6 ms·
The thread is from 2004, it should go into the title. I've been using Windows XP until January 2009, then I reformatted my laptop with Ubuntu. One of the first
by pmontra 11y ago
The thread is from 2004, it should go into the title.
I've been using Windows XP until January 2009, then I reformatted my laptop with Ubuntu. One of the first things I noticed was that it instantaneously recognized pen drives without going through all that found new device dance. OS X is also fast at mounting USB drives. I just can't understand the technical reasons that make Windows annoy people with that. Is it still the same with Windows 8?
- mavroprovato 11y agoTo be fair, newer versions of Windows are much better in autodetecting devices when compared to XP.
- jebblue 11y agoI consult a lot which means I often have to use a Windows desktop because the IT staff needs it to run Office for people who only know one email client. I mostly work in Linux usually in a VM in these case. To you point, on a new machine designed to run Windows 7, 3 times in the past few months I plug in my external keyboard and it fails. The only resolution is to reboot the windows machine. At least once I've had my USB headset fail, had to reboot Windows. In the past year on a different machine also designed to run Windows I could not get it to detect my Android phone while my Ubuntu desktop has never failed on 3 different machines running Ubuntu. When people say in any thread that Windows driver support is superior to Linux; the answer from my experience on a number of machines is still no.
- sudioStudio64 11y agoXP came out at the same time that Redhat 6.2 was out. I wonder how it recognized usb drives?
- pmontra 11y agoI've got a Redhat 6.2 CD. I wonder if it installs on some old laptop of mine but don't wait for news anytime soon :-)
- rwmj 11y agoI tried some old RHL and other Linux installs on qemu a while back, and it's hit and miss if they even work -- mostly miss in fact. (Back to RHEL 3 you're OK, RHL <= 7 didn't work). It seems qemu only emulates devices enough to work with modern Linux device drivers, which is natural because that's all most people test.
- ptaipale 11y agoWhat? Windows XP was published in October 2001. The latest Service Pack (SP3) was published in April 2008. RHEL 6.2 was released in December 2011. So even the latest XP release is 3.5 years older than RHEL 6.2 (which does recognize USB drives quite fine).
- stevehawk 11y agoThere were many versions of Red Hat before the RHEL run started. I believe that's what GP was talking about.
- mavroprovato 11y agoHe means this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Hat_Linux#Version_history https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Hat_Linux#Version_history
- ptaipale 11y agoRight, I just didn't expect anyone would compare to that since RH has been not really usable for quite some time (unlike Windows XP). (Usable in the sense of getting any recent application versions to install, not to mention getting security patches). Is there really someone actually running RH 6 from the year 2000? (I was actually thinking that if the comment were referring to RH prior to RHEL, we were talking of a version that was still using a.out binary format, but that was not so, I was off by some three years, it came in RH3).
- jlgaddis 11y agoRed Hat Linux 6.2 ("Zoot"), not Red Hat Enterprise Linux 6.2.
- jahnu 11y agoSome of that stuff is a result of legacy issues where Microsoft tried to handle badly made USB devices as well as possible. For example the reason Windows used to try and install the device again every time you switched ports was because USB device vendors really often didn't use a unique ID so identifying the device was tricky. Coupled with the multi-year release cycle that Windows had and Microsoft's mission to keep backward compatibility meant we had to put up with a lot of this stuff for a long time.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago"legacy issues"? If only. Some vendors still do this stuff today.
- ackalker 11y agoI'm wondering why Microsoft didn't add the unique serial number requirement to its WHQL driver testing, allowing vendors who realize too late that their shipped devices don't have a unique serial number to add the "magic registry key" (for ignoring the serial number) to their next WHQL driver candidate.
- talmand 11y agoIf the WHQL driver testing didn't exist at the beginning of USB then I imagine it would be for backwards compatibility.
- nolok 11y agoWin 7/8: the device install process is still there but it's instant, you wouldn't even know if it weren't for the notification popup in the tray. My issue on the other hand, is that it keeps asking to "scan and fix errors" when you plugin thumb drives if you take them out without using "eject" first.
- pmontra 11y agoI think that's a good idea. You can lose all the drive by pulling it out without stopping it first. It happened to me a couple of times. Even if that scan and fix thing was only a way to scare people into ejecting drives, I think it's worth it.
