12 ms·
How did DOGE disrupt so much while saving so little?
- arealaccount 11mo agoMany of the people they cut were able to negotiate a full year severance, then were hired back as contractors effectively earning double pay.
- nineplay 11mo agoThey will also be paying somewhere around 50k a year soon for heath insurance because contractors don't get benefits. Fun!
- lotsoweiners 11mo agoI work in state government and while contractors don’t get benefits that FTEs receive, they are usually paid close to double in salary.
- zzshampoo 11mo ago[flagged]
- jrm4 11mo agoGood for them.
- CamelCaseName 11mo agoNot so good for taxpayers.
- ares623 11mo agoWhich is also them
- IAmBroom 11mo agoPlease forward your next raise to me, since it will only raise your taxes.
- georgemcbay 11mo ago> Please forward your next raise to me, since it will only raise your taxes. Joking aside that's not really how taxes work (in the USA anyway). A raise might move you into a higher top marginal tax rate, but only the money you earn above that new bracket threshold gets taxed at the higher rate, everything below the threshold continues to get taxed at the same rate as before. Raises don't increase your taxes (though you might end up with a slightly higher top tax rate solely on the new money you weren't making at all before).
- exe34 11mo agoIt was never about saving money for the tax payers! They voted for this.
- firesteelrain 11mo agoIt was but the system is too corrupt
- chowells 11mo agoBasically irrelevant to taxpayers. Their salaries or triple their salaries will add up to a difference of a couple dollars on the average tax bill. Doge didn't actually cut any of the big expenses. It was only intended to cut the effective things.
- jrm4 11mo agoMeh, false; the cost of the disruption will almost certainly be comparable, if not outweigh, the money paid.
- boogieknite 11mo agoconsulting company i work at hired a grip of these people for construction and public land projects. struggle with guilt that our success is the result of capitalizing on incompetence and lies we certainly charge at least 3x cost for gov to employ them on top of whatever severance they might have received. the work still needs to be done and specific people know how to do it. sort of becoming a staffing agency because theres so much profit in it. makes my stomach sick writing this out
- ethbr1 11mo agoIf you're seeing that much money, imagine how much is flowing to the big preexisting staffing firms... Almost enough to make you think that gutting then offering employees back at higher cost and pocketing part of the difference was the goal.
- omnimus 11mo agoMcKinsey and other consulting firms are built on this principle. Lobby for “retiring” or deskilling people in organisation and then replace them with your own contractors once problems arise.
- firesteelrain 11mo agoThat sounds like something DOGE should investigate as corrupt
- iwontberude 11mo agoWe all knew this would fail. Any leader worth their salt would know massive reorganizations are failures even when they aren’t unconstitutional and worthy of the death penalty.
- jrm4 11mo agoSystematic of so much clown techbro thought; idiots only see the obvious nicks and problems -- and even occasional absurdity -- in large institutions, and think they can come in fix everything. It's just an extension of good ol' Chesterton's fence.
- junglistguy 11mo ago[dead]
- InsideOutSanta 11mo agoPerhaps because disrupting things was the actual goal, rather than saving money. DOGE was highly effective in harming the entities meant to oversee Musk's companies, stealing information about union organizing and labor complaints, reducing the government's ability to collect taxes, and destroying its regulatory capacity.
- exe34 11mo ago[flagged]
- BennyGezerit 11mo agoThis is the right take
- underlipton 11mo agoThere is a certain class of American that rides the knife edge between credulity and contempt in supporting and accepting the activities and intent of bad actors who pledge to get rid of the things they don't like and they people they detest. They're ever-ready to believe the barest of excuses and to hand-wave the worst excesses in this regard. Today's anti-woke are yesterday's McCarthyists, and history will note the echo.
- MisterTea 11mo ago> There is a certain class of American The selfish kind. Unfortunately that seems to be the end goal of the American dream: "I got mine, fuck you." I can't tell you how many times I heard the "protect my family" argument from people I never thought would vote for that clown.
- ido 11mo agoAlso not exclussively American. Plenty of selfish assholes where I'm at as well, I suspect this is a world-wide phenomenon.
- 11mo ago
- RickJWagner 11mo ago[flagged]
- briffle 11mo agono, it wasn't even a real effort. A REAL effort would have been to collect what all is being done, and seeing where things should be removed, processes changed, etc. This was a slash and burn.
