13 ms·
So Your Company Has Been Found Using Alex’s Photographs Without Permission
- FreakyT 12y agoI can see the guy's point, but at the same time, I found the tone of the write-up to be unbearably smug. Evidently the law is on his side, but reading the way this page is written makes me wish that it weren't.
- ceejayoz 12y agoI'd go with weary over unbearably smug.
- FooBarWidget 12y agoYour response comes over like a false sense of entitlement. "It’s just a photo! Surely a photo can’t be worth that much." I can't believe people would actually think that after having obviously done something wrong.
- noobermin 12y agoIt's hard. When something is easy to reproduce, it's easier for humans to devalue it. "It's just a photo/mp3/movie/tv-show"... The problem is while things like oil and food and human labor are physically scare, information is not, and not because that information was easy to initially create, but just as a matter of fact, it is terribly easy to reproduce. It might have more to do with psychology than anything.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> while things like oil and food and human labor are physically scare, information is not It's hard to value something that isn't scarce.
- mentat 12y agoIt is not easy to reproduce capturing beauty. If the product is information than any random bits will do. What we care about is aesthetic bits, which his is the provider of.
- noobermin 12y agoLook, for most people here, we understand that something like the linux kernel took decades of man hours, if not a century by now. However, it's trivially easy to copy the result of those years of effort, even if the initial effort wasn't that easy, as I hint in my post. It turns out that such copying is legal and desired by the original authors, as it is much easier for them than it is for artist; still, it is a fact that the product is easy to reproduce while the act is not. This is at the heart of this whole conflict between the content-creators and the content-consumers today. The matter of fact is that artificial[0] constraints on the product of such creations are the best method we have developed to ensure that the creators continue to be paid for their work, and I'm not sure of another, feasible way. Things like generous benefactors, be them individuals, institutions, or governments, are too few and not with enough capital to support enough creators without selling their products. If anyone has a better idea, they could revolution history forever. Apart from Copyrights, Trademarks, and Patents, however, I know of no other way that will work. [0]when I say artificial, I am speak matter-of-factly, not to offend anyone. The interesting thing is such talent and experience needed to produce such works is scarce, it's just the product isn't.
- TheOtherHobbes 12y ago>The product is easy to reproduce while the act is not. The act is getting easier and easier to reproduce, up to a certain basic level - which seems to be good enough for commercial purposes. The arts have seen an unbelievable explosion of activity. There are more people writing, making art and music, taking photos, creating code, and everything else besides, than ever before - not just by a little, but by an astronomical amount. The problem is that most of the work is eh-okay. Average-and-worse mediocrity is very easy to fine. Basic entertaining competence is less common, but still not rare. And that seems to be all most consumers want - hence the success of 50 Shades of Grey, Twilight, and the rest, and their equivalents in other media. In the past, culture was good at distilling out the extreme talent, so historically the arts have amassed a fine collection of game-changing geniuses, while allowing the eh-okay creators to drop into oblivion. It's Salieri vs Mozart - commercially Mozart was the loser while alive, but not so much a few centuries later. Today it's harder to find a Mozart because the modern equivalent is probably working for an ad agency, and has limited time to produce truly game-changing genius-level work. And it might not sell anyway. And it would probably get lost in the noise even if it did sell. The answer is probably the much-discussed living wage. Let everyone who wants to make art get on with making art full time, without having to worry about starving or being homeless. Most of it will suck, some of it will be okay, a little of it will be jaw-droppingly awesome. tl:dr; It's the socially-enforced dogma that art exists primarily for profit that causes the problems. Get rid of that, and a lot of the issues go away.
- gutnor 12y agoNo - on HN it should not be hard. We may be smug about it and criticise his business model, saying "he should give his image for free and charge for making custom picture or work for the BBC or another imaginary plan based on whatever works in our field". But that should not be difficult for us to understand the value and the work there is behind a single picture. That's too similar to making a small fortune writing code which is what most of us are doing here.
- nathanb 12y agoI didn't interpret the tone as smugness so much as someone who's tired of having people illegally use his images and then try to argue with him about it.
