25 ms·
Why Inequality Matters
- k-mcgrady 12y agoI've been meaning to get a copy of this for a while. When it first came out there were a lot of people shouting he (Piketty) was wrong and there were problems with the data and other people shouting that those first people were idiots. The debate continued even after Piketty released more data in his defence. That shouting put me off a bit. It was nice to read a balanced review from someone I respect and I'm definitely going to read it soon.
- mjn 12y agoThey're a drier read than the book, but if you're interested specifically in the data and its analysis, there's a series of journal articles written by Piketty and another economist, Gabriel Zucman, which have more detail than the book does, "Wealth and Inheritance in the Long Run" and "Capital is Back: Wealth–Income Ratios in Rich Countries, 1700-2010". There are preprint PDFs here, along with some other papers on a similar subject by Zucman & other collaborators: http://gabriel-zucman.eu http://gabriel-zucman.eu
- k-mcgrady 12y agoWow thanks! Is there a lot of overlap? Might it be worth reading the book as an introduction and then reading the journal articles?
- chollida1 12y agoJust a heads up about the book. Its dense, like a Nassim Taleb book dense. it took me over a month to get through it so if you choose to read it, its not a weekend read. If you want the highlights, this economist article does as decent a job of summarizing 400+ pages as you can hope for in 4 paragraphs. http://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2014/05/economist-explains http://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2014/05/ec... As for the content, the main take away, is his r > g argument which is illustrated by the following chart: http://piketty.pse.ens.fr/files/capital21c/en/pdf/F10.9.pdf http://piketty.pse.ens.fr/files/capital21c/en/pdf/F10.9.pdf One of his other big ideas Bill hits on is his tax on captial. Bill proposes a tax on consumption instead. > But rather than move to a progressive tax on capital, as Piketty would like, I think we’d be best off with a progressive tax on consumption. Maybe not surprisingly since I work in finance, most of my colleges are on Bill's side and not Piketty's here. To be fair to Piketty, he chose a tax on capital because he's coming from a perspective of how do we prevent the accumulation of wealth over generations, where as Bill is coming at it from how do we raise enough taxes to pay for the the services the government needs to provide. I would recommend reading this book, its clearly a labor of love for him and he's spent the time to back it up with data, just don't expect to agree with all his conclusions.
- RockyMcNuts 12y agoNassim Taleb is dense, but not in the way you mean...New Yorker-level hand-wavy, extreme generalizations, OMG the horror of how stupid everyone else is...but if you can get past the pompous jackassery it is true there is much to be learned from him.
- m0th87 12y agoIt's interesting that you critique Taleb's broad generalizations, and then typecast him as a handy-wavy New Yorker at the same time.
- Marazan 12y agoTaleb starts The Black Swan by criticisng people for using anecdotes to justify their position. He then uses a series of anecdotes to justify his position. As far as I could tell this wasn't done as some kind of meta-commentary on anecdotes - just a massive lack of self-awareness
- dsrguru 12y agoThe parent was almost certainly referring to the publication the New Yorker.
- AngrySkillzz 12y agoI'm not sure if it's fair to compare what is essentially a textbook to a series of books by a dude whose style is crafted expressly to make him seem smart.
- ap22213 12y ago"I don’t see anyone on the list whose ancestors bought a great parcel of land in 1780 and have been accumulating family wealth by collecting rents ever since." Piketty makes it clear that America is a special case because of all of the 'almost free' capital in terms of land and population growth that had existed over the last couple hundred years. But, he claims that America in the future will more resemble Europe of the last few hundred years. Also, although Gates claims that half of the richest people in the US have gotten rich from their businesses (I haven't checked if that's true), he almost ignores the fact that most of these richest people have come from upper middle class background, at the least. He also ignores the huge number of richest people who have attained their wealth from financial instruments.
- selmnoo 12y agoI fully agree that we don’t want to live in an aristocratic society in which already-wealthy families get richer simply by sitting on their laurels and collecting what Piketty calls “rentier income”—that is, the returns people earn when they let others use their money, land, or other property. But I don’t think America is anything close to that. Take a look at the Forbes 400 list of the wealthiest Americans. About half the people on the list are entrepreneurs whose companies did very well (thanks to hard work as well as a lot of luck). Contrary to Piketty’s rentier hypothesis, I don’t see anyone on the list whose ancestors bought a great parcel of land in 1780 and have been accumulating family wealth by collecting rents ever since. In America, that old money is long gone—through instability, inflation, taxes, philanthropy, and spending. This was a little disappointing to read. Rentier income, in the context of the book I think includes passed down positions in which the children of the rich continue receiving that high income. That is to say, could the current owners of Walmart have been individuals other than the direct descendants of Sam Walton? If they had been other individuals chosen by a meritocratic criteria and process, Gates' point would stand. As-is, it does not.
- oska 12y agoAgreed, his definition of rentier income was very narrow. I would certainly consider the "Windows tax" where most consumers have no option but to pay for a Windows license when buying a computer as rentier income. Not surprising that Bill Gates has a bit of a blind-spot here.
- pessimizer 12y agoIt's also pretty silly to expect the makeup of the top .00001 percent to be representative of the top .1 percent. Of course the extreme top would contain a lot of people who are extremely active (and doing riskier things.) That's like characterizing a climate based on its hottest day. Just because Chicago's hottest day was hotter than Tempe's hottest day in a particular year (or every year) doesn't mean that Chicago is hotter than Tempe.
- danielweber 12y agoJust reading your quote, Gates didn't say "there is absolutely no one who inherits wealth or position." The Waltons are incredibly unusual because they've sustained inherited wealth to a second generation.
- taeric 12y ago"For example, a medical student with no income and lots of student loans would look in the official statistics like she’s in a dire situation but may well have a very high income in the future." Not that I really disagree with the point here, but I can't help but wonder whether or not the people in the categories he listed exist in large enough numbers to get out of the noise category. Heck, I would think there are about as many literal lottery winners as there are folks in this category.