- nailer 11mo agoYes because government employees are famously good at judging how to spend taxpayer money.
- tastyface 11mo agoThe idea that they aren’t is nothing more than a right wing meme, presented without evidence while corporate wastefulness is ignored entirely.
- nailer 11mo ago[flagged]
- bryanlarsen 11mo agoIn my experience at the DMV they process a large number of clients per hour; they appear quite efficient. The problem is that there aren't enough customer service agents to handle the volume so the lines are massive. Cutting their budget makes things worse, not better.
- tastyface 11mo agoYes: given the number of clients they have and the amount of services they offer, it’s a marvel that the DMV (and USPS) work as well as they do.
- JohnClark1337 11mo ago[dead]
- epistasis 11mo agoI remember people citing the All-In podcast about "you can always cut 10% without affecting things negatively" or something silly like that. Or thinking that $1T/year of cuts is something that's possible without taking out social security and medicare and tons of defense spending. I can not tell you how much respect I have lost for anybody involved with the All-In podcast. They sold out all credibility for political wins for wanna-be fascists. These jokers all got lucky, obviously. They can not perform basic analysis of organizations, clearly. What a joke of a result!
- thwarted 11mo agoPJ O'Rourke had a line in his book "Parliament of Whores" when he, as a layman, ham-fistedly cuts a bunch of stuff from the federal budget, and then just subtracts 10% from it at the end. Probably not the originator, but a quote I think about often. "Add it all together, and I've cut $282.8 billion, leaving a federal budget of $950.5 billion, to which I apply O'Rourke's Circumcision Precept: You can take 10 percent off the top of anything. This gives me another $95 billion in cuts for a grand total of $337.8 billion in budget liposuction." Parliament of Whores, page 103.
- epistasis 11mo agoI have never worked for the government, but have worked in industry that deals with government employees. One thing that is very different in industry than in government budgets is that industry budgets do have that 10% of waste. But the budgets of all government orgs I have seen are incredibly lean, especially on the salary side. The government gets mission-driven folks that are willing to give up income in order to accomplish the things they want in the world. I saw this most clearly at CDC, all the scientists I interacted with could double their salary over night by going to private industry, but they stayed where they were because they were more interested in doing meaningful and impactful work. And when it came to the budgets that CDC used to accomplish scientific work, they were even more frugal and effective than the most penny-pinching academic labs I saw. Industry is awash in waste in comparison to how effective the dollars were that were spent at CDC. And the CDC work is all pre-competitive work that boosts the efficacy of everything else in the economy. A tiny amount of money that results in so much more economic activity and savings than could be imagined in most private industry. And all the numbers for the public savings on, say, food safety are all clearly laid out in long reports. Reports that nobody at DOGE would ever read because they don't believe than anything good could be produced by people who accept lower salaries for higher impact.
- thdrtol 11mo agoWe all fall into this trap, thinking we can do better than others. The problem is that Elon Musk has power (in the form of money) and was able to buy his way into the government. Elon Musk is a smart salesman but that's about it. He has little deep knowledge in a lot of what he does.
- kelseyfrog 11mo ago> Elon Musk is a smart salesman but that's about it. How is it that most people here can see through it, but people in power can't?
- glitchc 11mo agoThe way most of our governments are set up, the people in power typically arrive on the backs of the people with money. Elon Musk has a great deal of wealth, so everyone in power is going to listen to him.
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> but people in power can't? Why do you presume they can’t? Musk failed phenomenally to sell DOGE to the public, the President or the Congress. The expectation was that he’d have been better at that.
- kelseyfrog 11mo agoCan you tell me more? I was already familiar with The Butterfly Revolution and RAGE before the inauguration, but it sounds like most people weren't?
- queenkjuul 11mo agoMoney and power are all that matters. Musk is a dipshit but he's a rich and powerful dipshit and that's all that matters
- epistasis 11mo agoPower respects power, ultimately. If you have wealth and power, those in power assume it was earned, because otherwise it's admitting that their own power could be through luck. I will say that there are a few billionaires out there that do not get respect because everybody else assumes they "got lucky," but it's certainly not many billionaires. And those that people assume "got lucky" have mostly had terrible PR management on their way up, and not bothered to try to clean up their image. I have taken investment from one such billionaire that people would tell me "he got lucky," and though I don't think he got lucky to make his billions, he was also really terrible in his judgement and could not make the switch to investing even in similar industries successfully.
