8 ms·
The Tech Worker Shortage Doesn't Really Exist
- mgirdley 12y agoRunning a coding school (Codeup), I get this email all the time from recruiters: "Dear xyz, I've been hired to fill this not-so-great job THIS WEEK and we want this crazy exclusive unicorn skillset that about a dozen people in the world have and, you know, we aren't going to pay much anywhere near going rate and we're going to hire as a contractor so we can fire you any time and we're not really interested in training a person who'd actually want this gig at the rate we're wanting to pay. So, do you know anyone?"
- lowglow 12y agoyeahhh... this happens. I don't get how companies want to compete for talent without paying a reasonable market rate. You should also add Codeup to https://schools.techendo.com/ https://schools.techendo.com/
- zyxley 12y agoJust as an individual, I get similar recruiter pings all the time. It's always contractor jobs (typically with a set term of 6 months and a "possibility" of longer-term work) with a tangential relation at best to the skillset and experience on my resume. The cherry on top is that the pay, if it's even outlined at all, is always insultingly low compared to the job I already have. On the upside, just mentioning my current salary to some of the please-call-me-I-have-just-the-job-for-you recruiters has been enough to make them stop trying to contact me at all.
- drivingmenuts 12y agoI get calls for potentially awesome jobs from people I can't fucking understand even though they're apparently speaking English. Not "don't want to understand" - literally, can't.
- jrochkind1 12y agoIf there was really a tech shortage -- and had been for years -- wouldn't the labor supply rise to meet demand? Wouldn't there be people willing to work less than the going rate (which is far above a living wage), wouldn't the going rate be dropping? I don't know the answer, I think what is going on may actually be kind of complicated. But that's the kind of question raised, you can't explain away the question of whether there's a shortage or not by saying "It's just that people aren't willing to pay the going rate."
- jacques_chester 12y ago> If there was really a tech shortage -- and had been for years -- wouldn't the labor supply rise to meet demand? Much of the demand for skilled labour is in the USA, much of the supply of it is not in the USA.
- runako 12y ago> Wouldn't there be people willing to work less than the going rate (which is far above a living wage), wouldn't the going rate be dropping? Possibly, except that there are a lot of pressures on people to move out of programming. Some examples: folks over 35 aren't welcome a lot of places; financial incentives often push programmers out of programming into e.g. project management. So you have a lot of people constantly leaving the field, somewhat by the design of the roles offered. Oh, and every programmer is reading HN trying to figure out how to start their own gig. Higher wages and other job fixes (e.g. security, status, professionalism) might bring a lot of these people back into the recruiting pool.
- gohrt 12y agoLuckily, 50 is the new 35, now that 35 year olds have figured out how to dress like 25 year olds at the office.
- killface 12y agoThe real problem is that to compete in today's world, your website: 1. Needs to have great design 2. Needs to be rock-solid in terms of stability 3. Needs to be snappy to use 4. Needs to be able to handle a Reddit traffic swarm 5. Needs to have individualization and customization 6. Needs to play nicely on computers, tablets, and phones The person (or people, more likely) who is good at all of this just isn't available at rates the companies want to pay. This is the important distinction. Hiring somebody for 100k/yr is pretty much the minimum ante for a good developer in a tech city. But these "entrepreneurs" and "founders" think that is too much money, and instead claim there's a shortage. In reality, if you're competing for top talent, 150k/yr should be your ante, and be prepared to go well into the 200s. This shouldn't be a surprise. To get even average talent from a consulting/contracting company, you're paying about 125/hr (of which 60-70 goes to the developer). That's 250k/yr. So why are companies freaking out at paying over 100k/yr for a full-time person who they can invest in? Hell, cut out the contractors and pay your people 200k/yr, and watch the good people come talk to you. This is what Amazon and the like are doing now. I'm hearing 22 year old kids who haven't coed a line of code in a professional capacity, getting offers of 120k/yr with a 20k signing bonus. Netflix pays a significant chunk of its engineers over 200k. The only real problem is that it's getting more expensive to do business in a tech world. But compare the skill sets that used to draw 100k/yr, and the skill sets now required to get 145k/yr (100k/yr in 1998 dollars = 144k in 2014 dollars). Before, you could just know HTML and some shell scripting. Now, you need to know multiple frameworks, how to deal with scalability, multiple data stores, "full stack," etc. If anything, the good talent in this industry is still dramatically under-paid. A common metric is that the company should make from you about 7x your salary to justify your position. So if a company is making 2.1 million, you should be getting 300k. But we all know that's not what's happening. Instead, our wages are being capped and forced down due to illegal collusion between the top tech employers. This all comes down to the people who own the businesses wanting to treat tech people as interchangeable cogs, despite all the evidence to the contrary.
- slantedview 12y agoThis comment exactly epitomizes the problems. It's not about supply - it's about price.
- dragonwriter 12y agoWith constant demand, supply determines price -- its about supply, and effect that has on price.
