36 ms·
Lenovo Caught Installing Adware on New Computers
- jsta 12y agoSo, what you're saying is that people still use the hard drives that come with their laptops. Interesting....
- maryland05 12y agoAccording to various reports, this Superfish adware uses the same certificate across Lenovo computers. It should be easy to grab the private key out of the proxy binaries. And then... all these computers are vulnerable to arbitrary HTTPS man-in-the-middle attacks. Uh oh.
- piannucci 12y agoYou're assuming that the proxy is on the laptops, no?
- kentonv 12y agoWell, the other possibility is that Superfish is routing and MITMing all traffic through its own servers, which is arguably worse.
- BrainInAJar 12y agoarguably? That's orders of magnitude worse
- kentonv 12y agoWell, I dunno. In one case Superfish can see all your data and store it on their servers, in the other case _anyone on the internet_ can spoof any site (as soon as someone extracts the key). Either way is pretty bad. But proxying all traffic from all Lenovo laptop owners through a third-party server without someone immediately noticing a problem is just not feasible, so I think we can assume that's not what they're doing.
- sliverstorm 12y agoAre you sure? Android Chrome proxies all non-HTTPS traffic through a third-party server, by default. So it isn't like the traffic volume is impossible.
- kentonv 12y agoYes but that's Google. I'd be surprised if Superfish had resources like that, or could generate that much traffic from their servers and not be noticed (by, say, Google). I could be wrong.
- kevin_thibedeau 12y agoSuperfish might have "benefactors" with deep pockets who want a scapegoat who won't squeal on them.
- abraham 12y agoIt's not by default, you have to enable it. https://support.google.com/chrome/answer/2392284 https://support.google.com/chrome/answer/2392284
- rurounijones 12y agoWow, really? I never knew that and some googling didn't find any decent sources. do you have one?
- mahouse 12y agohttps://developer.chrome.com/multidevice/data-compression https://developer.chrome.com/multidevice/data-compression
- rurounijones 12y agoMany thanks, easy when you know the right keywords >.<
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kentonv 12y agoThis is much worse than just installing adware. They install a web proxy which MITMs all web connections, including HTTPS by means of a pre-installed trusted root certificate. The root certificate is the same across all installs, and the private key is present on the machine (necessarily, to operate the proxy): https://twitter.com/fugueish/status/568258997578371072 https://twitter.com/fugueish/status/568258997578371072 Someone will extract the private key in the next few hours, and then HTTPS will be basically completely broken for all Lenovo users -- anyone will be able to spoof any site to them. Uninstalling the app does NOT remove the certificate: https://twitter.com/metsfan/status/568265468173107200 https://twitter.com/metsfan/status/568265468173107200 On the bright side, Firefox does not use the system certificates (it has its own list) and Chrome will no doubt push an update to block the certificate promptly.
- eloff 12y agoAnyway to see if that certificate is on a Lenovo computer? Anyway to remove it? I bought a Lenovo laptop recently, and I was appalled at the amount of crapware that was installed. It's a wonderful laptop at a great price, just too bad about the software.
- voltagex_ 12y agoCheck Certificate Management in mmc.exe (Add Snap-In).
- yuhong 12y agoOr just run certmgr.msc.
- kentonv 12y agoIt should show up in the system certificates list as "Superfish, Inc.". I haven't seen it myself but search for #superfish on Twitter to see a lot of screenshots and such.
- ekianjo 12y ago> It's a wonderful laptop at a great price, just too bad about the software. Lenovo's hardware support for Linux is great so unless there's something keeping you on Windows switching to a good Linux distro usually works fine on these laptops.
- PhoenixWright 12y agoWow. I just bought my first Lenovo product recently, a Q190. I will not be purchasing anything from them again.
- faster 12y agoThis reinforces my policy of buying laptops with the cheapest drive offered and replacing the drive with an SSD before the first boot. I run Linux anyway, so booting Windows has no value for me.
- beagle3 12y agoYou also have to reflash all firmware with known-trusted versions using a known-trusted reflasher to be safe. ... and replace the CPU with one that is known not to have backdoors. You'll have to craft it from Silicon yourself, though, because there aren't any available for sale anymore.
- unethical_ban 12y agoThis is what it looks like when people don't recognize that security is a spectrum.
- acadien 12y agoCan't you just write all 0's to the drive or just reformat it? Genuine question here, why would you need to physically replace the drive to ensure security when you can write to the whole thing?
- toomuchtodo 12y agoWould have to re-write/re-flash the firmware as well.
- acadien 12y agoWhat is it that the firmware can achieve? Is the firmware capable hijacking data, communicating with the NIC and transmitting data? Or is it somehow injecting harmful code? I feel like I'm missing something here.
- bzbarsky 12y agoThe drive firmware can change the bits going to/from the drive, no? For example, it could binary-patch (either at write time or read time) your kernel image on disk to communicate with the NIC, etc...
- jamesmcq24 12y agoWas just about to purchase a lenovo... although I would have wiped it and installed linux immediately this has caused me to look elsewhere. when will companies learn this kind of behavior is toxic to their business?
- Untit1ed 12y agoUnfortunately a very small proportion of potential customers are going to hear or care about this... it's about as toxic to their business as stepping in some stinging nettles is toxic to me.
- jamesmcq24 12y agounfortunately you're completely correct.
