes off the line. They have a special "experience" designed around that.
- chrisan 11y ago> They have a special "experience" designed around that. This can happen in the US too: http://www.chevrolet.com/bowling-green-assembly-plant.html http://www.chevrolet.com/bowling-green-assembly-plant.html
- larrydag 11y agoBeen there to the Corvette plant. It's a wonderful tour. There is even a section of the plant where the owner of the car can help build the engine. They put a special plate on the engine with the name of the owner too.
- nomercy400 11y agoTo be honest, should it really take months to produce and ship that one car through europe? Surely assembly lines are faster than that.
- bgribble 11y agoYep, buying a car sucks. But this is one of the largest supply-chain operations in the world. The dealer franchise system and its legal framework have evolved over 100 years and are balanced pretty delicately. It can't just be refactored by waving a regulatory wand at it and hoping for the best. Cars will still have to be warehoused, delivered, serviced, and resold. Somebody has to buy your old junky trade-in. Somebody has to run the showroom, if you want to actually like see the car before you buy it. So we're going to do a regulatory taking of the franchise, worth millions of dollars per dealership, and then have the manufacturer open a showroom and warehousing lot and service center in every town and city that has a dealership? Or just open a direct sales channel to compete with dealers, but make the existing dealers perform service and deliver inventory? And take your trade-in? Manufacturers hate dealers. It's mutual. The only reason consumers don't hate the manufacturers so much is that they have never had to deal with them directly. Dealer protection laws are there because manufacturers have a long history of trying to steal from dealers, cheat them, and put them out of business at whim. Those are the manufacturers that consumers are asking to deal with directly. I'm sure they'll treat consumers better than they treat their business partners!
- rlpb 11y ago> Dealer protection laws are there because manufacturers have a long history of trying to steal from dealers, cheat them, and put them out of business at whim. That doesn't justify them. I thought the US is supposed to be anti-regulatory? Why didn't dealers handle this by becoming primarily multiple-manufacturer and thus able to switch to or favor a different manufacturer at whim?
- bgribble 11y agoThat was the normal case in most of the US until pretty recently. Now manufacturers don't want competing brands in the same building. They want a uniform branded buying experience. So they make it very hard to transfer franchises if the new franchisee sells other makes at the same location. The manufacturer has refusal on the sale of the franchise, which is most of the dealership's value.
- 11y ago
- kristianrjs 11y agoI love this article. I've only spent a year working in the automotive industry between detail/lot attending, not even any sales. I've noticed some real big problems with the way dealers do business. It needs a serious overhaul. I've been working very part time on some of my ideas to reshape the industry. It definitely needs some shaking up.
- adventured 11y agoA long time ago I saw an ad on the back of a magazine, paying tribute to Dell's direct model. It was a Johnnie Walker ad, with a bar napkin. On the napkin was written Dell's business plan; it had "make computer, sell computer" basically crossed out, replaced with "sell computer, make computer." Make the car -> sell the car Sell the car -> make the car This switch should have happened a long time ago. The near total elimination of the vast inventory system. It would make most automakers dramatically more profitable. Dealerships should be replaced by small automaker-owned sales venues, stocked with one of each model for test driving purposes. Customers order their car, with some limited customizations. They come back in a week and pick up their car, and save 20% off current prices. The automaker never builds a car that hasn't already been sold.
- btgeekboy 11y agoThat elimination of the inventory system works great for cars produced locally. What of those produced overseas, or even on the opposite side of the US? Consumers can handle waiting a week for a car they ordered, but you can't just throw a car into the UPS cargo hold and deliver it to the buyer's doorstep a day or two later.
- adventured 11y agoJust as an example, if you're Toyota, and you know how well your top five models sell in the US, you'd either build two factories strategically located near the west and east coasts, or you'd build one giant plant in eg Texas and ship the cars west or east, splitting the time it would take to ship it across the entire country side to side. Most of Toyota's profit comes from just a few best selling models (that tend to be their best selling models year after year). That's where you'd start on this type of automation, and you'd invent new manufacturing technology accordingly as necessary. The criticism I see most often on the concept, is that it'd be challenging because our manufacturing processes are pathetically ancient. I agree: it's time to move manufacturing into the future. It's not a question of if it can be done, it's: who is going to do it first.
