17 ms·
Nate Silver correctly called 50 out of 50 states
- lbrandy 14y agoOnce California has its results in, I'm guessing his prediction on the popular vote will make it 51/51.
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoHe was down by 200k a few minutes ago, now he's only down by 110k. California has about 20 million more votes to count, if Obama takes them 55/45, should be good enough to take the popular vote.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jbester 14y agoYou're forgetting washington DC
- btilly 14y agoHe predicted that Obama would get 50.8% of the popular vote. Currently Obama stands at 50.3% of the popular vote. However the majority of the currently uncounted ballots are in Oregon and Washington. Therefore Obama's share is likely to go up a smidge. Still getting the popular vote to within 0.5% is pretty good. Especially considering that many national polls going in were consistently calling for a Romney win there.
- mhartl 14y agoThis remains to be seen. As of this writing, Florida and Virginia have yet to be called.
- arn 14y agoHere's VA http://electionresults.virginia.gov/resultsSW.aspx?type=PRE&map=CTY http://electionresults.virginia.gov/resultsSW.aspx?type=PRE&... Reporting at 100%. 50%/48% in favor of Obama.
- ComputerGuru 14y agoI've been a huge fan of Nate Silver since forever, and I must say, I really regret his "acquirement" by NY Times. When it was his own website, it was a much more user-friendly experience. For instance, though I have an NYT account, every other page view I get redirected to a login prompt if I don't press Esc fast enough (this page has expired? WTF?). It also made him more of an independent, though he is (falsely) discounted on many counts by other parts of media, his affiliation with NYT is yet another facet for them to criticize.
- lacker 14y agoTry browsing the NYT incognito - it seems to avoid the login prompts.
- Osmium 14y agoDisagree with this. NYT brought a much better user experience and much nicer data presentation, and leant him a feeling of legitimacy too. There's a reason the NYT has the reputation it does.
- rm999 14y agoI disagree. Here's an archive from post-2008 election: http://web.archive.org/web/20081106113055/http://www.fivethirtyeight.com/ http://web.archive.org/web/20081106113055/http://www.fivethi... The old page contains more information yet looks friendlier. The nytimes style is more streamlined, but it became too sanitized. The content became sanitized too; Nate Silver could be more himself when it was his blog. He gave personal accounts, he was more honest, etc.
- untog 14y agoI think the answer here is that it was better for Nate to join NYT- I imagine he was compensated well for the move. We can complain about it, but.. well, it isn't in our hands.
- mayneack 14y agoEdit: missed that part
- monochromatic 14y agoWhy do I have to enter my google profile information to open this?
- evoxed 14y agoIt's just a brief G+ post with two links, but if you want to see what it's talking1bout just go here instead: http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/ http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/
- ericdykstra 14y agoNate Silver's calculations are certainly more sophisticated that a simple time-weighted average of legitimate polling numbers, but are they more accurate? His baseball projection system, PECOTA, was extremely complex, but barely, barely outperformed a simple 3-year weighted average with an age component (Marcel), and some years was worse. Other projection systems that didn't take player comps into account were better overall than PECOTA (CHONE being the best, before the creator was hired away by a team).
- 3JPLW 14y agoThe difference? Sample size. In baseball, everyone has the same data. It's all the data available. There's no sampling going on; it's a projection from past performance. Which, in many ways, is way more difficult. His advantage in 538 is that he is using very sound statistical methods to combine multiple polls to increase the effective sample size and shrink confidence intervals. The complexities there are all related to increasing the individual pollster's historic performance and simulating the actual election.
- spicyj 14y ago> to combine multiple polls to increase the effective sample size and shrink confidence intervals How does this work? I was under the impression that to shrink the confidence interval by half you need 4x as many sample points, but there must be more sophisticated statistical methods at work here.
