18 ms·
Fucking Sue Me (2011)
- bcoughlan 13y agoPerhaps the lesson is that getting sued is an occupational hazard.
- JonFish85 13y agoAs much as I admire the candor & spirit of this, at the same time, I'd hate to have the chance of being completely destroyed by the lawyers. Dodged a bullet in this case, but to me, the downside is not even close to worth the upside. $400k contract, but if things go horribly awry, their lawyers are coming after you for millions, and drag you through the mud. Not worth it, in my opinion.
- ojbyrne 13y agoBut from the other side, the perspective is probably: - legal fees are going to be in the $100k's - he clearly has little money, so even if we win, we'll end up garnishing his wages for 40 years to get a fraction of what we sued for. - we might not win, then we're further in the hole So take the loss and move on. Thus from pud's side it's not an insane risk, but a calculated one.
- brazzy 13y agoThat assumes the other side is rational and motivated only by profit. Which is not always a given (or possible to tell in advance).
- JonFish85 13y agoI imagine there are cases where companies have to go after bad contracts even when they know they won't get their money. Whether it's a duty to their shareholders, sending a message to future contractors, what-have-you. And depending on the size of the company, their lawyers may be getting paid regardless of whether they are doing this case or not (not really sure how legal departments work).
- Spearchucker 13y agoIt is human nature to be more motivated by the threat of loss than the possibility of gaining something of equal value. Regardless of our predilection, neither is wrong, nor right. It simply is. Being aware of it however, gives us choice.
- joezydeco 13y agoI interpreted Pud's dad like this: "Fucking sue me" == "I'm 22, have no assets to speak of, and you're going to try and collect millions on me? Good luck." In Pud's particular case, it's easier to say this. If you're an established firm with hundreds of employees and millions in cashflow, not so much.
- MichaelGG 13y agoExactly. When I was about 20, one of my partners emptied the bank account leaving us unable to make payroll/rent and finish some client jobs. Had several clients come angry demanding we finish or they'd sue us. My dad gave me the exact same advice. We'd try to find some way of finishing the job over a longer period of time, otherwise, hey, lose your deposit, and good luck suing me or my company that have zero assets. It worked fine. Years later at a more successful startup, the "sue me" thing doesn't work so well, and a pretty major win depended on a simple "and/or" clause written with inverse logic.
- probablyfiction 13y ago> I’m not sure what the lesson is here. Me either, but it was a good read.
- calinet6 13y agoWell this just makes you sound reckless and ignorant. I don't think you are. The conclusion might be valuable; that taking risks is a necessary part of business. But the way you get there is not by ignoring the risks, but by fully understanding them and being prepared and willing to deal with the consequences. This is why you read the contract, understood it, and decided to sign it. It was because you understood all the bad stuff that could happen, but you decided to make it not happen or deal with the consequences. It was sort of a dare in your agreement, a recognition that the agreement you were signing was important but also impossibly complex (they always are), and that the larger picture was more important. Understanding that and making your decision is not the same as being lazy and irresponsible, and I really don't think that's what you are if you've made it any distance in business. Maybe some people are, I don't know. Cool story though.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoThis is from 1998 (written up in 2011), and was written by pud of f*ckedcompany fame, I think. He probably doesn't read hackernews.
- stevenj 13y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=pud https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=pud
- oskarth 13y agoHe very much does. https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=pud https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=pud (last comment was a month ago).
- brazzy 13y agoSo he very much does, but doesn't very much?
- ianstallings 13y agoPedantic pants now come in all sizes and colors!
- mildtrepidation 13y agoI'm not sure what the lesson is here. If a lesson would be considered an informative or useful conclusion based on the circumstances and results described, I'd say the only lesson here is that the author was very lucky despite what seems -- at least as described -- like very risky behavior. This definitely is not the way to run a business, particularly when there are people depending on you. It's great that it went well, but "just sign it" is very reckless, and "fucking sue me" is, quite literally, asking for it. If you're not prepared for the eventuality of being sued this is just an unconscionable stance to take. Yes, business almost always involves risk, but it's almost always possible to take calculated risks rather than throwing up your hands, signing whatever's put in front of you, and hoping for the best.
