10 ms·
Waymo seeking about $16B near $110B valuation
- mankyd 10mo agohttps://archive.is/asQ2x https://archive.is/asQ2x
- fnord77 10mo ago> The parent company would provide about $13 billion to the robotaxi firm, while the rest would come from others, including new investors ... No IPO for us little people
- kolbe 10mo agoWhat would you add to the company as an investor?
- WarmWash 10mo agoProbably money
- lotsofpulp 10mo agoAlphabet is already a publicly listed company. Just buy more Alphabet shares if you want to invest in Waymo.
- thundergolfer 10mo agoI presume if you invest in Google you are indirectly (but significantly) invested in Waymo, like it is with Anthropic? Waymo is the best service I've used in many, many years. The jump from Uber->Waymo is similar to the quality jump from Taxi->Uber 12 years ago, but I don't see an obvious way for Waymo to get enshittified.
- bryanlarsen 10mo agoThis is Google you're talking about. They're an ads+AI company. They'll figure out a way to enshittify, even if it's not obvious.
- crazygringo 10mo agoGoogle has a $4.1T market cap. So a $110B valuation is not currently that significant in terms of exposure. It's only 2.7% of it overall.
- thundergolfer 10mo agoFair, though my guess is that the growth rate of Waymo's market cap will far exceed Google's as Waymo scales. I wish I could invest in Waymo, so I'll take that 2.7% exposure.
- doctoboggan 10mo ago> I don't see an obvious way for Waymo to get enshittified. Oh ye of little faith! Here are some ideas off the top of my head, I am sure the suits at Google already have a bigger list. * Ads in vehicle * Adjust route so you see partner companies or billboards * Offering alternative destinations (I see you are going to Burger King, would you rather go to our partner McDonalds?) * Listening to conversations in car * Selling ride data.
- dotBen 10mo agoThey already will be selling your ride data and there is no way they could monitor conversations in the car for commercial purposes (at least in Western countries). Ads in cars, partnerships with alternative destinations, etc. definitely would feel like enshitification for a demographic comparable to the hacker news one here. But these are all per session/user settings just like most of us have a paid Spotify account and never see advertising and those who don't get a very different monetized experience. What is exciting about monetization like this is the possibility for rides to become very cheap or even free. If my dentist offers free rides to the office in return for my loyalty, I'm quite happy to take that.
- lotsofpulp 10mo ago> and there is no way they could monitor conversations in the car for commercial purposes (at least in Western countries). Why not? You can consent to having your audio recorded. They can even offer a higher “private” price and a lower “ad supported” price. I write “private” because I assume the microphones will always be listening no matter which price you pay.
- dotBen 10mo agoI guess that's semantics. If you opt in then yes I guess they could do anything. I think the point was that enshitification would occur if they forced you to do that. You could opt in to have blood or plasma taken on every ride if you so wanted I guess.
- ai-x 10mo agoGoogle's marketcap moves by Waymo's entire marketcap in a single day.
- pandemic_region 10mo ago"Please watch these ads before we start the ride. Any attempt to not look at the ads by looking away from the screen or closing your eyes will automatically cancel the ride."
- floxy 10mo agohttps://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=http%3A%2F%2Ftheawesomedaily.com%2Fwp-content%2Fuploads%2F2017%2F02%2Fbest-of-4chan-4good-1.png&f=1&nofb=1&ipt=772e04d56600578f5bd4da15abd1ba7fd8c4d3c489868f4f0ece18c190f91a3a https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=http%3A%2F%2Ft...
- g947o 10mo ago> I don't see an obvious way for Waymo to get enshittified. Raise the price?
- mbb70 10mo agoEnshittification is a technique to make more money _without_ raising the price by simply making the product worse. Self-driving taxis have a high floor for 'making the product worse' because the car fundamentally has to drive itself.
- sowbug 10mo agoIt appears that enshittification has joined exponential and literally as words that used to mean specific things but are now just generic intensifiers.
- ronnier 10mo ago> but I don't see an obvious way for Waymo to get enshittified My guess is that once Waymo starts to extremely take off, law makers in various cities will start to pass laws to ban them or the number of regulations will make it impossible to run at a profit. This will almost certainly happen. It will disproportionately impact an entire segment of the population and will put them out of work.
