17 ms·
New Mexico is first state in US to offer universal child care
- thelastgallon 1y agoThey'll probably just pass a law that states can't do this? Just like many states passed laws against municipal fiber.
- bediger4000 1y agoI've been told since at least 1980 that small, local government was best. I was given the impression that state level government was probably the optimum level to decide things, cities and counties could go off the rails in various ways. I haven't see a coherent rationale for reversing course on this doctrine, which was extremely strongly held, and cited a lot.
- outside1234 1y agoThere are no principles here, no moral compass, only power. It is important to understand this.
- fragmede 1y agooh whew! I though we'd have to out you as having any.
- Muromec 1y agoAnd once you do understand -- then what? You stop complaining and decide to put up with whatever the powers to be are up to, right?
- alchemical_piss 1y agoIncorrect, you keep complaining and decide to put up with the powers that be.
- dataflow 1y agoBest for what purpose?
- gchamonlive 1y agoI also think smaller administration cells are more efficient, but when the president of the federation can just reshuffle the congressional districts and meddle with universities internal politics we gotta rethink how independent these states really are. There is no silver bullet, specially in politics.
- stetrain 1y agoThis is generally the position of politicians with power in state governments, yes.
- mcny 1y ago> I was given the impression that state level government was probably the optimum level to decide things I don't think government at any level should get to discriminate based on protected classes and I hope most people alive today will agree https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Rock_Nine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Rock_Nine
- scarface_74 1y agoThat has never been true in practice. Just yesterday, the Supreme Court said that ICE can detain people solely if they are Hispanic and where they are. https://www.politico.com/news/2025/09/08/supreme-court-ice-raids-ruling-00550551 https://www.politico.com/news/2025/09/08/supreme-court-ice-r...
- pjc50 1y ago> I've been told By whom? > since at least 1980 that small, local government was best. I was given the impression By whom? > extremely strongly held, and cited a lot By whom?
- Muromec 1y agoThere is a rule of subsidiarity -- problems have to be solved at the lowest level possible, because it has the most information. If it's not, it bubbles up to the next level upwards. EU, US and Catholic church all do this to the various degree.
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoThere's no big money that wants otherwise. If anything, corporations are all for this.
- post_break 1y agoPaid day cares probably have a big issue with this.
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoMaybe, but they may also get vouchers (that's what it sounds like). I wouldn't be surprised if it encourages companies to have on-site daycare. Probably richer taxpayers are the ones that won't like it.
- Redoubts 1y agoThe federal government has a very different relationship to states, than states do to their municipalities. This law couldn't be passed, even if "they" wanted to.
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoThat's wild. New Mexico is fairly notorious for having terrible medical and social safety net stuff. I have a friend that had a daughter that lived there, and had serious mental health issues, and I'd hear nightmare stories about how bad the state was for that. I have family with similar issues, in New York, and they get an amazing amount of state support.
- lp251 1y agoThis is paid for by the oil and gas boom in Southern NM. The medical situation is getting worse by the year, though. I don’t think it’s just a matter of shoveling more dollars
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoWhat I was told, was it was anti-undocumented stuff. People don’t want immigrants getting help that residents pay for, so they turn the spigots off for everyone.
- pavon 1y agoI haven't seen anything like that. The biggest factor you can clearly point to is that NM has some of the lowest salaries for doctors combined with some of the highest medical insurance premiums.
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoIf you live there, and don't agree, then I stand corrected. I was told this by someone that lives there, but that's a sample size of 1 (from Albuquerque).
- pbk1 1y agoI went on a road trip through Southern NM a couple years ago. Highly recommend stopping at Gila National Forest - it's a certified "dark park", remote enough from sources of light to see the Milky Way with the naked eye. One thing that struck me - towns down there had a template. 90% of towns we drove through were just a blood plasma "donation" center, a dollar store, a gas station, and a cemetery. Very bleak existence out there, oil and gas boom notwithstanding.
- Groxx 1y agoChildcare is a great way to kick this off - it's politically hard to fight against anything "for the children" and it's not a stretch at all to extend coverage gradually, as people see the benefit and want it elsewhere / just one more year / etc. Just gotta hope it stays funded enough to avoid descending into a bureaucratic death spiral with months of delays for everything.
