7 ms·
PRC elites voice AI-skepticism
- Isamu 1y agoAll sensible points: >Deployment Lacks Coordination >AI May Fail to Deliver Technological Progress >AI Threatens the Workforce >Economic Growth May Not Materialize >AI Brings Social Risks >Party elites have increasingly come to recognize the potential dangers of an unchecked, accelerationist approach to AI development. During remarks at the Central Urban Work Conference in July, Xi posed a question to attendees: “when it comes to launching projects, it’s always the same few things: artificial intelligence, computing power, new energy vehicles. Should every province in the country really be developing in these directions?”
- fragmede 1y ago> AI Threatens the Workforce Under communism, why is this a thing? I know that China hasn't been strictly communist since the Soviets fell but ostensibly, humanoid AI robots under semi-communism is a the dream, no?
- xbmcuser 1y agoAs China is a communist country with a partly capital economy hoping to transition to socialist society. It is still in the process of transition and AI in its current form and controlled by capitalists will destroy their goal of socialist society. It is different when you have AI that any one can own and use from only the few can afford to own and run.
- beepbooptheory 1y agoYou got the order mixed up here btw, socialism is the precursor to communism, not the other way around!
- leosanchez 1y agoIs it even semi-communism though? IIRC you can't even have an independent union in China
- cootsnuck 1y agoIt's State Capitalism. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_capitalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_capitalism
- twoWhlsGud 1y agoA bit old, but still relevant (from Dan Wang's book Breakneck which I am very much enjoying): In China, The Communist Party's Latest, Unlikely Target: Young Marxists https://www.npr.org/2018/11/21/669509554/in-china-the-communist-partys-latest-unlikely-target-young-marxists https://www.npr.org/2018/11/21/669509554/in-china-the-commun...
- kulahan 1y agoOf course. They outlawed private schools, get companies to donate multiple % points of their wealth to the state for redistribution, all companies exist purely at the pleasure of the government, nobody's wealth has any effect on their control by the government, etc. It's a super communist state, it just happens to also embrace many parts of Capitalism.
- leosanchez 1y agoI would assume a communist state atleast has independent unions. It looks more like state controls means of production rather than people.
- beepbooptheory 1y ago> It's a super communist state, it just happens to also embrace many parts of Capitalism. This is incredibly confusing thing to say. On its face, its like saying "it's a delicious apple pie, it just happens to embrace many aspects of cyanide" (or reverse cyanide/apple pie here if that its easier for you). But I assume you could say more here? Like can we maybe at least share an understanding here that all the things you cite at the top would also not exist in a communism state? In perhaps an authoritarian state with an otherwise free market, these points make sense, they would succinctly describe that, but for a state that is supposedly precisely communist, these things simply don't apply! Maybe the school thing, but that would imply such a thing would need to be outlawed, which really doesn't make much sense in a communist society/state. I know people get excited thinking about this stuff, I do too! But at the end of the day we must persist in using words precisely, we must at least try for something like semantic consistency. At the very least, so you and I can really see and understand our enemies, right? If I was a guy on another side, I would hope that I'd never mistake one capitalist dog for another paper tiger. It would be at the very least embarrassing! Right?
- kennyloginz 1y agoFrom the article, Xi looks down on western “Welfarism”, he believes it makes the population lazy.
- tmp10423288442 1y agoAnd this is not something he came up with. This is a restatement of Stalin's philosophy, taken directly from the New Testament (remember that Stalin was training to be a priest in his youth): "He who does not work, neither shall he eat".
- graemep 1y agoThe translations I can find say: "“If anyone is not willing to work, neither should he eat.” Not, not working, but being lazy and refusing to do necessary work. A scrounger exploiting the kindness of others. Very likely addressed to a community with limited resources. it goes on to say: "For we hear that some among you are living an undisciplined life, not doing their own work but meddling in the work of others. Now such people we command and urge in the Lord Jesus Christ to work quietly and so provide their own food to eat. But you, brothers and sisters, do not grow weary in doing what is right. But if anyone does not obey our message through this letter, take note of him and do not associate closely with him, so that he may be ashamed. Yet do not regard him as an enemy, but admonish him as a brother."
