9 ms·
How AI destroys institutions
- reedf1 10mo agoIn other words: the penny finally dropped for lawyers. The next decade will be every knowledge field actively conspiring against AI.
- FromTheFirstIn 10mo agoAh yes, it’s not an earnest critique that the tech is destabilizing and isolating. It’s a conspiracy! Thank you. For a moment there I thought I’d have to examine my own beliefs!
- philipallstar 10mo agoSounds like you probably highly resist examining them.
- FromTheFirstIn 10mo agoDang maybe you’re right
- reedf1 10mo agoThis type of reflexive snark is just shite; I'm so bored of it. Things can be both earnest and compelled - right? I agree with you, and still hold my opinion.
- bogzz 10mo agoAwesome.
- Applejinx 10mo agoWhere appropriate. For instance, the purpose of lawyers is to serve and propagate the law, as distinct from 'most people say'. Justice in general is meant, imperfectly, to strive for correct answers on the highest possible level, even and especially if new accepted case law serves to contradict what was put up with before. So, web programmers could be going against AI on the grounds of self-preservation and be wholly justified in doing so, but lawyers are entitled to go after AI on more fundamental, irreconcilable differences. AI becomes a passive 'l'estat, cest moi' thing locking in whatever it's arrived at as a local maximum and refusing to introspect. This is antithetical to law.
- DrScientist 10mo ago> For instance, the purpose of lawyers is to serve and propagate the law But day to day, they spend a lot of their time selling boiler plate contracts and wills or trying to smuggle loopholes into verbose contracts, or trying to find said holes in said contracts presented by a third party[1] Or if they are involved in criminal law, I suspect they spend most of their time sifting the evidence and looking for the best way to present it for their client - and in the age of digital discovery the volume of evidence is overwhelmning. And in terms of delivering justice in a criminal case - isn't that the role of the jury ( if you are lucky enough still to have one ). I suspect very few lawyers ever get involves in cases that lead to new precedents.
- dooglius 10mo agoI believe an attorney is considered obligated to give a client the best possible defense (with limits as to ethics), which is definitely contrary to serving and propagating the law
- code51 10mo ago12 Angry Agents
- chrisjj 10mo agoTrue title: How AI Destroys Institutions
- PaulHoule 10mo agoI would say "Civic institutions function in ways that degrade and are likely to destroy ... civic institutions"
- inanutshellus 10mo agoCute, but that's an ineffective belittlement of his argument, not only because it's irrelevant but because he covers that even in the abstract: > Purpose-driven institutions [...] empower individuals to take intellectual risks and challenge the status quo. (which of course includes and is most-often the institution itself.)
- PaulHoule 10mo agoI'll argue otherwise. Almost the defining problem of modern institutions is sweeping problems under the rug, be it be climate change or (most important) Habermas's "Legitimation Crisis" [1] It's something I've been watching happen at my Uni ever since I've had anything to do with it. The spectacle of institutions failing to defend themselves [2] turns people against them. Insofar as any external threat topples an institution or even threatens it seriously there was a failure of homeostasis and boundaries from the very building. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legitimation_Crisis_(book) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legitimation_Crisis_(book) [2] ... the king is still on the throne, the pound is still worth a pound ...
- inanutshellus 10mo agoThat's not a fair statement. Every institution (let's say - my household) sweeps problems under the rug. It's the euphemism for problems that aren't worth dealing with. Institutions (in the form discussed) are either reinvented from the inside out and thus are and remain institutions, or are "toppled" in which case they are not "institutions" but "failures". Think of how the Tea Party and the Libertarian movements or affected Republican politics in years past, or how completely alien the party is compared to a decade ago. The institution of the "Republican party" persists, even though it's nothing like its former self. Same name, same "it's all fine just keep trusting us" but meanwhile quietly burned to the ground from the inside out.
- 21asdffdsa12 10mo agoNo, it does not. It preserves them as they where. Spreading of cultures that can not build institutions and uphold the rule of law does. To which stanford contributed considerately. The faction that can not build a working economic system and yearns to rule the economic system, is also incapable to build working societies, institutions and rule of law.
- SecretDreams 10mo agoDid you read the article?
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- hoppyhoppy2 10mo ago>Please don't comment on whether someone read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that". https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- SecretDreams 10mo agoNoted, thanks.
- alwayseasy 10mo agoIt feels like you didn't read or even skim the full article and instead are just reacting to the title.
- squeefers 10mo agofeels like you think social media is bad for other people but not you. every single one of you is posting on social media right now, whilst making the case its evil or a problem or bad or some negative descriptor. people who think its only bad for kids are quick to bring porn up, but that issue is itself an emotional reaction. remember when prior to the 1950s they said homosexuality was bad for mental health then once it became socially acceptable, there was suddenly "evidence" to the contrary.
- uptownJimmy 10mo agoAll scams are inherently destructive. Everything else is co-morbidity.
- alwayseasy 10mo agoNote this is the asbtract, so please let's not debate the abstract... The link to download the paper is here: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5870623 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5870623
- njhnjh 10mo ago[flagged]
- bayindirh 10mo agoIt's funny how many of us know the shortcomings of AI, yet we can't be bothered to do the thing ourselves and read or at least skim a in-depth research paper to increase our depth. Even if we don't agree with what we read, or find its flaws. Paradox of the century. P.S.: Using ChatGPT to summary something you don't bother to skim while claiming AI is a scam is the cherry on top.
- cybersquare 10mo agoIt's ok, I'll just read the AI summary...
- rpdillon 10mo agoI read the entire paper a couple of days ago and have done a lot of work to critique it because I think it is flawed in several ways. Ironically, this AI summary is actually quite accurate. You're getting down voted because posting AI output is not condoned, but that doesn't mean that in this case it is not correct.
- Sharlin 10mo agoThey're getting downvoted because without even taking a look at the paper, they felt that "please create a summary of the stupid, bad faith, idiot, fake science paper" is a reasonable way to ask for a summary.
- 10mo ago
- wendgeabos 10mo agoThe title makes me disinclined to read the whole paper. But I guess that's AI destroying institutions. Sigh. Social science != science.