- jimhefferon 13y ago> calculated risks Yes, you shouldn't agree to every crazy clause that is in a contract someone sends you. But you also shouldn't get sucked into lawyering. Your lawyer is paid to say "What about .." but it is kind of a YAGNI thing: the lawyer meeting is a part of getting work done but don't let it be too big a part. That's the calculated part of your comment and personally, reading this post in the past helped me to see that.
- petercooper 13y agoI've been trying to find a post by either Derek Sivers or Tim Ferriss along these lines. It was about basically ignoring annoying rules and regulations if the potential penalty was either small or unlikely to be incurred. Anyone remember it?
- lamby 13y agoIt's certainly in the 4HWW book. Probably in the context of ignoring emails.
- jacobparker 13y agoRelevant Hark! A Vagrant: http://www.harkavagrant.com/index.php?id=206 http://www.harkavagrant.com/index.php?id=206
- wavefunction 13y agoI downvoted your post because it only contained a link to a web comic. If you had provided some of your own opinions on the blog post or why the comic was relevant to the blog post, I would have refrained. I like to explain my downvotes when the downvoted post is not an obvious troll.
- sambeau 13y agoI don't see how adding commentary to the comic would have added anything. 'Relevant' linking is an art and in this case it was artfully done. You don't want to ruin the punchline, if any, as if done correctly the juxtaposition of the thread you go from to the relevant new thread should hopefully create something tangential, underlined or poignant. This link was relevant, funny & poignant. Adding a small commentary would have removed from the latter two. It also has something significant to say about startups. A link like this would never have made the front page even though it tangentially says something important about entrepreneurial success (something that successful entrepreneurs too-often choose to forget). Startups should print this out and stick it on their wall.
- tptacek 13y agoI canceled out your downvote because I like Hark! A Vagrant.
- dylangs1030 13y agoYou'd probably like SMBC too (if you don't already read it).
- pepve 13y agoI think you're being silly. And I don't think that's what downvotes are for (not that I have a say in the matter, because I don't have the button). Explaining why the comic is relevant would be like explaining the joke itself. That hardly every works. Would you downvote a comment with just a link to a paper about the technology being discussed in the article?
- jonnathanson 13y ago"I'm not sure what the lesson is here." I'm not sure, and furthermore, I'm not sure I agree with being overly 'fuck-it' about legal matters. But I can tell you what it's like having been where you were with the "endless lawyering," and why it sucked so badly. I worked for a startup once in which our CEO was a really smart guy, but the kind of smart guy that got overly worked up over tiny details and edge cases. We'd spend months working through "what-ifs" in Powerpoint, Excel, or Visio, instead of building and testing features. Anytime we wanted to make a strategic decision, we'd need to run it by our extremely expensive law firm. Picking the name (!) for our company took over $50,000 in legal bills and at least 3 weeks of everyone's time. In retrospect, I'm amazed anything got built at all. The lesson I personally took from that experience was that entrepreneurs need to make decisions, and often, they need to make them more quickly than they feel comfortable doing. They might fuck up here or there. And one day, when they're successful enough actually to need to run everything by lawyers, they can afford to do so. The ROI on legal fees and time is much more positive when the nature of the threat is being measured in the millions or billions of dollars. In the beginning, though, the biggest threat isn't a lawsuit; it's running out of time and cash. Lawyers still have their place, though. You need them in certain situations. But they can't wear your balls for you. When you feel the need to run every key decision through a third party, you're basically stripping the "E" out of your "CEO" title. Here's where I'll risk sounding contradictory: contracts are a crazy beast. Given your circumstances, the "fucking sue me" approach probably made sense. But you also got really lucky. It's not a terrible idea to consult a lawyer if you're entering into an agreement of a nature you've never taken on before (i.e., with a Fortune 500, with a scope of work you're not used to handling, etc.). I say "consult with," though, not "tie up." Most Fortune 500s have a take-it-or-leave-it policy w/r/t their contractors and their RFPs. They know they've got the bigger guns, so you're kind of playing on their terms. No amount of lawyering on your end is ever truly going to overcome that home-court advantage of theirs. So it's often a wasted and self-defeating effort to fight too hard on any terms -- with the possible exceptions of payment structure and timing (the ones that affect your ability to keep the lights on), provided they seem overly wonky as written. Fight to get paid on time, to get paid fairly, and so forth. Don't fight over nice-to-haves, because you won't get them.
