6 ms·
Cracker Barrel Outrage Was Almost Certainly Driven by Bots, Researchers Say
- mosura 1y agoGiven that everyone I disagree with on here is almost certainly a bot this fits.
- q3k 1y agoI'm not a bot! You're the bot! :)
- _9ptr 1y agoOh yeah? Can you even recognize all these stop signs?
- technothrasher 1y agoThe scary part of your joke is that there is no way to tell from the post if you are, in fact, a bot or not.
- q3k 1y agoYou're absolutely right!
- Forgeties79 1y agoYou’re absolutely - right!
- hagbard_c 1y agoA remake of the classic "On the internet nobody knows you're a dog' [1] cartoon is clearly warranted. [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/f/f8/Internet_dog.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/f/f8/Internet_dog....
- Simulacra 1y agoI don't think this is good evidence for this, there was a lot of people vociferously and quite publicly concerned about Cracker Barrel. This bot excuse seems more like a ploy to downplay things.
- j_maffe 1y agoWhy don't you think it's good evidence? Did you even read the report?
- Simulacra 1y agoHi, accusing someone and asking if they even read the report is actually against the rules. Go ahead check it out.
- smt88 1y ago"A lot of people" meaning bots. No real-life person thought the logo was offensive before or that the logo became woke. It never passed the smell test.
- Thorrez 1y ago>Of course, that means 75% of those posts were from people. PeakMetrics notes that the earliest posts expressing dismay and frustration at Cracker Barrel’s decision to update its logo came from human-run accounts. Once the bot networks started to pick up on the trend, though, they blew the whole thing up. “Authentic voices articulated cultural dissatisfaction, which bots then amplified,” the report said. >PeakMetrics didn’t attribute the bot megaphone to any specific organization or state actor. Rather, it found, “The initiators are ideological activist accounts with prior culture-war posting histories, supported by botnets.”
- entelechy0 1y ago[dead]
- skippyboxedhero 1y agoThe people who complain about bots never seem to identify bots posting things that they agree with. "the bots" is the new false consciousness, it is a deliberate attempt to avoid engaging
- api 1y agoI hated the new logo, but I don’t get how it was a “woke” thing or had anything to do with left/right politics. It seemed to me like a “sterile flat millennial-modernist design fatigue” thing. I’m very sick of flat designs and everything trying to look like the Apple Store. I could buy that the politicizing was bot and troll driven.
- q3k 1y agoI think some people are convinced that everything they don't like about society (in this case, companies coming up with "sterile" logos) is Woke and generally part of The Culture War. As they say, the internet makes you stupid.
- yostrovs 1y agoIt's not people that are "convinced". It's the bots.
- mapontosevenths 1y ago> the internet makes you stupid. Fifty percent of people were already of below average intelligence, and the average has been decreasing for years. Based on the invalid premise that the most commonly held belief is the correct one the internet has now given those idiots super charged megaphones.
- Nasrudith 1y agoI think it is defined backwards. They aren't convined that "woke" isn't everything that they don't like. They define "woke" is whatever you don't like. Mixed in with bigotry and conspiratorial logic attributing the cause, of course.
- pwython 1y agoThe logo has an old, southern white man, which some would call a "cracker" as a sort of white slur. That term originally comes from someone being a "whip-cracker." I'll let you fill in the blanks.
- 1y ago
- cramcgrab 1y agoMost viral things are driven, at least initially, by bots or click farms. Also, fake promotions from websites to artificially amplify posts or stories. View counts on a video or post can easily be manipulated.
- sigmoid10 1y agoYou can buy server racks for under $200 from China that are made for holding like 20 Android motherboards. Get 50 of those and some centralised management software to interact with all of them on one big screen and you have potentially 1000 unique users that will be really hard to distinguish from bots using normal techniques. That's more than enough to jump-start a viral moment on many social media platforms. And if you hire 5 guys to post full time, you can completely steer the discussion on individual channels like facebook groups, instagram posts or reddit/HN threads.
- ants_everywhere 1y agoWhat I don't understand about bot farms is how they don't get IP banned. If you do buy such a rack, how do people in practice get a rack full of devices to look like they're coming from valid ips that aren't in a VPN or cloud provider's ip range?