- 3JPLW 14y agoHis models have a memory (increase sample size by using a handful of day or week old data) and aggregate as many as 5 to 8 independent polls per state plus as many as a dozen national polls that factor into his simulations. That's easily four to sixteen times the sample size.
- niggler 14y agoYou can improve effective sample size by eliminating extraneous variables. One thing that Nate does is take advantage of implicit biases (for example, PPP polls lean slightly left)
- hayksaakian 14y agoLet's be honest though, the number of likely outcomes was low enough that simply picking the correct one isn't too impressive. Edit: I meant to say that the prediction itself was unspectacular, however I respect the meticulous-ness of his process.
- pfisch 14y agoWhat the hell are you talking about? If you actually placed bets by nate silver you could make quite a lot of money. The number of outcomes is very high on a parlay bet like this.
- hayksaakian 14y agoWhat I mean is that if you put 100 random people and a room, and explain the likely outcomes to them, its reasonable to expect that each of those outcomes is chose at least once. There was not anything wildly unexpected that happened, and therefore his predictions being correct seems unspectacular.
- mkr-hn 14y agoGaining traction with unspectacular predictions in the spectacle of politics is spectacular.
- fl3tch 14y agoOne way to look at is that there were only about 6 states that could go either way, so he picked 6/6.
- jlgreco 14y agoIn other words he, with confidence, called a 1 out of 2^6 coin toss... That either takes massive balls, or he was actually on to something.
- achompas 14y agoI don't know what you mean by this. Are you referring to "Obama wins" as a potential coin flip? Because Silver's prediction was more nuanced than that. Are you talking about his predictions for the 50 states, which represented a potential (albeit naive) 2^50 combinations? Because he called some very close states, including a Florida election that he forecasted as an Obama victory by hundredths of a percent. Or are you just trolling?
- tlrobinson 14y agoI wonder how much money he could be (is?) making in prediction markets like Intrade.
- crntaylor 14y agoIt's hard to make really significant money on InTrade. I don't think you could make a living at it, for example - there's not enough liquidity. There were some fun opportunities to arbitrage InTrade against BetFair this election, if you could be bothered with the faff of setting up an account on both of them. InTrade had Obama at 66-66% for a while, whereas BetFair had Obama at 79-80%. You could buy on InTrade and hedge on BetFair, and make a guaranteed profit (even after t-costs).
- jessriedel 14y agoThe presidential market on InTrade was quite liquid. $300k of volume with a bid-ask spread of like 0.2%. Do you know why there was such a persistent gap for arbitrage between InTrade and BetFair? I don't know about BetFair's vig and rules, but InTrade has only a couple of small fixed transaction costs. ($5/mo to have an account and $10 to pull your money out, I think.) Seems like it should have been eaten up.
- denzil_correa 14y agoQuite impressive. Prediction in any form is difficult; more so when there are a million people involved.
- moistgorilla 14y agoActually, I believe when there are a million people involved it's actually easier. As long as you have access to good data that is.
- denzil_correa 14y agoAs long as you have access to good data that is. This is very difficult in itself. Even once you have it; it is not easy. More data does not lead to better prediction. It's a fallacy which has been proven wrong time and again.
- dbaupp 14y agoI hope you mean "having more data doesn't lead to better prediction automatically", because, used correctly, it always gives more accurate predictions (e.g. prediction intervals[1] are smaller, one can make better determinations about the distribution of the underlying population, etc). [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prediction_interval https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prediction_interval
- denzil_correa 14y agoLet me me correct my statement. More data does not necessarily lead to better prediction. I must add that it is not always about usage as well. In some cases, the data is insufficient to make any kind of prediction.
- dbaupp 14y agoThe only data that is insufficient to make a prediction is either no data at all, or data suspected to be wrong (e.g. faulty observation equipment). Even given a single sample, one can make a prediction of what the next observation will be: the same value. Once you get more samples and more knowledge about the subject, you can bring stronger statistical tools to bear to get error estimates, prediction intervals, improved models, etc.
