12 ms·
Apple alerts exploit developer that his iPhone was targeted with gov spyware
- jokoon 1y agoThis is why I don't want to work in cybersecurity This is too dangerous, it's the wild west
- scheeseman486 1y agoYou swim with sharks...
- duxup 1y ago>Gibson, who until recently built surveillance technologies for Western government hacking tools maker Trenchant, may be the first documented case of someone who builds exploits and spyware being themselves targeted with spyware. Leopards ate my face moment? They're not developing these tools to NOT use them...
- alephnerd 1y agoBased on the article, it sounds like a bit of a "he said - she said" article after Gibson was terminated at Trenchant/L3Harris.
- duxup 1y agoI'm not entirely sure how that applies to my post.
- alephnerd 1y agoWhat I mean is: 1. Most of us in this segment of the industry recognize the risks 2. He is absolutely not the first person targeted by this 3. This article sounds like it's part of a wrongful termination suit by Gibson based on the context provided
- altairprime 1y agoTo clarify with the final paragraphs of context, “He said, Corp said, 3 of 3 coworkers asked corroborated what He said”.
- tptacek 1y agoFor at least 2 decades now exploit developers have been rather infamously prime targets for spyware, so whoever wrote this piece isn't read in at all to the industry.
- ghostly_s 1y agoOddly it seems to echo the feelings of the spyware developer in question.
- tptacek 1y agoI agree that developer, as quoted, has an odd vibe.
- jsonBorn 1y ago"..if you are a state or federal enforcement authority, and you have suspicion of any criminal activity of `Jay Gibson', be encouraged to immediately contact: Lorenzo Franceschi-Bicchierai securely on Signal at +1 917 257 1382, or via Telegram, Keybase and Wire @lorenzofb, or by email.
- runjake 1y ago"Leopards ate my face" reference for others not in the know: https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/leopards-eating-peoples-faces-party https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/leopards-eating-peoples-faces...
- throw0101c 1y agoThe original tweet just had its tenth anniversary (2015-10-16): > 'I never thought leopards would eat MY face,' sobs woman who voted for the Leopards Eating People's Faces Party. * https://twitter.com/Cavalorn/status/654934442549620736 https://twitter.com/Cavalorn/status/654934442549620736
- CaptainOfCoit 1y agoWhat happened with "reap what one sows", did it go out of fashion? Seems the same.
- tgv 1y agoToo biblical and old-fashioned, probably. I would say that at least half the people who've used "leopards ate my face" don't even know the meaning of reap. The simplicity and visual character of the modern expression make it memier.
- svnt 1y agoLeopards ate my face is only negative, and has been more political, typically someone voting to weaponize the government against their peer-level enemies but hypocritically, only to later realize they are not a party to the benefits, only the consequences. It is really about a perceptual flaw in pre-fascist democratic behavior: people believing themselves to be a part of the protected class because they voted for it. It seems to apply here because someone profiting from the creation of tools used on others by people with money/power has them used on him by the government. tldr; it is a subset of you reap what you sow, with more specificity and punch
- CaptainOfCoit 1y agoYou know what? Thank you for explaining that!
- ranger_danger 1y ago> I went immediately to buy a new phone. Why does he think that will help against a state-backed adversary?
- perching_aix 1y ago>> I went immediately to buy a new phone. > Why does he think that will help against a state-backed adversary? What are his alternatives?
- ranger_danger 1y agoNot using a phone anymore
- pinkmuffinere 1y agoIs this a serious response? It is nearly impossible to live without a phone, short of pulling a Christ Mccandless. I understand that means this _is_ an option, but it is an option in the same way that cutting off your leg for fun is always an option.
- majorchord 1y agoWell if you're knowingly being targeted by a government, your choices are basically go off the grid... or continue having every inch of your life tracked so they can find any tiny little thing to construe as probable cause to take you in. I don't really see any alternatives. Do you?
- kergonath 1y agoGoing off the grid does not really prevent the alternative. It also presents convenient opportunities for accidents, depending on how far you go.
- majorchord 1y ago
- rs186 1y ago> “I was panicking,” Jay Gibson, who asked that we don’t use his real name over fears of retaliation, told TechCrunch. And later, > Without a full forensic analysis of Gibson’s phone ... it’s impossible to know why he was targeted or who targeted him. > But Gibson told TechCrunch that he believes the threat notification he received from Apple is connected to the circumstances of his departure from Trenchant ... I find it funny that (1) this guy never thought this would happen to him (2) this guy has the balls to talk to media about this but fears retaliation I mean, seriously, those who want to know your real name already know it.