- wendgeabos 10mo ago[flagged]
- wavefunction 10mo agocomplaining about being downvoted is discouraged here tomorrow is another day
- PaulHoule 10mo agoFunny I find that "opinions like this always get downvoted" can suppress downvotes! On the other hand if you are overflowing with karma what is an occasional -11?
- PlatoIsADisease 10mo agoIf you really want to traumatize yourself, learn about Scientific Realism vs Instrumentalism. (And further reading, Early Wittgenstein, but know you are only going to understand 10% of it, but that's okay, everyone only understands 10% of it) If you want to further freak yourself out about probability look up Bertrand's Paradox and The Problem of Priors. Yes Social Science is less accurate than what people call hard science, but the edges of scientific systems should concern yourself of validity of even hard science. Its pragmatically useful, yes, but metaphysical Truth? No.
- diablozzq 10mo agoThe immediate hot take is even if correct, the paper is largely opinion piece wrapped in an academic paper with Stanford logo. Most of the sections had no citations and anecdotes. Like many who have predicted doom or ChatGPT can never do XYZ, anecdotes do not build a substantive argument.
- mahoho 10mo ago...What? Like half of the vertical length of the paper is footnotes with citations. Also, opinions are kind of an important part of how we get ideas.
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- rafaelbeirigo 10mo agoThis is a byproduct of every revolution.
- Forgeties79 10mo agoMost revolutions have historically resulted in a lot of death and little change for the better if any. Frequently the outcome is worse than before.
- nisegami 10mo agoForest fires are immensely destructive, but they clear the way for new growth in their wake. The same has been said for recessions and the economy, and I think there's at least some comparison to be made for revolutions and societies.
- oblio 10mo agoAwesome, please post this from inside a forest fire and tell us your feelings then.
- Forgeties79 10mo agodefinitely borrowing this
- thatguy0900 10mo agoNah this revolution the billionaires who control the Ai and automated means of production will voluntarily give their money to the little guy instead of needing widespread unrest and riots beforehand like the other times
- toddmorey 10mo agoRight you are. Nature can be violent, but prefers gradual change. Abrupt change shocks ecosystems and always comes with unintended consequences.
- bethekidyouwant 10mo ago
- SheldonNumber 10mo ago[flagged]
- toddmorey 10mo agoI struggle with the thesis that our institutions haven't already been fatally wounded. Social media and endless content for passive consumption have already errored the free press, short-circuited decision-making, and isolated people from each other.
- squeefers 10mo ago> Social media and endless content for passive consumption neither being able to speak to someone on a computer nor videos on the internet are new, fancy web 10.0 frontend notwithstanding > and isolated people from each other. I assume you mean doomscrolling as opposed to the communication social media affords. because social media actually connects us (unless apparently its facebook, then messaging is actually bad)
- harimau777 10mo agoI'm not sure what you mean. The internet itself is new let alone widespread access to video sharing. Part of the problem is that social media isn't social media anymore. Its an algorithmic feed that only occassionally shows content from people you're friends with. If Facebook went back to its early days when it was actually a communication tool, then I don't think you would see the same complaints about it.
- squeefers 10mo agodefine social media. because in UK law its defined as app or website with a chat or messaging functionality, and in US law its even more nebulously defined than that. UK law counts FitBit as social media. https://www.law.cornell.edu/definitions/uscode.php?def_id=42-USC-375472706-220085095 https://www.law.cornell.edu/definitions/uscode.php?def_id=42... > Its an algorithmic feed that only occassionally shows content from people you're friends with problem how? ill assume you mean the problem is it shows you or other people stuff that will turn them toxic, not that it literally shows you other peoples content.
- wat10000 10mo agoMost social media isn't about communication, it's about engagement bait. Most usage consists of popular accounts sending messages, then people writing replies that are never read by the original account, and some vapid argument or agreement among the replies. It essentially pretends to connect us while actually capturing our attention away from that connection.
- littlemerman 10mo agoTitle should be updated to “How AI Destroys Institutions” to match source
- world2vec 10mo agoHN auto-removes "How" from the titles.
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- buellerbueller 10mo agodang, this submission title should be amended. JFC downvoters; when I posted this comment the title did not match the article title.
- 6DM 10mo agoI don't think AI is the cause, it's merely the mechanism that is speeding up what has already been happening. Social media was already isolating people. It is being sped up by the use of AI bots (see dead internet theory). These bots are being used to create chaos in society for political purposes, but overall it's increasingly radicalizing people and as a result further isolating everyone. AI isn't eroding college institutions, they were already becoming a money grab and a glorified jobs program. Interpersonal relationships (i.e. connections) are still present, I don't see how AI changes that in this scenario. I am not a fan of how AI is shaping our society, but I don't place blame on it for these instances. It is in my opinion that AI is speeding up these aspects. The article does highlight one thing that I do attribute to AI and that is the lack of critical thinking. People are thinking less with the use of AI. Instead of spending time evaluating, exploring and trying to think creatively. We are collectively offloading that to AI.
- echelon 10mo ago100% correct in the first part, though I'd like to think there's a bimodal effect with AI users and usage. Hard working expert users, leveraging AI as an exoskeleton and who carefully review the outputs, are getting way more done and are stronger humans. This is true with code, writing, and media. People using AI as an easy button are becoming weaker. They're becoming less involved, less attentive, weaker critical thinkers. I have to think that over some time span this is going to matter immensely. Expert AI users are going to displace non-AI users, and poor AI users are going to be filtered at the bottom. So long as these systems require humans, anyway. Personally speaking: My output in code has easily doubled. I carefully review everything and still write most stuff by hand. I'm a serious engineer who built and maintained billion dollar transaction volume systems. Distributed systems, active active, five+ nines SLA. I'm finding these tools immensely valuable. My output in design is 100% net new. I wasn't able to do this before. Now I can spin up websites and marketing graphics. That's insane. I made films and media the old fashioned way as a hobby. Now I'm making lots of it and constantly. It's 30x'd my output. I'm also making 3D characters and rigging them for previz and as stand-ins. I could never do that before either. I'm still not using LLMs to help my writing, but eventually I might. I do use it as a thesaurus occasionally or to look up better idioms on rare occasion.
