19 ms·
What Does 200 Calories Look Like?
- smackfu 14y agoPeanut butter, nuts, and bagels tend to be the ones that are most surprising to people who are dieting for the first time. Just way more calories than people think because they think they are "healthy" because they are natural.
- jwoah12 14y agoPeople think bagels are healthy? They're just a big, dense (delicious) ring of simple carbs.
- peterwwillis 14y agoThey also have (on average) ~12g protein and 1.5g fat. At a little over 20% of the carbs you need per day, it's not going to ruin your diet, but could have an unhealthy effect on blood sugar levels in some people [http://www.phlaunt.com/lowcarb/19060174.php http://www.phlaunt.com/lowcarb/19060174.php]
- tocomment 14y agoAre pumper nickel bagels much better? That's what I've been telling myself ...
- stan_rogers 14y agoThat really depends on what you mean by "pumpernickel". If you mean black rye flour bread, it's not significantly different from any other grain-flour bread. If you mean rye meal bread ("real" pumpernickel), it would have significantly higher fat and caloric content (it's much denser than a flour bread, containing very little in the way of gas pockets, and uses more of the seed).
- maxerickson 14y agoIn relation to a custard filled donut, they probably are pretty healthy. They definitely fall on the 'health food' end of the breakfast breads/pastries/etc.
- jwoah12 14y agoTrue, relative to those things. I guess I was setting the "healthy" bar at things like eggs, oatmeal, whole wheat toast, lower-fat deli meats and completely forgetting about the fact that people eat donuts and other pastries for breakfast.
- smackfu 14y agoIf you had a bagel (plain with no spread) and a cream filled iced donut sitting next to each other, I think most people would think choosing the bagel would be the obvious healthy choice. (Honestly, I think that's why people have success with low-carb diets. So much of their calorie intake is from carbs from simple basics like breads and pasta.)
- Evbn 14y agoWhen I cut carbs, I was shocked that bagels had the highest protein ratio of any carb-based food, including hippie bread like Dave's Killer. And nuts are filling for those calories. Peanut butter (with added oil) I suspect is too easy to eat to slow down calorie intake.
- devrelm 14y agoI'm really depressed at the amount of Bailey's in that glass.
- Udo 14y agoThere is some surprising stuff in there. I would never have guessed that onions or broccoli have about the same energy density as Coca Cola.
- Evbn 14y agoWhich is more satiating, though? Coca cola is sugar dissolved in water. If you pureed broccoli and thinned it in water, it would be much larger than the equivalent amount of coke.
- boothead 14y agoWhat... balsamic vinegar is more calorie dense that Coca Cola?! Surely this must be diet coke right...?
- ihsw 14y agoBalsamic vinegar is a reduction of wine, usually, so it's almost entirely sugary syrup.
- antr 14y agoDon't let the calorie count fool you. I suggest you watch this presentation http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM
- DanBC 14y agoYou drink a glass of cola. I challenge anyone to drink a glass full of balsamic vinegar.
- drucken 14y agoEasy way to remember, something bodybuilders know intimately: for 1g, Carbs = 4 calories Protein = 4 calories Fat = 9 calories Alcohol = 7 calories.
- anoncow 14y agoBut aren't alcohol calories "empty"?
- TeMPOraL 14y agoSo? They still can make you gain weight: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empty_calorie http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empty_calorie
- alexhjones 14y agohttp://lmgtfy.com/?q=empty+calorie http://lmgtfy.com/?q=empty+calorie
- Dirlewanger 14y agoIf one is ingesting only, say, 80 proof hard liquor, your body actually burns net calories metabolizing it. Notice I say only because alcohol without carbs is rarely consumed.
- jonathanjaeger 14y agoI find it very interesting that an imgur gallery with the same title made it to the top of Reddit the other day and a different link with different pictures but the same premise made it to the front page on Hacker News. Of course on Hacker News imgur isn't the default.
- nakedrobot2 14y agonote: the pictures obviously have nothing to do with the "200 calories" part. for eggs, 3 eggs are shown with "150 grams" under it....
- qompiler 14y agoCanola oil sounds frightening!
- driverdan 14y agoAll oils are calorie dense, not just canola.