- Nelson69 11y agoYou gotta love the eagerness the HN world has to label these old companies as idiots.. Never mind that 'kanban' came from the auto-industry. I say that tongue in cheek, there probably are some changes that could make the industry a lot better, we need dreamers to try. The actual integration part isn't the problem, I don't believe. The dealers themselves could probably do that with a little help and some changes if you could deliver them a crate of all the parts. When you buy a Honda accord, there are at least 3 different power train options, a 4-cylinder manual (do they still make this?,) a 4-cylinder CVT, and a 6-cylinder automatic; and Honda has been amazing at actually reducing the number of options over the years. Do you build the power train on demand or do you attempt to forecast sales and stock an inventory? That's a very significant part of the overall cost. Many of those parts are forged and then machined both, just building the head takes some time and precision, let alone assembling it... there are interior changes that have to integrated as well, from the dash display to things like paddles for shifting in some formats. With a lot of modern cars, I wouldn't be surprised if the rolling chassis for the different models is very nearly the same but subtly different depending upon the power train. Toyota has the highlander, it's a very popular platform, it also comes in a hybrid configuration, I suspect that are more than just some subtle changes to a lot more parts for that. Same with like an all-wheel drive as an option type products... or convertible roof. I think the navi-option on some mass market cars results in a different dashboard molding. If you limit "options" to color and seat materials, this is an easy problem. The auto industry practically invented options though, like Ford and Lincoln and Mercury were the same vehicles for a long time, the fake options helped sell way more product. Today when you buy a Camry, it's almost like there are four or five entirely different products that are all labeled "Camry" from like an entry level spartan 4-cylinder edition up to the hybrid limited that costs nearly twice as much. The market seems to like that. That's the trick, if you could some how convince the buyer that they had real options but they didn't... Maybe electric motors are a big part of that, take performance off the table as an option and things can be made more simple.
- jasonkester 11y agoThis seems like an opportunity for an Uber/AirBnB move. Find a jurisdiction anywhere in the USA where direct manufacturer sales are legal. Negotiate with the manufacturers to handle direct-to-consumer sales for them. Write your "app" so that customers can build their car online and have the order go straight to the factory. Charge the customer a "delivery fee" to get their heavily discounted car to them, from which you make your profits. Seems like a lot of work, and a lot of fighting with a lot of bureaucracy, but that's what all these "disrupt the industry" startups like to spend their billions doing. I'm surprised that nobody is doing it today.
- jpatokal 11y ago> Negotiate with the manufacturers to handle direct-to-consumer sales for them. As in, found a startup and then negotiate with Ford, GM, Toyota, Volkswagen etc about a deal that's guaranteed to piss off the existing dealer networks that make ~100% of their revenue and will view this as an existential threat? Good luck with that! Above all, this seems to assume car companies are stupid. Ford, GM & co would sell their grandmothers to get an extra 6% margin on their cars, the reason they're not selling directly already (in the US) because they figure it's not worth the risk -- and if they do decide to try, they're certainly not going to give the opportunity to a random startup trying to form a new monopsony that would leave them even worse off than before.
- jasonkester 11y agoThus the billions of dollars of VC and fighting mentioned above. In the context of what you've written, though, can you explain why Tesla chooses to sell directly to consumers? They have the ability to sell through dealers, just like the established automakers. And it would cost them a lot less money and hassle to do so. Why then would they choose to sell direct if not that it actually made good business sense to do so.
- jeromeflipo 11y ago> They have the ability to sell through dealers, just like the established automakers. And it would cost them a lot less money and hassle to do so. Not in a world dominated by fossil fuels. This is worth a read: http://www.teslamotors.com/blog/tesla-approach-distributing-and-servicing-cars http://www.teslamotors.com/blog/tesla-approach-distributing-....
- Shivetya 11y agoHow do you plan to buy out all the existing investment these dealerships have? You certainly cannot legislate away their property without compensation. What about the jobs? That is no small number. With those go all the local taxes, benefits, and such as well. Dealer direct, sounds good. Until you find out that car you really want has a demonstration center that is too far away, in a place you don't want to go. Until you find out repairs are done at an authorized shop that handles so many brands they cannot get it right. Until you have serious problems with your car and that manufacturer is so far away they can ignore you for a good amount of time... and so on. While not everyone has a good experience at a dealer I have never had a bad one and considering the number of vehicles I have gone through, well. Dealers aren't there just to sell cars. They they maintain them, they work to keep you happy so you come back. This means they act as go between consumer and manufacturer and can often push the manufacturer to fix things they might just overlook. Tesla is fine as it is now simply because they don't sell enough cars to matter, let alone to the majority of people their cars are not affordable and the customers who do buy have the time to go anywhere they need to to buy a car or even have someone go get it. When, and it is a very big when, Tesla has any real volume let us watch how they handle problems
- thawkins 11y agoJust remove the protectionist support they have and then let the market have its way.
