10 ms·
Rental home shortage is America's next housing crisis
- eroo 12y agoIn Boston, an artificial scarcity of housing is the unfortunate result of laws that effectively limit new development. You either can't build new, can't build too high, or have to meet a neighborhood's aesthetic to get approval. The result is higher prices, more sprawl, and a generally depressing force on the kinds of great things that come from sufficient population density.
- VonGuard 12y agoSame in SF and Oakland. In fact, most of the approved new housing units in Oakland are designated to go in a giant development area on the water that doesn't even break ground for another 2 years... And people wonder why rents are so high.
- sadfaceunread 12y agoYup. The level of new construction in areas outside the waterfront is essentially 0. Which is preposterous given the current state of rental affairs. I'd bet you could count on two or less hands the number of new low rise buildings built in Cambridge this year.
- hga 12y agoWhat's the current status of rent control in Boston and the surrounding suburbs? Even if relaxed or gone, as I recall may have happened in some cities, it left a legacy, plus developers have to factor in the danger of it being reimposed.
- eroo 12y agoI'm a relatively new transplant to the city (3 years) and didn't even realize there was a time when the city was rent controlled. My cursory sleuthing indicates it was voted out narrowly in 1994.
- acomjean 12y agoCambridge (outside Boston where I live) had rent control but got rid of it around 10 years ago. I don't think its coming back. I work outside the city core, they seem to building a ton of rental complexes in Watertown. Probably because the permitting is easier.
- collyw 12y agoThis is why its not exactly a free market.
- csbrooks 12y ago"As an indicator, the chart below shows Google search frequency for rent related phrases." That chart has no y-scale, so it's impossible to tell if it means anything.
- derwiki 12y agoI tend to view the absence of a y-scale to be very telling ;-)
- talmand 12y agoThat and the lack of listing the "rent related phrases" used.
- dannygarcia 12y agoI'm not sure what the "rent related phrases" are but just looking at the trend chart for "rent" reveals a similar pattern [1]. "Numbers represent search interest relative to the highest point on the chart." [1] http://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=rent&geo=US&cmpt=q http://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=rent&geo=US&cmpt=q
- pdonis 12y agoMy problem with it is a bit more basic: why bother showing stats on Google searches as an "indicator"? Why not just go straight to the stats on rental demand vs. supply?
- com2kid 12y agoMeh, this is cyclical as always. Not enough rental properties means developers will start building more rental properties, which means they will ignore regular for sale housing, which means prices in the for sale market will go up, which means developers will build more units to sell, which will cause a lack of units in the rental market, ad infinitum. Exceptions for markets with government controls. :) (One thing I like about the Pacific Northwest, our government controls are minimal, and have loosened up in many places recently, with less height restrictions allowing for higher density housing!)
- bradleyjg 12y agoThe whole US is a market with government distortions in favor of ownership, in the form of subsidized mortgages.
- malandrew 12y agoExactly. This is most certainly not cyclic because legislation and incentives are not cyclic in nature. If laws, regulations, contracts, policies, etc. don't change, then this is likely to get worse before it gets better.
- bunderbunder 12y agoNot just subsidized mortgages. Also tax and other incentives, zoning laws that make it more difficult to build rental properties, and infrastructure that can't support (or is specifically designed to prevent) the kind of population density it takes for building rental properties make financial sense for developers in many areas. Combined with a lot of political tailwind behind these kinds of broad-spectrum public subsidies of landowners, because in the USA it's common for working class folks to think of themselves as really just being rich people who happen to not have a whole lot of money.
- scintill76 12y agoI like the quote, "Socialism never took root in America because the poor see themselves not as an exploited proletariat, but as temporarily embarrassed millionaires." often attributed to Steinbeck.
