23 ms·
Intel unveils tiny $99 MinnowBoard Max open single-board computer
- frade33 13y agowhat sort of devices it would support mobile or laptop?
- damian2000 13y agoNeither, its really designed for general purpose hacking, connecting to external electronics, sensors, motors, etc. just like the Raspberry Pi ...
- kqr2 13y agoIntel also has the Galileo board which is hardware and software pin-compatible with shields designed for the Arduino Uno* R3. http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/intelligent-systems/galileo/galileo-overview.html http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/intelligent-systems/g...
- makomk 13y agoThe Galileo's one of those boards where it's very important to pay attention to the fine print. For example, the GPIO controller is hanging off a relatively slow I2C port, so access to GPIO is much, much slower than even the lowest-end Arduino. Also, it's a modified 486 which takes multiple clock cycles to carry out many instructions that are single-cycle on modern ARM, so it's not as fast at arithmetic as the clock speed would suggest.
- tdicola 13y agoBe careful though, the Galileo emulates AVR code and is orders of magnitude slower than a real Arduino. Don't expect to pick up any shield and make it work, unfortunately.
- jpwright 13y agoThe Galileo actually only emulates a subset of the Arduino libraries. The AVR libraries themselves are, for the most part, not supported. This makes many popular libraries unusable even when hardware is not an issue.
- viciousplant 13y agoHD4000...hmm can we play Diablo III on it?
- scott_karana 13y agoMost likely. Skyrim was playable on the HD3000s, in my experience, so...
- Narishma 13y agoAs I said above, this thing is much slower than the HD 3000 or 4000.
- BHSPitMonkey 13y agoI think memory might be your bottleneck with newer games. Apparently Diablo III will tolerate having just 1GB, but only on XP.
- Narishma 13y agoIt's not HD Graphics 4000. It's just HD Graphics, with no numbering. It only has 6 execution units (compared to 16 on HD 4000) and is clocked much lower.
- vonmoltke 13y agoActually, per the datasheet[1] it has 4 EUs. I could not find any information about clocking the core, but I didn't search the entire 5100(!) page document. [1] http://www.intel.com/content/dam/www/public/us/en/documents/datasheets/atom-e3800-family-datasheet.pdf http://www.intel.com/content/dam/www/public/us/en/documents/...
- Narishma 13y agoI thought it was the same stuff they put in the Celerons and Pentiums, just clocked lower, but if only has 4 EUs, that's even worse.
- 13y ago
- andyl 13y agoI had hoped to use BeagleBoneBlack for a mobile low-powered application, but the overhead of the different architecture was too much hassle, and I ended up using an Intel NUC. With NUC I can use the same OS as our high-end servers, same 64-bit apt-get repos, and Docker. MinnowBoard looks like what I've been waiting for - fingers crossed...
- pietrofmaggi 13y agoOriginal site is not working for me. You can find board specs on the minnowboard official website: http://www.minnowboard.org/meet-minnowboard-max/ http://www.minnowboard.org/meet-minnowboard-max/ --update (it's working again now, slow but working) contains a lot of useful information, the link I posted contains just the specs.
- asaddhamani 13y agoOriginal site not working for me either. Something interesting like this gotta get a lot of traffic.
- pietrofmaggi 13y agoIntel News announcement (still shown at EELive in San Jose till April 3rd): http://newsroom.intel.com/community/intel_newsroom/blog/2014/03/31/chip-shot-intel-based-minnowboard-max-to-further-embedded-open-source-design http://newsroom.intel.com/community/intel_newsroom/blog/2014... Other sites reporting the same news: http://liliputing.com/2014/03/minnowboard-max-99-intel-atom-powered-single-board-computer.html http://liliputing.com/2014/03/minnowboard-max-99-intel-atom-... http://hardware.slashdot.org/story/14/04/01/0051224/intel-upgrades-minnowboard-baytrail-cpu-nearly-halves-price-to-99 http://hardware.slashdot.org/story/14/04/01/0051224/intel-up... http://www.bit-tech.net/news/hardware/2014/04/01/minnowboard-max/1 http://www.bit-tech.net/news/hardware/2014/04/01/minnowboard...
