19 ms·
Did Goldman Overstep in Criminally Charging Its Ex-Programmer?
- cgshaw 13y agoAs an attorney and someone moderately interested in politics, it's becoming more and more clear that technical literacy is going to play a huge role in law and policy. We desperately need more politicians, bureaucrats and law enforcement who at least have some basic technical knowledge. Empathy is the only way to prevent stuff like this.
- ionforce 13y agoUsually people who attain technical knowledge are the same type to avoid politics. Politics is a "soft" game of imperfections, where as technical knowledge is the opposite. Cold, hard, objective. What incentive is there for technically-equipped folk to deal with the imperfections and heartache of interacting with non-technical folk than to take a white collar job amongst other technically-minded folk?
- cgshaw 13y agoI completely agree. Maybe it should be more incumbent on politicians and law enforcement to learn more about technology and incorporate more private citizens as opposed to just big corporations in the dialogue. It's frustrating, I think everyone realizes that technology is going to become a greater and greater part of every day life in government and yet there hasn't been much of a push for elected officials to give a shit to do anything but fundraise with it.
- eshvk 13y ago> technical knowledge is the opposite. Cold, hard, objective. Life isn't that black or white. Companies run on soft games, the world, your product succeeds not because of "cold, hard, objective" amazing technical design but due to soft irrational people. I'd argue that there are enough people in tech well versed in the soft game for money to be made.
- Daniel_Newby 13y agoThis was not a case of ignorance or lack of empathy. The system worked as intended: the tallest poppy was cut down, his downfall was a PR victory for someone's reappointment campaign, and by extension someone else's reelection. Technical knowledge would merely give them Google level efficiency at shafting their victims.
- ImJasonH 13y agoMy favorite part of all of this is the scare-quotes around "subversion repository"
- hawkw 13y agoOh no! The hackers are coming with their terrible powers of "subversion"!
- ErikAugust 13y agoYou think if they chose to use Git for version control the agent would have not thought anything of it? Subversion just sounds too menacing?
- cupcake-unicorn 13y agoWell, I'm sure they'd find some other, equally ridiculous way to interpret "Git" - obviously the programmer was making a statement about the stupid "gits" in charge of the company...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- 6d0debc071 13y agoOf course they overstepped. They basically mugged a person of their life savings, deprived them of their liberty, and ruined his marriage over nothing of consequence.
- davidw 13y agoI have some recollection that it was a bunch of Erlang code, from some other article about it. Edit: Hah, wow... ok, so it's a small world. If I'm not mistaken, this is the same Sergey Aleynikov: https://github.com/saleyn/erlexec/commits/master https://github.com/saleyn/erlexec/commits/master I've been interacting with him quite a bit lately regarding his erlexec code. He strikes me as a nice guy. Edit2: Looks like he's asking for donations to help fund his defense: http://www.aleynikov.org/ http://www.aleynikov.org/
- cmiles74 13y agoProgramming is starting to seem like a relatively dangerous kind of work.
- hawkw 13y agoITT: journalists don't "get" programming.
- bmj 13y agoIt sounds like a couple of tech-savvy journalists should start the equivalent of http://getreligion.org http://getreligion.org.
- biafra 13y agoWhere in the article is the actual story? Can someone please point me to the page and paragraph that contains what actually happened? What did he do?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ig1 13y agoMy understanding is he copied a bunch of confidential code off company servers and then deleted the audit trail from the servers. He claimed that the confidential code copied was accidental and that he only meant to copy some open source code.
- kasey_junk 13y agoIt's a little harsh to say he deleted the audit trail. He deleted his bash history. Something I do on a near daily basis.