- Shivetya 12y agoTL;DR Metro Atlanta, incomplete/failed subdivisions are being finished by investment companies. However they are not aiming low, they are aiming for those who want out of apartments, have the income, and good background histories, to make renting profitable and safe. North Metro Atlanta, anecdotal here but I have read similar. There are a lot of failed/incomplete subdivisions out where I live. Recently an investment group bought the last 11 lots in my 54 lot subdivision, they had been empty for three years. Within short order 11 new homes were built and are being rented. There are two different companies contracted out to rent these homes for around 1300 a month. Single family only, background checks, and a host of rules. Two other nearby subdivisions are trying to sell their incomplete lots but the builder for this group told us the appeal of ours was no pool or tennis courts. Toss in large homes, existing were 3800 to 5200, large lots, and it was ideal for their investment. The new homes are 2400 square feet but fit in architecturally. With the possibility of an airport expansion in Paulding I suspect NW Metro Atlanta will see a large expansion in rental housing. Contracting out to build homes in numbers of near a dozen does save good money
- qq66 12y agoWhy are pools and tennis courts negatives? Maintenance costs?
- pitnips 12y agoNorth Metro Atlanta. I think people there tend to prefer country clubs over neighborhood pools/tennis courts, but I'm really just guessing since North isn't that specific.
- matwood 12y agoPossibly lower HOAs? But yeah, living in Atlanta would make a pool a must.
- maxerickson 12y agoI would guess the management company doesn't want to get involved in mediating spats over the shared use areas.
- 12y ago
- arielweisberg 12y agoInteresting. My rent increase was 6% this year. It was 4.5% the previous year and in prior years was around 3%. This would be in a suburb a few miles from Boston. The advertised price for apartments in my building is actually higher than my cost. I am waiting on renewal to see if they are forced to drop the price so I can use that to request a smaller increase. I suppose the smart money was to have leveraged up on some housing while I had the chance, but I just can't stand the entire home purchase and ownership ecosystem.
- cowsandmilk 12y agoI wouldn't hold your breath. My studio in Allston was going up to 1150 this spring when I moved out. They rented it back out within 2 weeks for 1450. Many Boston rental units are getting the advertised rates.
- kghose 12y agoIs this in cambridge/somerville? Big companies moving into Kendall Sq are pushing up rents like mad.
- arielweisberg 12y agoNot that close to Boston at all. Stoneham, just in the 95 loop. Rent went up to 1250 for a 1 bedroom. I forgot that my price is higher because they allow dogs. Very few places do.
- brudgers 12y agoThis is not a new problem, the Federal government has had programs subsidizing the construction of rental housing via HUD financing and block grants of Low Income Housing Tax Credits to the states for more than 20 years. The current scarcity of affordable rental housing -- and when we talk about a shortage of any kind of real-estate, we're always qualified by 'affordable' -- is greater because of two trends. The first was Hope 6 from the 1990's in which large public housing projects were torn down and replaced with much smaller and prettier public housing projects and by which the stock of public housing in the US was greatly reduced. Displaced tenants were expected to find housing in the private market using various vouchers, such as Section 8. This increased demand raised rents and removed surplus from the affordable housing market. The second trend however, effected the rental housing market more broadly. In the housing boom of the early 2000's, a large percentage of the existing rental housing units in the US were converted to condominium ownership and the units were taken out of the primary rental market. Because of the way condominium insurance is written, many condominium deeds restrict rentals of units in order effort to limit association fees. This makes it less likely for former rental units to return to secondary rental markets after a property has gone condominium. The issue is quite simply that rents don't cover development costs in much of the US for large demographic segments of the population. In part this is because the minimal cost of development is lower bounded, and not primarily by government controls but by land and construction costs established by the free market. In the extreme for illustration, even if you get the land for free in Detroit, you cannot charge enough rent to cover construction if you build for the economic segment where most of the demand exists, and in the segments where the numbers work out, there is limited demand and every other developer is targeting that segment. One last piece of rental housing development is also worth bearing in mind, the upfront costs tend to be higher and the payback longer than with owner occupied housing development. There's no deposits or presales to fund partial development or create an initial income stream. There's no revenue until the rent checks arrive so projects get built in a single phase. That means a bigger loan and an emphasis on faster construction times versus a slower more variable pace tailored to sales velocity. Addendum: Another factor which may be coming into play is that rental housing has traditionally attracted institutional investors. To the degree that startups offer an attractive alternative the pool of potential investors for rental housing development might be reduced.
