7 ms·
One of the dark consequences of America losing its city-upon-a-hill aspirations is we're less able to effectively call out evil abroad. Jimmy Lai should not hav
by JumpCrisscross 11mo ago
One of the dark consequences of America losing its city-upon-a-hill aspirations is we're less able to effectively call out evil abroad. Jimmy Lai should not have been allowed to this quietly.
- embedding-shape 11mo agoGo back a couple more years, and the UK is probably more relevant to bring up (especially considering the context), they used to have similar aspirations before they learned better.
- simianparrot 11mo agoThey didn’t learn better. They lost their aspirations and decided to give up as a nation.
- embedding-shape 11mo agoThey decided to stop being a world police, and correctly so. Now we're just waiting for US to understand the same thing, which is slowly happening, finally.
- spankalee 11mo agoGreat, so every country can just smoothly descend further into tyranny with no pushback from any other country. Thankfully we won't have any world police though!
- cafard 11mo agoDuring the US's period as hegemon, its influence extended only so far, and was only so often used to oppose tyranny.
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> its influence extended only so far, and was only so often used to oppose tyranny America was a major force behind post-War decolonization. It was one of our terms of the European peace.
- greedo 11mo agoThe US provided lip service to the idea, but quickly became paranoid about the threat of world wide communism and changed its tune relatively quickly. In the places where this wasn't a factor, it wasn't altruism by any stretch, but economic interests. The US saw that a post-colonial world would be fantastic for business...
- embedding-shape 11mo ago[flagged]
- nozzlegear 11mo agoIt may not be the sole reason but it's certainly the biggest. Pax Americana isn't just a phrase that wonks made up yesterday.
- embedding-shape 11mo agoYou do realize that there are stable countries that still exist today, that haven't been run by tyrants for very long time, and also are older than US been a country? Or even created before the US was a little British colony looking for purpose in the world? It seems like Americans forget how young their country is, it's barely a blimp in history so far, although recent written history makes it seem a lot older than it is.
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> there are stable countries that still exist today, that haven't been run by tyrants for very long time, and also are older than US been a country? Out of curiosity, who are you thinking of? There aren’t that many countries that made it through colonization, industrialization, WWII and then decolonization and the Cold War intact. Very, very few virtually continuously. Fewer still as democracies.
- nradov 11mo agoHow many other countries have been stable democracies since 1776? Or even since 1865?
- hervature 11mo agoI know you are using the definition of tyrant here to be "unjust ruler" as opposed to "absolute ruler". You can certainly have benevolent tyrants but I would argue that, without a constitution, you are by definition ruled by a tyrant. The USA has the oldest ratified constitution so that is a prime candidate for being considered the oldest stable non-tyrannical government. Of course, we are using different definitions of tyrant so you will not agree with my conclusion.
- dandellion 11mo agoThe world police was never really there to stop tyrants, the evidence is that they'd conveniently look the other way whenever they benefitted from it, and they would even put tyrants in place when it suited them. They did stop some tyrants, for sure, but only when it was convenient.
- mgfist 11mo agoThe world saw it's greatest peace under US hegemony. It wasn't perfect and there were bloody avoidable wars on the behest of the US, but by and large things ran smoothly and US sponsored globalism brought prosperity and peace to many.
- deleted 11mo ago[deleted]
- dandellion 11mo agoI think it's too early to make that call, considering pax romana lasted 200 years and we're not even a 100 into us hegemony.
- mgfist 11mo agoToo early to make what call? Pax Americana could end tomorrow and it wouldn't make the statement false (well, it would if whatever followed was even more peaceful).
- FlyingBears 11mo agoI would pick tyranny over "democracy" import any day. Neither US or UK have a great track record here.
- deleted 11mo ago[deleted]
- oblio 11mo agoThe US managed the assemble an alliance of the... let's count them: Based on military ranking: #5 SK, #6 UK, #7 France, #8 Japan, #9 Turkey, #10 Italy, #11 Brazil, #12 Pakistan, #14 Germany, #15 Israel, #17 Spain, #18 Australia, and if it were allowed to, #20 Ukraine. Based on economic power: I won't even bother, only China, India, Russia aren't US allies in the top 30 or so, by GDP. The US was a world police but it wasn't alone. Yes, it was far bigger than all its allies taken separately, but those allies could more than double its power. What the US is doing now is a tragedy that will unfold over many decades. [1] Based on https://www.businessinsider.com/most-powerful-militaries-2025-ranked https://www.businessinsider.com/most-powerful-militaries-202... (if you have a better ranking, please link it).