- leothekim 12y agoHe doesn't want you to take his position personally. He does want you to pay for using his work, and gives plenty of reasonable justification why. If he's coming off as smug, then I imagine it's because he's dealt with people/entities that feel that infringing his work is a benign act when it takes a big financial toll on him.
- PeterWhittaker 12y agoI liked the tone: "just the facts, ma'am" simply doesn't work in this case, mostly because of the tone of the questions - which is 100% accurate. His answers may be a little snarky and sarcastic, but the questions he is answering properly represent the attitude and tone of the people who use creative work without permission.
- psychometry 12y agoNot nearly as smug as the person who thinks creative works are easy to create and thus should be free.
- jorts 12y agoI'm sympathetic to his cause. Imagine having your work stolen and having to deal with this for years. It would be very disheartening work. It looks like he's trying to only go after those that are using his images to make money. If that's the case, they most certainly should pay for the service that he has provided.
- Arnor 12y agoI disagree but don't understand why you were down voted... it seems that others disagree and think that's who they should express themselves. Maybe they are smug?
- dietrichepp 12y agoCriticizing tone is one of the least productive ways to engage with an idea. It doesn't address the idea itself, and perception of tone is very subjective, so it stimulates an exchange of opinions, which is not what we want to read in the HN comments. Refer to DH2 in "How to Disagree" by Paul Graham (2008) http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html (not that this is a disagreement... but the article is still relevant)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Arnor 12y agoPerhaps the commenter I replied to above wasn't interested in engaging with the idea. Maybe he just wanted to express his displeasure with the tone. Not every interaction is going to be the type of interaction you expect (i.e. "engaging with an idea"). Sometimes, critiques of written works have to do with the tone. There is nothing wrong with that. The reason that comment got down voted and the reason I got down voted had nothing to do with PG'S 2008 post. It had everything to do with an abrasive community... Yet, as my old man used to say, "Never wrestle with pigs. You both get dirty and only the pigs like it." So it is on HN... QED Turtles all the way down.
- michaelbiven 12y agoHis tone doesn't even come off even as just barely smug. My take has been people who work with code build up a view of copyright that is completely biased by the way open source model works. A model where sharing everything benefits your peers, because most people using open source will generally make their living off of products or services that are built using those tools. The end result of photography is not a tool, it is an original creative work that is how professional photogrpahers make their living. Besides the very limited scope of fair use there is no general benefit for the community to be able to freely use the creative works of others who have licensed that work as All Rights Reserved other than to be a cheapskate.
- anigbrowl 12y agoI don't find it smug at all. I work in film, and whether I'm on set or writing a screenplay I make my business to know my responsibilities in regards to other people's copyrights and trademarks. And this is at the low-budget end, I don't collect a fat salary for rubber-stamping clearance forms or anything like that. I do the research, I write and ask for permission or information about authorship, and if I don't the reply I hoped for then I shelve the idea or rethink it. As a creator, I have a responsibility to treat the creative work of others with the same respect that I would like them to treat mine. Yes, it's often tedious and frustrating, and involves hours of work that I'd rather spend writing or photographing new material. On the other hand, I don't live in fear of demand letters.
- tjradcliffe 12y agoIt is well-known and well-documented that our ability to infer tone from electronic communications is poor, so your chances of being correct in judging his tone are not much over 50%: http://www.entrepreneur.com/article/239121 http://www.entrepreneur.com/article/239121 That's better than chance, but not really enough to pass judgment on someone. This may be why you have been downvoted. It may also be that others read his tone (with 56% accuracy) differently. The tone of this message is meant to be neutral and informative.
- bdcravens 12y agoIt came off as explicit, not smug.
- timus83 12y agoman, who cares?
- antidaily 12y agoAs a woman, which I am not, I resent your assumption that I'm a man.
- wlesieutre 12y agoAlex Wild's copyright infringement story on Ars Technica a few months ago provides some helpful context to the linked page. http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/09/one-mans-endless-hopeless-struggle-to-protect-his-copyrighted-images/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/09/one-mans-endless-...
- 2close4comfort 12y agoThis is the perspective you need to read that original post Thanks!