- bradhe 12y ago> we want this crazy exclusive unicorn skillset that about a dozen people in the world have Can you elaborate on this? Some specific examples? My hypothesis is the reality is that much of technology has become commotitized...and peoples' expectations for what they need don't line up with reality. Previously, this has to do with experience: We want to pay a senior java engineer with 10 years experience $75k. Rarely does it have to do with "skillset" outside of experience, as far as I've seen anyway.
- lowglow 12y agoHm. I don't know if it's a new shortage or not. But I'm currently hiring and finding good developers/engineers that are also a culture fit is pretty difficult. I guess it has always been this way since I moved to SF (~5 years ago). [edit] To clarify on 'culture fit' in my statement: Interesting, inspiring, nice, humble, pleasant to work with, eager to share knowledge, discover new things, understands our audience, who we are, and genuinely wants to further the vision of the entire startup. These are people that are going to help elevate the group together. I don't look at engineers as simply a commodity that can be replaced at a whim, but rather part of a symbiotic system that must transcends itself, grow, and evolve together in time.
- zyxley 12y ago> I guess it has always been this way since I moved to SF (~5 years ago). Are you accounting for the skyrocketing cost of living of SF? I'm guessing that (as the article suggests as a general case) there are plenty of good developers but they just plain want more money than you're offering.
- lowglow 12y agoThis is the difficult part. How do you accurately price for this market. I've tried salary searches across whatever job boards I have access to, but how can one be certain?
- zyxley 12y agoIf you're not getting enough people saying "yes", you're not offering enough money.
- irishcoffee 12y agoOr, there is a bubble about to pop.
- thirdtruck 12y agoCase in point: I've decided to pass over SF jobs categorically, based primarily on the costs of living.
- WalterBright 12y agoEconomically speaking, if the market is allowed to set the price, then shortages don't exist - the supply and demand curves cross. For example, if there were only 10 box folders in the world, you could get one if you were willing to pay more than about anyone else, hence no shortage. But from a pragmatic point of view, if the price is higher than you can reasonably afford to pay, then there's a shortage.
- fixedd 12y agoAs long as CEOs of the companies screaming that "there is a shortage and we desperately need H1Bs" have compensation packages that could pay for thousands of engineers I'm going to just go ahead and assume they've decided where their priorities lay.
- defen 12y agoThis is a very simple, basic argument that I've never seen addressed by people who want to bring in more foreign tech workers (for hiring purposes and not entrepreneurial ones) - the concept of a "shortage" of something in a free market is not a coherent one - it can only be addressed by supra-economic arguments. But no one ever wants to clarify what those are.
- jshen 12y ago"the concept of a "shortage" of something in a free market is not a coherent one" This is obviously wrong.
- defen 12y agoCan you give me an example of a legitimate shortage then, as defined in purely economic terms?
- analog31 12y agoThe typical Econ 101 view of supply and demand is a static model. It neglects time. Surpluses and shortages should be possible in any but the most trivial of dynamic systems. I'm not an economist, but I imagine an analogy to models of feedback systems that exhibit unstable behavior. Only the most simplistic systems can be made unconditionally stable.
- mbesto 12y ago> “It seems pretty clear that the industry just wants lower-cost labor,” It does, but that's not the issue. There is a shortage of good and qualified tech workers. Tech companies simply can't afford to pay whoever $120k/yr if their technology doesn't work.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoThis comes up a lot. The "qualification" clause. So whose fault is it there isn't a lot of qualification? Workers or Employers? What I've found hiring people into my organization is that there are many, perhaps dozens, of ways in which people develop software, all with a great analogy name from 'waterfall' to 'agile' to 'pair' to 'artisnal' to 'hacking' and back again. They come with different ideas about what is expected of the engineer and what is expected of the manager. Have a standup meeting every week? Great, what are you achieving by that? Getting everyone on the same page? ok, but what about the guy off site? How about folks who work best in quiet offices, or those who work best in a noisy free-for-all, do you playfully criticize each other over bugs or do you have elaborate silent shunning rituals. The reality is that everyone I hire seems to come from a different school of training about how to be effective at programming, what does that say about qualification? This last job of mine has been my first extended stint at managing engineers and I have learned so much about what folks can and cannot be expected to understand or know before coming to the company. It has given me a lot of appreciation for the intake process that I didn't really have before.
- napoleond 12y agoI wish I could upvote this twice. Is it possible that the real shortage is in competent technical managers?
- nikcub 12y agoThe shortage of competent technical managers is massive. If you have the bare essentials of communication and project management skills, plus tech and have a good network to bring developers in - you're getting your email box torn apart with offers at the moment and wages are insane. The real tech shortage is in project management, VP Engineering, product management, experienced multi-stack or vertical developer roles. It is really far from indicative to compare all of STEM.
- dominotw 12y agoI've been seeing a version of this every month for past 10 years or so. H1B in my view is new Ellis Island. Stopping H1B == Stopping all immigration to US. People often say they support legal immigration but don't support H1B. What are the other alternatives to H1B to immigrate to America?(I am not talking about Nobel Laureates or Olympic athletes, I am talking about common folk who showed up at Ellis Island). Immigration is one of those things where everyone who got in wants to shut the door behind them.( "I(or my ancestors) got a shot at a better life, fuck you the door is now closed.")
