6 ms·
Marissa Mayer will close her old AI startup, sell assets to her new AI startup
- philipwhiuk 1y agoWhat's the benefit of this paperwork re-arrangement?
- nextworddev 1y agorestructuring
- pkphilip 1y agoYou are buying the assets from the previous company but not its liabilities. So the previous company can file for bankruptcy without affecting the new company. Also, since the new company is buying the assets, it improves the books in the old company and the extra funds will be used to pay off some of the debtors without the debtors being able to access the assets in the new company.
- dtnewman 1y agoSeems like a non-story? Person starts a company and for legal or other technical reasons needs to restructure it. This happens all the time.
- tiahura 1y agoand, as per the article, largely self-funded.
- newfocogi 1y ago"Former Yahoo CEO Marissa Meyer is closing the doors on her consumer software startup Sunshine, and is selling the company’s assets to her new AI startup, Dazzle" and "all of Sunshine’s employees will move to the new company". Under what conditions is it better to buy the assets and hire the employees instead of just change the name and product offering of the company? Is it just to get the investors off the cap table?
- taeric 1y agoOstensibly, it is in what you left out of your question? If you can buy the assets, specifically, you can not buy the liabilities. Obviously, getting some people off of obligation lists is one of them. There could be others?
- eig 1y agoIs it not illegal in the US to break up a company to isolate liabilities?
- taeric 1y agoThis is why I said ostensibly. I think it should be assumed the financial parts were done on the up and up. Such that disclosures and such can waive a lot of the concerns that would make it illegal. There are non-financial liabilities, as well.
- rtkwe 1y agoIt's not illegal just (possibly) shady, but there are ways to link the former company's liabilities to the purchaser in some situations in some jurisdictions. That may apply here but that's for a whole court to decide. https://kddk.com/2015/07/30/successor-liability-in-the-purchase-of-a-business-part-4-of-8/ https://kddk.com/2015/07/30/successor-liability-in-the-purch...
- mrandish 1y agoIt's not specifically against a law but debtors who got shafted can choose to sue the "old" and "new" companies under a few broader laws, basically alleging "I had a valid contract with the old company but this sale is a sham transaction to get out of the contract and 'NewCo' is unjustly enriching themselves by screwing us 'OldCo' debtors." IANAL but my sense is such a case can be won but is far from a slam dunk and it will cost money and take time. Debtors will have to decide if they are out enough money to be worth sinking more money into recovering it. This kind of move might also be an aggressive escalation tactic in a hardball negotiation with debtors unwilling to renegotiate on acceptable terms. It's possible that the OldCo/NewCo people doing this may choose to leave certain assets in OldCo to make legal challenges less likely to prevail than if they'd completely emptied out OldCo. Other impacts can include future potential NewCo lenders being pretty leery about getting involved with the same people. It's also not a great look for the founder(s)/senior execs in terms of future resume - unless there are extenuating circumstances which justify doing it. An example can be something like a fundamental disagreement between co-founders who are major shareholders. In that scenario this may not be to shaft debtors but rather for the majority co-founders, investors and key employees to 'dump' a minority non-cooperating co-founder who's no longer involved with the company, has a "change of control" veto and won't sell their shares but can't stop an asset sale. Basically the board approves the sale and the key execs/employees all vote with their feet. The original OldCo shareholders still own those shares, they're just worthless without the people, IP, assets, etc. In such a case, the non-cooperating shareholder might have grounds to sue but one defense can be a solid paper trail showing the company treated them fairly, offered to buy out their shares at fair market value and was basically forced into this as the only alternative.
- ugh123 1y agoThis person has a history of failures venturing on their own.
- pydry 1y agoA history of failures period. She surfed google's wave of success before proving conclusively at yahoo that it couldnt have had anything to do with her.
- carlosdiaz3rd 1y agoThis is a description of the entire SaaS startup ecosystem; surfed on ZIRP but so so many AWS configurators are 100% convinced their deep memorization of syntax structures and git pull <all the deps> were real value creation
- moffkalast 1y agoI thought Americans figured that was the best thing ever or something.
- Keyframe 1y agoHow she gets any investment going anymore is a great mystery.
- baal80spam 1y agoBut of course she will.
- computerphage 1y ago"due to privacy concerns about privacy" This strikes me as a particularly funny typo
- cosmicgadget 1y agoProbably wrote "due to concerns about privacy" then realized it should be "due to privacy concerns" and forgot to remove the original bit. Many such cases.
- antod 1y agoI often do that frequently. I should do it, but forget to not fully proof read after a quick edit. I also regularly leave out n't a lot when changing where a negation happens (see above).
- crossroadsguy 1y agoDefinitely not using Apple's epic proofread feature.
- neilv 1y ago"In hindsight, the ad slogan 'Sunshine on your privacy' was a little too obvious, even for modern consumers. Let's Dazzle them with the next shiny thing instead."
- geodel 1y agoAs long there is new logo designed by founder/CEO I am in.
- mortoc 1y ago"That product saw little adoption due to privacy concerns about privacy, and pretty much languished." - A professional writer
- ipsum2 1y agoTypos and grammatical errors are common in journalism nowadays, even with formerly respected organizations like APNews.
- lesuorac 1y agoI think they're pointing out that the sentence is symmetric. "That product saw little adoption" - "and pretty much languished." "privacy concerns" - "about privacy"
- aspenmayer 1y agoTautologically redundant is how I’ve heard other professional writers older and wiser than I am refer to this occurrence.