- ig1 13y agoThe exact details (which aren't disputed) are covered in: http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/021110aleynikovindictment.pdf http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/021110aleyn... Basically he'd written a backup program which was specifically designed to compress both his home directory and propriety code from elsewhere on the system into a file (which it would do depended on parameters passed). On his last day of employment he ran it several times with different parameters which including copying propriety code. He then encrypted the file and then uploaded it to a SVN hosting service before deleting the encryption program and his bash history. Because it was encrypted it bypassed GS's automated scanners. He then downloaded the source files to both his laptop and external flash drive and took them to work at his new employer. Given the (undisputed) facts, he clearly broke several laws, the question is whether he was doing it innocently and just being stupid or if he did it with serious criminal intent.
- amalag 13y agoIf it was a normal company you could boycott them, but how do you boycott Goldman Sachs for all they have done?
- mikegioia 13y agoYou could try to convince other programmers not to work there? I really think that's the only way.
- xradionut 13y agoWhy boycott GS? It's their state, country and mostly their world to loot. They have been above the law for over 80 years. They own the current administration, courts and congress. I wouldn't doubt it if someone claimed they had access to much of the NSA collection due to the amount of influence they have...
- impendia 13y agoI was on a jury for a murder trial, and so I have some insight into how juries work. At one point, when I was splitting some hairs and discussing the meaning of some small details from the evidence, one of the other jurors got impatient and reached for the coroner's photo of the victim. "Someone died here, you realize."
- clicks 13y agoYou should have taken him to a side and told him to go watch 12 Angry Men when he gets home.
- GeneralMayhem 13y agoOr smacked him and told him to grow the fuck up.
- Symmetry 13y ago12 Angry Men might, perhaps, not be the best example. http://rationallyspeaking.blogspot.com/2012/11/odds-again-bayes-made-usable.html http://rationallyspeaking.blogspot.com/2012/11/odds-again-ba... EDIT: Actually, this is the one I should have linked to: http://www.avclub.com/articles/did-12-angry-men-get-it-wrong,83245/ http://www.avclub.com/articles/did-12-angry-men-get-it-wrong...
- digipaper 13y agoThat doesn't dispute anything about 12 Angry Men for me.
- gohrt 13y agoThe AV club article assumes that people never lie or are unreliable witnesses, even though the movie presents clear evidence to the contrary (and this is well known in the real world), assumes that the police conduct a thorough investigation instead of railroading a suspect who fits their prejudicial profile, and assumes things (like the knife) are uncommon because they are foreign to himself, though they may be quite popular in other social circles. That's exactly the point of the movie, and the author completely missed it.
- melling 13y agoIn case people aren't clear on this. He worked in an industry that takes this sort of thing very seriously. He shouldn't have even been trying to download open source from work. You don't email stuff home to work on it, for example.
- michaelochurch 13y agoYes, he did something stupid. It's not clear that he did anything wrong, but he should have known (and maybe did) that this was a really bad move on his part. It's not worth it to take work code out of its place, especially not in finance where this will be prosecuted. Unfortunately, engineers fail to account for the fact that image and credibility matter far more than substance. This is a case of a man who really had no intention to do anything wrong, but almost certainly did break the law in a pattern that's a notorious bugbear in finance.
- uxp 13y agoDid he break the law, specifically the espionage act? I could see theft of property, possibly, but the furthest I could see it going is breaking an employment agreement, which is a contract between two private parties and doesn't bring criminal charges for violations.
- aa0 13y agoIt depends how much capital the entity you steal from has. In the case of Goldman..well you don't want to fuck with the Gold Man...he's got quite a hammer.
- walshemj 13y agoYes banks tend to be considered CNI (critical national infrastructure) the The Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (as amended 1994 and 1996) seem to indicate that financial institutions are protected computers "intentionally accesses a computer without authorization or exceeds authorized access" which this guy did.
- melling 13y ago
- mathattack 13y agoThey did mug him, but it's considered a huge no-no in financial services to take any kind of code home. It's impossible that he didn't know the gravity of what he was doing when he did it. It's always a terminatable offense at the very least, and frequently leads to more.