- elnate 13y agoHow does this compare to a Raspberry Pi?
- damian2000 13y agoNot sure of exact numbers but I'd guess several times faster in terms of computation speed. It runs Android which I think the RPi couldn't do successfully. USB 3 vs USB 2. Double the RAM.
- cheepin 13y agoFrom what I can see, roughly as you would expect from the price difference ie, generally higher stats.
- vonmoltke 13y agoComparing the $99 version to the B ($35): - Double the clock speed (1.46GHz vs. 700MHz) - Double the RAM (1GB vs 512MB) - 8GB of on-board flash - Gigabit ethernet instead of 10/100 - A USB 3.0 port - A SATA II port - A PCIe 2.0 lane - JTAG - x86 architecture Overall, probably worth the extra cost if you need the power and features. The question is, who does? I'm considering this for no other reason than I want a board in this form factor and power class that has SATA and PCIe.
- jbit 13y agoSmall correction: The MinnowBoard MAX only has 8MB of on-board flash, not 8GB. (It's an SPI chip to hold the firmware)
- jmnicolas 13y agoIMHO what we need is not more powerful boards but more affordable ones. At $99 it's too expensive for small projects.
- sgsyc 13y agomaybe it still cant beat arm cpu.
- sgsyc 13y agoarm cpu board prices are much lowerr. shenzhen cpu board is less than 30 usd.
- mariuolo 13y agoThe big advantage is x86 compatibility. I'd pay a premium for that.
- marcosscriven 13y agoJust curious why you view that as an advantage, unless you mean to run commercial, closed-source applications on it?
- girvo 13y agoLess faffing around with even open-source projects that I can't be bothered porting. Although for me, it's Haiku that I want to run on here, and for now it's x86 :)
- aristidb 13y agoEven open source software is often easier on x86. There are more pre-built binaries from the Linux distributions and so on.
- wycx 13y agoBecause trying to run open source on almost all ARM SoCs is a massive pain in the arse. Is there a single modern ARM SoC for which you can download a Linux install image with a mainline kernel and everything `just works'?
- silversmith 13y agoThis seems like the ideal home server solution - powerful enough to run backup solutions / media server for couple people, small enough to fit wherever you want it to. I recently went with a mini-itx BayTrail-D solution as my BTSync / Plex server - a breath of fresh air after year of fighting with ARM board in the same role. This would have been even better, as it would allow me to maintain the same form factor, instead of making way for comparatively bulky mITX case. The only thing I'd like to know is how would you power a SATA drive attached to this?
- sdfx 13y agoThere are external power supplies available that connect directly to a disk. I would be more skeptical regarding I/O-performance. As far as I can see, there are only two SATA-ports available.
- jbaiter 13y agoFor a cheap x86 NAS, you might want to look out for the Asrock Q1900DC which was presented at CeBit this year and is supposed to come out soon. It has 4x2ghz Intel Celeron J1900, 4 SATA2 and 2 SATA3 ports and 19V DC input, so no more need for a bulky ATX power supply (though for a NAS you need to find a way to power those hard disks). Judging from the prices that similarly specced boards are fetching (between 50-70€), this one should be below 100€ as well. Here is a slide from the Asrock CeBit presentation with the specs: http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-1wOiaMWiiXw/Ux7HGzZAl6I/AAAAAAAAHQ4/fRiF1XFwOUs/s1600/Q1900DC.jpg http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-1wOiaMWiiXw/Ux7HGzZAl6I/AAAAAAAAHQ...
- ah- 13y agoI'm using an ifc6410 board as a home server, and as long as you stay with 2.5" disks all you need is 5V. The ifc and as it seems the Minnowboard as well provide 5V, so all you have to do is build your own adapter to SATA power. I just repurposed an old molex to SATA power adapter. For 3.5" disks you also need +12V, so the easiest way would be to gut an external USB disk enclosure.