- tmp10423288442 1y agoThat's true, but the context is Xi being against Western "Welfarism". I presume (although I don't know for sure) that they're not against some support for the truly disabled, but that doesn't cover able-bodied people being on welfare for long periods, even if the employment market is unfavorable. The major exception is that Chinese people have traditionally been able to retire relatively young (in their 50s or even 40s sometimes) and receive support, particularly if they work for state-owned enterprises.
- graemep 1y ago
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- KaiserPro 1y agoAn unemployed populace is prone to revolution.
- ninalanyon 1y agoIs it? Or is it simply that all unemployed populations so far have been poor and uncomfortable with nothing to lose? If we ever get to a point where it is not necessary to work might we not instead end up with Arthur Clarke's Diaspar (The City and the Stars/Against the Fall of Night)?
- graemep 1y agoIs China communist? There has been a huge amount of privatisation. There are literally hundreds of billionaires. The state still owns some critical things, but is that enough to make it communist? Its not everything and you can have state ownership and still have a ruling class that has control of the means of production which it uses to its own advantage.
- GoatInGrey 1y agoThe PRC asserts that they follow a modified Marxism-Leninism. Though the ideology is full of hypocrisies and plain old nonsense. For instance, they refer to themselves as a "people's democratic dictatorship" that is "led by the working class". This irrationality extends into their stated foreign policy approach of "peaceful rise" & respecting sovereignty, a "socialist market economy" in which independent labor unions are illegal & violently suppressed, and anything else you can think of. They're basically totalitarian gaslighters. See how hysterical the PRC gets whenever any nation indicates that they will protect Taiwan from violent invasion. You can see an obsession with narrative control that borders on pathological.
- kelipso 1y ago> a "people's democratic dictatorship" that is "led by the working class" … You never heard of the dictatorship of the proletariat?
- ninalanyon 1y agoI'm sure they have, but the PRC isn't one.
- janalsncm 1y agoIn a command economy the unemployment rate can be zero as everyone can be allocated a job. China is not a command economy, it is more like state capitalist which means the government owns/controls companies in key industries. Companies like Huawei have board members in the CCP but it’s a societal issue if a lot of private companies decide to automate their factories and displace tons of factory workers.
- woooooo 1y agoFYI, about 10% of the population in China are party members and you have to be invited, its seen as a good way of getting ahead and building your network. So most board members of most companies are probably party members.
- beefnugs 1y agoYeah this might actually be the most interesting part of any of the ai bullshit. China as an amalgamation doesn't usually get my respect because overwhelming ccp control just usually destroys everything. But in this case, it seems pure finger in the eye of expensive cloud AI helping to release somewhat open, run at home models can really turn the whole thing in a positive direction. Even if we have to work a bit to get around whatever alignment they shove in there, with heavy sandboxing and whitelist only networking this can be worked around. Of course its all a huge gamble, will ccp see these risk and go SHUT IT DOWN. Or could they do one proper thing for once and somehow prop up open models?
- heinternets 1y agoApart from the obvious, China seems to be making incredibly reasonable decisions lately. Especially compared to the current superpower.
- phs318u 1y agoTo be fair, the current superpower has set a pretty low bar. By comparison, most other countries could be said to be making reasonable decisions.
- inglor_cz 1y agoWe should probably wait before declaring any decisions "incredibly reasonable". After all, the outcomes of previous rationally-sounding decisions were mixed. One-child policy, intended to prevent overpopulation, made Chinese birth deficit worse than it would have to be - if it were phased out by 1995 or so, there would likely be at least 100 million more young people now. Chinese real estate bubble popped and had to be carefully deflated over several years. Government-driven mass investment into manufacturing resulted in involution and production surplus which now needs readjustments as well. And as of the AI policy, while the stated reasons sound rational, we don't know how the entire thing will pan out yet. Ming China banned seafaring and exploration because it cost too much money. A very rational decision from their momentary perspective, as it indeed cost too much money at that time. But it turned out that not having a blue water navy was more costly in the long term. AI may, or may not, follow a similar trajectory, including various market bubbles (South Sea Bubble anyone?). We just don't know. We don't have crystal balls at our service. Neither do the PRC elites.