- ForHackernews 12y ago> What are the other alternatives to H1B to immigrate to America? You can enter the lottery: http://www.usagc.org/USA-immigration.aspx http://www.usagc.org/USA-immigration.aspx
- presty 12y agonot if you're from one of those popular countries (China, India, Brazil, etc) that are ineligible
- gamesbrainiac 12y agoBangladesh has been recently added to the ineligible list.
- maerF0x0 12y agoEven your neighbors cannot enter the lottery. Canadians are pretty dang close to Americans, lots of us have family on both sides of the border, we speak the same language, have very similar media, similar education systems etc. etc. And yet we're not allowed to come to your country for much more than a few months at a time. Oddly we _are_ allowed to get a TN visa, in some circumstances, build up some wealth over a 3 yrs span and then we're promptly booted _out_ of the country with bags of money instead of being allowed to stay and spend it. strange strategy.
- 12y ago
- andyl 12y ago> "The real issue, say Salzman and others, is the industry’s desire for lower-wage, more-exploitable guest workers, not a lack of available American staff. 'It seems pretty clear that the industry just wants lower-cost labor'" That has to be BS. Industry leaders and investors want to expand the labor pool in the name of diversity, not to suppress wages. It's all about justice, not profits. Someone better flag/kill this article, I'm offended.
- fixedd 12y agoYou must have missed the revelation back at the beginning of the year that some of the biggest players in the tech world were caught in an illegal cartel to suppress tech-worker wages. So, there's that.
- arcosdev 12y agowhat candy land do you live in?
- powertower 12y agoAfter doing a double-take on it, I'm sure the post is sarcasm.
- gonzi25 12y agoSarcasm generally doesn't go over too well over here..
- slantedview 12y agoToo many crazy posters who are dead serious.
- andyl 12y agono it doesn't!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gonzi25 12y agoI get several emails from recruiters each week, almost none of them include a salary range at all.. I won't even respond.
- jshen 12y agoThat's short sighted.
- sroussey 12y agoPerhaps, but it can also be a good filter. Experience replying to the messages would tell.
- jshen 12y agoI've had some rather amazing opportunities that came without a salary range in the initial email. Using that as the primary factor is surely suboptimal.
- gonzi25 12y agoI agree, but having to spend the time on the phone with them or writing up a crafty email where I actually don't use 'hello $NAME' just to find out the salary range would be nice.
- cheepin 12y agoDefinitely true, but if America can't figure out basic rights like privacy there will soon come a time where it doesn't matter how many H1B visas are issued. However, in light of recent corporation missteps like the Google and friends wage suppression scheme, I don't think gifting them a bunch of cheap labor is the right choice. edit: Clarification. I am referring to privacy breaches causing a lack of trust in American tech companies by consumers, not whether they will be able to hire foreign workers.
- irishcoffee 12y agoBecause the US is the only country hiring. Because the US is the only place Google has employees. Because Google pays taxes in the US.
- frozenport 12y agoI suspect the many immigrants from Asia, and China in particular don't give a damn.
- philwelch 12y ago> “There’s no evidence of any way, shape, or form that there’s a shortage in the conventional sense,” says Hal Salzman, a professor of planning and public policy at Rutgers University. “They may not be able to find them at the price they want. But I’m not sure that qualifies as a shortage, any more than my not being able to find a half-priced TV.” I'm not sure how many developers Hal Salzman has tried to hire, but I find a lot more of them are weeded out at the "seeing if they can code their way out of a wet paper bag" stage than at the "salary negotiation" stage.
- Iftheshoefits 12y agoGiven the ridiculous technical and interview "requirements" that have been part of tech for the last several years I'm inclined to have as much sympathy for your statement as I do for companies complaining about tech worker shortage. Companies want ridiculous breadth of expertise (the ubiquitous "alphabet soup" listing of technologies), graduate level understanding of often irrelevant and unrelated algorithms and data structures, and a host of other absurdities for things like putting together a damn online shopping cart or, worse, a to-do list.
- ef4 12y agoMost people can't FizzBuzz. That's not ridiculous breadth of expertise. My basic filter question was always this: in any language you know, write a function that reverses a string. No tricks, no gotchas. Any reasonable solution will be discussed briefly and then we'll move on to discuss other things. But a shocking fraction of people -- even ones with CS degrees from fancy schools -- would spend 30 minutes stuck trying to write that function. That's what I think of when I hear "can't code their way out of a wet paper bag".
- nradov 12y agoWell what did you expect? CS education is usually mostly theoretical and not about practical code construction. Would you interview a Physics graduate and then complain that she didn't know how to design a bridge? In the early days of computing IBM hired candidates with the right aptitude but zero programming skills and then trained them. It Worked out fine.