- maaku 14y agoIncluding Alaska and Hawai'i, with zero precincts reporting! </sarcasm>
- MartinCron 14y agoIf he's wrong on AK and HI, I will eat my hat, a moose, and a rainbow.
- damian2000 14y agoI was looking at the Intrade prediction market a couple of days ago.. I think they got everything correct too.
- arn 14y agoPresumably Silver's projection is "priced in" to Intrade.
- usaar333 14y agoNope. Florida was predicted as going for Romney up until results starting coming in: http://www.intrade.com/v4/markets/contract/?contractId=745736 http://www.intrade.com/v4/markets/contract/?contractId=74573...
- nikcub 14y agoMost markets got the winner right, which isn't a surprise, but they didn't get the margin right. I found Obama to win 310-330 electoral college votes at $8 on Betfair yesterday (and I put it on, and it looks like I won). The betting markets did believe that Obama would win, but there was a lot of money on the race being closer and not as wide as Silver was predicting. This is probably because the media narrative of the past two weeks was that the race is close. There is a rumor that some Republican donors were shortening the odds in the margin betting in order to perpetuate the line that the race is closer. I don't know how true that is, but it would be possible to move the market with a few large bets.
- the_cat_kittles 14y agoWhere did you hear that rumor? I have all but concluded that on my own based on the bizarrely low prices on obama shares on intrade over the past week. It would be very interesting to hear something more than speculation.
- nikcub 14y agoI was hanging out and talking to other people who are interested in betting markets online, we were just speculating. We mostly talk about sports betting but the election was such a big topic in betting that you couldn't avoid it and I ended up getting sucked into it. I should have looked into it further, this has since been posted: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4756229 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4756229 I don't have much experience with Intrade, but there must be a way to dump data from the site and investigate the orders and buys being made. As that post says, putting down $1M to keep the odds more in line with a narrative of the contest being close is small change in the context of political spending today. I had two people tell me that rumor. One heard it via friends on Wall St and the other read it in another forum, IIRC. There must be something to explain the spread between Intrade and Betfair, that the market was being manipulated by those with a vested interest makes sense.
- tmister 14y agoNate's Prediction and actual results side by side http://twitter.com/cosentino/status/266042007758200832/photo/1 http://twitter.com/cosentino/status/266042007758200832/photo...
- pseut 14y agoSo, Nate Silver seems to deserve the even higher profile he'll have after this election, but his model is pretty explicitly not predicting the outcomes of any individual states. They're giving estimated probabilities of the various outcomes, and the (presumptive) outcome that happened was given a probability of ~20%, which was more likely than any other particular outcome, but a far cry from "calling the states." The big difference is that if this were to happen over and over again ("this" meaning that the most likely predicted outcome actually materializes), that would be (weak) evidence against his model -- if the model's right, he should "correctly call" the states only about 20% of the time. No more and no less. But good for him, because he's had a lot of unjustified criticism for the last month or so, so he's due some (slightly) unjustified praise.
- trhtrsh 14y agoHuh? http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/ http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/ "State-by-State Probabilities"
- pseut 14y agoDo any of them equal 1? Saying that >50% probability means that the model picks the state for Obama would be fine as a classification rule, but he's trying to estimate the probabilities, not forecast who will win. The ~20% comes from the electoral vote distribution, where you can back out the mix of states that gives 332 Electoral college votes.