- ActorNightly 1y agoThis honestly smells really strong like made up shit. Or the guy is very much a low key player. Generally, if you develop exploits, you should be completely aware of every single possible attack vector. If you are working for a company like Trenchant, and you know what you are doing, the last thing you do is use Apple devices (at least fully, most of the time you have a public phone and much more secure private phone) The reason is, when you take an Apple phone, connect it to a router that proxies through a computer so you can inspect traffic, you can see the vast amounts of shit being sent back to Apple which you have no control of. Meanwhile, if you do the same with my custom rooted, de-googled android phone that I take overseas, you will see only ntp traffic, and that is only so I don't have to deal with cert issues because my clock is wrong.
- saagarjha 1y agoTrenchant employees use iPhones just like everyone else. What else would they use?
- rekttrader 1y agoApple SRD devices.
- saagarjha 1y ago> The SRD is intended for use in a controlled setting for security research only…The SRD isn't meant for personal use or daily carry, and must remain on the premises of program participants at all times. (From https://security.apple.com/research-device https://security.apple.com/research-device)
- asadm 1y agoany guesses for the state here?
- duxup 1y agoThe article notes that the target's former employer makes hackng tools and they separated on bad terms. Seems like it easily could just be the target's former employer.
- iamnothere 1y agoI would be more surprised if these employers didn’t target their employees to prevent leaks of trade secrets, union activity, or other internal dissent. Having the power would be too tempting to resist, and besides, there is some degree of legitimate concern; it would be easy enough for rogue employees to sell exploits on the side for millions (there are plenty of buyers). Another reason not to work at places like this.
- duxup 1y agoYeah I think the sensibilities inside orgs like that filters out folks with some values and the result would be ... not a lot of trust.
- bink 1y agoI'm not disagreeing with you, but doing so would open them up to criminal charges and liability. Rightly or wrongly, selling exploits is not illegal. Hacking your employees devices is.
- iamnothere 1y agoTrue, but most governments probably aren’t interested in pressing charges against critical vendors, as long as the product is delivered.
- arthurcolle 1y agoI'm going to go out on a limb here and say it's a state in the DMV.. L3Harris HQ is in Arlington if I'm not mistaken
- amelius 1y agoMaybe it went like this: - Exploit developer makes and plays with exploits on their phone - Apple notices this, warns them that there is spyware on their phone - Exploit developer somehow thinks it is governments hacking into their phone
- saagarjha 1y agoThese exploits get developed on airgapped devices
- freehorse 1y ago> I have mixed feelings of how pathetic this is, and then extreme fear because once things hit this level, you never know what’s going to happen Interesting kind of payback. What does he think happens to the people whom the exploits he develops target?
- thesuitonym 1y agoSounds like he naively believes only governments use these, and only against legitimate criminals.
- markus_zhang 1y agoWhat is the surprise? If I'm in his shoe I'd expect the gov knows everything about me including how often I make sex.
- jeffhuys 1y agoNullable column I guess? I’m kidding of course
- markus_zhang 1y ago0 is not NULL!
- bink 1y agoI've interviewed with these types of companies (not the ones in the article). I've even caught them using their exploits on me after they made me an offer and that seems to be the most likely explanation for what happened here. I don't know how anyone can develop exploits for resale in good conscience. If these companies have no qualms using their exploits against their own employees they'll have absolutely no problem using them against members of Congress, the Courts, investment banks, tech leaders, and anyone with any sort of power. This gives them the ability to blackmail some of the most powerful people in the world. edit: And that's not even mentioning their reported "intended use" against dissidents and journalists.
- Ms-J 1y agoThat's outrageous that they tried to attack you like that. How exactly did it happen? Did they send a link via SMS to your phone, or some other way?
- bink 1y agoI don't wanna give away too much in case they're reading, but they didn't use their stealthiest exploit. It was pretty obvious, especially if you monitor your network traffic.
- cj 1y agoHow obvious would it be to someone being hired as an office manager or janitor or similar?
- cobertos 1y agoMonitoring your network traffic on your local PC (ala Little Snitch or Open Snitch) or monitoring it at the gateway/router level?
