16 ms·
I think that becoming the most profitable company in the world has negatively impacted Apple, at least how I view them. I wrote the chess program given away fr
by mark_l_watson 12y ago
I think that becoming the most profitable company in the world has negatively impacted Apple, at least how I view them.
I wrote the chess program given away free with the early Apple IIs, made some good money on a Mac app in 1984, and until recently favored Mac laptops: a fan boy. That is changing. I bought an incredibly cheap and underpowered Windows 8.1 laptop in January (HP Stream 11) for $199 and like it quite a lot. I plan on getting either a Surface 3 or Surface 3 Pro soon, and will put my old MB Air on the shelf next to my Linux laptop to be used just as needed.
Microsoft seems to be heading in a good direction, Apple less so. Things like living in a web browser and a platform neutral IDE (I use IntelliJ for Clojure, Java, Python, PHP, and Ruby) make OS platform less impactful on using a computer. I am looking at Surface 3 Pros and Surface 3s, price and feature wise, vs. Apple products and I find Apple losing ground. The comparison is especially bad for Apple re: cloud services: Office 365 is such a good deal for $100/year compared to iCloud, with way more and better services.
As software engineers, money for hardware, software, and cloud services might not mean much, but I think it is good to look at what the general public will be using.
- javajosh 12y agoI've not heard of people running IntelliJ on a Surface. I'd be curious to know how well that works.
- schandur 12y agoI have some complaints on the Surface Pro 2, but mostly related to the TypeCover keyboard. Haven't played with SP3.
- scott_karana 12y agoSorry, I've gotta say: you know that things like "SP3" in Microsoft-land typically mean "Service Pack", right? It's so easy to get confused in acronym-city already, shouldn't we avoid creating more? :(
- mark_l_watson 12y agoWith the keyboard, it is just a Windows machine - it should be fine, but thanks: I will do some research.
- Encosia 12y agoI run Visual Studio and Web/PhpStorm (essentially built on IntelliJ, I think?) on a Surface Pro 3 often. Mine's an i7 with 8gb RAM. More powerful than the 13" Ultrabook I replaced with it, and much more powerful than the MacBook I was using before the Ultrabook.
- pistle 12y agoI have felt no pain on my i5 Surface Pro 3. It outperforms the decent rig my office provides. I run multiple instances of VS, leave stuff open all the time, massive Chrome tab abuse... The fans only come on while streaming video AND compiling, etc. It doesn't hiccup or grunt. I wasn't 100% sold on the price/value ratio when I bought it, but now am totally happy I did. Great machine.
- Stately 12y agoI developed on Android with IntellIJ IDEA and an awesome Surface Pro 2 for almost a year, until a move to a new job made me switch to a MacBook Air. Amazing, amazing little thing.
- DAllison 12y agoRunning Android Studio and VS2015 side by side with no hardware problems (development-wise) on my Surface Pro 2. (Being honest, Chrome's significantly more of a resource hog than the two combined). My only problem was an incompatibility with a specific virtualisation technology in the Surface to reduce boot time and Intel HAXM. There's also a problem with bluetooth lag/packet loss when maxing out the WiFi. I'm running an Apple Bluetooth keyboard and generic bluetooth mouse when I work from home, Type cover on the go. The Type cover is terrible for the price, but it's an OK keyboard. The touchpad leaves much to be desired.
- ryanSrich 12y agoUntil an OS comes along that rivals OSX, I'll stick with Apple. I'm one of the few people I know that really doesn't put a whole lot of thought into hardware. Yes I need my machine to run properly but as long as there's a baseline achievement of performance I'm good. Obviously I'd never be able to give up OSX for work purposes. Pretty much every piece of software I use is tied to OSX only.
- pedalpete 12y agoWhat software are you using that is only on Mac? I'm surprised by this, as it seems most development software is available for all platforms these days.
- grimgrin 12y agoThis is from a dev standpoint but at my job we're using MySQL and I develop from Linux. When I want to browse or modify data with a GUI nothing quite matches OS X's Sequel Pro. The best I've found is DBeaver (or SQuirrel). IntelliJ is working on a thing called 0xDBE, but it feels even worse. I could easily rattle off a handful of other applications that just feel better, even if slightly, on OS X. DaisyDisk and Transmit come to mind right away.
