12 ms·
New Anti-Piracy System to Hit U.S. Internet Users on Monday
- sabat 14y agoI guess it's a lot easier to try things like this than to update your business model. That might require thinking and work.
- tbeseda 14y agoSeems like an automated version of current practices. "Owners" join a network of peers for a specific piece of content, and alert the ISP about offending IPs; ISP sends notices. Now it seems all this can happen automatically.
- samkline 14y agoIt sounds like a lot more than just notices: re-education videos, slower connections. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2012/11/us-copyright-surveillance-machine-about-be-switched-on https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2012/11/us-copyright-surveilla...
- voyou 14y agoI don't think this new system is any more automated, is it? The change is that the ISPs have agreed on various ways to penalize users who are accused of copyright infringement.
- carbocation 14y agoThis violates my perception of my ISP as a dumb pipe. I want to pay a fair price (whatever that may be) for an internet service provider that exists only to connect subscribers to the internet, at reasonable speeds near their advertised rates.
- mtgx 14y agoSonic.net does that. I don't think it's available in too many areas, though.
- wmf 14y agoTry business class service.
- richardwhiuk 14y agoThe entire telecoms industry is digging everything it can into absolutely not being that. It's entirely not a market they want to be any, as it's a commodity service and therefore yields poor profit.
- rayiner 14y agoStart your own ISP and make it a dumb pipe.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoAnd everyone's favorite VPN is...?
- dmschulman 14y agoWas doing some reading up on this last night! Torrentfreak had a handy article: http://torrentfreak.com/which-vpn-providers-really-take-anonymity-seriously-111007/ http://torrentfreak.com/which-vpn-providers-really-take-anon...
- rishimoko 14y agoPIA for me. They take Bitcoin and XRP. https://www.privateinternetaccess.com https://www.privateinternetaccess.com
- drakeandrews 14y agoXRP?
- 7c8011dda3f3b 14y agoAfter some digging it seems to be another decentralized virtual currency like bitcoin. "Ripple credits, aka XRP or ripples, are the units used as a transaction fee to protect the Ripple payment system from malicious attacks." Previous HN discussion: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5254395 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5254395
- kintamanimatt 14y agoPrivate Internet Access[1] has been serving me well for a long time and they've got endpoints all over the place, from Oh Canada to the Netherlands. Things are consistently fast and reliable, their customer service is responsive, and you can log in from multiple devices at a time which is great. They're cheap too. [1] http://www.privateinternetaccess.com http://www.privateinternetaccess.com
- GhotiFish 14y ago
- mehrzad 14y agoObviously this is ridiculous, but I find it just absurd. Who are the ISPs to tell their customers what is morally and legally right or wrong? Are we not allowed to have a reverse method where we penalize the ISPs for their crimes? Of course not. Guys, this is Hacker News, the breeding ground of entrepreneurship. One of you may to (for lack of a better buzzword) disrupt the ISP market. At least we have Fiber hopefully coming soon.
- tomp 14y agoThis is quite awesome... maybe encrypted P2P networks will finally take off!
- gizmo686 14y agoEncryption has been the default setting in most bittorrent clients for a while now. The fundamental problem is that no matter how good you encryption is, if some simply attempts to download the file themself, they can see what IPs are supplying them the pieces. In order to solve this, you would need to add an additional layer to the protocol, where a user downloads and uploads files not related to the ones they want for themselves, so knowing the IP that is uploading the file to you does not help you find someone who is actually responsible. At this point, you are probably better off running existing clients through a TOR proxy.
- nwh 14y agoPlease don't torrent through the onion router.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- bionsuba 14y agoCould you elaborate?
- nwh 14y agoThe Tor anonymity router is run by volunteers like myself. I donate several megabyte a second of my bandwidth to relay data for people avoiding censorship and protecting their anonymity. By torrenting through the onion router, you not only waste mine, but three other nodes bandwidth. It causes unnecessary load and attention to the last (exit) router. For every megabyte transferred over the network, at least 6 is used (in and out) to ensure that the connection is completely anonymous. It's a waste of my money if its being burnt by asshole pirates. If you want to know more about what the router is, there's lots of technical information on the projects website[1]. [1]: https://torproject.org/ https://torproject.org/
- james4k 14y agoAll of these guys aren't just ISPs; they're in the cable TV business. Conflicting interests, really.