- estearum 10mo agoNo they won't. The product is so outrageously superior on every dimension to the status quo that municipalities will figure out whatever they need to in order to accommodate them. You think the folks on City Council enjoy chauffeuring their own children around and will block a solution to it?
- ronnier 10mo agoYes. It's already happening https://www.reddit.com/r/Minneapolis/comments/1pdzd2f/some_minneapolis_city_council_members_want_to/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Minneapolis/comments/1pdzd2f/some_m...
- thinkmassive 10mo agoIn Virginia too, proposed in HB1124: > The bill prohibits the use of autonomous vehicles as motor carriers of passengers or property without a human operator who (i) meets any state and federal qualifications for the operation of an autonomous vehicle; (ii) is physically present in such autonomous vehicle; and (iii) has the ability to monitor the performance of such vehicle and intervene in the operation of such vehicle, including operating such vehicle without the use of the automated driving system and stopping and turning off such vehicle if necessary. https://lis.virginia.gov/bill-details/20261/HB1124 https://lis.virginia.gov/bill-details/20261/HB1124
- tanseydavid 10mo agoIf they prohibit autonomous vehicles, eventually their constituencies will be screaming for it. It seems that many people, after trying out the service for themselves first hand, in a locale that has it available today, are very eager to have the service available to them in their home locale.
- re-thc 10mo ago> I presume if you invest in Google you are indirectly (but significantly) invested in Waymo, like it is with Anthropic? You also get some Starlink.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 10mo agoThe obvious way such services enshittify is to become a monopoly by pushing everyone else out, then cranking up the prices (and lowering quality, e.g. by not cleaning the vehicles, longer wait times for better utilization, etc.)
- pm90 10mo agoWhy does Google need outside investors? Is it a play to get a “serious” valuation since it would be vetted by outside parties? I guess Im questioning why Waymo doesn’t just IPO, or raise 100% private raise by Google.
- andsoitis 10mo agoCompanies raise money for big projects all the time. From issuing debt, to issuing equity.
- kolbe 10mo agoHe's talking specifically about Waymo's situation. Alplabet, a company who has $75bn of FCF, owns 80% of Waymo. A $16bn capital injection is meaningless to Alphabet, so he's wondering why they're going through the trouble. He raises a good point, and the answer is likely that they can run into legal issues by either under or overvaluing the company in a capital raise where they're the controlling shareholder, then the IRS or existing investors have grounds for a lawsuit (or audit). They likely just want to bring the capital raise out in the open to get a fair market value, and then they will be 90% of the capital in the raise.
- dotBen 10mo agoIt's a very capital intensive operation given the amount of vehicles that need to be carried on the balance sheet. There are many reasons why a conglomerate like Alphabet doesn't want to hold all of that directly on the balance sheet, which is why Waymo is run as a subsidiary with its own sources of capital. When I was at Uber 10 plus years ago and we were ideating autonomous vehicles. The general consensus was that we would run the technology platform and private equity would own fleets of cars built and operated to our specification. Waymo has concluded either we are too early in the journey to decouple the tight vertical integration or they want to go very big and own all of the capital expenditure for what will presumably be a global rollout ultimately. For anyone like me with a finance and technology crossover interest I actually think this is as interesting, maybe more interesting, than the private equity play around data centers at the moment because all of that is constrained against chip delivery and power constraints.
- copilot_king 10mo ago[dead]
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- b33j0r 10mo agoJust don’t take one if another one is operating nearby. If they see another waymo, having passed the insecure emotional Turing test, they get self-conscious and wander the neighborhood backstreets until the other one has dropped off its passengers. (Just experienced this multiple times in Phoenix. It’s impressive at navigating and braking, but not rational planning or flocking.)
- Kique 10mo agoThis has not been my experience at all and I take Waymos pretty frequently, especially at popular areas like concerts or airports you'll see a bunch of them dropping off/picking up people without issues.