- rebelnz 12y agoTry MySQL Workbench - this is what I miss the most after switching to Postgres
- cwyers 12y agoI've never used Sequel Pro so I can't compare them, but I've been very happy with SQLyog, when I was working with MySQL.
- ChristianGeek 12y agoI'm a dev that uses Windows at work for development and the Mac at home for development and at work for general use. I've been a Mac devotee since 1984. For an IDE nothing beats the sheer joy of Visual Studio and ReSharper. I use NetBeans for Java (I prefer it over Eclipse and IntelliJ). For MySQL I use Sequel Pro on the Mac but prefer HeidiSQL on Windows. For Linux dev work I'll spin up a VM on Fusion on the Mac or VirtualBox on either. My point? There's nothing you listed that requires you to use a Mac. I completely understand if you choose to, but there's no need to discount Windows in the process...it's a great development environment for anything but Swift and Objective-C.
- csomar 12y agoFor general consumers, Microsoft is catching up. But Apple never really gained marketshare there because of its high prices. For Professionals, (especially software developers), I don't think so. OS X is still very superior to Windows. And the apps on OS X makes it worthwhile.
- tomc1985 12y agoIdunno, after running a MBP for almost five years, IMO Windows software is better. Most of it's not very pretty, but in terms of pound-for-pound productivity shortcuts and features-in-general, Windows designers/programmers seem to favor productivity over cheesy gimmicks (or, this contemptible trend of data sparsity)
- pedalpete 12y agoI work for a medium sized technology organisation (about 400 people) and lately you hear more and more developers talking about moving away from Mac. Most are going to linux some are picking up windows. I'd say it's about a 80-20 split. The thing I really notice is how everybody with a mac has a machine that is newer than two years. Those who are hitting the two year mark are experiencing hardware issues, particularly lighting, which is needed for dexternal montitors, but it seems trackpad longevity is also an issue. For most of us, the apps on OS X are also available on other platforms. The only thing I can't get on Windows that mac devs get is Sketch, but the designers post on invision anyway, so it isn't a huge loss.
- tjl 12y agoI have a laptop from mid-2009 that's still good (it's a white MacBook). The only problem I've had has been the battery bulging and Apple replaced them under Applecare with no problems. The last I had replaced out of warranty for no charge. It's slow, but everything still works. I used it for my main machine until late 2012 (when I bought an i7 Mac Mini) and was my portable machine until late 2013. My Mac Mini has been pretty heavily used since 2012. Everyone in my department at the university who switched to a Mac has had good longevity, most lasting about 4-5 years until they decide they want a new machine (but the Mac still works). I had two Mac Minis in the lab, one a G4 Mac Mini from 2002 and the other a first-gen Intel Mac Mini (it came with 10.4, I don't recall the year). I used the Intel Mac Mini until I graduated in 2013 and had no problems at all. So, anecdotes are just that. My department consistently has been moving to OS X. Probably about half the professors have switched when there was just 1 professor who used it in 2007. Even my supervisor didn't switch until about 2010. He's still using the same iMac he bought then. The labs mostly use Windows because of the data acquisition software only runs on it as they tend to have specialized equipment that only wrote Windows drivers.
- api 12y agoOne thought I had about MS as a development machine a while back: If you want your Unix toolchains for development, you could still have them. The Surface Pro is powerful enough to run Linux in Vagrant or another virtualization engine. So you could just run a virtual dev environment. Virtual environments are sometimes better anyway, since you can replicate your operational infrastructure. Windows 10 is looking good. If it gets really, really good they might close the gap with Apple for professional users. Their glastnost/perestroika trend of opening up and embracing the dev community isn't hurting their reputation either. I really think Satya Nadella is turning the company around.
- lukeschlather 12y agoI really hate using WinSCP for file transfer between Windows and the guest OS. If Windows shipped with a native sshfs-alike, I'd probably be ok, but I really prefer native Ubuntu development.
- zmmmmm 12y agoThere are lots of alternative solutions to share file systems between a VM and host ... is that all you're trying to solve? VirtualBox has it built in.
