18 ms·
How the Maker of TurboTax Fought Free, Simple Tax Filing
- Nursie 14y agoIn Australia there is a program distributed by the government each year, based on some sort of spreadsheet type thing, that looks up as much info as it can from central records (when provided with identifying info) and then walks you through the rest of the process of filling in a return. Not as simple as "yes, that looks right" that happens in a bunch of places, or the UK system (no tax return unless you have special circumstances) but it works well.
- yyqux 14y agoYes, it works fairly well, but unfortunately has crushed the capitalist Ubermenschen who never had a chance to build TurboTax Australia under the government's boot heel. I've actually had my return automatically amended a couple of times to give me more money back based on tax rulings on deductions.
- LarryMade2 14y agoThis is why the US can't have shiny things. I've always thought the IRS should provide us with a lot of the tax info, since it gets reported to them so regularly.
- jbellis 14y agoThe IRS computer systems are stuck in the 80s. You can get them to send you a copy of the information they have; it will be ready around August. I'm not exaggerating; I've done this a couple times because I'm terrible at keeping track of the paperwork otherwise. (Protip: you can file an extension until October with no penalty.)
- fr0sty 14y ago> Protip: you can file an extension until October with no penalty. Caveat: This is true ONLY if you are due a refund. If you owe tax you will be charged interest (and possibly penalties) for paying after the deadline[1]. http://www.irs.gov/uac/Extensions-and-Payment-Options http://www.irs.gov/uac/Extensions-and-Payment-Options
- mikeash 14y agoTechnically speaking, I believe you can still file in October, as long as you pay in April. So you can estimate (guesstimate) and pay, then calculate properly and file later, if that's advantageous somehow. If you pad your estimated payment so that you overpay, you should be safe from penalties, in the event that you can decently estimate up front but can't actually file a full return for some reason.
- danielweber 14y agoPartly they want to see what you say, to see if you are lying.
- nonamegiven 14y agoLet's give them an opportunity to lie, where a lie would otherwise be all but impossible. Then we get to put some of them in jail. Yay!
- nawitus 14y agoThis is one of the things that's done correctly in Finland. I've never had to do my taxes, it's always been correctly pre-filled.
- seivan 14y agoHmm. How good is Turbo Tax, I mean I can tell it's horribly coded, but does it have automated features/recommendations that will help you earn more? Or is it basically what the tax system does in Swede/Finland etc?
- k3n 14y agoThey usually have a free version that is adequate for the most basic of returns, and then all others require you to purchase something in order to file through them. If you actually want the value-added services (such as the recommendations you mention), then you pay even more. The situation is a farce and a disgrace to our country; the pockets of a few are getting lined at the detriment of the many. Wait, are we discussing taxes, or healthcare, or big banks....?
- gav 14y agoThe free version is just for Federal, you have to pay to file your state tax return. What I find insulting is having to pay to file my taxes, then having to pay sales tax on top of that.
- k3n 14y agoThanks for the clarification; luckily (?) I live in TX where we don't have state income tax, and so I forget that. Agreed about the "paying taxes on paying taxes", and of course the general idea of there being a for-profit industry centered around a requirement of citizenship. This is clearly another area that furthers the agenda of the Plutocracy, whereby the wealthy are at a great advantage on account of being able to afford a CPA to find all the loopholes.
- cm2012 14y agoI filed my NY state tax return for free using TurboTax, just a data point.
- smackfu 14y agoWhat a lot of people don't realize is how easy state income tax is, and how a lot of states have gone to fully online forms. I think people assume it is as complicated as federal taxes, but our state, it's essentially just "take your federal gross income from the 1040, add a few things to it, then subtract a few deductions." The form and the worksheets is two pages. So what I do is prepare the return in Turbotax, then print it, then file it electronically on the web for free. Fun thing is that Turbotax calculates the tax a dollar different than the state's web site.
- MatthewPhillips 14y agoThe IRS switched to an xml file format a couple of years ago for e-filing, which broke the first week of the tax season. They were unable to accept any returns for around a week, IIRC. This article is a little overly optimistic about their chances of fully replacing tax prep, in my opinion.
- eli 14y agoIt already exists and AFAIK works fine for state taxes in California.
- Joeri 14y agoThe belgian government is so ineffective we didn't have one for two years because they failed to organize a ruling cabinet after elections. And still we have prefilled returns that work well. It's not that difficult.
- niggler 14y agoFYI: this exists: https://www.freefilefillableforms.com/ https://www.freefilefillableforms.com/ I haven't used this personally for filing because it doesn't handle certain forms like 1128, but I'm told it's pretty good for basic stuff
- crazygringo 14y agoNo, it's not about doing your taxes electronically. It's about the IRS pre-calculating everything for you, so you don't have to input anything. You just say "yes, that's right", unless there are errors or additional information needed.
- toomuchtodo 14y agoExactly. We have the ability to do this, and private companies lobby against it (and win!) to protect their profit. What the fark.
- readme 14y agoSo, you're comfortable with just trusting the government to tell you what you owe? I'd prefer to check the math myself.
