15 ms·
Ireland is making basic income for artists program permanent
- nabla9 1y agoGood start, but it should expand to everyone without conditions. Imagine how easy it would be to start businesses, startups non-profit projects if you had UBI. Bunch of guys come together and everyone knows $1,500 per month each "funding secured forever." Many people people dealing with burnout, mental or physical problems, could ease up and work part time.
- poszlem 1y agoThis won’t happen until the immigration issue is resolved one way or another. The moment you introduce an unconditional $1,500 per citizen, the question of who qualifies as a citizen will become even more divisive than it already is. EDIT: I’d genuinely appreciate it if you could explain why you disagree, instead of just mindlessly downvoting as though I’d said something offensive or inappropriate.
- cheeseomlit 1y agoThey downvote because it makes sense and they can't refute it
- patrickmcnamara 1y agoHow is the argument much different than any current arguments? You can already get significant benefits from the state as a citizen (in European countries, at least).
- cheeseomlit 1y agoThe difference is magnitude, the benefits that European countries provide has made them a very attractive destination for immigration, so it stands to reason that something like UBI would make them even more so. No matter which side of that debate you're on theres a point where the math breaks down and some difficult choices need to be made, either you provide these generous benefits to your citizens or you have a generous immigration policy, but both of them together may prove unsustainable
- account42 1y agoWhich is why unchecked immigration is already a problem. Increasing the benefits without dealing with unchecked immigration is going to make things worse.
- cujo 1y ago"citizen" is pretty well defined in every country i've ever been in.
- poszlem 1y agoMaybe legally, but that's not what I am referring to.
- hshdhdhehd 1y ago1500 isn't much, I believe it is below UK minimum wage. That said the point of UBI is to supplement, get a part time easy going job and with UBI you can chill. Probably the solution for when AI takes over. So 2075.
- patrickmcnamara 1y agoIreland isn't in the UK. Minimum wage for full time in Ireland is about 2281,50 €.
- walthamstow 1y agoEvery problem in Anglo societies comes back to housing prices. Most of that 1500 will go to rent, then you're just using public money to pay asset owners. Housing benefit in the UK has these exact flaws.
- nabla9 1y agoIf you think this is relevant, then solution is obvious: Increase taxes on small wages until people can't effort rent and rents will decrease. Hint: it's not relevant. Housing benefits must be spent on housing. People can use UBI any way they want. With UBI, people can more easily move from expensive cities if housing is not affordable, and then rents and prices must adjust. The pricing of housing is defined by supply and demand. Every urban economist agrees that the solution is to build more housing. Rent controls don't increase the number of housing units; only building more increases the housing supply. It does not have to be affordable housing; just build more housing units and all price points eventually get an affordable house. Japan is an island like the UK, but they built the infrastructure and enough housing. At the height of its asset price bubble around 1990, the value of real estate in Japan was higher than that of the entire United States. But they built enough to match the demand. Now their population is in decline, and there are empty houses at the edge of the cities.
- CalRobert 1y agoOne fun thing about Ireland is that building homes in the countryside is nearly illegal, unless you have "local needs" (aka your parents are from there). It's a de-facto xenophobic "Irish people only" building rule, and the EU has ruled it illegal, yet it remains, because the Irish planning system is a reasonable contender for the worst possible way to plan your cities and towns.
- Supernaut 1y agoThe planning system here certainly has lots of problematic aspects, but making it difficult to build one-off homes in the countryside isn't one of them. As a housing solution, it's hugely inefficient and worse, it spoils the landscape. When the practice went unchecked in earlier decades, it lead to what was dubbed "bungalow blight".
- rbanffy 1y agoBaby steps. This is a very polarizing issue - a lot of people will complain that the receivers do nothing useful for society. There's also the matter of funding it, but I agree with you. Making it universal and consolidating other programs into it would create some savings as well.
- worthless-trash 1y agoI feel like artists may have been a poor choice to the subjective value of the outcome of their work, who knows.. maybe they figured this was destined to fail.
- rbanffy 1y agoOutput value being impossible to measure can be an advantage if the goal is to later expand the program. I wonder what indicators will me monitored.
- worthless-trash 1y agoThats a great point, I'd go as far as to say that it may be possible to see the 'side affects' further than first imagined with the artist group. I look forward to the results.
- thrance 1y agoI really like the idea of UBI but the math just doesn't add up. Even where I live, France, our entire welfare expenditures (that is supposed to be quite high relative to our neighbors) wouldn't be nearly enough to give each citizen 1,000€/month, which would be barely enough to scrape by on the country side. And that would require sacrificing our socialized healthcare system, our public education, etc.
- voxgen 1y agoIt requires tax increases, and the average earner's UBI will typically balance out the tax increase, meaning they don't directly profit. UBI isn't about giving everyone free money. It's about giving everyone a safety net, so that they can take bigger economic risks and aren't pushed into crime or bullshit work. The upper half of society will only see the indirect benefits, like having greater employment/investment choices due to more entrepreneurialism.
