11 ms·
Smartphones manipulate our emotions and trigger our reflexes
- n4bz0r 1y ago[flagged]
- hooverd 1y agowhat doesn't, at some point?
- quacked 1y agoBo Burnham put it succinctly, although he was talking about children on apps: "When they go to sleep at night, they have to choose between all of the information ever published in the history of the world, or the back of their eyelids." The smartphone is a perverted implementation of the goal that people use to fantasize about back in the early days of the computer revolution: a personal terminal to the world of audio, text, and video information stored in databases across all of humanity. It's of course worth talking about how they compel us to certain behaviors via push notifications, dark patterns, nasty design, etc. but also--obviously we'd be addicted to personal terminals that let us access all the publicly available digitized information in the history of the world.
- samrus 1y agoI think the access to so much information itself isnt bad. Cuz access to all of wikipedia wouldnt do this. People would get bored because its still work to digest that information I think this access gave opportunities to bad actors whose incentives are misalligned with society's. Social media companies. They use this opportunity to serve us easily digestible garbage thats going to get us hooked. Its a not some grand and malicious conspiracy or anything. Greed is just a part of capitalism. Before, people loved getting others hooked on drugs because it made them so much money. People who like capitalism know this is a bug in the system that needs to be patched with regulations. We stopped putting cocaine in coca cola. We just need to stop putting brainrot garbage in our kids information feeds. We need to penalize companies for these greed driven addiction algorithms. Itll be hard, but its what needs to be done and we can do it if we have enough societal willpower
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 1y agoI agree but it's too entwined with "freedom of speech" and section 230. Many here make too much money addicting children and don't want to turn off the fire hose of money.
- hooverd 1y agoThat just makes it So the big boys who are making all this money can continue to operate while small platforms can no longer afford to comply with the new regulatory environment.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 1y agoI don't buy it. The internet existed before the carve out and was in fact less centralized and less shitty
- kmeisthax 1y agoSo, do you remember the Wolf of Wall Street? AKA Jordan Belfort. Huge fraudster, did shittons of financial crime. People on Prodigy and Compuserve forums were talking about it, and so Jordan Belfort decided to sue the shit out of the companies in order to take the speech down and censor the users talking about him. The resulting caselaw we got out of this mess was that Prodigy's moderated servers were treated as publisher and assigned defamation liability; while Compuserve, being unmoderated, had no such liability. CDA 230 was written specifically to overturn the Prodigy verdict. So repealing it would put us in a place where Internet forums are either totally censored and sanitized, or completely unregulated messes of spam and garbage. No middle ground.
- ericmcer 1y agoIt isn't even a perverted implementation, we just overestimated ourselves. All our sci-fi futurism of the 70s/80s showed enlightened humans elevating themselves with technology. In real Star Trek the holo deck would be used for porn, the computer would be used to play shitty podcasts while they procrastinated work and the replicator would be churning out donuts and fried foods. It's philosophically a weird time, because we are more socially progressive than ever before, but we have a nonstop flow of evidence that people cannot self-govern. It feels paradoxical to demand freedom and protection from your own impulses at the same time.
- noduerme 1y agoI don't know that anyone's really asking for protection from their own impulses. Freedom requires protection from other people's impulses. That's where this is all going. A few truly free people, everyone else in a cage.
- wlesieutre 1y agoRather than framing it as "protection from my own impulses," I think it's more fair to frame it as "protection from teams of professional researchers and engineers and marketers whose entire life's work is fine tuning how to most effectively profit from my impulses"
- noduerme 1y agoWell, yeah, but that type of protection isn't compatible with freedom. Neither the freedom to consume nor the freedom to iterate on a product. I don't blame companies for making their products addictive. I smoke cigarettes. I drink. Sometimes I crave a Big Mac. I don't blame them for selling me poison, as long as I recognize it as unhealthy. The best way to protect yourself is by educating yourself to recognize manipulative patterns, and by extension sharing that with other people. We know from drug addiction that simply banning something doesn't work. And an insight from some great druggies like Philip K Dick and Hunter Thompson and Burroughs is that the list of things that can be addictive is endless. If someone made an app that made people chew their nails, or lick an escalator banister, or shock themselves with electricity, people would get addicted to it. I was hypnotized a few times as a child by a professional hypnotist. When in college I was invited to a "seminar" which turned out to be a cult indoctrination session, I immediately recognized what I was seeing the group leader doing to the audience. We don't need external protection, we need herd immunity. It's like"give a man a fish" vs "teach a man to fish".