- runako 1y ago> months of delays for everything Private childcare is also filled with months (often years) of delays. Expanding on this a bit: if you have a sudden need to get childcare, in much of the country you are not likely going to be able to find something that is convenient and of any quality that is also available within a week or two. If you are willing to spend 2x+ the local median childcare expense, you may have better results.
- bombcar 1y agoIf you want a quick response, you need either dedicated quick-responders (how are they paid when not responding) or you need a lot of slack in the system (caregivers are allowed 4 kids, say, but most have two or three). And that also needs to be paid for.
- dfee 1y agoKick what off?
- iamtheworstdev 1y agopresumably universal care in general, up to and including healthcare.
- whimsicalism 1y agoi’m down but i think there needs to be a recognition that this would require tax increases, not just on the ultra wealthy because there is simply not enough income up there to fund this.
- runako 1y agoImportant context here is that New Mexico's state income tax rates are in the "red state" bracket. Notably, they are lower than states like Alabama, Georgia, South Carolina, and Montana.
- kccqzy 1y agoI'm very unfamiliar with New Mexico (having only been a tourist in Albuquerque and Santa Fe for a few days), but according to U.S. News it ranks 50 out of 50 for education: https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/rankings/education https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/rankings/education. Given some level of geographic mobility it doesn't seem like a place I would want to raise a child. Am I mistaken? Thoughts?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Nicook 1y agoLike with choosing to live anywhere you shouldn't be looking at state level education for your child's education. That would be stupid.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- kccqzy 1y agoThe state certainly has an impact on local schools. In California for example the State Board of Education sets standards for education, and recently it published a framework whose first version discouraged students from taking Algebra I in middle school. Delaying algebra to high school and delaying calculus to college are opposite of my own upbringing and seem very wrong to me. It also had other guidelines that I vehemently disagree with, such as de-tracking in favor of heterogeneous student grouping.
- dghlsakjg 1y agoYou have to look at variability. The cities are doing ok, but it is out in the rural areas, and the reservations specifically, where there are going to be extreme negative outcomes. There are areas on some of the reservations that are yet to be electrified as an illustration of just what kind of challenges NM is up against.
- bombcar 1y ago
- dzink 1y agoThis is fantastic! I hope they succeed and there is no abuse or other issues, because it will show how much an economy can grow when women are allowed to work to their full potential. Families who were previously in poverty because the mom would struggle to pay for childcare to work can now have assurance kids are ok while the mom can pursue jobs, start her own small business (huge chunk of businesses are small businesses ran by women) and prosper. If you pose your child’s safety vs another dollar, most parents would vote for their children. But if the children are taken care of, parents can give the economy their best and the taxes paid and GDP gained will pay back for the expense manyfold.
- mothballed 1y agoWould make sense IMO to provide an equal value waiver to those who take care of their kid rather than send them to childcare. Stay at home moms do not provide a less valuable service than childcare providers. This policy appears to disincentives children staying with their mother even when it is preferred.
- bombcar 1y agoThere are many things that may be better overall, but because they're not financialized, they don't show up on GDP and so are deemed "worthless." Breastfeeding doesn't move money around, but formula does; things like that. Cooking your own meal doesn't raise GDP beyond the cost of supplies, but door-dashing from a restaurant does.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ch4s3 1y agoMore realistically here, there’s a limit to the funding any individual state can come up with to fund benefits. Tradeoffs have to be considered and increased workforce participation increases the tax receipts that fund these programs. It’s not much more complicated than that.
- Nifty3929 1y agoIt's easy to promise things, but hard to deliver them. How can the state "guarantee no-cost universal child?" Will the state provide the child care itself? Or will the attempt to provide funding, relying on the private market to provide the service. Are there a bunch of underworked child care providers just waiting around for new customers? Or would they expect the child care industry to go on a hiring spree? Regardless who provides it, more workers would be required to deliver the service, and new facilities as well. What industries will those workers come from, who will now see reduced services and higher prices as a result? What doesn't get built while the construction workers are building new child care facilities? Child care tends to be highly regulated. Is the government doing anything (aside from funding) to make it easier to open and run a child-care facility? It's so easy to spend money. The hard part is the real-world actions and tradeoffs required. Everything comes at the cost of something else we could have had instead. What you will see is: The funding will go to the people who are already receiving child-care services today, along with big price increases immediately and over time as government money chases supply that is slow to grow.
