11 ms·
EFF, AdBlock and Others Launch New “Do Not Track” Standard
- stephengillie 11y agoIt's nice to see they're taking another try at this. But I don't expect anything server-side to realistically work. If you outlaw online tracking, then only outlaws will track people online. And we know many outlaws download videos, music, and games, so what's to stop many outlaws from continuing to track? I don't see an end to the browser-side escalation of Adblock/uBlock, Ghostery, HTTPS Everywhere, uMatrix, etc.
- joosters 11y agoI'm not worried about outlaws tracking me, it's the thousands of legitimate, legal tracking companies that worry me!
- stephengillie 11y agoEdit: there's not even a law! It's just a voluntary agreement. How many of them will just ignore the agreement and keep doing business as usual? Why wouldn't they?
- jessaustin 11y agoPerhaps this depends on the definition of "legitimate"? Many reasonable definitions will change the quantity from "thousands" to "several".
- joosters 11y agoFar fewer. And it will make it more difficult for them to sell their analytics data on to legitimate companies when it is easily shown that they are breaking the law. I don't get your objection. Are you really complaining that if a law/agreement isn't 100% effective then it is worthless?
- stephengillie 11y agoMy objection is that I don't understand how it will work this time. I don't expect tracking companies to voluntarily obey a setting that loses them money; I don't expect people to act economically illogical. And why would other industry members voluntarily lose money by ignoring DNT results? Do you really think advertisers care what their products think? The only way we've got this attention is with widespread use of adblocking software.
- joosters 11y agoOh, I agree with you, I doubt that analytics companies will voluntarily sign up to this new code of practice. Your talk of 'outlaws' meant, to my eyes, a more hypothetical situation where some form of DNT was passed in to law. At the moment, companies that ignore DNT are not outlaws.
- Kenji 11y ago"Do not track" is completely useless. Somewhat ironically, it actually has the opposite effect: The "Do not track" boolean contributes to your digital fingerprint.
- sidarape 11y ago"The 'Do not track' boolean contributes to your digital fingerprint." I always thought that and that's why I didn't turn it on.
- joosters 11y agoUnfortunately, there's probably enough data to identify you anyway, regardless of DNT setting: https://panopticlick.eff.org/ https://panopticlick.eff.org/
- gruez 11y agoI feel that the methodology of that site reports your browser as more unique than it really is. For one, it doesn't take into account that plugins/browsers are constantly getting updated. This causes the user-agent string and the plugin names to constantly change, causing the site to report more entropy than there really is. For instance, I'm using firefox on windows 8.1. Based on the market share of windows 8.1 (13%) and firefox (11%), the chance that another browser has the same user-agent should be 1 in 70. However panopticlick reports 1 in 943.29. Similarly, panopticlick reports that 1 in 7596.81 uses the latest version of the NPAPI flash plugin.
- ori_b 11y agoYeah, the numbers seem very suspect. It says, for example, that 1 in 1.34 (ie, only about 75%) of all browsers have cookies enabled. Considering that these days, you basically need that for things to work: 1) They're probably getting a very skewed sample, and 2) They're probably counting bots that hit the site.
- hansjorg 11y ago
- joosters 11y agoWhy are third party scripts allowed at all if a site is honoring 'do not track'? For instance, the EFF page about DNT - https://www.eff.org/pages/understanding-effs-do-not-track-policy-universal-opt-out-tracking https://www.eff.org/pages/understanding-effs-do-not-track-po... has an analytics link embedded in it. This fetches a pixel gif from https://anon-stats.eff.org/piwik.php?idsite=1&rec=1&url=https%3A//www.eff.org/pages/understanding-effs-do-not-track-policy-universal-opt-out-tracking&action_name=Understanding%20EFF%E2%80%99s%20Do%20Not%20Track%20Policy%3A%20A%20Universal%20Opt-Out%20From%20Tracking%20%7C%20Electronic%20Frontier%20Foundation&urlref=https%3A%2F%2Fthreatpost.com%2Feff-adblock-and-others-launch-new-do-not-track-standard%2F114121 https://anon-stats.eff.org/piwik.php?idsite=1&rec=1&url=http... Why is this still allowed? What analytics are even useful when DNT is being honored? Could there be a google analytics style service that could honor DNT then?
- Dysprosium 11y agoanon-stats.eff.org is a subdomain of eff.org. It's not a third party.
- Someone1234 11y agoMost sites, almost all, would break if browsers suddenly disallowed third party scripts. If you're asking why it is "allowed" by their policy, I'd argue that it really boils down to if a script is tracking or not tracking. For example a CDN is a third party, but often aren't designed for tracking.