- lukeschlather 12y agoNo, I'm also trying to share between my laptop and a remote server. (actually, I very rarely use VMs hosted locally)
- Steko 12y ago> I think it is good to look at what the general public will be using. The general public really isn't using Office 365 or Surface 3 though.
- dade_ 12y agoMy Surface 3 Pro is my go to, take with me device. I always know I have everything I need, whereas I obviously don't with my iPad. Hopefully the next Surface Pro will have a longer battery life, it is still a few hours short. I recently started using the Windows Chocolately package manager, strange name, but works great and makes setting up a new machine and maintaining utilities much more simple.
- ghuntley 12y agoChocolately + Boxstarter = ./build.sh To build my work environment on a brand new install all I have to do is Start -> Run -> https://boxstarter.org/package/nr/url?https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ghuntley/dotfiles-windows/master/desktop.boxstarter https://boxstarter.org/package/nr/url?https://raw.githubuser... as administrator. See the following repo for more information https://github.com/ghuntley/dotfiles-windows/blob/master/desktop.boxstarter https://github.com/ghuntley/dotfiles-windows/blob/master/des...
- Zarel 12y ago> Things like living in a web browser and a platform neutral IDE (I use IntelliJ for Clojure, Java, Python, PHP, and Ruby) make OS platform less impactful on using a computer. Really? I'd think this would make the remaining things matter more. Things like: - International text input: in OS X, out of the box, é is opt+e, e (or the now even easier: hold down e and choose é from the menu). In Windows, é is alt+0233 or something, or change your keyboard layout and relearn how to type apostrophes. Everything else related to international text input is also much nicer in OS X. - Trackpad quality: I've yet to find a trackpad as nice as the ones that come on Mac laptops - emacs keybindings in every text box! Anyone? ...Anyone? Maybe it's just me.
- wodenokoto 12y agoI have never even heard of the emacs things. Can you explain further?
- chadzawistowski 12y agoMany OS X keyboard shortcuts are Emacs-inspired, though they aren't extensible in the way that Emacs is. http://www.cultofmac.com/247681/use-these-emacs-legacy-keyboard-shortcuts-to-move-around-in-your-text-files-os-x-tips/ http://www.cultofmac.com/247681/use-these-emacs-legacy-keybo...
- redacted 12y agoYou can extend them actually: http://osxnotes.net/keybindings.html http://osxnotes.net/keybindings.html
- sjm 12y agoNot just you — love the Emacs bindings everywhere. It always throws me off on Windows when I'm trying to C-n and C-p around, getting hit with new document and printing dialogs all over the place :)
- waterhouse 12y ago
- vinceyuan 12y agoMicrosoft is heading in a good direction. I do like Surface 3 and 3 Pro. But the battery life of Windows laptops (including Surface) is still not good enough. We have to admit Apple does well in Macbook's battery life.
- Tiksi 12y agoIf you're looking for battery life, it'd be worth it to look into the thinkpad x250. It claims to have a 20 hour charge, and real world tests [0] stand by that claim. [0] http://www.wsj.com/articles/the-two-day-laptop-battery-is-here-1421779300 http://www.wsj.com/articles/the-two-day-laptop-battery-is-he...
- marincounty 12y agoMy gripe with Apple is all these Operating system upgrades in iOS and OS X. I understand the need to change, and security is of utmost importance, but don't alienate your customer base with OS's that need hours of tweaking, and then you still have programs that don't work, and missing files. I can't imagine Steve Jobs would be running the ship this way. Are their products still the best-- yes, but the margin is closing in my little world.
- pXMzR2A 12y ago> Office 365 is such a good deal for $100/year compared to iCloud o_O Was the whole post in a sarcastic tone, or just this part? Serious question.
- fatratchet 12y agoOffice 365 for $100/year is the 5 license pack, that gives you 5 accounts with each 10TB onedrive storage + desktop office licenses + all the office online stuff. You can get the 5 pack on amazon for $70. I personally think that's way better than iCloud although I mainly bought it for storage, because if you need more than 1TB that becomes by far the cheapest available option. Not sure how the extra services from iCloud and office365 compare, don't use either all that much, but both seem kinda equal and lacking compared to google or dropbox. So I'd certainly call that a nice deal.
