7 ms·
U.S. Lost 32,000 Private-Sector Jobs in September, Says Payroll Processor
- mdhb 1y agoIt’s really hard to overstate just how much this administration has lit the entire country on fire for absolutely no good reason in a way that isn’t going to magically bounce back either for at least a generation.
- qwe----3 1y ago[flagged]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- daveguy 1y agohttps://music.youtube.com/watch?v=asojiVtJ7F0 https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=asojiVtJ7F0
- 1121redblackgo 1y agoBut it feels good, so here we are. (Feels good for now). (To some people)
- bdangubic 1y agoto people that it feels good now it'll feel good forever :)
- 1121redblackgo 1y agotrue
- wslh 1y agoBut isn't the lost of jobs also attributable to previous administration policies? This isn't in any way an opinion about the current government but an observation of lags between decisions and measurable metrics.
- ngetchell 1y agoI mean usually it is pretty hard to determine fault since most presidents don't make gigantic changes early in their presidency. Tarrifs on the whole world is a pretty large smoking gun.
- runako 1y agoNormally yes. However, it's worth noting that the last major economic legislation passed by the prior administration took effect over 3 years ago. Further, there is not a reading of that law that would predict a negative overall effect on hiring. However, tariffs have been extensively studied in a number of countries around the world. What we are observing in the labor market is more or less what economists would predict given the magnitude of the tax increase and the uncertainty around its application. Further, data[1] shows a rapid deterioration in the labor market corresponding to the initial tariff announcement. 1 - https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PAYEMS https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PAYEMS
- jfengel 1y agoThat's generally true. Presidents are routinely credited and blamed for things outside of their control, including things done by their predecessors. It's something you have to accept with the job. In this case, though, the President is taking actions designed to have quick effects. Presidents (of both parties) generally try not to do anything radical. (They promise to, then blame inaction on Congress.) This President is actually fulfilling his campaign promises, for once. So I think he will deserve a higher fraction of the credit and blame that he would have gotten anyway. The lag is shorter because he's bypassing the usual process for change, and is able to make much more radical changes with shorter term returns.
- georgemcbay 1y ago> But isn't the lost of jobs also attributable to previous administration policies? According to Trump, when Biden was in office it was Biden's failing economy that was the problem (despite the fact that Biden took office directly after Trump v1.0). Also according to Trump, when Trump is in office now it is also Biden's failing economy that is the problem. Its the same situation with the roles reversed because of Trump's gap of being in office so either the economy is a lagging problem from the last administration or it isn't, but somehow neither situation is "Trump's fault", according to Trump. The "Biden economy" wasn't as rosy as proclaimed by the Biden government, in large part because run-away wealth inequality is making all of the statistics we historically track very misleading (eg. consumer spending looking good, as long as you ignore the huge red flag that 50% of that spending is being done by the top 10% of wealth holders). So I'm not fully defending Biden here (both parties are ultimately allowing the economy to unravel because they refuse to deal with wealth inequality, though I do give Biden some credit for [temporarily] getting some things on the right track by, for example, putting Lina Khan in charge of the FTC) but economically things were still fundamentally much better under Biden than Trump, and we haven't even seen the depths of how bad Trump's economy is going to get (but have plenty of leading indicators of things getting much worse) and virtually all of the problems with Trump's economy can be traced pretty clearly to his own actions, such as his wildly irresponsible tariff policies. Like even if you believe tariffs work the way he thinks they do (they don't) anyone with any understanding of business at all would have to understand that changing the values wildly sometimes from day to day makes doing business impossible for a lot of companies due to a complete inability to plan. Its crazy shit.
- alfiedotwtf 1y agoWhen England created high tariffs on The Netherlands, it started wars, and relations took almost 100 years to repair. Trump basically did what Britain did, but against the entire world. … it might be more than a generation for the whole world to trust any trade agreement with the US if every 4-8 years agreements can be torn up so easily
- ahmeneeroe-v2 1y ago[flagged]
- watwut 1y agoIndia is gaining massively on this. China zeems to be the real winner. Russia cant stop to celebrate this development. The rest of the world is dealing among themselves, including Argentina who sells to China.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 1y agoWe just cut a $20 billion check to Argentina. So that they could then undercut our soybean sales even further. Edit: Guess I should add, now that China will not buy our soybeans, we are propping up a different country’s agricultural market, and are quite likely to soon cut a check to farmers who are struggling because of administration decisions.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Russia cant stop to celebrate this development China is winning. India is pivoting. Russia is still losing.