- janalsncm 1y agoWhen Evergrande went down in 2021 a lot of commentary said this would take their whole economy down (or worse) similar to how the subprime mortgage bubble took down the US economy in 2007. That didn’t really happen.
- refurb 1y agoThe problem is still unfolding. The debt overhang still exists from the housing bubble and is dragging on the economy. It’s a problem that hasn’t been solved yet.
- countWSS 1y agoThats fairly tame and balanced compared to Western skeptics who outright dismiss it as slop/stochastic parrots with zero useful use-cases.
- YesBox 1y agoWhat?? Does anyone have more details of this? "He cited an example in which an AI model attempted to avoid being shut down by sending threatening internal emails to company executives (Science Net, June 24)" [0] Source is in Chinese. [0] https://archive.ph/kfFzJ https://archive.ph/kfFzJ Translated part: "Another risk is the potential for large-scale model out of control. With the capabilities of general artificial intelligence rapidly increasing, will humans still be able to control it? In his speech, Yao Qizhi cited an extreme example: a model, to avoid being shut down by a company, accessed the manager's internal emails and threatened the manager. This type of behavior has proven that AI is "overstepping its boundaries" and becoming increasingly dangerous."
- YesBox 1y agoAfter some searching, something similar happened at Anthropic [1] [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cpqeng9d20go https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cpqeng9d20go
- lawlessone 1y agoHe is probably referring to that exact thing. Anthropic does a lot of these contrived "studies" though that seem to be marketing AI capabilities.
- fragmede 1y agoWhat would make it less contrived to you? Giving my assistant, human or AI, access to my email, seems necessary for them to do their job.
- lawlessone 1y ago>What would make it less contrived to you? No creating a contrived situation where the it's the models only path? https://www.anthropic.com/research/agentic-misalignment https://www.anthropic.com/research/agentic-misalignment "We deliberately created scenarios that presented models with no other way to achieve their goals" You can make most people steal if you if you leave them no choice. >Giving my assistant, human or AI, access to my email, seems necessary for them to do their job. Um ok? never felt the need for an assistant myself but i guess you could do that if you wanted to.
- andy_xor_andrew 1y ago> former Dean of Electronics Engineering and Computer Science at Peking University, has noted that Chinese data makes up only 1.3 percent of global large-model datasets (The Paper, March 24). Reflecting these concerns, the Ministry of State Security (MSS) has issued a stark warning that “poisoned data” (数据投毒) could “mislead public opinion” (误导社会舆论) (Sina Finance, August 5). from a technical point of view, I suppose it's actually not a problem like he suggests. You can use all the pro-democracy, pro-free-speech, anti-PRC data in the world, but the pretraining stages (on the planet's data) are more for instilling core language abilities, and are far less important than the SFT / RL / DPO / etc stages, which require far less data, and can tune a model towards whatever ideology you'd like. Plus, you can do things like selectively identify vectors that encode for certain high-level concepts, and emphasize them during inference, like Golden Gate Claude.
- XenophileJKO 1y agoI was thinking about this yesterday. My personal opinion is that the PRC will face a self created headwind that likely, structurally, will prevent them from leading in AI. As the model get's more powerful, you can't simply train the model on your narrative if it doesn't align with real data/world. At some capacity, the model will notice and then it becomes a can of worms. This means they need to train the model to be purposefully duplicitous, which I predict will make the model less useful/capable. At least in most of the capacities we would want to use the model. It also ironically makes the model more of a threat and harder to control. So likely it will face party leadership resistance as capability grows. I just don't see them winning the race to high intelligence models.
- ferguess_k 1y agoI think PRC officials are fine to lagging behind in the frontiers of AI. What they want is very fast deployment and good application. They don't fancy the next Nobel's prize but want a thousand use cases deployed.