- simonw 1y agoMobile phones end up sharing an external IP address with may other (real human) mobile phones on the same cellular network.
- sigmoid10 1y agoIP banning is way more difficult in practice than most people realise due to NAT. How do you distinguish a bot farm that is heavily posting on some trendy topic from a school full of highly engaged kids? They'll both have a ton of traffic coming from a single IP as far as your server is concerned. And if any IP ever does get flagged (which only makes sense for static ones anyways), it is trivial to move to a new one.
- 1y ago
- mouse_ 1y agoAll sentiment will be driven by bots, who will be driven by whoever has the most money.
- marginalia_nu 1y agoDon't discount state actors. You can absolutely derail a democracy you are not fond of by stoking the flames on both extremes on the political spectrum.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- tomrod 1y agoMoney is a place holder for power, which state actors currently have in their geographic monopolies
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- antris 1y ago>both extremes Oh come on
- marginalia_nu 1y agoWe know this is a thing from the Mueller report. The Russians had their hands in everything from LGBT and black advocacy groups to the Tea Party movement.
- rcxdude 1y agoIndeed. Amplify the most divisive messages. Anyone planning advocacy for anything nowadays has to figure out how to deal with the worst messengers for their cause getting the biggest platforms.
- 1y ago
- syntaxing 1y agoMy tinfoil hat conspiracy is that most outrages online is “fake” in general. They just need to get the ball rolling and the internet community takes the bait. For instance, I’m heavily convinced the Travis and Taylor subreddit was some sort of bot generated outrage or Peter Theil/Spez project. Mind you, I’m not a fan of either (I don’t even watch football) but the community really took off after Taylor Swift supported Kamala in the election. There’s a ton of stuff with (in my opinion) unwarranted hate on the subreddit and it’s always on my front page despite never clicking into either subreddit or read news about them.
- crazygringo 1y ago> In that timeframe, it found that 44.5% of all mentions of Cracker Barrel were flagged as likely or higher bot activity. This is a useless statistic without a comparison of what percentage of activity is bots for any culture-war news story of the day. And it means that over half weren't bots. People really were genuinely bothered by replacing an old-timey logo they grew up with and loved, with some bland corporate logo that looks like everything else. Also they were pissed off about the similar redesign of the interiors from homey personality to generic bland gray. If you think it's silly because it's not a restaurant you go to, imagine if Coca-Cola replaced their script logo with some generic sans-serif one. Don't you think the outrage would be real?
- tdeck 1y agoAs someone who has been to Cracker Barrel many times I find it hard to believe there was such strong affection for the logo. The logo is the least distinctive or memorable thing about Cracker Barrel's restaurant design.
- crazygringo 1y agoBut it's all part of the same thing. And it wasn't just the logo -- they redid the entire restaurant design. And they've rolled it all back now, the old restaurant design stays. And the logo is more recognizable than you seem to think -- you see signs for it on the highway, it's part of building anticipation for the visit. It's part of childhood memories.
- jfengel 1y agoSincere question: was there any actual outrage about it? I try to avoid the news as much as possible but a little about this slopped over my barriers. What I saw was pushback against the pushback, but none of the actual "oh no new logo is woke". I assume there must have been some, since Cracker Barrel did change course. Still, I can't tell how upset anyone actually was, and how much was just outrage about outrage.
- astine 1y agoI definitely saw some. It came from people who were in that culture war space where they interpret every trend as being part of a big left-wing plot to impose their values on everybody else.
- crims0n 1y agoIn my vague recollection, there was some legitimate outrage. The logo was just what people rallied behind, people were really upset that they planned to remodel the whole restaurant/store with some generic corporate slop. The “woke” comments came after from the usual crowd. If you have ever been in a Cracker Barrel, it has a very distinct feel of soulful agrarian Americana. I suspect most people used the fight as a proxy for preserving that part of our culture, which is getting more rare/unknown in modern America.
- jfengel 1y agoI find it kind of ironic that a chain restaurant is people's idea of authentic America. Which kinda makes it perfect, I guess.