- mattxxx 12y agoWell, the reality is that every company is becoming a tech company. Text Book Publisher -> E-learning Platform Mass Marketing -> Mass Emailing Hotel Booking -> App for Hotel Booking While there probably is no shortage of tech workers, finding ones that aren't going to mass-code unreliable software then leave the company is fucking hard.
- andylei 12y ago> Further, he and his co-authors found, only half of STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) college graduates each year get hired into STEM jobs Maybe those graduates aren't any good. > “We don’t dispute the fact at all that Facebook (FB) and Microsoft (MSFT) would like to have more, cheaper workers," ... “But that doesn’t constitute a shortage.” I'm not really sure how that squares with the fact that only half of STEM graduates were hired. Why didn't facebook and microsoft just offer those graduates cheapo salaries? Because most of the time, these workers aren't interchangeable cogs. A degree doesn't mean you can do work in the industry effectively. Maybe there are billions of STEM graduates, but if only 100 can do the job, there's still a shortage.
- jtbigwoo 12y ago> > Further, he and his co-authors found, only half of STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) college graduates each year get hired into STEM jobs > Maybe those graduates aren't any good. In my experience, it's because companies don't want to pay to train somebody in all the basics of office work. New grads (especially STEM grads) don't know how to run a meeting, write a status report, or do a thousand other things that a modern company requires. Instead they list job openings for two or three years of experience and hope to profit off of somebody else's investment.
- philwelch 12y agoCompanies tend to have special intake systems for college graduates. Plus, a new grad shouldn't be totally clueless in terms of how to work in an office; they should have had at least one internship.
- serge2k 12y agoBut the companies complaining about shortages (microsoft, facebook, etc...) are the same ones who are willing to hire new grads.
- gonzi25 12y ago1 out of 300 offers is really low assuming you're doing 2-3 screens then a ~5 panel onsite after that. I'd be seriously concerned with your sourcers.
- rubyn00bie 12y agoWe add immense value, yet we seen almost none of the profit of that value. Underpaid to say the least-- especially considering the value of money has steadily declined (overall) since 1972. I saw a number someone quotes in a comment of _$120,000_ but it doesn't go as far as it did in the nineties. Realistically, that wage should be closer to $180k or more now-a-days-- but it's not. Plus the real moral of the story is: your business is either capital intensive, or labor intensive. Software Tech isn't really capital intensive (per dollar) but is extremely labor intensive. If tech companies want more talent perhaps they shouldn't build their campuses on some of the most expensive land in the country. That'd probably save a lot right there. I'd be willing to bet Facebook wants more H1-Bs because it helps their bottom line (decreasing costs), which increases their profit margin, which increases their stock price... A dollar saved, is a dollar earned-- ask an accountant.
- 3EAFC164D817 12y ago> We add immense value, yet we seen almost none of the profit of that value. Underpaid to say the least-- especially considering the value of money has steadily declined (overall) since 1972. You will be paid in technology in financial services [if you are worth it].
- dmourati 12y agoI'm sorry, I don't understand this statement.
- 3EAFC164D817 12y agoThe parent claims tech workers are underpaid. The thesis of my statement is that if you are a tech worker in financial services, you will be paid fairly. Just because some parts of the market may be dislocated does not mean there are not fair paying jobs to be had.
- bluthru 12y ago>If tech companies want more talent perhaps they shouldn't build their campuses on some of the most expensive land in the country. That'd probably save a lot right there. It's expensive because it's desirable. Much of today's workforce doesn't want to live in the suburbs and drive to an office park. Living in a vibrant urban area is part of compensation for many.
- pm90 12y agoI'm increasingly agitated by these commentators on the topic, who have absolutely no idea what the ground reality is. Frequently, as in this case, they also seem to conflate two different problems: shortage of IT workers and shortage of software developers. A software developer cannot be asked to manage a linux database; I mean she can, but that is not what she is good at. Conversely, an IT person cannot be asked to architect the backed of a payment gateway system. Of course there is some overlap (devops is what comes to mind). I'm guessing that most of FB/MS employees are probably developers, so when they mention IT workers in the same breath as shortage at FB/MS, they are exposing their ignorance. Furthermore, the paper itself seems to be published as a "report" on the page of a dubious organizations. Come on journalists, please do some actual journalism! Ask more people than those who confirm what your story wants to show. Find and determine the truth of the story; that is what you are paid for! edit: as I suspected, most of the funding for this "institute" comes from labor unions. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_Policy_Institute#Funding http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_Policy_Institute#Fundi...
- fixedd 12y agoWhat, precisely, is a "linux database"?
- pm90 12y agoApologies, I meant a database running on a linux system.
- fixedd 12y agoMaybe I've just been lucky with the coworkers I've had, or maybe the problems I've been working on aren't as hard as they seem, but in all the jobs I've worked we have never needed someone specifically trained on how to (per your example) manage a MySQL database running on one or more Linux systems. I think I'd argue that any mid-to-senior-level developer who can't manage to figure it out in a few days is underexperienced or undereducated, where "database use" is within their domain.