- IvanK_net 10mo agoCan anybody prove that the essay and the abstract was not written by the AI, using 20 to 50 words as a prompt?
- Applejinx 10mo agoOf course not, it's expressing widely held observations that have been out there in the human population for a long time, and they're correct observations so they're hardly impossible to find. It's not really a good argument to say 'but what if this argument is so right and so commonly held that an AI could regurgitate it?'. Well, yes, because AI is not inherently unable to repeat correct opinions. It's pretty trivial to get AI to go 'therefore, I suck! I should be banned'. What was it, Gemini, which took to doing that on its own due to presumably the training data and guidance being from abused and abusive humans?
- throwaw12 10mo ago> Civic institutions - the rule of law, universities, and a free press - are the backbone of democratic life It probably was in 1850-1950s, but not in the world I live today. Press is not free - full of propaganda. I don't know any journalist today I can trust, I need to check their affiliations before reading the content, because they might be pushing the narrative of press owners or lobbies Rule of law? don't make me laugh, this sounds so funny, look what happened in Venezuela, US couldn't take its oil, so it was heavily sanctioned for so many years, then it still couldn't resist the urge to steal it, and just took the head of the state. Universities - do not want to say anything bad about universities, but recently they are also not good guys we can trust, remember Varsity Blues scandal? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Varsity_Blues_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Varsity_Blues_scandal - is this the backbone of democratic life?
- freejazz 10mo ago> Press is not free - full of propaganda Did you think that was different from 1850-1950?
- throwaw12 10mo agoI don't think, but I feel like situation was slightly better for some reasons: * there were no internet, so local communities strived to inform things happening around more objectively. Later on, there were no need for local newspapers * capitalism was on the rise and on its infancy, but families with a single person working could afford some of the things (e.g. house, car) hence there were no urgent need to selling out all your principles * people relied on books to consume information, since books were difficult to publish and not easy to revert (like removing a blog post), people gave an attention to what they're producing in the form of books, hence consumers of those books were also slightly demanding in what to expect from other sources * less power of lobby groups * not too many super-rich / billionaires, who can just buy anything they want anytime, or ruin the careers of people going against them, hence people probably acted more freely. But again, can't tell exactly what happened at that time, but in my time press is not free. That's why I said "probably"
- jvanderbot 10mo agoIt's hard for me to argue with these few direct sentences. They delegitimize knowledge, inhibit cognitive development, short circuit decision-making processes, and isolate humans by displacing or degrading human connection. The result is that deploying AI systems within institutions immediately gives that institution a half-life. ... even if we don't have a ton of "historical" evidence for AI doing this, the initial statement rings true. e.g., an LLM-equipped novice becomes just enough of an expert to tromp around knocking down chesterton's fences in an established system of any kind. "First principles" reasoning combined with a surface understanding of a system (stated vs actual purpose/methods), is particularly dangerous for deep understanding and collaboration. Everyone has an LLM on their shoulder now. It's obviously not always true, but without discipline, what they state does seem inevitable. The statement that AI is tearing down institutions might be right, but certainly institutions face a ton of threats.
- rpdillon 10mo agoThe examples that the paper cites that are historical are not compelling, in my opinion. The authors use Elon Musk's DOGE as an example of how AI is destructive, but I would point out that that instance was an anomaly, historically, and that the use of AI was the least notable thing about it. It's much more notable that the richest man in the world curried favor by donating tens of millions of dollars to a sitting US president and then was given unrestricted access to the government as a result. AI doesn't even really enter the conversation. The other example they give is of the FDA, but they barely have researched it and their citations are pop news articles, rather than any sort of deeper analysis. Those articles are based on anonymous sources that are no longer at the agency and directly conflict with other information I could find about the use of that AI at the FDA. The particular AI they mention is used for product recalls and they present no evidence that it has somehow destroyed the FDA. In other words, while the premise of the paper may seem intellectually attractive, the more I have tried to validate their reasoning and methodology, the more I've come up empty.
- OgsyedIE 10mo agoThe natural process of creative destruction deterritorializes everything, that's how every advance in history has always came about. The apparent difference perceived here is merely that this time, the human capital in the institutions that's supposed to reinvent the institutions alongside each new development are struggling. Coincidentally, this has happened exactly when the Flynn effect reverted, the loneliness epidemic worsened, the academics started getting outnumbered by the deans and deanlings and the average EROI of new coal, oil and gas extraction projects fell below 10:1. Sure, we should be wary of the loss to analysis if we just reduce everything to an omnicause blob, but the human capital decline wouldn't be there without it.
- blfr 10mo agoI am skeptical of hypotheses like this when the deterioration has begun before its supposed cause. This is how I look at social media or tinder being blamed for loneliness or low fertility. While they may have exacerbated the issues, trends have been unfavorable for decades if not centuries before. Similarly, it seems to me like the rule of law (and the separation of powers), prestige press, and universities are social technologies that have been showing more and more vulnerabilities which are actively exploited in the wild with increasing frequency. For example, it used to be that rulings like Wickard v. Filburn were rare. Nowadays, various parties, not just in the US, seem to be running all out assaults in their favoured direction through the court system.
- johndhi 10mo agoSorry to be this person, but I don't really agree with the first sentence: --> "Civic institutions—the rule of law, universities, and a free press—are the backbone of democratic life." People are the backbone of our civilization. People who have good intentions and support one another. We don't NEED an FDA to function -- it's just a tool that has worked quite well for a long time for us.
- AnimalMuppet 10mo agoThe problem is that not all people have good intentions. That's why we actually need the FDA, or something like it.
- johndhi 10mo agoThere are a lot of tools to address the problem that some people have bad intentions. We publish common sense laws, and we have police officers and prosecutors, and then we have a court system to hold people accountable for breaking the law. That's one pretty major method that has little to do with the need for an institution like FDA. I don't know if a system that relied entirely on tort and negligence and contract law to protect people from being sold snake oil would function better or worse than FDA, but I do know something like FDA (where a bunch of smart people advise very specifically on which drugs are ok to take and which are not) isn't the only option we have.