- josefresco 12y agoI had the same impression after reading these "examples" They seemed like massive outliers and not worth evening mentioning. Also, someone in medical school (or any schooling) isn't guaranteed riches. One could argue that a student in medical school with hundreds of thousands of dollars in debt is in fact, still in dire straits despite their future earning potential.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoNot your average book review ("Piketty kindly spoke to me on a Skype call ...") And oddly chimes very well with my own views on Piketty. (Yeah, me and billg, great minds you know:-) The Tl;dr is perhaps rd >g is a better formula where d is rate of decay of wealth. And "yes we need a wealth tax, can we make policy to differentiate between good wealth (used for socially beneficial purposes) and bad wealth (yachts, coke and hookers) I agree but that is a solution to late - "if we have robber barons we should encourage them to be philanthropists" is missing opportunities to use regulation and competition and externality pricing to flatten the profits accruing to monopoly holders and so reduce the amount of wealth horsing in the first place. That said nice piece, and billg still gets my vote for top ten nicest billionaire.
- r0h1n 12y agoI must say Bill Gates, in his post Microsoft avatar, continues to surprise me constantly. This is a refreshingly candid and sanguine review of Piketty's book from someone who was a ruthless capitalist not so long ago. Gates rightly (and self-servingly) also points out that Piketty does not consider philanthropy as a means to correct some of capitalism's imbalances. Here's a few of Gates' conclusions: > Piketty is right that there are forces that can lead to snowballing wealth (including the fact that the children of wealthy people often get access to networks that can help them land internships, jobs, etc.). However, there are also forces that contribute to the decay of wealth, and Capital doesn’t give enough weight to them. > I am also disappointed that Piketty focused heavily on data on wealth and income while neglecting consumption altogether. Consumption data represent the goods and services that people buy—including food, clothing, housing, education, and health—and can add a lot of depth to our understanding of how people actually live. Particularly in rich societies, the income lens really doesn’t give you the sense of what needs to be fixed. > Piketty’s favorite solution is a progressive annual tax on capital, rather than income. He argues that this kind of tax “will make it possible to avoid an endless inegalitarian spiral while preserving competition and incentives for new instances of primitive accumulation.” > I agree that taxation should shift away from taxing labor. It doesn’t make any sense that labor in the United States is taxed so heavily relative to capital. It will make even less sense in the coming years, as robots and other forms of automation come to perform more and more of the skills that human laborers do today. But rather than move to a progressive tax on capital, as Piketty would like, I think we’d be best off with a progressive tax on consumption. Think about the three wealthy people I described earlier: One investing in companies, one in philanthropy, and one in a lavish lifestyle. There’s nothing wrong with the last guy, but I think he should pay more taxes than the others. As Piketty pointed out when we spoke, it's hard to measure consumption (for example, should political donations count?). But then, almost every tax system—including a wealth tax—has similar challenges. Like Piketty, I’m also a big believer in the estate tax. Letting inheritors consume or allocate capital disproportionately simply based on the lottery of birth is not a smart or fair way to allocate resources. As Warren Buffett likes to say, that’s like “choosing the 2020 Olympic team by picking the eldest sons of the gold-medal winners in the 2000 Olympics.” I believe we should maintain the estate tax and invest the proceeds in education and research—the best way to strengthen our country for the future.
- sharemywin 12y agoThis is where it gets complicated for me. Gates value judges the rich person spending money on a yacht and plane. Planes and yachts are pretty complicated gadgets that employ a lot of engineers and others. The plane makers technology might even contribute to some other kind of businesses similar to the space program in the sixties and seventies. Where as tech companies sitting on piles of cash because they don't know how to spend it seems like a bad use of capital to me.
- wes-exp 12y agoEmployment is all good and well, but one needs to consider: what are the second-order effects of that action? For instance, you could employ people to dig holes that serve no purpose. Or, you could employ people to build public infrastructure that continues to pay dividends over its lifetime. Buying the yacht is a little bit like digging useless holes, because it's basically a very costly form of recreation that doesn't do much for society. Ideally, money goes into things that both employ and have desirable second-order effects.
- humanrebar 12y ago> For instance, you could employ people to dig holes that serve no purpose. Or, you could employ people to build public infrastructure that continues to pay dividends over its lifetime. I heartily agree with this. However, you could be understimating positive secondary effects. Private space travel, for example, is subsidized in part by rich people spending on luxury goods (trips to space, hobby projects, etc.). And besides, most of the people concerned about inequality in this thread want to see a more progressive tax that seems to be an end to itself. To be charitable, I'm sure they would like to see those taxes applied to re-distributive programs, but it's not clear to me that those programs won't also lack the "desirable second-order effects" you are looking for. In reality, taxes go to the general fund and then get spent on whatever the federal government wants to spend it on.
- wes-exp 12y agoAll good points. I wasn't trying to suggest a solution, but merely trying to point out that job creation should not be the sole bar by which we measure the investment of capital, but that it should do something useful too — whether that investment comes from private actors, or government.
- bsbechtel 12y ago>High levels of inequality are a problem—messing up economic incentives, tilting democracies in favor of powerful interests, and undercutting the ideal that all people are created equal. I agree with generally all of Gates' thoughts here, but there are two actors to consider when discussing how to address problems associated with inequality - the government, and those who own capital. There is an implicit assumption by both Gates and Piketty that a government is always powerful enough to control what portion of wealth flows to capital owners, and what portion flows to labor. The risk with a powerful government that can do this is it can be bought. A perfect example of this is Gates own story with The Common Core. From everything I've read, his own foundation basically bankrolled the lobbying, acceptance, and implementation of this program, much to the dismay of many educators I know. As long as a democracy bequeaths power to its government, there will be moneyed interests lining up to tilt that power in their favor. The other option is to limit the power the government has to control the flow of wealth. No one wants to buy a democracy that doesn't have any power to protect their interests. What ends up happening is wealthy actors have to figure out other ways to maintain their wealth - consumption in things like yachts and fancy cars goes down and investment goes up. As investment goes up, g goes up because that investment is creating more jobs and more competition for employees, and r goes down because the capital markets become flooded.
- dmm 12y agoThe common core is a just a standard of what should be taught and when. It is not a curriculum. It is not a book or set of books. It solves a real problem: schools in the US cover subjects at wildly differing times so when children change school districts they may have huge holes in their education.