- mikkupikku 11mo ago> Yes, it was far bigger than all its allies taken separately, but those allies could more than double its power. This breaks down as soon as you stop looking at abstract rankings and dive into the specific logistic realities of force projection. France and to a lesser extent the UK are reasonably capable, but there's no math that adds up to anything approaching America's capabilities.
- eszed 11mo agoBeyond that, if you do get into the specifics of force projection (and basically anything logistical to do with NATO), you see that the entire alliance was built on the assumption that the US would contribute the capabilities that kept the whole system viable. So, $(US) + $(ALLIES) > $(US) However, $(ALLIES) - $(US) < $(ALLIES) This has been true from the beginning, and I don't think was a nefarious plot, or even mistake, for most of the alliance's history. The further we get from the Cold War alignments within which NATO was created, however, the more difficult it has become to sustain.
- greedo 11mo ago'Keep the Russians out, the Americans in, and the Germans down' was a central tenet of NATO from its founding.
- renewiltord 11mo agoThis is something that people don’t realize. America is no longer world police. If Europeans want to resolve intra-European disputes like Russia-Ukraine we should stay out of it.
- Workaccount2 11mo agoIt's going to take more than 4 years of Trump for America to disappear. Even just a few days ago congress approved $800M in funding for Ukraine.
- pbhjpbhj 11mo agoInstead, by refusing to sell weapons to Ukraine -- and lying about Europe's support -- when it didn't suit Trump, you've firmly placed your flag. Not allies in any meaningful sense.
- kenjackson 11mo agoThe US is becoming even more the world police now. But now we support the wrong people too. It’s doubly bad.
- pbhjpbhj 11mo agoMaybe 'World mafia' is a better description? They're not enforcing law and/or morality (nor ever have been?), they're just pressing countries for bribes for Trump, or to shift World markets for insider trades, or probably still for oil, AFAICT.
- embedding-shape 11mo agoLets see what happens when the invasion of Venezuela kicks off, either the world tries to prevent yet another authoritarian government from bullying those who are already on the ground, or we'll join in on the fun I suppose, if the US feels like it wanna share the future loot.
- tempest_ 11mo agoThey didnt lose aspirations. A lot of the UK seems to be struggling with their loss of Empire even 80 years later. They ran out of money, 2 world wars bankrupted them.
- bArray 11mo ago[flagged]
- iamacyborg 11mo agoIf you’re that keen, go join the reserves? https://jobs.army.mod.uk/army-reserve/ https://jobs.army.mod.uk/army-reserve/
- bArray 11mo agoNobody in their right mind is keen for a war. Nobody would fight in one unless they believed they really had no other choice. I don't blame the people who would runaway to relative safety if the option is available. But. It's clearly a massive security issue. > If you’re that keen, go join the reserves? There is not currently a war, and if there was, there wouldn't be a choice but to join.
- iamflimflam1 11mo agoAnyone who thinks war might be fun should watch some of the interviews with veterans from the “great” wars on YouTube.
- jacobgkau 11mo agoThat's a valid statement that nobody in this comment chain was disputing. It is exactly why the person you're responding to is assuming anyone who can leave, will leave, in that event (and why "you should join the reserves if you're that keen" is an irrelevant comeback-- nobody was saying anyone's keen, only that people aren't keen and will leave to avoid it if able).
- lossolo 11mo agoI would like to remind you that HK was a British colony for more than 100 years, and there was no democracy or freedom then. They only allowed the first partly free elections two years before they gave it back to China, in 1995. And not because they suddenly wanted freedom and democracy for HK, but because it would be harder for China and better for their own interests. Hypocrisy all the way.
- Herring 11mo agoThat's kind of misleading. HK had a lot of civil freedoms (rule of law, independent judiciary, freedom of speech). China explicitly blocked earlier democratization. The vote only managed to get through after the 1989 Tiananmen Square crackdown made HK panic. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_in_Hong_Kong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_in_Hong_Kong
- lossolo 11mo agoThose freedoms were never unlimited, even under British rule (colonial era sedition laws and public order restrictions existed).
