6 ms·
SoftBank in talks to invest up to $30B more in OpenAI
- redrix 10mo agohttps://archive.md/uc1G9 https://archive.md/uc1G9
- Ronsenshi 10mo agoSo, about 2 years worth of operations based on alleged $14 billion burn rate projected for 2026. What an absurd amount of money - if only this was invested in energy sector scientific research and development, or healthcare or anything else practical. I really hoped to see compact molten salt nuclear reactors in operation before 2030.
- ActionHank 10mo agoTo be fair Softbank really likes to invest in lemons, so you know, let them do what brings them joy. Love this for them.
- bix6 10mo ago> if only this was invested in energy sector scientific research and development, or healthcare or anything else practical. Haven’t you heard? AGI is going to solve every problem for us!!!
- mekdoonggi 10mo ago"Solving" problems is useless. Spending trillions building a robot that might be able to solve a problem is way better.
- lumost 10mo agoThis .. doesn't seem like such a terrible deal? At the purported growth rates, you'd expect OpenAI to reach 60-100 billion revenue by 2028. This is more or less the equivalent of building a new AWS. Provided they keep cost growth slower than revenue and don't get disrupted by another model provider/commodification etc.
- CodingJeebus 10mo ago> At the purported growth rates, you'd expect OpenAI to reach 60-100 billion revenue by 2028. I hope that’s “real” revenue and not the cyclic quid pro quo that seems to be propping the whole thing up.
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- an0malous 10mo ago“My 3-month-old son is now TWICE as big as when he was born. He's on track to weigh 7.5 trillion pounds by age 10”
- joe_mamba 10mo agoYour son could reach the age of 10 in 5 weeks using our agentic SaaS product.
- gjsman-1000 10mo agoNonsense. To give you a sense about how much $100B in revenue is, that would be the equivalent of every person in the United States paying $25/mo. Obviously that’s not happening, so how many businesses can and will pay far more than that, when there’s also Anthropic and Gemini offerings?
- evilduck 10mo ago> when there’s also Anthropic and Gemini offerings? For average people the global competitors are putting up near identical services at 1/10th the cost. Anthropic and Google and OpenAI may have a corporate sales advantage about their security and domestic alignment, or being 5% better at some specific task but the populace at large isn't going to cough up $25 for that difference. Beyond the first month or two of the novelty phase it's not apparent the average person is willing to pay for AI services at all.
- oefrha 10mo ago> $14 billion Incidentally that’s how much SoftBank lost on WeWork.
- NickC25 10mo agoYou're not counting the money they paid to Adam Neumann to walk away, which was over a billion dollars as well. Imagine doing what was effectively fraud, building a cult around you, everything going completely to the fan, and then the team you defrauded turns around and gives you a billion dollars. And then, you get Marc Andreesen to write you a $350 million check not too long after.
- agumonkey 10mo ago2020s ai could be the first systemic stall I see. Let's assume agentic could really be a force for improvement but the cost model is unsustainable and will choke.
- amelius 10mo agoI suppose the idea is that the LLMs will invent the compact molten salt nuclear reactors. Double win.
- forinti 10mo agoThat's just magical thinking. And Ethiopia couldn't get US$5 billion loan for a dam to service 60 million people. The world is sick.
- iinnPP 10mo agoOut of curiosity, what personal blight have you faced to better the world?
- kurthr 10mo agoLLMs will create the pitch deck for molten salt reactors, provide progress reports, plans, and documentation, accept payment for delivery, and disappear into the night.
- android521 10mo agowhy are you obsessed with how other people allocate their money?
- serf 10mo ago>why are you obsessed with how other people allocate their money? I suggest you stop viewing the actions of multi billion dollar multinational corporations as anything similar to individual action.
- ForHackernews 10mo agoBecause Softbank are really bad at it, and they have lots of it. https://www.reuters.com/business/softbanks-wework-once-most-valuable-us-startup-succumbs-bankruptcy-2023-11-07/ https://www.reuters.com/business/softbanks-wework-once-most-...
- lotsofpulp 10mo agoHow did they get it?
- ForHackernews 10mo agoGot lucky on Yahoo! Japan in the 1990s.
- lotsofpulp 10mo agoWikipedia says Alibaba was their big win. And then they convinced the Saudis to let them bet with Saudi money. They also have decent net income trends: https://companiesmarketcap.com/softbank/earnings/ https://companiesmarketcap.com/softbank/earnings/ Either way, seems like enough of their bets work out, so far. https://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2014/09/19/softbanks-alibaba-alchemy-how-to-turn-20-million-into-50-billion/ https://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2014/09/19/softbanks-alibaba-al...
- Ronsenshi 10mo agoWhat made you think that I'm "obsessed" with how other people spend money?
