7 ms·
DMCA Takedown Notice for Popcorn Time and Time4Popcorn
- chc 12y agoIs it really even news when an app essentially dedicated to copyright infringement is claimed to violate copyright laws? Popcorn Time isn't a general-purpose app that happened to be used for copyright-infringing purposes sometimes. It was designed to help people infringe copyrights by making it as easy as possible.
- hubbub 12y agoWhat's news is that this isn't how the DMCA is supposed to work. It's supposed to apply to copyrighted material. Not material which when downloaded and run will connect to a P2P network and attempt to download material, which has some probability of being infringing. This case actually seems relatively flimsy; and as the DMCA notice admits, it hinges on a previous ruling that “the distribution of a product can itself give rise to liability where evidence shows that the distributor intended and encouraged the product to be used to infringe” Unfortunately there's no way this notice will be challenged in court, so we probably won't find out if it was legally valid or not.
- rhino369 12y agoIf the DMCA doesn't apply, then the MPAA could immediately sue whoever is hosting these files for contributory copyright infringement. The DMCA is a shield, not a weapon. Essentially, you are shielded until you get a notice of the infringing content. But there is no legal force behind a DMCA. If you get one you can tell the company to fuck off. But you are now liable for any infringement, if proven in court.
- totoroisalive 12y agoHave you try it?
- aspanda 12y agoany response form Github Inc ? i don't see any official word
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- SheepSlapper 12y agohttps://github.com/popcorn-official/popcorn-app https://github.com/popcorn-official/popcorn-app https://github.com/time4popcorn/popcorntime-desktop https://github.com/time4popcorn/popcorntime-desktop https://github.com/time4popcorn/popcorntime-android https://github.com/time4popcorn/popcorntime-android Are all unavailable, citing the DMCA request. So... that's probably Github's response.
- jsnk 12y agoAs far as I know, Github has never made any official response to DMCA take down requests. All they do is simply making them public in this repository. (https://github.com/github/dmca https://github.com/github/dmca)
- bhuga 12y agoAny repository served with a DMCA notice can file a counterclaim, as outlined in: https://help.github.com/articles/dmca-takedown-policy/#b-counter-notification-policy https://help.github.com/articles/dmca-takedown-policy/#b-cou...
- nthitz 12y agoGithub Terms state: "You may not use the Service for any illegal or unauthorized purpose. You must not, in the use of the Service, violate any laws in your jurisdiction (including but not limited to copyright or trademark laws)." which seems a bit wishy washy. The use of Github to host code doesn't seem to be violating any laws. The execution of the code does however. Splitting hairs no doubt, but it doesn't seem that merely hosting code that facilities copyright infringement is in itself copyright infringement. Granted if Github wants to uphold DMCA Safe Harbor they need to respond right away.
- maxerickson 12y agoThey also say We may, but have no obligation to, remove Content and Accounts containing Content that we determine in our sole discretion are unlawful, offensive, threatening, libelous, defamatory, pornographic, obscene or otherwise objectionable or violates any party's intellectual property or these Terms of Service. Which is a long winded "If we don't want to host something we won't."
- X-Istence 12y agoHow is it okay for source code that enables infringement but does not infringe itself to be taken down by a DMCA request? The claimant in this case doesn't own any of the rights to the software yet wants it removed anyway ...
- JacobEdelman 12y agoUmmm... that's almost the main point of the DMCA. Among other things the DMCA made it illegal to facilitate copyright theft. This has lead to several major cases including ones where attempts have been made to have scholarly papers censored when they papers point out holes in DRM (technologies that prevent users from doing what they want with content).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- yebyen 12y agoI could see a way in which the anti-circumvention provisions that prohibit any distribution of tools which enable the circumvention of access controls could be interpreted to enable action against or prohibition of PopcornTime distros. You have to squint and let the screen go a bit blurry to see it, but I wouldn't count on getting a judge that sees it the other way if I was GitHub. I've always interpreted "access controls" to mean a specific "technological measure" such as CSS encryption, but in a very broad sense the law does allow for tools that don't have any particular copyrighted works in them to be considered illegal and rulings that would disallow their dissemination.
- trillcode 12y agoWasn't popcorn time just a "tool" ? The tool is not infringing on copyrights until the user actually runs the application.
- saganus 12y agoMaybe Github does not want to have to deal with the fallout of not complying, even if the DMCA notice is not technically correct (i.e. the tool is not infringing anything, it's the use of the tool that allows you to do so). I would rather fight the takedown notice, as this will potentially turn into a slippery slope (moreso than now), but then again i don't own Github. So basically I'm guessing it's a matter of "cost of dealing with this" > "cost of kicking popcorn project out of github", no?