- furyofantares 14y agoTake Florida, for example. He predicted a 50.3% chance of an Obama win. If Romney actually wins it, he's only a little bit wrong - counting him as 0/1 on Florida in this case wouldn't be accurate. If Obama wins it, he's only a little bit right - counting him as 1/1 on Florida here wouldn't be accurate. It's hard to quantify just how close he was. I give him props because his prediction was that Florida was very close and that turned out to be true no matter which way the state actually ends up going in the final result. Now take Virginia, which was one of the later states to be called. He had Obama at 79.4% chance to win. But it turned out to be reasonably close -- which makes me wonder if we really had enough data to justify such a large %. It's a highly polled state, so maybe we did and we just came somewhat close to hitting that 20% of the time where all the polling was inaccurate. Or maybe he had Obama's chances too high. Another way to judge a prediction model like this is to credit him with .794/1 for Virginia, rather that 1/1. For Florida he gets .503 if Obama wins, and .497 if Romney wins. That doesn't capture it perfectly, either, but at least it doesn't give him 0/1 in Florida if Romney wins even though he successfully predicted that the state was super close.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- programminggeek 14y agohttp://isnatesilverawitch.com/ http://isnatesilverawitch.com/
- keithvan 14y agoAhem, he would be a warlock.
- programminggeek 14y agoHe should have the right to self-identify as a witch if he wants. You have no right to take that away from him.
- TheGateKeeper 14y agoSelf identification is a ridiculous concept if it's not based on fact. They put people in the nut house for proclaiming they're a farm animal or Teddy Roosevelt.
- forensic 14y agoTransphobia in the software industry? Shocking
- TheGateKeeper 14y agoPhobia? Hardly. You don't call an ftp client and ssh client do you? Likewise you would and should never call a man a woman, unless you're tying to insult him and vice versa. It's called logic and not some ridiculous concept of accepting a mental disorder as something to be celebrated.
- forensic 14y ago"it's called logic" Actually, It's called not knowing what the fuck you're talking about The logical thing to do would be to educate yourself. P.S. trans people's brains objectively show non expected neural activation. And this is just one of the many ways for people to understand trans. It's a real thing and you need to EDUCATE YOURSELF instead of acting like bill oreilly. Ignorant asshole.
- paulsutter 14y agoNate Silver seems like a pretty smart guy, wouldn't it be better if he spent his time doing something more productive? Predicting the outcome of an election may have practical applications in gambling or for a hedge fund, and yes he gets mad publicity and attention from women sure, but aren't there more useful ways to apply statistics? EDIT: Haldean, your point is excellent and cancels out mine absolutely. Good thinking, you are entirely right. I would add that his attention and publicity itself should increase the credibility of rational analysis in the news, and that alone would be a great accomplishment.
- fourstar 14y agoPsh I think it's awesome and he's making statistics hawt right now. Gotta find your niche in something to make a name for yourself, anyway.
- hooande 14y agoTo his credit, he was wise enough to publish a book at just the time when people want to hear from him most. The downside of being the king of political prediction is that you're only popular once every four years. But you're really really popular, and he seems to be aware of and capitalizing on that.
- adestefan 14y agoIt's really every two years since he was one of the first that showed Republicans picking up big gains in the US House and governorships in 2010.
- haldean 14y agoInstead of thinking of him as a statistician who works for a newspaper, think of him as a statistically-minded journalist. I wish _more_ people did what he did: apply scientific reasoning to national and global issues.
- yen223 14y agoHe began his career predicting baseball scores, so I guess that's more useful?
- mamatta 14y agoquick image reference on Nate's predictions versus actual results: http://cl.ly/image/0744432U0S0L http://cl.ly/image/0744432U0S0L
- quangv 14y agoI'd love for him to go to past elections and see how well our political voting system works...
- the_cat_kittles 14y agoYou might like the economic sub discipline of "Social Choice Theory"
- ww520 14y agoHard cold numbers won again. The venom directed at Nate Silver before the election was astonishing. I guess the pundits had sensed their careers of predication were numbered and fought back hard, but Nate was proved right again. Kudos.
- rndmize 14y agoPerhaps this will lead to a greater interest in statistics and data in general politics and less in pundit opinions. Haha, who am I kidding...
- mkr-hn 14y agoThere will always be a market for uninformed jabbering. Pundits wouldn't worry if they looked at their own record.