- trhway 10mo agoA major cost in building and operating datacenters is energy, so it does mean that significant share of those money would go into energy development. Large demand is one of the best things for stimulating technology development, and in this case we'd definitely see investment in solar and compact/safer nuclear of which MSRs are a part of. xAI already brings gas turbines on-site, and i think the trend of on-site energy generation will grow, which will open opportunity (by providing well finaned demand) for compact/mobile/safer nuclear, and BigTech companies are among the best for any new tech development. I expect nuclear engineer positions get opened with Google and the likes :)
- josu 10mo ago> invested in (...) anything else practical. I don't understand how this is the top comment. LLMs have unlocked a lot of value for me personally, and arguably for the society as a whole. They are also one of the coolest technologies I've tried in years. As a technologist, I'm really glad that money is pouring in and allowing us to find its limits.
- mekdoonggi 10mo agoNot sure if this is the same sentiment, but I feel that even though the technology is handy, the investment is speculation. Billions and billions are being spent on developing this technology hoping to create a unicorn that turns billions into trillions. I know it's unrealistic, but imagine you took $30b and just started ploughing into a random city. Real estate, development grants, EV charging infra, renewable projects, transit. Just boring existing technology, but concentrated investment to make the other investments more valuable. You could turn that $30b into $60b in a few years while changing the lives of an entire city. But American capital says no, and gambles it, because it's just a game to the people in charge. Money is responsibility. While I pinch my pennies and show up to my day job, the people with the keys throw billions on an oil fire hoping it magically turns into gold.
- bigbadfeline 10mo ago> LLMs have unlocked a lot of value for me personally, and arguably for the society as a whole. The second part doesn't follow from the first which, in turn, is irrelevant here because we aren't talking about any value for society, we're trying to figure out if that value is greater than its opportunity cost. The "AI" has been with us for several years now but it hasn't improved overall productivity in any meaningful way and while it's use is already plateauing it keeps sucking in capital like a giant black hole. > As a technologist, I'm really glad that money is pouring in and allowing us to find its limits. That's not a good thing when it happens at the expense of the rest of society. It's only natural that workers at NVIDIA and other suppliers of AI-related products would like the gravy train to travel their way in perpetuity, but they are literally wasting capital, which isn't theirs, for their own enrichment, while creating inflation, shortages and misallocations on a grand scale.
- 10mo ago
- trolleski 10mo agoI think it should be 70 billion, scratch that, 125 billion, scratch that - 180 trillion. I'd rather have pictures of crocodile Trump on the Moon than a warm house, scratch that, rather than kids, scratch that, rather than any decent future at all. Great move, guys, can't get enough of it.
- captain_coffee 10mo agoSo ... will the crash be bigger that the one causing The Great Depression or smaller? Any bets?
- rvz 10mo agoBefore 2030, especially if the frontier AI labs begin to IPO before then.
- mhitza 10mo agoI'm really eager to see how Anthropic's IPO this year (if it even happens) will pan out.
- CodingJeebus 10mo agoThe Great Depression saw 25% unemployment and a third of farmers losing their land. Millions could die if it gets that bad today.
- lifetimerubyist 10mo agoThis sounds good to the "earth is overpopulated" crowd.
- zvqcMMV6Zcr 10mo agoNot even close. The 2008 financial crisis is better comparison. And even then I think most negative effect will come from investors pulling money away from everything non-AI, than OpenAI/Anthropic/Oracle crashing and burning.
- Ekaros 10mo agoIs this pre or post hyperinflation 30 billion? As things might be heading there and that might make a difference.
- randomtoast 10mo ago> as part of the startup’s [OpenAI's] efforts to raise up to $100 billion At this stage, why not go public? Yes, they would need to manage quarterly financial reports and answer to shareholders, but they have reached a size where they are in the top 20 range on the NASDAQ. These public companies doing well, so it seems like a logical next step.
- zpeti 10mo agoI actually think the public markets have a lot less faith in openai than softbank does. They need these crazy investors. Public markets would not value openai at $1.4trn. So they can't go public. It would reveal how bad things are.
- disgruntledphd2 10mo agoI used to hold this theory, but apparently Anthropic are planning to IPO, and surely both of them would be valued similarly? Anthropic don't have all the free users, but they're also raising absurd amounts and have similar costs.
- edoceo 10mo agoThe reporting creates "transparency" - there are 1000s of analyst ready to pounce on this (with AI assistant). What skeletons would they find?
- dgrin91 10mo agoI think they are still crazy r&d heavy, which it's not what investors like to hear. Investor pressure would make them stagnate from r&d side On the other hand they would probably set things up in a way where they still control all the voting power
- randomtoast 10mo agoOkay, but I don't think we can call OpenAI a startup until it has reached the number one spot on NASDAQ with a $5 trillion valuation. Therefore, I believe now is a good time to focus on more realistic fundamentals, rather than fueling the hype by burning even more cash on the way to the absolute top, which is typical bubble mentality.