- Flamingoat 1y ago> It requires tax increases, and the average earner's UBI will typically balance out the tax increase, meaning they don't directly profit. A good portion of my salary is already taken by Tax and the government wastes it. I've seen the waste first hand when contracting for both Local, Nation Government. I was so disgusted by this, I have made every effort to avoid working with them. I've also seen this waste happen in large charities and ossified corporations. The former also disgusting me as I know they would simply piss away a few thousand on complete BS, that took a whole village to collect and for it not to go towards the stated purpose of the charity. As a result I don't donate to any charities that aren't local. Every-time someone suggests a tax increase, I know for a fact they haven't seen the waste happen first hand. > UBI isn't about giving everyone free money. It's about giving everyone a safety net, so that they can take bigger economic risks and aren't pushed into crime or bullshit work. Giving everyone a safety net will require giving people money that is taken from others. To the people that benefit it is seen as "free" and will become "expected" and won't be treated as a safety net. Being a responsible adult is about reducing the amount of risk you are taking, not increasing it. So what you will be doing it teaching people to essentially gamble and people did similar during COVID. Some people took their cheques and put it into crypto, meme stocks or whatever. Some won big, most didn't. I've met people in my local area that have lost huge amounts of money on risky investments, everything from property developments, to bitcoin. Creating an incentive for risk taking without the consequences is actually reckless, a massive moral hazard and will simply create perverse incentives. > The upper half of society will only see the indirect benefits, like having greater employment/investment choices due to more entrepreneurialism. You will be taxing those people more and they will have less to invest. The reason why many people invest is because they have disposable income that they can afford to risk. By taxing people more (which you admit would have to happen), they will have less disposable income and will be inclined to invest less as a result.
- celeritascelery 1y ago7.2 million Irish multiplied by $18,000 a year is about $130 billion. In 2024 the government revenue was $148.3 billion. The government revenue would need to essentially double to make this program universal.
- CalRobert 1y agoThe Republic of Ireland has a population of ~5.4 million people.
- nabla9 1y agoMoney goes in circle, your counterargument should include multiple steps. The net effect will not be UBI on top of wages. For the economy as whole nothing is added. The money just flows different route that gives people more power.
- andrepd 1y agoNot quite. A huge chunk of those 148 billion are pensions and welfare benefits, which UBI replaces.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- patrickmcnamara 1y agoThis is much closer than I was expecting somehow.
- dfxm12 1y agoEven easier in places with a sane social safety net, where there aren't work requirements on benefits. You can take some time to train on certain skills, if needed.
- Mistletoe 1y agoThis reminds me of when I was a child and thought you could just write checks for infinite free money. The money has to come from somewhere.
- robocat 1y agoHopefully someone who is about to go bankrupt in the US will write a 3 trillion dollar cheque/check to their government. ICE could ask nicely.
- lingrush4 1y ago> Many people people dealing with burnout, mental or physical problems, could ease up and work part time. This is precisely why UBI (also known as socialism) is unsustainable. Most people don't want to work. If you disincentivize them from working, many of them will stop. And then there will not be enough taxpayers to support the government handouts anymore.
- 4793273022729 1y agoWhen can I expect your money transfer? I take Paypal or Bitcoin.
- whatevaa 1y agoNah, we would stop working. Idealistic view of the world.
- linhns 1y agoIt either should be for everyone or no one. 2000 slots is no different from another pilot.
- bananaeire 1y ago[flagged]
- mpalmer 1y ago[flagged]
- blamestross 1y agoIt's the sign they are leaving capitalism. That could be in a positive or negative direction. People very advocate of capitalism tend to present it as always a bad thing.
- crossroadsguy 1y agoNot necessarily leaving capitalism. It could be considered a way of art patronage or sponsoring as people/entities have been doing for artists et cetera for pretty much forever. This time it’s the state itself. It’s different but I don’t think it’s a net negative. We have, even in capitalism, jobs/trades that doesn’t pay much, definitely not in the beginning and even later only to a rare few, but that trade is needed and not just those rare few. I’d rather look at from this perspective — their output and quality could be much better if they don’t have to worry about shelter, food, and health while doing that monetarily thankless work.
- account42 1y agoIreland is basically funded by capitalistic American companies wanting to do business in the EU. They are not leaving capitalism anytime soon.
- arresin 1y ago[flagged]
- thrance 1y agoI don't know, an income with no strings attached sounds better than putting them all on a few media corporations' payrolls, that are controlled by, like, three guys.