- windexh8er 14y agoThese types of systems are highly susceptible to fog of war style mitigation. I'd like to find out who's providing the hardware behind the DPI. Having worked for a subsidiary of Comcast (250k subs) within the past few years I saw a handful of closed door meeting with the FBI and a few locked 'Do Not Touch' racks. The US government is spinning out of control in overreach with regard to the Internet. Whoever wants to fund an open access network with user protection and security as its core competency feel free to reach out. We'll seasoned network and security engineer waiting in the wings...
- dangrossman 14y agoAre they doing DPI? Or are they just responding to the notices they've always gotten from 3rd parties about infringement on their network with these educational/throttling responses instead of merely passing on the notices. A graduated response system need not involve new surveillance. Most of the notices were from movie studios and record labels hiring companies that participate in torrent swarms, produce logs of all the peers sharing pieces of the torrent with them, then send out notices to the ISPs associated with those IPs.
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoGame of Thrones (the most pirated show of last year) comes out in March. Still not for sale at any price unless you have a cable package AND one of their authorised ISPs (plus $18+tax/month). Maybe companies like HBO should update their business practices to something roughly compatible with 2013, instead of trying to legal threat everyone into submission. If they sold it on iTunes, YouTube, or Hulu+ they'd convert tons of pirates into paying customers. People want to give HBO their money but HBO literally won't take it...
- reustle 14y agoI feel the problem is they'd like to but their contracts with the cable companies prevent them from doing so.
- joonix 14y agoAnd the cable contracts provide basically guaranteed revenue as opposed to the risk of trying out online publishing. Execs want to cover their asses, not risk them. The potential payoff of going fully online is probably not high enough to justify risking their entire revenue base. HBO is just a publisher, their expertise is sifting through and finding great creative talent to produce great shows. There's not a big difference between cable TV and internet, they share the same last mile, even. It just takes a long time for incumbents to adapt to change.
- api 14y agoThe game is protecting cable TV from total disruption by the Internet. Cable is the big cash cow. That's also why there's such a powerful, almost jihad-like effort to keep sports off the net. A lot of sports fans have cable to watch the game.
- NoPiece 14y agoRight, and it is not just the cable companies that are fighting the disruption. Television networks are now getting a major chunk of their income from cable companies by increasing the carry and retransmission fees. This revenue source has become much more important as ad revenue has declined. So a healthy cable company business is in their interest of the big media companies as well. http://www.fiercecable.com/story/news-corp-reports-100-increase-retransmission-consent-fees/2012-02-09 http://www.fiercecable.com/story/news-corp-reports-100-incre...
- api 14y agoPersonally I see this as another overbilled project on the part of the snake oil DRM industry to part content owners from their money. None of these schemes work long-term, as there are tons of different strategies for defeating them.
- maqr 14y agoThey don't even work short-term. In fact, this gives users the means and incentive to figure out how to pirate without it being visible to the ISP. Imagine you're a clueless user that keeps getting alerts about torrenting. Maybe you get a VPN or switch to a private torrent network, or whatever technological next step you need to take. Now the alerts stop and you're pirating safely (or at least, safer).
- sokrates 14y agoThis is the perfect example of a result that arises when people disconnected from the internet think "OK, what can we do against piracy? Wait, piracy is a crime, and the best thing we can do to reduce crime is education. So why not educate users?" Why ISPs are complying with this bullshit is beyond me. The video perfectly demonstrates the sheer ridiculousness of this system. It reminded me of the Portal 2 trailers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0qcED35LL8I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0qcED35LL8I
- dangrossman 14y agoTwo reasons: 1) The top ISPs and the top media companies are one and the same. They're all cable providers and some of them are subsidiaries of entertainment conglomerates. It's their own content and their own cable TV revenue piracy threatens. 2) They're getting paid. Instead of handling infringement notices being a cost center, it can be an additional revenue stream for them, in exchange for a little throttling of the customers costing them the most in paperwork.
- Beltiras 14y agoBecause ISPs are the same corporations as the content owners.
- yaddayadda 14y agoBig brother is simply helping oldthinkers crimestop[1]. [1] http://www.newspeakdictionary.com/ns-dict.html http://www.newspeakdictionary.com/ns-dict.html
- mgkimsal 14y agoWould be sort of decent of them to actually, perhaps, reach out to their customers to let us know this is coming. Not had anything in my bill for the past several months that this new system was coming down the pike.