- monknomo 1y agoyou could sub in universal k-12 schooling and your concern trolling points would not need to be change. I applaud the versatile argument.
- sbrother 1y ago+1. That being said, universal k-12 schooling works because it is publicly run. A subsidized private sector model has a lot of bad incentives and issues to work out. As an example, I've sent my kids to a private school for the past five years, and last year our state introduced a voucher program to help subsidize private education. The school responded by raising the prices by almost the amount of the voucher, just for the age groups that it covered. See also: US healthcare.
- foobarian 1y agoLike I always said to my friend complaining you can't reserve a table at the Border Cafe: they don't need a reservation system if there is always a line around the block Of course they are gone now but point stands. :-)
- dpflan 1y agoWhere is the money coming from to keep these services afloat? The federal funding environment seems less magnanimous these days, plus as other have pointed out, New Mexico is not an economic powerhouse.
- pavon 1y agoThe NM state government has had surplus revenue for a few decades due to taxes on natural gas and oil, first in the northwest, which has since dried up, and now in the southeast. Previous state governments had the foresight to structure things such that this money goes into a trust fund from which the state draws interest. Of course all that money is a very tempting source to fund programs, and every session there are debates about increasing the amount drawn from the fund, for something or another. I have to admit that with everything else that has been going on politically, I haven't followed this latest push for universal child care, and don't know if the way they are funding it is sustainable. But previous pushes for preschool funding, etc weren't IMO; they were based on pretty optimistic estimates of both fund performance and economic returns from the preschool programs.
- criddell 1y agoOklahoma has had free pre-K for years now. If a red state like Oklahoma can figure out how to fund child care, it should be easy for New Mexico to do something similar.
- dpflan 1y agoPerhaps this is one of those issues that gains momentum amongst enough states to become nation-wide phenomenon like other government-solutions/decision-for-social-issues do.
- bertili 1y agoIt baffles me (as European) that any politician, or informed voter, would stand up for non free child healthcare. Let alone the moral aspect of denying a child healthcare because she happen to be born into a low income family, it can’t possibly be economically advantageous for any society to ignore child healthy issues and it’s future.
- petcat 1y agoThis is not child healthcare. That is already free in every US state. This is free babysitting. The vast majority of the EU does not offer anything close to free universal early childhood care like this. None of Western Europe. I can think of only Latvia and Romania off the top of my head.
- dannyr 1y agoread the article or even the title of the post. it's childcare.
- mynameisash 1y ago> That is already free in every US state. What?
- Workaccount2 1y agohttps://www.insurekidsnow.gov/ https://www.insurekidsnow.gov/
- chimeracoder 1y ago
- giancarlostoro 1y ago> New Mexico has expanded access to no-cost child care to families with incomes at or below 400% of the federal poverty level, reducing financial strain on tens of thousands of families. This is confusing me, is this the same as "at or below the federal poverty level" or is there something I'm missing with that 400%? Do you have to be 400% below the federal poverty level to qualify?
- nemomarx 1y agoI would assume take the poverty line and multiply by 4? if you earn less than that you get this program
- lucozade 1y agoIt means that the current system provides free child care if your household income is less that 4x the federal poverty level. The new scheme doesn't restrict by income.
- rafram 1y agoThe federal poverty level is unrealistically low ($20k for two people, which would be difficult to make rent and eat three meals on even in LCOL areas), so they set their own “poverty line” to 4x the federal one.
- bombcar 1y agoThe federal poverty level is defined by the feds. Many programs use that, or variations on like (like this 400%) - to index. So if the poverty line for a family of four is 32,150$ - then this program is available to your family of four until you make over 128,600$. Others will say "below 200% FPL OR qualifying condition" (think newborn, pregnant, etc). So some programs are open to baseball player families, as long as the qualifying condition is there.