- DanBC 14y agoIs there a "pundit prediction tracker" anywhere? Somewhere that tracks the predictions made by talking heads and shows how often they're right or wrong? > uninformed jabbering. And for informed jabbering. It's frustrating that analysis is being replaced with opinion, especially when it's clear that opinion driven prediction is garbage.
- mkr-hn 14y agoI found a couple of things that look useful at a glance (I googled for pundit prediction tracker): http://www.pundittracker.com/ http://www.pundittracker.com/ http://nymag.com/daily/intel/2012/11/exhaustive-collection-of-pundit-predictions.html http://nymag.com/daily/intel/2012/11/exhaustive-collection-o... I remember hearing about Pundit Tracker before it launched, but I didn't look into it after that.
- a_bonobo 14y agoDoesn't that destroy the allegations of voting fraud in the US? (Not a US-citizen here) If there was widespread fraud with the voting machines as alleged elsewhere, the voting outcome should have diverged widely from the predictions. The predictions are so close to the actual outcome, and because from what I understand the predictions are mostly based on polling, there couldn't have been much fraud, or am I wrong? Flippant edit: Assuming of course that Nate Silver wasn't in on the fraud and didn't adjust his predictions accordingly.
- jlgreco 14y agoAlternatively, it just suggests that people who engage in voter fraud tend to suck at it.
- mseebach2 14y agoNot on it's own, no. At most, is shows that fraud wasn't widespread enough (or equally widespread on both sides) to skew the election away from the will of the people. Also, fraud is much more effective in smaller races - of which there are lot, many of them too small to have as good poll coverage as the presidential one - so if there is fraud, those races are probably where to look for it.
- espeed 14y agoIn 2004 there was evidence of voting fraud in Ohio -- the exit polls weren't matching the results (http://whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/2004votefraud_ohio.html http://whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/2004votefraud_ohio...). Bush won Ohio, which helped him win the election by the narrowest of margins. Ohio used Diebold electronic voting machines, and Diebold's CEO Walden W. O'Dell was a long-time Bush loyalist. Later it was confirmed that Diebold voting machines could be hacked remotely (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3045086 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3045086). So yes, being able to create an independent, accurate model will add another layer of verification and will hopefully help keep voting fraud in check.
- dkrich 14y agoI've got to say that I've been a cynical admirer of Silver since the last election. Why cynical? Because I began to notice throughout the Republican nomination process that his observations varied wildly on which Republican candidate presented great values on intrade. I think over time he gave a nod to every candidate, save Michelle Bachmann, Tim Pawlenty, and John Huntsmann. From the outset, Romney was the favorite to win, and not surprisingly, he won. But throughout the nomination process where much less was known, many of his projections proved to be wrong. So despite all of the contrarian opinion on which candidates may pull it out against popular opinion (or perception) these faded away until Romney was the clear favorite, Silver predicted him to win, and eventually he carried the nomination. Once in the Presidential election, Obama was the favorite. Incumbent Presidents rarely lose, and Mitt Romney was not exactly a compelling candidate. All that said, he's clearly a brilliant dude, and I give him a lot of respect for the accuracy of his predictions. I just haven't found them to be hugely useful for any practical purposes. I guess people tend to be enamored by the things they don't understand (statistical analysis), and I don't think there's anything wrong with that.
- cdf 14y agoNate Silver claims to be a statistician, not a clairvoyant. While there is a sense of inevitability of Romney's nomination, I think it is obvious that the Republican voters agree with you that he is not a compelling candidate and were desperately looking for alternatives, and as each candidate wilted in the spotlight, they kept moving on to the next, and polling numbers reflected that, and Nate Silver was merely reporting that shift.
- dkrich 14y agoSo is that at all at odds with what I said? I'm saying that I haven't found his predictions to be useful because they have not correctly predicted anything that I myself didn't predict with the same information without any statistical analysis. Sure, he predicted it with 3% greater accuracy. So what? Sadly what makes most elections predictable is how shitty the candidates are on one side. To be fair I don't think that a statistical analysis will ever be useful in an election unless the election is absolutely a dead heat. Most elections for the past several years (with the obvious exception of 2000) have been fairly predictable from the outset.