- waffle_ss 13y agoOn the night of the arrest—without an arrest warrant—Serge waived his right to call a lawyer. He phoned his wife and told her what had happened and that a bunch of F.B.I. agents were on the way to their home to seize their computers, and to please let them in—though they had no search warrant, either. Then he sat down and politely tried to clear up the F.B.I. agent's confusion. "He was completely not interested in the content of what I am saying. He just kept saying to me, 'If you tell me everything, I'll talk to the judge, and he'll go easy on you.' It appeared they had a very strong bias from the very beginning. They had goals they wanted to fulfill. The goal was to obtain an immediate confession." Don't talk to police! - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc
- sneak 13y agoThat video is right up there with knowing about 83b elections as some of the most valuable information one can possibly possess. I rewatch it annually and send out mass emails to all my friends and family when I do reminding them to do so as well.
- reginaldjcooper 13y agoCan you add "jury nullification" to the mass emails also? That's what I tell my friends and family about.
- jlgreco 13y agoIf I ever get "fuck you" money, I am going to entertain myself by renting billboard space around courtrooms urging jurors to Google "jury nullification". I figure there would probably be some entertaining fallout of some sort.
- rhizome 13y agoDepends on your definition of "entertainment," but you'll probably want to do your homework first, regardless: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/26/nyregion/26jury.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/26/nyregion/26jury.html?_r=0
- noonespecial 13y ago“He was stringing these computer terms together in ways that made no sense. He didn’t seem to know anything about high-frequency trading or source code.” Programming is esoteric to common folk. Almost like witchcraft. When things go wrong for villagers, they often burn witches. They didn't burn witches in the old days because of some moral failing that we've outgrown. They burned them because they were unable to understand that "witches" didn't actually cause plagues.
- minimax 13y agoThat cringing sensation you got when you saw the scare quotes around "subversion repository" is the same feeling people in trading get when journalists write about HFT and algorithmic trading. You can see an obvious example in the article where Michael Lewis applies scare quotes to "dark pools."
- sgt101 13y agodark pools scare me a hell of a lot more than witches - possibly because the continued functioning of the financial system is more important to me than warts.
- phyalow 13y agohow, all they are is usually unlit "unadvertised" elob's?
- sgt101 13y agoI have no idea what you are talking about, but the reason they scare me is because they provide an opaque mechanism for trading that enables or allows the unmanaged exposure of major financial institutions. This means that the confidence that anyone can have in a particular counter party in a transaction is undermined - whether or not they are participating in these transactions, because we cannot know.
- 13y ago
- kenjagi 13y agoThat article is riddled with inaccuracies.
- chrisgd 13y agoTry listing them
- gd1 13y agoHis 'second jury' were comical. "Most were surprised by how little he had taken in relation to the whole: eight megabytes in a platform that consisted of an estimated one gigabyte of code. " Really? One gigabyte of code? Or one gigabyte of third party binaries, precompiled libraries, documentation etc.? All you need are the source files, and those language keywords compress nicely. Exactly how much plain text do you think they have? ' "But that’s the secret sauce, if there is one,” said the juror. “If you’re going to take something, take the strats.” ' Rubbish. The strats are the easy (or at least easier) bit in the high frequency space. That's like taking a dump of the html from facebook/twitter and thinking you've stolen their site. It's the scalable, distributed infrastructure that drives large websites, and it's the fastest possible infrastructure that drives HFT. One thing Lewis got right is the Coke/Pepsi analogy, and it really is that simple. A straight up race. " “It’s way easier to start from scratch.” " It is, and it isn't. In even the worst codebase there will be nuggets of usefulness that will accelerate the process. Isolated parts of the system that you've perfected. Exchange message decoders for example (ITCH, FIX/FAST, etc.). This is especially true when you, the genius who will be starting from scratch, has worked on it for a few years. I assume he was doing something useful in his time at Goldman. I'm not buying the innocent act.
- chrisgd 13y agoAren't these problems the jury faced or measured incorrectly rather than inaccuracies in the article itself?