- Dylan16807 11y agoThe entire drive was lost? That's really shameful firmware, even if you unplugged it mid-write. Unplugging an idle drive should never lose anything. But there's a lot of flaky hardware out there.
- mahouse 11y agoWhat does the firmware have to do with it? I don't think the firmware knows anything at all about what you have stored inside the drive.
- RndPwn 11y agoThe only reason I could think of is the firmware is not performing writes the way the OS expects them to.
- nickspacek 11y agoI thought this was a buffered-writes issue, where (perhaps based on the filesystem?) the OS may have buffered some of the disk operations in memory and by asking it to unmount you can ensure that everything gets flushed to the drive. Not sure how that would result in ruining/wiping the drive though.
- simias 11y agoNot only pen drives but also keyboards and mices. At home I often switch my keyboard from one laptop to the other and while it's always enabled near-instantly on linux it always takes a few seconds on windows (and especially the first time). It always annoyed me. This is actually one of the few areas where linux is significantly superior to windows from an average "destktop" user's perspective. For instance getting PS3 controller to work on windows is (used to be?) very painful. On linux I plug it and it just works. Same for network-over-usb "RNDIS" devices but that might be more of a niche.
- rplnt 11y agoIsn't it caused by different kernel designs? Or is it only user-space implementation that causes this? I mean how long does it take to recognize and initialize a device.
- deckiedan 11y agoSame here. I normally work exclusively on macs & gnu/linux boxen, and when recently doing a stint in a windows 7 pro environment was in utter disbelief that plugging in a USB keyboard or mouse could occasionally require waiting over a minute before it became usable, often with a popup saying, "new drivers installed, you should probably restart" or similar. The environment is a bit odd - on a ship, so restricted internet and permissions, but even still. What the hell does windows need to go looking for drivers for a bog standard USB mouse???
- sp332 11y agoIt doesn't really know it's bog-standard until it looks up the USB VID&PID in the Windows Update database, right? I mean sure it could initialize as a basic HID device in the meantime but it would have to make you wait later when it uninstalled the HID driver and installed the new one, which seems like a pain as well.
- freshyill 11y agoMy favorite similar WTF Windows behavior (I hope this is fixed by now): Drag a file onto an application in the taskbar (as you would with a Dock icon in OS X), and it doesn't just fail to open it in that application—it actually gives you an alert saying "you can't drag things onto the taskbar" or something like that. So they built in the ability to tell people they can't do it, instead of building the ability to actually do what people clearly already wanted to do. Classic Microsoft UX.
- agumonkey 11y agoI'm not that hard on MS, I learned so late that you could drag icons on taskbar-minimized application to reopen them and then drag the file to use it. Saw that from an average guy dropping mp3 files in winamp. I was silently screaming in awe.
- sigzero 11y agoYeah, that one is annoying for the message and the non-effort by MS behind it.
- sigzero 11y agoYeah, that one is annoying for the message and the non-effort by MS behind it.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoThe reason it's not allowed is probably because it's unclear what it should do. Windows doesn't have a means to do a generic drag-and-drop onto a whole application. They'd have to get every application updated to support it.
- pjc50 11y agoThere's a discussion of this on the same blog: http://blogs.msdn.com/b/oldnewthing/archive/2004/11/24/269237.aspx http://blogs.msdn.com/b/oldnewthing/archive/2004/11/24/26923...
- beowulfey 11y agoI switch between fedora, osx and windows 8.1 on the regular. It's not fixed, and drives me crazy every time I have to wait for the window to open before I can plop down my file.
- Grazester 11y agoIn Windows 8 its pretty fast(less than 5 seconds, just tried) but it did come up with a prompt saying new device found. I don't know if you realise that you are comparing an OS released in 2001(winxp) to Ubuntu, an OS that wasn't around until three years after XP's release.Chances are you are even comparing it to a version of ubuntu that is much more recent that it's 2004 initial release.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- e12e 11y agoThe initial Ubuntu release leaned heavily on Debian -- so I don't think the comparison is entirely unfair. Debian started in 1993, and Debian 1.1 "Buzz" was released in 1996. Now, I can't really remember when I first came across an usb device -- but I also can't remember them ever causing me trouble in Debian.
- LoneWolf 11y agoFrom my experience with windows 8 is even slower, it consistently stays there for 5 minutes saying it is installing etc (but sometimes the drive is ready within 30sec, but the message stays)
- IshKebab 11y agoWell this still happens in Windows 7.