- 1y ago
- goodmunky 1y ago[flagged]
- lucideer 1y agoSome of them may be politically disconnected or apathetic, but I can almost guarantee that not a single recipient of this funding is a political ally of the current Irish administration. Ultimately this is a fairly low cost programme, a very tiny % of revenue expenditure, & looks good to an electorate that are generally in favour of supporting Irish cultural assets. I would expect to hear unpopular aging conservative politicians bring this up a lot in the next election cycle while attempting to appeal to the younger vote.
- Supernaut 1y agoI think you're assessing this with a North American point of view. I have local knowledge, and I can tell you that the money is being given to people who will not under any circumstances vote for the centrist politicians who are handing it out.
- bananaeire 1y ago[flagged]
- rsynnott 1y agoI realise that it’s most improper to read the article on this here orange website, but it produced an economic benefit greater than the cost, which was fairly minimal. There are worse things for governments to spend money on. The idea that the average artist in Ireland is in any way an ally of the FF/FG coalition is also pretty farcical.
- CalRobert 1y agoThe program was championed by the greens, who would be generally well-liked by artists (and myself, even though I dislike this policy personally). Though they're somewhat less-liked since going in to coalition with FF/FG. The benefit was greater than the cost if you consider the psychological well-being aspect of it, but it was not self-supporting economically (i.e. it's difficult to see how this is scalable).
- deaux 1y agoAll paid for by virtue of Ireland being the tax haven and compliance haven for US big tech, hilariously the same group who trained their models on all of these artists' output without paying them a dime. Doesn't get much more two-faced than this.
- throwaway81523 1y agoJoke's on them, the art will be AI generated soon.
- flanked-evergl 1y agoThey will stil get their income, you think Ireland is going to vet that their art is actually valuable and sought after?!
- dmix 1y agoAll they need is some friendly policy thinktank to come up with some hand wavy numbers about economic activity before the program starts and then no one will pay attention to it again. It will just be another tax line item like hundreds of other experimental social spending programs.
- fkyoureadthedoc 1y agoThey trained them on my reddit comments too without paying me, we're all in the same boat brother
- deaux 1y agoWe're not being paid hush money by their biggest supporters though.
- bananaeire 1y ago[flagged]
- shadowgovt 1y agoMuch better system for everyone, really.
- bananaeire 1y ago[dead]
- lunias 1y ago"select artists", "2,000 spots", "eligibility criteria have not yet been announced". I have a hunch about how fair this will be...
- frzen 1y agoThe eligibility criteria was clear for the pilot[1] and has not been announced yet for the scheme from 2026 onwards. They selected 2,000 for the pilot which was due to end in June 2025 and was extended to early 2026 and in the 2026 budget was changed to reflect TFA. [1] https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-culture-communications-and-sport/publications/basic-income-for-the-arts-pilot-scheme-guidelines/#eligibility https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-culture-communications-a...
- CalRobert 1y agoThey tried to call this "universal" until people pointed out it is the opposite of universal. This program is a wild distortion of what UBI is meant to be. Everyone who would _like_ to be an artist, but can't afford to be one, is disqualified. Meanwhile, the acquaintance of mine who sold his house in London at a large profit and retired to a cottage in Westmeath to live off his gains and noodle around on the guitar a bit is a recipient of funds from this program. Tellingly there's very little information about how to _become_ an artist with this program. Edit/addendum: Worth noting they've produced some _very_ dubious numbers to claim this program is a net gain economically. https://www.rte.ie/culture/2025/0923/1534768-basic-income-for-the-arts-pilot-generated-over-100m-in-benefits/ https://www.rte.ie/culture/2025/0923/1534768-basic-income-fo... """ A key component of the total benefits came from psychological wellbeing, which contributed almost €80 million. In addition, the report estimates that audience engagement with the arts generated €16.9 million in social value, based on public willingness-to-pay for cultural experiences. """ And, as much as I like psychological wellbeing (who doesn't!) - saying that it's worth €80 million when you didn't actually get €80 million doesn't help things when it comes time to pay for the program. I'm unsurprised that giving people money improved their psychological well being. I'd be more excited to see basic income for Deliveroo riders and people working in chippers.
- philipallstar 1y ago> audience engagement with the arts generated €16.9 million in social value, based on public willingness-to-pay for cultural experiences. If people are willing to pay for their art then artists don't need a welfare check.
- RHSeeger 1y agoIt is possible that there can be a gap between "the amount people are willing to pay" and "the amount artists need to live on (food, housing, etc)"
- CalRobert 1y agoSure, but you could say the same thing for teachers, foodservice workers, nurses, etc.... yet they are unable to avail of this program, for reasons I don't understand.
- tyjrgherg 1y agoBasic Income for Scientists. That's ok, you can have this idea for free.
