7 ms·
Quantitative easing, Yen depreciation... What they need to do is figure out a way to grow the population locally or through large-scale immigration. I'm afrai
by mc32 12y ago
Quantitative easing, Yen depreciation...
What they need to do is figure out a way to grow the population locally or through large-scale immigration. I'm afraid this is the fate that awaits the developed world (or countries with low population growth).
Japan is like a canary in the mine of post-industrialism. It'll be interesting to see what they figure out for their society and the lessons they might have for us.
- gst 12y ago> What they need to do is figure out a way to grow the population locally or through large-scale immigration. That doesn't sound like a long-term solution. There'll be a limit to population growth at some point.
- mc32 12y agoYes, you're right. It depends on what we mean by long term. In the end we'll hit some natural population limits. It'll be interesting what they devise in order to have a viable economy in conjunction with a stagnant or declining population. We can all learn from their success or failure in that regard.
- sliverstorm 12y agoWell, their population looks about ready to take a nosedive, so it's not like they "just aren't growing fast enough".
- mc32 12y agoBe that as it may, the other option, to export their way out of this is not going to happen. They are not a cheap-labor based economy --and they don't have known viable reserves of natural resources. So, what are they to do?
- waps 12y agoThe general answer every country seems to have is "knowledge-based economy". Except it never works. Knowledge flees countries the moment it presents more than a small advantage, as the knowledge moves with workers and companies.
- alex_anglin 12y agoExport creative products or develop intellectual property?
- dmritard96 12y agoI really hope that we do not rely on population growth to stimulate or sustain an economy for too much longer. At some point humans will need to think about carrying capacity and understand how to structurally reconfigure such that we can maintain a high quality of life for us and other earth inhabitants.
- chvid 12y agoHad it not been for immigration from the 3rd world most 1st world countries would have a population in decline.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoWith the way Japanese society feels about immigrants, I doubt it'd be politically palatable.
- tormeh 12y agoI agree, but QE is not a dumb idea per se, it's just the way that it's done is severely lacking. What you want is inflation, which means you want to increase the amount of money in circulation. A simple way to do that is for the central bank to make money up and give, say, 20000 yen to each citizen every year until deflation went away. This is called a helicopter drop in finance-speak, and seen as very radical. Deflation should be cause for celebration: It means the central bank can print money without hurting the economy. The money thus printed could be used for all kinds of good purposes, but it's not done. I guess the reason helicopter drops are not done is that it kinda breaks some illusions people have with money. People generally don't know that central banks buy second hand government bonds, basically giving money to those who hold that kind of asset. In short, there's no law of physics that say you have to work for money. I guess they don't think the plebes would respond well to knowing this.
- techdragon 12y agoAustralia did one and it worked wonderfully. We rode out most of the brunt of the impact of the 2008 'GFC' with little disaster. The worst of it for most of us was that getting a home loan got a bit tougher, but really this was more a case of returning to earlier norms than really getting "harder"
- zeyus 12y agoAustralia has just delayed it, we are still letting people borrow more money than they can ever hope to repay (interest only loans on owner occupied places) now with our relationship with China growing tenuous (they're making deals with the USA and Russia instead of Australia), it spells bad news.
- adventured 12y agoTo what extent does Australia's tie to the Chinese economy deserve primary credit for Australia weathering the GFC?
- cylinder 12y agoAustralia did it by increasing immigration which is only a temporary solution. GDP per capita fell in the GFC.
- georgeecollins 12y agoI agree that Japan (and the US) would benefit from more immigration for a lot of reasons. But if you can only grow your economy by adding people, you aren't really increasing per-capita income, at least for the working class.
- nandemo 12y ago> you aren't really increasing per-capita income, Even countries that are relatively open to (legal) immigration, like Canada and Australia, tend to limit immigration to working-age adults qualified to work in technical, professional or otherwise white-collar jobs. So I think it's fair to say that you do increase per-capita income. I wouldn't put the US in the same boat as Japan, though. Between green cards and naturalizations, the US receives well over 1 million immigrants per year (that doesn't count non-immigrant visas like H1B etc): http://www.voanews.com/content/us-issues-million-green-cards-and-naturalizes-757000-in-2012/1627155.html http://www.voanews.com/content/us-issues-million-green-cards...