- nomercy400 11y agoShouldn't you have a free market economy? Where a customer is able to choose between a dealer or a direct sale company? The customer is the one that should be able to choose between a cheaper price with a lower service, or a higher price with more service. The problem here is that companies want to provide the cheap alternative but aren't allowed to do so. If a dealer cannot compete with a direct sale company on price and service, doesn't that make their business model flawed/outdated.
- notjoedimaggio 11y agoI agree in theory, but the reality is that these companies made large investments under one set of legislation. If a society flips and completely changes the economic/legislative landscape under which companies operate, it creates a very unstable business environment and discourages capex especially. This would not be good for the long term economic health.
- venning 11y agoI paused my software development career to sell cars for a year. I sold cars at two different Honda dealerships, both owned by Fortune 500 companies in, what I believe is, the densest single market for Hondas in the US (Metro DC). There's a couple things missing from the situation as described by the author. First, dealerships don't really make that much of a profit on new car sales. At least not Honda dealers. Used cars averaged around $1000 profit, but new cars were around $200. Yes, they really do lose money on some sales. That's not to say that there weren't expenses that were being covered in the price that are exclusive to the dealership, such as the salesperson's commission, but the total profit going to the dealership per new car was low. One of the older, wiser managers, who had come from Toyota told me, "A properly-run dealership pays for everything on Parts & Service. Car sales is just the profit." There are a lot of lean years in car sales. I can attest that no one in management was panicking when gas prices hit $4/gallon and we couldn't give a car away (car managers don't hold back their emotions). Sales stopped, but people kept getting expensive oil changes. Second, at least within Honda's North American division, you cannot just buy inventory. A dealership inventory is controlled in such a way that area dealerships are forced to compete heavily with each other. In order to sell a car, you have to have a car on your lot. In order to have a car on your lot, you have to order it from Honda. The number of cars you can order from Honda is restricted to a percentage of the number of cars you sold last year, something around 106-110%. You can't just take a big loan and buy yourself volume. To a dealer, inventory is life and must be protected. As a salesperson, I would lose so many deals to other Honda dealers who would lie through their teeth over the phone to sell. Dealers will cut their own throats to steal a sale from another dealer because each one is a net +2 in the inventory war. In theory, this is great for customers on cost, but terrible for customers on experience. The owner of the first dealer I worked for had just sold the dealership to a Fortune 500 company. He spent years and years basically giving cars away until he had the largest inventory on the entire East Coast (a big deal for Honda) and then had something very valuable, something that couldn't be bought. Somewhat like how Amazon, in theory, operates.
- A_Beer_Clinked 11y agoI've done a lot of data work for several other brands in a few markets and can confirm the used car part of this is true. A properly run organisation can sell and re-sell the same car several times, also selling parts and services to each owner in between sales. Rental and other fleets are particularly battled after for this reason as they can "inject" far more life time value in the the network than just the initial sale.
- alaskamiller 11y agoThis is why Apple will take over the car industry. Integrate the best supply chain management, best logistics, best customization processes, best personalization processes, best servicing processes, best retail sales force, best legal compliance/adherence processes. Then look at how to make a giant iPod on wheels then deploy.
- tim333 11y agoThat's an interesting point. I was wondering how Apple could get anywhere with no car experience but I guess if they had fairly generic cars manufactured by some outsourced company but with a better electronics/software and a better sales and service experience that could work.
- mikeyouse 11y agoIt's interesting that everyone assumes Apple's supply chain is superior to all of the auto companies. When looking at a Cost of Goods Sold basis, all of the big auto companies spend far more money on their products than Apple does (GM's COGS is several tens of billions higher than Apple's) -- and their margins are much smaller, so managing their suppliers and logistics matters much more to the auto companies' bottom line. A single car has ~30,000 parts.. an iPhone has, what, a few hundred? Why is it a given that Apple is going to be successful at doing something that they've shown no skill in actually doing?
