12 ms·
The problem isn’t piracy – it’s competition
- mehwoot 13y agoUtter crap. Not everybody can be a musician, at least in the genres I listen to, and the difference between the amateurs and the professionals is painfully obvious. I'm not being elitist here- I wish anybody could make what I like (and do it well), then there would be a lot more for me to enjoy. Maybe this is the case in rock music or whatever the author is familiar with, but it isn't in all genres. And still, the income from selling tracks is miniscule. It is not competition doing it, it is just the ease of getting it for free on the internet.
- graeme 13y agoCompetition might still have something to do with it. The superstar bands of the 60s are still actively touring. People continue to listen to popular music from every decade since. I'm not sure this was the case to the same extent in the past. It's never been this easy to access the music of the past. On the other hand, it's never been easier to reach fans directly and succeed in a niche, of which there are many more. I'm not speaking from experience on this last point, but I know it's true in publishing.
- Daishiman 13y agoThe "superband" concept of the sixties is dead and has been for a long time. The equivalent music of the times is usually done by electronic producers, who are much more plentiful, competitive, and underground; record labels prefer to invest in huge pop star acts rather the up and coming musicians. Consider that over 90% of radio is owned by Clear Channel, so the variety of music most people who are not hardcore listeners has been substantially decreased. Finally, since access to music from the past is easier than ever before (remember that in the age of vinyl records represses were rare, so people would only have what was available to purchase at their disposable), most people prefer to continue to listen to the stuff they heard in their teens rather than continue to investigate different tastes.
- anigbrowl 13y agoI'm a techno musician. It's very easy to reach fans, but succeeding financially (by which I mean being able to earn something close to the median income and pay for ordinary living expenses, as opposed to fast cars and luxury items) is extremely difficult. Of course one can 'go commercial' and make pop-dance music, aka EDM, but not everyone wants to do that, either materially or artistically. 10-15 years ago a good artist could expect to sell a few thousand copies of an album in a niche genre like psychedelic trance or drum'n'bass, which wouldn't make one rich but would keep a roof over one's head and provide a similarly reasonable return for the label. Now it's very hard to sell 1000 copies of an album and many labels are wary of even releasing in that format, preferring the lower risk of singles.
- graeme 13y agoThis is something I've wondered about. In my niche, if I can reach people, I can sell them stuff or make money from affiliate sales. But they're also making an investment in my niche, so they're willing to spend. When you've just got fans, to what extent can you make money via means other than sales?
- pzuraq 13y agoIt is competition though. Competition directly for listening time, a person's attention. Every musician has there own pitch, there own style, with which they compete for a listeners attention. It's not that anyone who picks up a guitar or drumset or ableton can be a professional, it's that these things are more accessible than ever and, much more importantly, the means of distribution is almost completely accessible to anyone. This means that there is a huge amount of music to choose from and a huge variety. Yes, a lot of it is crap, but there is still more that isn't due to the sheer volume of content (keep in mind that what is and isn't good is subjective. Even if you and I agree that musician X is terrible, maybe there's someone who likes terrible.) What this all boils down to is that professionals are losing there competitive edge, quickly. Publishing no longer needs a guarantee of profit because setup cost has dropped to practically nothing and distribution cost IS nothing. They can offer more varied and nuanced music, but when it comes down to it most people just want something to play and don't have stringent requirements for their music. Amateur music is quickly filling in that gap, especially on the electronic front (not just EDM, there is a huge variety of music composed digitally that sounds nothing like your standard rave music). In the end, music is becoming what it used to be, a cultural phenomenon.