- defen 13y ago> In even the worst codebase there will be nuggets of usefulness that will accelerate the process. Isolated parts of the system that you've perfected. Exchange message decoders for example (ITCH, FIX/FAST, etc.). This is especially true when you, the genius who will be starting from scratch, has worked on it for a few years. I assume he was doing something useful in his time at Goldman. The new system was going to be written in a different language than what Goldman uses.
- nonchalance 13y agoThe best lesson here: > The fourth, and final, rule was by far the most important: Don’t say a word to government officials. “The reason you don’t,” he says, “is that, if you do, they can place an agent on a witness stand and he can say anything.” Aren't you allowed to have a lawyer present in conversations with agents?
- chrisgd 13y agoA right he did not exercise
- sneak 13y agoI haven't clicked through, but only the government (via prosecutors) can charge anyone with criminal offenses. Additionally, while private people can suggest charges or report crimes, ultimately they have zero say one way or the other if charges actually get filed. See also: Apple/DoJ/Gawker, ATT/Apple/DoJ/weev, JSTOR/MIT/aaronsw
- s_q_b 13y ago>only the government (via prosecutors) can charge anyone with criminal offenses. That's almost universally true, but some states still do in fact have the right of private prosecution. E.g. New Jersey allows you to swear out a criminal complaint directly to a magistrate, and there isn't a damn thing the police or a prosecutor can do about it. Private prosecutions used to be the norm. It's actually a very powerful force against police corruption, and I wish it hadn't gone away in so many states. Also, in cases like this, the prosecutors will generally defer to the desires of the victim, especially when the victim is one of the world's most powerful corporations.
- JonnieCache 13y agoSide question: how do these people with "only the vaguest interest in his fellow human beings" end up with a wife and three kids? It seems to be a common theme amongst articles like this. They always paint the hero-programmer as some kind of rainman figure and then it turns out he has a loving family. Just the usual fictional press nonsense I guess. EDIT: should always read on before commenting: "He married a girl and manages to have three kids with her before he figures out he doesn’t really know her."
- feintruled 13y agoAs far as the article has it, it wasn't a match of love. It was just two Russians getting together through the ex-pat community, she got security and money to spend, and he just did it because it was the thing to do.
- thufry 13y agoI am someone who has only the vaguest interest in my fellow human beings, and has a great, loving relationship with my girlfriend. Different people want different things. I enjoy my girlfriend's company and enjoy spending time with her and a few other friends but in general I detest the presence of other people in my physical vicinity.
- ahallock 13y agoHow does this case not violate the eighth amendment? Or if not that, basic fucking justice and morality. He's lost everything, spent a year in prison, was acquitted of federal charges, and now is being charged by NY State? The justice system is seriously broken.
- wmil 13y agoFrom the article: "He didn’t fully understand how Goldman could think it was O.K. to benefit so greatly from the work of others and then behave so selfishly toward them." I don't think he understands Wall Street.
- chiph 13y agoWhile I'm a capitalist, I wouldn't conduct business with Goldman. They have a history of screwing the market (semi-ok), screwing their customers (not ok), and screwing their employees (not ok). And then blaming everyone else. I expect a certain degree of ethical behavior.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoOn the contrary, Goldman generally stands by their employees provided they believe the employee stood by them. See for example, Fabrice Tourre, who's personal legal expenses were entirely covered by Goldman.
- ajb 13y agoBut he was convicted of a financial crime. It's not in Goldman's interest for that sort of thing to happen.
- milemi 13y agoI think Goldman always stands by Goldman, first and foremost. And so do the lawyers paid by Goldman. Cf. in Fab's case they rested their case literally the minute they had their turn, without calling any witnesses. From day one I was amazed at the guy's naivete of accepting the "gift" from Goldman that he be represented by their lawyers. It's the rule #1: get your own representation folks. Company lawyers don't work for you, they work for the company.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoResting their case without witnesses is a fairly standard strategy in court - it's a way of emphasizing that the case has so little merit that there is nothing to argue against.