- mherdeg 12y agoWhile his article talks about "commercial infringement", his FAQ doesn't say that he's restricting his suits to people who are using his work commercially, which is really interesting. In principle he could be suing a lot of people, which is great for him and a great way to subsidize an unusual and interesting creative endeavor. I assume that Wild has registered copyright on all his works so that his firm can sue for statutory damages (easy) rather than actual damages (harder to prove). Suppose Wild is reading Quora answers about insects and notices that someone has left a comment where they pasted in a photo from his Web site. Super easy to do. Also super easy for him to send an e-mail to his copyright contractor, and a free $750 (minimum) in statutory damages. I have registered copyright on works before, very straightforward, opens some unusual opportunities. There's actually a great startup idea here: (1) Create a large quantity of high-quality unwatermarked stock images. (2) Register copyright on each work. (3) Sell them on a web site and use search-engine marketing tactics to make it a really high ranking Web site. (4) Wait 2.9 years, then sue every Web site and user who picked up the images.
- comex 12y agoThe FAQ, in fact, says something very similar to what you claim it doesn't say: > If the infringement appears on a personal blog, forum, or web page, I usually ignore it. If I have time, which I generally don’t, I may issue a takedown notice to remove infringing copies from personal sites most likely to feed downstream infringements. If the infringement occurs on a corporate or organizational webpage, product, broadcast, or similar, even if it is just a small internal image, I generally submit it to ImageRights.
- Throwaway1224 12y agoI'm curious how much of his revenue is driven through the usual channels and how much of his revenue is driven through recouping the illegal copies. Don't get me wrong, I'm NOT saying it would be wrong if 99% of his revenue was driven through legal action. I'm more curious what the balance is.
- jakejake 12y agoI can feel in this post the years of dealing with people nicely, only to have them treat you as if you are the bad guy. I've had people send nasty emails after I moved or got rid of an image that they were hotlinking. People have called me all sorts of ugly names because a free app that I wrote didn't have a feature they need. People have posted nasty stuff because I didn't provide them phone support at 3am for a GPL open source utility that I released. All this because I can't always manage to reply to people needing support for my free-time projects. I'm sure a lot of you here have known the same type of treatment.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> People have posted nasty stuff because I didn't provide them phone support at 3am for a GPL open source utility that I released. WHAT!?
- jakejake 12y agoThey were in another country where it presumably was business hours. I had one guy literally stalk me until he found a DNS registration with my phone number (will never make that mistake again)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- chx 12y agoI do not have a phone any more, all phone calls go to voicemail and I will call you back if I want and when I want (over Voice-over-IP for free). Texts go through the two way email gateway at Anveo.
- cpb 12y agoGo on...
- toomuchtodo 12y agoI just wanted to say thanks for this idea. I'm porting my old cell number to Twilio, sending all calls through Google Voice to get voicemail emails with transcription (Twilio charges extra for transcription), and getting a new number with no voice service through T-Mobile.
- bobhankson 12y agoI think we can all agree though, holy shit this guy has some amazing photos. If ever photos deserved a license, this is it!
- nfoz 12y agoAnother point of view: the more amazing they are, the more important it is that they are in the public domain, as it would be a valuable asset for the commons.
- slantedview 12y agoCommons or not, the guy still needs to make a living.
- nfoz 12y agoIt seems that he is (or, used to be) making a living from a specific business model that only exists because it is upheld by copyright law. I am of the opinion that copyright law should be (slowly, responsibly) abolished. As long as people have a need for photographs, we will fund their development.
- tptacek 12y agoThe overwhelming majority of HN users make their living in another business model that only exists because of copyright law.
- yellowapple 12y agoThat would've been more true 10 years ago. Now, the overwhelming majority of HN users make their living in yet another business model that exists increasingly because of the relative obsolescence of the previous business model - namely, by shifting into the $foo-as-a-service realm.
- 12y ago
- smoyer 12y agoI actually like the no-nonsense nature of this page. It would be even better if Alex profited more in the long run (he's got amazing images) and if less was going to support the legal system that created the copyright mess in the first place. One step at a time I guess!