- toomuchtodo 14y agoLogin to IRS website, be shown all your data. Is this correct? Yes. No. buttons. Workflow is present to deal with incorrect data. The data is already submitted electronically by employers, brokerage/retirement asset management companies, states, etc. Why should I have to pay a private company (I'm looking at you Intuit) when the IRS should have the ability to provide the same service FOR FREE.
- niggler 14y agoGovernment doesn't know your business expenses and various deductions (unless you want to stream your cash and credit card transactions directly to the IRS)
- rm999 14y agoThis stuff aggravates me. My taxes aren't abnormally complex (single, one state, very few deductions, one w-2), but I get several 1099s for my investments and end up spending an hour filling them in manually, importing CSV files from my brokerages, and double checking the numbers. What annoys me is all the forms clearly state the IRS has also been sent this information; I'm literally filling out forms in a slow, error-prone way just so the IRS can run a simple == check to make sure I entered them in correctly. I feel like it's something my third grade teacher would force us to do to kill time. I don't care about the 30 dollars turbotax charges me, I'll send 30 dollars straight to the CEO or promise to burn it. What bothers me is that I've been forced to do manual data entry - a pet peeve of mine as a programmer - because the government has been lobbied specifically to be less efficient.
- MatthewPhillips 14y agoThe government is not bad at code because of lobbying, they're bad at code because of fluctuating budgets, low salaries, and ridiculous processes.
- clarkevans 14y agoYet, Government programs have excellent customer service as compared to corporate equivalents. I use one example: student loan servicing. My loans were serviced by the largest company in the business for years, it was pure torture. When the department of education offered to assume the loans, I was happy to have the pain gone. They have been absolutely lovely to work with, clear, transparent and... helpful.
- theorique 14y agosome government programs have excellent customer service as compared to some corporate equivalents I am sure we could find counterexamples here.
- MatthewPhillips 14y agoEver been to the DMV?
- mcenedella 14y agoThe choice is between letting the government do your taxes for "free", versus having a company whose reputation rides on getting your taxes done as efficiently as possible with the least tax burden to you. Anybody who would choose to have the government complete them, hasn't been paying attention to the lengths revenue-strapped states will go to maximize their tax collections. It's a bit like letting the user car salesman set the price you pay for the auto versus haggling for yourself. It's also simpler, "free", quicker, and less intensive to let the professional do it for you. But free can sometimes be the most expensive way of all.
- raverbashing 14y agoThis is total BS Go reread the article, unless you're really in pro of companies charging for what should be free. Pro-tip: if the government thinks you owe X, it's not Turbotax that's going to change that.
- ScottWhigham 14y agoNo need for the hyperbole. OP's question is logical. On one hand you have a company who is taking your money and has a reasonable expectation that, as a result of using their software, you will save more money because they will help you find deductions and tax credits that you would've been hard pressed to find yourself. These companies compete in a free market for your money, both with other software companies and with CPAs/CPA firms. The "winner" (for a particular user/client) is the one who (a) has the best reputation of not getting you audited, and (b) who gets you the best price:deduction ratio. On the other hand, you have a government entity whose sole charge is to collect revenue. Is their system going to be designed to help you get as many deductions as possible? Are they going to prompt you to deduct moving expenses (just to pick one example)? Maybe, maybe not. The question is legit though and thus causes us all to say, "Wait a minute... maybe, since there is a financial incentive for them not to show me deductions, that they will hide some of that (or make finding it as complex as the tax code)." If Intuit/et al help you save $5000 in taxes this year by helping you deduct all that you can, Intuit/et al do not make one penny more - that money simply stays in your pocket. If the IRS helps you save $5000 that you would have otherwise paid (b/c you did not fully deduct all that you could have), then the IRS loses $5000. That in and of itself highlights the problem.
- JimWestergren 14y agoStats about tax declaration from Sweden last year: Via internet: 19,9% Via PIN code: 20,1% Via telephone: 12,5% SMS: 6,6% Smartphone app: 2,3% Total: 60,4% filed electronically The rest sent in papers via the mail. (the old method) Source: http://www.skatteverket.se/download/18.71004e4c133e23bf6db800078977/1336458264283/topplista_-_antal_personer_per_lan_som_deklarerat_elektroniskt_per_3_maj_2012.pdf http://www.skatteverket.se/download/18.71004e4c133e23bf6db80... Personally I have filed via the internet since 2005 both private and for my company.
- wilfra 14y agoSMS tax filing? #want
- polyfemos 14y agoIt really is that good - as a Swede, you get your prepared statement (and unless you've done a major or irregular thing in the past year, like buying a house, or trading stock on an exchange outside the European Union) that prepared statement is correct. Part of the statement says "If you agree without modifications, just text 1234234 to the number 1234454". And a few seconds later you get a reply SMS that confirms that your taxes are indeed filed for this year. Done. Simple. And awesome :)
- Erwin 14y agoThe latest statistics I could find for Denmark (2009) say 80% accepted the tax as prepared by the government, around 18% edited it online and 2% sent in paper. Recently most things are automatically filed and unchangeable, even down to something like charitable giving -- if you send Amnesty some money every year, they are responsible for telling TAX so you can get a deduction. If there's an error, you have to contact your charity, not TAX. If you paid too much money in tax, there's one specific account every citizen has, that's used by government to send you money. No checks.