- jonmrodriguez 13y ago
- OhHeyItsE 13y agoGood read. I get the message: done is better than perfect. However, in this specific example, it's pretty terrible advice to sign a contract that leaves you in a compromising position just to get a job. You'd probably be better off signing no contract at all.
- acidx 13y agoThe title remembers me of the Sosumi sound that came with Mac System 7 onwards: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sosumi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sosumi
- bananashake 13y agoThere are a few lessons 1) redlining a contract too much can destroy deals. Some lawyers do this instinctively but you should talk to your lawyer and review the changes and make sure all are important to you. 2) when you are starting off in business you can take more risks. but, i think that when you are established, it pays to be more cautious.
- jesusthatsgreat 13y agothis is an attitude that you need to earn, not the kind of attitude that you should start out with... the reality is bad things happen sooner or later and this attitude banks entirely on linear growth. the bigger you are the harder you fall, so if you're hiring employees without knowing whether you can afford them or not, then that's just wreckless and shouldn't be praised or encouraged. it's almost an 'all or nothing' approach where you reinvest everything you earn indefinitely because you want the snowball to keep growing. sooner or later, the snowball will start melting or you'll have to push it uphill and this philosophy will have to be 'put right' by sensible people who only spend what they know they can afford. it's a bit like playing the lottery and the guy that wins is giving advice to those who want to win - "play every week, buy as much as you can, that was my secret"... yeah, well that will work for some people, but for most people it won't work.
- raheemm 13y agoMy risk-averse nature has been the #1 challenge in my startup life of the last 11 months. I was worried about taking on a partner for 3 months. Finally I just decided to skip that - it meant I'll grow slower. I was worried about sending sales and marketing emails for 4 months. Finally, I decided to announce my beta launch and offer discounts for anyone who signs up. One customer signed up and paid for a year's subscription. Because I had a customer, it forced me to stop dreaming about the perfect product launch and just do my beta launch. Which happened 3 weeks ago. Now I worry about losing that one customer because my beta product is not perfect. Im also struggling with getting more customers. Why? Because I want to create the most perfect email marketing funnel. I've been procrastinating on this for a month now. If I worried a lot less, things would happen so much faster.
- StavrosK 13y agoThat's not risk aversion, risk aversion is picking the safe way/minimizing risk. What you're doing is actually increasing risk because you're too afraid to handle things. There's no upside to that.
- raheemm 13y agoMy point is that risk is often perceived to be greater than it actually is. So taking action in spite of the risk has two benefits - the real risk is exposed and often less than what we imagined and progress is made from taking action. True, this can lead to a stressful experience and perhaps recklessness.
- snorkel 13y agoIt is a truth of business that contracts are mostly for defining expectations and escape routes, but as long as the client is satisfied none of those clauses will be enacted, especially because most businesses have more important things to do then go to court.
- eli 13y agoI think the larger (and IMHO better) lesson is that it's really important to trust your clients and for them to trust you. That understanding is often more important than the legally-binding fine print that you two have signed. For example, if the client doesn't agree with the bill you presented them, you're gonna have a problem regardless of what the contract says.
- rrhyne 13y agoWhile I definately believe in taking risks, be sure to protect yourself. If you are doing anything unique for a client protect your IP and have a non-compete.
- crusso 13y agoLike with a lot of advice on HN, take this article with a grain of salt and pursue a balance while trying to understand the competing forces at work. My experience with entrepreneurial legal paperwork was that I ignored it too much in my early days and it bit me in the ass. When the money starts coming in and egos grow large, people reach for their lawyers when there's too much ambiguity in business relationships. You don't want to kill opportunities with too much negotiation, but then again you don't want to leave yourself too open to misunderstandings that could have been avoided with a line or two in a contract.
- inovica 13y agoVery well said. Everything went well for him in the deal and all was fine, but what if it hadn't? I know a few people who have had serious problems because of a lack of attention to detail with their legals (or just not caring) and one of them was put out of business by it. I also know another guy who is ruthless and enjoys the thrust and parry of suing people when they try to get our of his 12-month contracts. I personally would rather take a more cautious approach than rush into something. I sleep at night knowing that I have covered myself and my family as best as I can
- Yuioup 13y agoThe lesson here is that you couldn't resist bragging about the fact that you briefly made an exorbitant amount of cash during the DotCom bubble ... and that your dad is a bad-ass.