- teekert 1y agoWith a smartphone you do not only give the internet to a kid, you are also giving the kid to the internet.
- the_snooze 1y agoIt's not even just children in safe situations like bedtime. I regularly see adults crossing the street typing on their phones while having headphones on.
- tcfhgj 1y agoDo you have to be worried being killed by a driver all the time?
- ChrisRR 1y ago> all of the information ever published in the history of the world Why read that when you could watch 10 solid hours of clickbait?
- protocolture 1y ago>Bo Burnham put it succinctly, although he was talking about children on apps: "When they go to sleep at night, they have to choose between all of the information ever published in the history of the world, or the back of their eyelids." Ok but is the issue the information, or is the issue the presentation? I am an outlier, but I used to cure insomnia with excessive reading. I reckon if I had no other outlet, I would probably choose information over sleep. But we know that the 5 websites put a lot of energy into making them extremely desirable to cruise for hours, regardless of content. It feels like everyone has my unique problem, but its not really "information" they are after, its this one giant never ending pit of despair and bullying.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 1y ago>"When they go to sleep at night, they have to choose between all of the information ever published in the history of the world, or the back of their eyelids." But when they power the device on, instead of reading all the information ever published in the history of the world, they watch vacuous tiktok videos where losers talk in the most annoying voices possible TAP LIKE AND SUBSCRIBE. This should be obvious, I suppose. Gluttons aren't eating pounds of filet mignon and bags of truffles, they're chowing down on pseudo-manufactured crunchythings that are only distantly related to food.
- aucisson_masque 1y ago> When they go to sleep at night, they have to choose between all of the information ever published in the history of the world, or the back of their eyelids They are not tired enough if they choose to use their smartphone, that's an education issue. Children are taught the value of a good night of sleep, they are taught by having fulfilling daily lives and exhausting. If you let them be like a plant, yeah they will be just as dumb as a plant.
- Simulacra 1y ago"Short of powering off or walking away, what can we do to manage this dependency? We can access device settings and activate only those features we truly require, adjusting them now and again as our habits and lifestyles change." I think this is how some people feel about the dating apps. They promise love, affection, and future, but only manipulate our emotions.
- fellowniusmonk 1y agoAs someone who actively avoids political rage bait, was trained in rhetoric, was raised by public persuasion oriented public speakers. The idea that the most resonant rage bait that exists at any given moment is instantly, algorithmically, propagated to our public officials and the politically engaged is insane. All this while culture has now been trained to blindly celebrate bias, has been inculcated with a learned helplessness toward bias, have become poisoned against the idea that anyone has the goal of accuracy or objectivity and really does just wants accurate models of the world. We are lighting ourselves on fire.
- eep_social 1y ago> We are lighting ourselves on fire. And the majority celebrate because they feel warm.
- lijok 1y agoNotice under “Managing dependency”, the focus is exclusively on technological solutions. There is no technological solution to this. We have the equivalent of unlimited crack in everyone’s pocket 24/7 with no possible oversight over its use and no way to reel it back in. The genie has been out of the bottle for a while now. Just like gluttony, there is no solution, only management strategies and they’re all very human. Sensible education about these things starting at K1. Social and outreach programs for addicts. Etc
- array_key_first 1y agoWe actually don't know that there isn't a solution to gluttony, addiction, and other self-destructive and compulsive behaviors. The brain is somewhat stupid and can be tricked by very primitive things, like bright lights. We might also be able to un-trick it, maybe with medication. That's kind of what were seeing with GLP-1 agonists.
- r14c 1y agoWe know how to cure addiction though, and its really low tech. People (and rats) with adequate social lives and decent living conditions are able to consistently overcome addiction. In fact, addiction has come to be understood as a coping mechanism for living in an unpleasant environment. Imo the issue with phones is really a symptom of our lack of leisure time, pleasant outside settings, and affordable third places.
- actionfromafar 1y agoIt helps, but many prefer the phonecrack despite having access to all that.
- array_key_first 1y agoIMO it could be a matter of perspective. I think a lot of people turn to phonecrack instead of their social lives because they think phonecrack is their social lives. They've been told it's good, it's community, it's social. And maybe it was at one point. But it's not anymore. There are no social media sites left, only media sites.
