17 ms·
Japanese zoning
- abandonliberty 12y agoJapan has some of the most awesome architecture as house resale value is extremely poor.
- jcdavis 12y agoFor those curious - this is apparently due to laws regarding depreciation: http://www.archdaily.com/450212/why-japan-is-crazy-about-housing/ http://www.archdaily.com/450212/why-japan-is-crazy-about-hou... "Collectively, the write-off equates to an annual loss of 4% of Japan’s total GDP, not to mention mountains of construction waste."
- abandonliberty 12y agoThis is an awesome article, I recommend clicking on it if just for the pictures. sidenote: Thanks to Google and people like jcdavis I don't have to remember anything myself
- cskau 12y agoI'm not seeing anything in there regarding any law. My understanding of the issue is that it's simply the norm. Expectation is houses only last 30 years, so nobody spends more to make them last beyond that.
- desdiv 12y agoI was as giddy as a school girl when I read the phrase "euclidean zoning", but alas, it has nothing to Euclidean geometry: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Euclid_v._Ambler https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Euclid_v._Ambler
- mrschwabe 12y agoThe difference in zoning practices is super evident the moment you walk down any city street in Japan for the first time. In Japan, there are little shops and mom & pop restaurants on just about every street corner amidst even the most heavy residential areas. In many cases, the business owners live in the dwelling above. As a north american, I found this odd initially; but came to really appreciate it given all the excellent options for eating nearby!
- themodelplumber 12y agoSame here. When I left Japan to move back to the U.S., some of the things that seemed really odd to me were: 1) sweeter food, 2) obese people, 3) old cars driving around, 4) having to drive everywhere, even just to get to a small store, and 5) arriving via car at stores that sold things like electronics and office supplies that looked like throwbacks to a bygone era compared to what they had in Japan. As a small example of the latter, in 1997 I was using the Hi-Tec-C pen and I'm pretty sure I didn't see it for sale in the U.S. until 2007 or so.
- sampo 12y ago> 4) having to drive everywhere I can imagine that people who have grown up in walkable neighborhoods, would find a totally car-based lifestyle annoying. But how will those people feel who have made the move in the opposite direction? If someone moves from e.g. Texas to e.g. NYC or London, will they feel restricted or liberated when they walk, and use the metro? Or will they try to keep driving everywhere?
- themodelplumber 12y agoGood question. Speaking just for myself, I moved from a mainly-driving area to a small urban center residence some years back, and the walking aspect was great. I mean, walking to the library for the first time, I almost cried tears of joy. At my previous residence going to the library meant a ten-minute drive, which wasn't so bad, and now it was a three-minute walk. (Interestingly I just realized that I usually lived about a ten-minute drive from the libraries near where I lived, back in Japan) I guess I could say I felt more liberated, almost like I was part-owner of the downtown space, and it was no longer a destination that I felt I had to plan to visit. The car no longer felt so necessary-though I still used it--and riding my bicycle felt like more of a natural fit.
- tegeek 12y agoI second that. I live in a suburb of Stockholm, Sweden & its a pretty walkable area. The library is litrally 2 minutes walk from my apartment. I had tears in my eyes when I walked it two years back for the first time in my life. My son's day care is 5 minutes walk. The nearest shop is 3 minutes walk. The bus/train station is 6 minutes walk. I take train to reach office which takes 35 minutes door to door. Guess what, I rarely take my car out. May be I switch my car on twice a week or sometimes once a week just to warm up the engine. There is a lake with swimming beach in summer and a forest which is around 10 minutes walk. These are all the things which are truly priceless. And I wish everyone sometimes in their lives experience this, how much good it is to walk to do almost everything you want.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- sfall 12y agoZoning on a national level in the US would be horrible. I bet it can have some draw backs in Japan when you are trying to get something rezoned.
- azernik 12y agoPossibly, but probably outweighed by the flexible nature of the zoning system, where more is allowed for a given zoning classification and there are fewer classifications. i.e. developers probably end up dealing with the zoning bureaucracy and politics less than they would in the US.
- themodelplumber 12y agoJapan is notorious for bureaucracy. Just entering a government center and asking a simple question is sometimes enough to start a (figurative) three-ring circus.
- esfandia 12y agoSee Ikiru by Kurosawa for an admittedly fictional and old example.
- twic 12y agoWhy would it be horrible? How about zoning at the state level?
- sfall 12y agoa regional or state level would be much accurate comparison.
- WildUtah 12y agoIt's worth nothing that bigger cities in most first world countries generally have more expensive housing, rent or buy. Wages rise in bigger cities, too, but not as fast as housing prices. Sometimes we're told that it's a natural result of city living, sometimes we're told that without high rise apartment density, it's inevitable. Tokyo has 35 MM people, almost double the second largest first world city (Seoul, 21 MM), and has housing prices to income ratios far lower than London, New York, or Los Angeles. [0] Tokyo has very few high rises, medium density (150/hectare or 40k/mi^2)[1], low traffic, quiet streets, and mostly single family residential homes. What it doesn't have is low density suburbs (everyplace is medium density), mandatory free parking, or a street grid that serves much car traffic. There are eight first world cities over 10MM people and their housing to income ratios roughly run like this: (Middle class people can easily buy homes) Osaka/Kyoto Seoul Mexico City Tokyo (Things start to get really expensive) Paris Los Angeles London New York (Insanely expensive) Japanese zoning has a lot to be proud of. If Nagoya were a smidgen larger, Japan would dominate the liveable and affordable part of the list even more. [0]http://nextcity.org/daily/entry/japan-shows-the-way-to-affordable-megacities http://nextcity.org/daily/entry/japan-shows-the-way-to-affor... [1] SF is about 70/ha incl. parks, Manhattan 260/ha, Paris (20 arrondissements) 210/ha
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- maratd 12y ago> Wages rise in bigger cities, too, but not as fast as housing prices. If you want to lower housing prices, get rid of rent control policies and ease up on the zoning. Developers will create more housing units and you'll see a substantial increase in supply, leading to a lowering of the price level. The problem is that those already living in the city don't want this. They are against new development and they're all for rent control. They want to continue paying artificially low prices, while keeping anyone else who may want to live there out. Just a tad bit selfish.