- floydnoel 1y agoI really enjoy how that phrase is also an example of itself- such a great term!
- DonHopkins 1y agoDepartment of Redundancy Department
- moc_was_wronged 1y ago[dead]
- blackoil 1y agoI think it boils down to you get what you pay for. If information is free, it will become same as noise.
- azinman2 1y agoFirst a contacts app that bombed, and now an ai assistant? I fear she’s stuck in the past and now is in a beyond crowded space. Have any of her attempts post google worked?
- nextworddev 1y agoYou just need to be lucky once
- NickC25 1y ago>Have any of her attempts post google worked? Yes. She made a tremendous amount of money for herself while failing miserably at Yahoo!. Oh, you mean attempts at getting workable, groundbreaking new products out into the market with success? No.
- toast0 1y ago> Yes. She made a tremendous amount of money for herself while failing miserably at Yahoo!. I was at Yahoo from 2004-2011, so I've got my opinions, but I think failing miserably at Yahoo is like the default option. It was a great gig to take in 2012 --- if you do well, well then it's clearly your leadership; if you don't do well, it's that Yahoo wasn't salvageable.
- inerte 1y agoI was there too. The Alibaba investment is what doomed Yahoo. Investors wanted their money and didn't care at all about Yahoo's core business.
- itemize123 1y agowould you explain a bit more? Investor in Yahoo only cared about Alibaba?
- inerte 1y agoYahoo made a $1b investment on Alibaba early on, and Alibaba was growing a lot, investors couldn't directly buy Alibaba, so they bought Yahoo hoping to eventually cash in. Yahoo was valued at $44b at one time, and the $1b it put in Alibaba was valued at $40b. So 90% of Yahoo was the Alibaba investment. There was a whole spin off core business to separate it from the investment part drama, years and years of distraction and investors and board people who wanted their ~40x instead.
- cosmicgadget 1y ago> Originally founded in 2018, Sunshine first launched with a subscription app for contact management, dubbed “Sunshine Contacts.” I'm sure the new venture will be just as disruptive.
- thm 1y agoWhat Got You Here Won't Get You There.
- fishmicrowaver 1y agoTime to load up the Marissa laugh loop on YT while reading this
- add-sub-mul-div 1y ago"Slorp is now BONTO!"
- jacquesm 1y agoThe eternal sunshine of the spotless start-up. Mayer's track record is good enough that she's able to attract new investors easily enough but I wonder if they actually expect a return or if they see it as a lottery ticket.
- rightbyte 1y agoThe Adam Neumann-effect. Wasting alot of investor money indicates that you got the know how to do it again. I mean it is a hard to make people give you other peoples money which is worth investing in.
- inerte 1y agoI think VCs see those things as one :)
- crossroadsguy 1y agoFrom what I have seen in the Bangalore VC scene, a founder doesn't at all have to have a good track record to attract VC money again and again. They just have to have raised before, and they will raise again, no matter how badly and shadily they sunk the last ship(s). Maybe it's different in the OG valley.
- nivertech 1y ago> Both apps have been downloaded just over 1,000 times on the Google Play Store. The company had raised about $20 million in 2020. $20K per free app download?
- bix6 1y agoNow that’s some CAC!
- frankfrank13 1y agoIt was a paid subscription!
- runlaszlorun 1y agoYes but they'll make it up in volume...
- itemize123 1y agothat's not too useful ratio isn't it? investment is going to be lumped at the onset
- nivertech 1y agoI'm not criticizing. I think these 2 apps were experiments. They probably wanted organic downloads only, in order to identify real user needs / find PM/F. Otherwise, it's hard to explain why they wouldn't spend money on marketing/advertising.
- lisbbb 1y agoAnother whiff of 2001. I wonder if they will remove all the copper wiring and toilet paper from the office before they vanish?
- lbriner 1y agoA lot of misunderstanding here about "why would you invest in someone who has failed?" An investor is a gambler. Not just on past success, although I'm sure Marissa has had some successes even if people don't know them. They gamble on: 1) Has this person got the experience (good or bad) to run a business. A failed business leader is a better gamble than someone with no experience. 2) Does this person have a strong network so they can realistically pull in some really good people? 3) Has this person raised capital before? 4) Do they have a convincing narrative about why they have failed and what they might do differently? 5) Is the potential ROI high? 6) Do I have anything else I could invest in instead with better odds? If I think as an Investor and not as an Engineer, I am not surprised that she has succeeded and I wish her all the best.
- Ekaros 1y agoCould there also be 7) Can I sell or offer something to this new company and prop up my other parts of my portfolio?
- nivertech 1y agoaka "loss leader" or "supporting the ecosystem" e.g. VCs invest in startups commercializing open-source foundational/infrastructure projects not only for the financial RoI, but also because it helps their portfolio companies succeed faster while maintaining a smaller headcount or spending less on non-core R&D.
- frankfrank13 1y agoi use Sunshine contacts, its pretty nice. I used to have a work phone, my personal phone, and tons of linkedin and Gmail contacts, and I use Sunshine to sync them all to icloud. Works well! Was always super put off by the photos app, but I just never used it. I like Marissa Mayer, but I'm shocked at how little investment these apps got over the years, despite being the *only* apps they offered. What was this startup lab even doing? For five years!!
- frankfrank13 1y agoIf anyone has a replacement I am all ears
- BLanen 1y ago> That product saw little adoption due to privacy concerns about privacy, and pretty much languished. This sentence reeks AI-writing
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]