- simianwords 10mo agowhy is Tesla much higher? I thought Tesla's market cap was because of the self driving feature.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 10mo agoThe only semi rational thing that could explain it is the robots.
- sorenjan 10mo agoIt's always the next big thing. It used to be self driving, now it's AI and robots.
- everforward 10mo agoI don’t even think that’s rational, but it may be what’s propping them up. Last earnings call Musk said Optimus wasn’t doing “meaningful work” at Tesla and as far as I’m aware they haven’t done meaningful work anywhere. I think they’re behind the curve there. Figure AI recently finished an apparently successful feasibility trial of their humanoid robots with BMW and Boston Dynamics has a deal with Hyundai for their Atlas humanoid robots. I’m not even convinced humanoid robots are going to pan out in general. They only really make sense in a scenario where you’re back porting robotics to factories built for humans. That has value but feels temporary; factories designed to be robotic feel like the future, and there’s no need for them to do the job the same way a human would.
- philipwhiuk 10mo ago> Boston Dynamics has a deal with Hyundai for their Atlas humanoid robots Slightly depressing that we're back to replacing the big industrial robots rather than new markets.
- everforward 10mo agoI _think_ these are meant to replace humans working alongside the industrial robots rather than the big industrial robots themselves. I don’t work in manufacturing though, and the press releases are too buzzword-y for me to grasp the actual tasks they’re going to do. I would guess the long term strategy is to do this for economies of scale and then push into new markets opened up by the lower price point. I would guess these are horribly expensive right now, given something like Spot is way simpler and still like $40k
- jFriedensreich 10mo agoNo product had such a fast transition from novelty to "omg i never want to interact with a human again". I feel about 100% less stressed and happier using a waymo or riding motorbike or bicycle next to a waymo than with human drivers. I hope this next phase will bring availability and prices down. We need this in europe.
- locknitpicker 10mo ago> No product had such a fast transition from novelty to "omg i never want to interact with a human again". I still recall when taxi services were the only offering, and Uber et al were marketed as ride sharing services instead of ride hailing services. It's hard to put into words the transformative effect that ride hailing services had throughout the world. Overall rides are now far safer and more reliable, to the point where the old days feel like the dark ages.
- lazarus01 10mo agoIm fortunate to live in an area dense with traditional taxis and Ubers, no Waymo yet. I rarely take taxis, the exception is when I have to haul my gear to the studio for a jam session. I always take a taxi, because it’s cheaper and faster than using an app to call an uber. On 80% of the trips, I end up having a nice chat with the driver and learn something new about humanity or myself. I really enjoy these interactions, but I feel for the drivers, it’s a very tough job where most taxi drivers have to scramble to find places to urinate or do so in an empty bottle between their legs. There is not much dignity in the job. I feel a negligible segment enjoy it as a reliable career. I wonder what will happen to the drivers if a large representation of the 1 million+ daily trips are displaced by automation?
- irl_zebra 10mo agoI love, love, love Waymo and am so excited about their success. Uber and Lyft were the heroes for a while, but became the villains. If Waymo is available anywhere I need a cab, that is absolutely my first choice, even for the premium cost.
- OsrsNeedsf2P 10mo agoSame. I can't wait for Waymo to reach Fremont; the thought of going to and from SFO in a Waymo that doesn't tip guilt me would be wild.
- echelon 10mo agoI can't wait to subscribe to Waymo (or any reasonable provider) for personal cars. It's one thing to call an Uber. It's another to pack your car for a road trip to the beach or mountains. Waymo is going to make vacationing even bigger than it already is. It'll be easy, especially for remote workers. Van life with a Waymo is a whole new thing.
- pu_pe 10mo agoIt seems like a fair valuation to me. I can see a path for them to approach or surpass Uber's revenue (~$50B) in the future, and I think their technology and brand are actual moats in comparison to all other driverless systems out there.
- wasmainiac 10mo agoSure, but not for a while since there is a lot of hardware to pay for and maintain.