- mehwoot 13y agoAmateur music is quickly filling in that gap, especially on the electronic front (not just EDM, there is a huge variety of music composed digitally that sounds nothing like your standard rave music). No, you are completely wrong. I can't talk about genres I don't know about but for the electronic music I listen to there is a painfully obvious difference between amateur and professional stuff. To the point where I think it is harming the genre. The top artists earn almost nothing from sales of their music, but command large fees for playing 1-2 hours sets every weekend. There is a real dearth of new talent because people getting into it just don't have the sound engineering experience to make their music sound good enough for people to enjoy. What happens is the big labels find producers would could have some talent, take them on board and teach them how to make the music and have the experienced engineers tidy up their work until it sounds good. What this has resulted in is the two major labels absolutely dominating the scene with a large majority of the big names signed to them and absolutely dominating the share of music listened to. One of the labels also owns the major online store that sells music in this genre. And yet, they still make next to nothing from sales. This is why ghost producing is so widespread in electronic music- the only money to be made is in live performances. To get big there, you need good productions to get a name for yourself. So what do you do if you're only interested in making music but not performing? You make the music, put it out with someone else's name, they do the performance and bring in the $$ and you split it (or whatever your agreement is). Now, competition might be more prevalent in other genres- but I can tell you without a shadow of a doubt that in genres without significant competition, there is still no money to be made in sales. People listen to the top artists like crazy, they just don't pay for the music because why wouldn't you just download it all for free?
- ThomPete 13y agoSorry but many many many so called artists cant play or compose anything to save their lives. P-diddy never played an instrument. Plenty of popular singers are mediocre to say the least. And many many many very talented musicians make no money what so ever. Musical talent have very little to do with whether you can live from your music.
- mehwoot 13y agoMusical talent have very little to do with whether you can live from your music. For some genres of music yes, for others, no. There are genres where sound design is of the utmost importance. I'm not saying competition isn't a factor universally- I'm saying genres without significant competition still have the same problems, so it clearly isn't the dominant factor.
- ThomPete 13y agoThe genres where it matters are not genres where you can make a lot of money and are not the genres we normally talk about when we talk about piracy.
- uniclaude 13y agoA few electronic music acts might disagree with you here. Daft Punk? Skrillex? The Prodigy? A lot of importance on sound design here, and it is major enough to be on topic on most of those debates.
- ThomPete 13y agoLets not confuse things here. It is not because of their skills around sound design that they or any other become popular. It has to do much more with timing, culture etc. Again there are many great great sound designers and and composers out there that will never see any fame at all. It's much more complex than just the music itself.
- 13y ago
- hnha 13y agoso, what genres are those?
- GotAnyMegadeth 13y agoTechnical death metal
- thenomad 13y agoWhich genres are you referring to here? This is a really interesting data point.
- simplexion 13y agoHoodie Allen and Hopsin are laughing because they have embraced new ways of making money with their music. Mostly via social networking. There are more that are doing this but these 2 are good examples.
- graeme 13y agoAre you referring to this stuff?: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hoodie_Allen#Fandom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hoodie_Allen#Fandom I'd love to hear more detail.
- simplexion 13y agoYou can also download all his music except 1 album for free. http://www.hoodieallen.com/music/ http://www.hoodieallen.com/music/
- rayiner 13y agoThis article is totally wrong. It mentions two very important things, but gets the implications of both wrong. 1) Competition is an issue. But competition isn't driving down prices. Despite all the music out there, people continue to gravitate towards the big record label stars. Nobody is competing by producing something people like as much as Rihanna, except cheaper. Instead, the "competition" is by delivering Rihanna for free by infringing copyrights. 2) Marginal costs of production of music are zero. But that does not mean music should be free, any more than it means iPhones should be $200 or whatever. The point about competition shows that music is not fungible. People have rejected indie music. They want Rihanna. Now, when you're talking about a product that is not fungible marginal cost is irrelevant. It doesn't how much each Hermes bag costs to reproduce.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- clicks 13y ago> Despite all the music out there, people continue to gravitate towards the big record label stars. Nobody is competing by producing something people like as much as Rihanna, except cheaper. You seem to be under the impression that people determined her art to be of greater value and thus a higher demand for it was created than all of Rihanna's competitors. That is only very slightly true. Demand for Rihanna's music is created mostly by record companies' aggressively promoting it and advertising it in various venues, not because people decided with no outside influence that her music is better than the competitors'. Rihanna won because her record company is better at salesmanship than her competitors. Now her popularity is soaring in a bandwagon effect, as is typical of popstars or really any popular phenomenon. Your point that music should not be free because of its marginal cost of production being zero is an interesting one -- just as there isn't an expectation for the iPhone price to be $200, it does indeed make sense that music shouldn't be free. But, with all the talk about capitalism being a faulty economic system these days, a particular recipient of rage -- and rightfully so, in my opinion -- is that entity which charges bad prices [1] for its goods. Now, you might be wondering why it's music which gets all this drama about people objecting to its costs, and not the banking sector or something. That's because it's a thing that's close to people -- everyone listens to music, and naturally everyone wonders why it costs so much when the means of its distribution are effectively zero. Personally I think we as a society need to first think deeply about corporations that operate essentially on a rentiering model of monetization (the recent wave of 'sharing startups' are a prime example) and then we should worry about what is a good model of music distribution. But hey, record companies are basically rentiering companies as well. [1]: Bad as in socially or morally irresponsible. If some company finds a cure for cancer -- and that cure, it turns out requires only $2 to make for every pill, it would not be ethical to charge an exorbitant price like $20,000 for it, no matter how much the research costs were (people dying is a bigger concern than people not getting paid). This is obviously an extreme example, but you get the point.