- EGreg 14y agoLOOK MA, NO GOVERNMENT! With SOPA destroyed by the combined efforts of giant internet companies and internet users calling their congressmen, Hollywood was able to engage another group: ISPs. Note: this is done completely without government. It is one of the best illustrations to date of what I was saying, about nannies curtailing liberties being possible even if government doesn't do them. To all libertarians that single out the government for special thrashing, I have a question: doesn't this show that wherever power concentrates, you will find stuff like this. Government is just an example. We always knew they didn't need the government, just all the major ISPs.
- nitrogen 14y agoThis absolutely was not done with no government, but was created as part of a partnership put together with the direction of the White House. Also, there's no reason for a libertarian not to oppose concentration of power in anybody's hands, whether it's government or corporations. Let's let this thread focus on the issue at hand instead of derailing it into another fight between different quadrants of the political plane.
- pbhjpbhj 14y ago>a partnership put together with the direction of the White House // I'm wondering when the people of the USA voted for this in their great democracy? OT: As an outsider USA politics appears more and more about satisfying corporate desires and very little about government by the people and for the people.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ams6110 14y agoAlmost all residential ISPs operate under government-granted monopolies, though. If this were not the case it's a lot less likely that "Hollywood" could get thousands of smaller competing ISPs on board.
- adventured 14y ago
- digitalengineer 14y agoWell, here come the Dark Nets: "The RetroShare network allows people to create a private and encrypted file-sharing network. Users add friends by exchanging PGP certificates with people they trust. All the communication is encrypted using OpenSSL and files that are downloaded from strangers always go through a trusted friend. In other words, it’s a true Darknet and virtually impossible to monitor by outsiders. http://retroshare.sourceforge.net/ http://retroshare.sourceforge.net/
- wmf 14y agoTranslation: The system is hard to use, has little content available, and downloads slowly when you can find something to download.
- digitalengineer 14y agoTrue, but for a lot of people it is a new technology. I expect darknets to grow, perhaps helped by social media. That will also bring more content. Most VPN's will happily provide the police your real IP... I first heared about Darknets from tech-guys in France, where they have a "3strikes and you're offline" law, compliments of Sarkouzy. Any French guys here wish to chip in?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- kostya-kow 14y agoHow does this compare with Tor network?
- thefreeman 14y agothe real answer is seedboxes and VPN's, which are readily available for reasonable prices
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- javajosh 14y agoIs there some reason why there isn't an inexpensive Chinese-made device that people could buy that creates totally decentralized urban and suburban mesh networks over public spectrum?
- kaybe 14y agoHm, the Chinese government doesn't endorse that kind of technology?
- javajosh 14y agoThe Chinese make 'em, they don't use 'em. You know, like iPads.
- wmf 14y agoMesh networking is very hard and there's no business model to pay for the very hard R&D since it's fundamentally about not paying.
- cjh_ 14y agoI really wish business practices would change to meet this demand. I recently came across crunchyroll [1] which has a huge amount of japanese animation available to watch online 'for free' if you can put up with ads, or you can pay $7/month to have ad free (as well as higher def). What I find really awesome is that for many shows it is available online an hour after it is shown in japan (this is for paying members, free members have to wait a week). I apologize if this seems like nothing special to you, but living in New Zealand I can really appreciate sites that are both affordable and don't lock me out because of my region. [1]http://www.crunchyroll.com/ http://www.crunchyroll.com/
- kaybe 14y agoCrunchyroll does however only give access to some shows depending on your region. Makes it mostly unusable for me, sadly.
- cjh_ 14y agoI'm sorry to hear that, I made the jump from 'it works in New Zealand' to 'it works everywhere'.
- creamyhorror 14y agoCrunchyroll is a unique case. It started out as a typical pirate video site that basically streamed and profited off anime fansubs, then later managed to go legitimate by licensing anime from Japanese studios (presumably because it had a large audience and the studios decided to experiment with streaming to the international market). It's a one-off occurrence that I don't think has been duplicated by any other site since. It'd be great if more pirate streaming sites started up and became legitimate, but it's unlikely to happen so easily with content owners who are more protective of their copyrights (e.g. US studios/channels). They'd probably sue instead of discuss licensing terms. Hulu and Netflix need to go everywhere, but content licensing by region will always stand in their way. Here we're stuck with high-priced cable TV packages that I don't find appealing, and Amazon's ebook store isn't even available.