- namdnay 1y agoat or below 400% of the poverty level. so if the povertly level is 1k/month for a family of 4, anyone making 4k or less with the same size of family is included
- 1y ago
- SethMLarson 1y agoThis is really great!!!
- lysace 1y agoThis is is honestly an economic nobrainer. Of course it needs to be tuned correctly for the context. I hope they they look at the long history of this in the Nordics. There's an insane amount of economic research readily available.
- earlyriser 1y agoWe have something similar in Quebec, $7 CAD per day. It's one of the coolest societal things in the province. Yes we pay a lot in taxes, but we have stuff like this. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/jun/24/quebec-universal-childcare-us-learn https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/jun/24/quebec-unive...
- defen 1y agohttps://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/pol.20170603 https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/pol.20170603 > We test the symmetry of this finding by studying the persistence of a sizeable negative shock to noncognitive outcomes arising with the introduction of universal child care in Quebec
- oblio 1y agoDoesn't that study compare the results with basically keeping kids at home? That's not an option for a lot of people.
- Muromec 1y agoWhat kind of childcare you can get for 7 CAD a day? Where I'm right now it's something like 10 enlightenment bucks per hour.
- jeromegv 1y agoThe same or almost better than the privately funded one.
- Workaccount2 1y agoEvery state should have universal childcare, however we should also be offering universal birth control as a compliment.
- SignalM 1y ago[flagged]
- plantwallshoe 1y agoIt was previously at 400% poverty line, it is now universal.
- ddoolin 1y agoIt's $16k for a 1-person household. Here's the rest: $21,150 (2), $26,650 (3), $32,150 (4), $37,650 (5), $43,150 (6), $48,650 (7), $54,150 (8) Also the median household income in NM is ~$62,000 according to the Census, which is already under the 400% threshold for just a one person household. https://www.healthcare.gov/glossary/federal-poverty-level-fpl/ https://www.healthcare.gov/glossary/federal-poverty-level-fp... https://data.census.gov/profile/New_Mexico?g=040XX00US35 https://data.census.gov/profile/New_Mexico?g=040XX00US35
- ant6n 1y agoIf a family if three has a poverty limit if 26K, than this would already be beneficial for those up to a household income of 100K. Are only families with young children paying extra taxes to finance this?
- aiono 1y ago> With Monday’s announcement universal child care will be extended to every family in the state, regardless of income. This amounts to an average annual family savings of $12,000 per child.
- aisengard 1y agoYou literally only had to read one more sentence: "With Monday’s announcement universal child care will be extended to every family in the state, regardless of income. This amounts to an average annual family savings of $12,000 per child."
- d3rockk 1y agoRight?? If only the "hope the audience here would read the article" crowd would read the article. Wouldn't that be something..
- SamuelAdams 1y agoIs there a mandated state ratio of workers to children? In Michigan, by law, it is 1:4. It is great to offer free childcare to all citizens, but if those childcare facilities are inadequately resourced the quality of care will decline.
- jonathanlb 1y agoA quick glance at https://worldpopulationreview.com/state-rankings/child-care-ratio-by-state https://worldpopulationreview.com/state-rankings/child-care-... It looks like it's 1:6 until kids are 27 months, at which point the ratio becomes 1:10. When kids are 3-4 the ratio is 1:12, and when they're 5 and up, the ratio is 1:15. These are numbers from 2011, so not sure how that's changed over time.
- resters 1y agoImagine if we saw mostly headlines like this rather than things like "Trump threatens war on Chicago" or "Supreme Court approves racial profiling", or "Columbia students deported for protesting" or "Trump delays tariffs for 90 more days".
- ciconia 1y agoChances are you'll soon see something like "Trump threatens nuclear war against communist New Mexico".
- resters 1y agoIt's off topic to mention this, but I've become convinced that the richest among us really don't care about improving the systems and institutions that would really elevate humanity and unlock tremendous human capital.
- alchemical_piss 1y agoWhy would they? They’re wealthy enough to weather nearly anything. They do lack total power though, which is why you see Silicon Valley flirting with Yarvin.