- eli 12y agoTools designed to circumvent copyright are illegal too.
- saganus 12y agoAh. Good point. This is under the DMCA act? I guess the problem then becomes defining what exactly constitutes a tool that aids in infringement. A debugger is potentially a tool that can be used to circumvent copyright (let's say, by means of bypassing a very weak protection scheme). But it's obviously not only for this case, so you might argue that if the tool's sole purpose is to circumvent copyright it would have a leg to stand on. But what happens when this tool can also be used for something else? Like someone said elsewhere in this thread, what if the tool is changed such that it could be used to stream movies from, let's say, remote places (you go to your cabin in the woods and stream your legally owned movies, directly from your house, but also from your office, from your parents' house, etc), but it's only one config file away from streaming illegal content from torrents. Then what? Is the tool at fault here? or is the configuration at fault? And these are honest questions I really can't even begin to try to answer, but I guess the point still stands that making this law able to take down tools is a slipery slope to say the least. Edit: Typos
- expose 12y agoGood luck keeping any clones from popping up in the future, especially in a decentralized repository.
- nvk 12y agoIt's time to decentralize source repositories.
- illektr1k 12y agoIf only git were good at that already... >> Git is a free and open source distributed version control system designed to handle everything from small to very large projects with speed and efficiency
- mtrpcic 12y agoThe funny thing is that git wasn't built to have a centralized host, but that was the paradigm people were used to, and Github was so convenient that the paradigm stuck around. There's no reason we couldn't just `git remote add backup <VPS_ADDR>` to have a secondary host.
- 2ion 12y agoMore like not to entrust single copies of open projects to US-based companies. Even a somewhat 'respected' company as Github is just a corporate body that will bend over for anyone with business and away from anything that is Too Troublesome.
- fixermark 12y agoIf someone wants to set up a source repository to host content that is designed to make it easy to infringe copyright, I'd be in favor of it. Mostly so that content can live somewhere other than GitHub, which would free up their admins from having to deal with this mess.
- u124556 12y agoAs the other replies say, git is already decentralized. What we need is a decentralized way to recognize one of those mirrors as the main one. I think gitchain: http://gitchain.org/ http://gitchain.org/ was supposed to solve that.
- sarahj 12y ago> Attached as Exhibit A is a series of screenshots taken from within the applications of each Project that includes images of copyrighted works available through the Projects. The representative titles shown in Exhibit A consist of only some of the motion pictures and television programs that are owned or controlled by the MPAA Member Studios and that are being infringed via the Projects. Exhibit A is provided as a representative sample of the infringements being committed as a result of the operation of the Projects and to demonstrate the readily apparent nature of the massive infringement occurring via the Projects. So by this logic...the source code for any web browser, torrent client, media player etc. etc. should be subject to these notices because they can be used to infringe copyright? After all, through any of those applications, I can take a series of actions which could infringe copyright.... Maybe we can skirt by with the general purpose nature of the above tools...so what about tools used to facilitate penetration testing (which can also be used for computer crime) - should we get rid of that source code too? I don't know the architecture of popcorn time, but if they published a generalized application which when given a configuration file (sources of infringing content etc.) would allow copyright infringement should we ban both? Or just the configuration file (which does not in itself infringe copyright)?? Making distinctions like this is dangerous, and allowing speech to be suppressed by corporate interests is a worrying trend.
- vlunkr 12y agoI can't say where the line is, but popcorn time seems to be in a different category than torrent clients, etc. in that popcorn time just gives you a list of copyright protected movies in its interface. With a torrent, you have to get a seed file elsewhere which could potentially be anything. It could be dangerous though, to start banning tools like this without defining a difference. That's why this is troubling, because in this case, a DCMA makes no sense but they did it anyway.
- sarahj 12y agoI'll extend my hypothetical. Lets say there are two groups. One group builds a generic media client - under the guise of better delivery of free educational videos (MIT lectures etc.) The other group sets up "Movie Copyright Watch" and publishes an up-to-date list of movie torrents - under the guise of occasionally reporting this list back to MPAA and the like. Now lets say team A decide to adopt the same configuration format as team B uses to publish the list. Neither team has done anything wrong and the resulting application is capable of infringing copyright - and is essentially equivalent to what popcorn time has. What is the difference? Tools are tools - it is crazy to ban knives because you can stab people with them.