- ertucetin 10mo agoRecently wrote a blog about this: https://ertu.dev/posts/ai-is-killing-our-online-interaction/ https://ertu.dev/posts/ai-is-killing-our-online-interaction/
- rapatel0 10mo agoMore social science academic nonsense. Fun quotes from the paper > I. Institutions Are Society’s Superheroes: Institutions are essential for structuring complex human interactions and enabling stable, just, and prosperous societies. > Institutions like higher education, medecine, and law inform the stable and predictable patterns of behavior within organizations such as schools, hospitals, and courts., respectively,, thereby reducing chaos and friction. >Similarly, journalism, as an institution, commits to truth-telling as a common purpose and performs that function through fact-checking and other organizational roles and structures. Newspapers or other media sources lose legitimacy when they fail to publish errata or publish lies as news. > Attending physicians and hospital administrators may each individually possess specific knowledge, but it is together, within the practices and purposive work of hospitals, and through delegation, deference, and persistent reinforcement of evaluative practices, that they accomplish the purpose of the institution > The second affordance of institutional doom is that AI systems short- circuit institutional decisionmaking by delegating important moral choices to AI developers. >Admittedly, our institutions have been fragile and ineffective for some time.36 Slow and expensive institutions frustrate people and weaken societal trust and legitimacy.37 Fixes are necessary. > The so-called U.S. “Department of Government Efficiency” (“DOGE”) will be a textbook example of how the affordances of AI lead to institutional rot. DOGE used AI to surveil government employees, target immigrants, and combine and analyze federal data that had, up to that point, intentionally been kept separate for privacy and due process purposes. It's all politics. 150% bullshit.
- gbanfalvi 10mo agoI think the paper is really good and makes loads of valid points... and it's kinda terrifying. Having super accessible machines that can make anything up and aren't held accountable run the world is going to break so many systems where truth matters.
- pizzafeelsright 10mo ago> Having super accessible machines Having large bureaucratic organizations > that can make anything up and aren't held accountable that run everything and aren't held accountable > run the world is going to break so many systems run the world breaking up families, freedom, and fun > where truth matters. where truth is determined by policy
- gbanfalvi 10mo ago> Having large bureaucratic organizations Yes, that's what the paper argues. Institutions at every scale (say, doctor's clinics, hospitals, entire healthcare systems) are very challenging to access compared to me asking ChatGPT. And it's not just the bureaucracy, but there's time, money and many other intangible costs associated with interacting with institutions. > [Large bureaucratic organizations]that run everything and aren't held accountable But they ultimately are. People from all types of institutions are fired and systems are constantly reorganized and optimized all the time. Not necessarily for the better -- but physical people are not black boxes spewing tokens. Individuals' choices are ultimately a product of their knowledge and their incentives. An MLM's output is the result of literal randomness. > run the world breaking up families, freedom, and fun There's lots of terrible institutions vulnerable to corruption and with fucked up policies, but inserting a black box into _can't_ improve these. > where truth is determined by policy The truth is the truth. Regardless of what policy says. The question is, do you want to be able to have someone to hold accountable or just "¯\_(ツ)_/¯ hey the algorithm told me that you're not eligible for healthcare"
- FuturisticLover 10mo ago"Isolating people from each other" I can see this happening. Earlier, more people worked in groups because they relied on their expertise. Now, there is no need for this; people can do it alone. Even though this makes the work done, it comes at the cost of isolation. I am sure for some people this would look like a win.
- littlecranky67 10mo ago> I can see this happening. Earlier, more people worked in groups because they relied on their expertise. It only isolates you, if you let it isolate you. The pandemic shifted my life, as I have been working alone at home ever since. I am single no kids, and after the pandemic ended I continue to stay "isolated". I knew about that dangers and took active measures - some of which were only possible because I was no longer required to go to an office. I moved to another country, to a location with a lot of international expats that work online, too. I built an active social circle, attending meetups, sport groups, bar nights etc. I am now more social and happier than ever, because my daily social interactions are not based on my work or profession, and I get to chose with whom I spend my time and meet for lunches. Before, the chores around hour long commutes, grooming, packing my bag, meal-prep, dressing properly etc. just to sit in the office all day - all are gone from my schedule. I have more free time to socialize and maintain friendships, pay less rent, and in general - due to lower cost of living - life quality has improved significantly. Without work-from-home this would not be possible. You could argue WFH results in isolation and depression, but for me it was liberating. It is, of course, each individuals own responsibility (and requires acitve work, sometimes hard work, too) that will influence the outcome.
- wiseowise 10mo agoWhich country is that? If it’s not a secret.
- littlecranky67 10mo agoSpain. You can basically pick any continental coastal town, or any of their islands (Baleares or Canarias) and will find similar conditions. Portugal was (and still is) also an option for the future. For US citizens, I personally would look at Mexico, Costa Rica or Columbia, as those timezones are probably best when working with US companies. I am personally not a big fan of Asia (no offense to anyone), so Thailand was never on the list for me but I know it is very popular for remote workers. EDIT: To add to this, you might not need to change countries if all you look for is to be more socialable/outgoing. A key factor here for me was the expat community - not because I want to live inside a little expat bubble, but at least within that community people usually moved away to another place to be more active/outgoing, make new connection etc. People don't expatriate to stay at home, commute to work, and watch netflix/play videogames all day. This could also work for you if you i.e. move to a more touristy/active area within your country, because a lot of options for active passtime such as outdoor sports attract people also for long term.
- zinodaur 10mo agoI firmly believe "AI will be used by the psycho weasel billionaires to torture us all", but this article is weak. It seems like it was written by people too scared of AI to use it. They have a couple of points you realize in your first month of using AI, and they wrap them in paragraphs of waffle. I wish the anti AI camp was more competent
- onaclov2000 10mo agoI think that as communities spread (as with increased joining of online communities) we lost much in our local communities, this feels to me like a sort of extension of that, it's a community of one (well kinda, it's a sum of communities, and kinda missing the bidirectional communication, of the community) maybe?