- throwmeaway222 1y agowhat happened with socialization, friends and parents
- pavel_lishin 1y agoDo you have a lot of friends who'd be willing to watch your children for 9 hours a day while you work, especially young infants?
- tbirdny 1y agoNo one does because everyone needs to have a job to survive in the US today. It used to be that many couples could survive on a single income. Not only did that allow them to better care for their kids, it also allowed them to help their siblings, parents, other family members, friends, neighbors, and community.
- habinero 1y ago> It used to be that many couples could survive on a single income Historically, this is not true - women have always taken in work. Living on someone else's dime was for the wealthy only. The post-war years were a historical anomaly.
- jonathanlb 1y ago> socialization, friends This still happen at daycare. If you have sent your kid to daycare/preschool, you'll know that kids become friends wit nother kids there, and parents can become friends withnother parents. A community forms because playdates are necessary when daycare/preschool is out. > parents Sometimes economic realities are such that both parents have to work to make ends meet. There are single-family households that also exist. Childcare is a necessity in these and other situations.
- rexpop 1y agoDaycare involves all of those things.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- declan_roberts 1y agoI'm going to take the reverse position. I don't like this policy. I think it would be much better to provide a one year paid stipend so that a parent can be home with the children during their tender years. This entire structure is set up to keep the boss happy while a stranger raises your child during their most formative and vulnerable years.
- MisterTea 1y ago> This entire structure is set up to keep the boss happy while a stranger raises your child during their most formative and vulnerable years. I can agree. I had grandparents to take are of me. During a family emergency I stayed with a friends family for a few weeks. We had a lot of people in our family and friends to step up who were all located in the same city. Now everyone moves a thousand miles away from their existing support networks for a tech job.
- pitpatagain 1y agoAmericans move significantly less today than they did in the mid 20th century, not more: https://www.marketplace.org/story/2024/03/14/why-might-americans-be-moving-less https://www.marketplace.org/story/2024/03/14/why-might-ameri...
- Loudergood 1y agoStudent loans can really force this.
- Avshalom 1y agoThis isn't just for babies. My coworker's 12yo is covered by this because he's got cancer and is too immunocompromised to go to school.
- mrits 1y agoI'm not sure we want to treat this as a related issue unless you want this kid to be sent to their death at 18
- jp42 1y agoSlightly tangent. At some point in future I can imagine humanoid robots will be doing this job. Of course, the robots need to be super reliable before we hand over the our kids
- yoyohello13 1y agoWhat a disturbing dystopia where the robots are at home taking care of the kids so the parents can go work in the factory.
- jp42 1y agoMay be when robots truly arrived. We don't have to work and we get to spend more time with our kids.
- yoyohello13 1y agoThat's definitely the better alternative.
- zackmorris 1y agoI just want to +1 this post before it gets flagged for being "political" or whatever. I grew up in the 1980s and have watched America slide from being a civilization that was the envy of the world into something resembling empire or feudalism or I-don't-know-what. The US literally declared its independence from England to shrug off authoritarianism/aristocracy. Yet we've reproduced that wealth inequality here. We're going to have to draw a line in the sand that says that we believe that we can build a dignified society together. That means that we've got to stop worshipping rugged individualism when our billionaires got rich on government contracts and let children starve in poverty. The hypocrisy has reached self-destructive proportions. If free childcare is gonna sink the country, then we're already sunk. Same with free healthcare and free education. You want to know what sinks a country? When grocery prices triple and (waves hand at everything).
- scarface_74 1y agoWhat’s frustrating about this is that conservatives are always warning about the decreasing child birth rate. But fight against policies that would help support families who have children. Universal healthcare is similar. You want to support small businesses? Lack of affordable healthcare stops a lot of people from leaving corporate America to start their own business.
- Muromec 1y ago>What’s frustrating about this is that conservatives are always warning about the decreasing child birth rate. But fight against policies that would help support families who have children. That's what happens when party doesn't have an actual policy stance and min-maxes their pooling numbers based on target audience instead. Another more cynical take is "childbirths" is just a code for racism and "pro-life" a code for religious types.