- self_awareness 1y agoThen scientists would waste their time doing pointless research. Oh wait... https://arxiv.org/abs/1310.3737 https://arxiv.org/abs/1310.3737
- tyjrgherg 1y agoSeveral points here: A) For the most part, scientists do research because they are curious and enjoy it, not because they plan on making money out of it. Getting a salarys allows them to do what they like, they don't it do for the salary. B) If there's a little slippage due to lazy, misaligned, or fraudlent people, it might still be worth it. Consider two proposals: "I'll give you money every month if you're a scientist and just hang around studying whatever you like" vs "I'll give you money every month if you hit research metrics XYZ as a scientist" - the former will allow you to pay way less and sciensists will still be happy. It's just getting them for cheap. C) I'm skeptical that you personally can tell whether the paper linked is pointless or not. Many ideas seem pointless when they first appear. Some are, and some contribute a tiny bit to the progress of understanding.
- self_awareness 1y agoWell, there are papers that prove people use warmer clothes in winter than in summer. If you want to argue there's a deeper meaning behind such science, then who am I to change your mind.
- dahart 1y agoAre there? Multiple papers? Citations please. Even if true, I have to assume there’s a high probability that you’re leaving out important context, misunderstanding the results, or just plain exaggerating.
- jt2190 1y ago> The announcement follows the release of an external report by UK-based consultants Alma Economics, which found that the pilot cost €72 million to date but generated nearly €80 million in total benefits to the Irish economy. The report also found that recipients’ arts-related income increased by more than €500 per month on average, income from non-arts work decreased by around €280, and reliance on other social programs declined, with participants receiving €100 less per month on average. So, overall a neutral-to-good outcome, from a financial point of view. I think we can debate about whether it’s necessary for the government of Ireland to fulfill this funding role, but I’m not sure this is the most wasteful thing that a government can do.
- seivan 1y ago[dead]
- JonChesterfield 1y agoI'd bet the 72M cost was in actual euros that could be spent on other things, while other people have noted that the 80M in benefit was not in euros, but in happiness, which is notable for being difficult to spend on different things. Some people might speculate that the arbitrary multiplier on happiness-to-euros for the second half was chosen to make it look like a slightly profitable endeavour on superficial examination.
- john-h-k 1y ago> generated nearly €80 million in total benefits to the Irish economy Approximately 75% of the “benefits” is by the WELLBY framework, which considers each “wellbeing point” to be equivalent to €13,000 a year additional income. This could be a valid metric, but it feels a bit iffy, and without this evaluation it would be a significant cost to the Irish economy, so I do not think this UBI can be considered truly a positive return to the economy [1] https://assets.gov.ie/static/documents/b87d2659/20250929_BIA_CBA_Final_Report.pdf https://assets.gov.ie/static/documents/b87d2659/20250929_BIA... - goto ‘Results’
- kieranmaine 1y agoI only found out about the WELLBY due to this report. I don't have the time or expertise to evaluate it, so I'm interested in why you find it "iffy"?
- nubbler 1y ago[flagged]
- manyaoman 1y ago[flagged]
- TallGuyShort 1y agoThere's 1 day a year in the US where everyone is Irish. It's off the hook.
- nubbler 1y agoWe're probably more Irish than a lot of the "new Irish" people rorting their system in schemes like this
- mpalmer 1y ago[flagged]
- noworriesnate 1y agoYeah the qualification criteria are undefined, and some criteria are easily gamed, so this ultimately their criteria is going to probably be some combination of: - Those who have connections - Those who have an immutable trait that puts them in a minority (after all, there's not enough money / slots for a majority to qualify) Which makes this a highly political program no matter how you look at it.
- thunderfork 1y ago[dead]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- andsoitis 1y ago> selected artists receive a weekly payment of approximately $375, or about $1,500 per month. There are 2,000 spots available, with applications set to open in September 2026; eligibility criteria have not yet been announced I would love to see a list of the artists with links to their work, some of which, presumable, would be for sale.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mpalmer 1y ago> In October, the government released the results of a public survey on the scheme, which found that 97 percent of respondents support the program. However, 47 percent of the 17,000 respondents said artists should be selected based on economic need, while 37.5 percent favored selection by merit. Only 14 percent preferred random selection. People generally won't prefer the fairest method of selection, but that doesn't mean it's not the best.
- lingrush4 1y agoMost surveys can't even get 97% of respondents to agree that terrorism is wrong. The government is just blatantly lying about these results. There is simply no way 97% of the population (most of whom pay into this system yet receive nothing from it) supports this.
- whimsicalism 1y ago> In October, the government released the results of a public survey on the scheme, which found that 97 percent of respondents support the program. Very, very hard for me to believe this.
- pshirshov 1y agoI create state-of-the-art FOSS libraries, why I can't qualify? Why clowns and vloggers can but I can't?