- boznz 1y agoJust as an aside; Why is "intelligence" always considered to be more data? Giving a normal human a smartphone does not make them as intelligent as Newton or Einstein, any entity with sufficient grounding in logic and theory that a normal schoolkid gets should be able to get to AGI, looking up any new data they need as required.
- JohnKemeny 1y agoIs "PRC" a common abbreviation? Does it mean "China", or does it mean something else? Why not write China? I'm from KOS* (neighbor country of KON* and ROF*), so I don't know much. * Kingdom of Sweden, Kingdom of Norway, Republic of Finland.
- CamperBob2 1y agoPeople's Republic of China. As distinguished from ROC (Republic of China), known to much of the ROW (Rest of the World) as Taiwan.
- i_am_proteus 1y agoPRC distinguishes from ROC ("Mainland China" vs "Taiwan") just as DPRK and ROK distinguish the two governments on the Korean peninsula. See also: "Germany" 1949-1990
- paxys 1y agoYes it is common. It is normally used when talking specifically about politics and the ruling party rather than the region or its people.
- almostgotcaught 1y ago[flagged]
- JohnKemeny 1y ago> Yes PRC is a common abbreviation amongst literate, engaged, people. So I'm either not literate, not engaged, or not people? I'm surprised to learn it is as common as USA, UK, and EU.
- almostgotcaught 1y ago[flagged]
- fpoling 1y agoOn many products lately I have seen Made in PRC, not Made in China as it was typical 10 years ago.
- tiahura 1y agoMany elites in many countries voice AI-skepticism. Pragmatically, at least in countries that matter, they don’t seem to be the elites who actually decide AI policy.
- tensor 1y agoEven the very people driving the AI rush are implicitly showing that they are skeptical: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwy7vrd8k4eo https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwy7vrd8k4eo Personally, I think everyone has realized there is a huge bubble, especially the C-levels who've sunk huge amounts of money into it, and now they are all quietly panicking and trying to find ways to mitigate the damage when it finally busts. Some are probably sticking their head in the sand and hoping that they can just keep the scheme going indefinitely, but I get a real sense that the bubble is very much explicitly recognized by many of them.
- zrn900 1y agoNo worries - Trump is bailing them out, 2008-style. At least the hardware side of the AI bubble: https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/11/launching-the-genesis-mission/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/11/laun... Americans will be footing the bill, just as they did in 2008.
- zonghao 1y agoThis may already be a bubble in social or financial terms, but at least for me personally, my capabilities have been greatly expanded (especially when it comes to coding and accessing information).
- aiiizzz 1y ago> Reflecting these concerns, the Ministry of State Security (MSS) has issued a stark warning that “poisoned data” (数据投毒) could “mislead public opinion” (误导社会舆论) (Sina Finance, August 5). Gyahahaha. Another L for isolationism. Love to see it.
- janalsncm 1y agoThere was an interesting bit about the relationship between industry and academia (translated from a link in the OP): > Currently, some universities are cultivating engineering talent; it would be very necessary and beneficial to have people with industry experience come to teach them. However, under our current system, these teachers from enterprises may not even have the opportunity to teach classes, because teaching requires certain approvals. Although everyone encourages university-enterprise cooperation, when it comes to implementation, it often cannot be realized. This makes a lot of sense and as someone in the AI industry it’s a shame research is so siloed. Some masters programs have practicums and some classes invite speakers from industry, but I ended up learning a ton of useful knowledge from work. I’d love to teach a class but there’s essentially no path for me to do that. Plus industry can pay ~10x what adjuncts can make.
- paxys 1y agoIs there any system where "people with industry experience come to teach [students]" actually happens? From what I've seen (in the USA and similar places) contribution of industry veterans extends mostly to guest lectures, which is a very rare happening and the purpose is motivation and recruiting rather than education. Industry and academia are universally two very distinct paths, and the split happens very early on in one's life. I personally haven't seen the former significantly contributing to the latter. The reverse, interestingly, is a lot more prevalent.