- itafroma 14y agoHow people file isn't a problem in the US: in 2010, 70%[1] of tax filers (~90 million people) filed electronically and that number has almost certainly increased since. The issue in the article is whether the IRS (our federal taxing agency) should be allowed to file returns on behalf of citizens (i.e., do most of the work for them). [1]: http://www.nbcnews.com/id/42275764/ http://www.nbcnews.com/id/42275764/
- bjhoops1 14y agoDavid Cay Johnston covered this in one of his chapters in The Fine Print. If you're looking to be incensed by more cases of corruption between corporations and government, it's definitely worth a read. You'll also get to find out why we in the US pay 38x more per bit of data transferred than the Japanese do!
- warmwaffles 14y agoIt's also another source of income as well for the IRS. Intuit makes money off of selling their product, their earnings get taxed.
- FireBeyond 14y agoThe IRS is funded on a needs basis, not as a percentage of tax revenue.
- facorreia 14y agoIn Brazil this kind of tax statement has been done online for many years using software supplied by the federal government. Unfortunately the government doesn't supply the data as well. It knows much better than me how much money I was paid, how much I paid for medical services, what my bank statement says, and so on, because we have a very comprehensive and intrusive set of laws about accountability towards the government. But still the government has us entering a lot of information from a lot of sources every year (information, I repeat, it already has) and we face harsh liabilities if we fail to retrieve and enter the correct information.
- readme 14y ago>Intuit argues that allowing the IRS to act as a tax preparer could result in taxpayers paying more money. Gee, you think? Thanks for saving us Intuit.
- kyrra 14y agoI'm not sure what the tax code is like in other countries, but the US one is pretty complicated due the number of write-offs you can add to your tax deductions. A lot of those deductions are not reported to the government, so it's up to you to figure out if its worth doing or just doing the standard deduction amount.
- ScottWhigham 14y agoTo those saying "We should be more like Sweden/Finland!", I'd ask whether those countries have a tax system that is also based on using tax credits and deductions to lower your tax due? I don't know the tax codes in those countries but my guess is that, because they use the tax entity-created system, they do not have such a complicated tax code as the US. In the US, you have two sides of this: (1) the IRS, and (2) CPAs, CPA firms, and software firms like Intuit who profit from helping customers file taxes. The question always is, "Why would I pay someone to file my taxes?" The answer is, "If they can save you more than their fee, it's worth it." In other words, if they charge $100 but save you $101 in "tax due", you have a net "win" of $1 thus you should hire a professional. Why does this work? For the CPAs, CPA firms, and software firms like Intuit, you have a professional who is taking your money and offers a reasonable expectation that, as a result of using their software, you will save more money than you pay in fees because they will help you find deductions and tax credits that you would've been hard pressed to find yourself. These companies compete in a free market for your money, both with other software companies and with CPAs/CPA firms. The "winner" (for a particular user/client) is the one who (a) has the best reputation of not getting you audited, and (b) who gets you the best price:deduction ratio. On the other hand, you have a government entity whose sole charge is to collect revenue. Is their system going to be designed to help you get as many deductions as possible? Are they going to prompt you to deduct moving expenses (just to pick one example)? Maybe, maybe not. The question is legit though and thus causes us all to say, "Wait a minute... maybe, since there is a financial incentive for them not to show me deductions, that they will hide some of that (or make finding it as complex as the tax code)." If Intuit/et al help you save $5000 in taxes this year by helping you deduct all that you can, Intuit/et al do not make one penny more - that money simply stays in your pocket. And you probably smile, buy a new car/vacation/etc. And you certainly tell your friends, "You should use Intuit!" If the IRS helps you save $5000 that you would have otherwise paid (b/c you did not fully deduct all that you could have), then the IRS loses $5000. That in and of itself highlights the problem. Do you trust the IRS to say, "It's okay if we lose $5000 - you're happy, right? That's what matters!"? Of course not. Having the separation works in the US for this clear conflict of interest. Again - I don't know the tax code of the Euro countries but I'd be interested to hear if they have a similar setup and how they work around this. It's logical to think that the IRS could invest $500 million building such a system and then no one uses it because paying $30 to Intuit/etc results in a higher refund for the above reasons...
- theorique 14y agoAll taxes are theft of the private property of free citizens.
- akadien 14y agoI definitely agree with respect to income, estate, and property taxes. Consumption-based taxes are fairer than so-called "progressive" tax schemes implemented to fund world wars and military expansion. Ref. http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/03/24/is-the-estate-tax-doomed/ http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/03/24/is-the-estat...
- harshreality 14y agoProperty tax encourages those who aren't using a property to sell it. Real Estate ownership is already tracked (you can argue it shouldn't be, but that would upend the real estate system). And unlike cash sitting in a bank account, it's already fairly common to tax real estate. If someone wants to keep 5 houses and leave 4 of them empty at any given time, as a status symbol, shouldn't they be taxed punitively? Real estate is not an unlimited resource. Occupation of any sort would disqualify the taxation; this could be verified easily in most cases by data from utility companies. Pure libertarians tend to argue that rational individuals will not let assets go unused. I think rationality as a model for human behavior has been thoroughly debunked. And if they don't let their real estate go unused, if they invest, lend, rent their property to others, taxes under the described system wouldn't apply. Some of these arguments can be applied to hoarding other assets (like cash), but it would be an uphill battle to tax cash (not cash inflows -- as in the income tax -- but static cash). One place to start might be cash held by public corporations, which have no privacy interest.