- alaskamiller 11y agoYou assume that a car will always have 30k parts and that Apple doesn't know how to manage more 1k parts. Remove the combustion engine and its related systems, don't get beholden to legacy, and how many parts will a battery operated car really have? To an ambitious team backed with plenty of money and expertise this is their dream come true.
- OliverJones 11y agoSteve Rattner's book about the auto industry bankruptcies and restructuring in 2009 (http://www.worldcat.org/title/overhaul-an-insiders-account-of-the-obama-administrations-emergency-rescue-of-the-auto-industry/oclc/515468255 http://www.worldcat.org/title/overhaul-an-insiders-account-o...) makes one thing clear: a major win for the US manufacturers from their bankruptcies was getting out from under the onerous terms of some long-term contracts with dealers. Also, the last holdouts to getting the deal done were certain politically connected dealers.
- joosters 11y ago"Don’t ever take a fence down until you know the reason why it was put up" You can't write a balanced article on car dealerships without researching why these laws were enacted in the first place. So many people here just assume "oh, it's because of greed" - but perhaps you should spend a short time first of all investigating why these laws were created and the problems they were trying to solve. Likewise, you can't write a convincing article about removing these laws if you don't speak of the reasons why the laws were created. You need to show why these reasons are no longer good.
- lawstudent2 11y agoWe know why it was put up. This is not a mystery. It was lobbied for by car dealerships in order to procure monopoly status, under the guise of 'consumer protection.' This is kind of a bullshit response, honestly. This is a very, very well plumbed, documented and reported on issue. The corollary to your statement about fences is: "About which you do not know, be silent." Car dealership laws may have served a purpose, but their primary purpose these days is to enrich car dealership owners: http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2013/02/19/172402376/why-buying-a-car-never-changes http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2013/02/19/172402376/why-b... http://www.americanbar.org/publications/franchise_lawyer/2013/summer_2013/has_traditional_automobile_franchise_system_run_out_gas.html http://www.americanbar.org/publications/franchise_lawyer/201... Their passing will be a net gain for the consumer.
- GhotiFish 11y agoOh... so I'm one of those ignorant masses that should be silent, I hope that rule doesn't extend to asking to asking a few questions? If not, I hope you can forgive me for this: Why were they made before? Why does this not apply now? This whole thing seems to be lifted on it's own bootstraps, and I think the grandparent post and I want this paradox addressed.
- lawstudent2 11y agoAs posted in another thread: > These laws that were passed to prop up car dealerships and came about in an era without mass marketing, but, very importantly, and self-acknowledgledly, these laws existed to prevent the manufacturer from undercutting prices offered by dealers - under the theory that dealers were of critical importance to customers for servicing and selling cars. Which is a combination of circular and dumb. And even if it was once true, because people could not comparison shop without the internet, it is now no longer true, because people can comparison shop with the internet and can visit manufacturers directly for servicing. These laws are literally anti-competitive monopolies that, if they never existed, would not need to be invented now to protect consumers. Instead they operate as enforceable licenses, dividing the country up into fiefdoms, in which each little fiefdom the local car dealer is the ensconced baron, operating with a monopoly on all original cars sales from that manufacturer in that territory - and if another dealer tries to sell new cars from that manufacturer in that territory, they can be stopped by the state and sued out of existence. In other words, it was once thought that car dealerships offered critically important services to consumers - and even if that were once the case - and I deny that it was ever the case, it was just an excuse to pass these laws - it is no longer the case, because of carfax, bluebook, rigorously licensed repair shops, and car manufacturers that have figured out how to create and operate manufacturer owned dealerships. This is the vestige of a bygone - and I argue, wholly credulous - era. It is a straight-up tax on the consumer, and it benefits no one but the car dealerships to make it literally illegal for two people to be selling new cars from the same manufacturer within the same territory. That is what those laws do - let that sink in, because that is fucking ri-goddamn-diculous. Car dealerships, and their territories, literally become heritable assets like a barony. It's insane. And no, my sarcasm aside, the point about being silent in areas of ignorance was made out of frustration that because the person I was replying to was personally ignorant it meant that there was a bona fide debate in this area. There isn't. And it is pretty easy to do the research. I find all to common, however, it being a very fashionable and vogue statement for someone to make to prove how intellectual and cultured they are that, if they aren't familiar with an area of discussion, then surely there must be a legitimate debate to be had. Well, no. That is sometimes true, and very often not. This is one of those cases. You will find two sides in this debate: car dealers and the people paid by car dealers; literally everyone else.