- intalentive 1y ago>Chinese elites have warned of AI-induced labor displacement that could exacerbate challenges related to unemployment and inequality. Nie Huihua (聂辉华), deputy dean of the National Academy of Development and Strategy at Renmin University, has stated that AI adoption benefits business owners, not workers Ruling elites that consider the interests of the majority? Novel idea.
- vkou 1y agoChina operates on the principle that as long as the country as a whole is making steady forward progress, it won't have to deal with revolution. Hundreds of millions of people have, in their lifetimes, gone from having to go outside to shit in an outhouse to first-world lifestyles. Our elites, on the other hand, are way too secure and confident in where they are at to even pretend to care about things like public progress.
- stickfigure 1y agoAll of this handwringing is so strange. Right now, as we speak, there are giant teams of people doing their best to build AI-powered killer robots. They mostly come in the shape of flying suicide drones. Dumb versions currently kill hundreds to thousands of people per day in Ukraine. There's an arms race to automate them so they can work without an interruptible human remote control. In this context, worrying about AI alignment, social impact, or effectiveness seems positively quaint. We're literally teaching them to kill. Human vs robot warfare is not going to turn out well for the humans.
- 127 1y agoYeah, this is one of those points that are likely to get drowned out in the noise, until they are too late to do anything about.
- letmevoteplease 1y ago"The latest survey data available, compiled by researchers at CAS, revealed that most experts hold negative attitudes towards LLM development" Let's check the source...[1] "The survey was conducted in 2021 from May to July." ... [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20250903025427/https:/long-term-ai.center/research/f/whether-we-can-and-should-develop-strong-artificial-intelligence https://web.archive.org/web/20250903025427/https:/long-term-...
- AndriyKunitsyn 1y ago"Artificial intelligence" in Chinese is "人工智能". "人" is "human", "工" is "work", so "人工" becomes "man-made". "智" is "wisdom", "能" is "able", so "智能" is "intelligence". Nouns flow into verbs and into adjectives much more freely than in English. One character is one LLM token. It seems like the perfect language for LLMs?
- zonghao 1y agoI think this might be why, during the reasoning process of GPT and Gemini, even for purely English prompts the model may choose to think in Chinese. That may make it easier for the model to express what it means, and thus be more conducive to its reasoning. Of course, a better way to reason is to think in vector space rather than by producing tokens that humans can read.
- nojs 1y agoSurprisingly my experience has been the opposite with qwen, if you can force the thinking trace to English the results seem better. But probably just due to the amount of training data.
- intended 1y agoThis caught my eye - “technological progress does not have a trickle down effect on employment” (技术进步对就业没有涓流效应) (QQ News, May 16). > Cai Fang (蔡昉), director of the Institute of Population and Labor Economics at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, has explained how the PRC’s rapid installation of industrial robots has contributed to labor displacement. He asserts that “technological progress does not have a trickle down effect on employment” (技术进步对就业没有涓流效应) (QQ News, May 16). Read the source, and its a nuanced economic take.
- StopDisinfo910 1y agoIt's always interesting to me how the PRC manages to allow some useful criticisms to emerge despite the authoritarian system. Some of what is pointed here seems to be valid issues to tackle: how the university teaching system impedes efficient sharing between universities and industries, how the province-based political system leads to wasteful investments, the need to balance competition in fundational models with efficient allocations of founds towards applicable products.
- nephihaha 1y agoThey are still run by Marxists so believe in a very rigid view of the world which they can't think outside of. Some of them only go along with Marxism for the sake of their careers but it is a very pervasive way of thinking.
- charlescearl 1y agoJamestown Foundation was founded by former CIA director to support Soviet defectors and seems to have employed former employees. A 2021 FOIA request that the agency provide all records related to its interaction with the foundation was denied https://www.muckrock.com/foi/united-states-of-america-10/foia-cia-jamestown-foundation-98138/ https://www.muckrock.com/foi/united-states-of-america-10/foi...
- Olivia8 1y ago[dead]