- jasonkester 13y agoThere's a simple reason why this works for small businesses: nobody sues a guy with no money. So if you're a sole proprietor scraping by and you piss off a giant company with lawyers enough that they want to file a lawsuit against you, well, what's the upside for them if they win? Tens of thousands of dollars in expenses on their side, and roughly zero dollars in recovered costs from the business they destroyed or the guy they sent in to bankruptcy. Unless their goal is simply revenge, there's really no reason for them to follow through with such a course of action.
- libria 13y agoQ: Does LLC or Inc. allow the organization to take the hit (or fold) while leaving the founders relatively safe?
- aioprisan 13y agoYes, that's the entire point, it shields you from all liability. If you perjure yourself, you're still personally liable, but for things such as money owed by the business, you're not personally liable unless if you personally guarantee something (i.e. a company credit card that you guarantee with your social).
- tehwebguy 13y agoYes, that is the point of them. If you are planning on creating one you should speak with an accountant and attorney to make sure you know the rules. If a corp or LLC is being used simply as a front a suing party can "pierce the corporate veil" and come after you personally.
- Retric 13y agoThat only works if the company signs a contract, if you sign so pretending that says you can be held accountable then you can be held accountable. Most often seen with loans.
- pearjuice 13y agoSomeone with 500k and a few employed certainly has money. This story was sheer luck and is only showing off that.
- DanBC 13y agoJust signing anything is great until they do sue you and you're fucking screwed. Tenancy agreements is one thing where it pays to look through and say "come on, you didn't get a lawyer to draft this, let's cross these bits out."
- mikro2nd 13y agoHad to laugh... in my one-man business (20 years and still going) I have almost no "Standard Policies". Almost. But one ironclad rule I do have is, "If a the CEO is a lawyer, run away. Away is where you must run." Every time I've dealt with client companies run by a lawyer it has been horrible. They seem incapable of signing a reasonable deal and getting on with the business at hand, but insist on crossing every t and dotting every i to the death. All the juice is sucked out of the deal before it even begins. Oh, and the only client I have ever had to see a lawyer over (to collect outstanding invoices) was a law firm that had hired me to help them design a software system for... Debt Collection. (I kid you not.)
- ganeumann 13y agoI think there are two kinds of lawyers: the kind who want to utilize their law school education to the fullest and the kind who have done that and realized the cost-benefit to over-lawyering is negative. The second kind has reasonable standard contracts and pretty much just refuses to spend more than a few minutes changing them. The first kind has completely unreasonable contracts and expects a long adversarial process to reach a reasonable contract. But I agree with you because most lawyers are the first type.
- ianstallings 13y agoAlthough I think you should always have a lawyer around to highlight and explain the risks, business is not always cut and dry and contracts disputes sometimes require you go to court. After all, you just need an impartial party to make a determination. It's part of business and entrepreneurs should get used to it. Especially in our field where people throw around Intellectual Property wants/demands so easily.
- Spooky23 13y agoEnd of the day, this is risk management. The risk of getting sued over a deal that doesn't happen is zero. The risk of getting sued for deal that goes through is non-zero. Here's a great example. If you want to do business with the State of New York, there's a list of non-negotiable clauses that you need to agree to. ( http://www.ogs.ny.gov/about/Docs/AppendixA.pdf http://www.ogs.ny.gov/about/Docs/AppendixA.pdf )Several are onerous... you need to provide periodic reports about whether you discriminate against your employees in Northern Ireland (whether you have them or not). As a smallish enterprise, you do not have the ability to negotiate with a big org. So you need to decide: Do you want risk and a bag of money? Or no risk and no money?
- tqi 13y agoIsn't this a classic example of Survivorship Bias? i.e. you know who probably doesn't write a lot of popular blog posts? Unsuccessful entrepreneurs who's companies failed because of something in their contract that they didn't read. But as with many things, the smart path is probably somewhere in between the two extremes...
- raldi 13y agoBingo. "Everyone says to wear seatbelts and buy homeowners insurance, but I never have and I turned out fine! I'm not sure what the lesson is here."