- eikenberry 12y agoUnfortunately they have no competition in terms of a quality laptop to run Linux on. None of the competition offers similar features as my current x230 or the x250 I'm probably going to pick up later this year. If you could recommend a replacement that has a good keyboard, trackpoint, 12+ hours of real battery life, i7, etc. I'd be happy to hear about it.
- EpicEng 12y agoI don't know; if this gets into the news cycle (which it should), I think it will be a huge problem for lenovo. The people buying one of these to run Linux likely already understand the implications and are reading about it now. The rest of the consumer base need only hear "someone can intercept your banking password" and they will take notice. There has been an uptick in computer security related news stories lately. I think the tide may be changing, albeit slowly.
- andrewchambers 12y agoFirst thing I also do on a new PC is reinstall the OS from scratch and get rid of all the preinstalled shit.
- AlexeyBrin 12y agoYour strategy works only if you have a clean copy of the OS or you buy one (since the thread is about Lenovo I assume you are talking about Windows). Typically, a new PC doesn't come anymore with a copy of the OS, but with a hidden recovery partition that will basically let you do a factory reset (meaning all the crap will show up again).
- cdr 12y agoMicrosoft itself has provided Windows installation media for download since Windows 8, including Windows 7 media. All you have to do is read your key off BIOS or the sticker. And of course Windows 10 will be a free download.
- sliverstorm 12y agoUnless things have changed, usually the sticker key is only valid for a certain kind of media. E.g. VLK's only work with VLK images, retail keys only work with retail images...
- ptaipale 12y agoJust recently installed Windows 7 Pro on a HP ProBook thing: - looked up the Windows and Office license keys of the existing installation, using an utility - download Windows 7 disk image from Microsoft and burn on a DVD - take out the old disk with recovery partitions and installation with crappy bloatware - put in a new SSD disk, boot DVD to install OS and install Office - download and install HP specific drivers for peripherals (display adapter, fingerprint reader, wlan/3g, whatever) - enjoy a relatively bloat-free Windows experience with improved battery life
- jgrahamc 12y agoCan someone with one of these laptops connect to https://www.howsmyssl.com/ https://www.howsmyssl.com/ and post what it says? I'm curious what cipher suites are used from the proxy to the real site.
- BorisMelnik 12y agonot a laptop, a VM that I've built with a similar environment but: http://i.imgur.com/YyawOxc.png http://i.imgur.com/YyawOxc.png http://i.imgur.com/V33bYuv.png http://i.imgur.com/V33bYuv.png
- mahouse 12y agoI think that is because you're using IE 8...
- aughfucklenovo 12y agoIt says it's "Probably Okay", even when I have Superfish's certificate enabled. (I have the program installed, but the cert sticks around.)
- 4mnt 12y agoThe site cannot detect that you have an extra root certificate lying around on your computer. If you visit the website without the Superfish program installed, you just evaluate the SSL settings of your browser.
- tombrossman 12y agoFirst thing I did when I saw that URL was to run it through Qualys' SSL Labs test. Multiple issues, no forward secrecy, weak ciphers, grade set to 'C'. Oh, the irony. https://www.ssllabs.com/ssltest/analyze.html?d=howsmyssl.com https://www.ssllabs.com/ssltest/analyze.html?d=howsmyssl.com
- foodstances 12y agoUh, because it needs to allow weak clients to connect in order to report on them?
- ntakasaki 12y agoI am guessing the Lenovo machines that are bought from the Microsoft Store are free of this, because of the Signature PC program, might be worth the extra cost if any and the trip there to get a crapware free machine.
- crimsonalucard 12y agowhy risk it.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- r721 12y agoI wonder what are the legal repercussions of this, can't someone sue them?
- BorisMelnik 12y agoI think worse than that, I see criminal charges being brought up for this including fraud, theft, etc.
- technomancy 12y agoTheft? Seriously?
- BorisMelnik 12y agoThey were making money (tens of millions) from software illegally installed, so definitely.
- technomancy 12y agoDo you know what the word "theft" means?
- michaelelliot 12y agoJust found this: Spy agencies ban Lenovo PCs on security concerns (27th July 2013) - http://www.afr.com/p/technology/spy_agencies_ban_lenovo_pcs_on_security_HVgcKTHp4bIA4ulCPqC7SL http://www.afr.com/p/technology/spy_agencies_ban_lenovo_pcs_... "Multiple intelligence and defence sources in Britain and Australia confirmed there is a written ban on computers made by the Chinese company [Lenovo] being used in “classified” networks."
- rodgerd 12y agoAnother black eye if they knew about Superfish and didn't alert their citizens.
- yuhong 12y agoIt is from 2013 though.
- tedunangst 12y agoIIRC, that article is a fine combination of bullshit and technically correct. There is a "written ban" purchasing equipment from anyone not on the approved vendor list. Lenovo didn't ask to be on the list, they're not on the list, therefore they're banned. As am I. As are you.
- vxNsr 12y agoI thought that had to do with the fact that they're a chinese owned company and if say the CIA makes a large order (or any order really) the chinese government might step in and force malware to be installed.