- dash2 11mo agoNo freedoms are ever unlimited, so that's not an interesting point. The question is, were they useful? A lot of HKers seem to think so.
- lossolo 11mo ago> No freedoms are ever unlimited, so that's not an interesting point. Of course no freedoms are unlimited, so I'm not sure why are you reading this literally? > The question is, were they useful? Are we talking about the same thing? I'm talking about the lack of freedom under British rule, and you ask if it was useful for HKers? While there are a lot of people in HK who are not happy about what China is doing now, there is almost no one who would take British rule over that. I actually talked with people about it in person when I was in HK.
- jimbob45 11mo agoWhy is this evil? Most countries draw the line at aiding and abetting foreign harm to your own country, no matter how justified. I would expect no different if it happened in America or Europe.
- embedding-shape 11mo ago[flagged]
- mikkupikku 11mo ago> Most countries draw the line at aiding and abetting foreign harm to your own country, no matter how justified On the books maybe. But for instance, America defines treason so narrowly that nobody has been convicted of it since WW2. Americans are free to sing praise of China, Russia, North Korea, whoever they like no matter how unjustified. Unless Congress has declared a war, which hasn't happened since WW2, you can talk as much smack about America or praise opposing regimes as much as you like.
- waffleiron 11mo agoIt doesn’t matter if its called Treason, for example the Rosenbergs were executed for espionage. Aiding and abetting what the US saw was foreign harm.
- BurningFrog 11mo agoNot just any espionage. They gave the Soviets the atomic bomb designs, permanently changing the global power balance!
- greedo 11mo agoThe Soviets would have developed the atomic bomb (and eventually the hydrogen bomb). This simply accelerated their development. And considering that for the first decade after the end of WW2 the US considered and threatened the USSR with nuclear annihilation frequently, this is probably a good development...
- beepbooptheory 11mo agoOh yes, I'm sure we all can easily enumerate the times America has effectively called out the "evil abroad." And such instances have all indeed survived the scrutiny of history/retrospection no less!
- colejhudson 11mo agoYou’re literally just restating OPs point but with heavy sarcasm.
- beepbooptheory 11mo agoYep! It's meant to indicate the absurdity of the point. Probably not my best form, but for a state that murdered literally millions of people the first two decades of this millennium, I would of hoped the intent would have been more obvious here.
- GuinansEyebrows 11mo agoevery president who ever invoked the "city on a hill" metaphor was simultaneously responsible for acts of unprecedented evil in foreign countries; from JFK in southeast asia, to reagan in the middle east and central america, to obama's drone strikes in the middle east.
- deleted 11mo ago[deleted]
- paganel 11mo agoBy “calling out” you mean invading, or what, exactly? And haven’t you guys had enough of fighting “evil” while causing the deaths of hundreds of thousands of civilians? See Iraq.
- mikkupikku 11mo agoAssuming that somebody is implying something as insane as an invasion of China when they say something as mellow as "call out" is certainly.. a take.
- netbioserror 11mo agoSo then what use is any other approach than simply letting it happen? Words are just that. If violence is out, then the only other approach is escalating the trade war and Chinese isolation, at great cost.
- mikkupikku 11mo agoIf your only plan is invading China, you don't have a plan.
- netbioserror 11mo agoPrecisely, and I'm saying there is no other good plan. If the cost of defending democratic values worldwide is starting WW3, we simply can't defend democratic values worldwide anymore.
- deleted 11mo ago[deleted]
- colejhudson 11mo agoObviously not. As in the 20th century, it means to cultivate moral, and thereby political, opposition to imprisoning activists. It’s a soft power the US has gradually lost.
- HSO 11mo agonever was it was always BS now everybody can see thats the only difference
- JumpCrisscross 11mo agoThe aspiration was always BS? I think we have fairly concrete historical records showing the opposite.
- throwaw12 11mo ago[flagged]
- ericmay 11mo agoDang, you're right. America is evil, so we might as well keep doing evil stuff since we're already evil. :)
- throwaw12 11mo ago@ericmay, you are not wrong, its already doing a lot of evil, I am from one of those countries destroyed by the US. its less evil when country economically destroyed (with sanctions), but its another thing when some of your relatives killed because some people wanted to play with their gun and shoot real people, for sport.
- barfoure 11mo ago“As the HN poster proudly clicks on the reply button having delivered a blow to the vast ignorance of a stranger, a train arrives somewhere deep in rural China carrying Uyghurs ready for their re-education.”