- DavidPiper 1y ago> Short of powering off or walking away ... We could all stop any time we want, but we don't. :(
- MathMonkeyMan 1y agoI find it helps to leave the phone at home when I'm running errands. It helps that I work from home so I can mostly just leave it in my bedroom all day.
- user2722 1y agoBut solutions? Here's my take, will gladly take input (Android): Two profiles: profile 1 has no notifications, reading apps (ebooks) and shouldn't have a browser (mine does and shouldn't); profile 2 has all apps, inclusively all of profile 1 apps. Idea: have an "offline" phone. Good for battery. Whenever I need IoT or something else, I shrug and change profile. Use desktop apps/desktop browser: should work. Doesn't much. When I'm on laptop I tend to do terminal stuff, social apps feel like wasting time, do it fast and multitasking mode. Multitasking is not really what I want to train my attention span. Sometimes I turn on notifications but put system notifications in DnD so I can check what's notificated every half an hour or so. Use Waydroid to have social apps: should work, never worked. Special profiles on social apps: my current social apps have only institutional accounts being followed. Some decorum is kept, and with it, sanity. Exceptions: Facebook, Bluesky, Mastodon, Linkedin, where I follow regular people. But I really should implement something similar for my LinkedIn account. Alternate sites/apps/mode of usage: use WhatsApp/Telegram to interact, say hi to some people online on Facebook Messenger, install Discourse; on group chats avoid links or include a short summary written by an human of why people should open your link and a quick "what's on the link" description. These are my takes to extract some humanness from my machine mobile phone.
- Fnoord 1y agoFairphone (with Fairphone Moments) has a focus mode [1]. I should write a bit about it here instead of merely linking to it, but I do not have the Fairphone 6 with this mode so I feel like I cannot comment on it the way I'd like to (I've owned Fairphone 2, 3, 4, 5). They're not the first though, see e.g. Lightphone [2]. What I want (and I suppose this is kind of possible with Island or equivalent application) is a guest mode for my kids. So I can give them my smartphone without my notifications popping up between a game or movie. [1] https://support.fairphone.com/hc/en-us/articles/26886939326610-Fairphone-Moments https://support.fairphone.com/hc/en-us/articles/268869393266... [2] https://www.thelightphone.com https://www.thelightphone.com
- heikkilevanto 1y agoFairPhone Moments looks like a good idea. But why does it require a mechanical switch? I am not going to upgrade my FP4 just for that, but might be willing to install an app that does the same kind of thing
- godelski 1y agoI always feel conflicted when I see this problem phrased as "smartphones". I understand why but at the same time I wonder how much, if any, it detracts from solving the actual problems. The article discusses the usual surveillance capitalism and social media stuff[0] that we're probably all pretty familiar with here. But where I feel uneasy is the blaming on the device or technology itself. Smartphones, and even social media, could be amazing technologies. We use them poorly, but that's a different issue in of itself. It is their utility that is a big part of why they won't go away. But that also makes them ripe for abuse. Anything with value will be such a target. So even though I know "smartphones" is a shorthand for "surveillance capitalism and 'engagement based' social media", I do worry that it abstracts the problems too much, making it just seem like by getting rid of our smart phones we could fix everything. We've been using this tactic for years and tbh, I don't think it has had any meaningful success. Maybe it is time to try a different approach? I think the average person can handle a little nuance. And by breaking it down a little more we might be better at addressing the real issues. No one wants to give up the GPS in their pocket, but in 2025 do we really need that data to leave our device (except when explicitly sharing with someone like friends and family)? We don't need to throw the baby out with the bathwater. [0] To anyone who works on feed ranking systems and engagement: I'm genuinely curious, are you seeking to better measure engagement and look at ways to optimize different kinds of engagement? From the outside it seems like only the lazy measurements are being used, and let's be honest, arguing on the internet generates more comments and misinformation as well. Any bad comment that gets lots of responses falls down the ranking (top viewing), only to end up being replaced with similar comments which causes the process to repeat. Brandolini's law, right? But what are the issues? Is sentiment analysis just not good enough? Is a lack of desire? Momentum? I would seriously like to understand. Feel free to respond with an anonymous account. And please don't downvote responses, even if you disagree. Maybe we all can have an understanding that we can use votes to express our interest in the conversation (upvoting honest but disagreeable responses, downvoting quips and "mic drops") rather than our to express our agreement with a particular comment? We get to decide what votes mean, right? [1] Follow-up Can we at least tone down notifications? It is absolutely insane how complicated it is getting. I need to leave my bank notifications on to ensure I get notified of a fraudulent charge but that same notification system is being used to advertise to me savings bonds and referral bonuses. Same thing happens to emails. Let's be honest here, too many false alarms makes people ignore true alarms. Alarm fatigue is a real thing. If you don't believe me, watch what people do with a faulty smoke detector in an apartment. They just remove it!