- techdragon 12y agoImmigration is painfully unlikely due to cultural issues. It's oft suggested by non Japanese people looking at the problem but at least from what I can see, the majority of the Japanese voting public don't want immigration. There's reasons if you want a fun read. Particularly interesting is the history of people of Korean decent who are native Japanese residents for a generation or two.
- mc32 12y agoIt's true Japanese aren't very accepting of immigration, historically --and having to be blood to be a true national is a bit of an odd theory for citizenship; however, unless they (or anyone else) devise an alternative to neo-liberal capitalism which provides a decent living for its population while that population is in decline, the Japanese may have to reconsider their position on immigration.
- mimighost 12y agoWell if they change their mind on immigration, they better be quick. Japan's neighboring countries are quickly catching up, if not surpassing, in a lot of respects, such as PPI and HDI. Even in China, on the east coast, in certain sector, especially high-tech and finance, local companies can offer competitive salary and a better potential for career progress. It is not like in 80s, when Japan is the envy of all kids in the class, the interests is quickly fading, with a aging population and stale economy.
- MarkMc 12y agoIf neighbouring Asians are too rich to immigrate, there will still be plenty of poor Africans for decades.
- mimighost 12y agoWell, lets face it.If Japan is so reluctant to accept Chinese/Korean/Other Asians, whose appearance and culture are perhaps much closer to its own than other countries, it will only be harder for it to embrace the rest of the world. It is pretty much like Asians in US sometimes being called as perpetual foreigners, even if some of them might been in this continent for generations. Assume Japan is ever going to change its immigration policy, it will surely starts from developed countries and its neighboring states. But as I said in the above comment, the charm around Japan is vanishing, so even with a more friendly immigration policy, how much it could help Japan step out of painful declining is questionable.
- bpodgursky 12y agoLarge scale immigration is just passing the buck down onto a currently-poorer country. But poor countries aren't going to stay human-meat factories forever, and sooner rather than later someone is going to have to figure out a way to maintain an industrialized society with a stable population.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoThe end of consumerism, less income inequality, and automation. I must just not understand. It seems pretty simple.
- mc32 12y agoRight, but point me to a society that's been able to make that work. The formula has yet to be cracked.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoShow me a society/country who has actually made a go at making it work in the last 40 years. If you're not attempting to execute theory in the real world, you're not trying hard enough.
- mc32 12y agoI'm not sure I'd agree with you. It's not the kind of thing you try in order to see if it sticks. Communism tried with two out of your three criteria and it didn't turn out all that well --mostly ended up a terrible 'experiment' for those whom it affected. So, I don't think 'trying' is the way to go, when otherwise what you have is working well enough. That said, Japan has to try something --they are entering 25 years of being in a standstill, so relatively speaking, they are in decline. They (politicians and population, by large) may not have the will to try anything radically different from the status quo --which is a quasi neo-liberal economic model, so they may just end up crashing hard or slowly becoming kind of irrelevant, economically speaking.
- 12y ago
- minikomi 12y agoAs someone who has lived in Japan for the past 8 years.. I still feel like an outsider in many many ways. Unfortunate to have to say it, but there's much deeper issues than immigration law at play.
- ekianjo 12y ago> It'll be interesting to see what they figure out for their society and the lessons they might have for us. What makes you think they will find a "smart way out" of the situation ? Japanese politicians have been incapable of handling pressing issues for years. They just care about the next elections, as usual. Since no-one expects any drastic change of political climate to happen soon, it's more likely that Japan goes in the wall.
- j_lev 12y agoI don't agree that increased immigration/population growth is necessarily the key (for Japan or other developed nations). Technology should be able to go a long way to replace the workers who support the nation. Japan, of course, is doing its utmost to prove this wrong.