- ethbr1 1y agoRussia doesn't have the demographics to win, and they're throwing what young workers they have into a Ukranian meat grinder. (Or a war-focused economy that's going to leave them uncompetitive in any other industry) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Russia#/media/File:Russia_Population_Pyramid.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Russia#/media/... The longer the Russian-Ukranian war drags on, the more likely Russia becomes a third-world resource extraction state on the other side of it.
- Terr_ 1y agoI went and lived overseas in Asia for a while, and at this point back in America, I keep thinking of comparisons to Mao's "Great Leap Forward". Directly equating them remains hyperbole due to the death-toll, but... it's not a joke anymore, or at least not a funny one. ____ [Edit] In brief, a disastrous attempt in 1958-1962 to quickly force China into an industrial powerhouse, with a lot of weird autocratic commands. It backfired with a severe economic recession, the killing/exile of subject matter experts, officials lying about how well it was going to avoid being punished, and tens of millions of peasants dying from famine.
- jmclnx 1y agoIn a way I suppose, but from what I heard lots of people were killed or died due to the "Great Leap Forward".
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> lots of people were killed due to the "Great Leap Forward" Mostly due to economic mismanagement. I’m not sure we’ll see starvation from Trump’s incompetence. But preventable health-related mortality? Probably.
- heavyset_go 1y agoWhat's the COVID death toll in America and how many people are going to die from preventable causes when healthcare cuts go into effect next year
- aiauthoritydev 1y agoThe people who are lighting up the country actually enjoy and fire and smoke and they don't own (or they think they don't) anything that is worth protecting.
- sampton 1y agoThat's one way to lower the interest rate.
- mlinhares 1y agoIf nobody can borrow money for anything it doesn't matter what the interest rate is. I'm very smart!
- silisili 1y agoPowell said explicitly a year or two ago that it was his goal to bump unemployment numbers to tame inflation. Kinda sick to think about, but, here we are I guess.
- alostpuppy 1y agoIsn’t that the charge of the federal reserve? I think this is what he is required to do statutorily.
- nielsbot 1y agoWhat he is doing is counter to the Fed charter, but if you're pro-Capital, you like some unemployment because it disciplines Labor. > The chair's main responsibility is to carry out the mandate of the Fed, which is to promote the goals of maximum employment, stable prices, and moderate long-term interest rates. (per Investopedia https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/082415/what-are-federal-reserve-chairmans-responsibilities.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/082415/what-...)
- ytpete 1y agoIsn't the idea that maximum employment, stable prices, and moderate long-term interest rates are somewhat in tension with each other though? Which would mean the mandate is to balance those three things – e.g. maximize employment to the extent possible while maintaining stable prices and moderate interest rates.
- 1y ago
- carabiner 1y agoSatirical IG post I saw from a college professor: "In 2050, I'll be getting emails from high school students about research opportunities, because the average college will require 2 publications to get in and will cost $500k." Fertility rates are plummeting globally for this reason in addition to housing, and earth has reached its carrying capacity. There are no entry-level jobs, because "entry level" now requires years of experience: https://www.zippia.com/advice/entry-level-jobs-pay-experience-by-industry/ https://www.zippia.com/advice/entry-level-jobs-pay-experienc.... If you decide to have kids today, you should factor in the cost that they may significant require financial support into their 30s. I know a couple of guys over 40, including a laid-off SWE, living with their parents again.
- ge96 1y agoThe fertility rates thing, is it true everywhere seems poorer countries/people are used to having 4+ children.
- com2kid 1y ago> "In 2050, I'll be getting emails from high school students about research opportunities, because the average college will require 2 publications to get in and will cost $500k." From my general understanding, those are already the numbers for elite colleges. I hear complaints about kids that have published research, have started local charities, and have completed most of an undergrad degree already, that they are still getting rejected from top colleges.