- FlyingBears 11mo agoIf we just admit to it and do it anyway, we won't have to masquerade with democracy theatrics.
- leptons 11mo agoAlready happened - they renamed "Department of Defense" to "Department of War".
- throwaway29812 11mo agoYou didn't define evil, which I think was on purpose. The United States does a lot of things with its military. But it does not jail elderly political opponents and sentence them to death for being a threat to the regime.
- 11mo ago
- mytailorisrich 11mo agoIn the "good old days" it was like that: "The colonial government used the Control of Publications Consolidation Ordinance (1951) to regulate publications and suppress freedom of the press. One notable case resulted in the suppression of the newspaper Ta Kung Pao for six months (later reduced to 12 days) for its criticism of the colonial government's deportation of the Federation of Trade Unions-backed fire relief organisation officials and use of live fire against protestors. Deportation was also used as a method to control politics in education. Lo Tong, a principal at a pro-Beijing, patriotic middle school, had been deported in 1950 for raising the People's Republic of China (PRC) flag and singing the national anthem at his school." [1] Now of course we'd all prefer Western-style freedoms but the narrative on HK is highly skewed and hypocritical, with HK used as a pawn in the broader anti-China narrative. Even Singapore isn't exactly rosy but it is a friend of the West so it's fine. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_in_Hong_Kong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_in_Hong_Kong
- xbmcuser 11mo ago"Most of it is a lie that they tell their own citizens, though, as America and the West only want democracy and promote it for their own ends. They destroy any democracy that might not align with their worldview or serve their interests. The current administration is overtly doing what was previously done covertly. Dictators are acceptable as long as it is politically convenient. One of the most recent cases is Pakistan, where the army has taken over, and EU and Commonwealth election monitors did not issue even election monitor report even after two years. Instead, they have facilitated the murder and killing of Pakistani civilians. But maybe Pakistanis are brown-skinned, so for them, democracy is not allowed. Pakistan should be under sanctions, but it is not, as it is providing ammunition for Ukraine. That is the biggest problem of the West: their hypocrisy. They are calling for democracy in Hong Kong, as that serves their own agendas, but will say nothing about an apartheid state like Israel." "Imran Khan, the former prime minister, has been jailed without trial for the last two-plus years and has been kept in solitary confinement for months out of those. How many newspapers mention it in the West or make it a news topic? But this Hong Kong (HK) Jimmy Lai conviction will be the headlines in most of the Western media a clear example of propaganda to rile up the population against China and socialism. This is why I laugh when people here on Hacker News mention China's control of media and its propaganda, when the Western media is no better than them. At least many Chinese citizens know they are being propagandized against and can filter it out."
- xyzal 11mo agoCan you imagine a Chinese person writing like you just did on Weibo? Democracy/liberalism/civil liberties etc. isn't 100% or not at all.
- benmmurphy 11mo agoThat reminds me of an old cold war joke. In China you are free to criticise western governments on Weibo. What is the problem?
- snapcaster 11mo agoThis feels very dismissive. The comment you responded is about the very real killing of a lot of people and your response is "at least we can talk about it?" Being free to talk about the horrible things happening doesn't appear to stop them from happening so what exactly is your point here?
- lacy_tinpot 11mo agoIt's not our aspirations that we've lost. It's the entrenchment of a particular kind of parasitic elite. The logic that made them into "elites" has turned in on itself and is now self-cannibalizing. The saving grace is only the capacity for the American people to see through this, but with the derangement of information pathways we're increasingly at the behest of these people and their narratives that only serve their aggrandizement. All the talk about "saving the west" or "individualism" or the some other talk of spirit that these preachers sermon about, is only to serve themselves and no one else. "Calling out evil" is another one of those victims to their self-serving motivations. Along with "climate change", "environmentalism", "democracy", "freedom", or a whole host of otherwise genuinely noble causes.
