8 ms·
> And I did not chip in ten grand to seed a first investment round to build value for a Facebook acquisition He really puts his finger on one of the reasons wh
by smacktoward 13y ago
> And I did not chip in ten grand to seed a first investment round to build value for a Facebook acquisition
He really puts his finger on one of the reasons why this deal feels so weird here, I think. Nobody who contributed to the Oculus Kickstarter did so because they were hoping Oculus would get flipped to a mega-corp. They didn't do so because they wanted the Oculus team to have a big, splashy VC-style exit. They did so because they wanted the Oculus product. And the history of products that have been swallowed by mega-corps, after the swallowing, is not encouraging.
It's an outcome that strikes directly at the heart of the Kickstarter ethos. Everybody wins in this deal -- except the people who donated to the Kickstarter. Those folks... well, they kind of end up looking like suckers.
- arasmussen 13y agoWho ever said those people aren't going to get the product? Why do you think the product will get swallowed up? > "Oculus will continue operating independently within Facebook" --Mark Zuckerberg
- smacktoward 13y agoYes, just as every CEO of every big company that has just acquired a smaller company has ever said, back unto the dawning of the world. Nothing is ever going to change, until suddenly it all does.
- to3m 13y agoSee, for example: http://www.gyford.com/phil/writing/2013/02/27/our-incredible-journey.php http://www.gyford.com/phil/writing/2013/02/27/our-incredible...
- mcphage 13y agoThat is a seriously depressing tumblr.
- magic_haze 13y agoSurprising how many companies Yahoo has been gobbling up... and shutting down. What exactly _are_ they doing with all the new hires?
- eloisant 13y agoEven when they don't shut them down, they can often turn gold into shit. See Delicious, Flickr (before Melissa Mayer) and so on... Google actually does a better when they decide to keep the product (Android, Blogger, Google Docs...), but it's impossible to know whether they're buying the product or the team until they either integrate the product or shut it down.
- joelrunyon 13y agoDisney picked up pixar and didn't screw it up (too) much.
- nitrogen 13y agoI've wondered whether Pixar would have ventured into making more grown-up movies if they hadn't been bought by Disney (not that I don't enjoy their current stuff, even as an adult).
- thedudemabry 13y agoA very good point. Pixar is notably a huge fan of Ghibli studios, which has ventured into less child-friendly fare in the past. But they have always been a big proponent of universal stories, stories which do not demean children nor sacrifice their integrity to subtextually cater to adults. I would bet that they would be making the same movies that they are now, but Disney would not have released Frozen (as a childless 20-something duder, I was absolutely ecstatic watching that old-style Disney musical.)
- Piromancer 13y agoCars 2.
- frandroid 13y agoYeah but Pixar was already a mature business minting money by that point, with a mature business model, which is very similar to Disney's: Make animation. Release to the big screen. Profit. No need to tinker. It's not like when you buy a startup that's bleeding money with 50 engineers that you could add to your existing products.
- joelrunyon 13y agoYeah - but the parent company didn't make a distinction about startups - just big evil companies acquiring smaller ones.
- devcpp 13y ago
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Kiro 13y agoGive me one example where that actually has happened.
- skore 13y ago> They did so because they wanted the Oculus product. Let's not forget that a huge part of the pitch was to be part of a developer community that sets out into an as of yet unknown realm. I don't think people are worried about what Facebook might do to Oculus, the product. They have a hard time seeing Facebook the social engine and Oculus, the developer community coexisting peacefully. In a way, they're already making a rather concrete case against it.
- bliti 13y agoThat is a very strong point I had not considered. Facebook does not have a smooth relationship with developers. Oculus requires involvement from the developers in order to further develop their product. I reason the Facebook culture of move fast-break things (but don't document it too well) might hurt Oculus. Plus, I saw Oculus as a technology to build upon. I was already planning to use it with robotics. Now, its merely a pawn in Facebook's game.
- tripzilch 13y agoHeh, just had a bit of a wry thought: At least they didn't get bought by Twitter.
- JPKab 13y agoI see this as Oculus being a pawn in the Google/Facebook war for the future of owning all of us. Google is doing Glass(which admittedly is nothing like Oculus) and here comes FB buying Oculus. I'd like to know why Oculus sold to Facebook. That's bullshit. If there's ever been a company that didn't need to sell because its so obvious they are going to be huge, its Oculus.
- visakanv 13y agoAccording to John Carmack: "For the record, I am coding right now, just like I was last week.I expect the FB deal will avoid several embarrassing scaling crisis for VR." "I have a deep respect for the technical scale that FB operates at. The cyberspace we want for VR will be at this scale." Source: https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack
- paulhauggis 13y agoIs this the equivalent of a fan hating an indy band for "selling out"?
- whatisa 13y agoA better analogy - fans pay an artist up front to record an album, said artist then uses the resulting success to produce a different genre of music for a major label under an exclusive contract.