- akadien 14y ago> If someone wants to keep 5 houses and leave 4 of them empty at any given time, as a status symbol, shouldn't they be taxed punitively? No.
- deleted 14y ago
- hkarthik 14y agoUS Tax reform is one of those things I don't expect to happen in my life time. Our government is too addicted to the income stream it provides and is just too scared to mess with it in any meaningful way. All it takes is a fear monger with an agenda like Intuit to whisper "Our experts estimate that you will lose $X billion in uncollected taxes with this new scheme" to send congressmen from both parties running. Ideally, we would see state governments take the lead here and innovate. If they can show meaningful gains then maybe the Federal government will pay attention.
- datasage 14y agoTax reform generally means simplified tax code and which does not necessarily result in less revenue. But there is a huge industry built around servicing the complex tax code, many of whom wont be needed if the tax code is simplified. Just like any other industry disrupted by changing business environment, they will fight to the death to keep their industry alive and necessary.
- brown9-2 14y agoIf you read the article, it seems like there are at least several members of the legislative branch in favor of reforming the tax filing process to simplify things (and save taxpayers money). The opposition comes from business interests whose revenue comes from helping taxpayers navigating a complex code and processing.
- sliverstorm 14y agoAre you suggesting he should actually read the article? Such nonsense.
- gyardley 14y agoYes, TurboTax is being rather transparently venal, but that doesn't mean they're wrong. I doubt the American government is competent enough to get tax calculations right, and I suspect they're hungry enough for revenue to make all their default assumptions in their favor. At least that's been my experience with every state and federal tax authority I've dealt with for the past half-decade or so. Once we have a tax code that's simple enough and a government that's competent enough to get things right, then we can talk about having the government fill out our tax forms. Until then, the government's just going to be ripping off the blindly trusting, a little bit at a time.
- danso 14y ago> Once we have a tax code that's simple enough and a government that's competent enough to get think right How do you foresee this happening if we -- the government and the public -- maintain a status quo in which feasible optimizations are never pursued because hey, we have a private alternative that doesn't charge too much to do it? For the government to become more competent, the people have to demand reform. For people to demand reform, they have to be aware of how much better things could be. Private competition helps spur that reform, but this doesn't mean that the government shouldn't itself be expected to optimize things. This is not an either-or zero sum game
- gyardley 14y agoI'm arguing that without these prerequisites, this 'optimization' isn't an optimization at all - it'll be a step backwards, because it'll just end up ripping people off. People certainly should demand reform, but not this particular reform at this particular time. People should absolutely demand a simpler tax code - I don't know about you, but I'm still holding out hope we'll see some tax reform in 2013. 'Competent government' is a harder problem. Americans aren't Norwegians or Germans, and simply aren't good at large bureaucracy. Unless America starts subcontracting out its administration to the Swedes, better government is going to take either a change in American character or something smaller and less-centralized.
- 14y ago
- joras 14y agoTaxes are prefilled in Estonia also, you can see all of the information on the webpage, and in case of a home loan or investments, you can send that information to the tax form from a bank site with one click. If you're married you can file joint tax. And thats it. The whole process takes about 10 minutes, the deductibles are calculated and returned quite quickly, this year I was returned about 100euros, mostly because of my daughters dance lessons that are exempt of tax. I dont see the reason people try to defend TurboTax here, yes, taxes are more complicated in US, but still, government does the same calculations anyway, have the same data anyway. Why not do this automatically. And if government wants to screw you, well, then I dont belive that turbotax or alternatives could help you anyway.
- salvadors 14y agoOn my Estonian tax return last year, I had to declare overseas income too, and was impressed that it even did the exchange rate calculations at the relevant dates for me.
- fduran 14y agoAlso unlike other countries from what I remember you mail your federal and state tax forms and you don't even get a receipt or acknowledgement notification, just hoping the envelope won't be lost. A simple official paper stating your basic tax figures (gross/net income) can also be used as a simple way to verify low income when asking for scholarships and other financial aids right?
- nathanb 14y agoOMG big business is trying to ruin my life! The government are not incentivized to do a good job preparing your taxes. I'm not a tinfoil-hat conspiracy theorist. I don't think the US government wants to institute a program to systematically defraud the population. But I do believe that governmental inefficiency and incompetence is nigh-limitless, and the very people who may need their tax returns the most could end up being cheated out of them, not by malice but by indifference or stupidity. (And there are many opportunities for the poor and underserved to have their taxes prepared for free. Many credit unions will do it, for example, and they are incentivized to do a good job because the tax returns will likely pass through their hands). I realize the counter-argument is "but you can just opt-out if you don't trust the government". Sure. I can also choose to drive if I don't want my civil liberties violated by the TSA (and I do, except when traveling internationally). If the easiest and most convenient option also involves giving away rights, most people will take it. And then when later it turns out that it's being abused, there will be insufficient infrastructure in place for many people to choose an alternative. I hope this is just paranoid ranting.