- bigbug123 10mo ago[flagged]
- naasking 10mo ago> Encourages cognitive offloading, leading to skill atrophy Speculative, we don't have that evidence yet. The evidence we do have is in students who have not yet developed skills and maturity, and who also have a lot of other confounding factors in their development, eg. social media, phones, formative development years exposed to immediate pleasure-seeking feedback loops. > Backward-looking nature cannot adapt to changing circumstances As opposed to the nimble flexibility that established institutions are historically known for? > Displaces knowledge transfer between humans If people use LLMs, presumably it's because knowledge transfer is faster and more convenient that way than via direct interaction. > Flattens institutional hierarchies needed for oversight We have hierarchical institutions for oversight because flatter institutions don't scale (because humans don't scale). If AI can scale and can provide the same transparency, accountability and oversight, how is that not an improvement? I could go on with the remaining points, but suffice it to say that there are a lot of faulty assertions behind the paper's arguments. It's also interesting that every chicken little saying that the sky is falling immediately reaches for the ban hammer instead of providing constructive criticism on how AI (or whatever innovation) can improve to mitigate these issues.
- notjes 10mo ago"Civic institutions—the rule of law, universities, and a free press" All of those are rotten and corrupted to the core. But I don't think they will be destroyed by AI. People are voting with their feet.
- embedding-shape 10mo agoThis has had a large discussion already just five days ago, with ~160 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46644779 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46644779
- fabian4 10mo agoAI can change how we work and think, but institutions didn't become fragile overnight because of it. Many of the pressures on universities, media, and governance predate AI by years or decades. Using AI wisely can augment human capability without eroding institutional roles — the real question is how accountability, transparency, and critical thinking evolve alongside the technology.
- wat10000 10mo agoWhen has humanity ever used technology wisely?
- Sol- 10mo agoDo they assume that the current state of our institutions is normatively correct? AI progress will come and have manifold benefits, therefore we shouldn't really restrict it too much. If the institutions cannot handle that, they will have to change or be destroyed. Take university, for instance. Perhaps they will go away - but is this a great loss? Learning (in case it will remain relevant) can be more efficiently achieved with personal AI assistants for each student.
- techblueberry 10mo agoI think one of the paradoxes of modern life, is I assert that one of the things we're all nostalgic for are institutions. For sure we all believe in different institutions, but watching the decline of institutions, we all seem to be dancing on our own graves.
- fullshark 10mo agoSure I'm nostalgic for my own childish naivety, aren't we all?
- techblueberry 10mo agoYour childish naivety values universities, the rule of law, a free press and the military? We had very different childhoods; and more importantly, clearly different definitions on what maturity is.
- fullshark 10mo agoI definitely thought there were adults, who are basically gods when you are a child, that were in charge of or steering these institutions and they had principles and values beyond careerism and greed. Go talk to any academic about how they view their field as a child versus today and it will illustrate what I'm talking about.
- goatlover 10mo agoDoesn't mean institutions in general aren't a net good for society. What would replace them? Also doesn't mean you can't structure institutions to incentivize values beyond careerism and greed.
- fullshark 10mo agoYes the hope is that the institutions under attack can rebuild or be replaced by ones with better alignment with social good. There's a lot of disagreement about what that means and that's part of the chaos, but yes.
- reactordev 10mo agoI’m going to play devils advocate and cough recite a common argument from the pro gun Americans. “It’s not guns that kill people, it’s people that kill people”. It’s not “AI bad”, it’s about the people who train and deploy AI. My agents always look for research material first - won’t make stuff up. I’d rather it say “I can’t determine” than make stuff up. AI companies don’t care about institutions or civil law. They scraped the internet, copyright be damned. They indexed art and music and pay no royalties. If anything, the failure of protecting ourselves from ourselves is our fault.
- baggachipz 10mo agoAnd the vehicle to protect ourselves is called "government". Looking around... yeah.
- wrqvrwvq 10mo agoThe common argument seems to hold up in both cases.
- goatlover 10mo agoYeah but it's people with guns that kill people, therefore a lot of countries regulate & restrict gun ownership to reduce gun violence. Same can apply with AI abuses.
- alphazard 10mo agoIt's not AI. Human institutions rely on humans acting in good faith. Almost every institution is held together by some kind of priesthood, where everyone assumes the priests know what they are doing, and the priests create a kind of seriousness around the topic to signal legitimacy, and enforce norms on the other priests. This is true of Government, Law, Science, Finance, Medicine, etc. But most of these institutions predate the existence of game theory, and it didn't occur to anyone how much they could be manipulated since they were not rigorously designed to be resistant to manipulation. Slowly, people stopped treating them like a child's tower of blocks that they didn't want to knock over. They started treating them like a load bearing structure, and they are crumbling. Just as an example, the recent ICE deportation campaign is a direct reaction to a political party Sybil[0] attacking the US democracy. No one who worked on the constitution was thinking about that as a possibility, but most software engineers in 2026 have at least heard the term. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sybil_attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sybil_attack
- chrisjj 10mo agoWhere is Sybil's large number of pseudonymous identities in this case?
- sigotirandolas 10mo agoN~10^(6.5) aliens.
- noosphr 10mo agoWhy isn't there a major lack of institutional trust of dentists? Between 1990 to today fillings have gone from being torture to something that takes 30 minutes while I listen to a podcast. I've not met anyone who distrusts big dental. But fluoridated water is still a hot topic. The best that the experts the paper talks about can do today is say that if we follow their advice our lives will get worse slower. Not better. Just as bad as if we don't listen to them, but more slowly. In the post war period people trusted institutions because life was getting better. Anyone could think back to 1920 and remember how they didn't have running water and how much a bucket weighed when walking up hill. If big institutions want trust they should make peoples lives better again instead of working for special interests, be they ideological or monetary.