- ekianjo 12y ago> What they need to do is figure out a way to grow the population locally or through large-scale immigration Or drastically increase productivity, or have more people join the workforce. Women are massively under-used in Japan. There's no need for immigration as long as there is a large untapped segment of the population not actively employed.
- mc32 12y agoIntegrating women into the workforce is a different issue. It would help to some degree --and the government is making a greater effort in having this happen. As paternalistic as Japan is, given the choice of making life easier for women to join the workforce or allow greater legal immigration in Japan, they have chosen to encourage women to stay in the workforce and to try to make it easier for them to succeed. As good as that is for society, it still will not make up for the structural problems bought on by a declining but aging population _and_ a large and growing retiree population. They need a younger population. Bringing in 10 million retirees from Florida would not help Japan's economy's structural problems. they need young, eager and enthusiastic immigrants to bring some vibrancy to their flagging economy. Japan has great productivity and has automated moreso than any other country --it's had to due to a retiring population. They need a younger population with disposable income who are willing to spend their disposable income.
- ekianjo 12y ago> Japan has great productivity and has automated moreso than any other country --it's had to due to a retiring population. They need a younger population with disposable income who are willing to spend their disposable income. I'm sorry but the myth about Japan productivity has to stop :) I work in Japan and there are the most ineffective and honestly useless jobs out there. People guarding plastic cones on the road. People waiting at the car park exits everywhere to ensure no accident occurs. People at the front of numerous stores and train stations paid to salute everyone passing by. I understand it's all a part of customer service but this is just bringing actual productivity down. And I'm just citing obvious examples here, inside corporations there are tons of underemployed or useless jobs as well and since companies cannot fire people in Japan they carry on the deadweight for decades. There's so much fat in every Japanese organization out there they have enough to skim out for 20 years and still be in shape.
- MLR 12y agoThey have 5% unemployment, and, after a quick check, it seems like a similar labour force to population ratio to the UK and US. I'm not an economist, but in their position, what would mass immigration solve?
- hudibras 12y ago(Twenty-five minutes too late...) No discussion of Japan's economy (whether it's government debt, inflation rates, recession, etc.) is complete without mentioning that the unemployment rate is 3.6%, the 2nd-lowest (behind South Korea) in the OECD.[0] So all the doom-and-gloom about Japan's future prospects and what they're doing and should be doing has to be balanced by the continued commitment by the successive Japanese governments to maintaining full employment. [0]http://stats.oecd.org/index.aspx?queryid=36324 http://stats.oecd.org/index.aspx?queryid=36324
- adventured 12y agoJapan's biggest problems are extreme debt, and poor allocation of capital via government spending (Japan's famed public works programs, which have net resulted in zero real GDP growth for 20 years). Japan is the poster-child for what's happening to the US and Europe: Keynesian economics has failed. QE, inflation, central bank stimulus, debt accumulation - none of it actually grows an economy or increases productivity. It's all fake, all of these measures are meant to keep the fraud going a bit longer, and now the clock has run out and the consequences are being paid.
- nhaehnle 12y ago> Keynesian economics has failed. QE, inflation, central bank stimulus, debt accumulation It's kind of funny how much of a content-free buzzword Keynes has become. None of the measures you mentioned are originally tied to the original Keynesian idea of anti-cyclical government behaviour.
- dagw 12y ago"Keynesian" as used by the mainstream today is only very weakly related the writing and thinking of John Maynard Keynes. I've seen it suggested in more than one place that if Keynes was alive today he wouldn't be a Keynesian.
- DominikR 12y agoIn my view low birthrates are a result of financial insecurity and the fact that now both parents have to work full time to make a decent living while 50 years ago it was sufficient to have only one parent working. I just don't buy the story that post-industrialist societies are somehow more enlightened and therefore prefer to have less or in case of Japan often no children at all. Reproduction is one of the strongest needs a human being can have after survival and security.