- WalterSear 13y agoThe problem isn't piracy, it's the mediocrity of the stuff put out by professional music industry.
- quadrangle 13y agoYour statement would be valid if the concern was only about quality, but higher quality wouldn't rescue a completely obsolete economy.
- beloch 13y agoBefore the twentieth century, and even today in some parts of the world, music wasn't something you buy. It was something you participate in. Before the invention of the phonograph, people would bring instruments to parties and play music themselves. It took time for this tradition to die out. Even in the 40's movie theaters frequently showed sing-a-long shorts! While recorded music has brought first-rate professional performances to the masses, it has robbed untold millions of musical expression. How many of us learned to play some instrument or another as children, but never bothered to keep playing because we didn't like the music we were taught to play and didn't think we could ever play well enough to be worth listening to? Odds are most people reading this are much less musically accomplished than their great-great grandparents were. For a substantial portion of the twentieth century, technological limitations made recording and distribution expensive. You could make a lot more money by promoting a star and making everyone want a small number of records than you could by recording everything under the sun! Some of those stars were just gifted amateurs who had mass appeal the moment they walked in from the wilds. Those were rare enough that we soon learned how to manufacture stars, and the methods have reached a level of sophistication where musical talent isn't even necessary anymore (see autotuning). The internet has practically eliminated the costs and difficulty of distribution. The moment you record something, you can send it to the other side of the planet almost instantaneously to as many people who are interested in it exist. Recording still takes some knowledge, but the equipment required to do professional quality recording is now easily accessible to hobbyists. Natural prodigies are still showing up now and then, and stopping them from recording great music would be more challenging than allowing them to do so! It's the manufactured star system that's collapsing. It costs a lot to do research on what should appeal to teenagers in a few years, hire professional writers to design songs matching your research results, hire somebody who looks good in a latex bikini to record those songs, shoot videos, etc., and finally have a team of professional audio engineers digitally massage her horrid caterwaulings into something that doesn't sound horrible when blasted through iPod earbuds at top volume. Manufactured music superstars are a dying breed, and good riddance. My playlist is devoid of them and full of gifted amateurs, and I couldn't be happier with the change! The global musical monoculture is ending and a diverse, global party is replacing it. We are working towards the point where music can be created by anyone, anywhere, to be shared with everyone, everywhere. Perhaps, as we listen to superstars less and to ordinary people more, the pressure to play like a superstar or not play at all will drop away and we'll reclaim the tradition of participatory music that we've been robbed of. Perhaps, one day, people will start bringing their instruments to parties again!
- bhewes 13y agoWhen I read stuff like this I think, oh, I can download Linux, emacs, the GNU Science package, quantlib, a few pirated quant books and then call myself a quant trader. I mean come on, just because the tools are cheap or free does not translate into me being competitive. Music and art has always been about competition. Let me talk about space I know better, Poetry - The Roman Empire produce a total of four major poets Horace, Virgil, Catullus and Ovid. That is it four. A thousand years of history you get four. Anyways, everyone wants to be on top, but the top is only so big. And Art has a nasty winner take all effect (as clicks pointed out). That is the game deal with it. As for Piracy, it is a side effect of making money. People only pirate things that have value. Otherwise the use of the word piracy does not make any sense.