- sanqui 12y agoSee also "Popcorn Time Devs Drop Like Flies, But No One Will Talk" from April: https://torrentfreak.com/popcorn-time-devs-drop-like-flies-but-no-one-will-talk-140420/ https://torrentfreak.com/popcorn-time-devs-drop-like-flies-b...
- eyeareque 12y agoIsn't source code free speech? I know 2600 spent a lot of money fighting for their rights to post text (not even links) to DeCSS code/apps.
- ivraatiems 12y agoTime4Popcorn's domain (or one of them) was also recently shut down, apparently [1]. Perhaps this is part of a larger effort by the various copyright organizations against the various Popcorn Time derivatives? [1] http://blog.popcorn-time.se/help-save-popcorn-time/ http://blog.popcorn-time.se/help-save-popcorn-time/
- nvk 12y agoAnd it's back http://blog.popcorn-time.se/ http://blog.popcorn-time.se/
- buro9 12y agoIs that real? On the main domain: http://popcorn-time.se/ http://popcorn-time.se/ > Our user's safety comes first!! Therefore we added a free Built-in VPN so you can use Popcorn Time ANONYMOUSLY! Have they really built in a VPN? How would one know it is operating? Does the VPN re-route all traffic? If so, how isn't that malware?
- singold 12y agoIs the git repository blocked too? or only the github project? (I can't try it right now)
- jenandre 12y agoIt seems to still be available from popcorntime.io in a local Stash repo: https://git.popcorntime.io/stash/projects https://git.popcorntime.io/stash/projects
- randallma 12y agoThe .io project is a different fork from the original project than the one referred to by this post.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- slucidi 12y agoNo doubt this will be reinstated in a few days after the devs file their counterclaim. IANAL, but there's no DMCA violation in the code itself. Even though the DMCA claim was spurious, GitHub did was they were obligated to do by taking it down for now.
- atmosx 12y agoI get the feeling that a github clone paid in bitcoins running on tor is on the making somewhere, somehow...
- eli 12y agoA lot of people seem unaware of the "Anti-Circumvention" provisions of the DMCA: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-circumvention#United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-circumvention#United_State... It's illegal to publish tools that have "limited commercially significant purpose or use other than to circumvent [copyright restrictions]"
- cheald 12y agoIt's sad that there isn't a studio exec out there who can make the leap to realize that there is a impedance mismatch in the market that they can capitalize on. Netflix resoundingly proved that there is an appetite for streaming movies and TV, and the studios' response has been to...withhold content, and when they do license it, to do so at enormously exorbitant rates. Do they actually think that if they just make it difficult to stream that people are going to be content to go back to buying DVDs at $25/pop, or driving to rental stores to rent a DVD that you have to return the next day? There's a huge vacuum in the market ready to be filled. The first mover to start making new-release movies available for streaming at decent rates (Hint: $20 for a digital movie that has effectively zero marginal manufacturing cost is not a decent rate in this day and age) is going to need an aircraft carrier to carry all their cash. Killing Popcorn Time, etc isn't going to kill the market desire. People are still going to stream stuff, and the genie is out of the bottle - there's no returning to the mid-90s distribution model, no matter how much some crusty old suits want to.
- chc 12y agoThe marginal cost of producing a copy of a movie is not the predominant factor in the actual cost of producing a copy of a movie. So I don't know why you're bringing it up.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- maxerickson 12y agoI wonder if maybe they just have a good picture of their current revenue and profits and some projections that show numbers that are smaller. After all, they are perfectly happen to make cents/viewer over on cable.
- MyDogHasFleas 12y agoThis is the only on-point comment so far. At some level both these apps are big time enablers of copyright infringement. Maybe you don't think that's a bad thing and all copyright laws should be gutted, or maybe you want to play lawyer or (worse) make analogies. That is totally not the point here. The point is, what some view as copyright infringement, others view as unsatisfied demand. Music has already crossed the chasm, but that's probably more because there is so much more of it in such smaller economic units. Big budget movies have more mass and will find it harder to leap that chasm to streaming services. I think that if anyone manages it, it will be Apple. And it will start with TV, not movies. I will take issue with cheald's "marginal manufacturing cost" argument, a big budget movie has to make back its gigantic capital investment, and each unit of consumption has to pay its share.
- clemfromfrance 12y agohttps://twitter.com/Time4Popcorn/status/521738186834575361 https://twitter.com/Time4Popcorn/status/521738186834575361 and they they share sources -> http://popcorn-time.se/source.html http://popcorn-time.se/source.html