- DanBlake 12y agoWhat was the result of the lawsuit v orkin? Doesn't show any of the details / payout
- scott_karana 12y agoIt was filed last December, so maybe it wasn't resolved yet?
- mattbgates 12y agoOn a bright note, you take gorgeous photography and I agree with you.. at least get your written permission to use, and if you don't want someone to use them, than its yours only.
- bthomas 12y agoHow much are the infringement letters demanding? $200 for a $100 photo is totally reasonable; $1000 and he has no moral argument.
- kevan 12y ago$200 probably wouldn't cover lawyers fees. From an amoral perspective, there's a simple cost function: (cost to buy) vs (chance of being caught * cost of damages). If you don't make the cost of damages high enough then the behavior will continue. [0] [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punitive_damages http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punitive_damages
- nav1 12y agoYes he does. Dealing with copyright infringement can be very expensive and time consuming.
- diminoten 12y agoLegal fees are likely more than $100 per image, so I imagine he's asking for licensing fee + legal fees + deterrent fee. So probably closer to $1000, if not more. Also, who said anything about morality? This is law, not philosophy. We're firmly planted on the 'is' side of 'is/ought', at this point.
- atourgates 12y ago> $200 for a $100 photo is totally reasonable; $1000 and he has no moral argument. How do you figure? I think 10x is an entirely reasonable penalty for stealing* someone's work instead of paying for it lawfully. The MPAA demanded $30,000 for a $0.99 song, which I would say is completely unreasonable. But 10x seems pretty inline with a non-excessive penalty.
- mckoss 12y ago>>> Our government’s copyright enforcement framework treats infringements as civil matters that generally require legal counsel. I wish it did! Most infringement of a commercial work seems to incur criminal penalties (though you can recover civil damages as well). http://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap5.html http://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap5.html
- tptacek 12y agoThough there's wiggle room in the statute, the USG has two bars to clear in order to criminally prosecute the misuse of a copyrighted photo as a promotional device for a business: * The infringement must be not only intentional but willful, which implies not only that the infringer deliberately used the photograph, but did so with full awareness of their duties under copyright law; that's a higher bar than simple intent. * To be a felony, the infringement must not only have a goal of commercial advantage or private gain, but that advantage itself must be with respect to the reproduction and/or distribution rights of the original author. If you deliberately harvested this guy's bug pictures and resold them, you'd be easy to charge criminally. But slapping one of his pictures on your website is probably too fuzzy to charge criminally.
- harshreality 12y agoI don't believe there does have to be advantage/gain, if the retail value of the work exceeds $1_000. [1] He seems to be taking a very reasonable tact by going after genuinely commercial abusers, if his description is correct. [1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/506 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/506
- tptacek 12y agoFrom the DOJ Criminal Resource Manual: There are four essential elements to a charge of criminal copyright infringement. In order to sustain a conviction under section 506(a), the government must demonstrate: (1) that a valid copyright; (2) was infringed by the defendant; (3) willfully; and (4) for purposes of commercial advantage or private financial gain. The language in (4) is actually the subject of a good deal of discussion, because it changed (to that) relatively recently.
- slyall 12y agoIf you want more Public Domain images of insects out there I'd suggest donating to the "Insects Unlocked" project. It is raising money on Utexas' kickstarter clone "HornRaiser". https://hornraiser.utexas.edu/project/54e79bbc14bdf7205ddd5ab7 https://hornraiser.utexas.edu/project/54e79bbc14bdf7205ddd5a...
- ezequiel-garzon 12y agoIt is worth noting that the author, Alex Wild, is also the mentor of the project you mention. He discussed [1] a day before the impact of the project on professional photographers. [1] "Will The Insects Unlocked Project Damage The Commercial Insect Photo Market?" - http://www.myrmecos.net/2015/03/27/will-the-insects-unlocked-project-damage-the-commercial-insect-photo-market/ http://www.myrmecos.net/2015/03/27/will-the-insects-unlocked...
- slyall 12y agoGood catch. I had completely missed the link.