- cindyllm 1y ago[dead]
- Rileyen 1y agoSometimes I wonder if I’m using my phone, or if it’s using me. I know things like notifications and vibrations are designed to grab my attention, but the phone always seems to know exactly when I’m at my weakest. The moment I feel even a little bored or empty, my finger just taps open that familiar app before I even realize it. Have any of you found ways to break out of this cycle of being led around by your phone?
- rstuart4133 1y ago> Sometimes I wonder if I’m using my phone, or if it’s using me. It's always both. The phone is a doorway. On one side is you trying to exploit the resources on the other side. On the other side is the rest of the world, trying to exploit you.
- Tade0 1y agoYes and my comment is just relaying what professionals have to say about the phenomenon: Bottom line up front: the way out is to set aside some time for a menial task that isn't mentally taxing. Screens are a particularly effective means of avoiding processing one's emotions. Those, of course, don't go away by themselves so if you don't take time to deal with them, you create a dependency. The moment before going to sleep is typically when piled up emotions and intrusive thoughts return, so that's also when the temptation to set them aside is the greatest. Resisting that temptation, but giving in to it eventually is dangerous, because next time the signal is stronger.
- zahirbmirza 1y agoLet's be clear. It is not the actual smartphones that do this; machines are designed and programmed by humans. Companies can choose to use technology to manipulate our emotions and trigger our reflexes, and many do choose just that, often for financial gain.
- coffeefirst 1y agoIndeed. Delete everything that doesn't respect your time and attention and a funny thing happens: your phone becomes a tool again.
- api 1y agoIt’s the apps, specifically algorithmic social media and addictive games. The latter now also includes addictive gambling apps.
- changadera 1y ago"Guns don't kill people..."
- Cthulhu_ 1y ago[flagged]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- vaylian 1y agoKitchen knives do
- bognition 1y agoNot sure if you’re being coy or pushing the trope but you’re right guns don’t actually kill people. The bullets and blood loss tend to do that. That said, denying people access to guns does result in fewer gun related fatalities.
- loloquwowndueo 1y ago
- aucisson_masque 1y agoI don't understand how having faceid, a touchscreen, vibration, gps would manipulate my emotions. Makes no sense. Developers using these features to build app that makes you addicted ? Yes. But these features in itself are not manipulatives or triggering reflexes. I just don't understand the author reasoning... I don't use addictive social media on my phone and when I receive notification, my phone makes a sound, it vibrates and yet I don't feel urged to look at it.
- mrweasel 1y agoI actively dislike my phone. It's an entirely to expensive platform that I "need" to own, to interact with certain parts of society. The screen is to small to be useful for media consumption, without making me sick. It's also to small to be useful as a web browser, except in an emergency. It is great to have GPS and mobile payments, and Uber if you're in the US as it's pretty much impossible to locate a regular taxi. Other than that it's ... for making phone calls, texting is done better view a desktop app, though I need the smartphone to activate the account (Signal). Claiming that the phone is manipulating is a bit of a stretch. One roundabout why I can see the phone manufacturers being complicit is in pushing what a phone can and should do. If you remove the manipulating apps, then you end up with people replacing their phone way less frequently. E.g. the iPhone 7 is still a good phone, it has texting (and iMessage or Signal), calling, security updates, notes and updated maps. It probably sucks at running Instagram and TikTok (though I'd assume it plays videos just fine). Apple just isn't really going to make a ton of that original sale anymore.
- skeezyjefferson 1y ago> I don't use addictive social media on my phone and when I receive notification, my phone makes a sound, it vibrates and yet I don't feel urged to look at it. the hysterical mob has decided it is literal crack rocks and EVERYONE ELSE cannot be trusted to not get hopelessly addicted to it, however they can use social media to of course decry its evils
- nanna 1y ago> sharing biometric data through pre-loaded health and wellness apps. I've been thinking about finally getting a smartwatch to keep tabs on my sleep and encourage me to do more exercise, like jogging for a certain amount of time or something. Suggestions for privacy respecting, ideally FOSS solutions?