- liveoneggs 12y agothis is false and boston proved it
- JDDunn9 12y agoIt's unfortunate that zoning laws seem to keep us far away from our food and nature. The inventor of the skyscraper intended it to allow for high population density and be surrounded by nature. China's trying to do this with Sky City, but it would be hard anywhere else.
- _delirium 12y agoI think this is one case where the law is largely following many people's desires, at least in the USA. I used to live in a city with no zoning (Houston), and yet it was exactly the same thing: no retail or commercial anywhere near the residential area, and very low density. Why? Houstonians reinvented zoning via private-sector contract law. Since many people apparently want to live in residential-only neighborhoods—or at least have fears of what kind of noise/crime/etc. might happen if the alternative were allowed—developers cater to that by putting "residential-only" deed restrictions on new developments, so there are large tracts of land where it's prohibited to use the land for commercial activity. Usually higher-density redevelopment, or even subdividing/subletting, are also prohibited by the contracts.
- kiba 12y agoThey believe they want to live in residential-only neighborhoods? They believe they want to drive cars everywhere? Yet, when it did come to living in those neighborhoods, would they change their mind?
- _delirium 12y agoI mostly grew up in American suburbs, and my conclusion from that is that many people really do seem to like that lifestyle. Not everyone; some people who live in residential-only, car-oriented neighborhoods would rather not, but have various constraints keeping them there. But quite a few people moved there on purpose and like it.
- WildUtah 12y agoHouston's minimum parking laws, setback and construction envelope laws, and other suburban style mandates make it impossible to build in the traditional city style of Europe or Japan (or the USA). There's somewhat more flexibility than some other US cities but something close to modern suburbanism is mandated in most cases.
- mattm 12y agoFrom the chart, I probably live in a Neighbourhood Commercial Zone which is weird for me coming from Canada. There are small factories making sheet metal or agricultural products right next door to or across the street from someone's home. I live in a city of 400,000 people. The sheet metal factory has been in business for 65 years so I'm guessing that they were here first and as the city grew, the area was designated as a Neighbourhood Commercial Zone so they could stay but allow houses to be built since it is close to the centre. Some other weird things in my area: - there will be 3-4000 sq ft mansions and then down the street there are people living in basically what amounts to something a little bigger than a shack - there is one new house near me that was literally built in a parking lot. It is surrounded on 3 sides by a parking lot and the back side faces right onto an apartment building. - another house comes directly up against a graveyard
- po 12y agoSome anecdotes from my neighborhood in a quiet mostly residential part of Tokyo (All of this is about a 20 minute walk from the famous "Shibuya Scramble" super-busy intersection that you see all the time): - I walk past two or three different convenience stores on my 8 minute walk to the train even though my neighborhood mostly looks like it's residential. - All of the buildings around me are either very large single-family homes, or medium sized 3 floor multi-unit apartments. Almost nothing higher than 3 stories. There is also a school and an embassy on my block. - The very large estate owned by a single family that has lived there for over 30 years that was next to my building was torn down last year. They are constructing an apartment building. That single lot will go from 1 unit to 26 units. Most units are single bedroom and will not have a parking spot and will be priced from about $500,000 up to $1.5M for some of the larger ones. I think there will be 10-15 parking spots in the basement underground. - A guy down the street from me has set up a vegetable shop in front of his house. He puts out locally obtained vegetables with prices and you take what you want and drop the money in a slot in a cardboard box he has in his open window. People running little side-businesses like this out of their apartments seems pretty common. - Buildings tend to have walls that are built right up to the street edge forming a 'corridor' feel. - Streets are so narrow when I first got here I couldn't believe they were 2 way streets. It might take cars 10-20 seconds to pass each other going the opposite way because of negotiating the walls. - It's extremely quiet and peaceful (except for the construction next door)
- minikomi 12y agoVietnamese embassy? We live very close it seems!
- poglet 12y agoSounds like your describing my area, on the very edge of Tokyo near nothing special.
- sdrothrock 12y ago> Buildings tend to have walls that are built right up to the street edge forming a 'corridor' feel. I can't stand this and wish it were regulated. I stopped cycling in Tokyo because those walls up to corners make for a lot of blind turns for both me and drivers, and as someone with a hearing impairment, I can't count on being able to hear the car before it blindsides me or vice-versa.
- obviouslygreen 12y agoThis meshes with my impression that the separation here is almost nonexistent; the zones are more a matter of density than category. The lower residential zones can't have quite the same type of commerce in them, but I think most people in Tokyo live somewhere in the quasi-residential/neighborhood commercial/commercial row, so the more limiting zones aren't something you necessarily see a whole lot of.
- Too 12y agoExclusive zoning sounds really odd to me. Not only because you have to travel to get to anything. It also divides the usage of the city into different zones for different times of the day. 7-17: People are in the office or industrial districts. 17-20: People are in the shopping/eating districts. 20-07: People are in the residential districts. Even the most busy office district can become quite dead and scary at night time, would you want to walk alone there at night when nobody else is around? Who watches over your house during the day? The problem is also when you combine these time slices with the traveling - Everybody has to travel between the different zones at exactly the same time, causing major traffic congestions.