- bink 1y agoAt the router level. I turned off cellular data to be sure, but I don't even think that was necessary since it was on wifi.
- yachad 1y agoLive by the sword, die by the sword.
- antonymoose 1y agoIf an engineer at Ford dies in a car crash does he really deserve it? We live in a world full of threat-actors. We need exploits just like we need firearms and tanks and fighters and jets. To mock the guy is just naive.
- kuhsaft 1y agoAn engineer at Ford isn’t developing cars that actively harms passengers. If you develop weapons, physical or digital, don’t be surprised if you end up on the receiving end.
- just_steve_h 1y agoWell, they’re certainly developing cars that kill and maim pedestrians, disperse clouds of microplastics, and contribute excess CO2 to our atmosphere…
- kuhsaft 1y agoRight. I was talking about passenger safety. But sure, if you purposefully designed a vehicle that has poor pedestrian visibility and end up getting hit by that same vehicle due to that poor visibility, you shouldn't be surprised.
- moritzwarhier 1y agoI agree that car analogies should be taken seriously. Sure, cars are useful. But aiming to sell as many cars as possible is no more ethical than selling as many yachts as you can, especially if it involves making the living conditions worse for anyone who doesn't own a yacht, for example by bribing politicians, or destroying non-yacht-capable waterways.
- at-fates-hands 1y ago
- r_lee 1y agoThis guy is pretty naive if he thinks they (or their biggest customers) won't verify whether he really was leaking something or not if they've got the tools to do that lol and to maybe send a message to not think about it
- eimrine 1y agoI would like to see the screenshot or the photo of display with that kind of alert.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- runjake 1y agoHere's what it looks like: https://c.ndtvimg.com/2024-04/30p8264g_apple-notification_625x300_11_April_24.jpeg https://c.ndtvimg.com/2024-04/30p8264g_apple-notification_62...
- veeti 1y ago> Apple detected a targeted mercenary spyware attack against your iPhone Not going to lie, this subject line would fit right in with the phishing messages and 419 scams in my Spam folder.
- internetter 1y agoIndeed, however the notification also comes via iMessage and appears at the top of your Apple account, plus contains no external links
- aspenmayer 1y agoI wouldn’t be surprised if Apple’s malware notification comes via the same or similar mechanism as Apple 2FA codes on iOS, as iMessage itself is a common vector for these kinds of malware being warned of, such as Pegasus. Apple also notifies you of this kind of malware via the email used for your AppleID, in addition to on-device, though I wouldn’t be surprised if that same malware would attempt to monitor for these messages from Apple to prevent them from being received and/or read. The Apple Support app, for example, has capabilities which when triggered from the Apple side, allow screen-sharing and logging to be shared with Apple. I don’t know if this functionality relies on iMessage being enabled either, but I do know that the Apple Support app seemingly still works in Lockdown Mode. I’d be curious if the person in TFA had their device in Lockdown Mode, which supposedly is supposed to make these kinds of exploits harder to install. If they were using Lockdown Mode, and they still got exploited, that isn’t great news for the rest of us, but the fact that Apple notified them is better than the alternative of Apple not being aware of the breach and/or Apple being aware and not notifying them for reasons.
- CaptainOfCoit 1y ago> Gibson .. may be the first documented case of someone who builds exploits and spyware being themselves targeted with spyware. > But the ex-Trenchant employee may not be the only exploit developer targeted with spyware .. there have been other spyware and exploit developers in the last few months
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ajross 1y agoThis framing seems weird: > Two days after receiving the Apple threat notification, Gibson contacted a forensic expert with extensive experience investigating spyware attacks. Surely as a professional "exploit developer", Gibson himself should have been about as expert at this particular niche as any human being on the planet already. I mean, sure, absolutely he should have called in his friends in the community and gotten more eyes on the device. But the way that's written it sounds like he took it into the local Genius Bar. It also, in context, feels a little obfuscatory. Like he's trying to flag the involvement of senior folks who he can't name.
- tptacek 1y agoI agree it reads weird, but I am leaving room for the idea that there are a lot of very gifted people who work on this stuff as an intellectual challenge, have a sort of straight up systemsy computer science background, and don't have or care about a bigger picture of where they fit into the industry. But still: the companies that became Trenchant were notoriously paranoid about state-sponsored CNE threats! It would still be weird to be surprised by them.