- nfmangano 12y agoI'm surprised that this is just now news. I received complaints from people participating in our beta trial (http://sketchtogether.com http://sketchtogether.com) from as early as October 22nd, 2014 that our website was broken, and it was because of Superfish being installed on their lenovo laptops. When they uninstalled Superfish, our webpage started working again. Superfish injected a line of code that referenced "sf_main.jsp" from a remote site into all webpages (including ours) that interfered with our code. Here's a pastebin of the sf_main.jsp javascript file it linked to: http://pastebin.com/bZFkfRd5 http://pastebin.com/bZFkfRd5 (I assume the linked code is not copyrighted, if it is, please let me know and I can take it down).
- kentonv 12y agoAn all-new reason to use Content-Security-Policy. How much you want to bet that thing is XSSable?
- pmh 12y ago>An all-new reason to use Content-Security-Policy Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think any amount of CSP will help you in this situation. They're MITMing traffic and thus can modify the CSP headers.
- kentonv 12y agoFair enough, though I'd bet they aren't smart enough to have actually blocked the header. They apparently don't even support WebSocket.
- lstamour 12y agoLine 194 -- They customized their ad script for Lenovo. Making them entirely aware of what's going on...
- userbinator 12y agoGoogling "hdrykzc" returns some interesting results...
- mrsaint 12y agoSome more URLs... https://www.superfish.com/ws/sf_code.jsp https://www.superfish.com/ws/sf_code.jsp https://www.superfish.com/ws/sf_conduit.jsp https://www.superfish.com/ws/sf_conduit.jsp https://www.superfish.com/ws/sf_conduit_mam.jsp https://www.superfish.com/ws/sf_conduit_mam.jsp https://www.superfish.com/ws/sfw.jsp https://www.superfish.com/ws/sfw.jsp https://www.superfish.com/ws/sf_main.jsp https://www.superfish.com/ws/sf_main.jsp https://www.superfish.com/ws/getCouponsSupportedSites.action https://www.superfish.com/ws/getCouponsSupportedSites.action https://www.superfish.com/ws/getSupportedSitesJSON.action https://www.superfish.com/ws/getSupportedSitesJSON.action
- chinathrow 12y agoIf I were a company on one of those lists, I would start litigation immediately. If you work for SuperFish and read this: I think it's time to learn about ethics and it's time to walk away from your job NOW.
- gerty 12y agoI love my Thinkpad and couldn't think of using anything else. I value it for the hardware and buy it without pre-installed OS, so this wouldn't affect me anyway. Superfish is however an absolute clusterfuck on behalf of Lenovo, though at least it was caught rather fast unlike the Sony rootkit. One thing I really value in Lenovo is their customer service and as a long-time customer, I'd expect some people to get fired, a heartfelt apology and a compensation for those affected. It's their PR image on the line. Just don't be f*ing Sony.
- elcct 12y agoThats funny how today I finally convinced myself into buying Lenovo laptop. I guess I was wrong.
- rikkus 12y agoI used a ThinkPad 700 in 1992 and have bought ThinkPads ever since. Lenovo keep trying to ruin them while ignoring customers telling them to stop. A ThinkPad 1. Is robust 2. Is reliable 3. Is black 4. Has only useful software pre-installed, from the manufacturer (e.g. the Lenovo thing which updates drivers) 5. Has a TrackPoint 6. Has a consistent keyboard layout 7. Has hardware buttons ('mouse', function keys, etc.) 8. Has a functional screen Every few months David Hill of Lenovo starts crowing about some new ThinkPad where they've 'innovated' by breaking one or more of these features, usually the keyboard layout or the hardware buttons. There is then a storm in the comments, which is ignored, then they put the thing out, and people skip that model, then they think 'maybe we should listen to our customers' and put it back as it was. Then they make the same mistake again. The last two X1 Carbons are a perfect example of this. They turned the TrackPoint buttons and function keys into 'touch' buttons. Everyone said it was a bad idea, but they did it anyway, then quickly reversed the decision for the next iteration. They're going to keep making this sort of mistake, because there's a problem in understanding their customers which doesn't seem to be getting fixed - so it's probably at a high level. What I'd like to see is another manufacturer step up and make a ThinkPad-ish line, so that Lenovo can be taught a lesson by having their customers abscond. They might then realise that they can't keep doing this and put in place a policy of keeping a line of ThinkPads for their ThinkPad-loving customer base. Now that they've diluted the brand by making some terrible laptops with ThinkPad stamped on them, though, (W, E, L series, etc.) they should probably have some other mark on their 'proper' ThinkPads, i.e. their X and T series.
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoAgreed. Somebody really needs to start making Thinkpads again. Lenovo ain't it. All they've done is manage to kill the brand.
- rikkus 12y agoThey could rescue it easily, but they're muddled up between their (best selling, I presume) consumer (including low-end business) and premium business hardware. If I was given the job of fixing this at Lenovo, I'd do this: 1. Kill off the ThinkPad brand. It's tainted. 2. Invent a new name for the premium laptops. Something workmanlike, off the top of my head: WorkStead. 3. Tell the world that the premium business laptops are now called WorkStead. 4. Tell the world what makes a WorkStead laptop, guaranteeing those things which have been broken repeatedly over the past few years, e.g. consistent keyboard layout, real buttons for everything. 4. Rebrand the X and T series with this name, but only the ones that deserve it. 5. Wait for people to again start saying 'Get me a fully loaded WorkStead T4xx series' like they used to do with ThinkPads, before they had to say 'Let me check which models they've managed not to ruin recently'. 6. Stop asking people to choose between 3 slightly different Intel wifi cards within $10 of each other in price, defaulting to the worst one, when they're buying a $3000 laptop. ... And other brokenness in the configurators.
