13 ms·
Negative Interest Rates May Spark Existential Crisis for Cash
- jchrisa 12y agoHere's an unconventional but powerful take on the subject of negative interest rates. http://sacred-economics.com/sacred-economics-chapter-12-negative-interest-economics/ http://sacred-economics.com/sacred-economics-chapter-12-nega...
- fche 12y ago"Money does not decay over time..." ... except in the form of inflation. Adding yet another centrally-planned mechanism for that (negative interest rates & elimination of cash) will amplify rather than reduce chaos, and (as intended) lead to a less-free market.
- cesarb 12y ago> "Money does not decay over time..." ... except in the form of inflation. We've experienced another form of decay. We had a few old leftover dollar bills from a trip to the USA we made last century. When we wanted to exchange them back into local currency a couple of years ago, all exchange houses would only give back around 70% of their face value, merely because they were old bills (they were in good condition).
- fche 12y ago"all exchange houses" (American banks would give you face value.)
- cesarb 12y ago> American banks would give you face value. It's still a loss of value. When they were new, they could be exchanged everywhere for their face value (minus a few percent for the commission). After a few decades, they can be exchanged for their face value only in certain places. Who knows what will happen after a few more decades? Will they still be accepted anywhere? In my country, if you still have any local currency bills or coins from before 1994, they're worthless except as a collector item. Won't surprise me if the same happens one day to old US dollar bills.
- walterbell 12y agoCoverage of ten recent statements about cash, http://wolfstreet.com/2015/04/25/don-quijones-war-on-cash-quotes-to-cashless-society/ http://wolfstreet.com/2015/04/25/don-quijones-war-on-cash-qu... "As a result of technological advances and generational priorities, cash’s days may well be numbered. But there is a whole world of difference between a natural death and euthanasia. It is now clear that an extremely powerful, albeit loose, alliance of governments, banks, central banks, start-ups, large corporations, and NGOs are determined to pull the plug on cash.." In 2011, System D (global underground economy) was claimed to be $10 trillion in size and growing, http://www.forbes.com/sites/benzingainsights/2011/11/07/rise-of-the-shadow-economy-second-largest-economy-in-the-world/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/benzingainsights/2011/11/07/rise... "..the OECD concluded that half the world’s workers (almost 1.8 billion people) were employed in the shadow economy. By 2020, the OECD predicts the shadow economy will employ two-thirds of the world’s workers.."
- crdoconnor 12y agoThe PR push seems mainly to be coming from Citi primarily (although other banks may be involved). It's pretty clear why they'd want to push to abolish cash and institute negative interest rates. It would put them at the center of the economy instead of the near center. Another back-door bailout like this might help deal with their, um, insolvency. What isn't clear is why anybody else would want it.
- Spooky23 12y agoThe existential crisis is the brain dead policies leading to this situation. We must not have inflation to protect the wealth of people and institutions with billions of dollars. But it's ok to destroy the ability of normal people to save or conduct business. If we live in a world where it's too dangerous to have any unauditable transaction, perhaps we're doing something wrong at another level. Most of these arguments are bunk anyway. The government captures every phone call in entire countries. We collect images of every piece of mail. Are you telling me that the government forgot to collect the serial numbers of every dollar bill as it enters the banking system? The other sad thing is this really reinforces and legitimizes the fear that fuels the right wing. Perhaps the goldbugs on talk radio are right!
- jevgeni 12y agoThe first sentence makes sense. The rest - doesn't.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- zhte415 12y ago> Are you telling me that the government forgot to collect the serial numbers of every dollar bill as it enters the banking system? They do. Mainly to track banknote usage and average life from when / where they enter circulation, to when / where they end up. Basically demand for and lifecycle of cash. It is valuable information for knowing how much to print, and for improving the durability of notes themselves (which is surprisingly low, an average of months, with a non-fat long-tail to weeks, for low denomination notes). [BTW, the date on the note has little to no relationship to the date it enters circulation, the serial number is used for this.]