- bsbechtel 12y agoThat's not really relevant to my point. I was trying to demonstrate that it is entirely possible for someone with a lot of money to influence policy in the US, using Gates own activities as an example. Next time, it could easily be someone who is using their own money to push a policy requiring iPads or Windows tablets into every classroom, or using their own money to fight off an anti-trust lawsuit being brought forward by the government.
- esfandia 12y agoPhilanthropy strikes me as anti-democratic. Why should the rich get to choose which causes are more deserving of their generosity? Let the elected government pool the money and make this determination.
- icebraining 12y agoThe government can choose who is more deserving of their money; it can't choose who is more deserving of their generosity.
- jkscm 12y agoDo you live in a democratic country?
- icebraining 12y agoI don't know, define "democracy". I live in a Western European country, but I don't see how is that relevant.
- noarchy 12y ago>Philanthropy strikes me as anti-democratic. Why should the rich get to choose which causes are more deserving of their generosity? Let the elected government pool the money and make this determination. The reason the rich get to choose is because it is their money. Just as you can decide, today, to donate your money to the charity of your choosing. And really, this isn't any different from asking why the rich (or you or me) get to decide which car or house to buy. If government is failing to give your money to areas where you think it should go, perhaps this is what is anti-democratic.
- crdoconnor 12y ago>The reason the rich get to choose is because it is their money. This presumes that most, if not all of the money gained by the rich is justly earned. I would take serious issue with this.
- penprog 12y agoWhy would we want to tax consumption of the wealthy (or anyone)? Don't we want to promote spending? The tax code should reward those that make investments, purchases, and donations. Not punish them. They should punish those that sit on their wealth and do nothing with it.
- TheIronYuppie 12y agoThe idea is that just having money does no one any good. You want to spend it on stuff. Further, having an estate tax caps that accumulation at the end of your life. There may be people who truly don't spend any money, but that would be the minority.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mhb 12y agoWhat is this idea of rich people having money sitting in the bank "doing nothing". Do you suppose that these rich idiots have the money in a checking account?
- akmiller 12y agoSpending doesn't do as much as starting or investing in new companies or even philanthropy itself. Gates and Pickety agree on the estate tax which would help for people trying to sit on their wealth and simply pass it along to their heirs. Of course the estate tax needs some improvements.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- akmiller 12y agoI don't think that encourages spending....I think that encourages offshore bank accounts and the like. Anyhow, I'd think that anyone with any type of massive windfall is pretty thoroughly invested so in some capacity it is contributing back to the economy. I also can't imagine there are many who receive some type of windfall and are just sitting on it!
- Joeboy 12y ago> I think we’d be best off with a progressive tax on consumption In theory I like the idea of a "tax on consumption", because it suggests a penalty on conspicuous consumption and wasteful spending. In practice, taxes on consumption are seen as regressive, ie. they affect the poor more than the rich. Is there a way to tax "bad" consumption, without penalizing people who "consume" a large proportion of their income simply because they don't have much of it? I'm picturing some byzantine tax code system where functionaries make value judgements about the morality of various kinds of goods.
- seren 12y agoWell in theory, you could have a progressive tax on consumption, i.e. basic subsistence item have a low VAT, while luxury goods have a higher rate. This is already in application in some countries, but this is rather crude and does not take into account what you are using the item for. For example, electricity to heat your single room apartment has the same tax rate than the one used to heat your Olympic pool when it's freezing outside.
- dragonwriter 12y agoYou can tax "bad" consumption, but it ends up with the same kind of complexity as existing income tax with filings and tracking and specific exemptions/deductions/adjustments. As simplicity is one of the big reasons people propose a consumption tax over the existing income tax, almost no one who would want a consumption tax in the first place is interested in such an arrangement. Personally, I'm unconvinced that there is any real practical advantage to consumption taxes, and think a better simplification is the smaller change of having a progressive tax on income without undermining progressivity by favoring capital income. At any target revenue level this enables lower taxes on working people which enables more peoe to become at least small scale capitalists, rather than taxing working people extra to reward those people who have already accumulated or inherited the wealth to live off capital rather than labor.
- crdoconnor 12y ago>In theory I like the idea of a "tax on consumption", because it suggests a penalty on conspicuous consumption and wasteful spending. If you want a penalty on conspicuous consumption then simply levy taxes on items which count as conspicuous consumption - yachts, private jets, houses > $2 million USD, super cars, etc. It would probably not be a huge list and it wouldn't be a complicated rule. You might miss one or two exceptions, but that's okay. It would be a LOT simpler than going the other way - taxing everything consumed in the economy and then making exceptions for conspicuous consumption.
- plehoux 12y agoGates described three personas : 1. One guy is putting his capital into building his business 2. A woman who’s giving most of her wealth to charity 3. A third person is mostly consuming, spending a lot of money on things like a yacht and plane All three actually spend their wealth. The problem with extreme inequality is that really wealthy people can invest, give and spent AND still sit on massive amount of wealth that get past to the next generation. A progressive tax on consumption wouldn't be enough to fight this. One core argument of Piketty is that the actual debate has been highly distorted by the massive wealth redistribution that happen in consequence of the first two world wars, something Gates doesn't acknowledge in his review. [UPDATE] I overlooked the estate tax Gates proposed in his review.
- icebraining 12y agoAll three actually spend their wealth. The problem with extreme inequality is that really wealthy people can invest, give and spent AND still sit on massive amount of wealth that get past to the next generation. A progressive tax on consumption wouldn't be enough to fight this. Gates also specifically talks about an estate tax to prevent the wealth to pass to the next generation (at least, part of it).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- spenrose 12y agoPiketty cites 1914->1945 over and over in his book as the one period when r < g, and discusses the implications for his theory over dozens of pages. Yet Gates somehow seems to think WWI and the Great Depression are a gotcha! he has come up with. Gates: "Far more people—including many rentiers who invested their family wealth in the auto industry—saw their investments go bust in the period from 1910 to 1940, when the American auto industry shrank from 224 manufacturers down to 21. So instead of a transfer of wealth toward rentiers and other passive investors, you often get the opposite."
- GuiA 12y ago> Take a look at the Forbes 400 list of the wealthiest Americans. About half the people on the list are entrepreneurs whose companies did very well (thanks to hard work as well as a lot of luck). Contrary to Piketty’s rentier hypothesis, I don’t see anyone on the list whose ancestors bought a great parcel of land in 1780 and have been accumulating family wealth by collecting rents ever since. In America, that old money is long gone—through instability, inflation, taxes, philanthropy, and spending. The USA are somewhat of an edge case here due to their youth. Look at older countries, such as France (where Piketty and I are from) and you'll see a marked difference.