- scarface_74 1y agoIt’s not just pro-life - even though it might encourage more women to not have abortions - it’s also they want to stave off the country from becoming “majority minority” to “preserve their culture”. The minute they even think that minorities are help by pro child policies they will be back to the “welfare queen” dog whistles that Reagan did. But to be fair, a few of the religious non MAGA conservatives did understand that the best way to reduce abortions were to support new mothers and children. But now that Roe v Wade has been overturned, they don’t seem to care about it anymore.
- mythrwy 1y agoNew Mexico has some serious generational social issues. Extreme poverty, lack of education, lack of work (or most anything else) ethic are very common. Drugs and alcoholism are endemic. I wonder if some of the intent behind this is to reduce some of the generational effects by exposing children early to at least some semblance of order and sobriety? Then when they enter school they have more of a chance. I'm not by any means "socialist inclined" but I can't say I'm against this program because the situation is dire enough something must be done.
- travisgriggs 1y agoAs I read the back and forth here… When I lived in Norway 35 years ago, I’m pretty sure they had this. Little kids went to barnehagen. I think as early as 1. Can anyone from the Nordic states chime in? Is that still the case? Does it work? I would guess Sweden and Denmark were similar.
- xp84 1y agoApparently until now they've been providing this only to families below 400% of the Federal Poverty Level. FPL is $32,150 for a 4-person family, so $128,600 combined family income (2 people working for $64,300 each -- and that's before fed and state taxes are deducted). Since that is far from being wealthy enough to "just" spring for expensive care, I'm glad to see this. My only question is who the heck is going to be working in these childcare centers?? Right now (granted, I don't live in NM so this is in California) most places that are decent have waiting lists - indicating that they could expand but are unable to, instead they're already leaving money on the table. I don't think there are enough people willing to work a very grueling job for a wage that the current costs are enough to support. So, if this is a new entitlement program the state may find its costs doubling soon as they try to force the market to provide, or are forced to directly provide, care.
- hedora 1y agoNot sure where in California you are, but the SF Bay Area’s economy is heavily distorted by intentionally bad roads and artificial housing shortages. Pretty much any blue collar or service worker is either living in a prop 13 house, has roommates, or is driving well over an hour to get to work. That’s not true in many other places on earth. California could fix it, but the politicians keep actively making the problem worse. For instance, there’s a statewide mandate to reduce commute miles (not carbon, and not time). If towns don’t comply, they get in trouble with the state government. Similarly, construction permit departments are adversarial, and “affordable housing” initiatives routinely block market rate housing from being built. On top of all that, the ‘08 housing crisis put a bunch of contractors out of business, and so did covid. Those people largely moved out of state. The result is that there’s no one to train new workers, and even if there were, there’s no reason for those new workers to locate here, since the pay scale doesn’t make up for housing costs. (This would be a huge opportunity if we fixed the roads so they could drive to work sites quickly, or allowed new housing construction, but we don’t.)
- SilverElfin 1y agoProviding such benefits to those below poverty level doesn’t make sense to me. People are that level of economic value need to improve their situation before taking on the burden of children. Taxpayers should not be subsidizing the poorest to have large families they can’t take care of. The opposite should be happening - we should subsidize households with demonstrated capability to be successful (which in our society does mean economically) to have more children.
- dreamcompiler 1y agoNew Mexico also issued an order removing barriers to pharmacies giving COVID boosters. https://www.nmhealth.org/news/vaccine/2025/8/ https://www.nmhealth.org/news/vaccine/2025/8/ The states are stepping up.
- cushychicken 1y agoThis is awesome. I suspect that for every one job the government would subsidize for a daycare professional, that we’d see three women enter the workforce. That’s a net of four people employed. I have no proof of this aside from my own experience watching parents struggle to find care for their kids. Even well off ones where I live. In Massachusetts! Good for you, New Mexico. I’m rooting for you.
- foxyv 1y agoWhat's even better is this isn't costing New Mexico that much and it removes income restrictions for daycare. I think the total budget is something like $36 million extra with about $20 million of that being capex to build new facilities.