- GeneralMayhem 13y agoThis makes me angry. Not just the story itself, but the way VF goes about telling it, which commits the same sins (albeit with better intent) as Goldman Sachs. "So-called 'subversion repository'?" Why don't we just accuse him of summoning demons while we're at it?
- danielweber 13y agoMichael Lewis is a great writer about economics. He appears to have gotten out of his depth here.
- GeneralMayhem 13y agoWow, I don't know why the name didn't register. Yeah, he's spectacular when writing about economics or sports.
- freyr 13y agoMaybe I'm giving him too much credit, but I think the author's emphasizing that the term itself sounds like damning evidence to anyone who doesn't know better, since subversion means "a systematic attempt to overthrow or undermine a government or political system by persons working secretly from within." He's pointing out that agent used such terms without understanding them (or exploited the public's ignorance to make their case). That's why he put it in quotes. Lewis goes on to explain, later in the article, that subversion repositories are commonly used and aren't evil. He could have explicitly spelled out that the term subversion relates to version control, but I think he explained it adequately enough given the intended audience.
- shubb 13y agoTo be fair to the agent, I think uploading company code to your private third party repository is pretty bad. Especially if you are thinking (later in the article, quoting the programmer), 'they wouldn't like it', 'it was like speeding, in a stolen car'.
- 13y ago
- zeteo 13y agoThe justice system is, of course, still in the business of catching and punishing murderers, thieves and such. But, with the decline in crime since the early '90s, this side of their activity is becoming increasingly supplemented by a different game altogether: enforcing a growing set of complex laws against practically everything [1]. There is a lot of prosecutorial discretion in choosing which of these laws to enforce and the degree to which to enforce them. With prosecutors often competing against each other in the number and severity of convictions secured, it's hardly surprising that they've arrived at the age-old algorithm used by street muggers: pick the most likely victim, and go all in. A guy like Aleynikov was thus ideally suited as a prosecution target: unlikely to excite much sympathy from a jury with his heavy accent and un-American looks; clueless about lawyers and confessions; cooperative enough to sign statements that were re-formulated by investigators to look bad in court; high-tech enough to mark novel and impressive prosecutorial checkboxes. They consequently made sure to squeeze him for all he had. So, while I think the often repeated advice about never talking to the police sometimes goes too far (it's probably good to have a friendly relation with the neighborhood cop, and by all means please help in apprehending murderers and burglars if you safely can), it's pretty much dead-on as soon as you step into enforcement la-la land: - Don't consent to any searches. - Don't say anything without a lawyer. - Put great effort into finding a competent lawyer. - Don't say anything your lawyer hasn't approved. Beyond refusing help to efforts to prosecute you, such steps will clearly mark you as a non-victim. (Same advice as applies when you have to pass through a mugging-prone area.) This will cause a lot less effort towards pushing through with your case. After all, there are other suckers born every minute. [1] http://reason.com/archives/2009/10/19/were-all-felons-now http://reason.com/archives/2009/10/19/were-all-felons-now
- gknoy 13y agoOnce targeted by something like this, how does one go about finding a competent lawyer? How do I evaluate their competency?
- sfall 13y agolook at their boy of work, their specialty, their work history, and then sit down and talk with them they should be able to quickly start asking questions about relevant specifics
- vijucat 13y agoI have worked with Goldman and UBS. UBS, to it's credit, has taken a liberal stance and explicitly addresses contributions to Open Source : if they are done on your own time, that's fine. Goldman, in contrast, had the usual, "anything and everything you do or do not belongs to us" agreement.
- jrochkind1 13y agoMan, talk about risks computer programmers don't usually consider in taking a job on wall street.
- vermontdevil 13y agoAnd now he's being charged by the state of New York. This will never end as long as Goldman Sachs continues to pull the strings, I fear.
- GeneralMayhem 13y agoAn interesting takeaway from this piece is that GS is blatantly and systematically violating the terms of the MIT license, GPL, and whatever else they happen to get their hands on. I'd love nothing more than for the FSF to take them to court over it.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoMe too, in principle, but realistically I think it would be a poor bet to make. Given the legal resources available to the respective parties there is a real danger that GS would win despite the merits, and possibly even set some precedent that Open Source folk would not find favorable.