- UnFleshedOne 14y agoSo, to extend your analogy, if flight was just invented and a flight transport system was being proposed now, you would argue against it because TSA would start violating your liberties when you use it and deterioration of existing horse carriage-based infrastructure will make opt-out a non-option?
- nathanb 14y agoSure, if you want to convert my argument into straw-man form to more effectively belittle it, that is a very effective way to do so. A more accurate way to extend the analogy to transportation would be a company starting a free bus service for lower-income neighborhoods. All you have to do is link your grocery store rewards card and scan it every time you use the bus, which will authorize the company to access all your purchase data from that card. You could very easily argue that this is a good thing, and perhaps at the outset it would be. But if it turns out that the company is doing something sleazy--rewards cards sometimes also encode personally-identifying information which could be used unethically, for example--then at that point a person's livelihood could very well depend on continuing to use that bus system, especially if the convenience of the system forced other free or low-cost alternatives to stop serving those neighborhoods. In both of these cases (the IRS preparing your taxes and the company holding your personal information), the organization is not incentivized to do a good job. In fact, especially in the IRS case, the worse a job they do, the more tax money the government takes in.
- frogpelt 14y agoFrankly, anyone who does trust any government hasn't had very much experience with them. At best, governments are inefficient and incompetent. At worst, they are run by politicians absorbed with self-interest. There are already scads of people trusting too much to other entities rather than figuring it out on their own. These people leave their tax withholdings at default levels, then walk down to the local Wal-Mart and trust the Jackson-Hewitt crooks to do their taxes. Jackson-Hewitt files a 1040EZ for them, charges $300 bucks and they leave happy because it will be automatically be taken out of their $10,000 refund. They feel rich for about two weeks. The solution is not more government nanny-state ideas. The solution is to find ways to require people to be MORE accountable for their own well-being. How about requiring every person who receives 10% or more of their yearly salary back in a refund to attend classes on how to maximize their tax benefits? It would be paid for out of their refund. After they go once, they don't have to go again for 5 years. If you're too dumb or unaware of your surroundings to know that you can file your taxes for free with a little bit of effort, you need education.
- sixothree 14y agoLet me guess, we should trust corporations?
- hnal943 14y agoWhat? This post criticized corporations (Jackson-Hewitt in particular). The point was that people need to take individual responsibility for their tax liability.
- mpyne 14y ago> The point was that people need to take individual responsibility for their tax liability. There are people in the military who get married just to claim a higher housing allowance (this despite it being against the UCMJ). Yes, we should be individually responsible but it's not practical to actually expect that from people.
- loeg 14y ago
- ericcumbee 14y ago"When you make an appointment for a car to get serviced, the service history is all there. Since the IRS already has all that info anyway, it's not a big challenge to put it in a format where we could see it," Say What?
- eumenides1 14y agoIsn't there free options in the US? In Canada, we have StudioTax. http://www.studiotax.com/ http://www.studiotax.com/ It's free and on a donation basis. I switched from TurboTax to this and I'm really happy with it. I'm surprised there isn't a open-sourced free way to do taxes. That way we can address the tinfoil hat based worries of the government doing your taxes and have free and easy software.
- teamonkey 14y agoI might do the same, having just filed last years' Canadian taxes with TurboTax. I didn't have a problem with TT but I do have a problem with Intuit's actions here. Coming from the UK where it has been automated all my working life, I resent having to file my taxes each year. As others have said, the government has nearly all the information anyway.For anything else, then only short declaration forms should be necessary and not a full return. I also don't like the lump sum return or payment if there's any discrepancy. In the UK the most common option is to have an adjustment to your tax code, which simply deducts more or less tax at source over the following tax year. You don't even need to give them your bank info.
- eumenides1 14y agoThe only reason why i used TurboTax in the past was because my parents used it and they were comfortable with the UI. But I've since taken over that task and I have no such love for their UI, especially when a free alternative is available.
- paulyg 14y agoMany in this thread seem to be glazing over one important detail. This system would be opt-in. Don't trust the IRS? Have a lot of complicated deductions? Hire a CPA or use Turbo Tax or fill out the paper yourself. Approx 13% of filers used a 1040ez last year. This system is perfect for them. I would venture a guess that 1/2 of 1040a filers could also use it. Again though it is your (hopefully informed) choice to do so.
- pc86 14y agoThis is the biggest thing. There is literally no reason to do this if it's opt-in.
- ams6110 14y agoBeing more cynical... deducting taxes from your paycheck before you even get the money is already (by design) lowering awareness of how much we are taxed. Imagine if we had to write a check to the IRS every month like we pay our utility bills... Making your tax return a "click here" effort while on the one hand appealing has the disadvantage of further reducing your awareness of how much you are taxed. This is why I do my taxes by hand, with pen and paper. I want to read the instructions and fill out the forms so I never lose awareness of how insane the system is.
- paulyg 14y agoThe only two monthly expenses I still write a check for is the water and sewer. That does not stop me from realizing how expensive my mortgage, electric, etc is. Trying to save people from their own stupidity or ignorance by making them fill out menial former is not the answer.