- muxxa 14y agoAlso, Canola oil (aka Rapeseed oil) is possibly the best oil you can use. If you eat a lot of good fats (good = monounsaturated, e.g. olive oil, avocados, peanuts), then it reduces cravings for bad fats (fried foods, butter, animal fat etc.). A rule of thumb is that any fat that it is liquid at room temperature is 'good'.
- tbrownaw 14y agoAlso, Canola oil (aka Rapeseed oil) is possibly the best oil you can use. It's the best, except when it doesn't agree with you. In which case it's rather annoying, since it's so very popular.
- rkowalick 14y agoOil is pure fat, and fat is the most calorie dense of all foods. Canola Oil, Corn Oil, Soybean Oil are all pure fat, so they are all around 120 cal per Tbsp (9 cal per gram). From a calorie standpoint, butter is better, as it is not 100% fat. It also tastes way better.
- rubyrescue 14y agoOne of the things I've enjoyed the most in the past 4 months has been diving into reddit.com/r/fitness. If you spend a few hours reading the FAQ on that site, plus examine.com's nutrition articles, and reddit.com/r/leangains FAQs, you will come out with a much better understanding of your diet. There are also calculators listed in the FAQs that will help you determine what you need to eat to maintain your bodyweight, lose fat, gain muscle, etc, over a user-selected window of time. First thing I realized - that the difference between tracking your "macros" and not is like programming with Word or with vi/emacs/slickedit/etc - the difference is AMAZING. The next thing I realized - is that to get enough protein if you're even moderately active, you have to eat A LOT - eggs, milk, meat, tuna, and even then I still have to supplement with protein supplements. Now, combine the diet knowledge with a beginner weight training program like Starting Strength and the effect is amazing. I've gained 10 pounds of muscle and lost 10 lbs of fat. I've doubled all my lift numbers (which are still admittedly quite low) in four months. I have far more energy and other activities - I occasionally play tennis - I play better and feel stronger. Edited to add - and most importantly, use something like myfitnesspal.com - which is free, has a great app, and has millions of food items, and track everything for just a few weeks. it will teach you what protein/fat/carbs common foods you eat have.
- stdbrouw 14y agoThe picture changes, though, if you decide not to steam your vegetables but sauté them with oil instead. Doesn't make vegetables any less healthy, just something to take into account.
- jws 14y agoThis would be much more useful with a recognizable, standard sized object in each picture. Maybe not as pretty, but a heap of flour is a heap of flour. (For bonus usability, they could stop shifting the popups off to the right so I need to make my browser window wider to close the popup.)
- elsewhen 14y agoFrom the bottom of the article: "All pictures were taken with the same camera (Nikon D70 digital camera) and with the same setup; in other words, the portion sizes displayed are all relative to each other. The plate is 10.25" (26cm) in diameter and the bowl is 6.25" (16cm) "
- voidlogic 14y agoI'm guessing this list as the same pitfall as food labels and is showing quantities based on the amount of energy (calories) in the raw material rather than using the amount of energy the human digestive system can actually exploit. For example while you might get nearly 200 calories of from 200 of white bread, you would only actually get 150 calories from 200 calories of many meats. I think that if nutrition labels changed to estimated "exploitable calories" that a lot of the magic diet nonsense would evaporate.
- moggie 14y agoHow is the exploitable amount of calories determined, exactly? Is there a layperson-readable resource somewhere that you might recommend?
- dfxm12 14y agoI'm not sure what exactly OP is referring to, but there is a difference in the nutritional data of, for example, raw chicken breast (which is marked on the packaging) and baked chicken breast (which is what gets digested [unless you actually eat it raw]). See http://nutritiondata.self.com/facts/poultry-products/701/2 http://nutritiondata.self.com/facts/poultry-products/701/2 VS http://nutritiondata.self.com/facts/poultry-products/703/2 http://nutritiondata.self.com/facts/poultry-products/703/2 Make sure you line up the serving sizes.
- Evbn 14y agoSelf.com has great data tables for many variations of foods.
- khuey 14y agoIt's not, for the most part.