- nathanvanfleet 12y agoI was pretty surprised at the level of skill that the hired programmers at my company had. And I imagined it was because it's just hard to find anyone. But I'm not sure if it's just a Montreal Canada problem where the talent left for elsewhere or if the quality is just never good.
- ankurpatel 12y agoThis is very correct. I feel in East Coast and other parts of US besides California companies are underpaying their engineers and expect to get talented people for a low annual salary. From experience this is especially true in New York City where engineers in big banks get underpaid a lot and could earn double the salary if they worked in California.
- ankurpatel 12y agoThis is very correct. I feel in East Coast and other parts of US besides California companies are underpaying their engineers and expect to get talented people for a low annual salary. From experience this is especially true in New York City where engineers in big banks get underpaid a lot and could earn double the salary if they worked in California.
- dagobert63 12y agoI think several people mentioned this separately: Yes I agree there are no shortage of people with CS degree the question is 1) Can they code their way out of an interview. Turns out many people can’t, even though they held a “senior” title in another company. They can’t solve a simple linked list problem 2) Living cost of where the company is hiring 100K in Atlanta goes farther than 120K in SF or in Seattle. I can rent a 2 bedroom town house in a good neighborhood in Atlanta for 1200$ Vs. you MAY be able to find a 1 bedroom apartment in Seattle for 1700$ – 2000$. 3) Some companies have very unrealistic expectations, they want a person with all the experience in the world, which is just not gonna happen. Personally if I am looking at a candidate I will look at how he approaches a problem, I will throw him some curve-balls and if he can handle it they he will be fine. We are in a world where the technology changes rapidly, a tech/language/skill-set that is popular today might not worth a dime tomorrow. If you learned how to learn and adapt you will be fine.
- chralieboy 12y agoIt is a quality, not a quantity problem. At a previous company I interviewed hundreds for engineering positions (Ruby & Rails or JS/Backbone.) Our average was 1 offer extended for every 300 phone screens. The problem wasn't that we extended 50 offers and got rejected; money was not a part of the equation. We simply couldn't find the quality we were looking for. Specifically, coding schools have capitalized on the gluttony of open positions, but don't actually go towards solving the problem. There isn't a shortage of bodies, there is a shortage of experienced developers.
- coldcode 12y agoWhere was this previous company located?
- hiou 12y agoSerious question: Why did it never occur that you might need to take in a less experienced developer and train them? Wouldn't it make sense that there are no experienced developers available because they are currently fully employed?
- nathanvanfleet 12y agoI work with less experienced developers. They really put a drag on the project. They need to be watched and you have to give a lot of pointers and refactoring suggestions. And then their tasks just don't end up coming in fast enough either. Personally I think I'd learn a lot more if I was working with more advanced devs where I could learn from them than seeing the mistakes I would have made years ago.
- vonmoltke 12y agoSo, basically you are saying you want to be the less-experienced dev, but not work with them. I think the prevalence of this attitude is a key part of the problem.
- Bahamut 12y agoAnd then a more advanced dev might say the same of you. People should come first. Everyone has to start from the beginning at some point.
- hiou 12y ago> Asked what evidence existed of a labor shortage, a spokesperson for Facebook e-mailed a one-sentence statement: “We look forward to hearing more specifics about the President’s plan and how it will impact the skills gap that threatens the competitiveness of the tech sector.” For companies like Google and Facebook, which place such strong emphasis on data in making decisions, its very telling how little data they have presented to support their claims.
- smtddr 12y agoI'm still of the mindset that the problem is transportation in the Bay Area. If I had a magic wand and I could wave it and we all woke up tomorrow to a nonstop-bullet-BART train that goes 100mph from San Francisco to Mountain View, Palo Alto, San Ramon, Danville, Cupertino, Daly City, Foster City, Redwood city, San Jose and the Persidio and we had some kind of crazy zipline thing that gets you within 1/2 mile of any location within SF, this perceived shortage wouldn't exist. The problem is salary compared to cost-of-living in desired locations. And those locations are mostly desired, IMHO, because nobody wants to deal with a commute. My LinkedIn clearly states that I won't accept any job outside of walking distance of a BART station regardless of salary. What I'd like to see is a poll of HN users that look like this: You want to live in $DESIRED_LOCATION because: A. I love $DESIRED_LOCATION and want to be surrounded by its vibe 24/7. B. $DESIRED_LOCATION is a reasonable commute to/from my job. C. $DESIRED_LOCATION is a reasonable distance between job & loved ones.
- NhanH 12y agoThere are 65000 H1B visa issued a year (and 20000 more for Master & higher degree holders). H1B visa is 3 years, extendable to 6 years, with a maximum of 10 years. But I'd think most people don't stay on the H1B more than 6 years. So there's approximately 65000 * 6 = 400000 H1B visa holders in the US. For size comparison, there are about ~240millions adults in working age in the US. And the possible amnesty from the executive order a few days ago would cover some where from ~4-5 millions people. I'm not actually sure what's the point I should be making here. I guess it just feel to me that in the grand scheme of things, the number of H1B visas is tiny tiny. It's just incredibly sad to me to see on HN that someone would be concerned about H1B taking over US's jobs (or repressing the wage - which is the same, just lesser extreme than "taking US's jobs").