- sarchertech 1y ago
- busterarm 1y agoIf my employer were using ADP in 2025, I'd have a grim outlook on my job's future.
- hhh 1y agostarts sweating
- manchmalscott 1y agoEvery job I’ve ever had has used ADP for payroll.
- phatfish 1y agoThe radical left are everywhere!
- triceratops 1y ago1 in every 5 employees works at such a company.
- busterarm 1y agoAnd?
- triceratops 1y agoIt's a statistically significant sample size. If you think 20% of employers are doomed let's see your puts.
- busterarm 1y agoI'm invested significantly in a competitor payroll company carving out an underserved niche market. It is well loved by its customers and rapidly becoming that industry's default choice.
- 1y ago
- aynyc 1y agoDon't worry, it'll revised to +50,000 soon! /s
- the_real_cher 1y agoNo it will be revised to +one million. I create the most jobs, tremendous jobs
- Analemma_ 1y agoIn short order there will be a speech about how ADP has "very nasty people" who need to stop saying like this or there will be "serious consequences". After that, it's not that ADP will fabricate the numbers, they'll just stop making them public, and when e.g. analysts buy them the contract will come with a term forbidding public disclosure.
- aiauthoritydev 1y agoThere are multiple excellent policy choices. 1. Claim it is Biden's economy and his job numbers. 2. Claim the lost jobs are actually indian immigrants going back. 3. Your point about ADP. 4. Threaten any media that reports these numbers.
- hypeatei 1y agoAnd if ADP did get the wild idea to resist any government action, the law firm representing them would be targeted as well. Like we've seen this year already.
- dyauspitr 1y agoIt’s a wasteland out there.
- lbrito 1y agoI am signing a beautiful Executive Order firing Maria Black, the radical left-wing CEO of ADP. As the President I can do that, you know. She was appointed by Joe Biden. She has said some very nasty things lately - I've been told by very nice people that she is very, very bad. The order is effective immediately. Failure to comply will trigger retaliatory tariffs on ADP. Some very smart people - I'm very smart myself, but there are some other smart people around me - have even suggested labeling ADP a terrorist organisation, and I'm thinking about that. I think its a beautiful idea.
- throwaway0123_5 1y agoNot quite enough random capital letters for me.
- insane_dreamer 1y agoalso the reference to Joe Biden contains no slur. Feels fake. And where's the sentence about how the greatest presidency in the history of the United States has CREATED MORE JOBS than ever before in history?
- cozzyd 1y agoThank you for your attention to this matter.
- noitpmeder 1y agoI can believe it. Speaking as a SWE working in a finance-related space in NYC the quantity of recruiter spam on linkedin has decreased _notably_ over the last 2 months.
- tamimio 1y agoI don't know what's the end game here, you read news like this, another that thousands of government workers aren't paid, at this rate everyone will be homeless in a few months. In another news, you read someone like Musk hit a net worth of half a trillion dollars, if the economy is bad and people are losing jobs, why are others getting richer?
- DrewADesign 1y agoWhen you consider the free market an unimpeachable ideal, being able to manipulate the system to hoard resources is a feature, not a bug.
- sph 1y agoLet's stop calling it a free market if manipulation is the name of the game, then.
- DrewADesign 1y agoFree Market™ There we go.
- auggierose 1y agoBecause it is becoming more like a zero sum game?
- danesparza 1y agoIf this is a genuine question, my only answer would be "It's because this is poorly run capitalism" (aka "crony capitalism")
- SantalBlush 1y agoThis makes as much sense as the notion of "crony communism," which is to say, it doesn't. Ignoring the harmful side effects of an economic system makes one an ideologue.
- deleted 1y ago
- sauercrowd 1y ago>The U.S. shed 32,000 private-sector jobs in September, payroll-processing giant ADP said on Wednesday. > That is down from a revised loss of 3,000 in August. Economists polled by The Wall Street Journal had expected an increase of 45,000. Yikes
- sssilver 1y agoHow does this happen?
- jeffbee 1y agoEvery single day at 2:30 in the morning the inebriated President radically reconfigures federal trade policy.
- PartiallyTyped 1y agoIt’d be okay ish if the president was just inebriated, but we are looking at dementia, an aged mind that seems to have trouble telling real from fake (as evident by the flurry of AI generated videos posted on his page).