- DanielBMarkham 14y agoCouple of notes. 1) The IRS itself gets most of the tax advice wrong that it gives out to taxpayers 2) Paying taxes is one of the few transactional relationships you have with your government. If you ask me, a government representative should come to your office and you should pay him in cash, not hide and automate taxes so that they disappear. 3) There is a difference between a simple tax system and a tax system that is simple to operate. Taxpayers deserve a simple tax system. Continuing to automate the byzantine monster we already have is a terrible, terrible idea. How would reform ever take place? 4) Think for a minute what this implies: that a government agency that is responsible for collecting money should also be the sole source for computing how much money is owed. Where else would you allow such a conflict of interest? Should the police come by your house to determine what crimes might have been committed? Would you want inspections by the local health department of your private cookout? Right now we have administrative courts and such, but the principle is fairly clear: reporting by the citizen, oversight and acceptance of reporting by the government, and the court system to sort out problems. You don't start putting everything in one bag under the name of ease-of-operation. That's whacked. 5) I do not believe these candidates campaigned on this. What I believe they said (or meant) was that the system should be simple enough to eliminate the burden on the taxpayer, not that compliance with a bad system should be automated. As a side note, have any of these people ever created software or worked for a project inside the IRS? The guys I know that have could tell you horror stories. Testing alone should give anybody who knows programming and the IRS nightmares. This is a tremendously bad idea, both from an execution and a structural standpoint. When something doesn't work, the answer isn't to just do it harder or throw computers at it. Having said all of that, having the IRS give you the information that's already been entered once so you don't ever have to re-enter things? Excellent idea. ADD: Completing taxes is not hard because we don't have technology applied in the correct manner. It's hard because the tax code is a complex, unintelligible POS. The only people benefitting from continuing to hide the POS that the tax code is are those folks who made it complex in the first place (And will continue to add to its complexity the more that we ignore it)
- ellyagg 14y ago"2) Paying taxes is one of the few transactional relationships you have with your government. If you ask me, a government representative should come to your office and you should pay him in cash, not hide and automate taxes so that they disappear." Yep. My brother resists giving his credit cards to businesses to keep on file because it makes it much easier for them to get your money habitually, unconsciously, accidentally and by sleight of hand. There should be a little friction at every transaction wherever possible. Frankly, this goes double for the government, which has way more power than any business. I like the government. It does lots of good stuff for me. But I like it at the right price, and I know that just like any other powerful entity, it will take more than its best share given a bad dynamic. In the same way that unconscious eating habits make people obese, unconscious tax policies makes the government obese.
- ilaksh 14y agoThis seems an easy to grasp example of how the free market actually benefits the wealthy disproportionately. I think its an over-simplified concept. Yes, we definitely need to remain free and diverse, but we need to figure out how to factor more actual science, especially science related to human needs, into our decision-making systems. Right now its just whoever manages to collect the most money buys the policies. I think that the concept we have of money is inadequate. We need to start tracking and taking into account more data rather than just how many points everyone has regardless of how they got them or how they want to spend them. And I think to make things fair and effective the rules and enforcement need to be automated. Imagine a computer game where there was only one stat. Does that sound like a fair, fun, or sophisticated game?
- jdminhbg 14y ago> This seems an easy to grasp example of how the free market... I can't even begin to grasp what part of lobbying the government to prop up your business via threats of penalties and imprisonment you are interpreting to be "the free market."
- ilaksh 14y agoYou aren't going to get something that works better without altering the fundamental structures. The way things are set up you can't take lobbying, money, and special interests out of government. Because every politician needs money for everything and there is one number tied to your bank account that goes up or down on the basis of how much people give you, with little to no accounting for what you did to get it. What I am saying is that we need more variables. There needs to be some math equations and technology that actually support and automatically enforce the market ideal. Because making laws and relying on people to do the right thing just isn't adding up, since there is no money in doing the right thing. We need to improve the nature of money so that doing the right thing adds up. This is an oft-repeated conversation but I just don't believe that fair and free market ideal ever actually existed.
- xenophanes 14y ago
- danso 14y agoThe fact that a tax-hater such as Grover Norquist opposes reforming the tax-filing procedures illustrates the complex dichotomy between giving government good responsibility without giving it dictatorship-like responsibility. In Norquist's opinion, making taxes too easy to file will make citzenry too complacent about how they're being nickel-and-dimed and will lull them into not pursuing reform. OK, fair enough. But what about a scenario in which for 30-50 million Americans file for their taxes by sending a SMS (as it's apparently done in Scandinavian countries)? And all the other taxpayers, they're wondering: "Why the f-ck can't my taxes be that easy??" Isn't this scenario as likely to lead to overhaul of our complicated tax code?
- rhizome 14y agoI would caution against making Grover Norquist the foundation of any inquiry.
- yyqux 14y agoThe argument seems to be that Americans don't sufficiently resent paying taxes already because it's too efficient, so we have to make their lives even more inconvenient. The amount of complaining about taxes I hear on a day to day basis I think entirely discredits the premise of the argument.
- sc68cal 14y ago>But what about a scenario in which for 30-50 million Americans file for their taxes by sending a SMS (as it's apparently done in Scandinavian countries)? And all the other taxpayers, they're wondering: "Why the f-ck can't my taxes be that easy??" That's why Grover Norquist and others are lobbying against this. If taxes weren't a hassle, their movements would lose an important emotional touchstone that fuels many people's aggravation against the government. Being able to tap into that frustration, in order to enrich themselves and their political donor class is very effective.