- plasticchris 1y agoNot enough connections to the bureaucracy…
- esafak 1y agohttps://www.youtube.com/shorts/O-teI4Qr35o https://www.youtube.com/shorts/O-teI4Qr35o
- 01284a7e 1y ago[dead]
- analog8374 1y agoHave you tried creating portraits of famous irish movie stars rendered in macaroni salad?
- zeristor 1y agoOr ASCII characters
- username332211 1y agoYou create things of concrete and tangible value. In the eyes of the many, that makes you unworthy of generosity.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- torginus 1y agoincluding the people who actually get paid for using your libraries
- billy99k 1y agoThe problem with every basic income program is in the long term. Eventually, generations of people are receiving basic income and relying on it and 1) will never vote against it (and politicians will use it as a weapon against anyone that suggests it). 2) It's ever expanding and will become unaffordable and unsustainable 3) inflation will destroy its value over time I also believe that if universal income becomes common, you forfeit your right to vote while accepting it.
- api 1y agoAny pseudo-UBI that is not actually universal will create a distorting perverse incentive for people to fake qualifications for it. There will suddenly be a lot of “artists” who don’t do much, debasing the definition of artist. Just do UBI. Politicians just can’t help hanging conditions on it and making it complicated. “But some people will sit around and do nothing!” Yes and they already do, including at bullshit jobs pretending to work. The punishment for a life sitting around doing nothing is a life wasted doing nothing.
- flanked-evergl 1y agoBased. Going to get one of them rubber boats and become a clown. Sweet sweet Irish tax money. I can taste it now.
- Dumblydorr 1y agoAs an Irish musician, I’ll note Irish culture has an outsized footprint globally. It’s probably top 3 most successful folk styles, these tunes are played throughout the globe. And counting Irish poets and writers amongst some of the best, I’d say Ireland has historically done well culturally. Whatever the merits of this specific program, there’s a lot of potential cultural value to be kindled.
- joduplessis 1y agoAnd pubs! I'm not Irish, but it's very comforting going half-way across the world to somewhere like Florence or Hamburg, and going to an Irish pub where everyting feels familiar.
- cenamus 1y agoEven the prices will be similar to Dublin, regardless of whether the beer usually costa 2€
- whimsicalism 1y agowho is the other one of the three? Mexico?
- jabroni_salad 1y agoIt's just so fun to play :) I'm a bluegrasser and probably half of every session is annexed by reels.
- ptero 1y agoThis is a regular fellowship. Nothing wrong with those, they can be government (assuming people are OK with this way to spend their taxes) or private. Those are pretty common. I was funded by a private fellowship for a year of my PhD; don't remember the details. But as others have said, this has nothing to do with the UBI, as this is not universal. The main thing that makes this fellowship unusual, and not in a good way, is the fact that the selection criteria are shrouded in mystery.
- scop 1y agoI have a huge disdain for artists who do not bleed and sweat like the rest of us doing jobs we don’t necessarily enjoy. Especially in this age of opulence. Welcome to life. Art should capture truth, the essence of things, and how can you do so without your feet planted firmly on the ground? Perhaps I could make exceptions for those on whom skill is truly refined in a dedicated way (think YoYo Ma practicing 10 hours a day), but I suspect your avg artist spends more time navel gazing than putting in the work. (And I say this as a huge supporter and fan of the arts)
- thunderfork 1y ago[dead]
- spacechild1 1y agoWhy would you disdain someone who finds enjoyment in their work? But don't worry, making art is not always a joyride, it can be hard work. For me pesonally, writing software is a breeze compared to writing an orchestra score or the last days of a theatre production. Also, the idea of the poor and suffering artist is a cliché. Many famous artists actually came from wealthy families or had generous financial support from friends or patreons. It doesn't make them lesser artists.
- account42 1y agoIf they already find enjoyment in their work then why do they need additional support at the expense of the rest of us? I also enjoy playing computer games and browsing the web all day. How would you feel about a tax to pay for my lifestyle?
- spacechild1 1y ago> If they already find enjoyment in their work then why do they need additional support at the expense of the rest of us? Enjoyment doesn't pay bills. As an aspiring artist you typically can't make a living with your art, so you have to work a day job. This means there is significantly less time for creating works and practicing your craft. (Again, creating art takes time and energy!) That's why there are grants and fellowships: they (temporarily) relieve artists from financial pressures and allow them to focus on their artistic practice. > I also enjoy playing computer games and browsing the web all day. How would you feel about a tax to pay for my lifestyle? In case you really don't know the difference: Artists produce works that are received and valued by other people: concerts, shows, books, movies, sculptures, installations, etc. This is not the case with playing computer games and browsing the web.
- exabrial 1y agoAll UBI programs funded by the theft of wages are corrupt and bankrupt from the start, as demonstrated. I expect a lot of “No true Scotsman” [ironic] arguments inbound.