- jballanc 13y agoThe lesson, or at least the lesson I've learned from dealing with lawyers at companies big and small, is that lawyering is a practice in making sure nothing can possibly go wrong. In a way, lawyers are the QA team for the legal world. They know that the shit hitting the fan can potentially be very expensive, so they will go to extreme lengths to prevent any possibility of that happening. But just like you cannot rely on your QA team to prioritize features and bug fixes (because, really, who's going to click those 15 buttons in that precise order with that precise timing to trigger that bug), you cannot rely on a lawyer to determine your business plan. Lawyers fill the role that lawyers fill. If you're an engineer, then you have to fill the engineer role. What is that role? My father is a mechanical engineer, and he explained to me very early on just what it means to be an engineer. You see, an engineer could design a bridge that doesn't collapse and lasts for thousands of years, but that's not the engineer's job. The job of an engineer is to take the cost of materials, the budget, the expected longevity of the bridge, the project schedule, the prevailing environmental and geological conditions of the siting, etc. and balance all of these different variables against each other to arrive at a solution. If we're programmers, then we're saying that we can write down instructions in such a way that a computer can execute them and produce some output. If we're software engineers, then we're saying that we can balance features, schedule, bug fixes, test coverage, etc. and eventually ship it!
- Zuph 13y agoTold to me by one of my engineering mathematics professors: "Anyone can design a bridge that doesn't fall down. It takes an engineer to build one that only barely doesn't fall down."
- jnbiche 13y ago>The job of an engineer is to take the cost of materials, the budget, the expected longevity of the bridge, the project schedule, the prevailing environmental and geological conditions of the siting, etc. and balance all of these different variable against each other to arrive at a solution I'm not a lawyer, but I would assume that a good lawyer adopts an analogous process: they take the value of the contract, the prevailing legal conditions, the case history, etc., etc. and balance all these different variables against each other to arrive at a solution. I think the problem with many corporate lawyers is the same as with many corporate programmers working at large, traditional corporations: risk takers are heavily penalized, and those who make traditional, low-risk decisions are rewarded. You know, the whole "nobody ever got fired for using Java" bit. But lawyers working in private practice, or partners in firms with a lot of power, will presumably be willing to balance risk against reward, and try to optimize accordingly. Lawyers: please correct me if I'm assuming incorrectly here.
- FrankenPC 13y agoThe only downside to this article is the URL with profanity in it...apparently it can't make it through my corporate firewall!
- 6d0debc071 13y agoLawyers can either be your best friend or your worst enemy in getting a contract worked out. If they're just posting letters back and forth at each other, I'd try and find a different lawyer fast. A conversation needs to take place with the interested parties so that people know what they can compromise on and what they can't - see how much leeway they're prepared to give each other. Marked up contracts, after the initial exchange arguing about things that the client perhaps doesn't even care that much about, is not such a conversation.
- skore 13y agoMaybe some more in-depth advice while not missing out on the profanity: Fuck You Pay Me by Mike Monteiro[0] (for the few who haven't seen it yet) [0] http://vimeo.com/22053820 http://vimeo.com/22053820
- mverwijs 13y agoReminded me of "Screw you. Pay me.", a video that advices to get a lawyer before you sign anything. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2450424 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2450424
- otikik 13y agoNote that the original video was titled "F*ck you. Pay me.". The linked venturebeat article decided to use a synonym for some reason.
- workhere-io 13y agoThis lesson in total disregard for risk served me well. They say entrepreneurs are risk takers. I think of myself as too lazy and irresponsible to fully understand the risk. This attitude works very well - right until everything goes horribly wrong and you wished you had tried to minimize risks.
- acjohnson55 13y agoNo kidding! Can you say, "survivor bias"?
- keithrl 13y agoAs a lawyer, that is a stupid attitude to have. Having legal shit done correctly for start-up businesses is a lot like having insurance. You'd prefer not to have to pay for insurance and you'll likely never need it. But when you need insurance, you're glad you have it. Same thing is true for having your legal ducks in a row. You hope you never get sued or embroiled in a lawsuit, but if you do, you'll be glad you had lawyers involved at the beginning.
- ktran03 13y agoAs a newish freelance/contractor, what stood out to me is that's a shit tonne of money made there. I wonder if there's contracts close to that floating around still.