- glenstein 11mo agoExactly right. And what's more, I think this is cynically exploited by apologists who want to defend evil by resorting to whataboutisms. State sponsored troll farms are real and the market for buying and selling, and mobilizing accounts is increasingly mature. And even, dare I say, strategically and intellectually sophisticated in some ways while simultaneously being intellectually and ethically bankrupt. But I actually don't think it's that hard to understand that (1) the US has significantly compromised moral authority, but also (2) China bad and (3) there's important differences of scale of moral offense depending on what you are talking about. You can land a perfectly coherent point about, say, China's hostile takeover of Hong Kong being bad, it's military ramp up to seize Taiwan by 2027 being bad. But too often, I think bad faith actors will intentionally exploit the complexity to try and muddy the waters, and the only reason it seems like it's hard to articulate the distinction online is because of motivated performances. Of course there Poe's law element too, which is that you should never underestimate the ability of people online becoming confused about politically charged topics, but in this case I think it's a bit of column a, a bit of column b synergistically amplifying one another.
- erxam 11mo agoEvil? Rooting out traitors and compradors is evil now? I guess it is, since it goes against American interests. I don't really know why everyone is crying for him, he knew exactly who he was playing for.
- hearsathought 11mo ago[flagged]
- testdelacc1 11mo agoReally weird bringing religion into this discussion. Don’t be weird.
- hearsathought 11mo ago[flagged]
- jandrese 11mo agoSomeone can be and asshole and still be right. It will be harder to convince other people to go along with you if you are an asshole, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't call out wrongdoing when you see it.
- maxglute 11mo agoSomething less effective about ass holes doing wrong things complaining about other assholes doing wrong things, a while insisting they're not assholes. Ultimately the "damage" isn't being called out as a hypocritic asshole, it's the world realize there's nothing wrong with said wrong things. Although to some that's not damage but nature healing.
- ngruhn 11mo agoBut you're word doesn't really have weight, if you did the same thing 10min ago.
- glenstein 11mo agoWhich is a fair charge of ethical character, but not of truth. What makes whataboutism a fallacious rhetorical move is not that it fails to identify someone's ethical shortcomings, but that it tries to substitute them for subject matter. The logic of whataboutism is fascinating, because as long as someone is deemed a bad enough actor, their statements have the effect of dynamically rewriting reality in real time to be the opposite of whatever Bad Actor says. Which, to my mind, gives them too much power. It's simpler to just believe in objective reality, believe that language works roughly according to a correspondence theory of truth and that statements are or are not legitimate on account of their corresponding to reality, which isn't something you can determine based on character alone. But I admit on some level this might be a misunderstanding of whataboutism, because it's holding it to a standard of intellectual consistency that it's not aspiring to.
- pandaman 11mo agoA "whataboutism" defense only works in an argument that goes like this: A:"You should stop doing X because X is wrong and evil and you are wrong and evil if you continue doing X!" B:"But you beat your wife." Where X != "beating one's wife". Here the B's argument is: "But you do X yourself!". This is not an attack on moral character but a direct refutation of A's argument. If A really thought X is wrong and evil then A would not be doing X. And if A really considers itself wrong and evil then it should be figuring a way to stop doing X first, or, at least, concurrently with demanding that from B. Either way, A is not very persuasive.
- BurningFrog 11mo agoNot everything is about Trump!
- IAmBroom 11mo agoTrue. But he will somehow find a way to make it about him.
- SilverElfin 11mo agoAmerica was on the decline for a while already. Look at how forgotten Tibet is. Why would HK be any different when a treaty was signed to hand it over? It’s more official than Tibet which was just annexed through force. Although it’s worth remembering that China has violated the terms of the HK treaty as well. Also as a reminder, back in 1993 Richard Gere was banned from the Oscars for 20 years for advocating for Tibet (https://www.foxnews.com/media/richard-gere-speaks-out-nearly-20-year-oscars-absence-controversial-tibet-comments https://www.foxnews.com/media/richard-gere-speaks-out-nearly...). American institutions have been declining/corrupted for a lot longer than the current administration.
- angry_octet 11mo agoTibet is clear-cut annexation of a sovereign country. HK / New Territories was only leased, and it wasn't going to be practical to keep it longer. The problem is that Beijing no longer needed HK as a gateway, the US/EU had already embraced going directly to the mainland to do deals by the early 2000s. The HK I knew was already gone by 2014.
- brazukadev 11mo ago> America was on the decline for a while already. Look at how forgotten Tibet is. First, look how forgotten Puerto Rico is.
- ta20240528 11mo agoA healthy reminder that Hawaii became a US state AFTER Tibet became a Chinese province. An lest one suggest that it was the result of a peaceful referendum, know that the US congres apologised for the entire project, including the migration of mainland Americans who helped swing the referendum.