- josefritzishere 11mo agoThe intent was never savings. Hackers and Accountants are completely different specialties. If you send in hackers, the intent is obviously to hack, not conduct forensic accounting. (The inverse would also be true of course)
- aaa_aaa 11mo agoBecause "government efficiency" is an oxymoron?
- inejge 11mo agoBecause there wasn't that much to save, compared to the sheer size of the budget? Because it's much easier to destroy than to build, generally? Because it's always been more of an ideological exercise and a revenge vehicle than a real cost-saving venture?
- api 11mo agoSeemed like it was more about an ideological purge and possibly exfiltrating data than saving money. I predicted it would net cost money if you did a full accounting. May end up being true.
- goku12 11mo ago> I predicted it would net cost money if you did a full accounting. May end up being true. People don't appreciate the role of a working executive branch and government bureaucracy in keeping the nation working, stable and relatively free from unfair practices, no matter how inefficient they may seem. In most cases, they are inefficient and have other problems because they're understaffed.
- expedition32 11mo agoThat's because tech billionaires don't need all of that. They live in a bubble. It's the same with Trump. Do you think he has ever been inside a grocery store?
- goku12 11mo agoI absolutely agree about the billionaires. Not just because they're out of touch with reality, those government agencies are big hurdles to their pursuit of unlimited wealth by any means necessary. This was splendidly evident in the way Musk targeted the agencies that were either regulating or investigating his companies. But what perplexes me is the hostility against government bureaucrats shown by ordinary people who are getting impoverished. I see them routinely complaining online that government workers are lazy parasites who live off their tax money. Some people take it further, saying that these workers are part of the 'deep state' out to enslave them. Sure! Any bureaucracy will have some bad apples and corruption. But how do they miss the part that the government bureaucracy is the last line of defense blocking their all out exploitation? Like others point out, most government workers are too qualified and work too hard for what they are paid. They often take a pay cut to work on their passion and help everyone in the process. You can see this in the numerous bureaucrats who strongly resisted illegal and/or anti constitutional orders from the regime. Why are the people so oblivious to these?
- deleted 11mo ago[deleted]
- queenkjuul 11mo agoIf musk, Trump, or any of their allies had any interest in cutting spending, they wouldn't have passed budgets increasing the deficit every chance they've had. Must got what he wanted: some minor disruption to agencies that regulate him personally, the fear of god put into thousands of federal employees, and ostensibly federal data to help him bust unions. The side effect of disrupting thousands of normal hard working people's lives it's just icing on the cake for a miserable prick like him, even if he did have to hire most of them back. But if they could destroy the regulatory state while ALSO doubling the deficit with federal spending on defense, space, and oil, i don't doubt for a second they would do so.
- ourmandave 11mo agoBecause of the sheer idiocy of all involved. There was no plan, no thought process behind any of the cuts. Unless they thought appearing to be complete morons would distract from their actual mission of stealing all the Federal data they could. The whole operation of black hats need to be investigated.
- goku12 11mo ago> Unless they thought appearing to be complete morons would distract from their actual mission of stealing all the Federal data they could. That and the fact that many of the targeted organizations were regulating Musk's companies or even investigating them for serious violations. I don't think that I've seen such a blatant display of conflict of interest quite like this one.
- diego_moita 11mo agoBecause what they wanted was to "disrupt" and "saving" wasn't what they wanted.