- malandrew 12y agoBrudgers hit on many of the most important points, but I'm surprised no one has yet mentioned lending requirements from Fanny Mae and Freddy Mac as major contributors to this problem. The impact of their loan policies has increased dramatically as the US moved from small buildings and individual homes on city streets to a model of large housing developments and big apartment complexes. These two largest and most important lenders will either not lend or lend under worse terms when an apartment building or development has more than some small percentage of units available as rental units (IIRC, something like only 10-30% of units in a development can be available for rent.) This then leads many HOAs to actively monitor and police the number of rental units in any development or apartment building, since the HOA is often used to institute rules that protect or increase the value of the underlying asset. Renting your housing assets often requires HOA approval, and if the limit has already been reached, your petition to rent will likely be denied. Because of these lending policies rental units are under-represented in the overwhelming majority of new developments in more densely populated areas.
- brownbat 12y agoThere are all sorts of odd legacy housing policies in this country, some of which contribute to major social problems, like inequalities in education. This American Life touched on this in 512, "House Rules": http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/512/house-rules http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/512/h... (audio) http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/512/transcript http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/512/t... (transcript) TAL brings in Nikole Hannah-Jones, from Pro Publica. Her full article is here: http://www.propublica.org/article/living-apart-how-the-government-betrayed-a-landmark-civil-rights-law http://www.propublica.org/article/living-apart-how-the-gover... It's a really interesting tour through the political history of US housing law, highlighting some of its nonsensical impacts More of a snowfall version: http://www.propublica.org/article/segregation-now-the-resegregation-of-americas-schools/#melissa http://www.propublica.org/article/segregation-now-the-resegr...
- ozi 12y agoHaving just closed on a house today, I can confirm that the lending requirements have made a complete 180 degree turn from being too lax to monumentally ridiculous. What was annoying is the attitude the lenders seem to have when you give them shit for each hoop they make you jump through... it's their own fault the market is in the condition its in - not the home buyer's. That being said, this article is accurate for cities in Texas where the market is experiencing insane growth. I had to offer 5% over list and 40% down to get a winning offer out of more than 20 on a property that was active on the market for less than 48 hours.
- canvia 12y agoAll that fiat currency has to get invested somewhere right? The real estate bubble is re-inflating, check the S&P Case-Shiller 20-City Home Price Index: http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/SPCS20RSA http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/SPCS20RSA Dilbert touched on this back in '89: http://dilbert.com/strips/comic/1989-04-18/ http://dilbert.com/strips/comic/1989-04-18/
- pessimizer 12y agoNo, it's not. The shadow inventory (and home vacancy rate) in the US is still massive due to overbuilding during the housing bubble. House prices and sales are dropping for 80% of the market, and banks are releasing inventory in dribs and drabs in order to keep prices from collapsing completely. I have no idea which of these graphs is supposed to represent something other than a period of extreme overbuilding and speculation, followed by a reduction in building and a gradual rise in the rate of shelter cost increase which hasn't even reached trend yet. What difference would you expect to see 7 years after the collapse of a massive housing bubble if there weren't some pending shortage of rental housing? edit: The distressed housing, as it is released and foreclosures are actually completed instead of artificially being held in limbo, will of course largely be converted to rentals. Virtually all current residential construction is in multifamily units intended for rental. It's the only profitable segment of the housing market other than luxury. edit2: an image from that same blog that shows the enormous amount of vacant housing that isn't on the market: http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-GWjstiIc_No/UfQTK38X-TI/AAAAAAAAaQA/EjHfwxmEAn8/s1600/Vacanices.PNG http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-GWjstiIc_No/UfQTK38X-TI/AAAAAAAAaQ... from http://soberlook.com/2013/07/for-many-americans-rising-home-prices.html http://soberlook.com/2013/07/for-many-americans-rising-home-... This is yet another press release from the 'I want to build upwards in newly hot urban neighborhoods and get some of that upper-middle class 20-something moving from the suburbs into the city' money. edit3: Annual Rental Vacancy Rates for the United States and Regions: 1968–2013 http://www.census.gov/housing/hvs/data/charts/fig03.pdf http://www.census.gov/housing/hvs/data/charts/fig03.pdf Show me the problem here before we start building 80 unit buildings on the corner lots of quiet residential neighborhoods.