- jgrahamc 14y agoSome time ago I wrote about my own weight loss "program" which was fairly simple: http://blog.jgc.org/2010/01/johns-amazing-diet-secrets-revealed.html http://blog.jgc.org/2010/01/johns-amazing-diet-secrets-revea... Largely I cut down on carbohydrates (because I was stuffing myself with crap like Coke, sweets, etc.) and ate less in general. Late last year I realized that I had put on weight again because of the same bad habits so I cut them out again and redid my "program". I now weigh 71kg which is very healthy for my height. To be honest, a small investment in knowing the calorie and nutrient content of foods, cutting out processed and useless foods, and most importantly "listening to my stomach and not my mouth" made weight loss pretty easy for me. The other important motivator was realizing the asymmetry between the effort required to insert calories in my mouth (100s of calories per minute are easy) and burn calories once in me (100s of calories per hour).
- msluyter 14y agoAs someone who's successfully lost a lot of weight on a low carb / no grain diet, this chart irks me. That a handful of almonds has the same calories as a certain amount of Captain Crunch is irrelevant. The latter will quickly convert to glucose in your body, however, (unlike almonds) and that will make a huge difference in your satiety levels, insulin response (Hello, Metabolic Syndrome!), etc... [1] Some good resources: http://whole9life.com/start/ http://whole9life.com/start/ http://thepaleodiet.com/ http://thepaleodiet.com/ [1] Standard disclaimers. I'm not a nutritionist. This works for me. YMMV.
- TomGullen 14y agoI'm down 14kg in 120 days on a keto based diet. Works brilliantly, sustainably and enjoyable. Carbs are also full of empty calories, better to eat more nutrients like fat! I'm healthier because of that. The chart isn't particularly useful, but it's still interesting imo Whatever works for you of course is the best. Regrettably I've been a bit preachy about keto diets before, but understand now that some people prefer calorie counting better and it works for them, so fair enough!
- sneak 14y agoKetogenic diets are more trouble than they're worth. There's nothing inherently wrong with carbohydrates.
- TomGullen 14y agoYou can't say it's more trouble than it's worth because it's a sweeping generalisation, and different diets work better for different people. Calorie restricted diet I have failed at many times before. Keto was difficult for the first month but now it's a doddle. There's nothing wrong with carbohydrates either. Never said that. Carbs in moderation is a diet that most people I know seem to exist healthily and happily off. However elimination of carbohydrates is a tactic that's giving me awesome results, making me happy and more energetic. You do not need to consume carbohydrates to stay alive of be healthy.
- mapt 14y agoAppears to be in the same vein as this: http://www.healthassist.net/food/300kcal/300.shtml http://www.healthassist.net/food/300kcal/300.shtml which offers more items, better size comparisons, and a rough price
- muxxa 14y agoThe idea that eating healthily can be simplified to the reduction in a single number (a calorific value) really annoys me. Always remember that a calorie is a proxy metric, and a very poor one at that; it's the energy output of burning the food, which has very little correlation with what goes on in your body during consumption/digestion.
- TomGullen 14y agoThat's a very concise way to say it, thank you! Never read it explained that well.
- muxxa 14y agoIt really annoys me as e.g. the trend in industrial bread making is to reduce the relative quantity of flour (the most expensive ingredient), in favour of cheaper vegetable fats. This is achieved by the addition of emulsifiers. So the calorific value of the bread may go down, and you'll have to eat more bread to make you feel as full, but the overall nutritional balance is completely skewed away from what was originally a quite nourishing, wholesome food (the majority component of the European diet at one time). Next time you buy a loaf of bread look at the end of the list of ingredients. If there is an emulsifier listed it's a red flag; there really should only be Flour, Water, Yeast and (some) Fat. You can also tell the quality of the bread by squeezing it and feeling for the spring-back. Many supermarkets don't actually stock 'real' bread. I was alerted to this by reading the book 'Not on the Label' https://duckduckgo.com/?q=%22not+on+the+label%22+bread https://duckduckgo.com/?q=%22not+on+the+label%22+bread
- Evbn 14y agoWhole wheat and seeds are good ingredients too.
- Robin_Message 14y agoAssuming you are right here, which macronutrient (out of protein, fats and carbs) either: a) converts into ATP with significantly less or more than 40% efficiency; or b) is not absorbed in significant fractions by the human digestive system? Otherwise, bah to very little correlation.
- lorenzfx 14y agoI might be a nitpicker, but I really hate it when people say (or in this case write) "calorie" but mean "kilo calorie". There is a difference.