- nl 13y agoA better analogy - fans pays artist up front to record album. Band records album and delivers it to fans. Then band signs deal with record company. Fans hate band for "selling out".
- DanBC 13y agoA better analogy: Band wants to release music. Have a sucessful kickstarter and release an exciting first album to backers. Everyone is excited. Band then signs to a label that won't let people listen to the music without signing in to a social network first, and who will post "Joe Bloggs likes Band!" on your wall, and who only let you listen to the music in their app.
- rubinelli 13y agoThe funny thing is, every major game company does exactly that. Want to play this offline, single-player game? Well, let's first create an account in our service, so we can enhance our experience! Wow, you collected your first item! Here's an achievement that will show up on all of your friends' feeds, along with how long you've been playing. Surely you want to announce to the world you spent your last twenty hours playing Lawnmower Simulator 2014? Hey, how about we add a button to your controller to make it even easier to share videos with all our friends?
- 13y ago
- mcphage 13y ago> Everybody wins in this deal -- except the people who donated to the Kickstarter. Those folks... well, they kind of end up looking like suckers. It's kinda a twist to the normal Kickstarter warnings—if you back a product, it might not ever succeed, jut disappear. This was a product that people backed, that was too successful, and looks like it's about to disappear.
- clef 13y agoUnfortunately there is a difference between "backer" and "investor", even if they both chuck money in the project. Would there be such a thing as a kickstarted kind of thing where backers can become shareholders? Or could this simply be a case of "if you invest 10 grand, you get x shares"? This way there could be a way for investors not to ride on the back of backers later on? Or am I being totally silly?
- contulluipeste 13y agoFor public shares there is only the stock market, but that isn't a kick-starter. It would be interesting to have an option in the stock market of just bidding money for stock and the actual transaction to be executed only after the required amount was gathered. I'm not sure if it would be possible to build such thing without involving governmental regulation.
- eloisant 13y agoThis is the problem I have with Kickstarter. * You can't see it as investing, because you're not getting any share. * You may see it as pre-ordering a product that doesn't exist (and I think that's how most backers see it), but you don't get any consumer protection if the project fails or doesn't live up to your expectation. * All is left is seeing Kickstarter as a charity. You're giving charity to a for-profit organisation.
- moron4hire 13y agoKickstarter is patronage. It can't be considered anything else or they get into some legal trouble with one or more US bureaus. You can't see it as investing because then the SEC gets involved. You can't see it as prodding a product because then, as you said, consumer protection act gets involved. And you can't see it as a donation because then the IRS gets involved (more involved, as backers will want to take deductions). Kickstarter, as a company, cannot and does not promote any view of backing except patronage. You are literally a sugar daddy for the people working on the project. Backing buys their time. Time they have promised to use to make a thing you want, but your only recourse if they don't is to not buy anymore of their time.
- samstave 13y agoPersonally, I think this illustrates a severe gap in how crowd-funding works. 10K drops by an individual are no different than an angel investor. There should be a chip-in-level for crowd-funding campaigns that require the OP to provide some % equity into the project.
- frandroid 13y agoSuddenly, the SEC wants to regulate your crowd-funding business. Oops.
- thedudemabry 13y agoYeah, that thought makes me a little bit uncomfortable. Kickstarter campaigns were interesting precisely because they didn't equate investment with profits. They attempted to align investment with niche product delivery.
- k-mcgrady 13y ago>> "10K drops by an individual are no different than an angel investor." They are different. An angel investor is investing - they may lose that 10K. Someone dropping 10K on a crowd funding project is told the rewards they will get up front and receives them when the project is complete.
- dagw 13y agoand receives them if the project is completed
- Jtsummers 13y agoThere's no guarantee that you'll receive anything. If the product or project fails, you get squat, or maybe a t-shirt. An investor gets a stake in the company, if it succeeds their investment grows. A backer gets nothing extra if the project succeeds beyond the promised reward.
- wolfgke 13y ago> 10K drops by an individual are no different than an angel investor. So far accepted. The difference is that the angel investor buys equity share with their money, while the individual gets a piece of the product if its development and production will succeed.
- calbear81 13y agoHow is pre-ordering not just a form of fundraising on Kickstarter that skirts the laws around crowsourced investing? Couldn't a startup just go on Kickstarter, promise some type of product to be delivered x months in the future, raise their seed and focus on getting bought w/o ever having to give up any equity?
- jrochkind1 13y agoSkirts the laws around crowd-sourced investing? If it had been 'investing', the funders would have gotten a piece of facebook's two billion acquisition bucks, right? That's what investing means, right? As you mention, "without having to give up any equity." I think kickstarter funders on technology projects are frequently suckers, but it's not got a lot to do with 'skirting the laws around crowdsourced investing'.