- scotty79 12y agoPlease stop polluting public space with proprietary images. If you don't want to share keep them in your drawer. It's immoral to use the reputation boost internet provides without accepting that people will share your work. To downvoters: If copyright lawyers can manufacture morality and play on lowest instincts ("mine! go away!") so can everybody else ("stop limiting my freedom!"). On more serious note every resource that is copyrighted should carry plainly visible note about like warrnings on cigarette packs so mildly creative people can stay away from it.
- adventured 12y agoYou've got that backwards, nearly the entire Internet is private space, with specific terms & conditions for being allowed to use said private space.
- scotty79 12y agoI'd argue that much of the internet consists of minds of people who browse, communicate and share. Private are most of the pipes, low level and high level (like Facebook but not torrent).
- tptacek 12y agoFrom the author: Of all the varieties of infringement-related comments, the “stay off the Internet” refrains are the most toxic. In one go they both acknowledge that infringement is bad for artists while also showing no concern for the Internet, which would be poorer for their absence. “Don’t post it” is the ultimate nihilistic diss.
- iaw 12y agoI think a lot of people conflate the rent-seeking behaviors of the larger media conglomerates that acquire licenses to creative works with the monetization seeking behaviors of small-time content creators.
- throwaway9324 12y agoIt's not a "diss" though, but a legitimate opinion on copyright which is found both in discourse and in law. Just because the author is opinionated and throws around rhetoric emotional words like "toxic" and "nihilistic" doesn't make his opinions any more supported.
- borgia 12y agoVery reasonable all in all, and it's pretty clear that he's damn tired of people's antics with regards to using his work without license and then going on the defensive about it when caught. Some people's sense of entitlement to creative, but easily replicated, works never ceases to amaze me. Whether you like Tidal and those involved or not, this week we saw its launch being met with backlash online that included comments that amounted to "Why would I pay $20 a month for this when I can torrent it free?". People acted indignant over being asked to maybe pay for some of the works they consume. As though they had a right to have a copy of the works simply because they were technologically capable of getting their hands on one without paying for it. And then creators and artists are vilified for going after those who steal/distribute copies of their works. I can't imagine how stressful it is for those who have to deal with these constants acts against them.
- williamcotton 12y agoI think a lot of the backlash against Tidal was the way it was presented. Having all of these rich and famous musicians complaining about how they're not making enough money isn't going to go very well with the general population. What does Tidal do to help unknown and struggling musicians? The whole thing seems to only really be about protecting the revenue streams of the musical elite.
- borgia 12y agoI'm not defending Tidal, I personally think it's a cringe-worthy joke at best and I hope the worst for it. It's the attitude that was on display regarding it though and it's the same attitude seen previously when Spotify was launched i.e. I want this for free, I believe I'm entitled to this for free and I will get it for free regardless of how you, the artist and distributor, feel about it. Musicians, etc. produce products, as any other non-service based industry does, and nobody is entitled to those products for free...yet because these are digital products a large amount of people seem to think otherwise.
- williamcotton 12y ago
- nsnick 12y agoNo one can ever arrange bits in that order because I was the first one to do it.
- s73v3r 12y agoYou're making it sound like there was no effort that went into capturing that image.
- icebraining 12y agoWell, for copyright, it doesn't actually matter anyway.
- bdcravens 12y agoAre you implying that the photographer's digital assets aren't being used, but that the alleged infringers somehow recreated the bits and the fact that they are identical is coincidental?
- have_humility 12y agoLet's assume that this is a valid characterization of things. Now, we could try flipping one or more of those bits. Surely the soundness of this argument guarantees that the resulting bit sequences are not protected so long as nobody else ever arranged those bits that way, and we're free to use them, right? In fact, we would be the only ones allowed to use the resulting bit sequence then. Problem is, if we actually did this, the protection status of those bits in real life would not comport with the results we outlined above. Specifically, we would find that many of the resulting bit sequences would be just as off limits to us. That's because copyright is not about bits, and the original characterization that it is is not a sound one. http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23 http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23
- clamprecht 12y agoDoes anyone else get the startup idea I got? Photo copyright infringement enforcement as a service? Feels too dirty to interest me, but maybe there's a business there for someone.
- MichaelApproved 12y agoThis exists.