- vidarh 13y agoThat's only true if they distribute the code, is it not?
- GeneralMayhem 13y agoIANAL, but I don't think so. Practically, probably; legally, unknown. > The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all copies or substantial portions of the Software. That makes it sound like ripping the license out and replacing it with a proprietary one, even for purely internal use, is probably a bad idea. I don't know who'd be able to sue them for that, though, if the original copyright "owners" aren't supposed to have seen it in the first place. Article II of the GPL has a specific exception for transferring GPL-ed software to employees to work on without letting them spread it beyond that, but I don't know how much of this that would cover.
- lmm 13y agoCopyright only applies when you distribute something. With your internal copy of something that you don't redistribute you can modify it however you like, and the GPL or any other copyright license never gets a chance to apply.
- mratzloff 13y ago
- snake_plissken 13y agoLike the opening of the Vanity Fair article, I never and still do not understand exactly what he did that is illegal.
- jmduke 13y agoThis is the first front-paged post I know of where nobody's invoked Betteridge's Law of Headlines, which I find particularly ironic. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headlines http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headlines
- mcgwiz 13y agoThe article was very sympathetic toward Aleynikov and accounts his acquittal on appeal, so it breaks that "law" (which IMHO is upheld primarily due to confirmation bias).
- jmduke 13y agowhich IMHO is upheld primarily due to confirmation bias I agree; this was my point. Its frustrating to trot out a trite middlebrow dismissal for when we don't like something and to pretend it doesn't exist otherwise.
- finnh 13y agoI was actually just about to post a corollary to Betteridge's law of headlines, which is: Any headline asking if Goldman Sachs committed malfeasance can be answered with "yes."
- Geekette 13y agoWow. Naivete is a bitch... Or one hell of a drug, depending on your viewing angle. And given his re-arrest on what appear to be spurious charges (1st set were thrown out on appeal), I can't help but agree with this comment on VF: "When Goldman says 'jump', the gov't says: 'How high?'"
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- justinhj 13y agoThe only thing I find odd is the deleting of the bash history. There are no passwords in there, unless you type one by accident.
- beerscout 13y agoIf he used wget (or similar utility) he could specify password as a command line argument. It's not a very good practice security-wise but people do this sometimes.
- mcgwiz 13y agoAlthough I acknowledge the sympathetic angle of the article, I cannot fathom why he would take such a risk. During my 2 years consulting in global investment banks in NYC, it was standard practice for all employees, internal or external, with access to sensitive data or IP to undergo comprehensive IP compliance training and execution of IP agreements. This had to be performed within a month or so of engagement or your badge and account would be deactivated. Every year at a particular client required the training to be repeated. It was inculcated that violations of such policy had a high likelihood of being caught and would carry very significant penalties. In my experience, they successfully established very taboo cultures around transmitting IP out of their systems.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoIIRC one speculation on the matter was that the information that was taken would have proven that GS engages in all sorts of illegal and rule-bending trading strategies (say it ain't so). edit: added quote from court record below. "...because of the way this software interfaces with the various markets and exchanges, the bank has raised a possibility that there is a danger that somebody who knew how to use this program could use it to manipulate markets in unfair ways." See page 8 http://www.scribd.com/doc/17191934/USAvSergeyAleynikov-7409-Full http://www.scribd.com/doc/17191934/USAvSergeyAleynikov-7409-...
- Fuxy 13y agoThat's the problem with the American judicial system. Whenever they want to convict someone innocent of a bullshit crime they just assemble of idiots who just say guilty to go home to their trailer. Have they heard of the phrase "jury of their pears" that actually means pears not of the same species. I wouldn't consider any of the people on that jury my pears.
- iopq 13y agojury of my pears? Why would the jury consist of fruits?