- mbrubeck 12y agoThe article says that Superfish "injects third-party ads on Google searches." Does that include https://encrypted.google.com/ https://encrypted.google.com/ in Chrome and Firefox, or do key pinning and HSTS preloading successfully prevent that? EDIT: According to another comment here, HTTPS connections in Firefox aren't affected because they don't use the system certificate store. But what about Chrome - do users see an error on pages with pinned keys, or is the proxy smart enough not to attack those connections? Or does it also disable Chrome security features like HSTS and key pinning?
- pencilo 12y agoLocally added CAs override pinning, so no it wont help.
- joe_the_user 12y agoI presume the next step is Adware installation on in the flash of the system's boot drive.
- rodgerd 12y agoInteresting that the Superfish job page is looking for an iOS kernel hacker. And by "interesting" I mean "horrifying".
- 0x0 12y agoWhat other purpose beyond the development of drive-by installs of iOS rootkits can such a job position have in a company like that?! :(
- BorisMelnik 12y agoAs a Lenovo owner, I'm really pissed off, and offended. I feel violated. I just can't comprehend how they could think they wouldn't get caught at something like this. Especially with the current climate of the privacy movement in the US. This is bad, very bad for Lenovo.
- malexw 12y agoI just wanted to echo your sentiments. I bought my T440p last year and have otherwise been reasonably happy with it (though not entirely, due to the iffy trackpad). Fortunately the first thing I did was replace the hard drive. Despite that, I'll never buy another Lenovo product. I have completely lost confidence in the company.
- adamnemecek 12y agoHow to kill a brand in 1 easy step: do this.
- apaprocki 12y agoProof that this has been happening since at least December 2014: http://itnerdysoldier.blogspot.cz/2014/12/where-does-this-wwwbest-deals.html http://itnerdysoldier.blogspot.cz/2014/12/where-does-this-ww...
- BorisMelnik 12y agoWell, it seems as though this [superfish] is categorized as a virus on most websites. From their own description: "Superfish Window Shopper is a free browser add-on that instantly compares prices and shows similar items on ANY product in hundreds of U.S. online stores including Amazon.com, Best Buy, Macys, Nordstorm, Overstock.com, Staples, Target, and Wal-mart." So if I have this right, this is essentially a massive affiliate scheme to produce revenue for the company? If it compares prices on all these sites, affid='s are injected for Lenovo and a % of the sale is given to them? Edit: doing the math here on this for the last few hours and even if just a few million units have been sold, this has to be 10's of millions in dollars (being very generous) over the past few quarters. There reviews are horrible as well. All spam / annoyance related.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoGiven that antivirus products detect this as malware, does Lenovo not install any antivirus on their systems, or do they install a substandard one that fails to detect it?
- superuser2 12y agoLenovo was the last respected PC laptop brand. Is there anyone I can trust to sell me a well-made laptop anymore besides Apple?
- mintplant 12y agoYou can still wipe the hard drive and replace it with a Linux install (or a fresh Windows install, if you must).
- rozap 12y agoAsus is about it.
- Maakuth 12y agoI thought so too, but my recent experience with a Zenbook has changed my view. WiFi drivers were so bad it took half a year after my purchase before the connection became stable (not dropping every 15 minutes requiring a reboot). Touchpad drivers were also a mess with awful kinetic scrolling. And just couple of weeks ago it stopped booting Windows altogehter (something related to ACPI I guess, Linux works if I don't use suspend). Conveniently one month after the expiration of the warranty.
- wvenable 12y agoDespite the initial problems, I like my Zenbook. The WiFi drivers are made by Intel, but yes, they were terrible (blue screen). I had to downgrade back to the drivers that came with Windows for while but the latest versions seem to be fine. I'm using some stock touchpad drivers that don't seem to have any kinetic scrolling. But I'm the person who brought this to the attention of Hacker News: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8546702 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8546702 Basically after installing just about everything the laptop comes with, it seems to be running great. :)
- rozap 12y agoMaybe Windows is terrible, I've heard lots of bad stuff about the wifi and touchpad drivers in particular. I installed xubuntu the day I got it and everything worked out of the box from day one. Power management on ubuntu 12.04 wasn't so great, but battery life became significantly better on 14.04. Additionally, a roommate spilled a pint of beer on my computer and Asus replaced it for free, despite not having an accidental damage warranty.
- SwellJoe 12y agoJebus, how far the might IBM laptop line has fallen under the leadership of Lenovo. There was a time when a ThinkPad was arguably the best laptop money could buy. Many companies, including Google, would offer a choice between a ThinkPad or a MacBook, because those were the really reliable choices that were free of shovelware. I even considered buying a Lenovo recently when a pretty nice looking ThinkPad was on sale, but a couple of friends have had very bad experiences with their Lenovo laptops. Both have had to go back to Lenovo for repairs; one of them had to send it back twice, and on the second go around demanded a new one instead of a repaired one, because the "repaired" one was worse than when it went in for repairs. That said, there's "bad QC", which is forgivable with time and a sincere effort by the company to correct it, and then there's "evil". Intentionally shipping adware is evil. Given this, I can genuinely think of no way for Lenovo to ever get my business for any product.
- navlelo 12y agoI have a X230 and I'm super happy with it. The quality is beyond everything I have experienced with laptops. I have a newer Dell E-series at work now and it's ok, but lack the same quality feel imo. I suspect the cheaper Lenovo laptops are shitty though.