- dwoldrich 11mo ago[flagged]
- epistasis 11mo agoWhy would you believe any numbers coming out of DOGE? The entire article is about their clear lies about their own numbers. Posting a number from the DOGE website and believing it is not rational behavior. Further, there is nothing that will make the US poorer than ending the Fed or fiat money. The US has blown past all other economies in the world because of fiat money and its special status. > revealed corruption in the NGO's. No, it absolutely did not. DOGE revealed the corruption of DOGE. It's all political corruption, eliminating the regulators for Musk's empire, cover it up with lies about other things. > Doge helped a lot of people come to that conclusion, so that's helpful. The only thing that DOGE convinced people of is that Musk is a fraud. Nobody lost trust in the government because of anything Musk did, nobody thought "Oh I used to think that USAID was good, now I think it's bad!" Musk's popularity has hit rock-bottom, he has ruined some of the most valuable consumer brands in the world. It's odd to see so many words that are directly contradicted by plain reality. One must be in a very very very deep information bubble to see your post
- dwoldrich 11mo ago> It's all political corruption, eliminating the regulators for Musk's empire, cover it up with lies about other things. I just don't see the world this way, and I don't think my being argumentative about it is healthy for either of us. > deep information bubble The same could be said for you. You've left very little room for nuance. I am not a direct investor in any of his businesses, and my opinions are my own. Musk was and is the largest military contractor, bought and paid for. He's a genius marketer, autistic, and gets his hands dirty on projects technically. He's not an idiot and he is socially awkward. I believe whatever big projects Musk starts are at the urging and partly the direction of the US military. It seems clear (to me) that Musk is crushing it in most of his businesses. It's clear (to me) that the on again, off again relationship he has with the Trump administration was just pro wrestling kayfabe. It is impossible for me to impute motives to Musk, he says pro-human things and he works (potentially) very anti-human projects. I am apprehensive about everything he has his paws in.
- cjoelrun 11mo agoImmune systems of all interested triggered.
- stranded22 11mo agoBecause it was about Elon musk’s companies getting out of being investigated. His pay off for helping Trump.
- jgbmlg 11mo ago2nd law of thermodynamics is what makes destructiveness so costly. It is much easier and cheaper to destroy than to build or rebuild. The Trump administration is devaluing the United States at an alarming rate.
- goku12 11mo agoAs I understand it, this is to wreck the government oversight on the conduct of the rich and the powerful. They really want to establish a full blown oligarchy. And they managed to convince the poor people that the government is bad for them too.
- silexia 11mo agoBiased article behind a paywall.
- tlogan 11mo agoThe goal was to disrupt government bureaucracy. Saving money was never the real objective, even though it was marketed that way. Anyone who knows how to use Excel understands that entitlements and defense are the biggest issue (60%) when it comes to government spending.
- sokoloff 11mo agoOn top of that 60% is ~13% on net interest payments.
- Havoc 11mo agoI don’t buy that it was ever aimed at saving any more than RFK is about running a competent health dept
- TheOtherHobbes 11mo agoThe US is being run by a hostile regime which is intent on destroying wealth, health, stability, and credibility. The people who have convinced themselves government is evil and taxes are bad are useful idiots. They're being used by others who very much want to destroy the US as a superpower. Musk is between the two. He's acting to keep his ass out of jail, and he's a True Believer in certain senses. But ultimately he's disposable, and will be removed when he's no longer useful.
- firesteelrain 11mo agoEvidence? You can’t make outlandish claims and don’t back it up
- xgkickt 11mo agoIt was a smash & grab.
- cedws 11mo agoOr smash and delete. If you needed to infiltrate government to cover something up you wouldn’t go straight for it. You would infiltrate many points at once and create chaos and misdirection to obfuscate what you’re really doing.
- TheOtherHobbes 11mo agoBackdoors. US government privacy is now compromised at most levels.
- Nasrudith 11mo agoNitpick. Governments don't have privacy. They have opacity. Don't anthropomorphize governments, especially not to that extent.
- jalapenos 11mo agoBecause the whole thing wasn't actually wanted. They just needed some theatre to make it look like they were fulfilling their campaign promise. Trying to get a government to reduce its spending from within is stupid and naive. There is no scenario, no matter who is voted in, where government spending goes down. They just talk about it, and then increase spending on the things they like (e.g. the last "big beautiful bill"). This was the primary cause of the Trump-Musk spat: former promised the latter a cost cutting campaign, but it was just a trick, used only to destroy those parts of the government he disliked like USAID, after which he promptly neutered it and signed a massive spending bill, basically having conned him. If it has actually been wanted - something that's literally impossible unless it was say created through an Article 5 convention - it would have been effective.
- faidit 11mo agoEven if removing corruption was an actual goal, the big corrupt whales that do exist were/are just like Elon himself, all well-connected and had already paid their bribes to the current regime, making them untouchable.
- deafpolygon 11mo agoThe disruption was the point — it was all distraction while Trump worked on setting up his second term.
- postalrat 11mo agoPolitics ensures that nobody will know what was actually saved and lost.