- moron4hire 12y agoIt's interesting to see how much the FOSS developer community (or rather, the people in this thread who are complaining about this article as if it's part-and-parcel with supporting FOSS) has confused the idea that software should be libre with the idea that it should also be gratis. That's unfortunately not their last mistake, as it seems then also want to extend this to an idea that other copyrightable works should be gratis, too. The Software Freedoms [0] don't mean you get to scarper off with other people's hard work. They mean that, once you have paid and received permission to use the work, you shouldn't be restricted in your use of the work. Software is a thing that we use to get work done, a thing that doesn't necessarily work correctly or sufficiently or whatever other reason you might want to change it. We have a need to protect the rights of users because, without said rights, the user could potentially end up in a situation where their livelihood is significantly impacted by the failing software. A work of art, on the other hand, is meant for consumption. You can't make a photo so integral to your workflow that replacing it with another photo could be detrimental to your self. Most programs are not reasonable substitutes for each other. Most photos of bumblebees are--more or less--perfectly acceptable substitutes, not because all photographers are equivalent and interchangeable, but because your need to have that photo is not more important than the photographer's need to eat. The Software Freedoms are not about copyright. Copyright is just the mechanism through which the GPL operates, in an ideology that believes that software should not be copyrightable. It's the belief that these two things are so fundamentally different, that copyright is not the appropriate means to protect software developers, that led to the creation of the GPL. The GPL is nothing more than a hack on top of the copyright system to make copyright--for software--useless. It is not an overall indictment of copyright. [0] https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html
- mikekchar 12y agoI have to admit that I once thought essentially the same thing that you have written. However, I'm not so sure now. I think Software Freedom is distinct from copyright and while copyright in its current form is a problem for Software Freedom (insofar as it is too restrictive), doing away with copyright does not seem to be on the agenda of those who are concerned with Software Freedom (notably the FSF). If it were, we could all move to CC0 from GPL and be happy. I am not one of those who would espouse that all FOSS software should use unrestrictive licenses. CC0, or attribution based Free software licenses definitely have their place, but I think that the world would be poorer without a license like the GPL. The GPL ensures an even playing field so that someone can't take a large Free project, add a small piece and compete with the original project using different rules. If someone wants to compete against a GPLed project, they either have to play by the same rules or build their own project from the ground up. Instead of "copyright or not copyright", I think the Free software movement has shown that there is a range of restrictions that can be beneficial. Picking the appropriate restrictions for your project is an incredibly important task. When looking at CC (Creative Commons) licenses, I think it becomes a bit more obvious what things are valuable. They definitely benefitted from being able to look at the history of Free Software development when these licenses were developed. I know there is a growing movement of people who are extremely enthusiastic about very unrestrictive licenses. However, I can't help thinking that they miss something -- only thinking about a binary world of very restrictive (all rights reserved) and non restrictive (at best attribution only). To be honest, I love the thought of living in a world where everything was CC0 and everyone would willingly encourage people to take the source code and make derivative works. Of course it isn't. Even in a world without copyright, this would not happen because lacking legal means, companies would pursue technical means of making it difficult to make derived works. Because of this I tend to license my work as GPL because I know a thriving, fair community can be served this way. The restrictions (made possible by copyright) are valuable.
- jammycakes 12y agoThis article presents a side to intellectual property rights that it's all too easy to overlook when you are constantly hearing about patent trolls, the MPAA/RIAA, and so on. Copyright is intended to benefit people just like you and me for whom content creation such as this is how they feed their children and keep a roof over their heads. This does also highlight the need for due diligence if you're using images that you've found on the Internet though. This is often easier than you might expect -- you just have to upload your image to Google image search, and it will do a pretty good job of helping you track the original creator.