- josephjrobison 13y agoThe fact that he closed with "It works for me. I’m not sure what the lesson is here." Takes it from another 'oh this entrepreneur has a few specific experiences and things he has business wisdom' to just funny and awesome.
- rzimmerman 13y agoIt turned from "I'm not a laywer, but.." to something that was unexpectedly deep and thought provoking.
- jwb119 13y agoThe lesson from this isn't that you shouldn't get a lawyer to review your 400k business critical contracts, it's that you should pick a lawyer who knows what's important to fight about and what's not, and understands the objectives of the business. The "Sue me!" attitude is pretty shortsighted thinking. Disclaimer: lawyer here.
- lnanek2 13y agoI have seen many deals die with the lawyering back and forth, even if both parties agreed on the essentials.
- Knight4 13y ago"Worry about that in 2 months," I can't help but cringe. I quit my former job at a startup because they owed me 7 months salary. I really believed in the projects and in the CEO but, in the end, he couldn't walk the talk. It's a real shame because the company had - and still has - TONS of potential, but management is appalling.
- phpnode 13y agoI cringed reading your post, how on earth does someone get themselves into a position where they are owed 7 months salary? What happened there? I hope you managed to collect in the end
- mydpy 13y agoBy following the advice in this blog, aren't we letting the big corporations hold all the legal cards and potentially put smaller operations in very uncomfortable positions? That isn't right.
- call 13y agoPrevious discussion, posted by the OP. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2985195 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2985195
- dctoedt 13y agoRelevant: The funniest lawyer cartoon ever, at http://dilbert.com/strips/comic/2008-08-28/ http://dilbert.com/strips/comic/2008-08-28/
- vph 13y agoThe obvious lesson here is: listen to dad. If you are starting out, have a mentor.
- crazygringo 13y ago> This lesson in total disregard for risk served me well. They say entrepreneurs are risk takers. I think of myself as too lazy and irresponsible to fully understand the risk. I recall a study somewhere (can't find it now, unfortunately) that concluded: it's not actually that entrepreneurs are people who intentionally take bigger risks than others. It's that they have so much self-confidence that they believe things are less risky than they really are -- somewhat self-delusional, perhaps? But hey, that's how things get done.
- eplanit 13y agoYou should not engage in contracts as an individual person. Form a corporation (a sub-chapter S if you're a very small team or an individual). As owner of the corporation, you can legally indemnify yourself. The company acts as a shield to protect the assets of the owners/stakeholders.
- grellas 13y agoLawyering in general, and business lawyering in particular, is an art in which good judgment counts a lot more than mere technical precision. From a lawyer perspective, a written contract may have all sorts of areas in which it falls short of an ideal in capturing all key issues potentially affecting a client. There are recitals (defining factual context), covenants (setting forth promises), conditions (defining when an obligation kicks in), and (often) representations and warranties (defining the extent to which parties stand behind what is purporting to be sold, etc.). In any of these areas, a lawyer can potentially find things that are inconsistent with what a client says the deal is supposed to be. Sometimes this happens because of unequal bargaining power, where a big company essentially presents a host of oppressive boilerplate terms and conditions as "take-it-or-leave-it" items. Other times, it happens because of what I call "slicko" tactics by the other party, where something that appears to say "x" in fact has a legal meaning of "not x" owing to the use of weasel wording and the like. Still other times, it happens because entrepreneurs are trying to cobble together their own contract by picking and choosing what sounds good from others they have seen and, in the process, failing to ensure that things don't conflict with each other or perhaps just omitting to address key legal issues by having put an exclusive focus on the business issues. Finally, it can come about simply because of either poor drafting by a lawyer on the other side or simple attempts by a party to overreach. When you see this as a lawyer, what do you do about it? First, the final say on such issues belongs to the client and not to the lawyer. So, after a high-level assessment, you talk with your client, explain the general range of issues and problems, and get direction on the desired level of response. Is the deal such as even to warrant legal review? Is it to be a high-level review only, just enough to let the client know what key risks exist and to address only egregious things that go to the heart of the deal? Is it to be comprehensive to try to catch and fix everything that is even potentially material, even if it deals only with issues that are highly unlikely to arise? Or is it to be something in between? This need not be an elaborate discussion and often takes only a few minutes. But it is vital to the process because it lets the client make an informed choice