- d4vlx 14y agoExactly, instead of having a convenient -option- that could save many Americans time and money Norquist and people like him are forcing the rest of the country to use a less efficient method. In other words they are taking away people "freedoms" in order to force them to fight to get their "freedoms" back. Norquist is of course more than happy to provide helpful guidance on what freedoms should be fought for.
- HarlinAtWork 14y agoPersonally I'm against any business lobbying to change laws to give itself a competitive advantage. However, so that I don't have to pay more than my fair share in taxes, I have to itemize deductions: business expenses and those that I am entitled to. Until we can implement something more libertarian like the Fair Tax plan, a lot of us are stuck with long tax forms unfortunately. An online EZ form or a tax form that the Government fills out "on my behalf" won't cut it. The Government will screw you as much as these scumbag businesses.
- jcr 14y ago> The following month, an ad in The Sacramento Bee, paid for by the CCIA, cautioned "Taxpayers beware" and said ReadyReturn "could be very harmful to taxpayers." The ad pointed to a now-defunct website, taxthreat.com, opposing ReadyReturn. Well, they won't be doing that again! http://taxthreat.com http://taxthreat.com http://taxthreat.info http://taxthreat.info http://taxthreat.org http://taxthreat.org http://taxthreat.us http://taxthreat.us (Note To Self: Eventually, I might regret this.)
- scott_s 14y agoThanks for making my day.
- yyqux 14y agoGovernment sucks since it's inefficient and bureacratic and wastes people time. In order to remind people of this fact we must ensure that it remains this way so that people don't get the incorrect idea that government can be efficient.
- mikec3k 14y agoWhy does anyone give a fuck what Grover Norquist says? He was never elected to any office.
- pm24601 14y agoIntuit could not get the Minnesota tax returns right. Minnesota had to threaten to refuse any TurboTax generated returns for Intuit to fix the problem: http://www.twincities.com/business/ci_22767151/minnesota-turbotax-flap-fixed-but-some-10-000 http://www.twincities.com/business/ci_22767151/minnesota-tur... "On Monday, March 11, the state released a list of 13 specific line items that led to errors on Minnesota tax returns filed through the Intuit software and other tax-preparation products from the company. "These were very serious to us," Terri Steenblock, the state's assistant commissioner of individual taxes, said Monday at a news conference. "We've never seen issues like this." Last week, the state advised people not to use Intuit products to file their state taxes. Those products include TurboTax, Lacerte, Intuit online and ProSeries."
- fakeer 14y agoCan't you sue your Government for this crime? It's a crime, isn't it? Your government is doing it on the behest of all those companies who fund the lobbyists. You must be having some public litigation system. It disturbs me when in countries like USA such policies that directly and greatly affect the citizens are controlled by lobbyists. My hope and enthusiasm for changes in my own country dims by a bit. (BTW taxation has become very simpler off late here, relatively I mean).
- just2n 14y agoHere's my idea. I suspect TurboTax would lobby against it as well. Tax reform. Woah. I mean make it simple enough that there isn't any need for tax specialists, because it's just not that involved. Then filing takes seconds for most people, audits are trivial, costs go down for everyone, and most importantly, companies that shouldn't exist die (H&R Block, TurboTax, the many law firms that help major corporations exploit tax loopholes). Win win win win? sigh. Never gonna happen.
- cletus 14y agoThere are two things that disturb me about the US government: 1. As a whole, it seems to operate on the assumption of guilt; and 2. It seems bought and paid for by special interests, pork barrelling and so forth. As a foreigner I of course have foreign retirement and bank accounts. If they total more than $10,000 (at any point in the last calendar year) you need to report them. This is FBAR (Foreign Bank Account Reporting). Failure to do so can result in civil penalties up to the 300% of the balance and/or criminal prosecution. Why? To fight money laundering, drugs, terrorism or child pornography (every piece of onerous US legislation or prosecution is justified by ostensibly fighting one of more of these things; even sharing MP3s). How are foreign retirement accounts treated? Are they taxable? How do you report them? Nobody really knows. Just tick "Other" and write "Retirement account" and hope for the best. If your foreign assets are above a certain amount there is another separate form you need to send to the Treasury department IIRC. You can e-file this form... if you use Internet Explorer. The JavaScript actually doesn't work in any other browser in a way that locks your account after 2-3 attempts. In Australia the ATO (Australian Tax Office) produces e-tax, which for most people allows you to file taxes for free. But beyond that, the ATO doesn't seem to have this same level of mistrust of its citizens that the IRS does. In Australia it doesn't scare me to make an honest mistake. In the US it does. This is not only for taxes but things like immigration issues. In some European countries, once a tax return is accepted, that's it, it's done. The government basically can't reopen that later in an audit. In Australia I think they can go back 7 years. No idea what it is in the US. Probably to the day you were born. Now I'm sure there are exceptions to that rule (as in if you commit deliberate fraud) but the point of the system isn't to punish innocent mistakes. All the while corporations and high net-worth individuals get away with blue murder as far as tax obligations go. The US could solve a lot of problems if it treated foreign corporate earnings the same as foreign individual earnings (in that you owe taxes on foreign income even if it isn't repatriated but tax you've paid with double-tax treaty countries offsets that obligation). Yes by all means send me to prison for failing to mention a $24,000 retirement account in Australia I can't touch until I'm 65 instead. Great use of resources. EDIT: to clarify (2), which is the major point relevant to this article, I don't understand why other governments don't seem so easily bought and sold for a pittance (in this case $1.5M over 5 years). Another example: toxic fire retardants used in pretty much all couches due to a California law bought by an industry only worth tens of millions a year [1]. In the case of TurboTax specifically, I think so many people use them because of (1) and the complexity of the tax system created by (2). Many people use TurboTax. You can say that's because of lobbying but that's only part of the story. [1]: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/09/magazine/arlene-blums-crusade-against-household-toxins.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/09/magazine/arlene-blums-crus...