- thedudemabry 13y agoAgreed. This is a "gamble to win a product that you want" game, not a "gamble to win a stake in a company that you like" game. The very product-based focus of the transaction is intended to discourage thinking of it as an investment. I think Notch was perfectly reasonable in his analysis. He got the product that he wanted, but was disappointed that their tactics after fulfillment were to cash out and align their direction with Facebook's. And he doesn't trust facebook.
- jrochkind1 13y agoWell, I think both yes and no. I think many people _do_ give to kickstarter campaigns when it's a group of people they _feel like helping_. This is a bigger part of non-technology project kickstarter transactions, but I think it's probably a part of technology projects too, as can perhaps be seen in the way they are pitched on their project pages, or how funders respond to them -- obviously Notch didn't give $10k just as a 'pre-order'. It's not _just_ "I want to pre-order this not yet existing tech thing which hopefully will exist", it's also "I want to help these guys succeed, I understand they're scrappy nobody's who might not be able to do it without me, I'm willing to take on some risk and perhaps pay a premium in part because I want to help them, and I know they're taking on risk themselves." It's not about equity, in fact it's more... charitable? Solidaritous? Helpful?... than equity. I mean, consider, if Facebook itself started a kickstarter project to fund some new device or platform -- do you think people would fund it on facebook? I think it's both predictable and understandable people feel 'sold out' when they thought they were funding some scrappy strivers who were putting themselves on the line for the project too, only to have those scrappy strivers make a huge amount of cash by selling out to major corporation -- before the product you thought you were helping to make possible was even finished.
- yaeger 13y agoNo he doesn't. He oversimplifies things. You know what the money during the kickstarter campaign was for? The first DevKit! They raised money for the dev kit and guess what? The people you chipped in got their dev kits. As far as I can see, people got exactly out of the kickstarter campaign what they wanted. They helped to start the business of Oculus and in return even got the DevKit to experience the first results on the road to VR. I hardly think just cause you started your business with a kickstarter campaign and gave the backers what you set out to give them should exempt you from ever getting acquired by another company somewhere down the road. If that were true, why go on kickstarter at all? That would basically mean you will always stay a small time player. If you can survive at all because you will have to do it all by yourself. Next thing you know, kickstarter backers demand that you also don't accept other investors money because then, these investors would also have a say how to do things.
- Argorak 13y agoYou are oversimplifying things as well. On the "cash on the table" side of things you are right: people put cash on the table and got the goods. On the other hand, Kickstarter is a platform where people invest in future of some geeks. A successful funding drive plays on emotions, on promises and a glimpse of the future. A lot of the people that got a dev kit were closely monitoring what Oculus was doing and were pleased. Those people feeling let down by Oculus not staying independent is perfectly reasonable and fine to state. It is also fully okay to withdraw your future support because they are now part of a company that shows not general interest in helping any companies but themselves.
- runako 13y ago>> Kickstarter is a platform where people invest in future of some geeks And then those same backers complain loudly when those geeks succeed at business. Oculus just sold, before launching a product, for a quarter of the value of Electronic Arts (revenue: $3.7B). Perhaps Oculus (the business) was too successful for its backers, but there's not a lot of teams that would have turned down a deal like this.
- 13y ago
- Nursie 13y agoYet another reason that kickstarter should be equity based. At the moment it's basically a charitable donation to someone else's success.
- joezydeco 13y agoUm, you do get a product if it successfully completes. That's what most people are paying for.
- rabz 13y agoThese products or services are not guaranteed by Kickstarter or Kickstartees though, so we backers aren't paying for a product alone. In many cases, the value of the product is not commensurate with the money paid. Notch certainly didn't get his $10000 worth from getting a kit and meeting Carmack—he could have picked up a kit after the campaign and met Carmack at GDC or Quakecon or wherever. It's more akin to donating $100 to PBS and getting a tote bag and a $70 tax write-off, without the write-off. As others have said, it's a charitable donation to a cool project from which backers could possibly get some benefits.
- TheCapn 13y agoSomeone who's read the terms of use and licensing and all those other jazzy legal documents could correct me if I'm wrong, but is there anything stopping a company from having one of their promises an equity stake in the company? Say, I'm running a kickstarter and put a tier of funding as "equity". I put aside 10% ownership of my brand to those willing to pay $1,000 or more (for instance). If I set up terms that those who pay above $1k get equity relative to how much they contributed would that be wrong? An example, 10 people paid $1k to each earn 1% equity in my new company. Or, say 20 people each paid $1k, would get 0.5% each. (20k total, 1k contribution). Terms are loose, and this is all speculation, but at a theoretical level is there anything wrong with the founders creating such an incentive?
- pjc50 13y agoLocal securities law usually prevents you selling shares to the public without a lot more accounting.
- madeofpalk 13y agoHow would you feel if Valve bought Oculus? Do you think the internet's reaction would be different?