about how to proceed with the legal review. Having gotten client direction, it is still important in all but mega-deals to keep a sharp practical focus in doing a review. What good is it to do a scorched-earth review and markup if the result will be overkill that is likely to alienate the other side (some lawyers who do this do deserve to be called deal-killers)? It really is poor business lawyering simply to proceed unthinkingly and one-dimensionally in every case to review and mark up everything no matter how remote the risk or how likely it is to be material. There is a dynamic to negotiations and nothing galls the parties more than to have to sort through a lot of lawyer comments over what they see as non-essential points for their deal. On the other hand, it never pays arbitrarily to cut corners in doing a review. Just because a client says "spend no more than an hour on this" doesn't mean a proper review can be done with such bounds. If a lot is at stake, and a client is just being penny-wise and pound-foolish, it is better not to do the review at all than to gloss over all sorts of serious problems in the name of economy. The lesson from this piece, to me, is that entrepreneurs can do well in keeping a sharp eye on the practicalities of managing their business opportunities and they should not let lawyers get in the way of that. A related lesson, in case a lawsuit ever did result on signing any complex contract blindly, is that entrepreneurs can act foolishly in casually inviting lawsuits by failing to manage the legal review process at all and simply signing complex contracts as is. The net of this is: use your lawyers in proper cases but make sure to use lawyers who have a good practical focus in addition to legal skill and then manage that relationship to get what you need from the services for your deal. In any deal that really matters, it is usually a mistake to proceed without lawyers and it is an equally big mistake to give the lawyers sole discretion in how to do the project. Be proactive and smart in this, just as you would be in making any other business decision.
- vladimirralev 13y agoBad idea. Anyone who is offering hostile contract terms is very likely to use them. Many of these terms are extremely expensive - such as non-compete or excessive confidentiality, forcing you to put your name and reputation on the line for shady business practices or excessive liability. Even if they don't sue you, they may publicly call you unethical for signing terms and then breaking them, turining the tables on you to sue them. It is considered excusable if you are a very small guy who simply doesn't have any other choice, but if you are a bigger company building on reputation you will suffer from it.
- adammil 13y agoAfter handling lots of contracts back and forth, my experience is that you avoid adding new conditions to a contract for a large company if you can, but you had better remove anything that you don't intend to actually comply with. As an independent contractor, I've had companies remove the insurance requirement, non-solicitation, any unusual IP ownership clauses, etc. and never lost a contract yet. I especially watch for clauses that affect my ability to do my normal business with other companies after this work is complete and anything that puts a weird reporting burden on myself. You'd be surprised what's hidden in the company's contract boilerplate text that even the company lawyers forgot about. My overall goal when doing this is to ensure that when the work is done, the customer signs off and the checks stop coming, that I don't owe them anything more.
- skidoo 13y agoThis ideology works wonders within the United States government's war on terror especially.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- alan_cx 13y agoForget the legal stuff, the lesson here is to just get on with stuff and gather up and loose ends later. That's it.
- zefi 13y agoThe lesson here is the same drawn from pg's essay on doing things that don't scale - http://paulgraham.com/ds.html http://paulgraham.com/ds.html. If you were a multibillion dollar company acting at scale, it would make sense to spend time perfecting the contract. But because you could assess the risk of failure for all elements of the project and felt comfortable with them, there's little need to do the extra due diligence required by a company acting on a larger scale. The majority of a founder's job is making decisions. But the point at which a decision needs to be made to be effective is the point where the founder often has only 10% of the information needed to feel comfortable making it.
- krmmalik 13y agoSo I've skimmed maybe the top 10 comments on this thread and it seems everyone has gone off on a complete tangent. I'm seeing this more and more on HN. Maybe someone further down has covered the point but I'll say it anyway. The lesson has nothing to do with a lawyer or hiring people. It's to do with embracing uncertainty. That's the key take away here.
- marincounty 13y agoTake the risk, but try to protect youself--become judgement proof if you can? I sometimes think if you're doing something risky, with the real possibility of getting sued it's not unreasonable to hide money in a tin can. Ha--Ha. Yes, it's not conventional advice, but it might keep you from being homeless, or despising all lawyers.