- pkulak 12y agoIs it even possible to buy a Windows laptop right now with only the OS installed? This is exactly why I've been recommending Chromebooks to anyone who asks my advice for about a year now.
- thom 12y agoThe alternative to this is buying an OEM copy of your Windows OS, and hoping the driver situation works out.
- arthurfm 12y agoThere isn't any need to spend any money on an additional Windows license [1]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9073739 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9073739
- BorisMelnik 12y agoOh, let us not forget the crap PC cleaner program that gets included in the Superfish install ("a Microsoft Partner"): http://i.imgur.com/7cFlZLr.png http://i.imgur.com/7cFlZLr.png http://i.imgur.com/R4sHowP.png http://i.imgur.com/R4sHowP.png So on a fresh Windows 7 virtual machine with zero apps installed, this program gives me 200 some errors and wants $49.99 (-$20 for instant savings) to register the program. This keeps getting better. Typical scam.
- _Adam 12y agoStupid. I don't understand their motivations - are they making such a huge amount of money from this? Lenovo doesn't stand out as much as they used to. Dell/HP/Apple make pretty great business laptops these days. If everything else is equal and I know the competitor (for example) won't install adware, then why would I ever buy Lenovo again?
- erikschoster 12y agoI don't see myself ever bothering to keep the default windows install on a thinkpad but this really hurts my impression of the company regardless. I've had my eye on the new X1s and had planned to upgrade my X201 this year but now I'm having second thoughts. Who if anyone has taken over the place of great laptop for linux / development?
- ertdfgcb 12y agoI don't know about dev, but here are three linux computer/laptop companies in descending order of how nice their websites look: https://system76.com/ https://system76.com/ https://zareason.com/shop/Laptops/ https://zareason.com/shop/Laptops/ https://www.thinkpenguin.com/ https://www.thinkpenguin.com/
- lkbm 12y agoI bought a Bonobo in 2011. The fan's loud sometimes nowadays, and the battery's kinda shot (mostly because it's old, but also because it's trying to run a 17" 8-core beast), but it's still my primary machine nearly four years later. They're basically rebranded Sagers/Clevos, I believe, so you may be able to get essentially the same machine for a little less money, but weigh that against supporting a Linux laptop seller.
- davidw 12y agoThe new Dell XPS 13 looks like a very nice laptop. I have the previous version and it works very well with Linux.
- crdb 12y agoI used the XPS 13 as my main machine from 2013 to late 2014 (when I switched to a MBPr). It was a nice machine initially but I found that it ended up looking pretty tattered (particularly the plastic edge, which looks and feels cheap and a bit fragile in the long run). Most annoyingly, it had a tendency to overheat, particularly when dual booting into Ubuntu. After about 20 minutes, I couldn't leave the thing on my knees - had to find a table. Both the "tablet/screen" and the base were affected. It was portable and powerful enough, but the MBPr gives me a much better overall experience. At half, perhaps 2/3 of the price of the 13" MBPr, it might still be worth it.
- negamax 12y agoSuperfish. How apt.
- userbinator 12y agoMore like Superphish.
- negamax 12y agoExactly
- OscarCunningham 12y agoWould it be correct to assume that this doesn't affect any of the thinkpads used at IBM?
- TallGuyShort 12y agoIf they've installed Windows themselves (as I suspect many enterprises have) it's probable, but I wouldn't say it's correct to assume. There's a test going I've seen being shared around by people who are fairly trusted in the tech community that uses an image (supposedly) signed with the private key to see if the certificate is installed: https://filippo.io/Badfish/ https://filippo.io/Badfish/. If I were you I'd at least check that out.
- krisgenre 12y agoOne more good reason to not buy a laptop with pre-installed OS.
- bharad 12y ago1. I connect to https://encrypted.google.com/ https://encrypted.google.com/ on Firefox and the certificate says it is verified by SuperFish. 2. Also, my broswer.newtab.url was changed to some URL (http://homepage-web.com/?s=lenovo&m=tab http://homepage-web.com/?s=lenovo&m=tab) instead of the default about:newtab Steps to remove VisualDiscovery / Superfish 1. Home menu, search for Administrator tools 2. Open services 3. Find the VisualDiscovery service. Stop the service. Right click properties. Set "Startup type" to Disabled 4. Start -> Control panel 5. Add/ remove programs 6. Find Superfish and uninstall
- taspeotis 12y agoFrom what I understand, you need to go one further and spelunk through your local machine certificate stores and remove any Superfish certificates. They are not uninstalled.
- markbnj 12y agoJust one more very good reason why the first thing I do with a new OEM machine of any kind is reformat and reinstall from my own media.
- synkarius 12y agoThis is like the Avast spyware story: once you break trust, it's really difficult to get it back.
- gasping 12y agoLenovo going down the drain. All they had to do was continue the Thinkpad legacy left by IBM. It's honestly breathtaking how badly they've fucked up. After the touch-based function keys, ruining the trackpoint buttons and now this. It's unbelievable.
- eikenberry 12y agoThey brought the trackpoint buttons back on the latest line and you can switch the F-keys back to being the defaults via a bios setting. Just in case you were curious.
- yuhong 12y agoAnd they never preinstalled this on ThinkPads as far as I know.