- mkempe 12y agoMaybe these "older countries" should try --for a century or two-- laissez-faire capitalism and a government limited to the protection of individual rights.
- Kalium 12y agoAnd maybe the rest of the world knows something we don't - like where laissez-faire capitalism actually leads. Hey look, I can toss around unsupported political assertions too!
- LLWM 12y agoIt would probably make more of a difference if they tried for a century or two expanding into a sparsely populated, resource-dense area many times their current size.
- mkempe 12y agoWhich is how Switzerland implemented its version of American government, freedom and prosperity starting in 1848?
- peteretep 12y ago> Maybe these "older countries" should try --for a century > or two-- laissez-faire capitalism and a government > limited to the protection of individual rights I used to work at an 800 year old pub. American tourists would helpfully come along and tell us we'd gotten the location all wrong.
- netcan 12y agoBill gates is impressive. It's a hard subject to stay objective with. The validity of the data has some level of uncertainty (by its nature). The interpretation of the data too. I have yet to find an explanation (by Pickety or others) that made me understand the mechanics of the "Snowball Effect" at the centre of it all: 'r > g.' Once you get into the soup of morality and policy, well… I like how he starts with the things he broadly agrees with. Even just agreeing that extremely uneven distribution is a problem and why, gives us a starting point. I personally take a slightly Marxist view on this. I don't think that extremely uneven distribution is politically stable, or compatible with democracy. I am slightly doubtful of taxation as a solution. Taxation is stuck really. The problem is that most tax regimes are designed to maximize tax revenue while minimizing damage to the economy. Consumption/sales taxes, income taxes and other middle class taxes are convenient in that they are very hard for people to avoid and they don't affect behavior much. marginal income tax of up to 60% is generally assumed to have a negligible effect on how much people work. A 1% annual tax on wealth equates to a $10m annual cost of living in a country for a billionaire. Would they move (themselves and/or their wealth) to avoid it? Can some of that $10m be used to find ways of avoiding the rest of it? I think that ultimately, wealth accumulation needs to change in order to change the structure of the economy. Also, I like that Gates considers cultural norms, not just policy. What Gates & Buffet have committed to is a partial solution. If 20-30% of billionaires do this, it might be enough to change overall distribution somewhat. In any case, more questions than answers.
- 123testaccount 12y agoWith regard to the mechanics of the "Snowball Effect", my understanding is that the flat tax on capital gains vs the progressive tax on income is one cause in the US. I would speculate that one other mechanic has to do with time. For the vast majority of people there is a hard cap on wage income based on the hours they can possibly work in a day. People who have money to invest can put that to work for them offline, so to speak. And at a certain threshhold a person can put their money to use to pay for specialized labor (tax attorneys, finance managers etc) to receive an even greater return.
- netcan 12y ago
- bigdubs 12y agoI haven't read the book, and not sure Gates reaction covers this. It's fine to have a progressive tax. That progressive tax becomes useless if you gut entitlement spending and instead spend on programs or services where the money ends up back in major corporations hands (defense spending, private contracting etc.) In order for a progressive tax to be corrective it has to put the money to work for people in the lower end of the tax curve.
- michaelochurch 12y agoThe "r > g" debate is interesting. I think the problem is more subtle than that. One of the problems is that people get different r's. Just look at VC firms. A pension fund that invests in venture capital funds gets mediocre returns: nothing much better than they'd get from an index fund, and often less. VC partners collect 2-and-20 and get to allocate favors (because it can benefit their careers to make decisions that are suboptimal for the portfolio, and they often do). The "real r" in that engine might be higher (if VCs focused on technical excellence rather than their own careers, I think we'd see quite a respectable r) but the delivered r is mediocre. That's just one example. To go further, and I don't know how to solve this: if you have good relationships with various counterparties (especially, banks) you can get a low-risk r > 15% in arbitrage. Contrary to stereotype, arbitrage is neither risky (it's low in risk, and most arbitrage blow-ups occur because some hotshot trader got bored and started taking unauthorized positions) nor is it socially harmful (it provides liquidity to markets, which is a good thing). It is, however, not open to most people. There are many things that cause "wealth decay" or normalization. I'll name four. Hyperinflation and violent revolution are the most disruptive (sorry San Francisco, but disruption is a bad thing). Taxation is the smoothest but can be ineffective (loopholes). Wealth management is yet a fourth: at some point, a large fortune has management overhead and, as its owners become less interested in day-to-day running of the money, much of that excess "r" goes to the agents than to them. As for "r >? g", I'd prefer two things. First: I'd like that everyone have access to the same r, but I don't know how to achieve that. Second, g isn't constant. World economic growth is 4.5% per year. I believe that it could be 8% or 10% with some heavy R&D investment, and with better (and, quite frankly, smarter) people running the world. The all-time record high for world GDP growth is 5.7% in the 1960s, but we have so much more technology, and the shape of economic growth is (while I don't believe in a "singularity" of the theatrical sense) faster-than-exponential. Even now, we have a world in which programmers (not 10x or 2.0+ engineers, but just regular programmers) become 10-12% more productive each year due to tool improvements. Motivated, ambitious programmers can do 30% per year. The bad news is that it's almost impossible for a programmer to grow her income at any rate near that. In fact, as she becomes more experienced, she's also more specialized and dependent on her employers (or clients) for great projects. They'll pay her pennies on the dollar relative to what she's worth, that charge being for the "favor" of allocating the good work. The reason why 10x engineers only make 1.3-1.5x salaries (until they become consultants, at which point it's more like 2-3x) is that their employers are very good at playing the "we can give you a raise, or we can give you career-positive work" game. The software economy is at the fore of what's happening to other industries, but people in most sectors are a good deal poorer. We're comfortable upper-working class people complaining about our slide into the upper-middle-working class, but people outside of tech don't have anything to lose. What we actually need to focus on is g, and r_labor. We want a high r_capital and an even higher r_labor. Sadly, badly managed economic growth tends to make r_labor negative. That happened in the American 1920s with agricultural commodities (contributing to spiral rural poverty, which led to the Great Depression) and it's happening to all human labor in the 2010s.