- mirimir 11y ago> Most sites, almost all, would break if browsers suddenly disallowed third party scripts. I don't find that to be so. I use Firefox with AdBlock, NoScript, RefControl and Disable WebRTC. In NoScript, I've flagged third-party ad servers and trackers as untrusted. In RefControl, I block third-party referer by default. I use private browsing mode, and accept third-party cookies from visited sites, but all cookies are deleted when Firefox closes. I do allow useful content from third-party scripts. But that doesn't include crap from Facebook etc. And it's very rare that I need to enable other third-party scripts to get what I want from sites. If there's something truly evil that I want to read, I fire up a LiveCD VM.
- 0x0 11y agoIs this just like P3P? Because that was a failure of a standard if I ever saw one. Web devs blindly copypasting random P3P headers just to get third party widgets to load properly. Or even setting headers like "not a P3P policy" with less than honest side effects. Like Google does: https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/151657?hl=en https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/151657?hl=en
- makomk 11y agoP3P was a train wreck because no-one actually set their own policies and the UI to do so was hidden and ridiculously complex, so the only reason anyone ever used it was by accident due to using IE, and it broke stuff like single-sign-on with the default policies unless sites actively worked around it.
- Dysprosium 11y ago> it’s still a voluntary policy All has been said.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mangecoeur 11y agoTo encourage adoption and enforce DNT ad-blockers like AdBlock could agree to relax ad blocking by default on sites which genuinely honor DNT. This way sites have an incentive to do the right thing. Of course for tracker-blocker add ons nothing should change since a DNT respecting site shouldn't fall foul of a tracker block.
- kofejnik 11y agoI solved the tracking problem very easily with just three Chrome profiles: 1. Gmail work, gmail personal, chrome profile linked to gmail. Some work sites (clicking links from work emails). No other use. 2. Facebook + Vk only, not logged in, ublock origin, only session cookies enabled (exception - facebook). 3. All other browsing, ublock origin, only session cookies, not logged in With right-click profile switching, it's really not much more hassle than switching between windows.
- redwards510 11y agoHow do you know that works?
- joosters 11y agoYou could take a look at the cookies / local storage used by each profile. If I understand the situation right, profile 1 would keep cookies forever, so if you saw countless cookies by multiple tracking companies, you'd know that you forgot to switch profiles at some point.
- chii 11y agoA large advertising company would have enough resources to code up browser profiling tool that can almost uniquely identify you from various performance characteristics such as canvas render. Those separate profiles only serves the illusion of privacy IMHO.
- doubt_me 11y agohttps://github.com/gorhill/uMatrix https://github.com/gorhill/uMatrix Same developer/ for advanced users I have been using it since it was HTTP Switchboard and works wonders
- gamesbrainiac 11y agoI feel that this would not deter companies from tracking. People would still use disconnect and adblock to make sure that their search queries are not being tracked. I myself am considering getting a VPN since a lot of sites track according to mac address.
- astrobe_ 11y agoI appreciate the effort but DNT will remain an opt-in for me, not a weak opt-out based on purely on trust. That means Adblock, Ghostery, Noscript, and whatever is required to ensure that websites don't collect data about me when I don't want to. I want to choose to whom I give my data; because I also may want to do that when I trust or want to support a website. This is all about principles. When I say "no" it means no. Especially in this times of guerilla wars against privacy. We have to win this fight, because privacy is one of the fundamental human rights.
- jedberg 11y agoHonest question: Would you be ok if a website blocked your access because you were running those, since they interpret it as stealing, by denying them the data that makes them money?
- chiefsucker 11y agoIf he stands by his principles then it should be OK. For me it would be OK as a “counter-measure” against an ad blocker.
- wtallis 11y agoOnly if they achieve the blocking by not sending me the data in the first place. If you send me a multi-megabyte page that relies on Javascript to prevent a redirect to an "enable cookies" page or to remove an overlay, you're an asshole.
- Balgair 11y agoMany websites already do this (sorry, I can't think of them off the top of my head). For me, it hasn't affected my browsing. If anything, it serves as a warning that those people are shady about privacy and respect for their users.
- mirimir 11y agoSure, no problem. But I'm typically testing various VPN services, using pfSense VPN-client VMs. So I would just fire one up, and route a LiveCD VM through it. The site could collect whatever data it wanted. But it would mostly be noise.