- bunderbunder 12y ago> This is yet another press release from the 'I want to build upwards in newly hot urban neighborhoods and get some of that upper-middle class 20-something moving from the suburbs into the city' money. I'll take it. The "I want to build condos so I can cash out ASAP, and then turn around and stick that money into mortgage-backed securities so I can also cash in over the long haul, perhaps at the expense of those same people I just sold a condo to" money has been dominating the conversation for far too long. Back in the 2000s I got kicked out of a perfectly fine apartment along with everyone else living in the building so that the property owner could flip all the units over to condos. Last I checked the building's still at ~50% occupancy, down from 100% when I was living there. And about half the units that are occupied are also for sale. It's far from the only former apartment building in that neighborhood with a similar story to tell, either. Yes, that does mean that there's an incredible amount of vacancy in the area. But - and this is critical - the amount of vacancy that's a reasonable option for people who aren't in a good position to take out a 30-year is very, very small. If you're in your 20s and single with no kids, a 1-bedroom apartment is a great idea. But unless you're confident that you'll remain single with no kids for the rest of your life, a 1-bedroom condo (that you probably won't be allowed to sublet) is a kind of stupid idea. And all those empty condos units are difficult to flip back to rental because condminium developments have legal encumbrances that make things more difficult. So for now they're going to stay vacant and continue being a senseless waste.
- tdiggity 12y agoIs there a way to get this data per county or even state? I'd like to see how my area compares (San Francisco Area).
- mariusz79 12y agoIncrease in number of searches (?) on the Google Insight graph could simply mean that more people are using google to search for rental properties than in the previous years..
- gtjay 12y agoI'm currently living in Australia, and the rent prices are fascinating. You see, to a certain extent, the housing bubble never "popped" (sudden massive drop) here. Instead of being bundled into investments or handled by real estate firms, a large portion of the market is privately owned (this was driven by "negative gearing" that gave tax breaks etc. for ownership). Sure, the market is depressed compared to pre-GFC, but property is still astronomically overpriced. The fascinating part: the rent is much more reasonable. It's like some odd market form of cognitive dissonance. The boomers refuse to believe that a crappy apartment isn't worth 5 million dollars in the sense that they won't sell any lower and list at that price, but at the same time they'll signal that the "real" value is the much more reasonable half million by charging in rent what would be the equivalent payment for a half million on a twenty year mortgage. This leads to all kinds of odd pathological situations. As far as I can tell, purely paying agents in commission is much less common here. Combined with the unmovable listing prices this has led to what is basically welfare for real estate agents and the most lackadaisical salesmen I have ever witnessed, even adjusting for the generally easy-going culture. I'm used to having to ignore calls from agents once it's known that I'm looking. Here, it's the opposite you have to keep calling them. I only have my current place because my wife explicitly asked about it, to which the agent responded something along the lines of, "Oh yeah. That's been open for months." Since many of the property owners aren't professional (pooling the risk/cost of owning over many units) and cash-strapped, getting maintenance done is a nightmare. It's either all done by themselves (with the ensuing comedy that entails) or farmed out to agencies that still bill the owner mostly piecemeal (so that every issue is a situation akin to getting your insurance to pay your doctor). I would like to think that when the boomers prove, despite their thinking to the contrary, quite mortal and start dying collectively in large numbers that this will correct the market. My worry is that instead what boomers die last will use the last of their block voting power to convince the government to ease restrictions on foreign investment and Australia will become much like Hawaii.
- marvin 12y agoYour correction will probably also start if interest rates ever come back up, and many of the owners need to actually spend some money on the mortgages. Interest rates have been low so long now that we have a whole generation that believes that borrowing money will be free, forever.
- thrownaway2424 12y agoI don't really have an opinion on the conclusion, but it seems like some of the supporting charts are weak. For example, new housing per capita doesn't indicate shortage, and in fact I would expect this metric to fall to zero in case of a housing glut. What you really want is new construction per new households, ideally, or at least per new population. You don't need to build new houses for your existing population.
- dnautics 12y agoespecially if you're coming out of an overbuilding boom where too many housing units were built out of sheer speculative investment that destroyed a lot of equity.
- peter303 12y agoThe market catches up with time, then overshoots. In both directions too. Just wait a bit.
- Bangladesh1 12y agoIts true.