- rumcajz 12y agoIn what way would consumption tax address capital accumulation? Also, using 1910-1940 period as an example to show that Piketty is wrong doesn't make much sense given that Piketty's data show that inequality have actually lowered in that particular period.
- PythonicAlpha 12y agoMust be some American specialty. At the end, Bill Gates sees Philanthropy as (part of a) solution. This must have something to do with the US-American history and background? I heard that opinion so often and we are in deed in an era of big philanthropists (like Bill himself). But I (no American, and maybe missing some genetics for it) can not see any solution in it. The biggest philanthropists today are in the US, but also the US is one of the countries, where inequality rises fastest. So, by this viewing alone, there must rise some doubts about it. Also, you could compare philanthropy with the "foreign aid" that western countries give to poorer ones for decades now. Did it help? In many cases, it made things worse, because the money did not help the people to help themselves, but made them addicted to the aid. The point is also that philanthropy -- as it might silence the own conscience -- is often the overflow of the overflow. We give, because we have more than we need and than we give what we need least. But what people really need, is not somebody that throws pennies in your hat, so you can buy some old bread -- but what they really need, are equal chances -- to be able to visit the same universities, to have the same jobs and to earn the same money as other people with the same talents. You might argue: But Bill also fought his way from "rags to riches" -- no, that is not right. Bill already was born in a well being family and visiting visited Harvard College. With such a background, it is much easier to come from rich to riches, as if you come from Uganda slums (or even Harlem).
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoPhilanthropy is many things. It includes emergency aid, which by no means makes people addicted to aid. It includes schools and scholarships which are doing what you ask - leveling the opportunities. Where philanthropy fails is when its not matched to cultures. Building schools for girls in countries that won't tolerate that - they get closed soon after you leave. Or educating local doctors, who immediately leave the country for a better job in America. But what can philanthropists do? You can't make people change to suit your goals.
- PythonicAlpha 12y agoI don't say, that philanthropy is bad. What I mean: Philanthropy does not help, when the reasons of poverty are not removed. Biggest philanthropy will not help, when it is the result of extreme redistribution of money. The philanthropy of the monks in the middle ages did not help, because the monks where part of the system of inequality, where few owned all and the rest had to live on .... sometimes philanthropy.
- ash 12y agoPhilip Greenspun has written a whole series of posts reviewing this book: http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/philg/2014/06/17/book-review-pikettys-capital/ http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/philg/2014/06/17/book-review-pi...
- mkempe 12y agoGates, and Piketty, would benefit from considering the insights of the Austrian school of economics, instead of accepting then regurgitating Marx & Engels with a veneer of civilized discourse. Neither seems to have read a single page of Ludwig von Mises or Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk. Piketty certainly quotes Marx ad nauseam. George Reisman has offered a thorough critique [1] of Piketty's arguments -- arguing across a range of topics, from David Ricardo's insights in the role and formation of capital to the meaning and value of inequality in both income and wealth. [1] http://georgereismansblog.blogspot.com/2014/07/pikettys-capital-wrong_28.html http://georgereismansblog.blogspot.com/2014/07/pikettys-capi...
- chippidysan 12y agoThe majority of these comments are "tax the rich!" with no regard to current government spending trends. Oh and the obligatory, "BUT WHO WILL BUILD THE ROADS!?"
- nandemo 12y agoThanks, that's a much more interesting review than Bill Gates'.
- ska 12y ago"I don’t see anyone on the list whose ancestors bought a great parcel of land in 1780 and have been accumulating family wealth by collecting rents ever since." What you do see though, in the same Fortune 400 list is that 6 of the top 10 people on that list didn't build their companies (in the sense that Bill Gates did), they inherited them. I don't know how much the current crop Kochs or Waltons are responsible for the current success of their ventures, but this is the type of thing I believe Piketty had in mind as much as the "parcels of land" approach. Also rent seeking is a problem distinct from a rentier class. Can you argue convincingly that these people would have been just as successful without the advantages of their births? I suspect that would be quite difficult.
- judk 12y agoTop 400 is misleading. In US capitalism, single winners like Gates and Zuck Rockettes to the top. Look at the next many thousands, the grandchildren of previous barons who each have a share of inheritance, still far in excess of the productive classes. Look at the Bush and Kennedy dynasties in government.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dllthomas 12y ago"Gates and Zuck Rockettes" That's a strange image. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rockettes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rockettes
- humanrebar 12y ago> What you do see though, in the same Fortune 400 list is that 6 of the top 10 people on that list didn't build their companies (in the sense that Bill Gates did), they inherited them. But 10 out of the top ten did not have billionaires for grandparents. The Kochs and Waltons are second-generation billionaires. They're not the product of hundreds of years of steadily accumulating wealth. So there's a flaw in the thesis that wealth continues to grow. There's a significant amount of churn in the ranks of the superwealthy.
- georgeecollins 12y agoI like his comparison of how the emergence of the auto industry was a way new wealth was created by entrepreneurs and old wealth was destroyed through bad investments. He says he sees a similarity in tech booms. There is a real value in the frothyness of tech bubbles. Capital can't accumulate forever. People need to be convinced to make bad investments. In that sense unsuccessful VCs serve a useful purpose.
- harmonicon 12y agoI have a lot of respect for Bill Gates because of his philanthropic efforts. However, I am very skeptical of the consumption tax argument. To me that sounds like a sales tax and sales tax is regressive. i.e. Tax on French baguette hits the poor more than the rich, since as a group they consume way more baguette. Even if it is just a special sales tax that targets the rich only, discouraging spending by people with money can hardly be a good thing; that's how recession happen and the rich will continue to capture a bigger share of the total wealth. For an economy to flourish we need the wealth to flow from individual to individual. If all the water on earth is stuck in the ocean we'd have serious problem. Same with wealth.