- jedberg 11y agoAs someone who used to run a site that made money from tracking people by showing them ads (and we tried really hard to make those ads unintrusive and relevant), I have mixed feelings on this. On one hand I totally get why people don't want to be tracked (I don't). On the other hand, for many of these sites, this is their only source of revenue. Whenever I ask, "is it ok for those sites to block you if you are running adblock" usually people say "no, they need to find a different business model!". But my question back is always: until they do find a new business model, if they can survive by blocking people who use adblock, why shouldn't they?
- chimeracoder 11y ago> But my question back is always: until they do find a new business model, if they can survive by blocking people who use adblock, why shouldn't they? In this day and age, Adblock is a necessity for nontechnical users. I installed it on my parents' machines to protect them against drive-by-downloads, malware, etc. Someone may say, "I know my ad networks would never do anything of the sort". But the fact is, ad networks get compromised, and even ad networks that have strict policies for acceptable ads sometimes have bad actors slip through. Even if it's not often, it's enough of a risk that it's simply not worth it. FWIW, Reddit may be in a different situation, since I believe Reddit's ads are self-hosted. In that sense, I'd view it more as analogous to sponsored user-generated content, which I have other philosophical issues with, but don't suffer from this problem.
- jedberg 11y ago> since I believe Reddit's ads are self-hosted I'm not sure where it is at now, but we had a mixed situation when I was there. We self hosted some, but one of the things we "self hosted" was an iframe to an ad network. We had to be really careful because everything you said was (and probably still is) true. Bad actors slip through, networks get compromised, etc. This is spot on: "Even if it's not often, it's enough of a risk that it's simply not worth it.". That was exactly the conclusion we came to.
- iigs 11y agoThis was it for me. I don't really care about the stupid "hit the monkey and win" blinking animated .gifs, and lived with them for years without really worrying, but in 2015 ad blockers aren't sunglasses, they're condoms. Furthermore, I installed uBlock in Firefox for Android because ads were getting so bad that it was essentially impossible to view some sites. It was a last-ditch effort to offer the content one last chance to survive. If publishers would prefer I not see their content at all, that's fine... I was almost already there, anyway. In response to jedberg's question: I personally don't mind but I don't believe I'm as petulant and entitled as the typical loud mouthed redditor, but reddit made that bed, and now they get to lay in it.
- WireWrap 11y agoAre they announcing the launch of the not quite finalized W3C Tracking Protection Group recommendations (see the last call working drafts, bottom left, http://www.w3.org/2011/tracking-protection/ http://www.w3.org/2011/tracking-protection/)? The 1.0 of their dnt-policy.txt (https://raw.githubusercontent.com/EFForg/dnt-policy/master/dnt-policy-1.0.txt https://raw.githubusercontent.com/EFForg/dnt-policy/master/d...) which points to one of those drafts (http://www.w3.org/TR/tracking-dnt/ http://www.w3.org/TR/tracking-dnt/)?
- forrestthewoods 11y agoAnything that can simply be ignored is worse than worthless. It's worse because it's actively harmful in the cases, the numerous cases, where the tag is simply ignored. Ghostery + AdBlock. No regrets.
- ikeboy 11y agoWhy not link to https://www.eff.org/pages/understanding-effs-do-not-track-policy-universal-opt-out-tracking https://www.eff.org/pages/understanding-effs-do-not-track-po... directly? This has pretty much zero relevant info about what the new standard does.
- dmitrygr 11y agoStill voluntary compliance = still toothless. How about the agreement between users and site to the tune of "you honor DNT or I block every little bit of your ads"?
- makecheck 11y agoMaybe there should be a standard to go the other way: a scheme to let web sites communicate monetary requests to browsers in an "official" protocol. A lot of this tracking only seems to exist for advertising schemes, which only exist to monetize the page. We are years past the point where we should have figured out how to make it easy to pay who you're looking at. For instance, when you visit the page for Article X on news site Y, maybe Y's response includes a header that says it requests a donation, with some suggested value like "10 cents". And then, in some standard interface, the browser would show this request (e.g. a small icon in the corner with a price, including some given link on how to pay it). The request would require certain things for security; e.g. use of HTTPS and being on the same domain as the majority of the content. And since blatant copy/paste stealing and re-posting to blogs, etc. is a money-making scheme in itself, the browser might "protect" monetized pages in some way; e.g. disable the copy/paste and printing functions unless the donation interface is used to pay, to at least make it more difficult to outright rip off web sites.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoWhy would I want to run a browser that hurt me to benefit other people?
- qu4z-2 11y agoSometimes people forget that browsers are user agents. Sometimes that includes browser developers.