- jjice 10mo ago> Why isn't there a major lack of institutional trust of dentists? FWIW, I know a lot of people who refuse to go to the dentist unless it's an issue because they're one of the medical professions that seem to do the most upselling. I go every six months for a cleaning and trust my dentist, but I can definitely see how these huge chain dentists become untrustworthy.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 10mo ago>Why isn't there a major lack of institutional trust of dentists? Between 1990 to today fillings have gone from being torture to something that takes 30 minutes This one is personally hilarious to me. My dentist said there were "soft spots", that like a fool I let him drill. On the sides of my teeth. Those fillings lasted about 6 weeks before they fell out. He refilled them once, telling me to "chew more softly". Basically, he was setting me up to get caps... but he hadn't checked that my insurance basically covered 0% of such. My own trust in dentists is nil at this point, though I desperately need dental work. Dentists make their money by rushing as many patients through in a business day as they can. Boats to pay for, yadda yadda. There might be dentists out there that take their time, who pay attention to the patients needs, and are reluctant to perform irreversible and potentially damaging work... but those dentists are for rich people and I am not rich. Trusting dentists (in general) is one of the most foolish things a person can do.
- mellosouls 10mo agoNote the author here is presumably not so concerned about the decline of the institutions given his flag-waving for censorship in previous years, eg: "Banning Trump from Twitter and Facebook isn’t nearly enough" https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2021-01-15/facebook-twitter-extremism-donald-trump-violence https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2021-01-15/facebook-tw... Even if you dislike Trump, the campaign to suppress conservative voices of the 2010s (now largely reversed) that he argues for there was a significant contribution to the decline in authority and respect that academia has had in the eyes of the general populace. To be clear, the same must also apply to any suppression of liberal voices - its unacceptable in a culture that claims free speech. But I am sceptical that this particular writer has a moral high ground from which to opine.
- loudmax 10mo agoAI might be accelerating the trend, but there's been a populist revolt against institutions for over a decade. It's been happening long before ChatGPT, and this isn't just in Europe and the US. The erosion of trust in governments and institutions has been documented globally. The obvious culprits being smartphones and social networking, though it's really hard to prove causality.
- Flavius 10mo ago> The obvious culprits being smartphones and social networking, though it's really hard to prove causality. Totally get hating on social media, but social media didn’t make politicians corrupt or billionaires hoard wealth while everyone else got crumbs. It just made it impossible to keep hiding it. Corruption, captured institutions, and elite greed have been torching public trust for years. Social media just handed everyone a front-row seat (and a megaphone).
- srijith259 10mo agoI understand that everyone is disillusioned with current institutions. But I don't understand the prevailing sentiment here that it's therefore okay for them to fail. For one, there will never be perfect institutions. One would think we would create technology to complement and improve them. Instead, recent technological trends seem to have done the opposite. At the very least, this should make us reconsider what we are building and the incentives behind it.
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- book_mike 10mo agoMy word, it doesn't have to be that way.
- mistivia 10mo agoWe have seen similar situations countless times before. Just as the Internet allowed people to bypass publishers to release text, and YouTube allowed creators to bypass TV stations and cinemas to release video, AI now allows people to bypass lawyers to read legal texts, which are often deliberately written to be indecipherable to an average person. AI will not destroy institutions, but it will pose challenges and lead to restructuring.
- code51 10mo agoI know it's a draft but why on earth people cannot use page formats the same (more or less)? Material (full page) material material, sources at the end. Simple. Readable. Material (half page), sources (half page). Material/source. Material/source. Looks quite unreadable to the eye.
- dzink 10mo agoThink back to Maya history when the rulers kept astronomy knowledge secret to pretend they were Gods and had control over celestial objects. If expensive education and publishing access provides power to someone and free education and publishing becomes a thread to their authority, that’s not a good testimony on how they used their education advantage while they had it. AI may be destroying truth by creating collective schizophrenia and backing different people’s delusions, or by being trained to create rage-bait for clicks, or by introducing vulnerabilities on critical software and hardware infrastructure. But if institutions feel threatened, their best bet is to become higher levels of abstraction, or to dig deeper into where they are truly deeply needed - providing transparency and research into all angles and weaknesses and abuses of AI models. Then surfacing how to make education more reliably scalable if AI is used.
- avsteele 10mo agoObviously ~nobody has read this yet... But I did have a question based on the opening: "If you wanted to create a tool that would enable the destruction of institutions that prop up democratic life, you could not do better than artificial intelligence. Authoritarian leaders and technology oligarchs are deploing [sic] AI systems to hollow out public institutions with an astonishing alacrity" So in the first two sentences we have hyperbole and typos? Hardly seems like high-quality academic output. It reads more like a blog post.
- embedding-shape 10mo ago> Obviously ~nobody has read this yet... It was uploaded 8 Dec 2025, surely someone have gotten through it by now.
- rpdillon 10mo agoI read through it a couple of days ago. Your read is correct; it's poorly written, poorly argued, and poorly cited. It's basically a draft of an op-ed with a click bait title.
- shevy-java 10mo agoThe title is a bit odd. For instance: "The affordances of AI systems have the effect of eroding expertise" So, some expertise will be gone, that is true. At the same time I am not sure this is solely AIs fault. If a lawyer wants 500€ per half hour of advice, whereas some AI tool is almost zero-cost, even if the advice may only be up to 80% of the quality of a good lawyer, then there is no contest here. AI wins, even if it may arguably be worse. If it were up to me, AI would be gone, but to insinuate that it is solely AI's fault that "institutions" are gone, makes no real sense. It depends a lot on context and the people involved; as well as opportunity cost of services. The above was an example of lawyers but you can find this for many other professions too. If 3D printing plastic parts does not cost much, would anyone want to overpay a shop that has these plastic parts but it may take you a long time to search for, or you may pay more, compared to just 3D print it? Some technology simply changes society. I don't like AI but AI definitely does change society, and not all ways are necessarily bad. Which institution has been destroyed by AI? Has that institution been healthy prior to AI?
- macleginn 10mo agoI think part of the negative attitude towards the effects of AI stems from the fact that it demolishes a lot of structure. The traditional institutes maintain well-structured, low-entropy societies in terms of knowledge: one goes to a lawyer for legal advice or to a doctor for medical advice, one goes/send one's children to a university for higher education, etc. One knows what to do and whom to ask. With the advent of internet, this started to change, and now the old system is almost useless: as you note, it may be more efficient to go to AI for legal advice, and AI is definitely more knowledgeable about most things than most university teachers, if used correctly. In the limit, the society as it existed before is not simply transformed but is completely gone: everybody is a fully autonomous agent with a $AI_PROVIDER subscription. Ditto for professional groups and other types of association that were needed to organise and disseminate knowledge (what is a lawyer these days? a person with a $LEGAL_AI_PROVIDER subscription, if this is even a thing? what is a SWE?). Now we live in a maximum-entropy situation. How do values evolve and disseminate in this scenario? Everybody has an AI-supported opinion about what is right. How do we agree? How do we decided on the next steps? AI doesn't give us a structure for that.