- sonofsam 12y agoThe rich prodomiently hold their wealth in assets. These assets are more akin to rise in an inflationary environment (ie. Stock market.) It usually the middle class that is desvated as most do not have any assets other than their homes and rely on a salary for the majority of their income. It is possible for inflation and deflation to co-exist. Wages could down while the cost of food, housing and energy raises.
- mxfh 12y agoIn short term scenarios with negative/penalty interest rates, cash is considered an option favorable to accounted money by some. It seems that a Swiss pension fund tried to evade negative rates on deposits by withdrawing a very large amount of physical cash with the intention of vaulting it. But the bank refused to allow it to withdraw the money in the form of physical cash. http://www.forbes.com/sites/francescoppola/2015/04/25/the-swiss-have-eliminated-the-zero-lower-bound/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/francescoppola/2015/04/25/the-sw... ADDENDUM: The OP article is more about banks imposing negative interest rates, actually triggering a renaissance in cash storage. While storing huge amounts of cash as an individual during a deflation is, from an egoistic perspective, the better option in terms of personal purchasing power (minus the obvious physical risks). That the banks and financial regulators don't like this is clear, since it's money not under their control.
- anon4 12y agoI'm pretty sure that if you abolish paper money, you'll just give rise to a strong barter economy culminating in private paper money.
- VLM 12y agoOr you get a commodity bubble. Also a bubble in art, collectibles in general, metals... Also the old "alpha strategy" or whatever it was called from the 70s. If you know the price of TP is going to go up 20% per year (or even just 1%) if thats the best rate of return you can get, you buy a years supply of TP. Its not like you're going to stop using it anytime soon and you know prices only go up. This is the middle class version of the strategy, the poor don't have the money to buy a years supply of TP at once and the rich are talking about larger sums of money. In the short term this "activity" is exactly what they're trying to spark. The problem is in the medium and long term all you've done is pull demand forward.
- pjc50 12y agoAbsolutely. Faced with a choice between "deflate property prices" and "rewire the entire economy to force property to be the only long term store of value", people holding a lot of property are trying to organise the latter.
- mxfh 12y agoSo in effect for any non-institutional, non-property owning individual it still feels like an inflation since increasing rents and property prices will eat up way more income than any negative interest rate could raise. Classy way to ramp up societies inequality.
- walterbell 12y agoFrom http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/2015/apr/02/new-york-conspicuous-construction/ http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/2015/apr/02/new-yor... "58 percent of New York City condominiums are paid for entirely in cash ... If, as Goethe posited, architecture is frozen music, then these buildings are vertical money."
- VLM 12y agoTwo interesting concepts to think about: This is a strange "basic income" strategy. Mash that meme up against that meme and you get some weird observations. It seems to be failing, but its at least interesting. The idea of a debt jubilee, of course only for rich people, implemented as a low negative rate rollback instead of simply eliminating debt accounts, is related and interesting. Consider a novel solution to the housing bubble crisis or the death of the oil frack industry or the upcoming death of the social media bubble, don't just write off mortgages and loans but make them all neg 2 percent or whatever to not suddenly shock the economy. Its an interesting implementation idea. This is a symptom of a dying/collapsing economy. Not the rate itself, but look at how fast people are getting kicked off the island and no longer allowed to participate as they had participated for decades/centuries. Much like has been happening in the labor markets. The way economies die is almost never a light switch (that comes from reading greatly summarized histories deep in the past) but its more like the number of people permanently kicked out of the game increases YoY until no one cares about the legacy economy so it gets unstable and the few remaining die hards watch the final irrelevant tipover. You can see a technology analogy in software versions. Windows XP never died on a certain date, just fewer people used it over time with variations in rate due to external forces (support contracts, new windows version releases, pirated releases, etc) and finally it'll no longer be relevant in the marketplace, eventually. Likewise, economies die the same way. Its not only the quantity of transactions or size of transactions, but literally the number of players.