- foldor 13y agoThis should be a great replacement for my D510MO [1] Mini-ITX home server. It's slightly weaker in CPU speed, but it should be completely fanless and even smaller. For my needs, it should still be plenty enough. [1] http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/motherboards/desktop-motherboards/desktop-board-di510mo.html http://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/motherboards/desktop-...
- tdicola 13y agoThis looks neat for people that want a cheap board to hack on embedded Linux. However for serious control of signal generation, acquisition, PWM, servos, etc. you really don't want to be running a multitasking OS. Something like the Beaglebone Black, with its dedicated 200mhz programmable units in addition to embedded Linux, is much more interesting for hackers and makers IMHO.
- mcescalante 13y agoAgreed - after working with some bit modulation for a whole lot of LEDs and with the PRU unit on the BeagleBone, I don't think I'd want to use a big multitasking embedded system for finer-tuned stuff.
- marcosscriven 13y agoThe PRUs are a seriously underrated feature of the BBBs. It's like having another two computers over 50x as fast as my ZX Spectrum that can run independently, and provide completely realtime output.
- jmulho 13y ago> The PRUs are a seriously underrated feature of the BBBs. Speak English, please.
- stonemetal 13y agoPRU-> programmable real time unit BBB-> BeagleBone Black The BBB has an extra dual core processor that runs at 200Mhz. It is interesting because it is like the processor they teach you about in your intro to computer architecture classes, every instruction is a single cycle instruction. Since it is a co-processor(not running an OS but controllable from the BBB's OS) and execution of instructions is deterministic, it is a good choice for running hard real time code.
- jmulho 13y agoThanks.
- rednukleus 13y agoIs there any way of upgrading the RAM on this so that it can run SteamOS?
- rbanffy 13y agoI don't think an Atom SoC would be adequate in terms of processing power. This is for more modest chores.
- Jach 13y agoNice... I'm glad we're finally getting into the 64-bit age on microcontrollers so 4+ GB of RAM isn't too far off... I've been using the latest Cubieboard (http://www.cubietruck.com/collections/frontpage/products/cubietruck-cubieboard3-cortex-a7-dual-core-2gb-ram-8gb-flash-with-wifi-bt http://www.cubietruck.com/collections/frontpage/products/cub...) for a project and it's been performing pretty well, but having more RAM and x86_64 would be great.
- sliverstorm 13y agoI think we are getting 64-bit microcontrollers because everything else is 64-bit, so 64-bit has become the natural/cost-effective choice. Rather than because uC's are regularly utilizing 4+ GB. It seems unlikely that 4+ GB of RAM will be common just yet.
- ah- 13y agoI wouldn't call the minnowboard a microcontroller, it's more similar to other single board computers like the Pandaboard and the odroid boards. And 2GB are already common for such boards, so 4GB are really not far off.
- TD-Linux 13y agoI would not consider the Minnowboard or Cubieboard a microcontroller. It's usually called an "application processor". Microcontrollers generally have onboard flash and ram. 32-bit microcontrollers have only recently gotten cheap enough to supplant the old 8 and 16 bit mainstays. I don't expect to see AArch64 on any of them anytime soon.
- tim333 13y agoGoogle cache http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:hLPlk9MjDewJ:linuxgizmos.com/intel-unveils-tiny-x86-minnowboard-max-open-sbc/+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:hLPlk9M...
- math0ne 13y agoWell the Pi had a good run, honestly longer than I thought it would but the big boys have entered the arena now. Also imagine what the prices on services like kimsufi and online.net will look like once these guys have hundreds of thousands of them rack mounted. Good times to come.
- eloisant 13y agoThe PI is still a third of the price, depending on you want to do with it, it might be amply enough.
- math0ne 13y agoFor how long though...
- ah- 13y agoThere's also the ODROID-U3, which is roughly comparable to the Minnowboard, and it's just 59$. http://hardkernel.com/main/products/prdt_info.php http://hardkernel.com/main/products/prdt_info.php
- beagle3 13y agoBut do note that it is a "community price, one for customer" only offer. I doubt they are losing money on it, but I suspect you'd have to buy a few hundreds (or maybe thousands) to get that price if you actually want to build something around it.