- kaa2102 13y agoI don't think entrepreneurs should be lazy or blind to risk; rather, they should use strategy, options and flexible arrangements to eliminate, minimize, or transfer risk. Big companies didn't want to handle fraud for online payments - Paypal founders figured it out. The OP could have brought the employee on as an independent contractor. Moreover, forming a corporation would help to limit the risk of non-delivery with the $400k contract.
- PhantomGremlin 13y agoThe 20-something young hipsters in startups now, reading HN during compiles, mostly think the sky is the limit. Salad days, nothing but good times ahead. But we've seen this movie before, and it didn't end well the last time. The whole frenetic startup scene will eventually blow up again. IMO. Archive.org has quite a few captures of fuckedcompany.com, Pud's great site chronicling the (previous) dot com bust. I don't know if they archived everything; companies were blowing up on a daily basis, laying off people, missing payroll, closing doors without notice. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fucked_Company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fucked_Company
- Silent_Wolf 13y agoIn this case you should have gone to a lawyer who knows this type of biz. not some random or general lawyer lol
- unclebucknasty 13y agoYears ago, I participated in a mutually beneficial potential partnership being lawyered to death, and missed out on a great win. As a small business that was approached by a large organization with potential to drive us a ton of new customers, I had a great opportunity. But, I also saw some risk, due to the sheer size. So, I let my lawyer review it, which initiated a death spiral. In retrospect, there was nothing onerous in the initial proposal. My attorney just wanted to cover all bases. That's how they envision their jobs: If a client ends up in a bad situation that could have remotely been avoided, then they have failed (in their eyes). But, there is sometimes no scale brought to bear. Any degree of risk--no matter how small--becomes a point of contention. The funny part is that I and the biz dev guy on the other side just wanted to get it done. But, we became unwilling conduits for lawyers who tried to eliminate all risk from their respective sides and we just wound up passing marked-up agreements back and forth until we (and the deal) were exhausted. So, I learned that all of this legal "protection" must be taken with a grain of salt for the small business owner in particular. The upside is generally so much greater than the risk for us, and in the off chance that the risk becomes a reality, it can generally be mitigated then. There is risk to simply being in business, especially in this litigious society. So, you cannot deny yourself an opportunity simply because your lawyer couldn't wrangle every last bit of risk out for you. And, when you assume that posture of trying to eliminate risk completely from your side, then you have to know that the legal folks on the other side will follow suit. That's when the show stops. The advice given to the author by his dad is exactly what I'd give to my kids, minus the expletives.
- grandalf 13y agoNot getting a good contractual arrangement is all fun and games until you're the Winklevoss twins.
- suyash 13y ago$400,000 for an e-commerce site? Can't believe that happened. Anyone can point me or tips as to how to get those 6figure plus contracts now days?
- thebandrews 13y agoHow did this make it to the front page of hacker news for a second time? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2985195 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2985195
- aceperry 13y ago"It works for me. I’m not sure what the lesson is here." The lesson is: he needs to get sued. :-)
- Jugurtha 13y agoI think that there is inherently some risk taken in any endeavour. I think the biggest risk is not doing anything. I agree on that. Signing contracts without legal counsel might turn out okay, but legal counsel is like insurance or a seat belt: You don't need it until you have an accident. It is dissuasive, and it is mitigating. i.e: Those who want to screw you will think twice when you have an attorney, and if they wish to screw you, you have a better chance to get screwed less if you have an attorney than if you haven't. On the other hand, it depends. Just as some seat belts and air-bags were actually the cause of death of the car driver, it depends on your lawyers. It's not a generic term. One needs to find people who are well versed in the matters, and the body of law is large, so one needs specialists in a field. You can't get the best advice on start-ups from a lawyer who specializes in divorces. Again, on the other hand, Elon Musk once affirmed that they didn't have lawyers because things were too complicated and it wouldn't make any sense to them. That was back in 2003, I doubt things stayed the same. The stakes are high, and a company like SpaceX ? I don't think they don't have lawyers.
- presspot 13y agoWell put.
- presspot 13y agoWell put.
- teeja 13y agoI never heard Robert Young say "fucking sue me" in Father Knows Best. But then fathers don't wear fucking fedoras these days either.