- epaga 14y agoEven with an incredibly exact model, to actually get ALL 50 right really does require a lot of luck in addition to skill. Even if he's 98% accurate for each state (which seems amazingly high to me), that's still only a 1 in 3 chance to get all 50 right.
- shalmanese 14y agoHe really only got 7/7 right. The other 43 states were not really in contention.
- crntaylor 14y agoIt's clearly great work by Nate and the rest of the 538 team. However, as has been pointed out, it's not that hard to build a model that gets close to predicting everything correctly. I built a model in a couple of hours on Sunday afternoon, which simply takes all the most recent polling data, takes an average, does a quick fudge to adjust for the number of polls, and then runs 10,000 simulations to get a probability for each state. The source is on Github: https://github.com/chris-taylor/USElection and the predictions are in this gist: https://gist.github.com/4012793 The result? My model gets 50/51 correct if Florida eventually goes DEM (which looks likely) or 51/51 correct if Florida goes REP. -- Edit: full disclosure - with all data up to 6 Nov 20120 it predicts Colorado to be a toss-up, and I manually broke the tie in favour of Democrats, based on earlier models favouring them in that state.
- chaz 14y agoNice work. The success, though, isn't his specific model. It's that Silver was able to market the idea that using statistical models is better than a table full of talking heads at predicting an outcome. And that a "dead heat" doesn't mean it's a coin flip. In hindsight, it seems almost ludicrous that it hasn't gained greater traction before. He deserves a ton of credit for championing analytics into pop/political culture, but I'm sure we'll see many more models and a lot more statisticians during the next election, some of which will be better than Silver's models (if he's still doing them). I'm all for people asking to see the data instead of the media sound bites. To keep this HN relevant: it was the marketing that drove his startup success. The product (the model) isn't quite perfect and an excellent substitute product was created by someone else in very short order (you). But he put together a great blog, grew out his brand, and eventually saw hockey stick growth.
- crntaylor 14y agoYep, I agree with this. I really built the model for fun, just to see how close it was possible to get with a few hours work. A lot of forecasting problems have a structure like this one did: - There is a lot of publically available data, and simple statistical models based on that data give pretty good predictions with very little effort. - If you're an expert with a lot of time on your hands, you can put a lot of effort into improving the forecasts by 1-2%. - In the end, it comes down to the effective business use of your model. Nate Silver had an excellent brand around his model. In fact, I'd wager that he knows his model is more complex than it needs to be, but part of his brand is "rogue genius with a complex model that's far too difficult for mere mortals to understand".
- brianchu 14y agoKeep in mind, however, that we could not have expected Nate Silver's own model to predict 50/50 states. Given that Nate predicted that there was a 50.3% chance that Florida would go to Obama, the only difference between this being a story of predicting 50/50 states and this being a story of missing at least one state is a coin toss. The reasons his model turned out to be 100% accurate is sheer luck.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Kurtz79 14y agoI think it's realatively easy, for a smart guy with a solid understandings of statistics to come up with a reasonable model (weight polls by sample size, come up with probability distribution for each state, run x Monte Carlo simulations and take the average of the result...). But a thing is coming up with a good model, another is to defend it publicly putting your reputation on the line, while it would have been a much safer bet simply to say 'it's too close to call', as many so-called experts did. Full credit to Nate, he made math cool for a lot of people.
- brownbat 14y agoDoesn't that mean he undercalibrated some of his predictions? If you say 50 events should happen with a 60% probability, and they all happen, shouldn't you have upped your confidence? That said, since most his naysayers were saying he was OVERconfident at the time, kudos to him for proving them wrong.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jmduke 14y agoSuch extrapolations are really tough -- keep in mind, for each state we only have results with a sample size of 1.