- ywy9876 11y agoMOLT BE
- mtanski 11y agoI'll post the same thing I posted in the Bob Lutz on the Tesla thread with some amendments. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10457754 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10457754 According to Bob Lutz having car dealerships is a pro. LOL, I am yet to talk to anybody who actually enjoyed the car dealership experience weather it's buying or servicing the car. The whole car dealer enterprise is a rent seeking business. In many states you cannot have the manufacture sell the cars directly. That's changing slowly -- thanks to Tesla -- the dealer lobby is a big contributor in many local and state wide elections. The pricing for the automobile / features is not clear to begin with. It's to the point that there's many competing business that try to give you true car pricing. And, every step of the way the dealership tries to extract another fee / charge for you via various tactics like destination fees, myriad of financing fees, unneeded insurance (tire insurance, ones that overlap with the manufactures warranty). Personally, I would love if the dealership model died. The alternative being ordering a car online and having it show up at home at a scheduled time. I imagine the same experience can be replicated the other way when the car needs servicing, schedule it online and have it picked up / drop it off and a point of aggregation of the car maker where they handle volume. And before you tell me about the test drive and getting a feel for the car. Meh. Your fooling yourself if you think that a 15 minute test ride will tell you much about the cars performance, comfort or even layout. You will only learn that the seats are uncomfortable on a 3 hour trip once you take that 3 hour trip. If a test drive is really important to you, you should really rent the car for a couple days. One could also make the argument that dealerships should go away based on their general discriminatory tendencies. Here's a recentish paper quantifying it: http://islandia.law.yale.edu/ayres/Ayres%20Siegelman%20Race%20and%20Gender%20Discrimination%20In%20Bargaining%20%20for%20a%20New%20Car.pdf http://islandia.law.yale.edu/ayres/Ayres%20Siegelman%20Race%... . The quantify how much more dealerships by different gender / race. The recent book named Phishing for Phools dedicates some time to this topic as well.
- AstroJetson 11y agomtanski "you should really rent the car for a couple days." Exactly! This what we do when we are car shopping. Normal cycle is to start looking when the existing car hits the 8% mark in unscheduled maintenance (or 150K miles) (your percentage may vary). Once we close in on the model we like we find a rental and drive it for a week. If it passes we find a dealer, get the model and what we want on it and then shop that info around between multiple dealers in the area. We never use the existing car to trade in since most are 10 years old and have lots of mileage on them. When we pick up the new car we will offer it to the dealer as a trade and decide at that point if we want to sell it to them. Last cycle the dealer said he would give us another $200 off the deal if he didn't need to take the trade.
- Turbots 11y agoPreferred process: - go online, pick a car you like, check out the colors - go to a dealer - (make a test drive) - buy the car (down payment or whatever) - dealer orders car - dealer receives car and notifies buyer - buyer picks up car (finalize transaction or whatever) The only downside in this process is that you have to wait for the car to actually be produced and shipped to your dealer... I wouldn't have a problem with that
- donkeyd 11y agoIn the Netherlands, you go to the dealer and order a car. The car gets built to order, unless it's in inventory at a nearby dealer. The way it works in the US sounds needlessly complicated to me.
- PantaloonFlames 11y ago> needlessly complicated Doesn't seem complicated to me. The US system just warehouses inventory on dealer lots. Maybe because it's feasible due to geography. Allocating inventory based on prior year's sales is just a way to provide growth incentive to dealers. They don't make much money on new car sales but they do make money on the volume of retained service customers, which is indirectly related to the aggregate of new car sales from prior years. So to make money in the future, the car dealers need to expand new car sales today. Increasing sales is what the manufacturer wants. This all seems like a pretty nicely worked out system, if you ask me.
- pjspycha 11y agoHere in the US, we just bought a car and because they didn't have the model on lot anywhere, we just ordered through Toyota the exact model we wanted with all the features we wanted in preferred colors/finish. The dealership still got a cut but they helped us select the car are made the process very easy.
- donkeyd 11y agoThat's good to hear, I was under the impression that this wasn't possible.
- nevinera 11y agoI was nodding along until that last part, where it indicated that our best answer was to have the federal government extort states into behaving as they ought.
- shmerl 11y agoThat's what had to happen with FCC repealing local monopoly protectionist laws which ban ISP competition. How is this any different?