- k-mcgrady 12y agoPeople seem to be having a hard time with the consumption tax argument. I may be completely wrong but here's how I interpret it: 1. Like income tax you have various 'bands' 2. The more you spend/consume they higher the band you are in 3. Lower bands pay less 4. Someone with little money buying just the essentials consumes e.g. $10,000 per year. Band 1 (a tax of say 10%) starts above $10,000 and thus this person is exempt. 5. If you buy Ferrari's, mansions etc. and consume $5m per year you would be in one of the higher bands and would pay a higher tax rate (say 40%). In other words the little people keep all their money as it's only spent on essentials. People who have disposable income pay back a percentage of what they spend. Your argument that it would discourage spending and be bad for the economy is fine but I don't think it would hit as bad as you think. Say I can afford to spend $1m on a car but because of the 40% consumption tax it will actually work out as $1.4m at the end of the year will I still buy that car? Chances are that $0.4m isn't a big deal to me. Sure I might not like it but I probably have enough disposable income that I'll pay it. The key is getting the tax bands correct so that your disposable income is still high enough that after the tax you will still buy the item. You will have less purchasing power but the money going into the tax system could be used to offset the decline in economic growth.
- nhaehnle 12y agoThat's how I interpret it as well, though I don't see how one would implement this. Would we all have to start collecting all our receipts, even for private purchases? That seems like a headache...
- peter303 12y agoironical from a multiple times convicted monopolist
- naland 12y agoConvicted, oh no —it's worse than that. Now he is a hero figure one national pride. For those who express doubts to national pride, HN underside them to this thread.
- foobarqux 12y agoI can't understand how someone so intelligent can misread Piketty so badly. For example, Gates focuses on individuals in some of his critiques but Piketty is talking about classes of wealth, the constituents of which may change but, Piketty argues, whose characteristics do not.
- naland 12y agoGates on notes in vinyl …oh boy Girl you know it's true. And I blame myself can't read this.
- michaelvkpdx 12y agoI appreciate Gates' analysis of Piketty, but Gates is still blind to an important point- he came from a middle-class background and therefore had enough capital to gain a footing in the world and to be able to write his initial code without worrying about the basic needs of survival. 40% of youth in the USA today do not even have that, and as such, have virtually no chance at all of being able to even play in the capitalist economy. They will be successful if they avoid homelessness and hunger, which will be a daily struggle. Gates, Buffett, and others who claim to be philanthropists work from a point of ignorance, believing that all youth at least have their basic needs covered by this society. They are blind. Piketty at least acknowledges the underclasses. These so-called philanthropists depend on the existence of a permanent underclass to support their "charity". I was raised on the edges of this underclass and even today, after 20 years in the business doing quite well, I worry every day that I will soon be homeless or hungry. I have no inheritance to count on,other than debt from my family. The idea of taking a couple of months without income to make a startup is laughable- how would I eat and make my house payment? Most of the peers from my youth are on public assistance, in jail, ill, or worse. They are easy prey for the tech titans, who fill their eyes with glittery visions that make them forget their hunger and cold. This is in the Bay Area, mind you, less than 20 miles from the Valley. Gates' idea of a consumption tax would heavily penalize these people, who have been enslaved into a consumer lifestyle by the wealthy who exercise control over their lives. The whole "inequality" debate laments the demise of the middle class. But it never acknowledges the permanent underclass that is a necessary component of a society that can take the time for the inequality debate. I got out, though you never lose the psychic clutches of abject poverty. Most folks never get out.
- alukima 12y agoI try to explain this to people all the time. Most of my childhood friends/family worked much harder than any I know now and are just barely making it, some not at all. I watch friends in the Bay Area spend everything-save nothing and then call the homeless kids in the Haight lazy bums. I have a savings but if the tech bubble did burst there's a very real chance I could end up home. My family doesn't have wealth and some of my siblings are already homeless.
- mchusma 12y ago
- IanDrake 12y ago"Imagine three types of wealthy people. One guy is putting his capital into building his business. Then there’s a woman who’s giving most of her wealth to charity. A third person is mostly consuming, spending a lot of money on things like a yacht and plane. While it’s true that the wealth of all three people is contributing to inequality, I would argue that the first two are delivering more value to society than the third." The problem with this line of thinking is that yachts and planes don't grow on trees. They're built and maintained by people who have jobs (typically well paid jobs) because someone with wealth is paying for it. So, to me at least, there is only one type of wealthy person who doesn't add value and that is the hoarder.
- mempko 12y agoI am going to repeat here, what I posted on hist site. Mr Gates, I am hoping you posted this not only to express your opinion, but to engage in conversation. And it appears you certainly are. My criticism with your response is that philanthropy distorts economic resources through a similar mechanism that consumption does. That is, by dictate. I believe in the idea that people who are affected by decisions made should have a say in those decisions. This is the value of democracy. And just like consumption of fine wine and jewelry distorts the economy to produce more of those things, philanthropy moves vast economic resources for what I would call "the pet projects of philanthropists". Typically the people affected by the philanthropic expenditures have no say. More often than not, no democracy processes take place. A king who lives a modest lifestyle, who spends all his wealth on what HE thinks is just and good, is still a king. And I hold contempt for his arrogance.
- JeffL 12y agoVery interesting and thought-provoking point. Although on the other hand, I personally think that Bill Gates, acting as a king and trying to figure out what he thinks will do the most justice and good, is going to do better for the world than what people in a democracy will vote for themselves. Democracy has given us unbalanced budgets, runaway debt, pointless wars, and corrupting entitlements. Bill Gates is doing some amazing and wonderful things. Not saying that monarchy is better than democracy. Democracy is best at protecting rights, which is the function of government. But as for making the world a better place, really, individuals are probably best at that.
- mempko 12y agoI am guessing when you say "democracy" you are referring to places like the USA? If so, let me ask you a question. Do you feel that you have a say in decisions that affect you day to day? If the answer is no, I feel it isn't fair to blame the problems we have on democracy. As for what the system the USA has, well, these guys think it is a Plutocracy http://politicalgates.blogspot.com/2011/12/citigroup-plutonomy-memos-two-bombshell.html http://politicalgates.blogspot.com/2011/12/citigroup-plutono...