- Evbn 14y agoYeah, and a pound isn't a pound, and a dry cup isn't a we're cup. Welcome to America.
- 38leinad 14y agoI have always asked myself why that is so? how did it happen that this "mistake" got into everyones mind? you don't say "meters" if you mean "kilometers"...
- Mitt 14y agoYes, it’s strange. My idea here is: for distances both things are typical: meters and kilometers. Every day we need to handle both unites. It would be impractical to give longer distances in meters (“Hey Jeff, it’s still around 100000000000000000 picometers to your home, will be there in roughly 4200000000000 nanoseconds…”). But even huge distances on Earth can be measured in km, and we don’t need megameters. With calories however for all practical purposes we have a number range in which it is okay to use kcal. So here people just forgot that the k actually has a meaning. It makes not much sense to go down to the level of cal.
- iand 14y agoHow were the calories counted? It seems that many common foods are mislabeled since they are using older forms of calorific calculation that don't include fibre. See http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2013/feb/18/food-retailers-underestimating-calorie-content http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2013/feb/18/food-retailers...
- Evbn 14y agoThat article also links to the OP wisegeek article, and mentions protein calorie overcounting and cooked-food calorie undercounting, which other commenters here have mentioned. And it was published yesterday! Strange loop, or filter bubble?
- Evbn 14y agoMost commonly consumed foods don't have fiber, so this isn't a huge issue.
- plg 14y agoBacon FTW
- rb2k_ 14y agoSeeing as this usually turns into a low-carb diet thread, here is a great post about the common nutritional misconceptions of most modern diets and links to the accompanying scientific papers: http://authoritynutrition.com/11-biggest-lies-of-mainstream-nutrition/ http://authoritynutrition.com/11-biggest-lies-of-mainstream-...
- 3minus1 14y agoThis makes it sound like I could eat greasy pizza all the time and it would be healthy.
- rb2k_ 14y agosadly no. the carbs in pizza in combination with the fat are a bit of a problem. If you want to go for cauliflower pizza ( https://www.google.com/search?q=cauliflower+pizza&oq=cauliflower+pizza&ie=UTF-8 https://www.google.com/search?q=cauliflower+pizza&oq=cau... ), knock yourself out :)
- andygcook 14y agoWithout the full shot of the plate or another object as a frame of reference, it's hard to tell how much volume each portion of food represents. The imgur gallery makes it easier to gauge the portion size in my opinion. http://imgur.com/gallery/w9nHF http://imgur.com/gallery/w9nHF
- juan_juarez 14y agoThe page only shows thumbnails. You can click on the image to get the full picture.
- jtheory 14y agoUh, carbs as in "you burn it, you get X carbs", or carbs as in "when your body digests this, it uses A carbs to process, B carbs go out in waste, and the balance is C carbs"? The former isn't nearly as useful (but of course is much easier to figure out with any accuracy).
- ck2 14y agoThe way the government allows corporations to calculate calories is a very corrupt system, self-moderated with little to no supervision or enforcement. So keep that in mind when reading labels.
- csmeder 14y agoThis page says: Brown Sugar 53 grams = 200 Calories Splenda Artifical Sweetener 50 grams = 200 Calories I don't understand?
- igul222 14y agoA gram of Splenda might be 10 times as sweet, and occupy 10 times as much volume, as a gram of brown sugar.
- Mitt 14y agoBoth numbers are totally wrong. Because both should be closer to a quarter million, and not 200. Even one gram of sugar already has over 4000 calories. But besides that, and this is probably your question: you only need a tiny amount of artificial sweetener, to get the same sweetness that you would get with sugar. For example Aspartam is about 200x as sweet as sugar, but it contains a very similar amount of energy. Sugar has ca. 16.8 kJ/g and Aspartam more like 17 kJ/g.