- felsokning 1y agoI think you're conflating two precepts. Just because you can write an exploit, it doesn't - inherently - mean that you have the skills/knowledge/tools of where to look for all signs of exploit having occurred on your device(s). From the inference of that logic, every developer should be able to use gdb or Windbg to ascertain where they shot themselves in the foot - but we know that this specific set of skills isn't inherently required to be a developer. So, the same logic would be true here: Just because you can write a hand full of exploits, it doesn't inherently mean that you have the tools/know-how to be able to ascertain if any of all of the available exploits in the wild (or in private, re: tools for Trenchat) have been used on your phone. Edit: gbd != gdb
- ajross 1y agoYou're arguing at the wrong side of the problem. Obviously yes, everyone can't be a perfect expert on everything and when doing anything complicated you should ask for help. Duh, as it were. I think I even said as much. The point was at this level of expertise and size of market ("detection of iOS zero day rootkits"), there simply isn't a pool of "experts" you can draw on to do this a-la contract work. It's a tiny world and everyone is fumbling around and asking for help independently. And as a member of that tiny world, Gibson surely knew who he needed to call already. But that's not the way the article framed the interaction, which implies to me that there's more context at work here.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 1y agoWhy is it not computer crime? It wasn't done by the govt, they suspect it was done clandestinely by Trenchant. Sue them!
- kuhsaft 1y agoThere's still no proof that it was Trenchant, and there was no evidence on the device. It's unlikely that it will ever be identified as an attack from Trenchant. Trenchant/L3Harris is a supplier for Five Eyes, and any attribution of their exploits will likely be concealed.
- ta1243 1y agoNormally with crime we arrest people. Half the problems in the world seem to stem from the fact companies are unaccountable.
- stego-tech 1y agoI can kinda sympathize with the guy, as I got fucked over in Defense contracting in a not-dissimilar fashion a lifetime ago. These companies reel you in with decently-sized (or even outrageously-large) pay packages and promises of doing “good work”, bleed you of your energy and time for their profits, then shove you out the door and blame you for anything that went wrong (especially if you try to act honestly and report wrongdoing - that’s a one-way ticket out the fucking door and into blackball territory). Nobody should be doing work for these scumbags, but people will always fall for their spiels and grifts, unfortunately, out of some naive sense of “doing good” or “getting the bad guys”. It’s always just “leopards ate my face”, though.
- cindyllm 1y ago[dead]
- spelk 1y agoEnlist and get your top secret clearance managing LANs and teaching officers how to add images into PowerPoints, they said. You’ll never be unemployed. Then you realize the “job” mostly involves being a disposable cog in some ex-colonel’s endless PowerPoint war. Every meeting feels like a high-stakes reenactment of “Yes, sir,” where accountability is optional and speaking up is career suicide. Billion-dollar mistakes are brushed off as “lessons learned,” while you get a lecture about integrity. It’s the world’s most expensive game of “the emperor has no clothes,” except everyone’s wearing lanyards and classified guilt.
- midtake 1y agoI'm more interested in how Apple makes this determination than I am about the drama between this dev and his former employer.
- rekttrader 1y agoHis former employer sandbox over wifi or use stingray like devices. Apple can see that this went over the public iMessage/PushNotification channels.
- flux3125 1y ago>“I was panicking,” Jay Gibson, who asked that we don’t use his real name over fears of retaliation, told TechCrunch. I lol'd for a second imagining this is his actual name but the writer didn't realise it
- justinclift 1y agoSo basically it was probably someone in his chain of command leaking the Chrome exploits, and this guy was the scapegoat used to cover that up for now. Though the whole thing sounds more made up than legit.
- kstrauser 1y agoI had to read "Apple alerts exploit developer" several times to understand what it meant. First read: "Apple's alerts somehow exploit a developer". nth read: "Apple's alerts tell a developer of exploits that..."
- seba_dos1 1y agoSo Apple told them of exploits? :)
- rekttrader 1y agoAs a former researcher in this space, anyone who develops commercial exploits knows what they are doing and that their work if they happen to be in the US is subject to ITAR level restrictions. I stopped when it became a game at that level. I refuse to be a government contractor…. It’s about not using software like this to kill people like Jamal Khashoggi. F the dipshits at NSO and the turds at Corellium.