- dmichulke 12y agoNegative interest rates may as well spark questions as to how f*ed up a system can be until it implodes and what happens then. Seriously, if they truly were negative, we could all stop working now, borrow some money and live of the proceeds. IMO, the story that CBs know what they do and are there for our own good is not believed by anyone anymore and the future will teach us a lesson of sorts that will prevent us from repeating such lunacy for hopefully at least a few decades.
- mdemare 12y agoNegative interest currently only applies to a few banks and governments. The goal of the central banks here is to get people to spend/invest their money instead of saving it.
- fche 12y agoSee also https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JUvm9UgJBtg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JUvm9UgJBtg
- jrs235 12y ago"The goal of the central banks here is to get people to spend/invest their money instead of saving it." Because otherwise who will pamper and serve the central bankers and politicians if we're allowed to live free off our savings?
- pjc50 12y agoCentral banks generally have a very narrow remit: they're not political agencies. Most central banks have inflation targets. Inflation is low due to lack of economic growth. The only tool they're allowed to use is interest rates, and to some extent QE. Hence ridiculous schemes. Negative rates for bulk low-risk lending are a result of the collapse in borrowing. If retail rates are 1-2% and there's a 3% overall risk of default, that turns into a negative rate.
- dataker 12y agoIf interests rates are lower, borrowing increases, including reckless borrowers. So, technically, wouldn't it be more likely to have an even stronger economic crisis?
- pjc50 12y agoThere's nowhere for the borrowing left to come from. Due to a combination of income inequality and tightening creditworthiness standards, everyone (business and individual) is either too risky to lend to or doesn't need the money but is instead looking for somewhere to park it.
- lucozade 12y agoIt encourages borrowers to borrow possibly recklessly. It doesn't encourage lenders to lend recklessly (they won't make any money for the credit risk). Of course, that won't stop anyone from lending recklessly any more than rationality did last time around.
- jrs235 12y ago"It doesn't encourage lenders to lend recklessly (they won't make any money for the credit risk)." As long as lenders are Too Big To Fail and therefore don't take on the full risk of their lending decisions why wouldn't they continue on the private profits/rewards and public losses/risks trail?
- meric 12y agoIt will. Banks absorbed creditors' risks and lend them money for mortgages anyways until 2007. The financial crisis caused the government to bail out the banks, whose risk increased because they ate up all the mortgagee's risks. Now the governments are beginning to see problems, and the central banks are absorbing the risks. I think what happens next is the crisis with government bonds spreading from Greece to bigger nations and affecting the U.S., but the crisis will be aborted by central banks, somehow, eating up all the risk. The central banks' risks will in turn eventually be absorbed by currencies, which, when stressed too much, will fall apart and hyperinflate. I think signs of stress include overpriced assets, and volatility of value. A lot of this is my own observations, so take it with a grain of salt.
- fixxer 12y ago"If there’s one thing that militias and Tea Partiers hate more than “fiat money” that’s not backed by gold, it’s fiat money that exists only in electronic form, where it can be easily tracked and controlled by the government." Ugh. Good article until the author felt the need for this asinine political gem. I am neither a militia member nor a tea party republican, but I recognize the flaws of a system in which a bureaucracy controls money supply based on arbitrary theory rather than some index immune to manipulation. Therefore, I must be a militiaman. Cheap thrills kill copy, journo.
- thaumasiotes 12y agoIn what sense is tracking an index, or some function of an index, not basing the money supply on "arbitrary theory"? There's no law of nature that says the money supply must have X relation to any index -- if there was, the whole concept of "control of the money supply" would be ill-formed.
- fixxer 12y agoSure, let's go with that. It is all subjective. What political color am I now? My real argument is that the article had merit until the subtle mud slinging and big reveal of the author's bias.