- dba7dba 12y agoI think it's called Victory Disease. When you think you have been winning all the time and it will continue, your way of thinking becomes polluted, less clear, biased, slow etc.
- donkeyd 12y agoEvery time I update Windows, or even restart my windows laptop I hope that it'll still work afterwards. Updating has previously killed my dedicated graphics card, which turned out to be a driver issue. With Intel providing 2 nearly identical drivers one of which kills it. A while ago the fingerprint reader just stopped working after a restart. After a full hour of debugging and restarting I gave up. The next day I figured I'd try one of my debugging steps again and it started working again. On my Mac, the worst that ever happened was a corrupted HDD. Booted into recovery, used disk utility to find and fix the problem and never had issues again. Also, dat touchpad, nothing competes...
- izacus 12y agoOn the other hand, updating my Mac to Yosemite turned it into a slow stuttering mess - WindowServer memory leak forced me to reboot the Mac about every two hours or so or watch my desktop at < 1fps. While Windows does have problems, latest Apple software is mostly worse bug and update-wise.
- reustle 12y agoThese kinds of issues are why I always suggest people do fresh installs of operating systems, and not upgrades.
- calgoo 12y agoI get similar memory leaks with WindowServer on a brand new macbook pro. The damn process is eating 4gb of ram sometimes...
- thesagan 12y agoI did a fresh install from a seemingly healthy, semi-recent MBP and Yosemite's WindowServer seemed to begin a slow strangulation on my machine. Solved it by buying a top-of-the-line machine, which I'm sure Apple is loving.
- jawngee 12y ago
- baddox 12y agoInterestingly, the increasing role of the web and other platform-neutral software has pushed me toward Apple products. I now care much less about the massive amount of software written only for Windows, so I'd rather just buy the Apple product that I know is going to be a reasonably solid experience from purchasing, to updating, to customer support if necessary, to even selling when I upgrade.
- netcan 12y agoI'm not really a fanboy, so maybe my expectations are lower. I think Apple are doing a good job. I admire what I think of as Apple's unique quality: the product/marketing/tech strategy. Apple insist on charging a premium. In addition they prefer to play the above median range of the market. Apart from first-to-market "freebies" they don't play for dominant market share. They insist on that premium, at the expense of market share and other trade-offs. They don't play for check box ticking. They don't adjust to appeal to mobile service companies, IT purchasing departments or other buyers that make decisions about what other people will use. IE, it's not corporate sales departments dictating strategy according based on short term sales. In order to get their premium they make stuff appealing enough to a subset of people that they are willing to spend their own money, pay that premium and get the thing that they decided they want for themselves. To make a stretched, contrived and over-complimentary analogy.. It's like a politician who wants to convince the voting public to join him in his position vs a politician that checks the polls to find out what his positions are. Like I said, I don't have that much loyalty to Apple. I don't buy iphones because androids @ half the price are pretty good. I'd be interested if Apple puts out a laptop with a sub €500 price, but I'm not cranky if they don't have one. When they do happen to have a product that I buy for whatever reason, I'm usually on the fence mostly because of price but fairly well impressed once if I buy it. But….I suspect the €1000+ laptop market is going to keep shrinking, and it's getting harder to justify buying a macbook. I still expect to get years out of the one I have, but I wouldn't be surprised if I opt for a €200 something when the time comes. Unless… Apple happens to be making something I'm willing to pay extra for at the time.
- dagw 12y agoI suspect the €1000+ laptop market is going to keep shrinking Possibly, But the high end laptop mark is eating into the workstation market from the bottom now that 32GB and and decent Quadro cards are common in laptops. At work basically all our CAD and 3D modelling people use laptops, whereas a few years ago they all had workstations. Same seems to be happening with video and music production. Even more and more of the gamers I know are option for laptops over desktop computers.