- macleginn 10mo agoThe authors are quick to assume "the inevitable atrophy of human skills and knowledge". But skills and knowledge have not been propped up by some low-fi institutional magic: they stem from the necessity of achieving practical goals, as well as general human curiosity and competitiveness. Sure, there will be a period of slop sloshing around everywhere, but the main drives for excellence (or at least passable performance) are not going anywhere.
- petcat 10mo ago> The affordances of AI systems have the effect of eroding expertise I have actually seen this be a tremendously good thing. Historically, "expertise" and state of the art was reserved solely for those people with higher education and extensive industry experience. Now anyone can write a python script to do a task that maybe they would have had to pay an "expert" to do in the past. Not everyone can learn python or be a computer scientist engineer. Some people are meant to go to beauty school. But I feel like everything has become so much more accessible to those people that previously had no access. I liken it to the search engine revolution, or even free open source software. The software developed as open source over the last decades are not toys. They are state of the art. And you can read the code and learn from them even if you would never have had the opportunity for schooling or industry to write and use such software yourself.
- chrisjj 10mo ago> Historically, "expertise" and state of the art was reserved solely for those people with higher education and extensive industry experience ... I feel like everything has become so much more accessible to those people that previously had no access. Might you ever ride in a car, need brain surgery, or live within the blast radius of a nuclear power station?
- mikemarsh 10mo agoI wonder if the concern about "civic institutions" as some unique and special thing within society is a generational thing; as a millennial I've almost always viewed "universities, and a free press" ("rule of law" is much more nebulous) as simply "institutions", or rather "the establishment", the key distinction being "the establishment" also includes corporations, banks, big capital, etc. The "institution" of the AI industry is actually a perfect example of this; the so-called "free press" uncritically repeats its hype at every turn, corporations (unsurprisingly) impose AI usage mandates, and even schools and universities ("civic institutions") are getting in on implicitly or explicitly encouraging its use. Of course this is a simplification, but it certainly makes much more sense to view AI as another way "the establishment" is degrading "society" in general, rather than in terms of some imagined conflict between "civic institutions" and "the private sector", as if there was ever any real distinction between those two.
- funkyfiddler69 10mo agoEasy to fix, but it must be done by a front of academics, hackers, engineers and lawyers, which makes it next to impossible because even those with enough time, won't do it. It's a bunch of fallacies, and a bunch of inverted fallacies at play, tightly entangled with a cool Cheshire Cat kind of attitude. We have the bystander effect, pluralistic ignorance, diffusion of responsibility and everybody is so busy not suing. Why not do it just for the sake of it and to make the whole "game" stronger, harder, better, smarter? The easy path killed millions of species, ideas, intelligent people, solutions, work, things to do. Then there's the inverted spotlight effect, people believe they matter less than they actually do. The main character theme maximized, it's sad. All the young kids and potential stars abide by the mechanisms of learned irrelevance. Role models? Who? Role roadmaps, maybe, and they are not helpless and just make money and stick to their thing. An inverted egocentric bias, systems justification theory, credentialism, the authority bias: "that's lawyers in parliament, senate and where ever, damn it! They are smart!" The wealth of others disempowers intelligent people. Bam, corporate paternalism and discouragement of civic engagement. The right people just need to sue who needs to be sued. And they have to do it big and loud, otherwise this whole show turns into your average path towards a predictable dystopia. The insane number of species killed should give everybody an inkling about how many ideas, ways of doing things, personalities and so on died, often enough not for evolutionary reasons, but because people ignored the wrong things. And to those who think that "this is still evolution": it's not, sabotage is not evolution. And it's not securing anyones long term survival. Nobody cares about that of course. We have one lifetime and get to watch half of the life of our offspring, if we choose to, that is, and if we are lucky enough not to get poisoned, spiked, sick or smashed in an accident. But if you think about the edge of what is possible, and you maximize that image, and you realize how many awesome brains got caught up in ripples of ignorance and a sub-average life of whores, money, power and shitty miniature teraforming, you quickly realise that some kind of immortality was actually on the horizon. Our ancestors have build an impeccably working order that we simply stopped to maintain because the old guard refused to sue those who just had to be sued so that laws could evolve; and the young adapted. Of course there was and is progress but, a LOT of progress but if you apply readical honesty, you can't unsee and unknow all these big and obvious leaking holes. It's the same on any scale. Anarchists, lefties and whatnot don't matter in this fight because the bulk of the people trusts competence first, which should be our top, but isn't, and only then do they choose what is marketed, which currently is "Trump"... And if the top behaves in certain ways, people will follow. And all the narratives on TV and the radio come with more than enough subtext. In every town on the planet and every block, corruption, punched drugs, spiking, abuse of power by teachers, trainers, companies, institutions, malfeasance in office, breaches of privacy, you name it, it's on every scale. If you don't take proper care of that, meaning there must be an ongoing fight and law enforcement must be on the right side, before you let AI amplify and augment it all, then institutions will have a really bad time coming across as credible while corporations will continue to serve the peoples needs and desires ... ALL of their needs and their desires, even those they ought to keep in check: bam, your sub-average path to a predictable, sad dystopia, thank science there will be drugs.
- diggyhole 10mo agoOh you mean the same institutions that imprisoned Aaron Swartz for trying to democratize information? plays smallest violin
- ChrisArchitect 10mo ago[dupe] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46644779 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46644779
- GardenLetter27 10mo ago"Eroding expertise" - just sounds like lawyers and notaries, etc. worried that the gravy train is coming to an end.