- sounds 12y agoI'm not concerned about H1B's taking over US jobs. I can understand that labor unions want to push that message in the same breath they decry US immigration laws. I am concerned that H1B's are indentured servitude. That term has a meaning, and no, it's not slavery, but if you will be deported upon losing your job that's a little more than just "out of a job." So H1B's are not a fair way to bring in talent from around the world. Not Tech Companies' fault, though, if they hire talented people this way. It _is_ Washington's fault, since they are the ones creating the artificial scarcity in the first place (and turning a blind eye to the actual solutions for such a long time that it can't be ascribed to incompetence). On the other hand, Tech Companies _are_ guilty of wage fixing. They got caught. Some did the right thing and raised wages. Some didn't. The economy is tough, so the incentives are all there for the company to keep payroll down. That's not a reason to unionize the software industry. That's just all the more reason to start your own company. Startups have successfully challenged the incumbents and won, especially in software. It's still open season. Good luck!
- gabbo 12y agoYour point may be valid, but the math is a little off. If you're an H1B holder going through the employment-based green card process (which could take anywhere from months to 10+ years), you can extend your H1B beyond the 6 year cutoff in 1 or 3 year increments depending on where you are in the process. A former boss of mine was on H1B from India (big tech company and he wasn't even remotely underpaid) for 12 years, most of that time waiting for a green card.
- ykumar6 12y agoThis article is ridiculous. As a founder of a small startup in the bay-area, I can tell you it's absolutely impossible to find mid-level engineers experienced with Javascript, Node, Go, RoR, etc. And if you can, you're paying 30-50% more than just a year ago.
- epicureanideal 12y agoI assume you mean JavaScript and one of Node, Go, RoR, etc. as a server-side language. If you mean the subset of engineers who are proficient in all of those, then that's a pretty small set, but I assume you don't. What is your standard for a mid-level engineer, and what would their salary range be? If I were to introduce you to some mid-level or upper-level talent, would you pay typical recruiting fees plus provide some employment security to my associates who pass your hiring process? Some startups have high turnover and I wouldn't want to damage their career if you change your mind after hiring them.
- slantedview 12y agoYou are trying to hire in one of the most expensive areas IN THE WORLD. Does the compensation you're offering reflect that? Mid level engineers are obviously not hard to find. But in a market where tons of companies choose to locate themselves, and where the cost of living is massively high, engineers will tend to go where the pay is high and/or the product/tech is compelling enough to compensate for the massively high cost of living. This is to be expected, and has nothing to do with the supply of engineers.
- Bahamut 12y agoYou can always go out of the area and relocate professionals. There are some very talented people outside of the Bay Area who want to move here who can be swayed to making the change. But if you want good, you better be prepared to create the environment those will want to work in.
- jandrewrogers 12y agoThe article is rendered worthless by making the same flawed assumptions most of these articles make: - No one is claiming there is a "STEM shortage". There is a shortage of qualified software engineers. STEM includes an abundance of marine biologists, aerospace engineers, astronomers, and myriad other subfields with poor job prospects that are in no way qualified to fill the shortage that actually exists in other STEM subfields. - The category of "IT worker" sweeps up a lot of low-skill jobs that have nothing to do with software engineering. Maybe the low-skill jobs are not making great money but software engineers qualified enough to get a job easily make six-figures where I live, and I do not live in Silicon Valley. The oppression and slavery are palpable. - Training to become a qualified software engineer is not like training to operate a backhoe. It is not just about "being good with computers". Tool chains you can learn over weeks or months, but developing domain competence useful to an organization can take years. By analogy, both chemists and chemical engineers deal with designing chemical reactions, but neither can do the job of the other without a couple years of additional training even though they are both just making chemicals. Most companies will not pay to train a chemist to become a chemical engineer when they need a chemical engineer now. Every article like this that conflates software engineers with "STEM jobs" or "IT workers" isn't really talking about software engineers.
- nradov 12y agoThere is no shortage of qualified software engineers. As a hiring manager I have been able to find as many as I need, at the market price. Anyone can do the same.
- fredophile 12y agoThe article makes a really common mistake by confusing STEM and coding. A surplus of people graduating with STEM degrees doesn't say anything about whether or not there is a shortage of coders. I only have anecdotal data but I'll bet if you break it down you'd find that there are some STEM majors that have way more people than there are jobs for. This is especially true in majors where you need a grad degree to find real work in your field. I'd also guess that there are more coding jobs than CS degrees due to people coming out of coding schools and other degrees that tend to have a lot of crossover like math.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoI would bet 80-90% of STEM grads could be trained to code. If there's a true shortage, train some of those unemployed STEM people up. Invest some money in them.
- fredophile 12y agoIf they want to learn to code there are plenty of options. Do you expect companies like Facebook or Google to hire a bunch of biologists so they can send them to a coding bootcamp?