- ModernMech 1y agoIt would be okay-ish if the president were just inebriated (Grant), or had dementia (Reagan). What we have is a president who is a narcissistic psychopath (closet parallel in American history is Joseph McCarthy, although if you want a real comparison you have to go to Europe or South America).
- rocketpastsix 1y agoIt's common knowledge he doesn't drink.
- ceejayoz 1y agoAlcohol isn't the only way to get inebriated. https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/trump-white-house-drugs-speed-xanax-1234979503/ https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/trum... > If you ever looked at the actions of the Trump White House and wondered, ‘Are they on drugs?’ — the answer was, in some cases, yes. Absolutely, yes. > In January, the Defense Department’s inspector general released a report detailing how the White House Medical Unit during the Trump administration distributed controlled substances with scant oversight and even sloppier record keeping. Investigators repeatedly noted that the unit had ordered thousands and thousands of doses of the stimulant modafinil, which has been used by military pilots for decades to stay alert during long missions.
- paxys 1y agoI predict ADP's CEO isn't going to last another 6 months on the job.
- andy99 1y agoJust for reference, Canada, with an economy less than 1/10 the US lost 66k jobs in August. https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/canadian-economy-bled-66-000-jobs-in-august-as-unemployment-rate-at-its-highest-since-pandemic-days-1.7625918 https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/canadian-economy-bled-66-00... My first reaction to 32k for the US is that it's obviously negative but a pretty modest decline.
- NicoJuicy 1y agoWell, they were hit with import tarrifs...
- fabian2k 1y agoThe US policy is dragging many countries down, not just itself. The tarrifs and the huge uncertainty is really hitting companies that export to the US.
- alkyon 1y agoNext major crisis (like worst-case scenario AI bubble crash) could cause US economy to shed 3 million jobs. Unemployment rate reached 9% in 2010, now it is just 4%. 32k is a fairly insignificant number compared with 160 million employed overall.
- aurizon 1y agoThe genesis of high house prices lay in the low interest rates and nimby base home construction codes driven by owners who were deathly afraid of lower priced homes making their piles of brick decline in value. This regime ended with Covid and rates went from ~~2.5% to 5-6%. A few had 30 year mortgages at 2.5-3.5% but a huge number had corporate money market paper at 1-2% - this is great while it lasts, but it is short term, ranging from 30 days to 1-2 years, with the 30 day rates at the bottom. With low rates and efficient property managers and the shortage, these managers were able to keep occupancy rates in the high 90%'s, with aggressive vetting rules and retentive deposit procedures(deny full deposit return for trivial reasons = hoping the tenant will not create a long fight over a small bone - which often needed a small claims court battle, when at a new job far away, some managers got over 100% rent via this overlapped dual rent. Overlay this with AirBNB taking 5-20% of rental off the market where similar closely monitored management with cleaning staff kept occupancy in the 90% area in some places at 3x the apartment rent rate and greatly undercutting hotel rates at 5-10x apartment rates. A great squealing of the stuck pigs(Hotels) and the similarly stuck city tax pigs created insurance pigs and laws that shut down many of these AirBNB's = the worms all turned at once. Places that earned well became losing money pits, and large numbers were soon sold to capture the high prices of their low price circa 1999-2001 purchases. There was also the surf side condo collapse (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7KNwMSuwQ8w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7KNwMSuwQ8w) where Florida forced condos that were tall/old/salty footed into huge engineering inspections and catch-up reserve rules that made many condos worth less than the paper that was written to finance them. People walked and lost everything = thousands of horror stories on utube... Then AI mediated job losses.... 32,000 under reports this, as many companies have large internal payroll processing that is not reflected in that 32,000. as dyauspitr says = It’s a wasteland out there. This is a man speeding at 100 MPH into a blizzard with a 1000 car pileup 2 miles ahead!
- smartbit 1y agoThrough msn https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/markets/us-lost-32000-jobs-in-september-says-payroll-processor/ar-AA1NFdDQ https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/markets/us-lost-32000-jobs-i... (with graphs) and it's https://archive.is/B6XEh https://archive.is/B6XEh (without graphs).