- fr0sty 14y agoTo your first point: 1 Calorie = 1 Kilo-calorie = 4184 Joules so 200Calories actually _is_ close to a quarter-million calories (small c)
- fingerprinter 14y agoWhenever I see a thread like this pop up on HN, I feel a need to reply and dispel some myths. I'm going to do my best to provide a quick, yet thorough summary. I hope this helps. Who am I? I'm a techie and a fitness nut. I've played high level basketball, amateur football, rugby, aussie rules football. I've done some triathlons (not my forte), a couple ultra races (hate them, learned a lot about myself). My current area is gaining muscle, losing fat, and building strength. I write fitness books in my nights and weekends (no link provided). I'll try to give the briefest of summaries, though I know it is going to be challenging. If I didn't summarize something well enough or if it is unclear, let me know and I can try to do a better job. 1. Calories vs Macros also known as Weight vs Composition Calories matter for losing and gaining weight, but they don't tell the whole story. If the only thing you know about are calories, you can't lose weight or gain weight intelligently (ie. lose fat and gain muscle). You can do it by accident, but you certainly can't do it optimally. But, I'll offer this, if the only thing you care about is the number on the scale, you can safely just track calories and eat in a deficit. You'll lose weight. Macros, or macronutrients, are important to understand so you can achieve the goal you actually care about. Most people say "lose weight" and mean "lose fat". "Gain weight" actually means "gain lean muscle". If that is true of you, you need to understand and track macros. And, no, you do not need to track both macros and calories. Macros are just fine. 2. Gaining Muscle I wrote an entire book on gaining lean muscle mass complete with 3 workouts, nutrition info and a diet. I'm going to do my best to summarize it here as quickly as possible. A. Workout with heavy weights (see workouts below). B. Spike insulin after a workout (more on this in a sec). C. Cycle your days. Recommend: For C, cycle your food in the following manner: Workout days: 1g protein/desired lean bodyweight. Even simpler (if you hate math), just 1g protein/desired bodyweight. 1-2g carbs (post workout only)/desired lean bodyweight (this is more important to nail 100%), .5g fat(before workout only)/desired lean bodyweight. Non-workout days: 1g protein/desired lean bodyweight. Even simpler (if you hate math), just 1g protein/desired bodyweight. 0-30g MAX carbs, .5g fat(before workout only)/desired lean bodyweight. For B, you can see above that I'm recommending carbs post workout. The goal with the carbs is two fold: to replenish glycogen stores and to spike insulin. If you are diabetic or for some other reason can't eat carbs, you can still spike insulin, though not as fast and not as high. If no carbs, do the following: protein shake with creatine, leucine (5-10g) and MCT oil (prefer straight MCT, but coconut oil will do as well). (Note: this is the same shake I use in the 'lose fat' below to still build some muscle while losing fat). 3. Losing Fat Again, I wrote an entire book on this, so I'll do my best to summarize. Remember, lose fat probably means 'lose fat and maintain whatever lean muscle mass I currently have' . A. Workout with heavy weights (preferred, mostly to maintain your muscle mass...need to continue to stimulate the body), sprints/HIIT, or very low intensity walking (mid-level cardio, i.e. running is bad for this goal, just FYI). B. Spike insulin without carbs post heavy weight workout. If HIIT or low intensity cardio, NO insulin spike. C. Carbs once a week. For A, I prefer people to continue to workout with heavy weights simply to make sure they can maintain their muscle, or even pack a bit more on. For B, just use the same post workout shake above. Again, if workout was HIIT or low-intensity cardio, don't do this. And for C, follow "non-workout day" above and go ultra low carb for 5-6 days a week (in a row). Then carb-refeed (also called carbing up) once or twice a week. I highly recommend you start out with this approach: 6.5 days ultra low carb (less than 30g/day) and then on the 7th night, have a 6 hour window where you eat basically whatever carbs you want. On the order of 300-700g of carbs in that window. The next day you are going to feel pretty bloated and you'll gain weight (water), but in 2-3 days all that is gone and you are back to losing fat. The reason for the .5 days of carbs is hormonal adjustment. I initially intended to write much more, but this is already getting too long for a HN post. It is really hard to summarize everything down to the barest of essentials, so I hope I did an adequate enough job for people to get a start.
- pothibo 14y agoA calorie is not a calorie. Fructose could be the problem, and Robert H. Lustig explains what he believes to be true. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM
- brendoncrawford 14y agoFor what it's worth... I lost a lot of weight by eating the same stuff I have always ate, just much less of it. Cookies, oatmeal, chocolate, beans, nuts, fruit, etc. Pre-historic or not, paleo is a fad. People with self control are going to lose weight no matter what method they chose. People with no self control are going to stay fat no matter what they do.