- danieldk 12y agoStill, it ruins trust. Apparently Lenovo is morally corrupt enough to inflict this on their customers. Who knows what else? One can only hope that they keep Motorola as an independent business unit.
- NameNickHN 12y agoThat hope is pretty much gone, now.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI'll just leave this out there : http://www.komodia.com/products/komodia-redirector/ http://www.komodia.com/products/komodia-redirector/
- Matt_Cutts 12y agoDownload Valley, man.
- imthemobileguru 12y agoBZ
- amatwl 12y agoHopefully Redmond will give hell to Lenovo for this. Also, apparently this is just the start for crapware on new PCs - Paul Thurrott said on the podcast Windows Weekly about a week ago that crapware is going to get a lot worse this PC cycle.
- cbd1984 12y ago> Paul Thurrott said on the podcast Windows Weekly about a week ago that crapware is going to get a lot worse this PC cycle. Did he say why?
- mherrmann 12y agoUnbelievable. Guess switching to Apple from Lenovo last autumn wasn't the worst choice.
- teddyh 12y agoThat’s like leaving an abusive relationship to instead plug yourself into the Matrix.
- TallGuyShort 12y agoBecause Apple things never get hacked. Right?
- snsr 12y agoNo, because Apple doesn't pre-install malware on their systems.
- atian 12y agoAbout a week ago I was trying to troubleshoot Nitrous.io for a friend because she had complained that it wasn't establishing a connection. We discovered along the way that there was an odd line of Javascript on the page that immediately had me assume that her computer was infected with a virus. A Google search on the filename had others saying that it was removable by uninstalling some Lenovo Utility preinstalled.
- na85 12y agoUgh. So for "developer-tier" laptops, i.e. not a netbook, does that pretty much leave Apple as the sole non-shit laptop maker? Is there a chromebook out there that runs linux pretty well if you pull chromeOS off? You pay a hefty premium for that backlit Apple logo on the lid, and I'd prefer to get something a little more down-to-earth.
- q3k 12y agoDell Latitudes are still pretty okay (check out, for example, the Latitude E7440). Lacking an expresscard slot or a monster 9-cell battery, but that's something you won't get in a macbook, either.
- zaroth 12y agoThe premium isn't as high as you think, particularly if you account for resale value. Didn't Priceonomics do a feature on this?
- na85 12y agoI'm not sure why anyone buys anything other than a home when accounting for resale value unless they're just trying to pull a pump-and-dump. For laptops, at least, I buy them and use them until they die. I've only owned three laptops in my life.
- lmm 12y agoFor a long time a 3-year-old laptop struggled to run the latest eclipse (this may well still be the case). So at that point I'll sell them on to someone with a less intense workload and buy a replacement.
- sago 12y ago> a 3-year-old laptop struggled to run the latest eclipse There's a whole world of bad software engineering in that observation!
- rayiner 12y ago
- ryan-c 12y agoSince this certificate is unconstrained it can probably be used to sign drivers...
- jimktrains2 12y agoI'm assuming this only affects you if you're running windows? (Honest question, it's not some firmware based thing from what I've read, but just checking).
- mahouse 12y agoOf course... It's just a certificate and proxy that comes by default with the OS as it comes from their factory. You can uninstall the certificate, reinstall Windows, install Linux, etc. and the problem will disappear.
- Animats 12y agoThis should result in criminal prosecution under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act. A Lenovo buyer needs to file a criminal complaint. Now. If your company buys Lenovo computers, check for this. Just go to "bankofamerica.com", and read the SSL certificate.
- buildops 12y agoWhat do you recommend instead?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- belorn 12y agoIf you are a hardware seller, the dream is to get paid more than once. If your only revenue is from the sticker price, it way too easy to fall behind the competition, or inadvertently start a race to the bottom. A lot of focus has thus been done towards this goal, like adding adware, development license, a cut per sold app, data mining, DRM'ed required parts, and so on. This is a standard consumer protection issue, as the sticker price fails to represent the actual price of the product. The seller is concealing the true price, hiding it in the terms and conditions, while putting the blame on the consumer for not being aware before buying. It's likely false advertisement, possible misrepresentation in the contract (if the consumer knew the truth, would that party have agreed?), and very likely a case of fraud. Lenovo seem to have opened themselves to be sued.
- HackinOut 12y agoTheNextWeb does a poor job at reporting technical facts: "[...] its own self-signed certificate authority which effectively allows the software to snoop on secure connections [...]" "[...] the certificate allows the software to decrypt secure requests[...]" As kentonv reported, it's actually the local proxy, installed by the ad(Mal?)ware which is at the center of the MiTM attack. The root, self-signed certificate is installed in order for the attack to be transparent to the victim (i.e. no warning in browser).
- Cass 12y agoAs a non-technical user with a newish Lenovo laptop, is there some way I can make sure I'm not affected by this?
- zaggynl 12y agoAre you using the OS that came with the laptop? Easiest way would be to reinstall Windows, DON'T do this from the recovery partition or cd.