- waterlesscloud 12y agoIf the employers are truly desperate, they should be considering the option. Or I suppose they can just do without if they want to be stubborn.
- fredophile 12y agoLet's assume that they do this and check how the numbers work out. Say the program takes six months and they pay candidates $50000 a year while they're taking it. Google is notorious for preferring false negatives in their interview process to making bad hires so maybe 1 in 10 candidates gets offered a job at the end. The program also costs money to run. They need teaching staff, computers, space, etc. You're easily at over $300 000 and six months latency to get one junior programmer. Alternatively, they could offer someone more senior a $200 000 signing bonus, save a bunch of money and hire someone experienced. Which do you think is a better way to invest their recruiting money?
- vinceguidry 12y agoInformation technology is much harder than people think. It's so hard that management techniques evolved over millenia of human economic activity just plain don't work when you apply them to computing. Us tech workers take The Mythical Man-Month as obvious, no shit how could software work any other way, but throwing more resources at a problem has always worked to clear it, until now. It wasn't pretty, some of the bridges built like that are probably aren't going to last forever like they were designed to, but it worked. The reason BigCorps are looking to indentured laborers is not because technology workers are hard to find, but because technology management at scale is horrendously inefficient, but being managers, they don't really know that. More importantly, they'd have no real answer to it even if they did. The only lever they have in the face of this is cutting costs so that each individual failure doesn't hurt the bottom line so much. The personal answer to this dynamic is to get out of these labor markets. The products produced by these companies will always be terrible. I don't understand why people still want to work at Google and Microsoft, it's basically factory work now, the glory days are gone. Let the people motivated to escape poverty do it. The talent market has already started to fracture into a higher-tier professional caste and the lower-tier grunt caste. The professionals will slowly accrete into a Hollywood-style guild system serving anyone that wants to be on the leading edge of technology while the grunt-employing BigCorps will just keep pushing the state of the art of paying nine women to have one baby in one month.
- sroussey 12y agoThe real shortage is in bankers. Just look at pricing. Engineers are so much cheaper. We should worry about importing more bankers and traders. Those salaries are a sure indicator that there is a far larger shortage in that industry.
- ericd 12y agoYeah, good point. Extreme salaries are oftentimes evidence of a high-leverage industry, where you want a limited number of the absolute best people, rather than one in which you just need more people than you can get. CEOs, movie, and musical stars are other examples.
- ohazi 12y agoAlso in this particular example it's a zero sum game. The firm has so much money to gamble with, and the proceeds are distributed among the the bankers. More bankers --> smaller bonuses.
- dragonwriter 12y agoCEOs, movie, and musical stars are not industries. They are job titles/descriptions of the people at the pinnacle of certain career tracks (CEOs) or industries (movie/music stars) Business generalists, actors, and musicians generally -- the professions/industries as a whole, rather than just the titles at the top -- get paid a lot less.
- ericd 12y agoSorry, misspoke, but you know what I meant. Salaries are only absurd near the top of the software industry. It's certainly better distributed than those other industries, though.
- titanomachy 12y agoImagine how absurd that headline would be... "Financial industry declares severe shortage in investment banking workforce -- urges swift government action".
- dethstar 12y agoWhat's with taxes for offshoring for America? I'm guessing it isn't that bad since a lot of IT/desk-help and what not have been offshored for a while now. Whenever I read posts of "they want to pay us less" online I try to understand, why wouldn't a company simply offshore it? I live in Mexico, and when I was looking for jobs there were a lot of "nearshoring" (just like offshore but sometimes a business guy will go across either border.) companies, so it's clearly not that rare. Why? Because they can afford the same for less (due to exchange rates and what not) So I wonder why they'd move a lot of "talent" there instead of paying them less (but still considerably more than what an average person gets here) to work for them? Why go through all the trouble of even suggesting reforms and what not? There's got to be more to it, no?
- slantedview 12y agoWhen it comes to economic decisions, supply/demand is only one factor. Price always matters - because businesses that choose to locate in high cost of living areas are hiring human beings who have their own to pay, and regardless of how many engineers exist in the market, those expenses are fixed. So either companies pay up to get employees who can afford 3k/month 1 bedroom apartments near their SF office, or they don't. There are solutions to this problem, but it's not a supply problem.
- chuckcode 12y agoFrom my standpoint the problem with H-1B and other visas in the US immigration system isn't that we're issuing too many but rather that they tie the workers to a particular company in a way that prevents them from changing jobs easily if they are underpaid. Personally I feel really lucky as a US citizen that incredibly talented people from all over the world are leaving their families to come here and contribute to our workforce. Even if you feel differently I think there is no reason to tie visas to a particular company as it prevents the market from working efficiently. Tech companies have already admitted to price fixing for wages [1] and the H-1B visa can certainly act as a way to prevent other companies from easily hiring your workforce. [1] http://time.com/76655/google-apple-settle-wage-fixing-lawsuit/ http://time.com/76655/google-apple-settle-wage-fixing-lawsui...