- educating 13y agoCompetition has always been a problem. But the answer to that problem was people buying records of music that they liked. No videos. Stop fooling yourselves. Piracy did seriously wound the music industry. CD-R drives in computers and the internet, filesharing on Usenet, Napster, Googling for mp3s. Then record companies were getting less because they were selling singles vs. albums (though they sold 35s decades before with no problems, but albums/full CDs brought in more than the singles, at least when there was only one really popular single on an album/CD). The industry is not coming back either. The record companies have little incentive to put money into a loser, which means everything is candy, peanut butter, and honey. No gourmet. Dave Brubeck would be a homeless man in today's record industry.
- quadrangle 13y agoIn today's record industry, Dave Brubeck would not be homeless, he'd be one of the many thousands of extremely talented people recording stuff you've never heard because there's so much competition; but he'd find some audience and go around performing and making do. He'd probably struggle financially like lots of others and rightfully complain about gross economic inequities today in our corrupt system. None of this has anything to do with the red herring about "piracy".
- lutusp 13y ago> In today's record industry, Dave Brubeck would not be homeless ... I have to repeat something funny that Brubeck said -- he said the most common question asked by fans was, "How many musicians are there in your quartet?"
- gizzlon 13y agoStop fooling yourselves. Piracy did seriously wound the music industry. I'm not saying that it didn't. But you also have to recognize that the music industry betted against the Internet. It took 10 years before I could easily pay for Internet delivered music. I'm not even saying that this is better than CDs, but they should at least have explored the possibilities. They deserved to go bust for all the mistakes they made the last 15-20 years.
- moconnor 13y agoSo the software industry will be next, right? Zero cost distribution. Is this a factor in the popularity of offering SaaS?
- snowwrestler 13y agoTotal bullshit. The most pirated music is the most popular music, not indie amateur stuff no one has heard of. The problem is simply that teenagers like to get stuff for free.
- quadrangle 13y agoLogic fail. Of course there will be a correlation between most popular and most pirated. DUH. Your hand-wringing about teenagers is an insult to everyone's intelligence.
- snowwrestler 13y ago> Of course there will be a correlation between most popular and most pirated. DUH. Yes, that's my point, and it is counter to the thesis in the article, which is that established bands are being out-competed by amateurs. I'm not hand-wringing; it's also true that there is a correlation between teenage ages, and likelihood to download music rather than purchase it.
- josephagoss 13y ago>The problem is simply that teenagers like to get stuff for free. Thats funny because I sometimes download indie amateur stuff without paying and I am not a teenager, but I (and my many friends) are apart of the problem. So is the problem really teenagers getting stuff for free? No, not entirely. Augments with absolutes rarely work and make you seem like you have an agenda.
- josephagoss 13y ago*Arguments
- guard-of-terra 13y agoTeenagers would never have the money, write them off. You should target young adults who can pursue their hobby with money. When you can't make them part with their money it's your problem, not piracy problem.
- yason 13y agoPiracy only kills music that people are willing to bargain for, i.e. where the cost matters and not so much the music. That translates to a lot of mediocre crap generated and promoted by the record industry themselves. However, the reason people buy works of good musicians and bands is that because it means something to them to own that particular cd or album. That's something you can't pirate because the point is to own something from the artist and through that bond emotionally liken yourself to him/her. If someone's good, it doesn't suffice to copy his music for free because you can hear it in a lot of places anyway. And you've probably already copied his albums from same place or some friend by the time. But you're still craving for the only remedy which is to buy the album yourself so that you can listen to your own copy of that album. People want to own things that they deem important, and nothing's going to change that. The market for that is smaller than the preplanned pop music market of today, but it's still a big market and it's also a market that isn't subject to whims of trends that come and go.
- hrasyid 13y agoI'm obviously no economist, so can someone explain if price tends to be equal to the marginal cost, who is supposed to cover the fixed cost?