- deleted 11mo ago[deleted]
- damion6 11mo agoBecause that was the point.
- daheza 11mo agoI saw first hand the damage that was done by Elon's little purge. I saw people who were actively trying to make the world better - heal the sick, feed the hungry, and help the unfortunate - blindly struck down from doing those goals by a tiny egotistical mans joke of a initiative. I will personally never purchase or use anything from any of Elon Musk's companies ever again for the rest of my life and I push others to do the same and share their stories. This selfishness from a man with so much money and yet he only uses it for his own personal gain and to hurt others is disgusting.
- brcmthrowaway 11mo agoI'd be interested who here commenting negatively on DOGE actually has skin in the game (an American taxpayer)
- zem 11mo agodestroying things is extremely easy. there are typically a few ways for something to be working well and countless ways for it to be broken.
- wormius 11mo agoA few comments here touching on "disruption" (especially considering SV's historical mantras about "disruption" and "easier to beg forgiveness than ask permission"). So I think a good renaming is in order: Disruption of Government Efficiency Slows it down to give them time to catch up, especially in this new tech era. I read Wired in the 90s, I remember the Libertarian Logic. The best part is "Oh gee, we might doom society, we should think about these things... hmm. OK, guys, let's keep building it." Fuck it, let's straight up Stalin it, not just remove restrictions but FORCE these fuckers into slave camps building it all out, industrializing (Siliconizing? LLM-izing?) the future landscape. We've already bent our "conservative principles" in the name of corporate expediency and fascistic tendencies (who doesn't love a little "public/private" co-operation). The worst part is, most of these people have no principle and are merely opportunistic rent seekers bent on bending the rules for me, not for thee.
- stuaxo 11mo agoHubris, greed, corruption and contempt for four.
- Eggpants 11mo agoBecause it was really about serving red meat to the MAGA base. My relatives in Kentucky cheered because they believed the “all those lazy blacks are getting fired” narrative. It’s so strange to me as they are deeply religious and some of the kindest folks I know, but also the most racist.
- throwawayqqq11 11mo agoReligiosity, egomaniac libertarians, racists, etc. all suffer from an identity based cognitive bias revolving around their own or groups well being. These tribal members dont think critically about the $symbol related to their own or group identity, and the scary part is, these symbols could be anything and not just define their own ingroup but their opposing outgroup too, like eg. being vegetarian, riding a bicycle or showing broad empathy. IMO in severe cases it requires serious therapy to teach them to face social media or group gatherings with a different/critical mindset, that naturally comes after some unpleasant disillusionment but is needed before mistakes are made. If your realtive is not treatable, completely shut, you will talk to a brick wall. I hate to say it but Musk had a point, when he talked about twitter and his attempt "to cure the mind virus" (but as usual, he was clueless or biased). This identity based cognitive bias or identity politics is present on both political sides. The right/conservatives are just more susceptible, thats why religion, racism, libertarianism, etc. are often comorbid.
- pnt12 11mo agoSome religious people play their kind persona at church, to excuse the unkind persona in other situations.
- metalman 11mo agodoge went in to crack the internal records of huge government silos, in order to leverage the inevitable evidence of wholsale,corruption, nepotism, vice, and illegal political involvments. and lo and behold, everybody lined up and is doing whatever tumpy says, which will be to hand over, most....but not all, of the stolen money, useing the same mechanisms to move it as before.
- NuclearPM 11mo agoEvil people, corruption, and very stupid voters.
- tmaly 11mo agoIt seems very little could be saved without an act of Congress. I recall there was an interview of Bessent early on, on the All in One podcast where they laid out the plan for DOGE to cut 1 trillion. I don't think they even came close to a fraction of that.
- panick21_ 11mo agoBecause politics is about short term social media hype and not lasting change. Everybody who has ever studied the budget know that social services, debt payment and the military are the budget. Trying to effect any change with a major overall of these, or massive now broad taxes will not solve the problem. And politically the right can't increase taxes and the can't serously reform social services either. But likely it would lead to that eventially. So its literally just two parties fighting over trivial social media wins while debt pill and yearly debt upkeeep spending grows.
- neuralkoi 11mo ago“If you cannot understand why someone did something, look at the consequences—and infer the motivation.” ― Carl Jung