- dekken_ 1y agoit is theft, the government should not be involved in charity. taxes, are a burden, and should be minimal, and if individuals want to be charitable with there own money after taxation, great, that's their choice
- nntwozz 1y agoI wonder what Bono thinks of this, or John Sheahan from The Dubliners.
- lucideer 1y agoWorth contrasting this to the long-running Irish "Aosdána"[0] programme established in the early '80s, which is effectively the same thing, just a LOT more exclusive: a basic income for life is awarded to a tiny number of new artists every 2 years: it has up to a maximum of 250 concurrent recipients (so new artists are only selected when old artists die). This new initiative has had a lot of critics, but 2,000 spots annually is at least a bit of an improvement over the weird clique that admits 5 new people every 2 years. (Aosdána is being retained alongside this new programme) [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aosd%C3%A1na https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aosd%C3%A1na
- sktrdie 1y agoI mean, if you want to be an artist, you really can. I've lived off a van for almost a year... just for adventure. Traveled close to beach where I could shower. I spent literally close to nothing day-to-day. I could remake my weekly expenses just working at a few restaurants in the weekend, and enjoy the beach the rest of the week surfing. Now that I'm back to my normal office coding job, I feel like I'm actually saving less money because I have rent, and general city life to spend money on. It's all about the comforts one is used to. The story of artists not having enough money is probably about people that are used to too many comforts. I've seen people complain they didn't have money to go by, whilst living in an apartment close to a densely populated city and having a car... get rid of those comforts if you want to make it!
- notindexed 1y agoIn Luxembourg smth similar exists but it's called "social help" for artists. It's rather easily available if you make art for a living and it's enough to survive (paying social security & living costs)
- wtcactus 1y agoThis will become to poster child for left wing elitism in the future. What an utter, totally disconnected from reality measure. Tax payers need to go to work everyday to support more and more unproductive members of society and have the state take by force more than half their income.
- racktash 1y agoArt and culture may be "unproductive" from a utilitarian point of view, but it's valuable and enriching in ways hard to measure on a spreadsheet.
- wtcactus 1y agoArt and culture have always existed - and one may very well argue, it existed in much richer forms than most of the dubious "art" produced today. Society never needed to hand out money to every self-proclaimed artist for art to thrive.
- racktash 1y agoSome art produced today is good, some bad. Subjectivity will mean people disagree. It has ever been so. But the idea that art / artists don't require money isn't my read of history. When you go to an art museum in, say, London, you'll find lots of fantastic paintings depicting religious themes. Were artists of the time fixated only on the religious aspects of life? No doubt religion was more important, but the real consideration was that patronage came once from the Church.
- dizhn 1y ago2000 spots open with selection criteria unknown. Why don't you call them "State" artists like some countries do and call it a day.
- 4793273022729 1y agoThe left loves framing their state media to appear independent.
- cm2012 1y agoI don't see why artist should be a special category deserving of its own UBI. Its no more important than any other job.
- racktash 1y agoArt and culture is extremely valuable, but is often not profitable / sustainable. Banking is important to society too, but it's already well compensated!
- cm2012 1y agoBeing an EMT is incredibly important to society but poorly compensated, why not them?
- racktash 1y agoBoth are important, both are unprofitable, both (in my opinion) deserve public funding.
- whimsicalism 1y agolet’s decide the proper compensation for all jobs based on how much ordinary people feel it is noble/valuable and then pay people accordingly. food commodity trading? idk sounds speculative and ignoble to me, probably don’t need it - more money for the artists!
- racktash 1y agoStrawman. Some things need funding despite being unprofitable. Not everyone will agree, but I believe art/culture (including often unprofitable forms thereof) are worthwhile, and should thus receive public funding (to some degree). I believe the same about justice, policing, education, research etc. None of this rules allowing a freeish market to operate where doing so "delivers the goods".
- whimsicalism 1y ago
- xrd 1y agoI can't really make out what this all means. It seems like people cannot live in the world anymore because of expensive housing and taxation. Across the ocean, Peter Thiel recently did a private lecture on the anti-christ and how that is connected to how hard to hide your money and "escape from global taxation if you're a U.S. citizen." He has dual citizenship in New Zealand. And, the following article conjectures that "prophesies about a society where an individual's ability to engage in commerce is contingent upon brandishing the mark of the beast on one's body." Is this a criticism of swag? I love free t-shirts at tech conferences, is he calling me out for taking them? https://reason.com/2025/10/14/i-listened-to-over-7-hours-of-peter-thiels-leaked-antichrist-lectures-theyre-surprisingly-libertarian/ https://reason.com/2025/10/14/i-listened-to-over-7-hours-of-... https://sfstandard.com/2025/09/16/peter-thiel-antichrist-san-francisco/ https://sfstandard.com/2025/09/16/peter-thiel-antichrist-san... After squinting at it, this Irish action feels like paying off a few court jesters, nothing more.