- paxys 10mo agoI'm in the opposite camp. Waymo has neat tech, yes, but already valuing it on par with Uber is absurd considering the sheer scale at which Uber operates. 70 countries, 15K cities, 36 million daily trips. And this isn't counting Uber Eats and other side businesses. Waymo will have to accelerate its operations to the max for the next decade just to catch up. And that's assuming operating at such a scale is even possible considering they have to provide and maintain their own (very expensive) fleet. And this isn't a brand new market - Uber + local taxi companies have already set a hard cap on prices that Waymo cannot cross.
- pu_pe 10mo agoThere is no doubt they have a lot of catching up to do, but you have to consider their advantages. If Uber goes away, Lyft or others can take over the entire market overnight, precisely because they don't have their own fleet or unique technology. Waymo is placing itself as first mover into a completely new category of transportation which will require capital investment and new tech, so it will be much harder to displace once it gets going. It could target automated cargo transport in the future too.
- remus 10mo agoNo doubt there are significant challenges along the way, but waymo has a real product powered by tech that actually works which could massively change a huge industry. They're also notably more mature than competitors, and have track record of successfully rolling out in a safe way.
- wasmainiac 10mo agoWow that is headline carnage. What does it mean? Edit: there is a paywall in my country. Why downvotes? I’m just curious.
- zamadatix 10mo agoHN in a bit odd when it comes to paywells. You're not allowed to complain about them and everyone reading is individually expected to figure out how to access the content (which usually involves finding a top comment linking to a workaround for everyone or the usual users all going with their preferred tools silently). https://archive.is/Lh2QY https://archive.is/Lh2QY
- lapetitejort 10mo agoI do not think driverless will solve the main transportation problem we are dealing with as a society: we are giving up more space for cars, space that humans cannot use. We build more highways, widen roads, increase speed limits, and expect humans to stay out of this space. I live in a 100+ year old neighborhood. The roads were built for horse and buggy and streetcars. Now I have to beg to cross the road. My neighborhood has been effectively chopped up. I question whether I should walk to another block because I'll have to deal with crossing the street. Quiet houses now have the constant buzz of cars either from the ever-present highways or from the 40+ mph traffic right outside their doors. Driverless cars will not solve these problems. Fewer kids will die, partially from safe software, but mostly because they won't be able to leave their bubble without being strapped down into a car.
- guywithahat 10mo agoIn my experience if I want to living in a bikable/walkable/transit oriented area, I have to move there. I think expecting this sort of stuff to come to you is too much, especially since most city centers have good transit options. That said this is a tech forum, and while I don't think Waymo will be the only solution the tech is quite impressive and it's likely going to change how society works. Most people don't want to take public transit, they want to take a car and this is a much better solution for them. Forcing people to bike when they don't want to seems like bad form imo.
- DauntingPear7 10mo agoForcing people to take and buy and own and maintain a car since hundreds of billions have been spent on that mode of transit, but near zero (in comparison) on any other seems like bad form imo
- kccqzy 10mo agoNo one here should realistically think that Waymo can solve the main transportation problem. It will just (partially) replace Uber, Lyft, and taxis. And it will have a better passenger experience and it will also be safer. It’s obvious that cars, autonomous or not, can’t replace rail, bicycles, and walking.
- jeffbee 10mo agoFWIW Waymo may have been "seeking" this deal when Bloomberg wrote that article but FT reports that it's already closed.
- devmor 10mo agoAs someone who lives in a city with a lot of Waymos (Atlanta), I do not understand why anyone considers these things more than an early test or a novelty. From an outside perspective, they're constantly obstructing traffic and driving in erratic and confusing ways. It's gotten to a point that if I see one ahead of me, I'll turn down the next block and change my route to avoid being behind it and dealing with whatever slowdown its about to cause. I took one once via Uber with some coworkers and it was also jarring to ride in. I'd rather take my chances with a random human.
- devmor 10mo agoI must follow this up with today’s anecdote - heading home far later than usual from Midtown, stuck behind a Waymo in light traffic, inexplicably going 20 in a 35 with no one in front of it for nearly a mile. I loathe these things, they’re like automated drunk drivers.
- neom 10mo agoI'm pretty sure this is the first big post about Waymo on HN, the comments are fun to read: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13168888 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13168888 :)
- onetokeoverthe 10mo ago[dead]
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]