- rgbrgb 1y ago> Programs that commit to paying entry-level staff a minimum of $18 per hour and offer 10 hours of care per day, five days a week, will receive an incentive rate. New Mexico estimates an additional 5,000 early childhood professionals are needed to fully achieve a universal system. Is this a reasonable wage in New Mexico? Here in Southern California you could not find qualified candidates for that but I know general cost of living is higher.
- johng 1y ago$18/hour is a really good wage in New Mexico for every city except the richest ones... mainly Santa Fe. It's really high for smaller towns and villages.
- jandrewrogers 1y agoThat's really good pay for most parts of New Mexico.
- sparrish 1y ago"child care available to all New Mexicans" Does this mean a stay-at-home mom or dad can get a daycare license and get paid by the state to take care of their own children?
- trentnix 1y agoDespite being 31st in educational funding, New Mexico has ranked 50th in juvenile education for 8 years in a row per the Annie E. Casey foundation: https://www.aecf.org/interactive/databook?l=35 https://www.aecf.org/interactive/databook?l=35 You can research for yourself and see other evidence that the educational outcomes for children in New Mexico is generally very, very poor. Expect similar results with New Mexico's "universal" child care.
- gddgb 1y ago[dead]
- OsrsNeedsf2P 1y agoMaybe they're trying to fix it?
- seanmcdirmid 1y agoNew Mexico is filled with poor people, news at 11. But seriously, a lot of things go into your state's education outcomes: state of the kids coming into the system is actually very important, as is parent participation, before we even get to funding by the state. As the only poor blue state, New Mexico has a lot to make up for, and it can't just magic its problems away.
- onlyrealcuzzo 1y agoWhy should we all go off of one ranking? Quartz ranked New Mexico 5th: https://qz.com/early-childhood-education-by-state-ranking-2025/slides/2 https://qz.com/early-childhood-education-by-state-ranking-20... If I look hard enough, I can find a study that ranks New Mexico at every single ranking from 50th to 1st. In particular, the study you linked ranks on a lot of factors outside the control of the school - which is largely affected by the huge number of poor people in New Mexico (#1 in the country... Which is why they got the rating they did).
- surfmike 1y agoIf AI does actually lead to large economic gains but also high unemployment, then we should be able to invest most in social programs like this and let people make a good living providing them. (as well as all other workers, through wage subsidies) That said, if you don’t have a job… do you need childcare? But I’m assuming there will still be enough demand from those employed
- yencabulator 1y agoIf you don't have childcare, how will you get a job?
- surfmike 1y agoI think I muddled my point, I think with abundance we should offer childcare to people who have jobs. Even maybe some hours for those that don’t too.
- CGMthrowaway 1y agoSounds great. >average annual family savings of $12,000 per child. How is NM paying for this? They currently have a 'D' grade from Truth in Accounting[1] with a $9.8 billion debt burden driven by unfunded obligations of pension and retiree health care [1]https://www.truthinaccounting.org/library/doclib/NM-2020-2pager.pdf https://www.truthinaccounting.org/library/doclib/NM-2020-2pa...
- anothermathbozo 1y agochild care policy frees labor capacity for work that is more likely to earn a slice of the national income. It’s almost certainly going to result in greater economic activity for the state. In the immediate it is funded from two existing funds.
- CGMthrowaway 1y agoState + local tax burden in NM is 10.2%[1]. Revenue neutral would mean those taking the child care would instead take a job with average salary $120,000. But as another comment points out this policy attracts new jobs to the state, which complicates the math [1]https://taxfoundation.org/location/new-mexico/ https://taxfoundation.org/location/new-mexico/
- anothermathbozo 1y agoIncome tax is not the only revenue that the state and local governments capture when production increases.