- lgeek 13y agoThe regular price is $65. http://www.hardkernel.com/main/products/prdt_info.php?g_code=G138745696275 http://www.hardkernel.com/main/products/prdt_info.php?g_code...
- jimmcslim 13y agoMaybe, don't forget that the objective of the Raspberry Pi Foundation has always been education, and keeping the same hardware platform for a longer period of time, eschewing participation in a hardware arms race, works well for this objective (in terms of building learning materials for teachers around R-Pi etc). That said I think they have said that there will be an R-Pi too sooner it later, 2015 perhaps?
- MichaelMoser123 13y agoIt has an Atom E3800 processor. How does power consumption/heating of this Atom processor compare to its competitors?
- cottonseed 13y agoAre the chip docs open? Does linux need binary blobs on this board?
- ah- 13y agoTypically the worst blob are the GPU drivers, and it seems to work with the normal open source i915 driver, which is pretty much as good as it gets.
- voltagex_ 13y agoSorry, I missed that this had got quite a lot of attention! http://uefidk.intel.com/content/minnowboard-uefi-firmware-eula http://uefidk.intel.com/content/minnowboard-uefi-firmware-eu... says >The MinnowBoard EDKII Firmware kit is not available as a full open source release (BSD license). The CPU and chipset initialization code is currently provided as a binary module. The binary module is incorporated into the final firmware image as part of the build process. So graphics & motherboard seem to be open, bootloader is open-ish.
- vonmoltke 13y agoAs far as my EE-addled brain is concerned, there are 5100 pages of deliciousness: http://www.intel.com/content/dam/www/public/us/en/documents/datasheets/atom-e3800-family-datasheet.pdf http://www.intel.com/content/dam/www/public/us/en/documents/...
- Torgo 13y agoApparently the UEFI implementation it requires to boot is not open source :-(
- mark-r 13y agoAny way to replace it with a BIOS, e.g. Coreboot?
- rem1313 13y agoThis could be excellent as Plex client if it does support HDMI CEC. Raspbery Pi is too slow for this
- Tepix 13y agoI'd love to see a small, low power board (ARM or Intel) with Dual SATA ports, ethernet and preferably a serial console instead of the HDMI port.
- voltagex_ 13y agoDual SATA seems to be the sticking point. I'm still using a GlobalScale Dreamplug [1], but you'd be insane to pay retail (~250US) for it now. It's an 800mhz ARMv5 with 512mb of RAM and a single SATA port. It's well supported by the mainline kernel (with an upgrade to uBoot). The FreeScale iMX6 would seem to have enough I/O for two SATA ports (apparently it even has PCIe!) but I've never seen this in a retail board. At this stage you might be better off going for an off the shelf NAS, something that can run FreeBSD and ZFS. [1]: http://www.globalscaletechnologies.com/t-dreamplugdetails.aspx http://www.globalscaletechnologies.com/t-dreamplugdetails.as...
- josteink 13y agoInteresting to see it announced with Linux and Android support. If this doesn't signal a shift from a Microsoft-oriented (Intel) world to a new era, I don't know what does.
- tdicola 13y agoI think people are trying to read too much into this device. This is one of many small board computers you can buy today, many of which particularly in the industrial market have x86 processors. If this sells a few hundred thousand boards like the Beaglebone Black it will be a smashing success. This isn't a statement about Intel moving away from MS.
- exelius 13y agoI think it signals diversification for Intel; not necessarily a shift away from Windows. Running Windows on ultra-low-end boards like this makes no sense; the license would cost more than the board itself and the board isn't powerful enough to run anything approximating a modern version of Windows. It's an order of magnitude slower than your cell phone. Ultimately though, the x86 PC (aka Windows) market is not a significant growth market for Intel. They'll keep pumping money into it as long as they get their 3-5% growth, but if Intel wants to move the needle for the company, they need to find new markets.