- jokoon 12y ago> wealth decays I don't understand this. I mean you just get poor much quicker when you have less wealth. I understand that you don't stay rich, but it secures your kid's futures.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jotm 12y ago"A third person is mostly consuming, spending a lot of money on things like a yacht and plane. While it’s true that the wealth of all three people is contributing to inequality, I would argue that the first two are delivering more value to society than the third." Really? I always considered this kind of spending a good thing for society. Other businesses and people get that money, they create technology, materials and processes that would likely not exist otherwise, there's still tax being paid along the way and we get a bit of cultural heritage as a bonus (castles, boats, planes, cars, the Sistine Chapel, a lot of paintings - all of which exists only because some rich man decided he wanted it). Taxing luxury is a mistake and a potential slippery slope IMO. IIRC, the US tried it in the past with disappointing results.
- simoncarter 12y agoI was about to ask this question, though not sure I can share in the conclusion. I was under the impression that people who spend money on consumables help drive the economy, though this might be tangential to the net value to society of each dollar spent. Further, as I understood, taxes on consumables such as VAT, which is how I assume one would go about dealing with that third category of wealthy person, tends to disproportionately impact the poorer in society, at least from what i've read in the news.
- ommunist 12y agoThat's easy! Inequality matters until some people are more equal than the others.
- mgulaid 12y agoEconomists don't consider philanthropy a strong factor in economic development or advancement. Philanthropy IMHO has never contributed significantly to lift millions of people out of poverty. Although Gates Foundation and similar NGOs are doing wonderful deeds in Africa and the USA, it will not have the same impact as tax structure/incentives, trade policy, labor laws, access to education, immigration laws, etc. Also how do you define philanthropy, the work of the Koch brothers can be considered philanthropic in some peoples' opinions. Philanthropy is personal and political exercise. I think philanthropy is great, but only few people are doing it. And those who do it, don’t do it effectively, do it too late, or focus on the symptoms rather on the causes, which are much harder to deal with. Philanthropy has become an accessory or a career suffix for those have got lucky. Gates talks about the middle class in China and else where is getting bigger. True, but philanthropic has little to do with this improvement. Aggressive and central economic management, and free trade policy with the US helped above mentioned countries to sustain a healthy middle income class in China, Mexico, Colombia.
- lsiebert 12y agoOkay, I want to talk a little bit about how wealthy people would benefit in a more egalitarian society. But if we assume they are objectivist, there are some issues. It's difficult to do so, because it's hard to say what can benefit a person who is wealthy already. I mean I can point to data that suggests that people who earn better wages, get headstart, have libraries in their community, get a college education, etc are less likely to commit crimes, but your wealth probably means that you can afford good security. I can say that in a more egalitarian society, vaccinations would be free, and thus you are your children are less likely to get diseases, but you have good health care, and so this isn't a huge issue. So I guess the best way is to point out that in a more egalitarian society with free or low cost education and funding for research, general progress in the sciences would happen faster. You get better medicine, better technology, can potentially live longer. Also such an economy will grow more quickly, and while if there were more stringent taxes you may not gain as much of the pie as you could, a bigger pie would cancel that out.
- squozzer 12y agoI think what people miss about consumption taxes - beyond its' regressive nature - is that everything in the end is a form of consumption. The distinction between capital, labor, and consumption is false - it only has meaning once you account for expected outcome. Capital = purchases expected to generate a profit. Labor = purchases expected to generate work. It need not generate a profit necessarily - e.g. paying someone to mow your lawn. Consumption = purchases expected to generate pleasure, or avoid pain. I'm sure the basis of these distinctions rest on some idea of social utility - that trying to turn a profit has more social utility than eating a Twinkie. Maybe we should examine that assumption also. And consider how these notions entangle themselves in practice. A company car intended for non-personal use is considered an asset to the company, and treated as capital. But a similar car used for commuting is considered a consumption item.
- CharlesGust 12y agoBill Gates gives sound reasons for maintaining the estate tax, and I agree with the general proposition of having something like a consumption tax. But, I have a different take on the social utility of capital transfers. Yes, what you invest in you tend to get more of. But, each capital transfer does not destroy the capital. So, if you are buying a yacht, that capital goes to the designer, the builders, the welders, the suppliers, etc. Now, the point is that these people now have their own choices to do something with the capital received. Some of it will go for food, some of it will go for BBQ grills, some of it will go for big screen TV's. And, then the people receiving that capital will make their choices ad infinitum. (Perhaps a performance artist alighting a million dollars in cash would actually destroy capital. They are undoubtedly more examples of waste) I guess I can still see the incentives that would be built into a tax system (as they are built into ANY tax system) to alleviate what may otherwise be burdens on government into encouraging more social utility. But, I just wanted to emphasize that it is not that luxury spending has NO social utility, it just diffuses the social utility into multiple second order spending decisions.
- ajcarpy2005 12y agoFrom the comments on the site: >>>A poor person, will spend all his income on consumption of food, clothes, water and all the basic things that he can pay. >>>A rich person, will only spend a small fraction of it's income, so in the end, proportionally, poor people end paying more taxes then rich people, and that's actually something that's hurting poor people here. ^^^This seems to actually be a sensible argument for there being a problem with a simple flat consumption tax. A solution might be to have a progressive tax on consumption which becomes more meaningful when levels of spending on consumption reaches a level beyond that of the lower 33% of the populace or something like this. The problem would be figuring out how to apply this tax since it couldn't be done through the sales tax as it currently exists.
- humanrebar 12y agoNo, the solution is to separate the concerns, keep flat taxes (because they are more transparent and therefore more fair) and introduce direct subsidies to the working class (again, transparent and fair... I favor a guaranteed income or an earned income tax credit) so average citizens can buy necessities and even get ahead. It's a fair point that a flat tax, in a vacuum, is harder on the poor, but we're not in a vacuum.
- ajcarpy2005 12y agoYeah I agree with you completely that a guaranteed income would probably be the best way to take society to the next level in terms of economic stability and as a way to care for the best resource we have which is human capital. There are plenty of dynamics which would still be at play that would be capable of incentivizing the appropriate people to work in response to needed labor. (eg. landlord responsibilities to apartment tenants)
- vannevar 12y agoContrary to Piketty’s rentier hypothesis, I don’t see anyone on the list whose ancestors bought a great parcel of land in 1780 and have been accumulating family wealth by collecting rents ever since. Bill, you didn't read far enough into the Forbes 400 article, which says: "We didn’t include dispersed family fortunes. Those appeared on our America’s Richest Families list, which came out in July." That money from 1780 is far from 'long gone.' In fact, most wealthy people started life rich and got richer, largely because they could afford to place bigger bets in life and take advantage of opportunities for labor-free capital gains that simply aren't available to people born without capital. Contrary to Gates' assertion, a 2012 study found that two thirds of the Forbes 400 were born wealthy (http://www.faireconomy.org/bornonthirdbase2012 http://www.faireconomy.org/bornonthirdbase2012).