- wongarsu 1y agoOne thing to keep in mind is that studies that evaluate the sleep tracking of smartwatches and smartphones typically show them to be wildly inaccurate, to the point of being useless
- echelon_musk 1y agoFor iPhone there's Out-Run [0] which is a great open source running app with no vendor tracking (it optionally tracks your runs locally). For exercise, I would kindly suggest you don't make things over complicated. There's no tech solution that prevents you from putting on a pair of running shoes, getting outside and finding out what does and doesn't work yourself. [0] https://apps.apple.com/gb/app/out-run/id1477511092 https://apps.apple.com/gb/app/out-run/id1477511092
- wolvesechoes 1y ago> I've been thinking about finally getting a smartwatch to keep tabs on my sleep and encourage me to do more exercise, like jogging for a certain amount of time or something. Do people really need watches to able to sleep normally or get some exercise?
- PanoptesYC 1y agoTechy people enjoy stats and metrics you can review. It's fun to pull up my sleep data and compare averages between last 7 days/31 days/12 months. It's interesting to see my heart rate at different points during exercise or other activities. Sometimes I can recall what I was doing on a particular day just looking at the amount of steps.
- fsflover 1y ago
- nanna 1y agoI've switched to a CAT S22 Android builder's flip phone, and my usage has dropped significantly. The screen is so small and fiddly that it makes me feel sick using it for extended periods - exactly what you want from an adictive substance like a smart phone. Having to physically open it to use it, and then waiting 5 seconds before it lights up, creates a psychic barrier to just 'quickly checking for updates'. The camera is like an early 2000s cheap digicam - just about good enough for documenting things but it hardly beckons you to want to photograph your life constantly for social media. It's a PITA to use and that's why it's perfect for everyday use.
- nl 1y agoThis is getting ridiculous Everything we interact with has an emotional impact. And smart phones trigger our reflexes because they are literally tools for communication. > Most of these features were developed decades ago for other uses. GPS was created by the U.S. military in the early 1970s, then was adopted by hikers and sailors to both navigate and to allow others to locate them if necessary. > Vibration alerts were created for pagers in the late 1970s for professionals — from hospital staff to travelling salespeople — to notify them of an important phone call. > Sound alerts became more widespread with Tamagotchi and other 1990s digital pets. Those toys are especially significant when discussing today’s psychological dependency on portable devices. Seriously???
- lynx97 1y agoTo me, smartphones are a godsent. I use mine to communicate, get public transport information, have text read to me, describe pictures, get a GPS fix and help me navigate the city as a pedestrian, use devices where I wouldn't be able to read the displays, and so many other things I can't even list right now. I even met my partner of 14 years via Messenger. I occasionally scroll through facebook to find events I might go to, and amuse myself over comments on various divisive and not so diviseve posts. I am blind. My life would be clearly less fun without them. Tools are just that, tools. What you make of them is your call.
- djoldman 1y agoSome say it's not the phone, it's the app a company makes. So is it the company that is bad? Company products and services are a result of the system of regulations. The market is a playground where companies survive, thrive, and die, always trying to maximize total future profit, which is dictated by the shape of what is allowed and what things humans will pay for. The cause of "bad stuff" like "addiction" to a legal product/service is human nature. If a human will pay for something that is legal, there will be a market for it. In other words: it's not the company, it's the system.
- MangoToupe 1y agoWell thankfully the market is privately owned by a single entity via the app store, so we can just regulate the company. Or they can just open their fucking platform and clean their hands of their curation of shitty apps, which has clearly failed.
- podgorniy 1y ago> Smartphones manipulate our emotions and trigger our reflexes Lol. What a way to steer understanding from the cause of this phenomenon. Smartphone is merely a tool used by organisations for achieving own most often financial goals. It's like to say "TV manipulate people's emotions" while talking about tv advertisement industry.
- thelastgallon 1y agoIt's almost as if smartphones and cars are sentient beings controlling humans in ways they don't understand!
- yalogin 1y agoThis title feels so 2015. We now know the causes are instagram/tiktok or may be even the new llms even though less likely. Why not just say that?
- udev4096 1y agoThat's like saying we should ban knife because it could kill people. Please. Every adult can make an informed choice on what "manipulates" them. If they can't, if they prefer convenience over critical thinking, then you don't stand a chance and will be exploited by the capitalistic overlords. > also an issue of privacy Welcome to the age of obsessive and relentless mass surveillance. Want privacy? Impossible unless you have discipline and patience to not give in to the digital overlords