- pjmlp 12y ago
- lloeki 12y ago> That is changing Recently I challenged myself to learn more about USB, HID devices and kernel development, so I partially reverse engineered and wrote a driver for the Xbox One controller. This is great and all, but it needs to be signed for people to use it without lowering a level of defense. Turns out you don't just need to be an Apple Developer, you also need to make a special request and regenerate your certificate, which needs to have a special extension, else it'll be rejected by the kernel signing system. Not the least worried I pony up 99€ (not a dev), submit a request, and an automated mail tells me I'll have a reply under 7-10 business days. So I wait 2 months, and, slightly worried since I have no reply yet, I submit again. That was 13 days ago[0]. I used to think that GateKeeper was great technology and that things will be okay. Now I have doubts: does Apple really care about its developers? How long before the kext-dev-mode boot arg disappears and kernel space becomes inaccessible to mortals? [0]: https://github.com/lloeki/xbox_one_controller/issues/2 https://github.com/lloeki/xbox_one_controller/issues/2
- Joeri 12y agoI think it's not just that the dev backdoors will go away, I think the whole OS is going away. It's pretty obvious to me that in the long run only iOS will remain. It makes zero sense to keep two semi incompatible operating systems around, and it's just the sort of radical move apple would do. Yes, there are a gazillion reasons to keep OS X around, but knowing apple none of them will matter enough.
- extc 12y agoMe from 4.5 years ago agrees: http://mattshaw.org/news/apples-dumbing-down-of-computers-a-k-a-the-end-of-super-user-computers/ http://mattshaw.org/news/apples-dumbing-down-of-computers-a-...
- task_queue 12y agoI believe this is similar to Microsoft's driver model, where at the end of the day, they decide what's signed or not and thus what can hook into the kernel. Stallman was prescient.
- pjmlp 12y agoAfter I became more focused in the Java and .NET world, the OS started to matter less to me. Same would apply to most modern programming stacks that come with batteries. Given that I used to like Windows, before getting into the UNIX world. As it was huge improvement over plain *-DOS for someone with Amiga envy. Going back wasn't a big deal specially given the Windows office requirements. I enjoy playing with Macs since the LC days at the university, but always was put off by the hardware combination that was given at their price range. For me the GPU/CPU combo is quite important.
- amelius 12y ago> Microsoft seems to be heading in a good direction, Apple less so. Just have a look at the enormous amount of open research available at http://research.microsoft.com http://research.microsoft.com and try to find the equivalent of Apple. That tells me enough.
- marincounty 12y agoI was afraid of what might happen to Apple after Steve Job's death. He said Tim wasn't a gadget guy. I am trying to give Apple a lot of grieving room, but enough is enough. I'm particularly irritated because I'm having OS X and iOS problems simultaneously. I'm actually so impressed with Microsoft lately, I'm thinking of putting all my meager savings on their stock. This is coming from a guy who literally thought Microsoft was evil.
- rappr 12y agoNothing new there. Microsoft has always been very open their research, and Apple hasn't. They prefer to talk about products they will actually ship vs. things that might happen at some point in the future.
- ap22213 12y agoWhy not use your Linux laptop more? About 6 months ago, I installed Linux Mint on my Lenovo laptop, and I have barely looked at my MBP since.
- roma1n 12y agoJust out of curiosity: is using IntelliJ on the HP Stream a good experience? Considering a similar purchase (chromebook C720p) but afraid of performance issues...
- deveac 12y ago>Microsoft seems to be heading in a good direction, Apple less so. Things like living in a web browser and a platform neutral IDE (I use IntelliJ for Clojure, Java, Python, PHP, and Ruby) make OS platform less impactful on using a computer. I am looking at Surface 3 Pros and Surface 3s, price and feature wise, vs. Apple products and I find Apple losing ground. To keep this on the rails, I have to wonder exactly how much Apple has paid out to developers on the iOS platform vs Microsoft on their mobile platform. The very first reason the author of the linked article cited for his decision to pull out was competition, which combined with having the largest payouts by a large margin speaks to the health of the platform imho. Native vs. web apps has been debated endlessly, but the doomsday scenario for Apple's approach has which has been trumpeted for many years now has conclusively not come to pass. I suppose if you extend the time horizon out to some Nth degree that may change, but what has Apple been doing in the meantime? Making a ton of money and paying a ton of money to developers.