- ben0x539 13y ago(peers)
- BWStearns 13y agoI for one would be fascinated to see a jury of pears.
- tomjen3 13y agojury of one's peers n. a guaranteed right of criminal defendants, in which "peer" means an "equal." This has been interpreted by courts to mean that the available jurors include a broad spectrum of the population, particularly of race, national origin and gender. Jury selection may include no process which excludes those of a particular race or intentionally narrows the spectrum of possible jurors. It does not mean that women are to be tried by women, Asians by Asians, or African Americans by African Americans. http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/jury+of+one's+peers http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/jury+of+one's+... But originally jury of ones peers was a right of (so called noble) Englishmen to be judged by other lords, and not by commoners. Sadly, it does not give intellectual people the right to be judged by others with above room temperature IQ (what is it they say, a jury consists of 12 people not smart enough to get out jury duty?).
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Sadly, it does not give intellectual people the right to be judged by others with above room temperature IQ The closest English precedent for that was not the "jury of one's peers" but the "benefit of clergy".
- j_baker 13y agoWhen I took Criminology (or perhaps it was Deviance), my professor made me read this book: http://www.amazon.com/You-Are-Going-To-Prison/dp/1559501197 http://www.amazon.com/You-Are-Going-To-Prison/dp/1559501197 It was written decades ago, and is still relevant today. Sadly, I think programmers should begin reading it, as prison seems to be growing into a larger threat for us.
- rollo_tommasi 13y agoThis article is also interesting in that the total blind trust McSwain put in Goldman's explanation of the situation really illustrates the typical mob hit-man mentality of most law enforcement agents. The Big Boss gives them a name and they take that guy out, no questions asked.
- pigscantfly 13y agoIt's all down to laziness, IMO. That FBI agent could have done some research for verification and realized that Goldman was selling him an overblown story. What's the point, though; the courts will do their background research eventually, right? And by then they'll be arresting the next poor schmuck Wall Street doesn't want to lose to a competitor.
- pmorici 13y agoOr insider connections; I would bet that the people in charge of security at Goldman are probably former FBI, Secret Service, or similar background.
- nohuck13 13y agoI was working at one of the rival HFT's mentioned in the article when all this went down. I had some thoughts. -It's never ok to take proprietary code with you after quitting. I don't know anybody that would have thought that was OK, especially with the amount of money people were making off this IP in 2008. Of course that's true in any industry, but especially in trading. -That said, you can't just walk out the door of Goldman on Friday and be trading on Monday, even if you had their entire codebase. The infrastructure needed to be a world-class HFT player at Goldman scale is insanely complicated and prohibitively expensive to all but the most well-funded folks these days. You're going to need colo space and power at tens of trading venues, low-latency WAN infrastructure to ship production quotes and data around the world, expensive exchange gateway connectivity, quant research platforms and a giant compute cluster, significant devops and monitoring infrastructure to run and monitor it all, and smart people evolve the stategies, models, and code as it decays while you're setting all this stuff up.
- appdeveloper 13y agoI agree- it's not okay to take proprietary code. But criminal charges and an 8 year sentence? Totally disproportionate.
- nohuck13 13y agoOh, agreed. I was surprised at the attitude that taking code might be a commonplace thing. Didn't mean to defend the punishment.
- perlpimp 13y agoThat is some advertisement for Goldman, work for us and you will be fine, quit and we will sic FBI, Police or whoever we can find to persecute you, take your money destroy your family and ... .. man this sounds like some mafia.
- kaonashi 13y agoWhat does it mean exactly to 'take proprietary code'? You mean he had a copy on his laptop so he could work from home? Isn't that what most of us do?