- 14y ago
- rorrr 14y ago1) Install HTTPS Everywhere extension for your browser 2) Use VPN if you can 3) Use TOR browser if you can Let's overwhelm the internet with encrypted traffic. Nobody will have enough resources to decrypt or MITM all that traffic.
- zanny 14y agoIt isn't about encryption, since if a content provider can get a hand on a torrent file or a tracker + magnet, they can get all the IPs of everyone in the swarm. The only way to avoid that is having your traffic routed through someone else so you can't be directly visible, which is expensive in the broad sense.
- martinced 14y agoSo technically the bandwith-limitation can be triggered for any user from these ISPs right? So we may after all see some heavy bandwith-throttling for users whose machines have been infested and are part of botnets. That would be lovely.
- bigphishy 14y agoHere is a thorough guide for covering your ass and using darknets https://pay.reddit.com/r/evolutionReddit/comments/193m6k/six_strikes_goes_live_on_monday_how_to_beat_the/ https://pay.reddit.com/r/evolutionReddit/comments/193m6k/six...
- edouard1234567 14y agoSeems like a few ISPs are creating their own SOPA like system very similar to the HADOPY system put in place in France.
- goostavos 14y agoI'm not familiar with how that side of things works, how will they differentiate between legitimate torrent traffic, and traffic which contains pirated material? The video says that you'll be able to challenge alerts after you've received them, but is throttling pre or post that alert being filed? Legitimate use from about an hour ago: Downloaded a fan remix album of some video game music (A torrent is the method they give on their website for downloading). Will that activity result in any kind warning flags? Is this something that services like hidemyip circumvent? Or is it different since, I assume, my actual IP is visible when torrenting?
- 1337p337 14y agoAgreed; a link that discusses what it actually entails would be great. Or does no one actually know, outside the companies that implemented it?
- chucknibbleston 14y agoIf they know what you pirated, why don't the content providers just get your ISP to shut off your internet until you watch enough ads to make up for the cost (they could do a little rev-share to incentivize comcast). Piracy will exist as long as content providers insist on selling something that can no longer be sold.
- adventured 14y agoWelcome to fascism. Where corporate-government interests strictly control everything (Verizon and AT&T = US Government, since they've been granted government monopoly protections, they are in fact an arm of the Federal Government).
- D9u 14y agoAs exhibit "B," I list the granting of immunity to the above TelComs for their part in the domestic surveillance program(s.) http://www.dslreports.com/shownews/Effort-To-Scuttle-Telecom-Immunity-Push-Fails-90284 http://www.dslreports.com/shownews/Effort-To-Scuttle-Telecom...
- beedogs 14y agoSometimes I get the feeling that the second half of my life is going to be a lot shittier than the first.
- a1a 14y agoThis is really bad. I don't care for piracy, but I'm really worried. This is a prediction of the internet.. year 2020: TOR, freenet or some new network is in size like p2p was 2013. It has got a lot of attention from ordinary people and developers and it's actually pretty fast now days. Pretty much everyone runs a relay, it's basically like it was running uTorrent back in 2005 - not a big deal. While everything is free, which is quite nice for the pirate, it's also hell. Since everyone is basically untraceable, even Megan, the twelve year old who wants the new Disney movie. It's now totally impossible to trace down the terrorist, online drug-dealers, etc. The cyber-police is drowning in false positives, this because Megan and her classmates are using the same crypto-network. Is this what we want? I think we should tackle the piracy problem from another angle. Let's start more services like spotify and hulu. Make it not worth it to pirate stuff because there is a awesome legal alternative.
- Karunamon 14y ago>Is this what we want? Short answer: Yes - but not for the reason you stated. The "cyber police" have been getting far too powerful and chummy with ISPs as of late. Any measures an average person can reasonably take to make surveillance hard if not impossible to conduct should be happening. Police can rely on old fashioned police work. They do not need DPI gear in every datacenter to trace down kiddie pornographers, "terrorists" and online drug dealers (which is a section of law enforcement which needs to shrivel and die anyways).
- D9u 14y agoDoes anyone remember the NASA imagery from Mars which was taken down by YouTube due to alleged "Copyright Infringement?" http://www.theregister.co.uk/2012/08/07/nasa_dmca_takedown/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2012/08/07/nasa_dmca_takedown/ Who's to say there won't be more of the same with this system?