- ds9 13y agoIn the classical era, wealthy patrons contributed the fixed costs - training of musicians, providing room and board and practice time for sponsored composers and musicians, etc.. In the 20th century, the "record companies" covered the fixed costs - recording, distribution etc.. They did so by offering only contracts that were economically very unfavorable to the artists, and using some of the revenue from the more popular acts to finance others that they hoped would make money for them (not for the artists). Today, unless a musician is foolish enough to sign up for the old-style ripoff contract, it's DIY. But the fixed costs have declined - the musicians invest in practicing their craft at their own expense, and pay for instruments as always, but low-to-mid-quality recording and internet distribution are orders of magnitude cheaper than the old means of $100/hour studios and hauling boxes of CDs to stores.
- kfk 13y ago1. Marginal costs are not 0. The musician has a cost, his time has a cost. So, let's not fall in the trap of seeing only certain costs. Of course, a cook that does music in his free time might have a marginal cost of 0, but not everybody listens to that. Amateur music, when it sounds amateur, is horrible. I challenge the assumption that amateur is good enough for many, it is not true, I have never seen people listening to crappy music in their cars. 2. There is an easy way to make money: concerts. 3. The obvious answer is the destruction of neoliberalism. No it's not. The obvious answer is more liberism, because, believe it or not, less copyrights BS is completely in the realm of neoliberism. While what he hints too, planned economy and State, is exactly what has created these ridiculous music labels that cash out on monopolies instead than real value.
- yk 13y agoThe marginal cost, that is the cost of one additional copy, is zero. ( Actually it is some server cost, so < $10 per TB.) The musician., studio etc. are upfront costs.
- kfk 13y agoFor me the marginal cost is the additional song, not the additional copy of a song. Then again, if one looks at the obvious, that musician have to make money from concerts, it becomes clear that marginal costs will never be 0 in the music industry. Competition or not competition.
- yk 13y agoFor me the marginal cost is the additional song, not the additional copy of a song. From the perspective of the musician, who sells to a record label, yes. From the perspective of a record label, and thus what determines the prices for customers, the marginal cost is zero. So the record labels need some other revenue stream, and hence the push to control the entire 'celebrity product.'
- kfk 13y ago
- api 13y agoA comment from the article: "In point of fact, I don’t think you can get around the fact that we need to renegotiate how our economy works. It’s just going to become more and more obvious over time." It's already obvious. We're very rapidly moving toward a world where a tiny, tiny elite capture massive percentages of all value through controlling a small number of convenience portals. The value of all other non-commodity goods tends toward zero, or the cost of whatever commodities they require. This does resemble the post-Capitalist terminal state Marx described. Marx did not advocate a revolution, nor did he say "from each according to his ability" and so forth. That was Lenin and Trotsky. Marx was really talking about this-- about the fact that capitalism would eventually overproduce itself into obsolescence. He wasn't anti-capitalist so much as post-capitalist, sort of a sci-fi thinker talking about post-scarcity. But I'm not a Marxist per se, and I don't think he had the right formula for "what do we do now?" I think that remains to be discovered.
- Pxtl 13y agoI think a big problem is clearchannel. While the marginal costs are zero, the costs of marketing are not. The musical literati with their Pitchfork magazines and their music blogs and their custom-made Pandora lists and all that can dive into the deep end of indie music, but the laymen still just use the knob in the car, and the knob in the car is effectively controlled by the big record companies and they only offer it to musicians that they totally control. This means that, while the indie market is growing and the communication for indie fans is better, the indie fanbase can't really effectively invade the mainstream until terrestrial radio dies its long-overdue death. If you want to go out of your way to select your music streams, there's a lot for you. But for people who just want background music to some other task, the process of digging around and separating the wheat from the chaff is time they just don't want to allocate for 4-minute chunks of music.
- ianstallings 13y agoI kind of wonder if a newer patronage model may spring up, where people can pay an artist for works and then maybe even contribute themselves, adding a personal touch. We can already crowd-fund musicians, and donate to those that release their music for free. Why not go back to patronage?