- maxerickson 12y agoLearn how to view a certificate in Chrome or Internet Explorer: https://support.google.com/chrome/answer/95617?hl=en https://support.google.com/chrome/answer/95617?hl=en Then look to see if the certificate for a secured site lists Superfish: https://twitter.com/kennwhite/status/568270748638318593/photo/1 https://twitter.com/kennwhite/status/568270748638318593/phot... (That doesn't prove it isn't on your computer, but it will show if it is actively intercepting your connections)
- spacefight 12y agoThere is at least one possible solution for the near future: prohibit computer vendor by law to accept money or other compensation for pre-installing _any_ kind of 3rd party software except the bare naked OS. This shit must stop.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ibz 12y agoNot to minimize Lenovo's guilt for pre-installing adware and not to say MITMing HTTPS fine - it is not! But... I'd rather have a laptop that injects ads in my Google searches than one that sends all my data to some three-letter agency in the US. That being said, we might one day find out that all the Chinese laptops and routers are also sending all the data over to China... That's when the whole story will start being really funny!
- facepalm 12y agoHow do you safely install Mozilla Firefox if you have a broken certificate store?
- vacri 12y agoSneakernet.
- nly 12y agoHardware manufacturers cannot be trusted with software. One day the horrors of proprietary firmware will come to light as well, and people will wake up to this shit. Dells entire business line of Latitude laptops have been completely broken under Linux for 10 months. It took them that long to merely revert the "keyboard improvements" made between two BIOS revisions, but they subsequently shipped, and are still shipping, brand new machines without the fix or any downgrade path. These machines just aren't fit-for-purpose. Imho Richard Stallman is right if for no other reason than I see no other way to end all this consumer abuse and borderline criminal negligence. In the mean time, this debacle sounds Class-action worthy to me.
- ihnorton 12y agoPeople should also file complaints with their state consumer protection division. There are probably at least one or two AGs who would love to make an example out of Lenovo (big bad foreign company, etc.). Here's the complaint form for Massachusetts: http://www.eform.ago.state.ma.us/ago_eforms/forms/piac_ecomplaint.action http://www.eform.ago.state.ma.us/ago_eforms/forms/piac_ecomp...
- thewizardofmys 12y agoSo basically I have to pay for the hardware and then see annoying ads too?
- gchokov 12y agoI wish it was that simple.
- thewizardofmys 12y agoSo basically I have to pay for the hardware and then see annoying ads too?
- thewizardofmys 12y agoSo basically I have to pay for the hardware and then see annoying ads too?
- CatsoCatsoCatso 12y agoI have had first hand recent experience with this. I bought a new Lenovo laptop at the start of the month. When I put a new webpage online using my webhost's cPanel to edit the raw HTML everything seemed fine, until a friend asked about a 'best-deals' script running on the page. The Malware / Adware was intercepting & inserting a script not only into pages I was viewing but also pages I was putting online. Very, very concerning. I have since removed it completely from my system but it's still caused some paranoia. Thankfully it was only a hobby project which was affected & not paid.
- blumkvist 12y agoWHAT THE ACTUAL FUCK. Never buying Lenovo again.
- romanovcode 12y agoYou can just get precise Windows version that was installed and format all the drives (including recovery) and then do clean install. Result: no bloat and no malware
- jorgecastillo 12y agoNo, no, no! We can't just dismiss this sort of behavior because you can reformat the computer and "Result: no bloat and no malware". They need to learn that people won't let them get away with this. So no this is unacceptable, I too will never buy nor recommend a Lenovo product in the foreseeable future!
- userbinator 12y agoActually, it would be better to educate the masses they can reformat and install a clean OS, because that is what builds immunity and sends an even clearer message that the additional bloatware they ship is worth nothing.
- 12y ago
- Animats 12y agoThe Javascript code shown connects to "https://www.superfish.com/ws/" https://www.superfish.com/ws/". WHOIS for "superfish.com" gives names and addresses of people in Palo Alto, CA and in Israel. The other URL in the code is "https://www.best-deals-products.com/ws/sf_preloader.jsp" https://www.best-deals-products.com/ws/sf_preloader.jsp". That domain is being blocked by some DNS services right now, but it's up. It's a Domains by Proxy domain. That code is worth reading. You can tell what it's looking for as it examines the pages you are browsing. It has a detailed analyzer for car ad price comparisons, and a simpler one for hotels. It phones home to "http://ia1-p:10009" http://ia1-p:10009", which isn't a valid domain, but there may be some conversion of that I haven't found. One out of every 10,000 times, it reports some debug info to "https://www.superfish.com/ws/trackSession.action" https://www.superfish.com/ws/trackSession.action". There are long lists of sites, both blacklists it avoids and whitelists it messes with. There's a list of "paying countries: "IE|CH|ES|US|AU|BE|IT|AT|NO|CA|DE|NL|SE|GB|DK|FR|BR|NZ|AR|MX|CL|CO|RU". Lots of comments and debug code; it's not obfuscated at all. Javascript experts, please take a look at this. There might be something hostile embedded in this adware code, and it may bring in more Javascript.
- tomjen3 12y agoAre we absolutely sure that is the company involved? whois superfish.com gives both his personal email and telephone number. I want to share them on twitter, but not unless we are absolutely sure. Fuck that guy and the company he rode in on.
- cssmoo 12y agoThis is why I do a flat install on every new machine I get. Also, why are we bitching just at Lenovo. There are software developers out there writing this shit. Name and shame the companies and staff. There needs to be a no hire and no do business with list. Ethics go all the way down. I'm rather disappointed though as I've recommended Lenovo hardware recently to people and use an X201 myself.
- prodigal_erik 12y agoIf a guy is demonstrably capable of writing malware, and we all refuse to hire him to do anything else, he will probably write more malware rather than starve.