- jisaacstone 14y agoFor the past three years I have filed my taxes myself, and every single time I make a mistake +- $100 or so, the IRS sends a correction, I fill out more paperwork and send payment / receive refund. Y'all know this is inefficient. I spend at least 20 hours of work filing my taxes each year, and as a fairly intelligent citizen I always make a mistake anyway.
- rayiner 14y agoThere is a lot of reading between the lines that needs to be done with this article: > It's already a reality in Denmark, Sweden and Spain. This is roughly equivalent to saying: "New York, New Jersey, and Louisiana already do it, why not the whole country? Lobbying must be to blame!" > William Gale, co-director of the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center. So the left agrees with it, I wonder what the right thinks? > Conservative tax activist Grover Norquist Now things are getting interesting. > opposes IRS government tax preparation. > allowing the IRS to act as a tax preparer could result in taxpayers paying more money > calling return-free filing a "massive expansion of the U.S. government through a big government program." > In 2005, Norquist testified before the President's Advisory Panel on Federal Tax Reform arguing against return-free filing. The next year, Norquist and others wrote in a letter to President Bush that getting an official-looking "bill" from the IRS could be "extremely intimidating, particularly for seniors, low-income and non-English speaking citizens." > The letter says the IRS wants to "socialize all tax preparation in America" to get higher tax revenues. > A year after Norquist wrote Bush, a bill to limit return-free filing was introduced by a pair of unlikely allies: Reps. Eric Cantor, R-Va., the conservative House majority leader The article says Intuit spent $11.5 million lobbying in the last five years (which in the U.S. is table scraps--see $30 million paid by Yahoo! for Summly). What is really more likely here. That Intuit has managed to buy the government for $2 million a year, or instead that they've successfully hit on a message (free tax filing = government takeover of return preparation) that resonates with rightists and billionaires who have good reason to not want the IRS to have any part in tax return preparation, not to mention ideologues who see simpler tax filing as a slippery slope to making it easier for the government to raise taxes without push-back (on the theory that citizens are more likely to push back against taxes if they are forced to face the numbers every April).
- Symmetry 14y agoThis seems to suffer from the same main weakness as attempts to simplify the tax code. The people who most care about taxes and best understand alternative systems are those who know how to work the current system. No doubt the Grover Norquists of the world have accountants who can use differing opinions of the rules to shave their tax bill. If our tax system was simpler or easier more people would claim all the deductions to which they were entitled then taxes would have to go up, but effectively only on those who already knew about all the deductions. We might all be outraged about this, but we're not going to change who we vote for based on whether a given politician supports tax reform or not, we reserve that for things that directly effect us like SOPA. Likewise people who prepare taxes for a living will change their vote to punish politicians who are taking away their jobs, but will ignore stuff like SOPA.
- stmartin 14y agoWhy would I want my tax return prepared by the very people who stand to benefit taking most of my money - the government? Who modded this up?
- enduser 14y agoThose of you who live in Silicon Valley might consider writing to Rep. Zoe Lofgren about this. The article mentions she is one of two Representatives who co-sponsored a bill to limit return-free filing. From the article: "A year after Norquist wrote Bush, a bill to limit return-free filing was introduced by a pair of unlikely allies: Reps. Eric Cantor, R-Va., the conservative House majority leader, and Zoe Lofgren, D-Calif., a liberal stalwart whose district includes Silicon Valley."
- nico 14y ago"You'd open up a pre-filled return, see what the government thinks you owe, make any needed changes and be done. The miserable annual IRS shuffle, gone." That's how it works in Chile, for about 10 years now :D
- caycep 14y agosame thing is happening with electronic medical records. Why else does EPIC's CEO donate heavily to Wisconsin congressmen, or sponsor memberships to the FDA panels that oversee the guidelines and policies regarding these systems?
- RougeFemme 14y agoHere in the state of Virginia, we never had return-free filing for state taxes. But we did have free online filing of state tax returns. It was cheaper for the state to process the online returns rather than paper forms. However, the legislature decided that it wasn't proper for the state government to provide for free a service that should be provided by private enterprise. So now your choices are to file paper forms (which costs the state more to process) or file electronically, which, of course, costs you, the taxpaer, money. . .but is quite a boon for private enterprise.
- bjhoops1 14y agoWe the People white house petition, anyone?