- cgearhart 12y ago> ...some index immune to manipulation. Commodity money and representative money aren't any more immune to manipulation than fiat money. It doesn't matter whether you use gold, silver, or marshmallow peeps -- the value of your holdings are pegged to the value of the assets, which sway with the market. And the central bank can still manipulate that value, they just have to buy and sell the asset to do it. Fiat money gives nations a central mechanism to manipulate their own currency without hoarding gold and silver. Commodity & representative currency allow other countries to manipulate the currency. In _any_ monetary system, losing control of your money supply causes bad things to happen (see also: Greece).
- fixxer 12y ago
- koonsolo 12y agoI always saw money as some sort of unit for value. Everything valuable is expressed in some currency. Inflation is expressed as "things becoming more expensive", not "money loosing its value". Money seems to be the most basic part of how our economy works. I think the next decade will change everyone's perception of central bank money and cash, going from the most basic law on value, to just another thing that can be traded with another thing, losing or gaining value. The real question is if merchants will still accept these "I owe you" notes in the far future, instead of requesting something of real value. Timing means everything for something to become successful, and bitcoins couldn't have hoped for a better time than now.
- seanp2k2 12y agoYou're describing fiat money: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiat_money http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiat_money
- koonsolo 12y agoYes, exactly! But the point I was trying to make (very badly that is), is that most people call "fiat money" just "money". And they know no other money than money (including my past self). You can earn money, you can buy stuff with money, and you can save money. All fiat money of course, but that doesn't matter, because that's the only money people know. In the next decade, that perception will change. "Money" won't have a monopoly anymore.
- norea-armozel 12y agoOkay, I'm not quite understanding the idea of the negative interest rate other than it's levied against people who hold on large stores of cash in their accounts. My question is under what situations would a bank implement such a policy? It is because there's no way for a bank to invest the funds? Or is it something deeper?
- xnull2guest 12y agoThe policy maker mentioned in the article claims that credit is now more liquid than cash. This could be taken quite a number of ways. One way is to think that the conveniences of credit has made cash less relatively liquid (there are fewer goods, such as those online, that can be traded for credit whereas most things in the physical world can be traded for credit). Another way is to see this as a hedge against a currency backed by a US facing fundamental challenges to its place as the global leader (not just in finance), whose growth even with stimulation boasts a mere 0.2%; 7% under major competitors. Another way to see this (e.g. in these comments) is a strategic means for banks to try to institute consumer credit as a currency of their own. One could also think of it as a fed inspired policy trying to get cash into circulation. The point of inflation is so that those holding large amounts of currency can't sit on the currency and make money from doing nothing. Banks and finance basically allow people to do this despite inflation (tending to benefit the rich more than the poor in this case). Putting a negative growth rate on storage of cash simulates the same thing.
- norea-armozel 12y agoThanks for the break down. I think all the points are true within the context that it's clear the negative interest rate is a way to get around problems of stimulating the economy, but also that there's certain banks who would love to get more people hooked on consumer credit. Frankly, I just hope this situation is resolved without having to chain everyone to such a terrible situation of perpetually needing consumer credit to pay for goods/services. I don't feel it's the right way to ensure a healthy economy. Or at least that's my view of it.
- chiph 12y ago"Hmm. You're going to charge me $250 a month, based on my cash balance, to keep my money in your institution. How much would it be to rent a large safety deposit box and just put my cash in there?"
- fexl 12y agoSome have already closed that exit, banning the storage of cash in their boxes. They want to keep your funds available for negative interest rates and possible bail-ins.
- jliptzin 12y agoCould you just put the cash in a cardboard box and then say it's important papers or stock certificates? Do they have the right to open it?
- drjesusphd 12y agoOf course they do. If they lie and say it smells like marijuana.