- pappyo 12y agoFor a more in depth review of Piketty's book, I posted a review I found a while back. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7712623 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7712623
- auggierose 12y agor > g is not an equation, it's an inequality
- cyphunk 12y agoAnd when does inequality start doing more harm than good? First up, please explain when inequality does any good
- grondilu 12y ago> I fully agree that we don’t want to live in an aristocratic society in which already-wealthy families get richer simply by sitting on their laurels and collecting what Piketty calls “rentier income”—that is, the returns people earn when they let others use their money, land, or other property. This is debatable. For one, aristocracy is not exactly this, as it is a system based on the notion of privilege, not just wealth. Concretely, it often means the same but still, using the word is quite misleading. Secondly, one may argue that people, and thus families, should have the right to build stuff in the very long term, that is in a multi-generational way. Even if this thing they build is merely a framework of financial comfort. I doubt anyone would question the morality of offering gifts to children. So it's not clear to me why it would be wrong to give a child the means not to worry about money in life, and do it recursively through centuries.
- tn13 12y agoWhether or not inequality is a problem can be debated but we must be beware of that "I am from Government and I am here to help" trap. --- Governments can play a constructive role in offsetting the snowballing tendencies if and when they choose to do so. -- Governments of course could play a constructive role into many things just the way my son could spend more time doing math instead of watching cartoons. The sad problem about human beings is that unless they get something out of it they wont do anything. Government have a strong incentive to tax everyone more and more in the name of inequality and environment but they have 0 incentive to anything about inequality using that money. I would rather live in a world with extreme inequality rather than a world where government is trying to bring "equality".
- pastProlog 12y agoAt some point in the Matrix movies, Neo learns he is not the first Neo. If you read Hegel, you learn that capitalism is not the first economic system. It was preceded by feudalism, which was preceded by the slave latifundia of Rome and Babylon which was preceded by the hunter-gatherer bands that the world was solely covered with 10,000 years ago. Hegel saw enlightened, capitalist Prussia as the epitome of human civilization, but like those biologists who note that even humans are still evolving, Marx and Engels noted that the fourth economic system the world had thrown up might not be the last one, and that crises (like the one we had in 2008) were signs of the cancer it was dying from. The interview question on stages nowadays seems to be what does someone believe in that is not commonly believed, and I supposed the out idea now is the people who control production, the people who own capital are not interested in economy growing as fast as it sustainably can. They want a slower rate of growth in order to maintain more control of the system. This idea not only goes against current economic thinking, and investor's chasing of maximum returns, it's an anti-Marxist idea as well. It seems to be happening though. It's why people like Paul Allen and Nathan Myhrvold pour money into patent companies. It's why the joint chiefs of staff beg the Congress to cut funding for old Cold War tank factories every time the military budget comes up, but the billions for useless tanks, or the hundreds of billions for the designed by committee F-35 boondoggle etc. As Marx notes, something like a "war on poverty" is a joke, since people are not only purposefully kept poor but purposefully thrown into poverty, like during the enclosure of the commons in Europe. A surplus army of labor is a major tool to keep workers from keeping more of the wealth they create. Sooner or later, the good ship USS Wall Street will inevitably run aground, and the economy will grind to a halt in a way that will make modern Greece or 1930s USA look good. Then it will just be a question of what working class people and professionals do in their new situation. It's not really the working class people, who are familiar enough with reality, who one has to wonder about, it's more the US professional classes, who are more highly indoctrinated than probably any group of people in the world. I hold my mouth in awe as I hear US professionals pontificating about things going on half-way around the world in which they know absolutely nothing about. NPR is ultimately a heavier propaganda outlet than Der Stürmer, Правда or Fox News.
- clairity 12y agoi think what gates is ultimately saying is that "good" wealth (gates's main concern, since he's rather invested in the topic) has a potentially higher multiplier effect than bad (wealth solely used for consumption). so in his example, investors and philanthropists have more volatility around the potential effects of their wealth, so the multiplier can be >1, <1, or =1, but the key is that it can be >1, which means that it can be value generating. consumers' multipliers are necessarily <= 1. as an aside, i'm also intrigued by the idea of economic velocity as an indicator of economic health (as opposed to the gini coefficient, which is a rather static measure) that's tangentially related to the idea of economic inequality. of course, for capital to have a stabilizing effect on the economy, it needs to have a high dispersion coefficient, but that's another discussion.
- zachrose 12y ago"Imagine three types of wealthy people. One guy is putting his capital into building his business. Then there’s a woman who’s giving most of her wealth to charity. A third person is mostly consuming, spending a lot of money on things like a yacht and plane. While it’s true that the wealth of all three people is contributing to inequality, I would argue that the first two are delivering more value to society than the third." Of course buying yourself things you don't need delivers less value to society than commerce or philanthropy. Of course. Absolutely. But maybe... Maybe buying yourself things gives you the chance to have unique experiences. Maybe hitting golf balls into the ocean from the deck of your megayacht gives you the relaxing moment you need to figure out how to boost profits by 300%. Maybe doing a ton of blow and driving a Jaguar give you the necessary experiences to write awesome rock tunes that inspire millions. Maybe if Galileo Galilei hadn't bought himself a lump of clear glass in 1609 we wouldn't know about space.
- stuaxo 12y agoHe mentions three kinds of wealthy person and what they spend most of their money on. Surely the 4th is the most important - the one who is NOT spending most of their money.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoI'm always confused about the question of 'what wealthy people do with their money'. Unless its buried in a jar in the back yard, its invested in something, just like yours and mine, in a bank or CD or stocks. Its ALL 'spent'. What am I missing?
- quantumf 12y agoSo Gates wants heavy taxes on consumers, but no taxes on entrepreneurs and philanthropists. Interesting. I wonder which of these categories applies to Gates?