- abxyz 1y agoExcept this is a hot button issue. Everyone has an opinion on brands ruining their iconic logos. Nobody cares about cracker barrel specifically, they care about what the change represents. Real people love dumb low stakes drama, that has been true before social media and will be true long after it. Real people spent weeks all consumed by a cheating CEO. Almost all supposed outrage marketing is just marketing teams making terrible decisions because they’re people and people make terrible decisions.
- Ekaros 1y agoPeople don't care about single specific change. But they notice and are annoyed when it becomes a trend and half of the market is turning to generic boring sameness. So they latch on to the current culprit. I think people in general value identity of the brands more than many brands themselves do. And the change is in some ways attack to them, not to the brand.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- shaftoe 1y agoWhile bots are possible, another confounding factor is that the most prolific social media posters are strongly correlated with psychiatric disorders. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10129173/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10129173/ Anecdotally, either and both could be true: what "normal" person actually cares very much about the logo of a chain restaurant? Most people care about whether they can afford fun things, who they're sleeping with, and what they're having for dinner.
- JKCalhoun 1y ago> Most people care about whether they can afford fun things, who they're sleeping with, and what they're having for dinner. Ahhh, I see most of us are swimming around the bottom of Maslow's heirarchy of needs.
- orwin 1y agoI mean, I kinda? When I'm not working, I mostly think about tabletop rpgs, wingfoil/windsurf, my SO/family, and what I will do for dinner. Pegged me down to the T here.
- laughingcurve 1y agoIt’s the base because it’s the most important; not the least “erudite”.
- lambdaone 1y agoYes, that's exactly what the poster above was saying, just not in those words. The idea that we are one and all on a high-minded journey of self-actualisation is hopelessly naive; most people are indeed flailing around at the bottom of the Maslow's pyramid, and that's how we got to where we are today politically.
- JKCalhoun 1y agoSure — and I agree as well.
- 1y ago
- ants_everywhere 1y agoGone are the days when real humans needed to own newspapers and spend a lifetime writing to manufacture outrage.
- lyu07282 1y agoHas anyone dived more deeper into this, how do they determine if it is a bot or not? It seems like a non-trivial problem to me, on Reddit there is the BotBouncer [1] but that's all seemingly based on user-flagging. I couldn't find any real sources for it besides [2] but its not even mentioning bots, did Gizmodo make it up? Why don't they link their sources ffs! Like people constantly allege botting or brigarding for things they don't like, and even if it wasn't a machine it can still be inauthentic. The methodology seems really important to explain in detail otherwise this is all just vibes and junk science. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/BotBouncer/ https://www.reddit.com/r/BotBouncer/ Github: https://github.com/fsvreddit/bot-bouncer https://github.com/fsvreddit/bot-bouncer [2] https://www.peakmetrics.com/insights/the-politics-of-the-cracker-barrel-logo-rebrand https://www.peakmetrics.com/insights/the-politics-of-the-cra...
- Mistletoe 1y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_Research_Agency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_Research_Agency One I learned about on HN. Prior to this I would have thought this was a real tinfoil hat idea, but groups like this are actively online every day sowing unrest and it is working so well at destroying America. How can we combat it?
- jijijijij 1y agoBring people together IRL. I think one possible technical solution would be inherent bandwidth, range and commercial exploitation limitations. E.g. I think in a LoRa mesh network, you find those naturally. RNodes and Reticulum come to mind: https://unsigned.io/ https://unsigned.io/ Basically, through these hardware/physics restrictions abuse and enshittification doesn't scale, but genuine information does, and social communication patterns and scope resembles human nature/biological legacy better than the global web. Artificial software limitations can be cheated always, like with GPS spoofing, VPNs and so on. I presume, you could build communities around people, whose fates are actually connected significantly. A "killer app" to start off, could be dating, or blackboards, get the cool kidz aboard by using it to exclusively advertise the next rave, etc.. It is hard to censor and will be used for illegal activities, too, but it won't enable anything that's not happening on messengers anyway.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- IAmGraydon 1y agoWe can combat it by passing laws that don't make it so easy to create 1,000 identities on every social platform. In the grand scheme, it's not even a very complex problem to solve. Our lawmakers, however, are completely asleep at the wheel and the owners of these platforms are happy to facilitate foreign disinformation campaigns for the traffic they create.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- waltbosz 1y agoReading this thread is making me want to go out for breakfast, but the reminders that cracker barrel is a corporate entity is making me want to patron a local diner.