- linuxlizard 12y agoI think the difficulty would be finding enough safe deposit boxes. If I had $100M (let me dream, will you!) where could I store that physically? That much cash takes up a lot of space. The Oatmeal had a post where he talked about how heavy his $200,000 withdrawal was (that was in 20's). A little Google searching found: http://www.cockeyed.com/inside/million/million_dollars.html http://www.cockeyed.com/inside/million/million_dollars.html I think Adam Curry talked about buying actual gold bullion and storing that. Still takes a lot of space and a lot of cost in storage. $100M in gold is over 80,000 oz. Two tons of gold? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_bar#Standard_bar_weights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_bar#Standard_bar_weights http://demonocracy.info/infographics/world/gold/gold.html http://demonocracy.info/infographics/world/gold/gold.html Me, personally, if I had $100M, I'd buy an island somewhere close to an internet backbone. Real estate is always a good investment!
- websitescenes 12y agoThis is an excellent example of the extreme polarization of wealth that exists in America. Banks have so much money they don't need more!? All while more and more Americans slip into poverty. Remember, we bailed these institutions out with tax payer money. Does anyone else find this incredibly ironic?
- coldcode 12y agoEconomists rarely if ever care about people who have little or no money. Neither do most politicians. This has been the norm since people invented money and politics. If you eliminate money and deny credit to poor people, how does that work? Eventually it results in an uptick in guillotine manufacturing.
- Eye_of_Mordor 12y agoHuge drop in oil prices has driven inflation lower (oil had been high for a long time). Nothing to see here.
- nabla9 12y agoAnyone who has critical opinion of current system should first study enough to pass "Turing test for mainstream monetary economics and monetary policy" (test where you try to fake others that you are economist who understands prevailing monetary theory and defends the policy). For example, to know how economists think about general equilibrium theory of credit. There is huge knowledge cap between economists and policy makers and journalists and population. Who here in HN thinks they could pass the test If I were to administer one? For example questions related to macro- and microeconomic determinants of the demand for money, Baumol–Tobin transactions demand for money, portfolio selection, demand function stability, quantity theory, general equilibrium framework for money, yield curve, interest parity, AA–DD paradigm, etc. I feel that at least I know enough economics to know that I don't have simple technical solution (bitcoin, gold, what have you).
- pjc50 12y agoIsn't some of this in "economists differ" territory (Krugman and IS/LM, MMT, etc)?
- nabla9 12y agoYes, but you should expect that economists who differ understand the rationale behind different approaches. At least everyone should have understanding of classical form of monetarism before they start to depart from it.
- irixusr 12y agoThat's like saying 'anyone who's opposed to eugenics should pass the "Turing test for mainstream eugenics and racial hygiene" otherwise they're ill-informed'. Which is largely the argument used against opponents at the time (the opponents were ignorant "medieval obscurantists", if religious speaking from "superstition") My objections to modern economics are as follows: - utility is an ordinal quantity, not a cardinal one. I can tell you I prefer my soon-to-be-born daughter's first kiss to my sister's cheerful hello, but not by how much (how much "what"? What are the units?). - the utility function, so widely used, is an unknown function. However mathematics are performed after choosing an arbitrary functional form that has the features desired But most importantly: - It assumes utility exists and humans behave accordingly. These are fundamental objections to the field. I can talk to an economist about yield curves flipping, but that jumps over the foundational objections: they are projecting complex human behavior onto fairly outdated mathematics. And then making a mess of it.
- irixusr 12y agoWhen cash is abolished the bankers will own everything. We're asked to trust bankers to keep track of bits when they'd foreclose on homes that were current with their loan payments! Bankers who consistently make risky bets because they know their losses will inevitably be nationalized. Bankers who have manipulated the libor index, engaged in insider trading, broke the fiduciary trust between them and their clients advising them to buy assets they were selling. Ya, we should abolish cash and make these folks in charge of our money
- feraloink 12y agoThis is exactly the problem! What you wrote does not sound like extremist talk or paranoia. Certainly not after reading this: >Bank notes, as an alternate storehouse of value, are a constraint on central banks’ power. “We view this constraint as undesirable,” Citigroup Global Chief Economist Willem Buiter wrote. He goes on to describe some ways that central banks could stop people from trying to hold on to their cash, thus undercutting the supposedly desirable goal of expanding bank power. They included: > One, abolish paper money. Two, tax paper money. One lone guy at NYU's business school made the only (to me) rational observation. It was how the article ended: > if you’re afraid that central banks are in a war against savers, or that the government will try to control your financial affairs, cash is your best defense. Taking it away “is a prescription for revolution”.