- saidajigumi 11y agoAnd then you're right back into the great micropayments hole. No one has "figured this out", in part because of the real-world payment logistics, and and I'll pose another part: because it's a bad idea from a UX standpoint. Having to make a decision about whether to tip/donate to what would rapidly become nearly every site on the Internet would be a terrible user experience. "Decision energy" (aka willpower) is a scarce human resource; this would be an unparalleled waste of it. I wish there were a great alternative to ads as well, but I believe action-required micropayments will always be a non-starter. The best we've got so far are tools like Patreon and Bountysource's similar system. These can be viewed as a kind of "preaggregated micropayments", which eliminate per-click decision making via a user-configurable subscription. > the browser might "protect" monetized pages in some way It's already possible to disable copy on web pages. Some blog themes do this, and I wish browsers would just unimplement it entirely. This is right up there with lame DRM schemes, in that view source (or else curl) are still going to work. Likewise, bots will be completely unaffected. Such an approach merely annoys users with legitimate needs (e.g. who must to look up a word or phrase), but will have zero impact on content piracy.
- RexRollman 11y agoThis will fail. If we want freedom from tracking, we will have to take it; they are not going to give it to us.
- tracker1 11y agoWhat I want is adblock/ublock/ghostery for my phone... I swear it's worse than the popover/under ads in the 90's if you happen to click on the wrong clickbait article from your phone. For that matter, just make browsers not allow an iframe within another iframe... that should reduce a lot of the problems with ad/tracking networks. What's really annoying are the ads that block content, but have the weird /A logo that you can click to report that the ad is used to block content...WTH. The problem is the funding for the biggest browser is from an ad company, and a lot of the funding from one of the other largest is as well.
- slrz 11y ago> What I want is adblock/ublock/ghostery for my phone. Doesn't Firefox on Android give you exactly that? I never used the Android version but at least with its Maemo predecessor the ability to use Adblock Plus et al. was a given and really good to have.
- dzhiurgis 11y agoGoogle somehow manages to escape their own browser settings. I set the Chrome flag to 'Do not track', but when I go to their site settings I have to additionally disable tracking.
- Nursie 11y agoThis is still asking a dishonourable industry to honour a polite request, and as such I don't see that it has any value. I'm not sure why this voluntary code of practice stuff is still under discussion. Defensive measures are the only thing that's ever going to work because advertisers are actively hostile and forever trying to push boundaries in their continuous attempts to grab your attention. I propose a move in the other direction, I propose that tools like adblock and noscript start to broadcast their presence in request headers. I would perfectly happy to let a site owner know up-front that I will not be rendering any of their advertising content, I will not be keeping and propagating any tracking cookies (or cache entries or whatever) and they can choose whether or not they still wish to serve my request. They could even present me with the choice of disabling my blockers to see their site. That way everyone knows what's going on, nobody feels either ripped off by blockers or under attack from advertisers, job done.
- yuhong 11y agoThinking about it, there is the European "cookie law". Too broad, but DNT can be included in similar laws.
- manigandham 11y agoAds are the only micropayment solution that has worked so far. There are a few ideas out there to make things better (I'm currently working on one) but it's a very long road that requires massive reach and coordination between lots of major companies to work effectively at scale (as in the internet and not just 5 sites). Biggest issue is that people just don't like paying for content, or dealing with transactions (at the pace of website access). Also, I think people tend to forget but payments aren't really that much more private than ads. In fact most ad networks don't know that much or it's very confused (just go look up any of the info registries to see). Payments however usually mean a central service + credit cards = name, age, address, purchase history, etc.
- lucaspiller 11y ago> Biggest issue is that people just don't like paying for content I don't think people are ever going to be willing to pay for content in terms of giving their money to the writer/publisher/etc, even if it's 1c. Look at the app store as an example, if people aren't even willing to pay 99c for a game that they dump 20+ hours of their life into (which can be done friction-free in 2 taps), why would they pay to read an article with poor journalism about something that doesn't really matter to them? Giving up your privacy or agreeing to be shown big adverts for things corporations want you to buy seems to be perfectly accepted outside of our paranoid tech world. Next time you go to the supermarket look at how many products you see placed strategically at the end of aisles, or how many people have loyalty cards which give them discounts.
- Nursie 11y ago>> Giving up your privacy or agreeing to be shown big adverts for things corporations want you to buy seems to be perfectly accepted outside of our paranoid tech world. No, I really don't think it is. More and more non-tech people I know are running ad blockers these days. And for tracking I think there are probably three groups of people, those that know and object, those that know and don't care and those that don't know. The last group being by far the largest, so it's difficult to predict what they might think if they knew they were constantly being recorded and profiled.