- jcrawfordor 1y agoI wouldn't take these Truth in Accounting reports too seriously. They're linked to ALEC and take a very hard-right stance on fiscal issues, and in particular, this report on NM (which is also nearly five years old) seems to ignore the permanent funds---as best I can tell they are lumping them all under "restricted" and ignoring them, even though the land grant permanent fund, the largest of them, is totally at the discretion of the legislature and the others are very broad. The permanent funds are also now significantly larger than that report shows. While NM has debt it has been servicing it fine and state revenue has increased year over year pretty much since that report was produced in 2020 (either 2020 or 2021 were the worst years for the state's financial position). It's projected that 2025 will close out with nearly $3.5 billion in unspent revenue, and the state has about $50 billion saved in various permanent funds. The state's financial situation is currently so good that it has allowed things like universal free college tuition in a largely revenue-neutral way due to the significant balance of the invested funds. One of the main criticisms you will hear of the NM legislative on the fiscal front is that they are too hesitant to spend money, since NM has serious issues with underperformance in areas like education while also having billions of savings that could be spent down in an effort to address those issues (and in fact the state supreme court more or less mandated the state to start doing so several years ago). However, since NM's revenue is so tied to the oil and gas industry and its boom-and-bust nature, the legislature likes to keep a substantial cash reserve to manage the bust years. That may be particularly important right now as the Trump administration is radically reducing the amount of federal funding that NM receives, which has always been a critical revenue source due to the state's high level of poverty (third highest in the US or so, depending on year and how you measure).
- thelastgallon 1y agoMost people are forgetting the sine qua non: No billionaires were harmed in the making of this law. I wonder what other laws like this can be passed that do not harm billionaires.
- tbirdny 1y agoThe reason we need this is because both parents need to work because wages are so low families cannot live on a single income. I wish we could fix that rather than allowing even more people to work putting more downward pressure on wages.
- LightBug1 1y agoExcellent, it's a start ... anyone else predicting this will be get cancelled by the dumpling for being too Communist. It's on my bingo card.
- jimt1234 1y agoNew Mexico is too small for Orange Julius to care about. If it was California, the story would be completely different.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- bilsbie 1y agoIm probably in the minority on this opinion but I think its crazy to entrust your children to low paid strangers with no stake in their development during critical times in their lives.
- Ancalagon 1y agoCool - then you can pay for daycare
- savagej 1y ago[dead]
- trump4eva 1y ago[dead]
- onlypassingthru 1y agoJust as a general aside - The amount of hubris when it comes to Early Childhood Education is always astounding to me. So many people assume they are experts because they were a toddler once or can become an expert just by reading a couple books. How many people on HN are even aware there is an entire specialty in Education devoted to preschoolers for very good reason? ANY program that attempts to put kids in a good daycare with trained professionals is a win for everyone.
- johnbellone 1y agoI support my tax dollars going to pay for universal child care. This is likely the second or third largest expense for young families. To be honest, I do not know how people can afford to have multiple children in daycare in any major metropolitan area.
- robohoe 1y agoNice! Illinois had something similar called AllKids but that was for lower income families [0]. More states need this in US. [0] https://hfs.illinois.gov/medicalprograms/allkids.html https://hfs.illinois.gov/medicalprograms/allkids.html
- hopelite 1y ago“No cost universal child care” Also: “savings of $12,000 per year” So this will be financed by a voluntary election by those who support it, i.e., voluntary increase in the various taxes people pay in NM?
- showerst 1y agoI think DC has the start of a really good system here. There's universal Pre-K 3 and 4. Most elementary schools offer it, but you can also get a large subsidy to go towards a private daycare. I'd love to see that expanded to all ages. Day cares here are super heavily regulated (and thus expensive) and apparently the paperwork is a nightmare for the day care, but in practice it's super easy for parents. I see all these comments in the vein of 'why should you force people to work in the mines and not get to love their child' and I wonder if any of these people have ever had toddlers. I love my kid, and love spending time with her. But she really likes daycare (and now school). Not only does she get better socialization than me taking her to the park for 2 hours, but she learns skills that I wouldn't be consistent about teaching. It turns out, being taught by people who have years of practice and degrees in childcare is a pretty good idea! We did Prek-4 at our public school and you could immediately tell the difference between the daycare kids, the nanny kids, and the home-parent kids. The daycare kids were much more prepared and able to cope, and this is at a school where parental involvement was quite high. I don't think the different approaches are universally better or worse, but it's clear to me that the quality of the daycare and the parent matters a lot more than which one you choose.
- arathis 1y agoEverything about this thread sums up how brutal America is. It’s wild.