- tim333 12y agoThe main issue is a bubble market for bonds. People are buying them because they have gone up in spite of the fact they lose money in the same way they used to buy loss making dot coms in the 90s dot com boom. For example a 10 year zero coupon bond paying $100 in 10 years time would traditionally have sold for say $80 giving you some return but if people choose to pay $101 I have a feeling it will go all webvan and pets.com on them. In fact the market appears to have started crashing three weeks ago. Cash will survive of course as it always has done.
- Random_BSD_Geek 12y agoIt's curious to read contemporaneous reports about negative interest rates on record hoards of cash, the pending insolvency of social security and medicare (in the US), and high unemployment globally. You'd think we could find better uses for those massive piles of cash. I for one welcome our pending transition to federation credits. ;)
- fche 12y ago"You'd think we could find better uses for those massive piles of cash" But those piles of cash don't belong to "us" to spend as "we" like.
- malteof 12y agoEcontalk on interest rates are quite on topic, check out here: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2015/04/scott_sumner_on.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2015/04/scott_sumner_on.htm...
- snake_plissken 12y agoThis article is mixing up a few things, that although related to each other, are distinct. The theory behind negative nominal interest rates is that depositors will move their money out into the economy where it can earn a the least a positive rate of return, or used for consumption. For some reason this isn't explained very well in the article. Personally I've never bought it, both in theory and practice. Real interest rates (the rate of return you get after accounting for inflation, i.e. real = nominal - inflation) have been negative for some time and there has not been this huge outflow of deposits into other or potentially better investments. It is mostly institutional investors and banks with money parked on the sidelines who are affected by these negative rates, but being (supposedly) risk averse entities, it does sometimes make more financial sense to know you are going to lose 1% a year rather than something more. Ironically, if anything, having a nominal negative rate of interest in a situation where the money remains parked in a bank says more about how low economic expectations are. But the ECB and the Swiss National Bank are setting a negative nominal interest rate because there is political opposition to expanding their balance sheets in the same way the Federal Reserve has done, so negative rates are really their only additional option. Right now there is an ECB bond buying program, but it will only purchase (and inject) about $1 trillion dollars in the Eurozone. The Fed bought about $4 trillion dollars. To call what JP Morgan has done through this "utilization fee" a negative interest rate is slightly disingenuous albeit still correct in principle, in which case your could call any fee that decreases what you put in a negative interest rate. They want to get rid of these deposits because it improves their balance sheet and lets them operate more freely under the current regulatory regimes, or at least make something on the side if the money stays. The articles does state this but it's buried at the end of the third paragraph. Then there is the part about moving away from cash. There has been this push lately by well known academics and some main stream economists of an idea that cash is somehow detrimental to the economy. Beyond the privacy implications and the affect this would have on people who are in the low income segment of society and those who are un-banked, I really don't get it and I think it's driven by the need to try and get creative about monetary policy. I suppose with a cashless society you could technically also move to a completely consumption based taxation system, but this idea runs contrary to the idea of trying to get people to spend money since tax liability would be proportional to how much of your income you spend. It's also difficult to accept the proposition that trying to force people to spend money and increase consumption will improve the economy in a real and long lasting way, when it is savings and investment that drive the real economy. This is my main issue with an extended period of ZIRP or NIRP. No one is inclined to save anything and so investment is funded by further periods of monetary expansion. (And for everyone who is going to say something about the identity S=I, I know, I completely bastardized it and technically it's only true for closed economies but the point still holds the same, savings are important to a having a good economy.)