- hnthrow0287345 10mo agoI'm pretty sure I could become a billionaire just by meeting Masayoshi Son and having a chat for 15 minutes. I've never seen a better case for a fool and his money being parted.
- randomtoast 10mo agoThat may be true, but in order to meet Masayoshi Son, you have to be a billionaire to begin with.
- hnthrow0287345 10mo agoI'm a billionaire in EVE Online, and even though that counts for nothing, it'd still be enough for him
- rvnx 10mo agoIt can be also just a trade part of a deal; like in YC companies, where investor Y buys company A from investor Z, and in exchange investor Z buys company B from investor Y, so the choo-choo train keeps running.
- lifetimerubyist 10mo agohahahah, have fun with that
- libraryofbabel 10mo agoAll of these things can be simultaneously true (and I would say, are true): 1) We are in a huge investment bubble right now and it's going to burst. 2) LLMs are extremely useful right now for certain niche tasks, especially software engineering. 3) LLMs have the potential to transform our world long-term (~10 yr horizon), on the order of the transformations wrought by the internet and mobile. 4) LLM's don't lead directly to AGI (no continuous learning), and we're not getting AGI any time soon. This is an extremely obvious point, but bears repeating. I feel the assumption of an implicit link (in both truth or falsehood) between these fairly independent assertions can cause people to talk past each other about the really important questions in play here. Regarding The Great Bubble, I am very very bearish about OpenAI in particular. They've had a good run for three years with consumer mindshare due to their first-mover advantage, but they have no moat, trouble monetizing most of their users, not much luck building out products that stick among consumers that aren't chatbots, and their models are no better than Anthropic's, Google's, or even the best Chinese open weight models 6 months later. My bet would be on Google and Apple together (with Gemini powering Siri, for now) destroying OpenAI in the consumer AI market over the next 2-3 years. Google has first-rate models... but more than that, both Google and Apple have the enormous advantage of owning underlying platforms that they can use to put their own AI chat in front of consumers. Google has a mobile OS, the leading browser, and search. Apple has the premium hardware and the other, premium, mobile OS. They also have the advantage of the current regulatory climate being less antitrust than it was. And they don't have to monetize their AI offerings (no ads in gemini; ChatGPT is adding them) and can run them at a loss for as long as it takes to eat up OpenAI's market share. If they partner up, as they seem to be doing, OpenAI should very very afraid.
- WarmWash 10mo ago>2) LLMs are extremely useful right now for certain niche tasks, especially software engineering. Don't get lost in the tech scene sauce, programming is a small sliver of what people are using LLMs for. OpenAI's report in September pegged it at ~4% of tokens being for software generation. Sure Anthropic is probably 80% or something, but only a small sliver of LLM users are using Anthropic. The reality is probably even less if you count Google's AI overviews. We hate it, but I have never seen a regular person skip over it. The question is if regular people will pay cell phone level subscription costs ($70-$100/mo) for LLMs. If so, then we are probably not in a bubble, and the ROI will have a 5-10 yr horizon, which is totally tenable. 500,000,000 people paying $75/mo is $450B/yr. Inference is cheap too, it's training that is ludicrously expensive. Don't be fooled by the introductory pricing we have today either, that's just to get you dependent. And yeah, chinese models, but look at what they did to tiktok. No way they are going to let the Chinese government be peoples confidants and no way is more than 0.01% of people gonna home lab.
- cong-or 10mo agoAt ~$100B in AI funding, the question isn’t capital—it’s physical constraints. Data centers need power (H100s are ~700W each), and recent capacity additions were mostly pre-allocated. Chip supply is also constrained by CoWoS packaging, not fab capacity, and expansions take years. If power, packaging, and GPUs are fixed in the near term, does $100B mostly drive inflation in AI infrastructure prices rather than materially more deployed compute? Are we seeing the real cost of a usable GPU cluster rise faster than actual capacity? Has anyone modeled what $100B actually buys in deployable compute over the next 2–3 years given these constraints—and whether that figure is shrinking as more capital piles in?
- stefan_ 10mo agoOh it is driving inflation alright, inflation for everyone else because OpenAI are buying things like a years supply of DRAM with money they don't even have yet (surely that should be an investigation?).
- jaredcwhite 10mo agoSure, let's throw more wild amounts of money at a wildly unprofitable company with no clear roadmap to profitability any time in the near-term, and in the long-term it's very probable that any arguably-useful use cases for LLM-based technology will be a commodity anyone can run anywhere. My gosh, this bubble can't burst soon enough. It's a form of torture to keep waiting on the pain we all know is coming…
- heyaco 10mo agogotta rope in the japs.