- monk_the_dog 14y agoIf the predictions are independent, then I agree with you. I can think of reason why they would not be independent (trying to account for non-random polling samples, for example).
- 3JPLW 14y agoThey aren't independent. The developer of the 512 paths to the White House lamented this in getting conditional probabilities into the path choices. The simulations take into account the national popular vote polls and similar-state demographics (if one state goes one way, it's more likely that a similar one will, too). Look at his EV histogram; 332 EVs had the highest probability of occurrence at nearly 20%. While there are other ways to get to 332, I'd imagine most of that percentage is from a map like last night. That's clearly not the partial probability of each state multiplied together.
- k2enemy 14y agoI wonder if having such good predictions is ultimately harmful to the democratic process? If I were only voting on the presidential election, I would not have bothered going to the polls because my state was solidly on one side and the chance of my vote being pivotal was basically zero. But some of our local elections were less certain, so I went for those. As the prediction models get better, get applied to local elections, and get more publicity, I wonder what it will do to people's incentive to vote? I'm much more likely to go out and cast my vote when the outcome is uncertain and I think I have a chance of being the pivotal vote. But if super accurate forecasts tell me my vote won't matter, then maybe I won't bother standing in line for an hour.
- pfortuny 14y agoWhen the incentive of the people changes, then the outcome will change as well.
- Spooky23 14y agoIt's a little much to claim that this guy called it. The minor detail of actually conducting the polling was done by others.
- Tuna-Fish 14y agoThe point isn't that Silver is some superhuman guessing machine. The point is that Silver explicitly did nothing particularly special over applying sound statistics over publicly available data, came out with very different predictions than the traditional media did, took a lot of flak from them for it, and turned out to be exactly correct in every meaningful way. 538 is a statement against the traditional election coverage, in effect saying that math is better than pseudo-objective talking head bullshit. From his blog: Nevertheless, these arguments are potentially more intellectually coherent than the ones that propose that the leader in the race is “too close to call.” It isn’t. If the state polls are right, then Mr. Obama will win the Electoral College. If you can’t acknowledge that after a day when Mr. Obama leads 19 out of 20 swing-state polls, then you should abandon the pretense that your goal is to inform rather than entertain the public. http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/11/03/nov-2-for-romney-to-win-state-polls-must-be-statistically-biased/ http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/11/03/nov-2-fo... This is why the more math-literate portions of the internet have erupted with cheers for Silver.
- danielweber 14y agoand turned out to be exactly correct in every meaningful way. Silver himself wouldn't call his predictions correct. He was not making thumbs-up v thumbs-down predictions. When he said "60% chance of Obama winning this state," it means that 6 times out of 10 Obama would win and 4 times out of 10 Romney would win. If Obama won all 10 times, by his own account he would be wrong.
- Wilduck 14y ago> it means that 6 times out of 10 Obama would win and 4 times out of 10 Romney would win. If Obama won all 10 times, by his own account he would be wrong. That's a very frequentist perspective. I think the Bayesian interpretation is a little more sensible. Given a prior estimate, updated with the information we have, it is logical to assume that Obama has a better chance of winning. That is, Nate Silver's 60% doesn't mean that if the election in a given state were repeated, we'd see different results four times out of 10, but rather that his information in making the prediction was incomplete.
- Codhisattva 14y agoSilver affirms that public opinion polling is accurate - as long as you know how to read the data. Not to diminish Silver's work - I'm just saying the data he uses needs to be accurate in order for his models to be accurate.
- elbac 14y agoI'd like to see Nate run the numbers which would point to districts where there were statistical anomalies on the lookout for election funny business.
- caycep 14y agowhat is the technique he is using? is it something like a generalized linear mixed model? (i.e. like using R's lme4 module)?
- alexmr 14y agoI'd like to see the comparison for -90,-60,-30,-15 days from election too.