- underwater 12y agoThe idea of lawsuit-as-a-service is terrible. Last year I was accused of copyright infringement. I knew was completely in the clear - I hadn't ever heard of this person or seen their creation before. After dismissing some typo-riddled communication I though was bluffing I found myself named in a lawsuit. Turns out that knowing I was right was a whole world away from proving it in court. I was told it would cost me tens of thousands to defend myself. And the best possible outcome was for me to win my fees back. In the end I paid the other person to go away. The entire process was expensive, time consuming and incredibly stressful. I lost days of sleep worrying about what could happen. My case could have been resolved so much more easily without lawyers. I was actually interesting in monetizing and this person needed eyeballs on their product. I would have gladly sent them traffic if they agreed to an affiliate set up. The problem was that once lawyers start getting involved then the bills start adding up quickly. From then on it was classic sunk cost fallacy. Backing off means paying thousands of dollars for the privilege of being sued. No one wins but the lawyers. Sure, this company is going to be stopping some people from stealing images. But their business model is built on profiting from uncertainty and fear from the people they accuse of theft. This guy is an artist, yet he's so flippant about supporting an industry that profits by making the world a slightly worse place. He'd rather line the pockets of some lawyers than have to go through sending "dozens" of emails a month.
- iamhamm 12y agoThis is a very tricky situation it seems. I've never been party to infringement (on either side), but he explained pretty clearly why he outsourced this role. He has people legitimately using his work without license, so what's the problem with outsourcing enforcement? That said, I hear a story like yours and it freaks me out; I could be you some day. Maybe a "non-lawyer" system could exist, but without the threat of lawsuits, I suspect legitimate infringement situations would go ignored.
- underwater 12y agoThere's nothing preventing him from going to the lawyer after they refuse a request to remove the image. He's using his nuclear option as a first resort and claiming moral high ground.
- gesman 12y agoThe guy spent $50k on equipment to make these photos. Sorry iPhone/Android users. Pro photo equipment IS expensive. No matter how many terapixels your piece of shit, made in China pocket device is claimed to have, the true pro equipment takes a mortgage to have. And muscles to carry. High quality glass is heavy. And expensive (did I already said that?) to manufacture. It's all still made in Japan. Every little thing on it is. And that's a price to pay for top quality. And so - his response is reasonable.
- daturkel 12y agoThe licensing would be every bit as justified if the gear were cheap. This is how he makes his living, he's under no obligation to give it to anyone for free.
- bthomas 12y agoNaive question: how does the legal system determine appropriate damages for this kind of infringement? Can ImageRights just name a number, or is there some kind of precedent? Using a $500 photo intuitively seems worse than using a $5 photo. But if the offender had no intent - ie. a grandmother that didn't know you can't just copy anything from Google Images - would be bizarre to have punitive damages be a multiplier of the original license cost.
- kweks 12y agoDepends on the country. I recently had a case in France where a very well known magazine used one of my photos without permission; my lawyer advised that photo worth is judged by the reputation of the photographer. If you're an amateur happy snapper, you'll get hardly anything. If you're a world famous photographer, you'll get significant amounts. In one regard, that seems fair - and in another - grossly unfair.
- scott_karana 12y agoSounds like "greater of: reputation of infringer and reputation of photographer" would work.
- underwater 12y agoIf you look up the case that Alex linked to it turns out that the company he's suing were used hand illustrated paintings [1] that seemingly traced Alex's original photo. That's still fairly sketchy, but hardly the case of blatant republishing of photos that he's alluding to. I can actually see them arguing fair use. [1] http://cdn.orkin.com/images/ants/red-imported-fire-ant-illustration_1480x1062.jpg http://cdn.orkin.com/images/ants/red-imported-fire-ant-illus...
- em3rgent0rdr 12y agoMany people here believe a necessary and legitimate role of law is to provide specific methods for creators of intellectual goods to earn income, and are willing to encroach on people's freedoms in order to archive this goal. Other's don't view this as a necessary or legitimate role of law (and many aren't even convinced that intellectual property law actually provides a net benefit from a utilitarian standpoint). I believe it is specifically the creator's responsibility (and in general, the market's role) to figure out how the creator can make money. I am reminded of a rather blunt slogan found in cat-v (http://harmful.cat-v.org/economics/intellectual_property/ http://harmful.cat-v.org/economics/intellectual_property/) and in the Center for the Study of Innovative Freedom's page (http://c4sif.org/ http://c4sif.org/): "Your failed business model is not my problem."