- cupcake-unicorn 13y agoI don't have anything useful to say, but: "Serge figured, it was a matter of unfolding the box, turning a three-dimensional object into a one-dimensional surface" Now how does one do that? :) And he shouldn't have had to used the Pythagorean theorem on just a one dimensional line... Sigh. Just thought it was funny, since the article was about how programming/technical jargon goes over the heads of jurors, the FBI, etc. but seems like the article writer isn't immune to it either :)
- jmaygarden 13y agoThere are multiple ways to unfold a box into 2 dimensions. For example, see this printable pattern that you can try at home [1]. Also, how else would you determine the distance between two coordinates in a plane without using the Pythagorean theorem [2]? It's not like he could use a measuring tape in an imaginary, unfolded room. EDIT: I reread your post and see that you are pointing out a typo. The phrase "one-dimensional surface" was obviously meant to be "two-dimensional surface." A one-dimensional surface is non-sense. [1] http://familycrafts.about.com/cs/coloringpages/l/blboxtemplate.htm http://familycrafts.about.com/cs/coloringpages/l/blboxtempla... [2] http://www.purplemath.com/modules/distform.htm http://www.purplemath.com/modules/distform.htm
- cupcake-unicorn 13y agoYes, sorry - I was pointing out the "one dimensional" typo.
- imsofuture 13y agoWhile stupidity isn't a crime, people like Serge manage to find their way around that obstacle. It's pretty obvious he didn't have any malicious or illegal intent, but he definitely followed the checklist of 'things not to do when leaving a job'. Emailing yourself code? Seriously? The whole thing is a travesty, but he walked right into it.
- yogo 13y agoThat was my impression too. For someone that smart in a technical field, some things just seemed a little to casual or didn't make much sense. Deleting your bash history because there might be passwords in it? I generally give the benefit of the doubt to the guy in his position--maybe he was in a hurry or got comfortable being one of the chosen few super users--but, you have to think wtf. At a company like that where IP is highly valuable and you are paid handsomely, you know right off the bat that every character of code you right belongs to the company before even seeing employment and/or confidentiality agreements. Dating another woman or stuffing a large object in your trunk late at night right after your wife dies, does not look good. You may very well be innocent, but it doesn't look good.
- smm2000 13y agoI have passwords in my bash history - namely mysql passwords.
- yogo 13y agoUse the --defaults-extra-file to point to a file containing the password and stop the madness. At least that is what I think should be done if entering the password is inconvenient or not feasible (like in an automated script)
- paul_f 13y agoWhy? Use 'mysql -uroot -p' It prompts for the password and does not show up in Bash hsitory
- pawrvx 13y agoGoldman is above the law.
- metaphorm 13y agoA reminder everyone, the only thing you should ever say to a law enforcement officer is "I'd like to see my attorney."
- Tycho 13y agoRussians had a reputation for being the best programmers on Wall Street Is that true? (the rest of the paragraph was interesting, and worth repeating for anyone who read the whole article): Serge thought he knew why: they had been forced to learn programming without the luxury of endless computer time. “In Russia, time on the computer was measured in minutes,” he says. “When you write a program, you are given a tiny time slot to make it work. Consequently we learned to write the code in a way that minimized the amount of debugging. And so you had to think about it a lot before you committed it to paper. . . . The ready availability of computer time creates this mode of working where you just have an idea and type it and maybe erase it 10 times. Good Russian programmers, they tend to have had that one experience at some time in the past: the experience of limited access to computer time.”
- known 13y agoParanoid?
- mabhatter 13y agoBlack and white letter of the law, he should not have sent the modified Open Source programs home. The modifications really would be the employers property and the employer has all the power to release them. That said, he had been sending the files home to work on all along (before changing jobs) and never was EXPRESSLY TOLD to stop. That is why the original case would have been tossed as there was noillegal access" going on. The second case for sending secrets is closer to legit. But only because if you send secrets out at all, if you didn't have permission, it could be illegal. The REAL issue is font work for asshats that don't play nice. Alternately, accept that as a programmer mixing hobby Open Source projects with your Employment projects is a recipe for trouble.. Take their money and be a sucky leacher.. Or post your fixes to maintainers from home, reengineered solely at home with no files from work. As somebody who does admin work, its a great excuse just to not take work home at all unless its on my company laptop.