- jameslk 11mo ago> One of the dark consequences of America losing its city-upon-a-hill aspirations is we're less able to effectively call out evil abroad. "City-upon-a-hill" is marketing and has never been grounded in fact. It’s hubris and arrogance. The US is viewed as that place if you get on the wrong side of, it will bomb you or replace your government through coercion. It outspends every country on "defense" to ensure this. History is littered with plenty of examples where the US favored a more authoritarian or "evil" government over less, sometimes even installing them. Arab Spring is a recent example where you saw governments replaced with the US' help, while leaving some notable monarchies alone. In reality, the US employs its foreign policy for its own interests. It’s always been like that.
- epistasis 11mo agoThe Arab Spring is a bad example if you're trying to say that the US is installing governments... South America's history provides far better examples. That said, the US doesn't need to be perfect to still be an example of providing freedom for its own citizens.
- jameslk 11mo agoThere’s a lot of examples, yes in South America too, but the US helped replace or tried to help replace some governments during the Arab Spring. Libya being the biggest example, where the US and its allies imposed a no fly zone to help topple a dictator it didn’t like [0]. It could have done that in other places, but you didn’t hear a peep from the US when those protests were crushed by their governments during the Arab Spring. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_military_intervention_in_Libya https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_military_intervention_in_...
- epistasis 11mo agoLibya is a super super bad example if you're looking for bad US behavior. This is literally the very first sentence of your own source: > On 19 March 2011, a NATO-led coalition began a military intervention into the ongoing Libyan Civil War to implement United Nations Security Council Resolution 1973 (UNSCR 1973). Compared to the South America stuff, this is saintly and angelic behavior helping out the world in every way. It's not the US alone, it's a coalition that expands beyond NATO, there's a UN resolution... In fact bringing this up as a "bad behavior" example proves just how much of a shining city on a hill the US has been around the world. It's been bad, but it's also done lots of good stuff.
- reenorap 11mo agoWhy is America all of a sudden part of this? HK was a British colony, what is the UK doing to preserve freedom in HK?
- A_D_E_P_T 11mo agoThe UK's having a hard enough time trying to preserve freedom in the UK. Hold up... So you're saying that they're actually not trying to preserve freedom in the UK and have arrested hundreds of people over twitter memes?! In all seriousness, you're approximately as free in HK as you are in the UK. In HK, don't promote democracy or insult the government in Beijing. In the UK, don't suggest that diversity isn't Our Greatest Strength. Every society these days has an untouchable third rail. None are without beams in their own eyes.
- luxpir 11mo agoThe discussion has devolved to such a point that people from outside the UK keep parroting this (likely Kremlin originated) line that the UK is now a Muslim stronghold with no free speech when in reality it just continues to uphold the values it has influenced the world with, one of the few positives from its dark past, of protecting those unable to protect themselves. Hate speech and punching down. As if inciting violence is completely harmless and no bad ever comes of it. Many freedom-focused people without direct experience of disability, bullying or discrimination have no way to relate to that concept, and the echo chamber amplifies the intellectually dishonest takes until they take hold. Which is exactly what the angry, seething, downtrodden richest people in the world seem to want right now. I wonder why. What a sorry, hopeless state we've allowed to happen. Everyone is entitled to an opinion, sure, but the ones who've worked hardest to develop theirs should be weighted the most. Now a Russian bot has the same value on a platform as a nuclear scientist or, dare I say it, a real journalist. Because it's entertaining and tickles some dangling dopamine receptors. I'm sure people will wind their necks in when the ultimate result has finally played out and we'll cycle back to cooler heads prevailing, but I fear we'll have to go there first before we get back. Yes I took the bait, but no regrets, I'll die on this hill. Hate bullies and liars with a passion.
- keybored 11mo agoThat this is the top comment says all you need to know about this board. Being a city on the hill is a cudgel, not a halo. It’s always been used in a self-serving way, and always against enemies. Who is someone who points out the flaws of their enemies but never the flaws of themselves or their friends, even though they are all equally likely to commit the same crimes?[1] That is a scoundrel. Not someone that anyone needs to wait to Call Out anyone on anything. That it is (in this context) a self-admitted “aspiration” is the laughable part. No one else gets credit for “aspiring” (just words) to be a city on a hill. Except if it’s us. [1] Being generous here.