- lesser-shadow 1y ago[dead]
- poopiokaka 1y agoThis just reads like PeakMetrics trying to promote their closed source “bot detection” algorithm. Let’s say that algorithm doesn’t work?
- FrustratedMonky 1y agoI'm sure a lot of people on HN are very aware of AI, bots, manipulation. But I have to say, it is getting harder to tell. If you think the AI slop is the only AI content, you are missing all the AI content that is good and nobody is noticing. Its just that AI tools have become so wide spread that a lot of people are generating low quality slop. That is hiding the realistic slop.
- dgfitz 1y agoMy naive thought here would be: who made money off the outrage?
- iambateman 1y agoI feel bad for the brand team at CB. Their logo is perfect for a printed menu and basically nothing else. The only reason we recognize it on the highway is because we’ve seen it a million times. But it’s actually a low-contrast yellow-brown blob. On mobile, it’s bad. It doesn’t feel right on social media. It doesn’t fit in a website header. It’s hard to make black-and-white. I’m sure the team who put together the new mark were attempting to be faithful to the classic sense of Cracker Barrel while making a mark that’s a lot more flexible - and it was.
- xnx 1y agoStupid press release "research" by PeakMetrics that Gizmodo mindlessly reposts. Maybe 50% of all outrage is bots.
- NelsonMinar 1y agoThere's an article with more details here: https://www.wsj.com/articles/bot-networks-are-helping-drag-consumer-brands-into-the-culture-wars-63dffa04 https://www.wsj.com/articles/bot-networks-are-helping-drag-c...
- daft_pink 1y agoI would really like to see a comparison of how many bots started with the cracker barrel news story vs other news stories. Personally, I find most of the crap on the news to be utterly meaningless and I have no idea why they talk about it and just assume its because all content creators need content to fill their 24 hour news channel, huge newspaper, consistent YouTube or social media posting schedule, etc. That’s why the original daily show was so great, because it made fun of the lengths that the media goes to to fill their schedule.
- zelias 1y agoI got a similar vibe from the “controversy” over that Sydney Sweeney American Eagle ad. Not a single human I talked to about it, left or right, gave anything approaching two craps about it. It’s almost as if there are companies out there now selling outrage-as-a-service because outrage drives engagement and thus, attention market share, ideally translating into sales. Who knows if that last assumption has any merit though.
- daemoens 1y agoIt was mostly children. Every child is on the internet and uses the same social medias adults use.
- water-data-dude 1y agoThe thing that would get me to actually go to Cracker Barrel would be if they brought back rosin potatoes. It's a weird method of cooking potatoes where you throw them in a CAULDRON OF BOILING ROSIN, and apparently it's quite good. Idk, I read about them and I'm super curious now - but it's not like you can go to the store, grab a cauldron of rosin, and do them at home. Previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41991352 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41991352
- ClearDay 1y agoFor me, the tone of this article is off-putting. "Doesn't that make more sense than ..." "Did something feel…off ..."? " A little ironic, given ..." This signals that what I'm reading is not journalism, and therefore nothing in the article is reliable or credible. All that aside: What would really be helpful: some recommendations as to bloggers or other sources in this field whom people here find reliable and credible.
- pogue 1y agoOut of curiosity as to how PeakMetrics was getting access to Twitter's APIs after all the talk of Elon Musk turning off the tap & making it prohibitively expensive to even pull data off them, I wanted to see how they were doing it. But, I stumbled onto a different rabbit hole. On their website, PeakMetrics has an article about the Cracker Barrel logo debacle and in it, they don't use the term 'bot' once. So, is Gizmodo framing this completely wrong? Did the article PeakMetrics put up change after Gizmodo put up their article? What's going on here? https://www.peakmetrics.com/insights/the-politics-of-the-cracker-barrel-logo-rebrand https://www.peakmetrics.com/insights/the-politics-of-the-cra...