- ywy9876 11y agor
- Rumford 11y agoThere are some interesting comments in here about how tough the struggle is for car dealerships, but I don't think that necessarily justifies their existence or mitigates the point of this article. If what the dealerships do is valuable enough to the customer, they would exist even without the ban on direct sales. But I think we can all intuit that if the ban were lifted, buying a car would be a very different (and better) experience.
- 300bps 11y agoI agree that the ban should be lifted. And I think car dealerships would survive without it. I recently spent some time on many car companies' websites and navigating the options is extremely difficult. They use all their marketing jargon like sDrive vs. xDrive or 4MATIC or whatever else other nonsense. They don't explain well what any of them mean, and I was left googling the definitions of everything. Then you get to being actually able to see the car with the various options that you're interested in. The article decries the fact that dealerships have "$100 billion of unsold dealer inventory" but that inventory has a purpose. Some people need a car right away and they aren't picky about it being the exact thing that they want. Some people want to actually see, feel and use the options they are considering. So I'm against the government-sanctioned ban on direct sales but I think that car dealerships would serve a purpose and survive without it.
- Rumford 11y agoYou're probably right. For example: Even though you can buy a Thinkpad directly from Lenovo, Best Buy still exists.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>Even though you can buy a Thinkpad directly from Lenovo, Best Buy still exists For how long? It's a product an older generation that, for some reason or another, appreciates receiving the sales pitch. We're all tech savvy people here; go into Best Buy and start looking at computers. 4 out of 5 times you'll receive a sales pitch with, at least, a few elements of utter bullshit. Meanwhile, the younger generation are becoming more and more comfortable with buy things online, sight unseen. The GP said it needs to see and feel options on a vehicle. I don't. I need to know what they do, and whether they work (information I can gather from reviews). In my experience, going and playing with something for a brief period of time at a dealership or store doesn't provide enough real world information, and I'm just as likely to make the wrong choice about a feature.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoFrom time to time, I think the concept of car dealers has a lot in common with the RIAA model of the music industry. The RIAA has a vested interest in keeping "direct to consumer" models sidelined, or, once enough critical mass is achieved, to bring that artist/group into the fold. In reality, the RIAA system spends a lot of money on behalf of artists/groups, in a similar notion that car dealerships are at the forefront for manufacturers and brand stability. Sometimes dealerships go bust, sometimes labels go bust...sometimes dealerships do so well they become multi-million dollar enterprises (Don Huffines in Texas...now State Senator Don Huffines), and same goes for record labels (Big Machine). Both the dealership association and the RIAA push very hard in lobbying for their own ends. As can be seen in the music industry, fans nor artists haven't exactly jumped ship away from the RIAA system. There may be some similarities in the dealership scenario, but time will tell.
- Tloewald 11y agoThe situation with car dealerships is a quagmire. I'd suggest a broader, simpler, and probably more politically viable solution would be a law requiring truth in advertised prices: If you advertise something as $X then that is the maximum total amount you pay (tax-inclusive, all fees, etc.) Almost every other developed country does this (except for hotel stays and some large ticket items, like houses and -- ironically -- cars, but we can do better, right?) Now, I can imagine a sudden wave of protest -- but wait, what about state-wide or nation-wide advertising campaigns -- this happy meal for only $2.99? Sales tax varies from county to county, and then there are crazy exemptions, tax holidays, etc. EXACTLY. If you believe in markets then you should, at minimum, believe in price transparency. (Free markets assume perfect information -- how perfect can your information be if you can't even figure out the true price?) If this puts pressure on states and counties to simplify their tax rates (under pressure from businesses) then GOOD. If the prices that get advertised have to be real prices you get a huge improvement in market behavior -- from real estate to healthcare to cars to food -- immediately. And it will effectively demolish most of the issues with car dealers since they'll need to quote actual prices.
- xacaxulu 11y agoThis is the reason I like TrueCar. It's not a total solution, but it definitely starts down the road of leveling the playing field.
- solomatov 11y agoI love this service. It allowed me two buy a car from a dealership spending very little time,e and not spending it on unnecessary haggling.
- sgustard 11y agoI used www.roadster.com to buy a new car online for my father in law. It gives you a great price up front, and its experts do all the work of negotiating, handle your trade-in, and deliver the car to you, so you don't have to step into a dealership at all. Roadster's available in California so far. Check out their reviews http://yelp.com/biz/roadster-san-francisco http://yelp.com/biz/roadster-san-francisco
- mgalka 11y agoIs it just me or did this problem fly completely under the radar during the govt bailout?