- emsign 1y agoPseudo-religious bullshit to push his libertarian nihilism.
- tchalla 1y agoIt’s always interesting to see that consumption tax is pretty much levied on all purchases at all levels. But consumption is rarely considered as a criteria for decision making on benefits.
- Romario77 1y agoThis sounds more like a stipend for established artists, not basic income.
- throwforfeds 1y agoA lot of shadow artists in this thread seem upset that a relatively tiny bit of money is supporting some people that chose a difficult life producing art over a stable career. If I had a choice between some of my tax money supporting artists versus lighting my money on fire to pay an army of bureaucrats doing not much of anything, I'll always choose the artists. I've seen contracts for more money that do a lot less for society.
- lingrush4 1y agoThat's not the choice though. The bureaucrats are getting paid either way. The choice is whether or not you want your taxes raised by a small amount so that other people can live their dreams while you sit in a cubicle for 40 years.
- throwforfeds 1y agoI agree, it'd be nice to cut the bullshit jobs, but you're right that that's not going to happen. But I still am down with paying a little more to support people that are providing to our overall culture. I'm friends with many artists here in NYC, and in most cases everyone is broke. You'll see profiles written about them in the NYT, or see them on panels at major cultural institutions, but that's just the outward appearance. In reality, they're struggling to pay rent. Sometimes they're sleeping in cars when out on tour doing work because they can't afford a motel. Many of us don't have the courage to do what they do. It's not like they're sitting around, flush with cash, day dreaming all day. They're doing extremely difficult work (personal, spiritual, cultural), and we all benefit from it. I'm down with supporting it. Of the tens of thousands of dollars I pay in taxes every year, an extra $40 isn't a big deal.
- dekken_ 1y ago> But I still am down with paying a little more Then do that, no one is stopping you, I didn't vote for it, and I don't support it. It's blatant discrimination.
- account42 1y ago
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- GardenLetter27 1y agoThe whole of Europe is becoming more based around exploiting black markets and benefit payments than actually being able to innovate in a free market. Like in Sweden you pay 60-80% taxes as a sole trader - you're better off just trying to find some way to claim a disability benefit or subsidies like this.
- dekken_ 1y agoIt's either people don't understand perverse incentives, or, they want to gain from them and just keep quiet about it, I'm not sure we'll ever know.
- silexia 1y agoThese stories get up voted on HN because we all dream of getting something for nothing. But the problem is that if we all get something for nothing, no one is left to make anything and we all end up with nothing. Resist the siren appeal of easy outs and work hard and build what you want.
- carlsborg 1y agoPeople should vote on art and if you hit a threshold, you get the income.
- t0bia_s 1y agoExcellent method to make artists dependent and obey to state. Why artists? And how "universal" it is actually?
- rs999gti 1y agoDoes the public have claim on all of these artists' art? They all are now involuntary patreons.
- rich_sasha 1y agoUniversal income carries enormous moral hazard. Let's say its fine now, and in 5-10 years also. But in a sense, it is a lifetime commitment to a payment that can sustain people's basic living needs with no output from them. Because if suddenly you cannot afford this, what do you do? You tell people, after assuring them they can live their life free from fear of hunger death, that suddenly they have to fend for themselves. We kind of have "universal income" for old people in Europe - it's called pensions. And it's a massive ticking time bomb in exactly this way. They are increasingly unaffordable in the aging society, and chances are sooner or later governments will start curtailing these benefits. That's bad, but what makes it tragic is you first assured people they are safe and can rely on this.
- retrac 1y agoYou mention pensions already. In my country the profoundly disabled are also provided payments and housing. (Not much and not enough but it's there.) Your argument applies equally to that. We're promising to support them for the rest of their lives. But maybe one day we won't be able to. I think I see what you're arguing but I am not following the logic. It would seem to be a general argument that can apply to any form of assistance to anyone in need. Don't provide it, because one day you might be bankrupt, and not be able to provide it anymore, but now they'll be dependent on you and so they'll suffer more than they would have otherwise if they'd never been dependent on you. But one factor I think you maybe haven't considered: poverty often diminishes capacity to function, and to earn income. I realize this is well into just speculative economic philosophy but my own intuition seems to be the exact opposite of yours: assistance of this kind probably improves capacity to be independent, should it one day be withdrawn.