- cssmoo 12y agoInteresting and well thought out point.
- JoachimS 12y agoKomodia seems to be a good guess on the question of which company.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 12y agoI'm starting to think we need an equivalent of UL certification or even the old "BABT approved" stickers for consumer protection. UL provides a bunch of non-obvious to the user but critical for safety rules for mains-connected devices. Likewise users are subject to non-obvious privacy threats from internet-connected devices (leakage of personal information, injected advertising or referral links). These should be at least clearly labelled. So Android devices would get a "yellow" rating for "transmits personal information securely to Google" and these Lenovo laptops and Samsung TVs would get "red" for "transmits personal information in cleartext".
- jbarham 12y agoI quite like my new Lenovo M73 "Tiny" desktop [1]. It's fast and silent and really is tiny. But as far as adware/malware is concerned, that's a non-issue for me as the first thing I did when I got the machine was to replace the Windows drive with an Ubuntu SSD. [1] http://shopap.lenovo.com/au/en/desktops/thinkcentre/tinys/m73-tiny/ http://shopap.lenovo.com/au/en/desktops/thinkcentre/tinys/m7...
- itg 12y agoI replace my laptop OS with linux too but I don't want to financially contribute to companies that pull shit like this. Lenovo isn't going to change their practice unless sales take a hit or get into a legal mess. I'll personally will not buy anymore Lenovo hardware, and those new dell xps laptops look pretty nice anyway.
- romanovcode 12y agoThis is why first thing I do after getting a new PC/Laptop is get precise Windows version, download it to USB and do full-format/reinstall. Now only it cleans all the bloat from vendors but now it will also remove malware.
- wsha 12y agoSuperfish really creeped me out last November when I got a new Lenovo laptop. I first noticed it when using Firefox with NoScript. A script from best-deals-products.com was being blocked on every site that I went to (I never unblocked it so I can't confirm the statement about Firefox not being affected). It took me a while searching around to figure out it was the Superfish program. Rather than uninstall the program, I nuked the disk and installed the vanilla Windows from Microsoft. I bought the Lenovo because I was really annoyed with Apple when my MBP died just after the 3 years of AppleCare I payed for expired on my 2011 model (notorious for failing: https://mbp2011.org/ https://mbp2011.org/, I guess I can't win with laptop vendors). It was my first time working with OEM Windows in a while (laptop before the MBP was a Dell in 2005) and I was surprised at how much more bloatware vendors thought they could stuff into a new laptop compared to the past. Next time I guess I will either go back to Apple or get something that comes with Linux installed just to avoid the Windows bloatware.
- cesarb 12y agoI have to ask: can this root certificate be used for code signing?
- jussij 12y agoWhat a great way to destroy a brand! I know which laptop I will never be buying.
- quinndupont 12y agoAnd it has been successfully cracked[1], revealing (potential) associations with a dodgy SSL redirector [2]. [1] http://blog.erratasec.com/2015/02/extracting-superfish-certificate.html http://blog.erratasec.com/2015/02/extracting-superfish-certi... [2] http://www.komodia.com http://www.komodia.com
- SyneRyder 12y agoAlso worth giving credit to ChuckMcM who was on the right track a few hours prior: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9072815 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9072815
- skizm 12y agoSo now MBP is really the only laptop option, unfortunately. (not because I don't like Apple, I just would rather their be some competition)
- srj 12y agoIt looks like this certificate can also be used to codesign malware that can then run as a superuser.
- jacquesm 12y agoAnd I thought I was paranoid by swapping out the drive on the day I bought my new laptop.
- disputin 12y agoIs this sort of thing more tolerated in China where people are used to having explicit network interference, eg great firewall?
- geococcyxc 12y agoIt would be interesting to investigate whether the uncovered private key is shared by all the other customers of the SSL interceptor as well (http://www.komodia.com/products/komodia-redirector/ http://www.komodia.com/products/komodia-redirector/ as mentioned by ChuckMcM earlier). Their references there mention Barracuda Networks and Astrill, for example.
- swang 12y agoDoes anyone know when this started happening (installing of superfish)? Seems mid-2014 according to the article?
- bodecker 12y agoSuperfish, the movie http://imgur.com/WT33KBJ http://imgur.com/WT33KBJ
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- MM1102 12y agoIf anyone bought one of these, feel free to contact me. I am a lawyer and we handle consumer class actions. I would like to hear what you have to say.
- b3b0p 12y agoMy dad saw this post and asked that I post the following here for him. He didn't want to make an account: "Why do it if you are Lenovo? Well it seems clear to me that there was a financial inducement provided by superfish. I mean Lenovo is not loading software unless they are financially benefited. Come on. As far as other inducements go, consider this. Two weeks ago I got an expensive, new Lenovo machine. Got it running just fine, thank you, and then I download Chrome from what was very, very clearly identified as google.com. Who do you trust man. Fired it up and immediately my machine locked me out and became unresponsive. Called Lenovo and for $200 worth of Lenovo.premiumsupport they fixed it and gave me 10 months of additional support. $20/month for 10 months on top of a normal laptop margin does not provide much of an inducement to cease and desist."
- jorgearturo 12y agoI feel bad for Lenovo's customers, but I also feel bad for people who bought Lenovo stock, thinking they were investing in smart people who wouldn't risk on such a shity strategy.