- breischl 11y agoThey wouldn't have touched it at that time anyway. The point of bailouts is to increase (or at least maintain) employment and the economy. Dismantling a sprawling industry which provides many jobs that are available without degrees or other credentials would have defeated the purpose.
- 31reasons 11y agoKill the laws that unfairly protects X business.
- myth_buster 11y agoIs the savings from direct sales the reason for companies like BMW offering sponsored visit to German factory for a buyer in the states?
- ryanlol 11y agoIf your business model is so terrible that you need protectionist laws to survive, maybe you just deserve to go bankrupt.
- strommen 11y agoThe only real consumer benefit that this article describes for factory-direct sales is cost savings from no longer carrying inventory. But that's a completely separate issue: there's no reason an indy dealer can't have a low inventory and custom-order new cars for all their customers. Dealers carry a large inventory because it works. People (for the most part) want to pick out their specific car and drive it off the lot. They form an emotional connection with the car before they own it, and the dealer needs that emotional connection to close the deal. Going factory-direct with a wait time of several days would snap buyers back into logical reality, and car companies do not want that.
- gruez 11y agowhat about the commission the dealer makes off each sale?
- nickff 11y agoIf car companies "do not want" to sell direct, why did the dealers in so many states lobby for laws which guarantee that the manufacturers cannot sell directly to consumers?
- strommen 11y agoThe laws are typically guaranteeing that manufacturers cannot sell directly in places where they also have dealers. Because a regional car dealer with $X0 million of revenue cannot compete with a multinational car manufacturer with $X0 billion of revenue. Any time a manufacturer didn't want a particular dealer around anymore, they could simply drop their prices and drive them out of business. That's not a healthy dynamic for a business relationship. One could argue - and I agree - that the best way to handle this is via the free market, and let manufacturers who do this sort of thing gradually lose their distribution network due to lack of trust. But the short-term collateral damage is high-profile bankruptcies, unemployment, and high auto prices.
- gutnor 11y agoIt is interesting that in Europe, buying a car means going to the factory-franchised dealer, order and wait several months to get your car. The only car I bought new took 6 months to be delivered and that car model had existed for over 2 year before I ordered it, so it was not a new or recently refreshed car. When you buy a show-room car, or an in-stock car (km 0 car), you expect a significant discount (10 -> 20% off) over the discount you generally expect (i.e. not much nowadays except maybe free metal paint or free alloy wheels upgrade) There are few generalist dealer that do multi-brand dealer where you buy in stock car. The interest to go to those dealers is that they indeed have the car in stock and generally with a good discount over the factory-direct sales, or provide configuration that are not available in your country[1]. [1] Factories provide different pack and dependencies between options is different EU countries. For example, a car I was looking at requires luxury electric seats in order to install 360 camera in Belgium. It is available as a standalone option in Spain on most trims, but is restricted to the most expensive trim in the UK. The EU is weird like that.
- fjdjcjfjejs 11y agoITT: >Let's take money out of local communities and place even more wealth and power in the hands of wealthy megacorporations! HN truly disgusts me sometimes.
- MagnumOpus 11y agoLocal labour is inefficient, expensive and highly variable in quality. "Protecting local jobs" works against economies of scale and results in more expensive - and often worse - service. People vote with their wallet against the local corner store and pro Trader Joe/WholeFoods, against the local radio shack and pro Amazon/Newegg, against the local carpenter and pro IKEA. Their lives are better and they are wealthier for not having to spend $50 on a HDMI cable or $800 on a kitchen table.
- fjdjcjfjejs 11y agoRemoving protections for dealerships isn't about increasing efficiency: automakers simply want a larger share of the profit. These corporations wouldn't be clamoring to kill dealerships if they were going to take the profit out of selling cars. This is just going to result in capital flight from local areas, directly making them poorer. Unless you're a major shareholder in one of these automakers, by advocating for the deprecation of locally owned dealerships, you're advocating for making yourself poorer.
- ergothus 11y agoI used to work with a company that worked with dealerships, and I learned some pretty surprising (to me) details. For example: In most cases, the dealership buys the cars on the lot from the manufacturer via vastly short term loans. When the above article mentions the cost of sitting inventory, I assume that is what is being discussed. This isn't like inventory in a store, where the main concern is that it is losing value with age and occupying floorspace, this is actively costing INTEREST, in addition to deprecating with age and requiring lot space. I'll also second the other comments that talk about Parts & Service as the primary income. User/Certified Pre-owned come in a distant second, and new cars (aside from certain brands) are at best a thin margin, sometimes a loss-leader. While my management was very gung-ho about our customers, I saw nothing to convince me that the average dealership offers any value-add to the consumer, and where there is value-add it's destroyed by the laws that discourage competition and encourage industry practices that aren't good for the consumer.