- pixel 12y agoThere is no shortage of computer programmers. There is a distinct shortage of _good_ programmers.
- wyclif 12y ago"There's no shortage of smart, hardworking engineers. There's a shortage of smart, hardworking engineers willing to work for very little money." ~ David "Pardo" Keppel
- hw 12y agoI'm not exactly sure there's a shortage in tech workers. There is however, a shortage in quality tech workers. I have been on the interview loop at my company and we've been having lots of new college grads and junior software engineers (and a handful of senior ones) who come in for interviews, but only ~10% of them are quality. As for H1Bs taking up American jobs, I'm also not sure that's really an issue. Assuming H1Bs were abolished, and existing H1Bs were told to go back to their countries, would companies be able to fill that void - are there actually that many skilled tech workers out there that aren't H1B? I'm curious....
- x0x0 12y agoIf wages rise there are. There's a giant pool of highly skilled workers -- including friends of mine who've left the bay area -- living in the south, west, and midwest, because of the insane cost of living in the bay area. Fix that, and I personally know 4 very good senior (10+ years) engineers who would happily move back. But not for $120k, and not even for $200k, as long as a 3 bed condo on the peninsula costs $800k and comes with a 1.5 to 2 hour commute into sf for both parents.
- freshflowers 12y agoThe same combination of separate issues keeps polluting the debate. 1. There is no STEM shortage, there's a shortage of a particular subset of STEM-related skills, most notably software development (which btw is a skill barely even taught even in CS, and certainly not filtered for, leading to people with CS degrees that can't code their way out of a paper bag). Even within just IT, software development stands out by a mile in all stats when it comes to the imbalance between jobs and candidates. 2. Wages are being artificially kept down despite the shortage. Migrant visa's are one of the things being abused to depress wages. The fact that this is happening during a shortage is remarkable and confusing, but can be explained by fear (wages will explode sooner or later, and this terrifies many employers) and by the low social standing of software developers (even within IT software developers have for the longest time been known as the code monkeys at the bottom of the hierarchy, just above the support people) which leads to even developers themselves not questioning their salaries. Salaries that tend to be pretty decent, but well below what should be the market value.
- ulfw 12y agoThere isn't a Tech Worker shortage if you're willing to be outside the Bay Area or even outside the country. You're getting great developers in places around the world for reasonable prices. Those places just aren't San Francisco. Getting a developer in a mega-priced city and then hoping to pay less, that is not going to work well. And frankly that is not what H1Bs should be for.
- jdawg77 12y agoFor what it's worth, thought I'd drop a bit of my story here since April. I interviewed at Dropbox, ebay, Netflix and others after losing my job. American, FWIW, with a California birth certificate and everything if it matters. Did I get a job offer? Not a single one. More than a dozen interviews, zero offers but I can find consulting offers (with far, far lower hourly wage than in 2006-2009 last time I did consulting). I have friends who have been unable to find work also, with skills, experience and blue chip, so to speak, resumes. Somehow saying we need more skilled workers when folks in Silicon Valley with a decade of experience who have worked for, and been given awards by, the biggest names in tech only means that employers want it cheaper. A friend on an H1B who lost their job? Gainfully employed in less than a month after losing theirs, then again, they have to be seriously motivated else they get shipped away. Until the new immigration policy gets passed where we export jobless Californians to Oregon, my only option was to rebuild a consulting business. Funniest thing is, now that I'm an "Agency," again, I've had a list of people wanting me to hire them. So it certainly feels like there is a lot more unemployment out there than what I read in the media, at least with my experience...of course, YMMV.
- pm90 12y agoI'm sorry, I don't think your not being offered a job has anything to do with your nationality. You might not be what they are looking for, plain and simple. I wondered since you have 10 years of experience and are probably interviewing for a senior position, maybe these were being filled with H1B workers? From anecdotal evidence, that does not seem to be the case. Every company I've worked for has had ~90% senior devs Americans. Management has been even more so. I might be wrong here, but I thought H1B labor was overwhelmingly being used to fill lower paid, entry level or short-project kinda work and not being used to replace full time employment. Again, from anecdotal evidence, most companies I've worked with have always tried to hire domestically. And many of the jobs I've applied to, the recruiter outright told me that they wouldn't even consider noncitizens/non-gc holders.
- jdawg77 12y agoI could be a full blown (insert explitive here) but I won't mention the name of the company that they got hired at. Ironically, I also interviewed at same company, though six months prior when I had a full time job. Immigration is a tricky, tricky issue. When living overseas, the ambassador from another country dropped a proverbial bombshell about the human trafficking in the country where I lived. To whit, when living in Costa Rica myself, I only found out on exit from the country my former employer never got me a work permit - eg, I was working there illegally. I'd love to say yes, no fault of my own, but I should have investigated the situation myself. Lesson learned. So having worked in labor myself a bit (helping people get jobs) and been on multiple sides of various business disputes in various countries...well, the situation in US employment in Silicon Valley is quite puzzling.