- rich_sasha 1y agoPensions and disability payments are by definition targeting a small proportion of the society. It is one thing to make a promise to 10% of the society, and another to 100% of it. And indeed, pensions are becoming tougher as the fraction goes upwards. My point isn't that it is somehow bad that we have these benefits but that they are already quite expensive and look increasingly unsustainable. So with this knowledge, we should be very careful about making much bigger committments. Further, people on retirement or disability benefits typically don't have much choice. Due to age or circumstances, they cannot really earn a living, or a sufficient one. It's not a choice. We're not promising them an alternative to a productive lifetime. UI is different. If it is to be worth anything, it is surely a promise that you can take economically unsound or risky choices, and if they don't work out, the state has your back. If it doesn't, it's just pocket money. It is actively encouraging people to outsource the financial responsibility for their lives to the state, even as governments globally are struggling to make ends meet. What is even trickier is that pensions and disability benefits go to people who are generally not very economically active. Extending universal income to everyone kind of expands this to everyone else, i.e. the very people who need to work to make the society work. We have seen in many places in Europe structural decline of industries, and in various cases, the people affected were given long term unemployment benefits, a little bit like UI. It was probably the right approach - certainly the decent thing to do - but the areas where it happened tended to decrease in productivity and creativity, rather than the other way round. The ones that bounced typically got extensive investment rather than just relied on the improved creativity and industriusness of the people on unemployment benefits.
- guywithahat 1y agoThis would be a great program if there wasn't already an over-abundance of artists producing things nobody but their parents could appreciate
- krisoft 1y agoThe eligibility criteria of the pilot scheme is bonkers. For example a Costume Designer is eligible, but a Jewellery Designer is not. A Make-Up Designer is eligible but a Make-Up Artist is not. https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-culture-communications-and-sport/publications/basic-income-for-the-arts-pilot-scheme-guidelines/#eligibility https://www.gov.ie/en/department-of-culture-communications-a...
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Survived 1y agoI'd have spent my twenties writing free software if I could count on $1500/month. It would have been so great.
- sema4hacker 1y agoI manage a large art gallery that exhibits a large number of artists, selected from our database of over 4,000 artists, most of which are in the local area. NONE of them can make a living solely off their art. Personally, if I wanted to subsidize someone who could bootstrap their talent and efforts into self-sufficiency, I'd never pick an artist.
- Davidzheng 1y agonot arguing against you but maybe one takes the view that artists should not need to be self-sufficient purely from market forces and selling art? Maybe society should just subsidize them to an extent (this is obviously already happening but I'm saying as a matter of principle)
- sema4hacker 1y ago99.99% of artists definitely CAN'T make a living off only their art, but most can survive anyway by some form of other employment. Even though some small degree of government subsidies will always be around to help artists, and perhaps that's a noble principle, I'd just rather see my tax dollars go to health care or trade schools or food banks or child care or disaster relief or Meals On Wheels or medical research or similar efforts to help those in desperate need, instead of to artists choosing to be artists. There's always someone worse off than an artist, through no fault of their own.
- account42 1y agoThe problem with subsidizing a portion of the population based on the chosen line of work is that we will never all agree on what exact work is worth subsidizing. For example, there is a lot of "art" that I think is completely worthless. Why should choosing to go into art mean that your output is not judged by market forces while someone who does the work we all depend on for survival and convenience has to worry about making ends meet?
- elil17 1y ago> The announcement follows the release of an external report by UK-based consultants Alma Economics, which found that the pilot cost €72 million to date but generated nearly €80 million in total benefits to the Irish economy. I feel like this is not a good rate of return. For example, in the USA, 1 dollar spent on SNAP generates 1.52 dollars of economic benefit: https://www.cbpp.org/blog/snap-food-assistance-is-a-sound-investment-in-our-nations-health-well-being-and-economy https://www.cbpp.org/blog/snap-food-assistance-is-a-sound-in...
- sublimefire 1y agoWithout delving into the specifics Ireland already has a defacto UBI. This is subject to you having an address and a social security number. There is a notion of a minimum income you need to make and the State compensates the rest if you do not earn it. It depends on many factors and there are various edge cases. What is more, if you are in the receivership of such provisions you can stand in the line to get subsidised place to live (which is difficult to get mind you). Some people hate it some abuse it and some do not qualify despite living in the street. But if you know how to navigate the system the income is guaranteed. It is a bit sad though that some clerks like to abuse the receivers of such payments though, e.g. by inspecting your bank statements and questioning your expenses (true story). So making this whole thing closer to dejure is welcome as it avoids possible abuse.
- constantcrying 1y agoThe most basic premise of UBI is the universal part. None of the arguments for it function at all, if it is handed out selectively. The arguments for UBI are that it effectively requires no bureaucracy and can not be gamed, while providing basic needs for all people. If you are doing needs based analysis, you are just back to a regular social system, which requires bureaucracy and will be gamed. If some government decides to do UBI, than it actually has to do UBI and not just add another layer of social spending on top of an already sprawling social system.
- moominpapa 1y agoThat's just what we need, artists as wards of the state. Things are beginning to feel rather Soviet these days.
- metalman 1y agothese are your rights! with GUITAR https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1EKCAE1vDzY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1EKCAE1vDzY
- scoofy 1y agoPicking winners and losers. What could possibly go wrong?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- CarrieKalman 1y ago[dead]