- dragontamer 11y agoIMO, parts & service is significant value-added for consumers. For DIY, having a place to pick up a specific hose or brake rotors is always nice. There are online shops of course, but if you're shopping for OEM parts it seems like online prices aren't too much better. For those who don't have mechanic skills, knowing that the dealership is trained to _only_ work on your model of car is extra assurance that they'll do it correctly. (EDIT: Not a guarantee of course, but any extra assurance is helpful)
- jbigelow76 11y ago* knowing that the dealership is trained to _only_ work on your model of car is extra assurance that they'll do it correctly.* Semi-tangential: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ii8rC6CPCvM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ii8rC6CPCvM
- Vendan 11y agoIt may just be that my cars are old, but the dealerships don't have parts for them. On the other hand, there's 3 auto part shops less then 10 minutes from me that have the various parts I've needed on hand and ready to go.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- amha 11y agoIf anyone hasn't heard it, there's a fantastic This American Life that follows around a bunch of employees in a car dealership for a month. It's fascinating and sad: http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/513/129-cars http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/513/1... Abstract: "We spend a month at a Jeep dealership on Long Island as they try to make their monthly sales goal: 129 cars. If they make it, they'll get a huge bonus from the manufacturer, possibly as high as $85,000 — enough to put them in the black for the month. If they don't make it, it'll be the second month in a row. So they pull out all the stops."
- steamer25 11y agoRelated CollegeHumor/truTV info-tainment spin-off: Adam Ruins Everything - The Real Reason Car Dealerships Are the Worst https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uMWmYJOa-BM&list=PLZxWJ6CTr63Z4OYR3gdMEEog5Zju5ihyu&index=6 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uMWmYJOa-BM&list=PLZxWJ6CTr6...
- petemc_ 11y agoOld but good related article on life as a car salesman: http://www.edmunds.com/car-buying/confessions-of-a-car-salesman.html http://www.edmunds.com/car-buying/confessions-of-a-car-sales...
- stretchwithme 11y agoI recently bought a new car and I bought it just like my last one. I contacted the fleet managers at nearby dealers and asked for a price for the model and options I wanted. Then I just accepted the best offer that didn't require too much travel. Oh, this time I tried Truecar first, but the fleet manager price was lower.
- Digit-Al 11y agoI am English, not American, so I may be misunderstanding this - but I believe sales tax might prove an incentive for some states to oppose any changes to their existing laws on this. As I understand it, local sales taxes are paid to the state where the sale is made. I assume every state has lots of car dealerships, but only a few states have car manufacturers. This would mean that if everyone started buying their cars online direct from the manufacturers then the taxes would go from being distributed around the country to being concentrated to a few states. Surely those states without manufacturers would lose a lot of sales tax if this happened, so would have a strong incentive to oppose such a change.
- TrisMcC 11y agoI live on the border of a tax-free state (New Hampshire, live in Maine). When a car is purchased in NH, the sales taxes are assessed at the time of the auto registration (5.5% in Maine). No sales taxes are lost to the state.
- mikeyouse 11y agoIn the US, you're supposed to claim the sales taxes for all of your out-of-state online purposes every year. There's a supplement to your tax forms where you can itemize all of the online purchases you made and how much sales tax you owe. Since this form is voluntary and results in higher taxes, you can guess how many people actually go through this step. However, like TrisMcC says, most states assess Sales Tax when you register the car in the state. So if you bought a car for $50k in Oregon (no Sales Tax), but then registered it in California (7.5%+ Sales Tax), your registration fees would be the standard fee + $3,750. If you bought your car more than 1 year ago (in California at least), you don't owe any sales tax and if you bought it in a state with lower tax, you just owe the difference. For big online companies, we've started mandating that they collect sales tax on behalf of the customers, so for instance, Amazon now automatically collects sales tax based on where your billing address is. If direct sales were allowed, there'd surely be legislation to ensure that the manufacturers collect the tax for their customers.
- Digit-Al 11y agoWhat about used car dealerships?