- mark-r 13y ago> It's an order of magnitude slower than your cell phone. Really? I'd like to see some evidence of that. I'd assumed they were roughly the same ballpark.
- exelius 13y agoThe base $99 model is a single core 1.4 gHz E3815. The graphics core is significantly slower than a cell phone SoC as well. Intel is not an inferior company or anything; just this product at this price point is slower than a 3 year old cell phone.
- sireat 13y ago
- girvo 13y agoOkay, this is perfect for my low-cost Haiku box project. I'm definitely getting one to hack on. Well done, Intel, and the whole "launching with Android and Linux" thing seems to be indicating an interesting shift...
- samcrawford 13y agoDoes anyone know what would be a reasonable network throughput to expect on this device? I see it has a 1Gbps port, but whether or not the CPU can saturate that is not obvious.
- josteink 13y agoTangentially relevant, I'd love to follow more news from MirrowBoard on this project (and similar projects), but all they seem to have is a Google+ page, and I refuse to sign up for that for a handful of reasons, none which I can be talked out of. What happened to good old RSS? I'd subscribe to that in an instant, but every time I'm directed to a Google+ feed I close the tab and forget about the company. I'm pretty sure that for quite a few techies, looking to try out new gadgets and technology, a Google+ requirement is a deal-killer.
- visarga 13y agoUse a throwaway account.
- bananas 13y agoIsn't that just encouraging the problem and inflating sign up statistics?
- MichaelApproved 13y agoAre you trying to protest or get the information?
- bananas 13y agoThat will be protest. Have some more, I've got plenty left: Back in the good old days before the Internet was segregated into several factions behind membership walls operated by Facebook and Google we had public feeds that: 1. Didn't require signing up for anything. 2. Didn't redirect to some shitty feed aggregator that throws out partial pages so you have to click through to a page stuffed with ads and tracking to get the full content. 3. Actually respected established standards for subscriptions. 4. Actually worked properly. Going a few years before that, we even had this thing called usenet which allowed you to subscribe to topics as well and communicate with other people posting on the feeds!!! Think of that!!! Then Deja came along, got bought by Google, everyone got marketed to death and made to choose ecosystems, a subscriber became a dollar value or a social information provider rather than an appreciated reader, content became small and insignificant and people got lazy resulting in blindly ambling into ecosystems and getting stuck there. And now we're creating throwaway accounts to subscribe to things because that's the only measure of value for content.
- mschuster91 13y agoHmmm... can it run Windows 7? Serious question, I'm after a cheap base system for a HTPC and this looks quite like a fit.
- voltagex_ 13y agoIf you built a UEFI stick (basically drop the contents of a Windows 7 DVD onto a FAT32 (not NTFS) drive) then maybe. XBMC will run on this, but I'm not sure if it can decode 1080p H264.
- userbinator 13y agoIs it PC-compatible enough to run DOS? If not, then probably Windows is entirely out of the question. Just because it's x86 doesn't mean it's PC-compatible.
- outside1234 13y agoDoes anyone know how the performance on something like this stacks up to something like the Raspberry Pi?
- wmf 13y agoA 1.4 GHz Silvermont must be many times faster than a 700 MHz ARM11.
- dxbydt 13y agocan you connect a bunch of these in parallel and run, like, map-reduce or something ?
- wmf 13y agoSure, that's called microservers. It's not a good idea, but you can do it.
- mwcampbell 13y agoWhy aren't microservers a good idea?
- pm90 13y agoWhy is it not a good idea? Genuinely curious
- srdev 13y agoIf I had to guess, probably because you could get equivalent performance cheaper with standard servers. Plus, there's a good chance that your distributed solution could fit on a single server, removing the overhead.
- wmf 13y agoYep. If you compare a $1,000 Xeon E3 server with a $1,000 cluster of ten Minnowboards, the E3 will deliver more performance. Likewise, a $10,000 E5 server beats a cluster of E3s in many cases.