- dooglius 10mo agoIt's not clear from the page but this is the intro to a whole paper at SSRN https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5870623 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5870623
- rlewkov 10mo ago"Civic institutions—the rule of law, universities, and a free press—are the backbone of democratic life." Why are universities part of this set backbone items?
- johngalt7 10mo agoFull paper is here https://download.ssrn.com/2026/1/21/5870623.pdf?response-content-disposition=inline&X-Amz-Security-Token=IQoJb3JpZ2luX2VjEAAaCXVzLWVhc3QtMSJHMEUCIQCviDrxEgUqPQOcDBONmHPtneF%2FQHioKPCJOIGWsgk62gIgTvOAn2zNJd2StIh7o%2Fl%2Ff5Xiu78HbImhfOcDRe3K6C0qxgUIyP%2F%2F%2F%2F%2F%2F%2F%2F%2F%2FARAEGgwzMDg0NzUzMDEyNTciDKOHiDDNohMEq8wZ0SqaBXgGyhC8HRZgwK%2BKRtDdCGsMfDAvl%2BJfqsvCYpIXd5S0hV7WttgQ4hSwiIYJ0obyBo2yzbXiUN7Wwcx9km%2BnU8tjmLsZsRjtZU4%2F0Ebj23Ja8Fu4I1uGoBA7foRLZqwcV29%2B4qJPLfuHcKmjAOscxWQSJwjHujEXxaQK26xdAW33TCxNgW42ANHzg%2FTuPbP02YlecAEzfrzHAn3vNVHDApjsCKi9Uc3uyesh8VBsv5UC12DaTgD2OhaDSnIqvpXLJsm3TXDUrd5beh6SygzbKYzSzvuHjGqYtEdQpK5%2BOkhaGYB9I4XUSEh6VXbgVXMsugy1Vz%2BWMXasvew48Vgj3WbdlZWIxM1Acg5um4bt0Jrzt0DjgKpRPfQt%2For4U1mSCAZpmDkQYXBtAm%2BXGvNPtVJ3EMNbC3C%2F4NyHO2tTzvdXanzZ%2FFpZXh9dUYGO7TSKUHak4vmWEkU0aCFlfTSZ6XRgPFmX14JcOX%2BaS42M2e2dyw8XcJEy7JUwQ80K7ujbhOQY8qmcqfBswjFqMR2%2FC9hdnybrZd98Nq1H6Ot%2BQOM8jqszJIGXmMd31iAVESTb%2FosXIeIv8js1oeGbtjD8TikbcFjqH3%2BTtT3aA7fxCCIaaYv%2BCCSxq%2BTvO4wCDt5a9LAwsip%2FLjRhxqfWlbBUSWxNCrqqjWvdaH%2BTzS%2FXATCXjUvIhbm41x1XLDpCWRFt1f%2FBzbhrblao%2BnI27wMOjHPr%2B3QgIW14tJziWzollEGdVkNijigCwUelpx%2Bfvw8XX9aYQVsnFv9XWoukbWxO7EyazSj1ZJFSVDVrNGpdCoXgMvDbBhvi9NYvh1SQaADWJnTo8Dt9wCRk7PTLeCII07xaL9vJ3e7MkeL8V5dx88K4r42EyXi7DB%2BfhjD23cPLBjqxAdRFS%2BIXHKvtJCNy6fkuXbu7FBo8od3YsT%2FO%2BfNCxxf18lnxnoXn1RmcdiWzi5Oqi0nznqaSFRBtYsoridYXaXr%2BINzfOJs88cp0sysCy%2BcDYKHzXFdsS3uhj0B%2BUJIOw%2FoljkNeyhbZ5Ew4vNQihjK%2BKB5URkx5Q4WDr3Yfhpycz12zMSu3VV4w%2B0dU04qApuUA2JKUNEzk4tS5J%2FU2faqf44pSdQWuH7PbOQOAPZZrfQ%3D%3D&X-Amz-Algorithm=AWS4-HMAC-SHA256&X-Amz-Date=20260121T160522Z&X-Amz-SignedHeaders=host&X-Amz-Expires=300&X-Amz-Credential=ASIAUPUUPRWE2YXZ3GG4%2F20260121%2Fus-east-1%2Fs3%2Faws4_request&X-Amz-Signature=5bf2c15e34ef5707c75e044b73e33e001505e7cdb7eed721b066dbd519e9111f&abstractId=5870623 https://download.ssrn.com/2026/1/21/5870623.pdf?response-con...
- Sam6late 10mo agoI think cutting off money is like an emergency wound that needs a bandage right now to keep the school alive. AI is more like a difficult puzzle—universities can solve it eventually, but only if they are stable and have the budget. There are some lame attempts at taming the AI shrew: In reality a far more serious threat is the loss of academic freedom. This guy must deal with that issue, and onslaught on academic freedom and that is the real question because in 2025, billions of dollars in federal research grants were frozen for institutions, including Harvard, Columbia, Cornell, Northwestern, and UPenn. The US federal government remains the single largest funder of university research, accounting for approximately 55% of all higher education R&D expenditures (this is a capitalist country btw).
- erelong 10mo agoI think a lot of people are rooting for AI to destroy corrupt institutions
- SunshineTheCat 10mo ago> universities, and a free press—are the backbone of democratic life... The self-importance and arrogance of some people in universities never ceases to amaze me. I'm not saying they don't have value; doctors, nurses, lawyers, wouldn't exist without a university. But calling it the "backbone of democratic life" is about as pretentious as it comes. The reality is that someone bagging groceries with no degree offers more value to "democratic life" in a week than some college professors do in their entire career.
- zbentley 10mo agoEveryone interested (critically or not) in this paper should also read “Recoding America” by Pahlka. While written before the AI boom, it gives an extremely thorough treatment to institutional behaviors re: technology and effectiveness, informed by and informing Pahlka’s work with the United States Digital Service as a means of addressing these issues.
- thestructuralme 10mo agoFeels less like ‘AI destroys institutions’ and more like it removes the friction that used to force competence: drafts become publishable, citations become optional, accountability gets diffused. Institutions fail when error becomes cheap and responsibility becomes unclear. The fix isn’t banning tools, it’s redesigning workflows around verification, audit trails, and explicit ownership.