- acabal 14y agoThis strikes me as a scary first step. The whole "re-education" spin is extra-scary; if I had a kid who downloaded something and was exposed to this kind of treatment, I'd be pretty loudly wondering who Comcast thinks it is to be "educating" my child with its propaganda. What can we as techies do to combat this? How can we add a layer of encryption and anonymity that's so dead easy that it becomes ubiquitous?
- dmix 14y agoVPN software, even setting up tunnelbrick on OSX is pretty easy for techies, but I imagine it can be pretty tough for newbs. It'd be nice if there was a one-click type of process. Maybe where the credentials are transferred via web service using a login auth from the desktop client? The technology for anonymity is there and adequate, just needs some proper UX design and user education.
- acabal 14y agoThat's part of the problem, but the other part is that regular people just don't care. I don't think they will care until it's too late, and even when it's too late they might not care to realize it. (I.e. in the future where the internet only works for Comcast-approved sites, and folks are happy with it because at least they can pay Comcast $80/month to watch Game of Thrones in their browser.) Technology has to step in and make anonymity and encryption basic on some fundamental browser, os, or protocol level, so that the average user doesn't even need to actively search out anonymity solutions. I don't know what the answer is. I suppose if it were that easy, we would have figured it out by now. Edit: VPNs are still not a perfect solution, because your activity on them could be logged. (The TOS says they don't keep logs? Then you're just trusting the company to do what they say in their TOS, because when the government comes knocking it'll go right out the window.)
- ericabiz 14y agoPlenty of these exist on the marketplace. Personally, I use HideMyAss (http://hidemyass.com/vpn/ http://hidemyass.com/vpn/) (no affiliation other than a happy customer.) I use it for privacy reasons, although I'm sure there are plenty of folks who also use it for downloading. It's an OpenVPN client with its own configured servers and a friendly, easy-to-use GUI for Windows and Mac. It is so fast that sometimes I forget I have it on when I'm doing normal web surfing. It's also come in handy for me with troubleshooting. For instance, once I was able to track down an issue with Cloudflare's CDN where customers in certain parts of the world could not access a website, by using it to appear as though I was coming from that area of the world. Cloudflare support confirmed the issue and fixed it once I was able to screencap with my home connection vs. my HideMyAss proxy IP in a different "location."
- drivebyacct2 14y agoI have to say after using other ISPs, I'm quite happy with Cox Communications in the Midwest. It wasn't always great, but the reliability of service is much better than the others I've had the displeasure of using. It's a bit pricey, but they have a monopoly here so it could be worse. Other than frying my modem once (it was documented and others had the exact same problems on the same date), it's been good. With other ISPs I've had to lease their hardware that inevitability has fundamentally-broken Wifi functionality. And, more relevantly, they've stood up for consumers in these cases and their name is notably absent from the list of participants.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- smsm42 14y agoOK, so I guess we have a market for ISPs that don't do that. I wonder if there's any site that lists such ISPs at least in major cities?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- dzamie 14y agoIf I understand this correctly, someone who claims copyright on a software can sign up for an alerts system on a P2P, at which point any infringement of copyright is automatically forwarded to the ISP. The ISP then reprimands the alleged pirate via email/alert, and if the consumer continues to receive warnings, they will have to play a video on their computer and/or receive restricted internet access. The "you must watch a video" thing doesn't seem too bad, considering that it'll probably be possible to just run it in its own tab and ignore it, and speed restrictions are already being put in place by some ISPs.
- pbhjpbhj 14y ago> "it will issue escalating punishments to suspected pirates, severely reducing their connection speeds after five or six offenses" // How would you punish person A but not punish person B who uses the same connection. How can you establish person A is guilty rather than person B in order to decide that A should be punished. Why is copyright infringement now suddenly no longer to be decided by a proper legal process instead being decided by the plaintiff? How will the legal system protect against the innocent being punished and ensure that due punishment for false claims made by plaintiffs is forthcoming. Without a proper process to punish false (or evidentially unsupported) claims this surely breaches basic legal rights. When companies share libellous legal claims about a person without evidence surely the USA legal system would punish those companies?!?
- sexyalterego 14y agoThis was originally a Daily Dot story. Mashable just syndicated it. http://www.dailydot.com/news/copyright-alerts-system-launch-six-strikes/ http://www.dailydot.com/news/copyright-alerts-system-launch-...